You are on page 1of 201

BX

Student Name ANALYSIS cial, storage yards


Elements Elements 2009
2009 : The : TheGrand
Bronx’s Bronx’s Grand Concourse
Concourse Laura
Laura Janka Janka Zires
Zires ANA
70% of the70% people
of the inpeople in thecommute
the Bronx Bronx commute to Manhattan
to Manhattan and to and to businesses are slat

mega-commuting
mega-commuting
the restthe of rest of the country
the country (tenmain
(ten other other main cities)
cities) for workfor work in the long-term pl
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse thanks to the dense Subway infrastructure and its connectiv- Alpa Nawre ANALYSIS
thanks to the dense Subway infrastructure and its connectiv-

BX
ity withity withhighways
major major highways and airports:
and airports:
1.The Multimodal
1.The Multimodal condition condition and extreme
and extreme commuting.
commuting. This This
12 condition condition
has createdhas created a job network
a job network that hasthat has increasingly
increasingly
11
10
expandedexpanded and allowed
and allowed people topeople
work to
in work in the
the best or best
only or
jobonly job
Elements 2009 : The9 Bronx’s Grand opportunity
opportunity
Concourse they getthey get no location.
no matter matter location. Paola Aguirre ANALYSIS Víctor Muñoz Sanz ANALYSIS
8

THE BRONX’S GRAND CONCOURSE


ELEMENTS OF URBAN DESIGN 2009:
7 2.People2.People
spend morespend
timemore
andtime andcommuting
money money commuting
to work to work since
since
6 job opportunities
job opportunities have nothave
beennot been created
created in the borough.
in the borough.
5
4 3.Even at
3.Even though though
a cityat level,
a city New
level, New prime
York’s York’smobil-
prime mobil-
ity characteristic
3 ity characteristic is its reliance
is its reliance on publicon transport
public transport
and and
walking
2 walking
(the city (the city accounts
accounts for half
for almost almost
of half of all public
all public
transport transport
use in the use United
in the States),
United States), Bronx commuters
Bronx commuters depend depend
1
Elements 2009
greatly greatly
: The
on Bronx’son theConcourse
Grand
the automobile automobile if traveling
if traveling to othertodestinations
other destinations Student Name
apart fromapart from Manhattan
Manhattan (even the
(even inside inside the Bronx).
Bronx).
There are There
few are few investment
investment and financing
and financing opportunities
opportunities in in
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse Jonathan A. Scelsa ANALYSIS
transit transit infrastructure
infrastructure serving serving
internalinternal
boroughsboroughs and linking
and linking
the Bronx theeast-west
Bronx east-west
side. The side.
lackThe
of lack of infrastructures
infrastructures
280
asks asks 280

for creative solutions


linking linking land
anduse, andindus-
other indus-
240 240
for creative solutions land use, other
BRONX-COMMUTING
BRONX-COMMUTING SCALES
SCALES
CHANGING AXES: tries totries to support
support public investments
public investments
200
and PPP’s.
and create 160
create PPP’s.
200

160

Re-thinking Space 120 120

80 80

40 40
Beijing
Beijing Beijing
Beijing
The project looks at the site through
0 0

TokyoTokyo TokyoTHE BRONX: GLOBAL COUNTY


the Tokyo
two-dimensional plane of sections
-40 -40

Perception

commuters

Bronx=0.08*NYC commuters
and builds a model for mapping informa-
-80 -80

commuters
w tion Global
on these context,surfaces. It local is a different issues
native
native white
white population
population afroamerican
afroamerican population
population

280 280
way of looking at, mapping and designing

by
the site in a series of vertical planes
240

ELEMENTS OF URBAN DESIGN 2009: THE BRONX’S GRAND CONCOURSE 240

so that The the Bronx spacehas between


always been the sections
a diverse
200

Montpelier+ Montpelier
Montpelier+ Montpelier
+ M MM MM M 200

Bronx=0.08*NYC
Bronx=0.08*NYC
M MM
becomes expandable or collapsible.
160 160
place, with a non-static population with
l 120 120
an enormous variety of ethnic origins,
Boston+ Boston+ BostonM + M
Information about the site is mapped thein
80 80
coming into and moving within Bronx. M M
- four Such categories: perception, program,
40
Hartford + Hartford +
Hartford Hartford + 40
flows and changes, and their causes,
- mosholu ecology parkwayand history. to Perception
understand notes
+ + +
0 0
are definitive this unique (BronxNYC-
(Bronx 8%)
8%) (Bronx 8%)

INbound(B,H,NJ,PH,R)+F(X1,X2,X3)*(100/8) +OUTbound(M,B,H,NJ,PH,BL,R,RA,MI)
NYC-(BronxNYC- 8%)

INbound(B,H,NJ,PH,R)+F(X1,X2,X3)*(100/8) +OUTbound(M,B,H,NJ,PH,BL,R,RA,MI)
confluence

INbound(B,H,NJ,PH,R)+F(X1,X2,X3)*(100/8) +OUTbound(M,B,H,NJ,PH,BL,R,RA,MI)
- dawn dusk NYC- 225,926 2,471,576 225,926 2,471,576
225,926
24,498 225,926
24,498
2,471,576 2,471,576 24
24,498
traffic
Elements 2009 pattern
information
county. about Grand
: The Bronx’s perspectiveConcourse and views,
-40

80º
80º
Program + + + Ángel Rodríguez Colón PROPOSAL
-40

ne drop The in landdiagram in relation


on the left to the traces datum the
-80
New Jersey New Jersey New Jersey
NewJersey -80

we
280

Philadephia Philadephia ++
+Philadephia Philadephia + 280

of the Grand Concourse and of underpasses

Y1=B1*Acar/Bcar = B1*(Hcar*Bcarf/Bcar) = B1*((X2-X3)*Bcarf)/Bcar

Y1=B1*Acar/Bcar = B1*(Hcar*Bcarf/Bcar) = B1*((X2-X3)*Bcarf)/Bcar


patterns in the flows population

Y1=B1*Acar/Bcar = B1*(Hcar*Bcarf/Bcar) = B1*((X2-X3)*Bcarf)/Bcar


+ San+Francisco + + ++ Baltimore +
240 240

t- at the
San
San Francisco
coming
San Francisco
Francisco
intersections.
to the Bronx Program
and their notes the
ethnic 200
70º
70º
Baltimore + Baltimore
Baltimore 200

ck

d
land-uses,
originsmetro exit/ entry points and and

lan
in the period between 1910

fin
160 ru
russ 160

+ Richmond +
ssiaia

Y2= X1– Y1- Y3= x1- (B1*((X2-X3)*Bcarf)/Bcar) - Bsf*X1


60º
60º

Richmond +
bus-stops. Ecology
shows looks at the soil

Y2= X1– Y1- Y3= x1- (B1*((X2-X3)*Bcarf)/Bcar) - Bsf*X1


Richmond + Richmond
2009: it visually real and

a
ssww

ad
eedd

nia
120 eenn 120

can

ua
characteristics and range
history of maps the cut

lith
dynamic global the Bronx. The
nnee
eenn thee
th ggee
80 iriree gglala rlrlaa rm
rm 80
lalann nndd nndd aann

-
ss yy

h.
dd

and fill the bronx


next basedserieson ofearlier topographic
ppoo
50º
50º

ec
diagrams zoom into the
lalann

cz
nc
dd

er.
aauu

ry
d
40 40

fra
sstrtr

an

ga
itz
iaia

hun
otl

sw
maps. Bronx and show the ethnic origin and + Raleigh +

sc
Raleigh + Raleigh+

F(X1,X2,X3)= Y1(X2,X3)+Y2(X1,X2,X3) +Y3(X1)

F(X1,X2,X3)= Y1(X2,X3)+Y2(X1,X2,X3) +Y3(X1)


0 0

ec ania

F(X1,X2,X3)= Y1(X2,X3)+Y2(X1,X2,X3) +Y3(X1)


ly
Elements 2009 the: The
mainBronx’s Grand Concourse Paola Aguirre

ita
Raleigh

gre rum
40º
40º sspp
population density, as well as

e
aain

a
in

us
-40 -40

For the purpose of this exercise, the Ecology

ey
urban transformations that took place

turk
-80

rea
-80

an
-

ina

jap
ko
sections are taken social
along major roads

ch
there, mainly housing and 30º
30º

na
sti
th 280 280

le
intersecting the grand Concourse. Al-

pa
infrastructure construction. Left and Below

o
xic

.p
re
me
240 240

rico
ican
ternatively,
If we connect a typology can be set up
that information with a 20º
20º
egy adds a lay

in

rto
dom

pue
200 200

r
ado
time-line, it conditions.
is apparent Combining the reciprocal

ia
depicting various

ind
alv
mation accordi

el s
160 160

relationship
information on one between
section global
from the events dif-(e.g. 10º
10º
biotopes.

m
120 120

tna
a
aafrfr

Bsf*X1
afric

Y3= Bsf*X1
WWIcategories
and WWII, gives the Great Migration or
icicaa

ine
vie
ferent the conditions

ilip
ph
decode
80 80

economical
and their crisis in
interactions in Latin
one plane. America), 0º

1. to translate (data or o

Y3=
40 40

local information
Combining events and urban in one projects,
category and the
a message) from a code or
0 0

dramatic changes
through the different sections sums the in the flows of
a pattern into the original
-40 -40

site.
Grand population,
Concourse in both scales.
Extension; Re-configuration of trans- The conflict A system of ponds with artificial wetlands History was proposed to improve water quality of the Harlem
Network of bridges and paths, connecting the Bronx
k between
portationdesire and expectation of River.
infrastructures.
-80
language or form. / 2. to
-80

2007
2007 with the recreational facilities of Randall’s Island

F(NYC)=

F(NYC)=
F(NYC)=
equality and justice versus the reality extract meaning from
in the hosting territory becomes a
2000
2000
(spoken or written symbols)
Miami + Miami+ + Miami +
01 + 02 +03 + 04 + 05 + 06 + 07 + 08 + 09 + 10 + 11 + 12 Miami
1990
1990
spatial issue.
ANITA BERRIZBEITIA
ROACH

r 1980
1980 pattern
1. the combination of
3,000,000 3,000,000
3,000,000 3,000,000 2,500,000 2,500,0002,500,000 2,500,000 2,000,000 2,000,000
1950
1950
2,000,000 2,000,000 1,500,000 1,500,000
1,500,000 1,500,000 1,000,000 1,000,000
1,000,000 1,000,000 500,000FELIPE CORREA (coordinator)
qualities,
500,000
500,000 attributes,
500,000 0 0 0 0 500,000 commuters500,000 commuters
500,000 commuters 500,000 commuters
1940
1940

RAFI SEGAL tendencies, etc., forming


627,860 4,019,393 94,027 145,299 817,407 40,244
200,000-400,000

DEVELOPMENT PHASES
Logo
627,860
627,860 4,019,393 627,8604,019,393
4,019,393
94,027 94,027
145,299 145,299
94,027
817,407 817,407
145,299
40,244 817,40740,24440,244
e 47
public private
plaincar plainprivate
public private car plain
This is the Harvard Design School logo.

publica consistent caror character-


URBAN DECODING public
public private car car
private plain public private
public car plain
car plain
1910
1910
It is also an EPS file. See notes on color

private plain public private car plain


on page 6.
100,000-200,000

bronx
bronx global
global border
border
istic arrangement. / 2. an

rce: US Census
ound
ound
ound
ound
An Alternative Reading country ofof origin
country of
New
origin
EDITED BY CHRISTOPHER A. ROACH example, instance, sample
50,000-100,000

or specimen. / 3. the repeti-

und
128 129

und
und
und
(( )) amount
amount of
of population
population from...
from...
York City
10,000-50,000

2 Graphic Standards Manual

t tion of a unit in rythim and/or


Habana 1. Pools
,000-10,000

Habana Habana
Habana geometry.
00-5,000

The city is a puzzle. It is integrated by 2. Berms


1,000

3. Ponds
Editor:
Christopher A. Roach

Studio Coordinator:
Felipe Correa

Studio Seciton Instructors:


Anita Berrizbeitia
Felipe Correa
Rafi Segal

Acknowledgements:

Moshen Mostafavi, Dean + Alexander and Victoria Wiley Professor of Design


Alex Krieger, Interim Chair of the Department of Urban Planning + Design
Rahul Mehrotra, Chair of the Department of Urban Planning + Design
Andrea Leers, MAUD + MLAUD Program Director

Ian Michael Klein, T.A.


Dan Handel, R.A.
Yonatan Cohen, T.A.
Lorena Bello-Gomez, T.A.

