Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Guide For Preliminary Design of Arch Dams: United States Department of The Interior
Guide For Preliminary Design of Arch Dams: United States Department of The Interior
WATER
RESOURCES
ENGINEERING
TECHNICAL
MONOGRAPH
PUBLICATION
No. 36
OF
RECLAMATION
A WATER
Engineering
RESOURCES TECHNICAL
Monograph
No.
PUBLICATION
36
L. BOGGS
Division of Design
Office of Design and Construction,
Engineering and Research Center,
Denver, Colorado
United
States
Department
of the Interior
BUREAU
OF
RECLAMATION
. . _ _
ENGINEERING
MONOGRAPHS
are prepared and used by the technical
staff of the Bureau of Reclamation. In the interest of dissemination of
research experience and knowledge, they are made available to other interested
technical circles in Government and private agencies and to the general public
by sale through the Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing
Office, Washington, D.C.
First Printing: November 1966
Second Printing: August 1975
Third Printing: January 1977
U.S. GOVERNMENT
WASHINGTON
For
PRINTING
OFFICE
: 1977
-- ---
* . .
. . . _ _ .
Pre face
IN THEIR
PLANNINQ
of water resources development projects, Bureau of Reclamation engineers
may be required to prepare preliminary layouts
and estimates of arch dams. Such preliminary
studies aid the project planners in evaluating
the feasibility of arch dams and their relationship
to other types of dams in the project plans in
terms of comparative economy, availability of
construction materials, and other technical considerations.
iii
I . X
. . _ . ,
- - _
Summary
HE EMPIRICAL
FORMULAS
developed in this
monograph for use by project planners or other
interested persons will assist them in estimating volumes and basic dimensions for arch dams
on future projects and in updating past estimates.
The information contained here is to be used
only as a guide for the preliminary layout of
concrete arch dams.
Topographic dimensions necessary to compute
thicknesses, projections, and volume are structural
height, H, and horizontal distances between
abutments including estimated excavation to
sound rock at crest elevation, L1, and 15 percent
of H above base, L. Generally, results from
the suggested formulas are conservative as
compared with values computed more precisely.
Acknowledgments
John R. Brizzolara and Kenneth G. Bell of
the Stress Analysis Unit, Concrete Dams Section,
Dams Branch, Division of Design, were major
contributors to this monograph. Mr. Brizzolara
assembled major portions of the statistical data
Contents
Preface ____- ___________--___- L_________-- ______________________
Summary--.----------------------------------------------------Acknowledgmenk------_---------------------------------------Definitions------------------------------______________________
Introduction---------------------------________________________
Statistical Data------------------------------------____________
Analyses---____- ____----..-----------..----_---_-------_---_--Results--- _____-_-__-- _____-___---_---_-__________- ____________
CrownCantilever-Thicknesses--------_________-___- _______Crown Cantilever-Projections-~----~---c________
-__-- _______Volume___---_--------------------------------------------LimitationsandAccuracy-__--------------------------------Examples_-----------------------------------------------------Examplel_--__----_-__---_--------------------------------Exarnple2_________-___------------------------------------Layout--_-___-------------------------------------------------
page
.a.
111
V
V
ix
1
3
5
7
7
7
10
10
13
13
16
17
LIST OF FIGURES
1. Damsit.e topography and required dimensions for nomographs and
layoutofdam__--__-______-___-----------------------------2. Nomograph for obtaining crest thickness and projections on crown
cantilever__--____-____-___-_-_---_------------------------3. Nomograph for obtaining base thickness and projections on crown
cantilever__--__---____,___________-___--------------------4. Nomographforobtaining
VI- _________ -_-__---__--_--_________
5. Nomographfor obtaining Vz---- ______ -_-_----__-__--________6. Planforapreliminarydesign
__________--__----__-_--_____-____
7. Crown cantilever and lines of centers for a preliminary design- _____
2
8
9
11
12
14
15
vii
Definitions
CONCRETE
is not
univer-
curvature----
Foundation-..--..---Abutment
__________
Base ________-___.__
Extrados-
__ _ _ __ _ __ _
Intrados-
_ _ _ _ _ ___ __
Crest- _ __ _ ____ __ __ _
Axis- _- _ _____ ____ __
Axis radius--_--_..-Central
angle- _ _ _ _ _ _
Continuously
curved in plan and
elevation.
Curved in plan only.
Depth
from
ground
surface
to
sound rock as determined
from
available geological sources (geologists, geologic maps, cores, etc.).
Total mass of sound rock supporting the dam.
The rock mass which supports the
horizontal elements, such as canyon walls.
Bottom surface of vertical element
resting on foundation.
