1English 1103, Critical Review Reflection

Name:
Kyle Murphy

Please provide a short response to each following question or statement.

1. Did you feel that the six questions, used as a lead-in, were helpful to starting your own composition? Why so/Why not?
The six questions werent too helpful for me, but I believe this is my fault for not giving more in depth answers to
those questions.

2. Influence me as to what to focus most upon during grading: what do you most want weighed in your favor as I grade
your overall project? Why?
The connection I made to my life. That may be a tricky thing to base grades on but I do think it would help my
score.

3. Influence me further as to what to focus least upon during grading: what do you want weighed least against you as I
grade your project? Why?
The style of writing. I wrote this in a more casual, me talking to you kind of way. This paper is about as far from
formal as you can get.

4. Was the peer review beneficial to you? How so?

To some extent, yes. The peer review was mostly positive and I imagine this is mostly because no one wants to
be rude. It helped me get rid of a few reallys and a lots but other than that, I didnt make any changes based off the
peer review.

5. Based upon what you have been assigned, verses what you have completed, what grade does your work justify?
Why?
Had I been given this assignment as a grader, I would give the student a B. The paper meets the general
requirements of the assignment but it could have been better explained and possibly offered a few more examples.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Rubric ~
Item:
Point Value:
Reflection
Critical Review
Total

25
75

100
EC: Six-Question Lead-In/Pre-writing
Notes:

+1 - +6