Paul Cote, GIS Specialist

Sergio Bessa, Director of Programs, The Bronx Museum


David Burney FAIA, Commissioner of NYC Department of Design + Construction
Robert Lane, Director of Design, Regional Plan Association

Harvard University Graduate School of Design is a leading center for educa-


tion, information, and technical expertise on the built environment. Its
© Presidents and Fellows of
Departments of Architecture, Landscape Architecture, and Urban Planning and Harvard College
Design offer master’s and doctoral degree programs and provide the founda- All rights reserved. No part
tion for the School’s Advanced Studies and Executive Education. may be reporoduced without
permission

Printed in Cambride by
Kendall Press
2
ELEMENTS OF URBAN DESIGN : THE BRONX’S GRAND CONCOURSE
Fall 2009

ANITA BERRIZBEITIA
FELIPE CORREA
RAFI SEGAL
EDITED BY CHRISTOPHER A. ROACH
3
B
BX
CONTENTS
Introduction Felipe Correa / 006/

Section 1: Anita Berrizbeitia / 013/ Laura Janka Zires / 013/ Victor


Muñoz Sanz / 025/ Song He / 037/ Jonathan Linkus / 049/

Section 2: Felipe Correa (coordinator) / 061/ Jonathan Scelsa / 063/


HungKai Liao + HsiaoRuo Huang / 075/ Dongwhan Moon / 093/ Ángel
Rodríguez Colón / 105/

Section 3: Rafi Segal / 117/ Christopher A. Roach / 119/ Constantine


Bouras / 131/ Alpa Nawre / 143/ Mark Elliott Upton / 155/ Andrea
Pavia / 167/ Paola Aguirre / 181/

5
THE ELEMENTS OF URBAN DESIGN
Studio Brief + Research Platform

BACKGROUND INTRODUCTION

Elements of Urban Design is an advanced core studio As emergent models of urban development in the
for the post professional programs in urban design North American urbanized geographies continue to
at Harvard’s Graduate School of Design. This depart from the more time-honored envelope of the
studio introduces critical concepts, strategies and traditional compact city, the canvas of action for
technical skills associated with current thinking designers necessarily expands and diversifies. The
on urbanism, and speculates on the designer’s role customary post-war divide between the cultivated
in analyzing and shaping complex metropolitan city and its peripheries has, in the past three
systems. Applied research and lectures inform a decades, been partially supplanted by newer
series of interrelated exercises that construct morphologies fueled by urbanization pressures at
diverse hypotheses about new formal and experiential the scale of the mega-region. Fast paced forms of
urbanities, across multiple scales of intervention metropolitan development, paired with new “geo-
and development. political annexation” procedures have transformed
the urban / suburban dyad into a much more complex
system of loosely associated spreads and densities,
fundamentally altering the original kit of parts
of the post war suburb, and its social, economic,
and spatial dynamics. This new dispersed urban
model, regional in scale, is primarily driven by
off-center multi-nodal economic engines, large-
scale resource extraction / distribution, and
heavyweight regional mobility networks, that in
many ways rely less and less on the financial and
functional support of the compact city.

While the “traditional” city at the turn of the


twenty first century has witnessed an unprecedented
period of re-invention, coalescing a plethora of
strategies and scales to restructure its long-
established quarters, the vast majority of the
urbanized terrain continues to operate under the
influence of watered down post-war functionalist
schemas. Given this framework, the moment is ripe
to redefine the role of the urbanistic project
within an amplified context, and in doing so, re-
hatch the larger motivations that can guide the
designer in conceiving new relationships among
existing urban parts within an expanded field of
action, and act as a critical agent regarding the
spatial particularities of the parts themselves.

6
PEDAGOGIC OBJECTIVES

The Elements of Urban Design focuses on four main


pedagogic points:
...the moment is ripe to
1. Establishing constructive forms of exchange redefine the role of the
between analytical research and design
through diverse conceptual frameworks and
projective representational techniques.
urbanistic project within an
2. Exploring the wide range of scenarios amplified context, and in
currently at play within urbanized
landscapes and the diverse design procedures
that can inform their transformation at
doing so, re-hatch the larger
multiple scales.
motivations that can guide
3. Rethinking the role of landscape and
infrastructure as significant building
blocks in the creation of new urban systems
the designer in conceiving
and in the reconfiguration of existing
systems. new relationships among
4. Establishing an open dialogue between
larger design motivations and actions,
existing urban parts within
and how they might be tested and explored
through specific design hypotheses. an expanded field of action...

7
THE BRONX’S GRAND CONCOURSE

GEOGRAPHY

The Centennial of the Grand Boulevard and Concourse

The Grand Boulevard and Concourse, designed by


Louis Aloys Risse in the early 1890’s (completed
in 1909) and constructed at the height of the City
Beautiful Movement, was conceived as an ambitious
thoroughfare linking northern Manhattan to the
South Bronx and stretching for over four miles, to
the Mosholu Parkway in the Northern portion of the
Bronx. In addition to the Grand Concourse’s own
value as an early twentieth century infrastructural
piece of great significance, its scope and ambition
goes way beyond its four-mile length. Throughout
its one hundred year history, it has served as
both, a major spine along the Bronx and a pivot
between Manhattan and the Northern New York
region’s more dispersed development. It links to
the South, through an extension of Fifth Avenue,
Manhattan to the Bronx, and, to the north through
multiple parkways, the Bronx to Westchester County
and the lower Hudson Valley. In addition, The Grand
Concourse can also be uniquely conceptualized as
a repository of twentieth century urban episodes.
Ranging from early 1900’s City Beautiful ideas,
through the rise of the post war suburb, to urban
renewal and model neighborhood projects, and to
extreme urban disinvestment and abandonment. The
Grand Concourse and its affiliated parts exemplify
the diverse desires, ideals and conflicts that have
shaped the American Metropolis throughout the course
of the twentieth century. Most importantly, today
the Concourse and many of its adjacent areas are
in dire need of a renewed conceptual framework that
can fuel a restructuring process across multiple
scales; one that can effectively re-conceptualize
the urban identity of the Bronx, and its relation
and place within the larger metropolitan region.
The Concourse therefore needs to be read both within
its own four mile length and as part of a longer
cross urban element between Manhattan and the Lower
Hudson Valley.

8
COMPREHENSIVE PLATFORM STRUCTURE

Using The Grand Concourse and its extensions as an The fall 2009 studio was composed of three inter-
open laboratory, the 2009 Elements of Urban Design related parts that called students to investigate
studio acted as a research / design platform from a series of nested scales and sites.
which to investigate current physical and social
systems that are shaping the American metropolis, The first portion of the semester relied heavily
The aim was to lay out broad set of strategies on research and projective drawing in order to
and procedures to aid students in developing sound establish a clear body of analytical work that
hypotheses regarding the scope and ambition of the could serve as a primary source for future design
urbanistic project within the emergent scenarios of interventions. Students tackled the larger New
a 21st century urban terrain. York metropolitan region through a series of
“investigative tracks” that cut across multiple
The course was guided by two discrete, yet scales and material processes, in order to visualize
interrelated objectives; on the one hand, it the modus operandi of the eco-urban systems that
presented an introduction to a widespread set of have shaped this terrain in question.
ideas, strategies, and techniques that have exercised
significant influence in the physical development For the second portion of the semester, students,
of our current urbanized landscapes. On the other, working in groups of two, conceptualized and
it served as a critical lens to analyze the urban developed an urban strategy for one of four
and allow each student to engender cogent positions carefully selected areas of intervention along The
that re-evaluate the “agency” of the designer in Grand Concourse. Each area was charged with a set
relation to both, established and emerging urban of issues that was to be addressed. In addition,
contexts. As a studio, the students rethought the the material assembled in the first portion of the
motivations and techniques that can drive design in semester served as a reference source that helped
multiple settings and scales, particularly those in students to conceptualize their final strategy.
less established urban grounds were the discipline
must continue to fine tune well tempered design For the third and final portion of the semester,
strategies. students working individually, selected a site
within one of the four larger areas of intervention
(from the second portion) and pushed forward a
specific design proposal that tested some of the
hypotheses proposed in the larger group strategy.
section 1: ANITA BERRIZBEITIA
Professor of Landscape Architecture
Laura Janka Zires
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse
70% of the people in the Bronx commute to Manhattan and to
the rest of the country (ten other main cities) for work
thanks to the dense Subway infrastructure and its connectiv-
ity with major highways and airports:
1.The Multimodal condition and extreme commuting. This
condition has created a job network that has increasingly
expanded and allowed people to work in the best or only job
opportunity they get no matter location.
2.People spend more time and money commuting to work since
job opportunities have not been created in the borough.
3.Even though at a city level, New York’s prime mobil-
ity characteristic is its reliance on public transport and
walking (the city accounts for almost half of all public
transport use in the United States), Bronx commuters depend
greatly on the automobile if traveling to other destinations
apart from Manhattan (even inside the Bronx).
There are few investment and financing opportunities in
transit infrastructure serving internal boroughs and linking
the Bronx east-west side. The lack of infrastructures asks
for creative solutions linking land use, and other indus-
BRONX-COMMUTING SCALES tries to support public investments and create PPP’s.

Beijing

Tokyo

Montpelier +

Boston +
Hartford +
NYC-(Bronx 8%)
+
+
New Jersey
Philadephia +
+ San Francisco Baltimore +

Richmond +

Raleigh +

Miami +

3,000,000 2,500,000 2,000,000 1,500,000 1,000,00

Habana

Bogota

Caracas
14 Puerto Rico
Laura Janka Zires ANALYSIS

mega-commuting commuters
+

Bronx=0.08*NYC
ontpelier

Boston +
Hartford +
8%) +

INbound(B,H,NJ,PH,R)+F(X1,X2,X3)*(100/8) +OUTbound(M,B,H,NJ,PH,BL,R,RA,MI)
225,926 2,471,576 24,498
+
+

Y1=B1*Acar/Bcar = B1*(Hcar*Bcarf/Bcar) = B1*((X2-X3)*Bcarf)/Bcar


+

Y2= X1– Y1- Y3= x1- (B1*((X2-X3)*Bcarf)/Bcar) - Bsf*X1


+

F(X1,X2,X3)= Y1(X2,X3)+Y2(X1,X2,X3) +Y3(X1)

Y3= Bsf*X1
F(NYC)=

1,000,000 500,000 0 500,000 commuters

627,860 4,019,393 94,027 145,299 817,407 40,244


public private car plain public private car plain
outbound
inbound

National Highway System


U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration

Changes in employment and commuting patterns among workers in New York City
and New York Metropolitan Area 2000-2007 15
New York City Department of City Planning
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse
Actual infrastructure needs to be recalibrated and used at
its maximum.
The impact of New York’s economic system is nowhere as
evident and measurable as in the physical structure of the
Bronx. The Bronx is spatially and programmatically organized
according to a north-south basis, allowing its infrastruc-
ture to link and feed Manhattan and to cope with its geog-
raphy. These regional infrastructures have shaped Bronx’s
urban landscape and programmatic systems.
149th St-Grand Concourse (2,4,5)
1. Landscape: the railroad yard and the water reservoir
are revealed in the middle of the urban fabric. Thier lack
of public access and use makes them appear as voids and sub
utilized barriers. The Jerome Water Reservoir used to feed
part of Manhattan’s water demand but is no longer in use.
There is a new Croton Water Filtration Project that will
provide clean drinking water to the city.
2. Transit and road Systems connect the Bronx with
Manhattan but leaves the local area disconnected within it.
Inaccessible east-west street network.
3. These infrastructure landscapes are surrounded by
residential and educational boxed uses lacking services and
commercial uses. Uses are organized in boxes that run along
north-south corridors. RESIDENTS HAVE TO TRAVEL TO GET TO
THEIR BASIC NEEDS.

