c


m
Regional Director

 mm
m
  m  m

mm m  
mmm
 mm
m 
 mm m m
mm m  mmmm  m
mmm mm m  m

mm m  m
m   m m

 m
 mm m m
mm mm
 mm  m m m

 m m 
m m  m  m

m m   
m 
 m  m  
m
 m m m  m m  
m  m m 

m m 
m

m m

  m m
m m
 m m    m 
m! m"m


m
 m 

m m 
 m m
 m m  
  m ! m  m "m  m
   m  m

mm 
m  mm
  mmm #
m m
m


m $!%&&&'m " m  m 
m m   m 
m
m 
 m m 
 m  m

 m m m $(&'m
 m 
m  m  m  m m  m  m m  m
 m )m

 m 
m 
  mm  m m m  mm 
  m 
m m
m)
 m

m m mmm


m 
m

mmm
m mmm mm m*
 m
m m m   m m  m  m 
m 
m m  m  m m

  m

 m )m

m
 m m m m  m  m m 
  m


m m
m m
 m m mm 
 m mm
 m mmm
 mm m$('m 
m
m m m
mm

mmm m  mmmm
  mm m
m #

 mm m mm  mm+ 
mm
)m

mm
mm m m
mm  m
m
mm
m

m m m  m m  m
 m 
m  m m )
 m ,,(mm 
m  m
m m$%'m
 m
m m
mmm
mm
m

mm
mm m
-m m  
m  

m 
m
m 
 m  m  m m  m $.&'m

 m 
m  m  m
 

m m  m 
m   m  / m m  m  m 
m

mm
" m*
 mmmm  mm
mm m 
 m m

 
m  m  m m m 
m m  m  m

m m   
m

 m m 
mm mmm  mm
  m m
m m
$)
 m.,0mm mm 'mm
m
Labor Arbiter
1

m m m ) 
m m  m  

m m $'m #
m 

m  
m
 m  m 
m  m  m m ) 
m
m  m  m m #

 m
2

m m m m 
 m m m $(&'m
 m
m m  m
 

mm
 m

m m  m 
m m 

m m # 
m  m m  m 

m m

  
m 
m  m  m


m  m m + 
m   m  
m m
 
 mm
$.'m mm

m


3mm
$,'m "  m

3m$*2
mm)m,4.mm5)6
m2

m m
 m
 
m m7)8
 m 
 m

'm
$('m 9m

  mmm
 mm 
 m
m


mm+ 
m m
 m  m 
m  m m m 
m m +m m  m  
m m


mm  3mm
$:'m 
mm
m m # mm m
mm 
m
 m m
 m    m 
3mm
$%'m 

m 
 m  m m m m )
 m ,4:m m 
m  m 
 m
/

m m m mm
+
mm
+
3mmm
$4'm #
m

m m  
m   
m *
m *
m ; 
 m m
 m  
mm m

m
 m m    m 
m


 m 
m m  

m m 

m m 
m

m  m m
 m #
 m  m 
m 

m $!%&&&&&'m   m m m


  mmm
 mm 
 mm
$'m " m  

m
m  m #

 m   m 2

m  m m


m

 mmm) 
mm
$
'm 

m 
 m  m  m   m m   m m

 m   m
  
m m 
m 
 m  m  m   m m 
m m
 m
 
 m

m
m m

mmm mm) mm   m m
 mm m
 
m 
 mmmm
m m m mm
m  
m
$)
 m,.<mm mm 'mm
m

; m 
m m -
 m m 
m m m m  m
m  m m
) 
mm m-mm 
m 

m$-'m
m m m mm
#

 m2

mm mm
 mm m$0&'m
 m
m m m m
m m
 m m

m
 mmmm    m 
mmm m
m m m m

m  m =m + 
m m  

m   m 
 m


mm
m m # mm m
mm 
m
" mmm m
8  mm m
 8
m 
mmm
m m

m  m 
m

m
m  m 2m m
 m m "
m 
m
m  m

 mm m

mm 

m  mm
m mm
m
 m
m
mmm" m  
mmm m mm m
 8
m 
m

m mmm
m m
  mmm  m

mm 
mm m m
 m m  m + 
m m 9m  m 
 8
m  
m 
m m 2
m   m  m