Curved upstream
surface of horizontal arch elements.
Curved downstream
surface of horizontal arch elements.
Top of dam.
Vertical reference surface, cylindrical in plan and coincident
with
the extrados at crest elevation.
Radius of axis equal to extrados
radius at crest elevation.
Angle at extrados center formed by
lines extended to arch abutments.
Crown
cantilever-
_ _ _ Vertical
section positioned
about
midway between abutments
and
whose base is generally the lowest
elevation of the dam.
Structural
height- - _ _ Vertical distance from crest of dam
to lowest point of foundation.
Thickness- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Horizontal
distance
between
upstream and downstream
faces of
dam on line normal to extrados.
Upstream projectionHorizontal
distance from extrados
to axis on line normal to extrados.
Downstream
projecHorizontal
distance from intrados
tion.
to axis on line normal to extrados
(thickness=upstream
projection
+ downstream
projection).
=structural height.
TC =thickness a6 crest.
TB =thickness at base.
TO.aH=thickness of crown cantilever at O.&N
above base.
USP =upstream projection.
DSP =downstream projection,
=straight line distance at crest elevation beLl
tween abutments assumed excavated to
sound rock.
=straight line distance, at 0.15Habove base,
LZ
between abutments assumed excavated to
sound rock.
V
=estimated volume of dam.
H
ix
. . - .
. * _ . - _ _
Introduction
is a guide which presents formulas and charts for preliminary design of arch
dams. Included are the procedure and examples
for preparing a preliminary layout of a concrete
arch dam. Figure 1 shows the topographic map
used in example 1. The figure indicates the required measurements for determining the volume
of the dam and dimensions of the crown cantilever.
THIS MONOGRAPH
From statistical analyses of arch dam geometrical properties, empirical formulas were developed
for t,hherapid determination of initial physical
dimensions for design and volume estimates. The
more complicated formulas are expressed in
nomographic charts, shown in figures 2, 3, 4, and
5. Figure 6 illustrates a plan and figure 7 illustrates the crown cantilever and lines of centers for
example 1.
..--._-
L>
I II,w
--
FIGURE 1 .-Damsite
structural
.._.
..__.
Statistical
Data
Analyses
ANALYSES
of tabulated data were
based on observation, experience, and intuition.
Combinations of height, thicknesses, projections,
and distances were incorporated with constant or
variable coefficients in linear, nonlinear, or exponential equations to determine proper relationships for the basic dimensions and Volume.
A foremost consideration in developing empirical
formulas for concrete arch dams is the shape of the
canyon. Initia.lly, the tabulated data were separated into two general canyon shapes, U and V.
Several formulas were developed in part for each
shape, considering arc length at crest and structural height. These observations disclosed to
some degree the relative importance of the selected
variables. Including another variable, the canyon
STATISTICAL
Results
HE
~0sT
IMMEDIATE
INFORMATION
necessary
;
c. Thickness at O.45H, in feet,
T,,,4m=0.95 TB.
Nomographs for estimating the crest and base
thicknesses are shown in figures 2 and 3. The
crest thickness is found by intersecting the TO-scale
with a straight line from H to L, in figure 2.
Thickness of the base is obtained from figure 3 by
the following procedure:
1. Mark on the S-scale the intersection of
a straight line between known values L1 and
L-2.
2. The base thickness is read from the
T,-scale at the intersection of a straight line
between S, and the known value H.
Crown Cantilever-Projections
Upstream and downstream projections are horizontal distances used to locate the extrados and
intrados relative to the reference surface, the axis,
as shown in figure 2. Projections related to the
preceding three thicknesses are defined as follows:
7
--. -- .--._.
M-
- so,
so --II00
70 -
- ,000
-,OO
-000
so- 400
- so0
so -700
-so00
40-
SW
NOTES
so0
SOpooo
-.OO
Dlmonsions
roquirod for using shotis
H SEstimotod
structural
height of dam from crest to
bore including
assumed depth of excavation.
L1 &might
line dirtonce
at crest elevation
between
obutmonts
including
l stimatod excavation to sound
L2 =Stmight
line distonco
between abutments
including
excovation
to sound rock ot O.lSH above the base.
Procedur.