70 447
San Francisco
(

s
ood
Fo e
ole or ia
Wh ltim eph
Ba d ch
ila te sey
Ph e
n er le
Ge w J oog
ltin n ce

Ne G
re
nsu to n
ork r Sto
Co Bos pplia
g
e

ond
A
Ne tain

gh
n

hm

280 420
tw

Ralei
Co

Miami
R ic

200mph

150mph

100mph

50mph

16
Laura Janka Zires ANALYSIS
speed

extreme-commuting
50mph

100mph

150mph
Montpelier

200mph
4
8

5
n

7
sto
Bo

d
or
6
rtf
Ha

12

200mph

150mph

100mph
3

50mph
11

10

(60 min)
(90 min)
(120 min) 2

(240 min)
M sto ord rse ia
Bo artf Je eph
on n
H w d e

tp
Ne ila or d co po

eli
Ph ltim on nci
Ba ichmFra

er
R an
S
La

y
G

(360 min)
ua

commuting time (one way)


rd
s
ia
Jo

Ai
hn

r
F. K

Ra iami dy

rt
M ne
en

420
lei
gh

National Highway System


U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration
Air

Changes in employment and commuting patterns among workers in New York City and New York Metropolitan Area 2000-2007
po

New York City Department of City Planning


rt

2008 MTA New York City Travel Survey-Summary Selected Results


Metropolitan Transportation Authority

2007 Census Fact Finder


New York City Department of City Planning

Bronx County (NY) August 2009 Demographics Working Commuters


Bronx County

The Best Places to Work in New York Area,


Fortune Magazine

Commuting Time

Average Travel Time to Work of Workers 16 Years and Over Who Did Not Work at Home (Minutes)
US Census Bureau

17
Program Facts
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Gunter’s Chain: 1/4 Chain: landscape: Jerome Water Reservoir “The location of this site,

STRIPING LANDSCAPE

STRIPING VOLUME
Gunter's chain allowed either method to be used. 640 acres/4 area: 380,712 m2 immediately adjacent to the
An acre measured 4,840 square yards in traditional units program: water reservoir Bedford Park Boulevard station
and 10 square chains in Gunter's system state of use: unutilized on the 4 (Jerome Avenue) Line,
ownership: public ownership makes it ideally suited for
future plans: water reservoir by 2020 (??) transit-oriented development.”
North Rail Yard NYC DOT
52011 m2
raill yard and service buildings
subutilized Adjacent FAR: 8
DOT and private ownership
Transit Oriented Development Adjacent FAR: 6
South Rail Yard
56,875 m2
raill yard and subway station
subutilized im
DOT and private ownership
Transit Oriented Development
Harris Park
68,000 m2
baseball fields
subutilized
public ownership
no future plans

What a dollar spent on food paid for in 2000


sts s
n

er co xe
n
Ener tatio

Busi irs et)


Rent ciatio
Dep tising

Oth ness Ta
Reparest (n
g
agin

spor
gy
ts

re
er
r
Labo

Profi
Pack

Adv

Inte
Tran

19¢ 38¢ 8¢ 3.5¢ 4¢ 4¢ 3.5¢


4¢ 4.5¢ 3.5¢ 2.5¢ 4¢
1.5¢

Farm value Marketing bill

Profiling Food Consumption in America


STRIPING LANDSCAPE

“U.S. sales of organic food and b


have grown from $1 billion in 199
estimated $20 billion in 2007, an
projected to reach nearly $23 bil
Organic food sales are anticipate
an average of 18 percent each y
18 from 2007 to 2010.”
2007 OTA Manufacturer Survey
MERCA-BX
Laura Janka Zires ANALYSIS

“The population of the borough

SWAP STRIPING
STRIPING PROGRAM
STRIPING VOLUME

has a number of demographic housing


n factors all associated with unem-
, ployment,” said Jim Brown, a
labor market analyst for the State
Department of Labor. Mr. Brown
said in addition to the Bronx’s
poverty and high dropout rates,
its large immigrant population
and the percentage of its resi-
dents who speak languages other
6 than English factors in its high
unemployment rates.

Economists have two interests in “We must ensure that all


immigration: the labor market impacts New Yorkers live within a
services & facilities
of immigration and the progress of 10-minute walk of a park.”
immigrants in the U.S. economy

retail

parking

sports and recreation

research
production
storage
direct retail
machiney
mercado
green houses

water

farm land

of organic food and beverages


n from $1 billion in 1990 to an
$20 billion in 2007, and are
o reach nearly $23 billion in 2008.
od sales are anticipated to increase
of 18 percent each year
to 2010.” 19
Manufacturer Survey
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

MercaBRONX uses existing infrastructure for productive means


that create local, regional, and global economies and ecolo-
gies while reconfiguring a new artificial landscape system.
A market and farming program provides for infrastructure
to be reshaped, programmed and intervened in, in order to
become an active platform and access for the city, bringing
closer the basic needs:
Inclusive: allowing different social groups to produce,
to use and live a common though diverse landscape/infra-
structure.
Just: economies that reach different sectors give job oppor-
tunities for young and immigration populations who currently
suffer the most dramatically from unemployment.
Sensitive: a more permeable and accessible urban fabric and
infrastructure brings services, retail and institutions
closer.

The systems
Dynamic and mobility:
1.Bus Rapid Transit (10% the cost of subway line and more
reliable and efficient than buses) lo link the existing sub-
way north-south lines.
2.Bike path
3.Pedestrian paths
4.Street network connecting east-west
5.Recreational loop
Food/industrial
1.Farmland (1/4 Chain farming acres)
2.Delivery
3.Production into eatable and non eatable woods
4.Mercado
5.Food institution
Educational and recreational:
1.Sports
2.Food research and laboratory
3.School network
4.Plazas and gardens

Opportunities:
Fresh Food Store Program
Public Space Program to utilized and underused infrastruc-
ture
Crouton Water Filtration Project
High Sports Program
Population growth rate (4%)
Transit Oriented Development over the Subway Railyards

20
Laura Janka Zires PROPOSAL

( Bronx
Hunts Point Market (
52

43.5
36.7

US billion dollars/year 3.5 % of all food product sales in the United States

2006

2007

2008
water

delivery loop MERCA-BX

Croton Water
Filtration Project

23
8
St
re
et
Bronx Rapid Transit

wn
dla
oo
W
y
wa

info
rk
Pa

23
lu

1
hu
e
p bik

St
os

re
et
M

sports circle
info
p

p
p bike

X
AB
RC
ME

22
ark

5
St
dP

re
et
for

info
d
Be

e
Av
T ter
BR ebs
W
d
oa
eR
dg

M
os
bri

hu
gs

lu
Kin

Pa
rk

For
dha
ml
ine
XB

( (
Xlin
e
Bronx
Hunts Point Market

21
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Bar-CODE ME

Photovoltaic Arrays
Bronx Rapid TRansit

Market and Retail


Postproduction

Crotn Filtration
Consumption

Green Roof

institutional
sports circle
main roads

Pleasure

mercado
Platform

1M Tree
Harvest
delivery

private
FOOD

public

valley
Parks
water

TOD

park

land
rail
hill

air
da wires food phase public budget ownership zoning scale
"the development"
green terrace
entertainment
greenhouse
housing x 15
offices
retail
parking
multiple
housing
x 12

school bridge
x4

sky terrace
museum
mercabrOnx entertainment
Wholefoods Headquarters
THE Harvest LAB
offices
x4 x 15
retail
mercado access
parking
the container out

greenhouse
research
x2
in parking

seed maze

soccer field

football field

playzone

fitness center
x3

beisball

water reservoir

dune

farmland

olympic
swimming pool

x3

mercado unit
x 16

English tennis
court

backyard
housing
x3

22
Laura Janka Zires PROPOSAL
phasing
12 01

11 02

03
10

04
09

08 05

06
07

broccoli
beans
blueberries
cabbage
apples
peppers
pumpkin
squash

Broccoli MERCA-BX

25

broccoli import status


173,004 Ton/year (2005)

natural irrigation
Bronx Rapid Transit
and configuration of fields
10,000-12,000 plants/acre

pack
aging
and st
orage

seed
pl
and gr antation
eenh
ouse
s

harve
eatabl
produce and non
st

!
tion eatabl
e

local and migration employment

1,826 miles reduction

cancer
broccoli thanksgiving pie

detoxification

( (
stomach disorders
(fertilizer source) (organic source) skincare
US $5,000/acre/year US $5,000/acre/year immunity
bone health
US $1,632/acre/year US $2,486/acre/year pregnancy
blood preasure
US $3,268/acre/year amnesia 23
Victor Muñoz Sanz

25
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

THE BRONX: GLOBAL COUNTY


native white population
Global context, local issues

The Bronx has always been a diverse


place, with a non-static population with
an enormous variety of ethnic origins,
coming into and moving within the Bronx.
Such flows and changes, and their causes,
are definitive to understand this unique
county. 80º

The diagram on the left traces the


patterns in the flows of population 70º
coming to the Bronx and their ethnic
origins in the period between 1910 and
60º
2009: it shows visually the real and

da
na
ca
dynamic global range of the Bronx. The
50º the bronx
next series of diagrams zoom into the
Bronx and show the ethnic origin and
40º
population density, as well as the main

a
us
urban transformations that took place
there, mainly social housing and 30º

infrastructure construction.

o
xic
me
If we connect that information with a

ica
20º

min
do
or
time-line, it is apparent the reciprocal

lvad
sa
el
relationship between global events (e.g. 10º

WWI and WWII, the Great Migration or


economical crisis in Latin America), 0º

local events and urban projects, and the


dramatic changes in the flows of
population, in both scales. The conflict
between desire and expectation of 2007

equality and justice versus the reality 2000


in the hosting territory becomes a
1990
spatial issue.
1980

1950

1940

1910
100,000-200,000

bronx global border

country of origin
50,000-100,000

( ) amount of population from...


10,000-50,000
5,000-10,000
1,000-5,000
500-1,000
0-500

26
2
Víctor Muñoz Sanz ANALYSIS

afroamerican population
d
lan
fin

rus
sia
sw
ed
nia

en
ua
lith

ne
en the ge
ire gla rla rm
lan nd nd an
s y
h.

d po
ec

lan
e

cz
nc

d
er.

au
ary
d

fra

str
an

itz

ia
ng
otl

sw

hu
sc

ec ania
ly
ita

gre rum

sp
e

ain
ey
turk

rea

an
ina

jap
ko
ch
a
tin
les
pa
.
rep

o
an

ric
o
ert
pu

ia
ind

m
tna
a

afr
s
ic

ica
ine
afr

vie

ilip
ph
200,000-400,000

source: US Census

0º 10º 20º 30º 40º 50º 60º 70º 80º 90º 100º 110º 120º 130º 140º 150º 160º 180º

27
3
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

1909

1944

1954
1916

1917

1918

1919
1901

1902

1903

1904

1906

1907

1908

1911

1912

1913

1914

1921

1922

1923

1924

1926

1927

1928

1929

1931

1932

1933

1934

1936

1937

1938

1939

1941

1942

1943

1946

1947

1948

1949

1951

1952

1953
1900

1905

1915

1925

1935

1945

1955
1920

1930

1940

1950
1910
the world WWI begins WWI ends Spanish Civil War WWII begins WWII ends
russian revolution

usa Great Migration starts Great Depression second Great Migration


Puerto Ricans get US citizenship

nyc & the bronx line number 2 of subway reaches the Bronx the Bronx becomes a country Yankee Stadium opens Roosevelt visits the Bronx social housing units start to be built in the Bro
Bronx River Parkway first stage is completed The "Bronx Slave Market" starts working The "Bronx Slave Market" is officially forbiden

u sa

usa
George Washington Bridge opens

usa
eur eur eur
o pe op o pe
e

ic a
er ric
a
am e
aassiiaa

am
h

robert moses
ut

uth
so

FDR dr. construction begins Cross-Bronx xpwy construction begins

so
Triborough Bridge opened to the traffic Brooklyn Queens xpwy construction begins
Henry Hobson Expressway opened to the traffic Bronx River pkwy extension begins

hamerica
Bronx Whitestone Bridge opened to the traffic Bronx River pkwy extension en
Major Deegan Expressway reaches Grand Concourse

sout
grand concourse grand concourse construction begins grand concourse opened to the traffic six-story buildings start to be built along the concourse Loew's Paradise opens Lebanon Hospital opens
Roosevelt Gardens apartments is built Art Decó buildings start to be built along the Concourse
Concourse Plaza Hotel opens Concourse subway opens
Louis Risse dies Bronx Courthouse opens

co-op

1910 35 synagogues in south bronx


1940 193 synagogues in south bronx
1950 266 synagogues
*

in south bronx *in the end of the 50's


1980
ethnic concentration
+90% 60-90% 30-60% 15-30%

white / american + european black hispanic population density


+15000 p. 7000-15000 p 3000-7000 p. 500-3000 p. 0-500 p.