 m

mm

mm 
m
m m

m m m
m

m m
2m m
m  m m  m
m m  
m m  m 
m

m
m 
mmmm
###m

###m

###m

9m

m m   m m  

m  m m 2
m m m  m


m 
m   m m m m

m  m + m
m  m  m m  m m
  
m m 
m 
m  m m  
m m   m  
m $.,>'m  m  m

m 
m

m m  m  # m m m 
m  m

m m m  m $('m

mm  m mm m # m  m
  m
m

m
###m

###m

###m

$*
m.&mm 
m)
m-m?&:,m@; mA+ 

mmB 

m=
m)
mm.00%C'm
m
[ rea of Labor Relations
" m 7 m m m  
m m  m m  
m 

m m  m  m


m m  m   m m m m   m
m  m  m m #

 m
m m 
m m  m m  m m m  /
m m  m m m 
m m m
 m m m


m m m 

m  

m m 
m 
 m
 m m 
 m   m  
m m m +

m   m  
m m
 
m #
m 
m 
 m  m  m   m m   m m


 m   m   
m 
m
m  m  m
2
m m  
m 
 m
8mmmm
" m 7 m
m  m  m $.%'m
 m 
m m 
m m m


m   m m

2
mm # 
mm  mm m
m$)
 m,,4mm mm 'mm
m

 m  m *
 m m m m   m 

m m 2

m m  m  m
 mm)77B""m" m  m2

mm m*
 mmmm  m
m
  mmmm  mm

m

m
 mm m7mm m # 

mm
m
#

 m m  m 2

m " m *
 m m m m   m 
m m
2

m  m 


m m  m 7m    m m  m # 

m m 
m   m  m m

  m m

mm m m
mmm mm

m m6
m

 mm
 
m
m


m  mmm  mm
###m

###m

###m

9m
m
 m mm m*
 mmmm  mmm
 m  m
m
m

 mmm
 mm)77B""6
m m" m


mm m7mm


m m
  mmm m m m m
m mmm #
mD 
m m mm
 m   mm
mm

mmm m

m
m
mm
m m m
4%mm m
mmmm
$)m 
m 
m )m 
m  
m m @Em -m .(.(<:m ,4m
1m,&&&'m
m
-ol ntary arbitrator
" m 5m )m m  m m 5m )
m
m  m  m m
#

 m 2

m m  m m 
 m m 
 m  

m 
 m  m  m
  m m   m m  m 
 m 7  m )  m m 
m

 m m m  mm 
mm
 m 
 m

m   mm
m  m   m 
 m )
 m )

 m 
m m m 
 m 7  m
)  m #
m 
m 
m  m 

m m

 m
m m  m  m   m 
m
mm

mm
m m
 m
m  

m m m
 m7  m
)  m =m 

m m 
m )
 m 

m 
m m m 
 m 7  m
)  m
m m  m 8m 

m  
m m
 m m  m
 
m


mm

m  m
" m 

m
m mB

mm m m

mm m  m
mmm  m
mm  m

m  

mm  
m m m
#

 m m  m 2

m m  m m m m  m m m

mm
m  m

mm  m m
 mm m  
m 
 m
mmm mm m

 m  m  mm
$)
 m,4.mm mm 'm

 
From Labor Arbiter to NLRC
m
)
 m,,.mm mm m 
mm

m
mm  
mm

mm
m
m m  m
 m m m m  m 

m   m  m  

m m  m
m) 
m= m m 

m
m / mm
m  m 
 m 
mm


m m

mm mm


mm
 m"

m
m m m
 # mm  m 

 mm2

m" m 
mm m mm
mm mm
m /mm
   m
 m m 
mm 
mm m
mm
9m m

mmm  mm mmm m mmm
mm

 
m 
 m -m m  m

m 

 m   m m 
m

 
m

  m  m  m m

 m "
m   m m  m 

m



m m m
 
 m 
m
m


m
m m  mm
$F  m
m-m@Em-m..:.4.m,(m-  m.00%C'm
m
oro nds for Appeal
$'m 9m  m
m m
 m  
mm
mm

