Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Identity Development Throughout The Lifetime - An Examination of E PDF
Identity Development Throughout The Lifetime - An Examination of E PDF
Volume 1
Issue 2 Spring 2009
Article 14
3-1-2009
IdentityDevelopmentThroughouttheLifetime:
AnExaminationofEriksonianTheory
JustinT.Sokol
Abstract:Thepurposeofthecurrentarticleistoreviewidentitydevelopmentfromalifespan
perspective.Toaccomplishthistask,identitydevelopmentisexaminedatvarious
developmentalstagesincludingchildhood,adolescence,andadulthood.Thearticleutilizes
ErikEriksonspsychosocialtheoryofdevelopmenttoinvestigateidentitydevelopment
throughoutthelifespan.Researchfindingsfromempiricalstudiesareincludedwithinthis
discussion.Itappearsthatformanyindividuals,identitydevelopmentisalifelongprocess
thatextendswellbeyondtheyearsofadolescence.
TheinfluentialwritingsofErikErikson(19021994)havestimulated
over50yearsofsocialscienceliterature(Schwartz,2001).Histheorieson
developmenthaveinspiredcountlessresearchstudiesmakinghiman
especiallyrelevantfigureinthefield(Kroger,2007).Eriksonwroteat
lengthaboutidentity,focusingmainlyontheperiodofadolescence.
However,hedidofferinsightsonidentityduringbothchildhoodand
adulthood.Tracesofhistheoriescanbefoundinalmostallformsof
identityresearch.Therefore,itisappropriatetoinvestigatethistopicfrom
hisperspective.
Thepurposeofthisstudyistoexamineidentitydevelopmentfroma
lifespanperspective.ThearticlewillbeginwithadescriptionofEriksons
psychosocialtheoryofdevelopment.Next,attentionwillbegivento
identitydevelopmentduringchildhood,adolescence,andadulthood.Each
ofthesethreesectionswillincludeadescriptionofEriksonstheories;
empiricalstudieswillalsobepresentedtohelpillustratetheprocessof
identitydevelopment.Finallythearticlewillclosewithabriefevaluation
ofEriksonsidentitytheoryandcommentswillbeofferedforfuture
research.Beforestarting,afewwordsareinorderregardingterminology.
Inreviewingtheliteratureonidentity,thereisverylittleagreement
onhowidentityisdefined(Bosma,Graafsma,Grotevant,&deLevita,
1994).Eriksonaloneusedavarietyofidentityrelatedterms(identification,
identityformation,identitydevelopment,identityconsolidation,identity
foreclosure,andidentityresolution)withoutprovidingagreatdealof
explanation(Hoare,2002).Asaresult,hehasbeenheavilycriticizedfor
hisambiguousstyleofwriting.Thecurrentarticlewillutilizefewerterms
inanefforttoconveyaclearmessage.Therefore,identitydevelopment
willdescribetheoverarchingprocessofdevelopment,particularlyduring
theadulthoodyears.Identificationwillbeusedtodescribedevelopment
duringchildhoodandidentityformationwillapplytodevelopment
duringadolescence.
GJ
CP
ErikEriksonspsychosocialtheoryrevolutionizeddevelopmental
thought(Hoare,2002).Hewasoneofthefirsttoproposealifespan
modelofhumandevelopmentwhichincludedeightsuccessive
psychosocialstages.Eachstageisassociatedwithaninherentconflictor
crisisthattheindividualmustencounterandsuccessfullyresolveto
proceedwithdevelopment.ItisworthnotingthatErikson(1968)usedthe
termcrisisinadevelopmentalsensetoconnotenotathreatof
catastrophe,butaturningpoint,acrucialperiodofincreasedvulnerability
andheightenedpotential(p.96).Theassumptionisthateach
psychosocialstagehasbothasuccessfulandunsuccessfuloutcome(e.g.
trustversusmistrust,initiativeversusguilt,intimacyversusisolation).
Resolutionofearlierstagesisbelievedtodirectlyaffecttheresolutionof
laterstages(Marcia,1993).Erikson(1968)summarizeswiththefollowing
statement:
Ishallpresenthumangrowthfromthepointofviewof
theconflicts,innerandouter,whichthevitalpersonality
weathers,reemergingfromeachcrisiswithanincreased
senseofinnerunity,withanincreaseofgoodjudgment,
andanincreaseinthecapacitytodowellaccordingto
hisownstandardsandtothestandardsofthosewhoare
significanttohim.(pp.9192)
EriksongoesontosayTheuseofthewordstodowellofcoursepoints
upthewholequestionofculturalrelativity(p.92)whichhighlightsthe
emphasisheplacedonsocioculturalfactors.