4
28
Víctor Muñoz Sanz ANALYSIS

1964

1984

1994
1974

2004
1976
1956

1957

1958

1959

1961

1962

1963

1966

1967

1968

1969

1971

1972

1973

1977

1978

1979

1981

1982

1983

1986

1987

1988

1989

1991

1992

1989

1996

1997

1998

1999
1990

2010
1965

1975

1985

1995

2005
1960

1980

2000
2001

2002

2003

2006

2007

2008

2009
1970
Cuban Revolution oil crisis Vietnam war ends Salvadoran Civil war Berlin wall falls economical crisis in México Erika world financial crisis
Leonidas Trujillo dies

national per capita income equals $3900 Katrina

a
us

usa
ronx mandatory busing of children at school for racial balance Co-op City construction begins Co-op City's 15,000 apartments are completed crime rate peak in NYC Bill Clinton visits the Bronx 9/11
policy of concentration of welfare households in South Bronx $1000 to $3500 lump sum payments for relocation of low income people community development corporation program begins

usa
usa
Jane Jacobs' "The death and life of Great American Cities" is published 383.000 people living in the South Bronx 166.000 people living in the South Bronx
eur eur eur eur
15.000 fires in the Bronx op
e
op
e
op
e
op
e
"the Bronx is burning"
New York City Blackout a
eric eric
a
ca am am
Jimmy Carter visits the Bronx er i th th
am ou ou

s
asia asia asia

ut
asia

so
Major Deegan xpwy is completed Sheridan xpwy is completed FDR dr. is completed Bruckner xpwy. is completed Robert Moses dies
Sheridan xpwy construction begins Cross-Bronx xpwy is completed Harlem river pkwy opened to the traffic
Brooklyn Queens xpwy construction ends

southa rica
ends Throghsneck Bridge opened to the traffic

me

asia
New England throughway opened to the traffic
Alexander Hamilton bridge opened to the traffic

Young Israel of the Concourse opens a synagogue Plaza Hotel is transformed into welfare housing
Rossevelt Gardens is transformed into subsidized housing Young Israel synagogue is transformed into Bronx Museum Loeb's Paradise closes Loeb's Paradise re-opens as a latin music concert hall and boxing venue
Private developers begin restoring the last 5 vacant buildings in the Concourse renovation of the Concourse along 10 blocks

op co-op co-op co-op

54 are now empty lots

38 are now public buildings

14 are now private agencies

1 is now a parish house

5 are now new homes


nyc nyc

3 are now abandoned apartment house


nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc

3 are now inhabited apartment houses


nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc

3 are now office buildings


nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc

5 are now city parks


nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc nyc P.A. P.A. P.A. P.A.

7 are now replaced by cross-bronx


P.A. P.A. P.A. P.A. P.A. P.A. P.A. P.A. P.A. P.A.

9 are now replaced by industrial park

13 are now businesses


I
-
95I
-
95

27 are now private houses


I
-
95I
-
95I
-
95I
-
95I
-
95

3 are now methodist churches (black)


$ $ $ $ $ $
4 are now adventist churches (black)
$ $ $ $ $ $ $
1 is now adventist church (latin)

4 are now adventist churches (black)

8 are now pentecostal churches (latin)


VII VII VII

4 are now pentecostal churches (black)


VII VII

13 are now baptist churches (latin)

21 are now baptist churches (black)

13 are now christian churches (latin)

24

1990 2000 2009


are now christian churches (black)

4 synagogues in south bronx

5
29
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

THE XBX PLAN


current traffic pattern

The Cross-Bronx Expressway as it is now C


is pointless. Brave decisions such as
traffic restriction policies and by-
passing alternatives for automobiles are
needed. Nonetheless, the presence of this
infrastructure in conjunction with the
existing mass transportation network
passing across it, make this urban
corridor an area of opportunity:
developing uses and programs that could
(
(
take advantage of the infrastructure and
ease of communication could have a local A
and metropolitan impact and bring social
justice, activity and wealth to the
Bronx. B
By a very simple operation on the cross-
section of the Expressway and using the
existing bridges as base structures for
access, a new system of bus rapid transit
would be introduced, reclaiming the a parenthesis is needed
Cross-Bronx as a local east-west
connector. Together with a proposal of
park-and-ride facilities promoting the
use of the adjacent to mass
transportation systems. C
Just like the railroads in the Potteries
Thinkbelt, the Cross-Bronx could become
an infrastructural spine of a disperse
Technological, Manufacturing, Research
and Commercial Park, that would be
introduced and distributed along the
Cross-Bronx, hybridizing and sharing
programs with the existing city fabric.
The Cross-Bronx, the Bus Rapid Transit
System and the existing commercial and
A
open space systems would link the
different sites at different speeds and
new intensities would appear along their
trail. The Park and the city would become B
one landscape.

by-passing and traffic restrictions


6
30
Víctor Muñoz Sanz PROPOSAL

BRT XBX line BRT XBX line_park-and-ride

P P

P P

cross-bronx corridor_current zoning pattern XBX plan_ re-connecting the green system
on
cati
edu
ial
erc

and
mm

ial
co

ure
ustr
leis
ind

P P

P P

XBX plan_consolidating background program XBX plan_introducing the figures

P
P

P
P

XBX plan_tension between poles creates activity XBX plan_BRT line + park & ride / famliry logistics center

P P

P P

XBX plan_regenerating the green system / linear playground XBX plan_introducing the XBX transfer center

P P

P P

XBX plan_commercial axis/main street bronx/the lab XBX plan_housing renovation


7
31
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

32
8
Víctor Muñoz Sanz PROPOSAL

9
33
The Park program would be located and
objectified in some typical forms (the
main street, the campus and the bridge)
that would be placed in the current urban
tissue in a collage fashion. They would
introduce eidetic urban spaces and
figures that aim to create an urban
identity, fill the urban voids and
consolidate and stitch the existing
fabric. In those, the logistics
facilities mix with other users and
activities, promoting the creation of
direct and indirect employment and public
activity.
Over imposed to this new system, new
public buildings would be introduced.
Their aim is to rescale the existing
infrastructure and become local and
metropolitan milestones along the Cross-
Bronx, while they would solve other
endemic problems of the borough, such as
lack of day care facilities for single
parent households, lack of alternative
education opportunities as well as
obesity and health problems.

34
Víctor Muñoz Sanz PROPOSAL

11
35
Song He
2
1
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse
7 Edge of Bronx Politic Districts
N.H.Whites 75%+
N.H.Whites 50%+
4 Hispanics 75%+
Hispanics 50%+
2
N.H.Blacks 75%+
1 N.H.Blacks 50%+

7
3 N.H.Whites 75%+
N.H.Whites 50%+
4 2 Hispanics 75%+
Hispanics 50%+
5 1 N.H.Blacks 75%+
N.H.Blacks 50%+

6
3 7
N.H.Whites 75%+
N.H.Whites 50%+
5 4 Hispanics 75%+
Hispanics 50%+
6 N.H.Blacks 75%+
N.H.Blacks 50%+

5
Bronx Senate 6Districts

N.H.Whites 75%+
N.H.Whites 50%+

DEFINING EDGE Hispanics 75%+


ck Eastchester Bay Pelham Bay Co-op City

Hispanics 50%+ Racial-Ethnic Concentration


N.H.Blacks 75%+
Tangible and Intangible Edges N.H.Blacks 50%+

in Bronx
Edge is the boundary between different
objects. Some edges are tangible while
some others are intangible. However, both
of them exert an significant influence
on the people living around them. Look-
Pelham Parkway Bronxdale Lacona

ing though the Bronx, we could easily District1 District2 District3


trace its intangible political edges and
tangible community edges.
The edges of Bronx senate and assembly
districts seem quite unregular. But if
Morris Park Pelham Gardens
Van Nest
we overlap them with the racial-ethnic
concentration map of this area, we would
discover that these edges are highly
related with different ethnic groups.
And the result of this division is to
increase the seats of white people in the
senate and assembly while reducing the
wn Edenwald Eastchester
seats of Hispanics and blacks. District4 District5 District6
On the other hand, the edges of community
districts and neighborhoods are mainly
defined by the natural boundaries and
infrastructure of Bronx, including rail
Cemetery system, parkway, highway, main streets,
Wakefield Baychester

parks and water. The basic rule here is


the primary infrastructure defines the
districts and the secondary infrastruc-
ture further divides the districts into
several neighborhoods. District7
Williamsbridge Olinville

38
1
2 4
5 2
Song He ANALYSIS
6
3
7 10

1
9 N.H.Whites 75%+
N.H.Whites 50%+
11 Melrose Mott Haven Port Morris
Hispanics 75%+
Hispanics 50%+
N.H.Blacks 75%+
N.H.Blacks 50%+

4
8
5 2
1
N.H.Whites 75%+
6 N.H.Whites 50%+
3 11 Hispanics 75%+
7 10 Longwood Hunts Point

Hispanics 50%+
N.H.Blacks 75%+
9 N.H.Blacks 50%+

4
8
5 2
Melrose Claremont Morrisania Crotona Park East

6
3
Bronx Assembly
7
Districts
10

9
Concourse Village West Concourse Highbridge East Concourse MT. Eden

8
Racial-Ethnic Concentration Infrastructure of Bronx

District1 District2 District3

Rail System Parkway


12

10

11

9 10

District4 District5 District6 District7

Highway Main Streets


Haven Mott Haven Port Morris Port Morris

District8 District9 District10

Melrose Mott Haven Port Morris

wood Longwood Hunts PointHunts Point

District11

Longwood Hunts Point

ania Morrisania Crotona Park East Park East


Crotona Main Parks Water

39
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse
Edge of Bronx Community
8
12
8
12
7 10

7 10

5 6
11
Bronx Community Districts
11
5 6
4 3
9 10
4 3

2 9 10
1
2
1

Edge of Neighborhoods Infrastructure in Districts Edge of Districts

Melrose Mott Haven Port Morris


District1
Melrose Mott Haven Port Morris

Longwood Hunts Point


District2
Longwood Hunts Point

Melrose Claremont Morrisania Crotona Park East

District3
Melrose Claremont Morrisania Crotona Park East

Concourse Village West Concourse Highbridge East Concourse MT. Eden

Concourse Village West Concourse Highbridge East Concourse MT. Eden


District4

Morris Heights University Heights Mount Hope Fordham District5

Bathgate Belmont East Tremont Bronx Park South West Farms

District6

Unitversity Heights Kingsbridge Heights Fordham Bedford Park Norwood District7


40
Unitversity Heights Kingsbridge Heights Fordham Bedford Park Norwood

Song He ANALYSIS

Riverdale North Riverdale Marble Hill

Spuyten Duyvel Fieldstone Kingsbridge

District8

Clason Point Soundview Bronx River Parkchester

Harding Park Castle Hill Soundview-Bruckner Unionport


District9

Throgs Neck Eastchester Bay Pelham Bay Co-op City


Throgs Neck Eastchester Bay Pelham Bay Co-op City

Throgs Neck Eastchester Bay Pelham Bay Co-op City

District10

Pelham Parkway Bronxdale Lacona


Pelham Parkway Bronxdale Lacona

Pelham Parkway Bronxdale Lacona

Van Nest Morris Park Pelham Gardens


District11
Van Nest Morris Park Pelham Gardens

Van Nest Morris Park Pelham Gardens

Woodlawn Edenwald Eastchester


Woodlawn Edenwald Eastchester

Woodlawn Edenwald Eastchester

Woodlawn Cemetery Wakefield Baychester


Woodlawn Cemetery Wakefield Baychester

Woodlawn Cemetery Wakefield Baychester

Williamsbridge
Williamsbridge
Olinville
Olinville District12
41
Williamsbridge Olinville
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

SOUTH BRONX REVIVE


Waterfront and Old Yankee Underutilized Surfaces

Refreshment
Vacant Lots

School Bus Parking

Surface Storage

Parking
The Design aimed to increase the vital- Decorateive Green

ity of South Bronx by reusing the large Infrastructural Resources


amount of vacant or inefficiently used Subway Station

Metro-North Station
land and buildings. According to the dif- Bus Station

ferent types of land and building typolo-


Underutilized Surfaces
Vacant Lots
Health Care Facility

gies, we proposed a program matrix that


School Bus Parking

Surface Storage
Bicycle Station

hybrid certain kinds of land and build-


Parking

Decorateive Green

ings to provide space for the new pro-


Infrastructural Resources
Subway Station A

grams. We expect that through this more


Metro-North Station

Bus Station

flexible hybrid land use, the density


Health Care Facility

Bicycle Station
B

and diversity of activities in South


Bronx would increase. And by introduc- D

ing these new commercial, eductional and


C

recreational programs, more and more New


Yorkers would enter and experience this
area. The new waterfront would connect
the piecemeal public open space in South E

Bronx and create a recreational network


here. And the space under Deegan Express-
way, considering its close location to
the biggest shopping mall in Bronx, it F

can be transformed into a vendor’s mar-


ket, as a supplement for the mall.