Crest
- 1000
thickness,
1. Intersact
TC, on Figure 2
TC with o straight
line from H to L1
Bose thickness,
1. lntersoct
2. Intersect
lg. on Figure 3
S1 with a stmight
fg with a straight
line from L1 to L2
line from Ii to S1
Upstream pro/*ctions:
At crest, USP = 0.0
At 0.45, USP = 0.951s
At baso, USP = 0.67Ts
Downstream
pmioctions:
At crest, DSP = TC
At 0.45H, DSP =O.O
At base, DSP s 0.331~
FIGURE 2.-Nomograph
for obtaining
on crown cantilever.
rock.
stimotmd
RESULTS
9
I
I200
WOO
-034
ID00
Iwo
II00
1000
-000
5000
500
WO
WO-
1100
4ooo
wo-
400
rooIi
rwo
- woo
-11ooo
300
wo
400
woo
-000
3007
-000
PO0 -IO00
-
-wo
700
--,---
-WO
_---
Too
600
C-600
1
-600
-300
too
-:
SO
w
To
400
60
-400
80
300
/
40
900
1
L
MM-
I-
to -to
- 100 1loo
1
LI
FIQUMO 3 .-Nomograph
for obtaining
S
ba.se thicknees and projection8
II
L8
on crown cantilever.
See
note8 and
drawing
on figure 8.
_ .* ^ . .. .- - _
10
a. Crest
USP=O.O
DSP= T,
h. base
USP=O.67 TB
DSP=O.33 TB
c. At 0.45H
USP=maximum upstream projection=0.95 TB
DSP=minimum downstream projection=O.O.
Volume
The formula for computing the volume in cubic
yards is:
v=v,+v2,
where
v~=0.000002 H2 La H;y;1)2]
[
1
and
v~=0.0004
H L,[H+l.l
L,].
Formulas for VI and V2 are graphically represented in figures 4 and 5. The procedure for
estimating the volume from these nomographs is:
To obtam VI,
On figure 4-A,
1. Obtain a value of U by intersecting
the U-scale with a straight line between
known values L1 and Lz.
2. The value of W is obtained by intersecting the W-scale with a straight line
from L1 to known value H.
On figure 4-B,
3. Mark on the S-scale the intersection
of a straight line between H and L2.
4. Indicate on the L&scale the intersection of a straight line between U and W
(values for U and W are the scaled values
from figure 4-A).
5. VI is now found by intersecting the VI-
,-- _.__._.___
RESULTS
mtolosoIOQ-
40.000,occ
Loo-
x0FIGURE
4-A
_-
600NOTES
7wMOmolooo-
line from L1 to L;
line from Ii to L1
On Ftgure 4.B
3. Inkrsoct S1 with a straight Iin. from tl to L2
4. Intersect 52 with a straight lio. from U to W
(Values for U and W are obtained from
Figure 4-A)
5. Intersect V1 with o straight line from Sf to I:
rm
60
W
FIWJRE 4.-Nomograph
U
for obtaining
VI.
(V=
FIGURE
4-B
VI + VZ).
12
x Ll
5-A
H
FIGURE
- -
__----
c=;--------+
f-
----WOW
__
NOTES
wnrionr
N
r.qu1r.d
for
= Estlmoted
crest
of
using
structural
to bore
charts.
height
including
of dam
assumed
from
depth
l rcowtien.
L1
= Straight
between
l mwation
line distant.
at crest
&votion
abutments
including
estimated
to sound
rock.
L2
= Straight
line
including
reck
dum
for
On Figure
1.
at 0.15N
using
5-A
Figun
above
bohreon
wwwtion
the
abutment
to
sound
base.
charts
Intersect
Hto
on
distance
estimated
X with
o straight
line
from
l.1
LB
-i
2.
Intersect
S3 with
o straight
line
from
3.
Intorsoct
V2 with a straight
lin.
53 to X (Value
for X is obtained
from
from
HW
H to L1
Figur.
FIGURE
bA)
J?x.cwa~ b.-Nomograph
for obtaining
V2.
(V=
S-B
VI + V,).
Examples
Two EXAMPLES ARE PRESENTED to demonstrate
the procedure for using the formulas. Known
data are from dams designed and analyzed by the
Stress Analysis Unit. Actual values used in the
design studied are indicated following the computed values.
A typical damsite is shown in figure 1 from
which were measured the dimensions Ll and Ls.
The estimated structural height, H, together with
L, and La are illustrated in the nomographs,
figures 2, 3, 4, and 5. A layout for example 1
utilizing procedures outlined in this guide, is
shown in plan in figure 6 and in elevation in
figure 7.
Example 1
From the estimated structural height, H-290
feet, and the measured chord lengths from figure 1,
L, =550 feet and L,=160 feet, find thicknesses
and projections on the crown cantilever and
volume.
a. At crest
Thickness:
To=o.01[H+1.2L,]
=0.01[290+(1.2)(550)]
-9.5 feet- _ _ __ _ __ _ __ __ _ _ _ 10.0 feet.