Eriksoncontinuestoreceiveagreatdealofcreditforrecognizingthe
influenceofcultureondevelopment(Hoare,2002).Hewasthefirstto
illustratehowthesocialworldexistswithinthepsychologicalmakeupof
eachindividual.Erikson(1959)believedthattheindividualcannotbe
understoodapartfromhisorhersocialcontext.Individualandsociety
areintricatelywoven,dynamicallyrelatedincontinualchange(p.114).
ThisisathemethatpermeatesthroughoutallofEriksonseight
developmentalstagesandisespeciallyrelevanttothefifthpsychosocial
stage(identityversusroleconfusion)whichoccursduringadolescence.
Beforeexaminingthisdevelopmentaltask,itisimportanttorecognize
whatEriksonmeantwhenheusedthetermadolescence.
Erikson(1968)consideredadolescencetobeatransitionalperiodof
developmentfollowingchildhoodandleadingintoadulthood.
Unfortunately,heneverdefinedarangeofchronologicalagesfor
adolescenceorotherperiodsoflifesuchaschildhoodandadulthood
(Waterman,1993).Healsowroteinanerawhenattendingcollegewasless
commonthanitistoday;thishasdirectimplicationsbecauseofthe
140
http://epublications.marquette.edu/gjcp/vol1/iss2/14
IdentificationinChildhood(Ages611)
Theprocessofidentitydevelopmentbeginsmuchearlierthan
adolescence.Erikson(1968)believedthatseedsofidentityareplantedata
youngagewhenthechildrecognizeshimself/herselfasauniquebeing,
separatefromhis/herparents.Asmaturationoccurs,thechildtakeson
characteristicsandadmiredfeaturesofparentsorsignificantothers.
Eriksoncalledthisprocessidentification.Identificationallowsthechildto
buildasetofexpectationsaboutwhatheorshewishestobeanddo.
However,thechildeventuallylosesinterestinmerelyadoptingtheroles
andpersonalityattributesofparentsorsignificantothers;itisatthispoint
thattheprocessofidentityformationissetinmotion.
AccordingtoErikson(1968),identityformationbeginswhenthe
usefulnessofidentificationends.Takingoncharacteristicsofothersno
longerprovidessatisfaction;theindividualexperiencesadesiretoshape
hisorherworldinuniqueways.Identityformationbeginswithasynthesis
ofchildhoodskills,beliefs,andidentificationsintoacoherent,unique
wholethatprovidescontinuitywiththepastanddirectionforthefuture
(Marcia,1993).Eriksondidnotdiscussidentitydevelopmentduring
childhoodatgreatlength.Alternatively,heofferedgreatdetailaboutthe
processofidentityformationduringadolescence.
GJ
CP
Erikson(1968)believedtheprimarypsychosocialtaskofadolescence
istheformationofidentity.Therefore,hecalledthedevelopmental
conflictidentityversusroleconfusion.Thereareseveralcontributing
factorstotheformationofidentity.Theonsetofpubertyduring
adolescenceleadstonewfoundcognitiveskillsandphysicalabilities
(Kroger,2004).Inaddition,increasedindependenceandautonomyleads
togreaterinteractionswithneighborhoods,communities,andschools.
AccordingtoErikson(1968),thisallowstheindividualtoexplore
vocations,ideologies,andrelationships.Hegaveparticularattentionto
thecareerdomain,statingIngeneral,itistheinabilitytosettleonan
occupationalidentitywhichdisturbsmostyoungpeople(Erikson,1968,
p.135).Newexpectationsofadultresponsibilitiesaregraduallyassumedas
theadolescentmatures.Withadulthoodonthehorizon,eventuallythe
twinidentityquestionsemerge:WhoamI?andWhatismyplacein
thisworld?(McAdams,Josselson,&Lieblich,2006).Whentheindividual
isabletoassesstheirpersonalattributesandmatchthesewithoutletsfor
expressionavailableintheenvironment,Erikson(1963)wouldsayidentity
hasbeenformed.However,whentheindividualisunabletomanagethis
developmentaltask,roleconfusionoccurs.