Underutilized Land

Before Proposal
6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00 22:00 23:00 24:00 1:00 6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00 22:00 23:00 24:00 1:00 2:00

Yankee Yankee

Parking Parking
Multi-Family Residential Multi-Family Residential

1&2 Family Residential 1&2 Family Residential


Commute
Industrial
Industrial Commute
Commute
Park/Receational
Park/Receational Park/Receational
Commercial Commercial
School School

Land Using Proportion Weekdays Weekends

42
6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00 22:00 23:
Song He PROPOSAL

Open Space South Bronx

Underutilized Surfaces
Vacant Lots

School Bus Parking

Surface Storage

Parking

Decorateive Green

Infrastructural Resources
Subway Station A

Metro-North Station

Bus Station

Health Care Facility

Bicycle Station
B

D
C
A

C
D Proposed Open Space

Sections of New
Typologies E

Open Space Bronx

6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00 22:00 23:00 24:00 1:00 6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00 22:00 23:00 24:00 1:00 2:00

Utilization of Program Yankee Yankee

Parking Parking

Local Employees Multi-Family Residential Multi-Family Residential

Commute Employees
1&2 Family Residential 1&2 Family Residential
Commute
Industrial
Industrial Commute
Commute
Employees Outside Park/Receational
Park/Receational Park/Receational
Commercial Commercial

Unemployed School School

Land Using Proportion Weekdays Weekends


Students

Senior Citizens

Baseball Fans

1:00 6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00
Marshes in 1899
22:00 23:00 24:00 1:00 2:00
Land Fill and Erosion
After Proposal
Yankee
6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00 22:00 23:00 24:00 1:00 6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00 22:00 23:00 24:00 1:00 2:00

Yankee Parking Yankee

ntial Multi-Family Residential


Parking Parking

1&2 Family Residential Multi-Family Residential


Commute Commute
Industrial Multi-Family Residential
Industrial

1&2 Family Park/Receational Commute 1&2 Family


Residential Commute Industrial Residential
Park/Receational
Commercial Park/Receational

School Park/Receational
Park/Receational Commercial
Commercial
ekdays School Weekends School

Weekdays Weekends

43
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

The South Bronx area is lacking of


sports and fitness facilities, and the
redevelopment of Yankee Stadium further
demolished some of the sport fields. To
solve this problem with the redevelopment
of the currently inaccessible waterfront,
densifying the sports and fitness
facilities along the waterfront would be
a reasonable strategy. The current school Original River
Original RiverBank
Bank
bus terminals can be relocated under the
decking surface of the rail yard. And the
warehouse, storage space and industrial
plant can be moved to the adjacent low
density industrial area, to form a
more competitive high density industry
pattern. The railway on the water -- the
Old Point Link is like an obstacle on the
water. Since there would be only very
Interior Promenade
Back Promenade
few trains passing through every day, a
rotatable track system is proposed here.
The tracks can rotate 90 degrees and
become piers into the river.

Front
Water Promenade
Promenade

Steps to
Steps toWater
Water

Trees
Trees
44
Song He PROPOSAL

Land Use Condition


Old Yankee

Shopping Mall

Storage Space

Warehouse

Industrial
Rotating Rail System
Vacant Space

Education Institution

Parking Lots

School Bus

Original River Bank

RotatingLand Use Condition


Rail System
Old Yankee

Shopping Mall

Rotating Rail System


Rotating Rail System
Storage Space

Warehouse
School
School Bus Bus Storage a
Interior Promenade
Industrial

Vacant Space

Education Institution

Parking Lots

School Bus
Original River Bank

Water Promenade

Stra
School Bus Storage
Storage and
and Industry Interior Promenade
The
Land Use Condition the
Old Yankee
Industry Steps to Water
func
Shopping Mall

Storage Space
indu
Warehouse new
Industrial
a div
Vacant Space

Education Institution
and
Parking Lots Old
Water Promenade
School Bus
woul
Trees
rotat
rotat

Strategy
School Bus Storage and Industry Land
Land Use
Use
The shool bus Condition
Condition
parking would be moved to the space under
Land Use Condition the Old
decking
Yankee of rail yard. And the storage and industry
be added to the adjacent area,Steps to Water

15200
30000
Old Yankee function
Shoppingwould
Mall where some
Shopping Mall industries have taken place under a low density fabric. The

15200
30000
Storage Space
Storage Space newWarehouse
waterfront would be a super flat recreational stripe with
Warehouse a diverse
Industrial
of sports facilities. It would serve both the schools
Industrial and the communities around. The railway on the water -- the
Vacant Space
Vacant Space Old Point Link is like an obstacle on the water. Since there
Education Institution
Education Institution would be only very few trains passing through every day, a
Parking Lots
Parking Lots rotatable track system is proposed here. The tracks can
School Bus
School Bus
rotate 90 degrees and become piers into the river. 15200
30000

15200
30000

Trees
15200
30000

23400
52400
15200
30000

Strategy
School Bus Storage and Industry Scale 1: 3000
The shool bus parking would be moved to the space under
15200
30000

School Bus the decking of railStorage


yard. And andtheIndustry
storage and industry
15200
30000

function would be added to the adjacent area, where some


industries have taken place under a low density fabric. The
new waterfront would be a super flat recreational stripe with
a diverse of sports facilities. It would serve both the schools
16124
24100
15200
30000
16124
24100
16124
24100
16124
24100
16124
24100
16124
24100
16124
24100

and the communities around. The railway on the water -- the


16124
24100

16124
24100

15200
30000

Old Point Link is like an obstacle on the water. Since there


15200
30000

15200
30000

would be only very few trains passing through every day, a


15200
30000

15200
30000

15200
30000

rotatable track system is proposed here. The tracks can


15200
30000

15200
30000
23400
52400

rotate 90 degrees and become piers into the river.


15200
30000

15200
30000

16124
24100

16124
24100

16124
24100
16124
24100
16124
24100
16124
24100

15200
30000

16124
24100

16124
24100

16124
24100

15200
30000

Scale 1: 3000
15200
30000

15200
30000

15200
30000

15200
30000

15200
30000

15200
30000

15200
30000
23400
52400

15200
30000

15200
30000

15200
30000
23400
52400

15200
30000

WATERFORNT
Scale 1: 3000

45
15200
30000
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse
oft three-bedroom unit
nits 140m2 125 units

two-bedroom unit
70m2 296 units

m unit two-story loft


ts 104m2 148 units

m unit
nits Refreshment Process
Roof Lawn Perspective
As a place of worship, the baseball
field of the old Yankee Stadium would
be preserved as a heritage space. The
field would be lifted up to create a
huge space under it with five floors of
parking. The space under the stand would
be transfromed into residential. This LiftField
Lift Field
part would be redivided into different
housing units, according to the original
structure of the stadium. The lifted
field will continue to be a baseball
field for trainning or holding minor
league games. The roof of the stadium
will become a new open space. This
would ensure the heritage field to be Parking Space
Parking Space
accessible for the public. The amazing
field of view here would provide a new
perspective for the public to observe the
city.
S
As

E REFRESHMENT Adjust Structure


Adjust Structure
ol
he
hu
th
re
wi
he
pu
Refreshment Process Residential
Residential

Lift Field Space


Space Distribution
Distribution

Parking Space Open


Open Space
Space
46 Housing Typology
773 Units Total
Residential
Strategy
As a place of worship, the baseball field of the
old Yankee Stadium would Song
beHe preserved as a PROPOSAL
Adjust Structure heritage. The field would be lifted and create a
huge parking space under it. The space below
the stand would be transformed into
residential. However, the roof of the stadium
will become a public park. The amazing view
here would provide a new perspective for the
public to observe the city.
Residential

Refreshment Process

Lift Field Space Distribution

efreshment Process
freshment Process Roof Lawn Playground Playground and Roof
Parking Space Open Space

Housing Typology
Refreshment Process

Housing
773 Typology
Units Total
Strategy
Residential
773 Units Total Refreshment Process As a place of worship, the baseball field of the
Lift
three-story
three-story
Lift Field
loft
loft
Field
Adjust
Lift Field
Structure heritage. The field would be
three-bedroom unit
old Yankee Stadium would be preserved as a
three-bedroom
Space
Space
lifted andDistribution
Space Distribution
create a
unit
Distribution
145m22 51 units huge parking space under it.140m 22 125
140m 125 units
The space belowunits
145m 51 units
Refreshment Process the stand would be transformed into
residential. However, the roof of the stadium
Parking Space
will become a public park. The amazing view
Open Space
here would provide a new perspective for the
Lift Field Space Distribution
public to observe the city.
Residential
Residential Strategy
As a place of worship, the baseball field of the
ParkingSpace
Parking Space Lift Field
old Yankee Stadium would be preserved as a OpenSpace
Open Space
Space Distribution
Adjust Structure heritage. The field would be lifted and create a

stand would be
two-bedroom unit
two-bedroom
huge parking space under it. The space below
the transformed into unit
residential. However, the roof of 2
70m 296 units
the stadium
Parking Space 70m
2
will become a public park. The amazing
296 units
Open Space
view
here would provide a new perspective for the
public to observe the city. Residential
Residential
Residential Strategy
Strategy
ParkingAsAsa aplace
Space placeofofworship,
worship,the thebaseball
baseballfield field ofofthe
Open the
Space Residential
Strategywould be preserved as a
oldYankee
old YankeeStadium
Stadium
As a placewould be the
of worship, preserved
baseball field asofathe Residential
AdjustStructure
Adjust Structure heritage.
RoofThe
Lawn
heritage. The old field
field would
would
Yankee be lifted
Playground
be lifted
Stadium wouldand and create
create aas a
be preserved a Playground and Roof Lawn
one bedroom
one bedroomunitunit hugeparking
parking spaceunder
heritage. Theunder two-story
two-story
field it.The
would The loft
space
bespace
liftedloft
and below
create a
huge
Adjust Structure space it. below Residential
60m22 51 units the stand Strategy
stand huge parking space
would be 104m under 2 148
2 it.
transformed The units
space into
below
Housing 60m Typology51 units
the would
As
the standofbe
a place 104mtransformed
worship,
would 148
the baseball
be transformed units
into
field ofinto
the
773 Units Total
residential.
residential. However,
However,
old Yankee the
Roof Lawn
residential. theroof
Stadium
However, roof ofof
Playground
would
the the
be
roof the stadium
ofstadium
preserved
the as Playground
stadium a and Roof Lawn

three-story loft
will
Adjust Structurebecome
will become a public
heritage.
a public
will
three-bedroom
The park.
field The
would beamazing
unit park. The amazing view
become a public park. lifted
The and
amazing view
create
viewa
Housing Typology huge
here parking
would space aunder
provide new it. The spacefor
perspective below
the
145m2 51 units herewould
here would provide
140m2provide
125 units a anewnew perspective
perspective forforthe
the
773 Units Total the stand
public to observewould be transformed
the city. into
three-story loft publictothree-bedroom
public toobserve
140m
observe thethecity.
unit
residential.
125 units
2
city.
However, the roof of the stadium
145m2 51 units
one bedroom
one bedroom unitunit Residential will become a public park. The amazing view
Residential
48m22Residential
48m 102
102units
units
here would provide a new perspective for the
public to observe the city.
Residential two-bedroom unit
two-bedroom
70m2
unit
2 296 units
Roof Lawn Perspective
70m 296 units

one bedroom unit two-story loft


60m2 51 units 104m2 148 units

one bedroom unit two-story loft


60m2 51 units 104m2 148 units
one bedroom unit Roof Lawn Playground Playground and Roof Lawn
48m2 102 units
Roof Lawn Perspective

Housing Typology
one bedroom unit Roof Lawn Playground Playground and Roof Lawn
RoofLawn
Lawn Playground Playgroundand
Roof Playground SpaceandRoof
Playground RoofLawn
Lawn
773 48m
Units
2 Total
102 units
three-story loft Roof Lawnthree-bedroom unitPlayground Open
Roof Lawn Perspective
145m2 51 units 140m2 125 units
Housing Typology
773 Units Total
Housing Typology
ousing Typology three-story loft three-bedroom unit
373Units
UnitsTotal
Total 145m2 51 units 140m2 125 units

three-storyloft
three-story loft three-bedroomunit
three-bedroom unit
two-bedroom unit
145m
145m 51units
2 251 units 140m
140m 125units
2 2125 units
70m2 296 units

YANKEE REFRESHMENT
two-bedroom unit
70m 296 units
one bedroom unit
2
two-story loft
60m2 51 units 104m2 148 units

two-bedroomunitunit

YANKEE
two-bedroom
one bedroom unit 70m
70m 296units
2 2296 units
two-story loft
60m2 51 units 104m2 148 units
one bedroom unit

Y
48m2 102 units

REFRESHMENT ANKEE REFRESHMENT


onebedroom
one two-storyloft
bedroomunitunit
two-story loft
one bedroom unit
48m2 102 units
Roof Lawn Perspective

47
60m
60m 51units
2 251 units 104m
104m 148units
2 2148 units Roof Lawn Perspective
Jonathan C. Linkus
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

URBAN LAMINATIONS
Identifying Discord

The issue at hand is a disconnection


between the local functionality of the
city and both the regional natural and
regional human ecosystems in which it
operates. As larger infrastructural and
industrial systems have bundled along the
waterfront and rail corridors they elimi-
nate opportunities for open space connec-
tivity as a public resource. While these
performative laminations work systemically
on a larger scale, the proximal relation-
ships between these laminated figures
render discordant and prohibitive exter-
nalities. In essence, it is the disagree-
ment of use rather than the physical
barrier that is at issue. The solution
then is to integrate and intensify their
mutual functionality within each respec-
tive lamination.