Upstream projection:
USP,=O.O _-________--_-____
O.Ofoot.
Downstream projection:
DSP,=9.6 feet _____________ 10.0 feet.
b. At base
Thickness:
,=~0.0012
H L1 Ii%($)
TB
=(0.67)(28.9)
=19.4 feet ____________ 20.5 feet.
Downstream projection:
DSPB=O.33 TB
= (0.33) (28.9)
=9.6 feet ______________ 7.3 feet.
o. At 0.45H
Thickness:
To.(aa=o.95 TB
= (0.95) (28.9)
=27.5 feet- ___________ 25.7 feet,.
13
EW
..a
.-.
.I__~
.,
,.--Axis of dam
El. 325;-,
Normal W.S.
El. 30 5-----
--LB.
,-----Slope
T, = 28.9.:
MAXIMUM SECTION
(ALONG
PLANE
OF
LINES OF CENTERS
CENTERS)
FIGURE
7.-Cmwn
cantilever
and
lines
ojcenterejor
a preliminary
deeign.
1.25 : 1.00
16
Upstream projection:
USPo.4aa=0.95 T,zj
= (0.95) (28.9)
=27.5 feet- __ - _- - - _ 30.0 feet.
Downstream projection:
DSPo.GsH=O.Ofoot- - - __-__ _ -4.3 feet.
d. Volume
v= VI + v2,
where
v,=o.ooooo2HaL
(HL+yy
1 2
=0.000002(290)2(160)
2go&(0~;~]
(1.1)(550)]
cubic yards- __- __
88,300 cubic yards.
Example P
At 0.45H:
To.yH=o.95 TB
=(0.95)(113.6)
=107.9 feet- - - _______ 100.0 feet,
b. Upstream projections
At crest:
USP,=O.O- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _- ___ 0.0.
At base:
USP,=O.67 TB
= (0.67)(113.6)
=76.1 feet- __-_- ____-- 65.0 feet.
c. Downstream projections
At crest:
DSP, = T,
=23.6 feet- _ __- _______ 25.0 feet.
At base:
DSPB=O.33 TB
= (0.33)(113.6)
=37.5 feet-----------45.0 feet.
At 0.45H:
DSP,,.rsH=O.O____ - ____-___-__--___- 0.0.
d. Volume
Given: El=736
feet, L1=1,350
L=400 feet.
Find: T, USP, and DSP at crest,
0.45H and volume.
a. Thicknesses
At crest:
T,=O.ol[H+l.2L,l
=0.01[736+(1.2)(1,350)]
=23.6 feet------____-__-At base:
I
TB= 3 0.0012 H L, b(-$)
d
feet,
and
base, and
vI=o.ooooo2H2L
II
(HL+o*y
1- 2
=0.000002(736)(400)
{ 736+(0.8)(1,350)}
1,350-400
25.0 feet.
= 1,504,OOOcubic yards,
FT
isi
736
= 3 0.0012(736)(1,350)(400)(~)
J
=113.6 feet-------------
v= v, + v2,
where
110.0 feet.
and
V2=o.0004HL1[H+1.1L,J
=0.0004(736)(1,350)[736+(1.1)(1,350)]
=883,000 cubic yards.
Then,
V=1,504,000+883,000=2,387,000
cubic yards
2,240,OOOcubic yards.
-__-__--_---_-_--
Layout
BECAUSE IDEAL DAMSITES are virtually
nonexistent, a final design for an arch dam is the result,
of judicious evaluation and selection of physical
properties
which best satisfy site conditions,
stress requirements,
and design cyiteria.
This
final design is arrived at by several cycles of
layout, analysis, evaluation,
and improvement.
The initial layout in the series is based on results
of formulas in this guide and the judgment
of
the designer.
A procedure for making the initial
layout is as follows:
a. From the structural height, H, and chord
lengths, Ll and Lz, describe the crown cantilever
using equations or nomographs in this guide.
b. Compute the axis radius: RAxIB=0.6L1.
c. From all available geological information
on the damsite, estimate the depth of excavation
to sound rock.
d. Draw on vellum overlaying a topographic
map of the site a circular arc, with the axis
radius connecting abutments at the crest elevation.
This arc should be so oriented that
the angle of incidence t#o each abutment
is
approximately
equal.
e. On the axis, locate a point about midway
between abutments and in the riverbed (crown
cantilever).
A line on the drawing connecting
1 The RAXIS should be longthcned if either the arc fails to make contnct
with the abutment at the estimated depth of excavation, or if the subtended
central angle exceeds 120.
.:.U S GOVERNMENT
PRlNTlNG
OFFICE
1995-941.783