FromEriksonsperspective,identityreferstoasenseofwhooneisasa
personandasacontributortosociety(Hoare,2002).Itispersonal
coherenceorselfsamenessthroughevolvingtime,socialchange,and
alteredrolerequirements.Theformationofidentityisamajoreventinthe
developmentofpersonalityandassociateswithpositiveoutcomes
(Marcia,1993).Identityprovidesadeepsenseofideologicalcommitment
andallowstheindividualtoknowhisorherplaceintheworld(Hoare,
2002).Itprovidesonewithasenseofwellbeing,asenseofbeingathome
inonesbody,asenseofdirectioninoneslife,andasenseofmatteringto
thosewhocount(Erikson,1968).Identityiswhatmakesonemovewith
direction;itiswhatgivesonereasontobe.Eriksonclearlybelievedthat
havingasolidsenseofidentityiscrucialtofurtherdevelopment.
However,notallpeoplesuccessfullyresolvethisdevelopmentaltask.
Roleconfusioncanleadtoaverydifferenthumanexperience.It
causestheindividualtoseriouslyquestiononesessentialpersonality
characteristics,onesviewofoneself,andtheperceivedviewsofothers
(Bosmaetal.,1994).Consequently,theindividualexperiencesextreme
doubtregardingthemeaningandpurposeoftheirexistence,leadingtoa
senseoflossandconfusion.Duetochangingphysical,cognitive,and
socialfactors,nearlyalladolescentsexperiencesomeformofrole
142
http://epublications.marquette.edu/gjcp/vol1/iss2/14
Insummary,Erikson(1968)believedthatadolescenceisatimein
whichidentitynormallybecomesthefocusofconcern.Researchappears
tosupportthisnotionbyindicatingthatthemostextensiveadvancesin
identitydevelopmentoccurduringthecollegeyears(Waterman,1985).
Majorgainsareexpectedduringcollegeasstudentsmakeimportant
decisionsthatpertaintovariouslifedomainsincludingoccupation,
friendship,romanticrelationships,andreligiousorpoliticalbeliefs
(Waterman&Archer,1990).Collegeenvironmentsprovideadiversityof
experiencesthatcanbothtriggerconsiderationsofidentityissuesand
suggestalternativeresolutionsforidentityconcerns(Waterman,1993,p.
5354);Eriksonwouldcertainlyagree.However,notallindividualsattend
collegeandhavetheopportunitytoexploretheaforementionedidentity
domains.Evenforthosewhodo,isitrealistictothinkthattheywillmake
commitmentsintheseareasthatwillremainunchangedthroughoutlife?
Itisforthesereasonsthatidentitydevelopmentbeyondadolescencewill
nowbediscussed.
IdentityDevelopmentinAdulthood(Ages25andBeyond)
Eriksonheldthatidentitydevelopmentdoesnotendwithits
formation(Hoare,2002).Hevieweditasanongoingprocessthatcaptures
onesinvestmentsthroughoutthelongyearsofadulthood.Thus,identity
developmentisbothanormativeperiodofadolescenceandanevolving
aspectofadulthood.IncontrasttoEriksonsextensivewritingsonthe
adolescentidentityformationprocess,hedidnotofferdetailedcomments
regardingidentitysevolutionthroughouttheadultlife(Kroger,2007).As
aresult,hehasbeencriticizedforextendinghistheorybeyond
adolescencewithoutprovidingmuchdetail.Tocomplicatematters
further,Eriksonconveyscontradictorymessagesspeakingonidentity
developmentbeyondadolescence.AccordingtoErikson(1968),thefinal
identityisfixedattheendofadolescence(p.161).Hesuggeststhat
identityconcernsfadeasissuesofintimacy(followedbygenerativityand
egointegrity)becomethemainfocus.Alternatively,Eriksonproposedthat
identitydefiningissuesofadolescencedonotremainfixed;theyretain
flexibilityformodificationthroughouttheadulthoodyearsduetonewlife
experiences.Clearlythesetwostatementsappearcontradictory;thisis
whyitisdifficulttoassessidentitydevelopmentbeyondadolescencefrom
hisperspective.Thankfully,othershavepickedupwhereEriksonleftoff.