50
Jonathan Linkus ANALYSIS

51
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

52
Jonathan Linkus ANALYSIS

53
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Re:manufacturing + Ecology
Reformatting the Urban Laminations

The Southern tip of the borough handles a


disproportionately large share of the
city's waste volume (8% of the city's
garbage travels along the waterfront.
Compounding this difficulty is the fact
that 16,000 trucks still travel through
the South Bronx daily, despite that
industrial jobs among other business have
divested in the neighborhood. A commu-
nity based plan has been devised by
Sustainable South Bronx and the Green-
worker Cooperatives which proposes the
Bronx Recycling and Industrial Park.

The design objective then is two-fold:


Create a new sustainable-industry
district by tapping into a new stream of
post-consumer raw material via shipping
containers elevated on a light rail
network. Additionally, the pedestrian
infrastructure will be expanded and
reformatted to convey the ecological
history of the district. This involves
re-naturalizing the waterfront and the
Mott Haven Wye into a network of open
spaces rich in multi-functionality as
places of recreation, gathering, educa-
tion, and movement. The laminations of
waste infrastructure and waterfront are
not masked or mitigated, but rather are
capitalized-upon as unique juxtaposition
ready to provide benefits to the immedi-
ate context of this reformatted district.

54
Jonathan Linkus PROPOSAL

The crux of this proposal is a census


of the building stock in terms of its
usefulness to current economic and
industrial trends. The increasing flow
of waste through the southern Bronx and
the flight of stable manufacturing
employment present an opportunity
wherein raw material flows can create
new higher tech entrepreneurial oppor-
tunities. The current building stock
is not entirely incapable of supporting
the larger floor-areas required for
light manufacturing as well as other
uses such as multi-family residential
and mixed-use infill. The only excep-
tions are larger historic warehouses
that are able to provide a loose-fit
space. Residential and intuitional
properties are also preserved.
Single-story strip mall type commer-
cial, storage yards, and auto-repair
businesses are slated for replacement
in the long-term planning strategy.
55
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

56
Jonathan Linkus PROPOSAL

Left and Below: The landscape strat-


egy adds a layer of ecological infor-
mation according to a mapping of
biotopes.

57
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

The new district is an assemblage of


existing wharehouses with new constrc-
tion. The upper floors create a super-
block for manufacturing businesses. The
result is both apt for current economic
needs and mindful Hilberseimer’s work as
a historical precednt.

58
Jonathan Linkus PROPOSAL

Above: Plazas are created as the neigh-


borhood is redeveloped; these plazas are
designed as chamfers that can widen
existing alleys into pedestrian passages.
Projected images and materials both
convey the historical biotope of each
location before the city was built.

59
section 2: FELIPE CORREA
Assistant Professor of Urban Planning and Design
MAUD Program Coordinator
Jonathan A. Scelsa
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

TRANSIENT ARTERIES
Infrastructural Confluence

The Bronx is a space of transience; a


space of passing. The Bronx is a Zoom-
scape: an aggregate landscape of New York
City’s infrastructure, ushering people
into and out of the New York metropolis.

Geographically the borough is a bottle-


neck, flanked on the west by the Hudson
River and the east by the Long Island
Sound. The Bronx, is the very last and
narrowest portion of the peninsula land-
mass leading into New York’s metropolitan
area. As a result, the Bronx has accepted
major forms of transit infrastructure to
facilitate the growth and suburban impli-
cations of the metropolis. The borough
has found itself in the center of the
north east regional corridor harboring
two Interstate highways. In addition, the
rail system of the Bronx is comprised of
the New York MTA’s subway system and com-
muter rail network and while the former
serves the Bronx, the latter’s primary
use is from the suburban north. This
commuter train system which trifurcates
into Hudson, Harlem and New Haven lines,
funnel the suburbs into Grand Central
Station of Manhattan.

This confluence of infrastructure has left


the Bronx with unutilized public space;
the residuals of an infrastructural tran-
sit corridor.

64
Jonathan A. Scelsa ANALYSIS

residual spaces
bruckner boulevard

65
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

mosholu parkway
traffic pattern dawn dusk

mega-regional corridor
mta metro-north ridership

66
Jonathan A. Scelsa ANALYSIS

confluence

67
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

ILLUMINATED PIERS

INTERMODAL LAMINATIONS
North Bronx Confluence
LIGHT RAIL STATION

The northern most end of the Grand Con- SUBTERRANEAN PARKING


course houses large deposits of a city
wide infrastructure network that can be
reclaimed for public use. This is mani-
fest in both the Jerome reservoir and the
sunken subway rail-yards. This project
puts forth a series of strategies for the
covering or decking of the latter sunken
infrastructural condition with new hous-
ing and the addition of a new transit
hinge for the metropolitan system.

Capitilizing on a growing reverse commute


out of the Bronx to growing cities such
as White Plains and Yonkers. The existing
infrastructure on the site is augmented
through the addition of new connnective
STRUCTURAL LIGHT TREES
transit pieces such as a new Metro North
line and a Bus Rapid Transit system to be
utilized along the Grand Concourse. This
infrastructural augmentation stirs the
development of new housing and new com-
mercial space at this hingepoint.

The act of laminating new program above


the existing railyards and new railway
station is made possible by an archi-
tectural strategy using a consistent
structural system as the means for the
decking. The system is created to both ENTERTAINMENT COMPLEX
light and circulate air to the sunken
conditions while structurally serving the APERTURES TO BELOW
buildings above.

68
Jonathan A. Scelsa PROPOSAL

RESTAURANTS

LOEWS CINEPLEX

COMPRESSION-RING
TWO-WAY GRID SLAB BUS RAPID TRANSPORT DROPOFF

RADSISSON HOTEL

SKIN WRAPPER
PRIVATE OFFICE TOWERS

RAISED METRO PLATFORM

69
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

white plains

yonkers new rochelle

bronx park

montefiore
research

bicycle loft

hotel

restaurant

mta metro-north revision center

brt dropoff
jerome reserve

car park

grand concourse
lehman college collegiate housing

diversified flats

nyc bike path

new bedford train hub


mta metro-north concourse programmatic movement

70
Jonathan A. Scelsa PROPOSAL

new commercial
and hotel above

bedford
train hub

elevated
4 tube stop

collegiate
housing + center

campus quad
above train yard

diversified
raised flats

ground floor
shopping corridors

grand
concourse

lehman
college

1:2000 scale masterplan

71
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

path network

path network

softscape

wind collectors

path network
compression ring

structural supports
hardscape

softscape

sunken rail yards

72
Jonathan A. Scelsa PROPOSAL

new bedford train hub


mta metro-north
73
HungKai Liao / HsiaoRou Huang
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

THE BRONX’S MEMORIES


Mobility, Density, and Memory

Using six different kinds of density/


intensity( transportation, cultural and
social, service, open space, commercial,
and population), the analysis tried to
locate the most memorable hot spot in
Bronx. These different densities started
to map up a new concentration pattern all
along the city's built mobility. Combining
the densities and the mobility factors,
the project drew a new map of Bronx
according to the strength of collective
memories.

76
2
Liao, HungKai ANALYSIS

77
3
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

78
4
Liao, HungKai ANALYSIS

16 79
5
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

ELASTIC BUFFER ZONE


along the Cross Bronx EXPY

In order to deal with the impact of the


expressway to the downtown area, the
sunken type expressway became the ultimate
strategy in the US. However, the sunken
type EXPY, in one hand, provides high
efficiency on moving, in the other hand,
provide insufficient chance for us to
recognize and memorize the city. This
project provides a buffer zone matrix
which could deal with seven versions of
sunken expressway in the US. The buffering
process includes three critical strate-
gies: reveal, transform, and densify. In
the end, we had a demonstrated project on
the Cross Bronx Expressway by using the
buffer matrix. The buffer matrix will be
applied on the site along with the program
of informal city art campus. The program
works as a stimulus to activate the local
artistic activities to reform the forgot-
ten area of Bronx. The expressway provides
huge amount of population flow through the
Bronx area. The buffer zone matrix
provides a new possibility to rethink the
site which was originally influenced by
the expressway. The program of informal
city art campus further utilizes the site
prepared by the buffer zone to create a
bigger urban influence and redevelopment.

80
6
Huang, HsiaoRou / Liao, HungKai

When Cross Bronx EXPY meets Grand Concourse...

Grand Concourse
to our previous analysis. It is because that the sunken

eroding our memory of the city.

For a much efficient way of moving, we do whatever we want to the ground

Those moving methods eroded our memory like a wide river

The complex physical segregation was created by those operations

81
7
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

a study of sunken type EXPY in 10 major ci�es in the US

82
8
Huang, HsiaoRou / Liao, HungKai PROPOSAL

83
9
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

for Sunken Type EXPY

84
10
Huang, HsiaoRou / Liao, HungKai PROPOSAL

85
11
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Informal Campus
for City Art
Demonstrated Project

86
12
Huang, HsiaoRou / Liao, HungKai PROPOSAL

87
13
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Composite System

88
14
Huang, HsiaoRou / Liao, HungKai PROPOSAL

89
15
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

90
16
Huang, HsiaoRou / Liao, HungKai PROPOSAL

91
17
Donghwan Moon
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Rethinking Open Spaces


in the Urban Scale Edge Parking Lots

Large scale intervention


of open spaces in the city

The focus of this mapping exercise is to


investigate and achieve a large scale
intervention of open spaces including
parks, vacant lots, parking lots, and
abandoned spaces in the city. A series of
rigorous research and analysis exercises
reveals that this can only happen through
the accretion of smaller fragmented
parcels and a continuous street network.
As the research develops through the
investigation of legally defined open
spaces and their actual amount and value,
the establishment of a fine grain open
space system finally takes shape. This
new open space network may generate
new perspectives in designing an urban
environment with respect to every little
Urban Void Vacant Abandoned Areas
detail of the city, while maintaining a
great vision in urban scale.

Parks / Recreational Open Space All


94
Donghwan Moon ANALYSIS

“ Large Scale Intervention of Open Space can happen through


the Accretion of Small Fragmented Parcels..”

Parks / Recreational
Vacant Lots / Abandoned Areas
Parking Lots
Private Owned Public Space

Property value of open spaces

95
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Open Space Investigation


In Southern Bronx, there are numerous open spaces that
have high potential to be developed. My focus here is to
incorporate such areas into continuous FINE GRAIN open
space network.

Vacant Lots / Abandoned Areas

There are a great amount of vacant and abandoned spaces


in Southern Bronx. These areas are basis of the network.

Semi-Private Open Spaces

Private gardens and open properties will be incorporated


into the network.

Parking Lot

Existing Parking lots and structure can be reconfigured


with parks and other public facilities and open spaces.

Parks / Recreational Areas

Parks and green spaces are essential elements that make


the open space network work. Creating continuous bike
roots and pedestrain connections is critical.

Buildings around the Fine Grain Open Spaces

96
Donghwan Moon ANALYSIS

Development Strategy

Public Network

Residential Expansion

Commercial Node

New Green Network

Buildings to be preserved

97
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

REconfiguring
The Urban Network
New Proposal of
South Bronx Waterfront

After researching and analyzing the various


elements of the city specifically focused
on current processes that have shaped the
urban terrain, here I am proposing a series
of design actions in order to construct
a urban strategy for the specified given
site. The site is Southern Bronx where the
Grand Concourse and Deegan express highway
run as main infrastructure along the East
Harlem river. Yankee Stadium is considered
as the only cultural icon of the region,
with a new shopping center proposed next
to it. It is my desire to reconfigure the
existing infrastructure and terrain with
an operation of cut and fill, in order to
achieve an open space network throughout
the region linking cultural facilities,
parks and the waterfront. The proposed
urban space may act as Bronx’s iconic
complex with a celebration of leisure,
sports, shopping and culture. This will
also generate various potential urban
developments such as mix-use residential. The Current Site Condition

98
Donghwan Moon PROPOSAL

A. Entertainment / Shopping / Parking


B. New MTA Railroad Station
c. Department Store
D. Mix use Residential
E. Ferry Station
F. Art Gallery
G. Health care
H.Community center

Proposed Site Plan

Site Model 1:1000

99
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

100
Donghwan Moon Proposal

101
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

sec A
Cut and Fill Operations

Reconfiguration of

Edge Surface and Infrastructure

sec B

sec C

sec A

sec B

sec C

102
Donghwan Moon Proposal

Line Of Culture

Grand Concourse

Cultural Center New Residential


Development

Deegan Express
New Office complex
with semi private park

Ferry Sta.