 mm mmm mm
) 3mm
$'m 9m  m 

m  m m m 
m

 m  m m m
 
m

 m mm
3mm
$
'm 9m  m mm/

mm3mmm

$'m 9m

m 
mm m
mm

m m
m
mm

m  mm
  m  mm2mm m mm
m
orave Ab se of Discretion
m
" m 
m G  m 
m m 

 m   m m 
+m m #

m m 2

Gm

m
 m  m m  m 2
 
m m 
 m 9m 
m

m


m m


m # 

mm2 mm mm # 

 m2
mm/
2
m m

mm mm
+mm m$)m
m m5 
m@,<<m*)m,4?m$.00<C'm
m
! m 
 m  m 
 m m
m m  m m  6
m 

m  m  m
m  m m    m  m 

m m #

m 
m  m  m 2 m
-  m 
m m  m 
m  m m

m m
 m m 
m 
 m m  m

 m -   

m  m m m +m
 
m m  m   m  m  m


 mm  m
m  m
m m
 6
m m9mm
m
m
  m
mm m mm mmm
 mm  m
mm

 mm
  m m  m   m  m  m 
 m 
m  m 
 6
m  m m
 m
m m  m 
m m m 

 m  m *
m($'m  m 59m m  m 
mm
!
 mm-m$E
m
m-m@,4:m*)m,4.m.004C'm
m

" m m  m
  m  m 

m m 

 m  m  m  m m 
 m
  mm m mm mm


mm m mm
+mm2

mm
 m
 m m m 


m 
m  m m *
m .%m m  m 5m m  m - m

m m !
 m m  m -m ! m )
m 9
m 
m -m @,4(m *)m 4(?m
.004C'm
m

" m-m  m

m
m

 mm mm
 mm mm
m  m m  m  m  m 
m  / m  m )
 m ,,(m m  m m  m
$
 mA+ 
m!m
m-m@,4.m*)m%<(m.004C'm
m

" m m  m  m 

m 
m 

 m m 
  m  m  m   m

m  
m 9m 
m

m  m 
m  m  m  m  m 
m  
m m
 m   m m

 m  m

m
  m m 

m  m  m m  m
m
  m m
 m 
m  m m  m m m + m m


 m 
m 

m m 
m 

m  m  m 

m 
m   m m  m

 
m
 m  m$;F m
m-m@,,0m*)m,:&m.00:C'm
m

" m-m  m

m
m

 mm  m m mm
m
 m2 m
mmm #
m
mm mm  mm2 m9m m
m
m
 m
mm

 m

m #  m m  m mm m mm  m
 m2 m
mm  m mm

mm$E
 m
m-m@,.0m*)m
%4.m.00(C'm
m
Appeal [ond
m

) m m 


m 
m m  
m m  m m ) m  m m m #
m


m  mm m 

mmmmm
mm m$.&'m
 m
m
 m
mm

m


m
mm 
m*
m m m m   mm
mmm m m 
m
###m

###m

###m

9m

mmm2 m mm  mmm mm m  m m
 m  
 m m m  m 
 m m m

m m
 m m 

 m m m   m

 m
 m m 

  m m  m  

m m  m  m / m m  m

 mmm m2 m  m m$)
 m,,(mm mm 'm
m

" m  / m m  m  m 

m m

m m
 m m m  
m 
8
m
 m
m m  mm

 m m+ 
mmm m mm m

m m
m 
 m  m  m 2 m m  m m m  m 


m m  m  6

m
 m9m
m  mm

 m  
m m
 mm mm mm  m
 m m mm

m m  6
m2
mmm

. $5mE 
m
; mm
m-m@Em-m0<(%<m.?m;
m.00,C'm
m
"  m 
m m
 m 

m   m  m m mm  m m  m   m
 m m 
m  
m " m  m m 
 m  m  m m m  m   m
 mm m m m
 m )
 m ,,(m m  m m  m m  m m  m -m  m  m 


m

mm 
mm mm) m 
m m  mGm m$.&'m
 m
m m

mm

m


m
mm 
Gm m*
m($'mm m59mm m- m

mm!
 mm m-m m m
m 
m mmm m  mm
 m 
m m mm m m  m m
-  m mm mm
m   m
m


m mmm
m
  m m m 
mmm 
mm m mm
9

m 
m m 

m  m -m 
m  m  
m m  m  m m m
m m  m m m 
m 
m m 
m m m m m m 
m
m m mm m  m mm  . *
m m m m mm
 m m m m 
m  m 
m   m