Thereappearstobeaconsiderablescopeforidentitydevelopment
beyondadolescence(Kroger,2007).Theidentitydefiningdomainsof
GJ
CP
Identityrelatedissuescontinuetoemergeduringmiddleadulthood
(ages4065).Duringthistimeperiod,individualsbegintoreclaim
oppositesexqualitiesandexperienceashiftinperspectiveontime(Kotre
&Hall,1990).Womentendtotakeonmoremasculinecharacteristics
whilementakeonmorefemininecharacteristics(Huyck,1990;James,
Lewkowicz,Libhaber,&Lachman,1995);inaddition,therealitythatlifeis
halffinishedbeginstosinkin.Itisnotuncommonforindividualsto
reevaluate,refine,andreadjustvocationalandsocialrolesduringmiddle
adulthood(Kroger,2007).Changesinlifecircumstancescanalsocausea
reexaminationofidentityissues(Waterman,1993).Midlifecareerchanges,
geographicrelocations,resumingoneseducation,divorce,remarriage,
deathoflovedones,andadoptionareallviablepossibilitiesformiddle
adulthood.Finally,thecommonlyusedphrasemidlifecrisisisoften
associatedwithidentityrelatedissues,althoughresearchindicatesthat
thisisaninfrequentlyoccurringevent(Berk,2007).
Examinationandevaluationaretwowordssynonymouswith
continuedidentitydevelopmentinlateadulthood(ages65andbeyond).
Retirementallowstheindividualtoreflectuponthechoicesthathave
beenmadethroughoutthecourseoflife.Reviewingoneslifeinapositive
mannerallowstheindividualtoexperiencesatisfaction.Alternatively,a
negativelifereviewcanleavetheindividualwithfeelingsofregret.Kroger
(2002)conductedoneofthefewstudiesonidentityrevisionand
maintenanceprocessesduringlateadulthood.Resultsshowedthat
importantidentityprocessesincludedreintegratingimportantidentity
elementsfromyoungeryears,rebalancingrelationshipsandothersocial
roles,readjustingtolossanddiminishedphysicalcapacities,andfinding
lifemeanings.Theargumentcouldbemadethatidentitydevelopmentis
stilljustasmuchanissueinlateadulthoodasitisearlierinlife.
144
http://epublications.marquette.edu/gjcp/vol1/iss2/14
Insummary,Eriksonspsychosocialtheoryiscomposedofeight
developmentalstageswhichspanthroughoutthecourseoflife.Eachstage
presentstheindividualwithaninherenttaskorconflictthattheymust
successfullyresolvetoproceedwithdevelopment.Eriksonplacedagreat
dealofemphasisonsocioculturalfactorsbecausehebelievedthese
stronglyinfluencedevelopment.Suchfactorsareespeciallyrelevantinthe
processofidentityformation.Eriksonbelievedthatchildhood
identificationslaythegroundworkforidentityformationinadolescence.
Theprocessofforminganidentityinvolvescreatingacoherentsenseof
selfandwhooneisinrelationtotheworld.Adolescencerepresentsan
optimaltimeforidentitydevelopmentduetoavarietyofphysical,
cognitive,andsocialfactors.AlthoughEriksonbelievedidentitywas
largelyfixedbytheendofadolescence,hedidsuggestthatidentity
continuestoevolvethroughoutadulthood.Unfortunately,hedidnotgive
greatdetailonwhatthisprocesslookslike.Researchshowsthatidentity
developmentcontinuestobeanongoingprocessthroughoutadulthood.
Justasinadolescence,vocations,ideologies,andrelationshipscontinueto
remainimportantidentityissues.Severalstudieshavebeenpresentedto
supportthisnotion.
Muchlikeforminganidentity,reviewingtheliteratureonthis
nebuloustopicisnosmalltask.Asdiscussedearlier,researchersusea
varietyoftermsandphraseswhendescribingtheprocessofidentity
development.Itisalsodifficulttofindcontinuitywithregardsto
developmentalperiodsandassociatedages.Astrongefforthasbeenmade
touseterminologythatconnectsEriksonsworkwithmorerecent
empiricalstudiesinamannerthatisunderstandableandcoherent.It
wouldbewiseforfutureresearcherstouseagreedupontermsand
definitionssoasnottoconfusereadersandfellowcolleagues.Nomatter
whatyoucallit,identitydevelopmentisamajorpsychosocialtaskandone
thatappearsduringmanyphasesoflife.AlthoughEriksonmaynothave
beenclearregardingidentitydevelopmentbeyondadolescence,wewill
alwaysbeindebtedtohimforthegreatdealofdiscussionand
conversationhehasstimulatedonthisintriguingtopic.
REFERENCES
Arnett,J.J.(2000).Emergingadulthood:Atheoryofdevelopmentfrom
thelateteensthroughthetwenties.AmericanPsychologist,55,
469480.
GJ
CP
146
http://epublications.marquette.edu/gjcp/vol1/iss2/14
GJ
CP
148
http://epublications.marquette.edu/gjcp/vol1/iss2/14
10
GJ
CP
11