Department Store
New Waterfront

MTA Sta.

sec C
New Entertainment and
Cultural Complex

sec B

Harlem River

sec A

103
Ángel Rodríguez Colón
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Profile map of the New York subway, from Brooklyn Bridge to the Bronx

CUT AND FILL OPERATIONS

The first stage of the investigation


explored the influence of the different
processes of formation and construction
in the transformation of the geomorphol-
ogy of the site, particularly the process
of filling and excavation associated to
the development of the infrastructures.
From mid 19th century, the Bronx penin-
sula was subject of dramatic industrial
and infrastructural development.

Through sections and axonometric draw-


ings, the mapping exercise speculated on
the relationship between large construc-
tion events (such as the development of
the boat industry, and the construction
of thoroughfares and railroads) and the
transformation of the geography of the
neighborhood. Between 1850 and 1950, the
area witnessed significant geo-morpholog-
ical alterations, including the chan-
nelization of the Harlem River and the
emergence of the islands of Randall’s and
Wards Islands, product of construction
and dredging debris.

Towards its conclusion, the investigation


addressed the impact of these operations
on the ecology of the maritime border of
the Bronx, and therefore the relation-
ship between the community and this body
of water.

Construction of the Bronx’s Grand Councourse

106
Ángel Rodríguez Colón ANALYSIS

107
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Excavation/ Landfill Timeline Sections:

Soil Studies:

Through sections and axonometric drawings, the mapping exercise speculated on the
relationship between large construction events (such as the development of the boat
industry, and the construction of thoroughfares and railroads) and the transformation of the
geography of the neighborhood.

108
Ángel Rodríguez Colón ANALYSIS

The Bronx’s First Nature:

These cut and fill operations had a dramatic im-


pact on the ecology of the maritime border of the
Bronx and therefore the relationship between the
community and this body of water. Stream chan-
nelization, ditching in wetlands, disconnection
from adjacent ecosystems, and shoreline modifi-
cations led to problems such as habitat degrada-
tion, changes in flow regimes, and siltation.

Artificial Edge:

Many aquatic resources in need of restoration


have problems that originated with harmful altera-
tion of channel form or other physical characteris-
tics. In such cases, restoring the original morphol-
ogy and other physical attributes is essential to
the success of other aspects of the project such
as improving water quality and bringing back
native biota.

The Bronx’s First Nature:


Many aquatic resources in need of restoration
have problems that originated with harmful altera-
tion of channel form or other physical characteris-
tics. In such cases, restoring the original morphol-
ogy and other physical attributes is essential to
the success of other aspects of the project such
as improving water quality and bringing back
native biota.

109
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Reconfiguration of infrastructures:

FINAL PROJECT
Bioremediation and watershed restoration:

During the second part of the semester,


the project focused on the South Bronx,
particularly around the edge of Harlem
River and the Hudson Bay. The area faces
many challenges in light of its indus-
trial and infrastructural predominance.
Because of its history of concentrated
use for manufacturing and railroads, the
waterfront is presumed to be one continu-
ous Brownfield.
A particular challenge for this project
was the calibration of a large number of
operations within a cohesive time frame-
work. Different time spans and techniques
associated with the bioremediation pro-
cess would vary depending on the concen-
tration and nature of the pollutants in
each of the sites. Therefore, the proj- Functional diversification:
ect aimed to stress out urban strategies
that could operate simultaneously with
the bioremediation process.
In this sense, a matrix of block explora-
tions was used to articulate the urban
morphology of the proposal. Different
FAR’s and degrees of building frontage
were used to develop different levels of
urban porosity, enabling the calibra-
tion a variety of street conditions and
networks of open space or temporally
remediation sites. In addition, a system
of hard and soft surfaces was proposed,
allowing different degrees of perme-
ability that could operate according to
phytoremediation (the use of plants to
clean polluted soil) and water management
criteria.
A system of ponds with artificial wet-
lands was proposed to improve water qual-
ity of the Harlem River. In addition, a
Three major strategies were identified for this area, all of which were based on the premise that
network of bridges over the area would
public investment to improve environmental quality in this area would promote additional invest-
connect the Bronx with the recreational ment to address some of the additional challenges. Therefore, the first strategy comprised the
facilities of Randall’s Island bioremediation of existing brownfields and shoreline restoration. The reconfiguration of trans-
portation infrastructures and incorporation of a broader diversity of uses were also identified as
critical strategies for the area.

110
6
Ángel Rodríguez Colón PROPOSAL

Phasing Diagrams:
Brownfield Remediation
and Watershed restoration:

Because of its history of concentrated use for manufac-


turing and railroads, the waterfront is presumed to be one
continuous Brownfield.

Cut and Fill:


Reconfiguration of transport infrastructures to promote
pedestrian accessibility to the area.

Water Collection:

Strategies for storm water collection and management.

Density:

Incorporation of a broader diversity of uses in the area


with a important residential component.

Circulation:
Extension of the Grand Concourse to the site.

Open Space:
Networks of open space or temporally remediation sites.

A particular challenge for this project was the calibration of a large number of operations
within a cohesive time framework.

111
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Phytoremediation

Different time spans and techniques associated with the bioremediation process would vary
depending on the concentration and nature of the pollutants in each of the sites. Therefore, the
project aimed to stress out urban strategies that could operate simultaneously with the bioreme-
diation process.

Cap and Fill

Artificial Wetlands

Bioremediation

A system of hard and soft surfaces was proposed, allowing


Different time spans and techniques associated with the different degrees of permeability that could operate according
bioremediation process would vary depending on the concen- to phytoremediation (the use of plants to clean polluted soil)
tration and nature of the pollutants in each of the sites. and water management criteria.

112
Ángel
ÁngelRodríguez
RodríguezColón
Colón PROPOSAL
PROPOSAL

Different
DifferentFAR’s
FAR’sand
anddegrees
degreesofofbuilding
buildingfrontage
frontagewere
wereused
usedtoto
calibrate
calibratea avariety
varietyofofstreet
streetconditions
conditionsandandnetworks
networksofofopen
open
space
spaceorortemporally
temporallyremediation
remediationsites.
sites.

1139
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Grand Concourse Extension; Re-configuration of trans- A system of ponds with artificial wetlands was proposed to improve water quality of the Harlem
portation infrastructures. River.

DEVELOPMENT PHASES

In addition, a network of bridges over the area would connect the Bronx with the recreational facili-
First Phase: Randalls Island
ties of Randall’s Island

Section 1

Second Phase: Grand Concourse

Third Phase: Lincoln Ave

Section 2

114
Ángel Rodríguez Colón PROPOSAL

Network of bridges and paths, connecting the Bronx


with the recreational facilities of Randall’s Island

1. Pools
2. Berms
3. Ponds
4. Wetlands
5. Plataforms
6. Bridges
7. Berms
8. MTA Station
9. Highway
10. Marina

115
section 3: RAFI SEGAL
Design Critic in Urban Planning and Design
Christopher A. Roach
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

ELEMENTS OF OWNERSHIP
The Public Sphere
Survey O1 Survey O1

Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Access Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Occupy Occupy

Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1
Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1

Re Re

This project sets out to explore the


question of ownership in relation to
the city by questioning the dichotomy
of public versus private that is often
utilized to characterize the divisions of
ownership in an urban territory. I argue
that this binary relationship is too
simple to describe the complex conditions
of ownership in the modern city, where
questions of legitimacy and overlapping
claims create a field of ever shifting Access O1 Access O1

boundaries. The outlines of these Ac 138th St. B-D : Sidewalks + Open Space Ac Public Institutions Pedshed

boundaries, these claims to ownership,


take various forms, which I break down
Survey O1 Survey O1

Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Access Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Ac A O* O Oc
into the following taxonomy: survey,
so rs so rs
Access + O2 Register + O3 Register + O2 Access + O2 Register + O3 Register + O2
Occupy Access + Occupy Occupy Access + Occupy
Occupy Occupy

Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1
Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1

Re Re

registration, access, and occupation.

Surveying a territory, either through


seeing or moving through it, is arguably
the oldest and most basic form of
ownership, based on the concept that
to see is to know, and to know is to
own. Whether this is the feudal lord
or William Randolph Hearst, claiming for
themselves all that they can see from a
certain vantage point, Jane Jacobs’ “eyes
on the street”, or CCTV surveillance, Access O1 Access O1

seeing is a highly direct form of Ac 1/4 Mile Walk from Subway Ac Open Space Pedshed
exercising power over space. Survey O1 Survey O1

Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Access Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Ac A O* O Oc
Registering a description of a specific
so rs so rs
Access + O2 Register + O3 Register + O2 Access + O2 Register + O3 Register + O2
Occupy Access + Occupy Occupy Access + Occupy
Occupy Occupy

Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1
Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1

Re Re

piece of land, whether through mapping


or legal description, is seen in western
society as the most legitimate way to
claim and retain ownership over time.
This domain of ownership can be described
through a literary form, including
stories and descriptions of space, or
can be highly codified legal language of
meets and bounds or deed restrictions.
It can also be described graphically, as
with legal lot maps, zoning maps, and the
Access O1 Access O1

Ac Subway Pedshed Ac Subway Pedshed


120
Christopher A. Roach ANALYSIS

Survey O1

Su Survey + O2 Survey + O3 Occupy + O2


Survey O1

Su
Access Occupy + Survey
Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Occupy

Ao R Ro ao
Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
Access
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2

Sa Soa Os
Register O1

Re

Access O1 Access + O3 Ownership O4 Occupy + O3 Occupy O1


Survey + Register +
Register Survey

Ac Aso O* Ors Oc
Access +
Occupy
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
O2

Occupy

Ao Rao Ro Register O1

Re

Access O1

Ac Public Institutions + Open Space Composite Pedshed

Survey O1

Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Occupy

Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1

Re

Access O1

Ac Subway + Public Institutions Composite Pedshed

Survey O1

Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Occupy

Ao R Ro Register
ao
O 1

Re

Access O1

Access

Ac
O1

Subway + Open Space Composite Pedshed Ac Subways + Public Institutions + Open Space Composite Pedshed
121
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

whole range of political and regulatory mapping implies claims to equity in the context of social
utilized in modern society. This way of claiming justice and the notion of the common good, and
ownership is paradoxically the most abstract, but at its most atomic level, describes the singular
within our sociopolitical context is deemed the experience of the individual.
most legitimate and precise.
Physical occupation of a space, whether by
Controlling access to a territory is another objects or people, is a fourth and final way
way of exerting control over space, a form of of exerting claims to ownership. The seeming
spatial practice that usually takes place at permanence and immovability of buildings and
real or perceived boundaries. However, access infrastructure are “facts on the ground” in
can also take on an active sense, whereby a an urban territory, and their legitimacy is
subject or subjects moving through a space can therefore rarely contested. But the presence of
physically describe a domain of ownership, which human bodies is an equally powerful assertion
is reinforced through repetition or volume. of ownership, and squatters, sit-ins, and
Consider the way that an infantry moves through occupations of the public square exhibit the
a battlefield, simultaneously erasing present ability of citizens to project power over an
boundaries and creating their own. In a civilian urban territory.
context, this could take the form of a protest
march, or its simulacrum, the parade. Access also
Mt. Hope Place : Street Corridor
Survey O1 Survey O1

Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
Access Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Occupy Occupy

Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1
Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1

Re Re

Mt. Hope Place : Sidewalks + Lot Lines

Register O1 Register + O2
Occupy

Re Tremont B-D Property Lines


Su
Survey O1
Ro Tremont B-D Pedestrian Access Area
Su
Survey O1

Survey + O2 Survey + O3 Occupy + O2 Survey + O2 Survey + O3 Occupy + O2


Access Occupy + Survey Access Occupy + Survey
Access Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Occupy Occupy

Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1
Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1

Re Re

Mt. Hope Place : Built Form Tracing

Mt. Hope Place : Occupy + Register

Register O1 Register + O2
Occupy

Re Property Lines x Public Institutions + Open Space


Su
Survey O1
Ro Pedestrian Access x Ownership
Su
Survey O1

Survey + O2 Survey + O3 Occupy + O2 Survey + O2 Survey + O3 Occupy + O2


Access Occupy + Survey Access Occupy + Survey
Access Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
Occupy Occupy

Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1
Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1

Re Re

Mt. Hope Place : Ownership Intersections

Register O1 Register + O2 Register + O2


Occupy Occupy

Re Modified Property Lines Ro Pedestrian + Ownership Intersections Ro Tracing Register + Occupy : Mt. Hope Place
122
Survey O1
Christopher A. Roach ANALYSIS