 . 9m  m  m  m  m 
m m
 m 
 mm mm) m 
m2

m m m

mm m-m

m 
 m m m m m  m
m m m m
m# m m  m -.m $*m
) mD
m
m-m@Em-m.&?0.:m,&m*   m.00:C'm

" m 
 m m m 

m

m
m 
mm
m m
m  mm


 mm m

 m2 mm-m
m m m


mm
m


m )
m  m


 m  m m  
m


m m m m 

 m 
m

 
 mmm
m m-mmmm
m 
mm 
+
mm  m
 m
  m  m
mm m

m
m mm
9m
m
 mm
mm mmm  m
mm mmm mm
 m
m / m mm mm

mmm 
m

mm
m
 m%m
9m  m

m m m  m m m  / m  m #

m  m m m 

m m
mm

 mm m   m

m
mm mm m 
m
m  m  m  m m m  m m  m $.&'m 
m  m 
m m  m /
 m
2 m m  m -m m 
 m 
m 
m 2

m D 
m  m 
m m

m
mm
m

mmm
 m
= mm m mm mm

 mm m m  m
 m  m /
 m  m 
m m 

m m -m 

m m m
#
m m m$.&'m
 m
m m
m  m"
m
m 
m  m
 m

mm-m
 mmm #
mm
 m<m.00%m
/ m
 m 
mm m

m
mm m m   mm    mm m
 m-m

m m mm  m
mm

 m$ m
m-m@Em-m.,(4(4m(.m
;
m,&&&C'm
m
E  m
m 
m m

m
m 
m m m  m 

m m m m


 m
m m  m m
 mmmmmmmm

m


m   m 
m D  m  m  m  m  m 
  m 
m #

m m  m
 mA  mm
.m " m m
mm mm
m  m m
mm/m
mm2

3m
,m " m/

m
mm m
m

m m mm
mm


mmm m m
mm m m

 m
m
m
mm

m
mm m m
3m
(m "  m
mm m

mm m
mm m/
mmm m
 m m  2
m  m E  m m m  m   m m  m
2
m
 mm m
m
m 
 3m
:m  m m




mm mm

 mm m


3m
%m !  m
m  mm m

mm  m
m # m 
mm  3m
4m 9mm
 m

m  m mm mm
m
m mm m  mm


m  mm mm
m

m  3m
<m " m

mm m m
m mmmm
+mm m

3m
?m " m

m
m #m mmm
m m  mmmm
m2
3mm
0m " m

 m
m
m m mmmm  m
m 
m
m m
$) m
m-m@Em-m.:(?,(m&4m;
m,&&.C'm


From NLRC to Co rt of Appeals
m
)m  mm m 
 m

mm m
 
mm)m-m<0&,m 

m
m
m  m m m mm 
 mm m

mm m  
mm m
m)
m
mm 

mm m   m
m  m9m m 

mm mm m
m2
m  mm m2

mm m-mmm


mm m* mm
m   m 
m m 


m m  m   m 
m m  m   m  m m   m "
m



m
m m m 
mm m mm
m mm m m


 
m #m m  m 

m m  

m  m 
m m *  m 7m -m

.:0%mm m   
m  m mm*m-m.:0%8Dm-m.&:%,mm
" m m 
m    mm  m

  mm m  m

m 
m m  m
-m m  m * m m   m   m  m  
 m   m 
m m  m


m
m 
m m
m 

m m
m 
m  m  m  
 m m 2
m   m m



m m  m -m " m 
m m  m m G Gm m  m   m m m  m



m  m  m  m
m  m  m m 

m   m 

m  
m m

m m  m  m 
m m
m  m m 
m m 2
m   m


m m  m   m


m " m  m 

m   m  m   m
mm
m mm
m
m

 m  m
mm m

m
m
mm

m 
m m  m

 m  m 2

m m 
m m m  m m m
) 
3m  
mm mm m

 mm 
mm
mm m* m
m m mmm

 mmm
 m m mm 

m
m
#

mm m


m

mm*  m7m-m.:0%m
"   m m    

m m  m   m *
m 0m m 7!m -m .,0m m

m
 
m  m  m -m m  m * m m  m    m m   m 
 m m
mm  mm 
mm
m m m4%m
/ mm

m 
m

m  
m m  m m  m m  m m m ) 

m m

m 

m m  m

 mm m 
mm

m
m m m mm m  m
 m
$*m;m= mD m
m-m@Em-m.(&?44m.4m*   m.00?C'm