Su
O1
Su Survey +
Access
O2 Survey +
Occupy +
O3 Occupy +
Survey
O2
terrain. These overlapping domains may operate
Access

O2
O3
O2 Sa S Os oa to reinforce one another, or they may describe a
space of conflict, where the nature of ownership
Access O1 Access + O3 Ownership O4 Occupy + O3 Occupy O1
Survey + Register +
O1 O1 Register Survey

Ac O3 O4

O3
O3
Oc Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2
is contested or in flux. This overlapping of
O2 O2 domains continues on until, at the intersection
Occupy

O1 Ao R Ro ao
of all four circles, a fourth degree order of
Re
Register O1

Re ownership is described which begins to more


closely model the highly complex and constantly
The Venn diagram is a useful lens through fluctuating envelope of the urban public realm.
which these four dimensions of ownership can
be understood, illustrating through increasing The Venn diagram can be translated into a table
degrees of overlap, the space of their of elements, where each square represents a
intersection describes a highly complex territory model of a space of ownership prescribed by one
of ownership. If each of these single spheres or more spheres of influence. Each element
describes a single order of ownership, wherein corresponds to a zone in the Venn diagram, and is
a certain degree of public or private ownership given a degree (ox ) depending on the order of
of space is asserted, then the space where that domain. These elements then can provide a
two overlap represents a second order domain descriptive taxonomy of ownership spaces that can
of ownership that represents a more complex be applied to the mapping exercise.
Survey O1
Survey O1
Su

Su
Survey + O2 Survey + O3 Occupy + O2
Access Occupy + Survey
Access

Sa S Os
Access O1 Access +
Survey +
O3 Ownership
oa
O4 Occupy +
Register +
O3 Occupy O1
Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc so rs
Survey + O2 Survey + O3 Occupy + O2
Access + O2 Register + O3 Register + O2
Occupy Access + Occupy
Occupy

Ao R Ro
Access Occupy + Survey
Access

Sa S Os
ao
Register O1

Re
oa
Access O1 Access + O3 Ownership O4 Occupy + O3 Occupy O1
Survey + Register +
Register Survey

Ac A O* O Oc Access +
Occupy
so
O2 Register +
Access +
O 3 Register +
Occupy
rs
O2

Occupy

Ao R Ro Register
ao
O1

Re

Register + O3
Access +
Occupy

R ao Third-Order Ownership : Tremont B-D Subway Pedshed


123
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

RECOMBINANT URBANISM Size : Scale (domain+range) Pedestrian Scaling


Rescaling the Infrastructural
System of Open Spaces Site C Pedsheds
+ Pedestrian Domains
The project site is located at a key node
of the Bronx at northern terminus of the
Grand Concourse, where an accumulation
of utilitarian infrastructures includ-
ing the Concourse itself, the local road
network, the southern regional parkway
system, the Jerome Park Reservoir, and
the Mosholu Rail Yards are interspersed
with fragmentary enclaves such as the
campus of Lehman College and Paul Ru- City College System Areas of Low Intensity
doph’s Tracey Towers. These discrete and
large-scale fragments create a kind of
urban void, exacerbating the physical and
economic fragmentation and isolation of
the resident population, which is oth-
erwise well-served by a medium-grained
network of walkable city blocks defined
by low-to-midrise mixed use residential
buildings.

In order to rescale these fragments and


stitch them into the fabric of the city, Subway System Rail Yards Pedshed Terrain + Site Composite
the area of the void and its surround-
ing grain are mapped to a cartography of
walkability, indicating critical nodes
for focused intervention.

Aqueduct System Nodes of Potentiality

124
Christopher A. Roach PROPOSAL

Site Definition + Analysis Composite Site Analysis Diagram


Site Bounadry

Street Axial Vectors

Vector Composite

Vector Composite + Built Form

125
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

The block morphology of the existing fabric is Hybrid genotypes deployed at critical nodes
then indexed and deployed across the entire ter- within the new grid are transformed according to
rain of the void, where it is optimized into a the specific localized geometrical and functional
new pattern through a rational yet idiosyncratic conditions. The resulting phenotypes express
process of negation and composition. novel programmatic combinations and building
envelopes that are the expression of an urban-
In order to populate this fabric with programs op- ism optimized for generating pedestrian activ-
timized for pedestrian activity, existing building ity, though not necessarily pedestrian-scaled or
typologies are indexed according to each type’s “pedestrian-friendly” by standard conventions.
potential to generate pedestrian trips. These ty-
pologies are then hybridized to create the geno-
types of new mixed programs optimizing the volume
and diversity of pedestrian trips generated.

Grid Morphologies Morphological Expansions

m01 m02 m04 m02


Axial Modulation
m07
m12 negotiation of axes
m08 generated by Grand
Concourse
m06
irregular block size

m09 gradient from midrise resi-


M01
m01 dential mixed-use to lowrise
m10 commercial + industrial
m05

m02
m11

m04
m03

STREET GRID MORPHOLOGIES M01 M04


m05 m06 m07 m10

m04
Northern Extension

priveleges N-S mobility

occupies level terrian

E-W facing residential blocks

m02+ m04+ m06+ m10


compositional dispersal
within campus

m06
Topographical
Mediation

limited accessiblity

increased privacy

picturesque views

low-density residential

m10
Lateral Expansion

egalitarian accessibility +
pedestrial scale

equal division of land

priveleges E-W mobility

medium density low-to-mid-


rise residential + mixed

126
Christopher A. Roach PROPOSAL

Programmatic Typology Hybrid Genotypes


t = trips
(pedestrian trips / day)
t ≥ 10 t ≥ 25 t ≥ 50 t ≥ 75 t ≥ 100 t ≥ 250 t ≥ 500 t ≥ 750 t ≥ 1000 t ≥ 2500 t ≥ 5000
t = trips
(pedestrian trips / day)
t ≥ 10 t ≥ 25 t ≥ 50 t ≥ 75 t ≥ 100 t ≥ 250 t ≥ 500 t ≥ 750 t ≥ 1000 t ≥ 2500 t ≥ 5000

d2.1
Rs1 tdu 10
Rs2 tdu 25
Rsb tdu 259
Rsm tdu 538
Rsc tdu 838
Rss tdu 1487
Rst tdu 3368

Residential
Rs1 Rs2 Rsb Rsm Rsc Rss Rst
t = 3368
tdu 10 tdu 25 tdu 259 tdu 538 tdu 838 tdu 1487 tdu 3368
single family detached two family rowhouse midrise senior housing midrise apartment midrise perimeter block highrise slab multifamily highrise tower multifamily

Ac tf 34
Ac tf 50
Ac tf 340
Ac tf 950
2 2 2 2

Academic
single story primary school collegiate courtyard multistory high school multistory middle school

Pu tf 164
Pu tf 252
Pu tf 547
Pu tf 917
2 2 2 2
Residential

Cultural
Public /
basilica plan church performance hall religious community center community center

Pu tf 392
Pu tf 1456
Pu tf 4784
2 2 2

botannical conservatory hospital recreation sports center

Cr tf 250
Cr tf 508
Cr tf 2045
2 2 2

Commercial/
Retail
detached retail strip retail supermarket

Cr tf 99
Cr tf 113
Cr tf 2168
2 2 2

franchise retail big box retail shopping center

Si tf 22
Si tf 31
Si tf 58
Si tf 607
2 2 2 2

Industrial
Service /
Light
clear span warehouse utility equipment / office general light industrial gas service station

Mo tf 410
Mo tf 2539
Mo tr 4712
Mo tr 6780
2 2

Mobility
parking garage parking garage podium elevated metro station subway station

Of tf 479
Of tf 2224
Of tf 7046
2 2 2

Public Open Office


lowrise office midrise office highrise office

Po tu 11
Po tf 29
Po tf 55
Po tf 163
Po tf 1067
2 2 2 2

Space
community garden elevated plaza linear park plaza sports park

St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
2 2 2 2

single family detached two family rowhouse midrise senior housing midrise apartment midrise perimeter block highrise slab multifamily highrise tower multifamily

Streets*
alley residential street commercial street boulevard

tdu = rate x # of dwelling units * streets not rated: shown for illustration only
tf = rate x GFA (sq. ft.) / 1000
2

tr = daily ridership
tu = rate x # of units (plots)

Ac tf 34
Ac tf 50
Ac tf 340
Ac tf 950
2 2 2 2
Academic

single story primary school collegiate courtyard multistory high school multistory middle school

Pu tf 164
Pu tf 252
Pu tf 547
Pu tf 917
2 2 2 2
Cultural
Public /

basilica plan church performance hall religious community center community center

Pu tf 392
Pu tf 1456
Pu tf 4784
2 2 2

Rs +Ac+Pu+Cr+Si
s

t = trips
(pedestrian trips / day)
t ≥ 10 t ≥ 25 t ≥ 50 t ≥ 75 t ≥ 100 t ≥ 250 t ≥ 500 t ≥ 750 t ≥ 1000 t ≥ 2500 t ≥ 5000

o1.2
Rs1 tdu 10
Rs2 tdu 25
Rsb tdu 259
Rsm tdu 538
Rsc tdu 838
Rss tdu 1487
Rst tdu 3368

Residential
t = 8078
single family detached two family rowhouse midrise senior housing midrise apartment midrise perimeter block highrise slab multifamily highrise tower multifamily

Ac tf 34
Ac tf 50
Ac tf 340
Ac tf 950
2 2 2 2

Academic
botannical conservatory hospital recreation sports center
single story primary school collegiate courtyard multistory high school multistory middle school

Pu tf 164
Pu tf 252
Pu tf 547
Pu tf 917
2 2 2 2

Cultural
Public /
basilica plan church performance hall religious community center community center

Pu tf 392
Pu tf 1456
Pu tf 4784
2 2 2

Cr tf 250
Cr tf 508
Cr tf 2045
2 2 2
Commercial/

botannical conservatory hospital recreation sports center

Cr tf 250
Cr tf 508
Cr tf 2045
2 2 2

Commercial/
Retail
detached retail strip retail supermarket

Cr tf 99
Cr tf 113
Cr tf 2168
2 2 2

franchise retail big box retail shopping center

Si tf 22
Si tf 31
Si tf 58
Si tf 607
2 2 2 2

Industrial
Service /
Light
clear span warehouse utility equipment / office general light industrial gas service station

Mo tf 410
Mo tf 2539
Mo tr 4712
Mo tr 6780
2 2

Mobility
parking garage parking garage podium elevated metro station subway station

Of tf 479
Of tf 2224
Of tf 7046
2 2 2

Public Open Office


lowrise office midrise office highrise office

Po tu 11
Po tf 29
Po tf 55
Po tf 163
Po tf 1067
2 2 2 2
Retail

Space
community garden elevated plaza linear park plaza sports park

St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
2 2 2 2

Streets*
alley residential street commercial street boulevard

tdu = rate x # of dwelling units * streets not rated: shown for illustration only
tf = rate x GFA (sq. ft.) / 1000
2

tr = daily ridership
tu = rate x # of units (plots)

detached retail strip retail supermarket

Cr tf 99
Cr tf 113
Cr tf 2168
2 2 2

franchise retail big box retail shopping center

Si tf 22
Si tf 31
Si tf 58
Si tf 607
2 2 2 2
Industrial
Service /
Light

clear span warehouse utility equipment / office general light industrial gas service station

Mo tf 410
Mo tf 2539
Mo tr 4712
Mo tr 6780
Rs +Ac+Pu+Cr+Si
s
2 2
Mobility

t = trips
(pedestrian trips / day)
t ≥ 10 t ≥ 25 t ≥ 50 t ≥ 75 t ≥ 100 t ≥ 250 t ≥ 500 t ≥ 750 t ≥ 1000 t ≥ 2500 t ≥ 5000

o1.6
Rs1 tdu 10
Rs2 tdu 25
Rsb tdu 259
Rsm tdu 538
Rsc tdu 838
Rss tdu 1487
Rst tdu 3368
Residential

t = 8798
single family detached two family rowhouse midrise senior housing midrise apartment midrise perimeter block highrise slab multifamily highrise tower multifamily

Ac tf 34
Ac tf 50
Ac tf 340
Ac tf 950
2 2 2 2
Academic

single story primary school collegiate courtyard multistory high school multistory middle school

Pu tf 164
Pu tf 252
Pu tf 547
Pu tf 917
2 2 2 2
Cultural
Public /

basilica plan church performance hall religious community center community center

Pu tf 392
Pu tf 1456
Pu tf 4784
2 2 2

botannical conservatory hospital recreation sports center

Cr tf 250
Cr tf 508
Cr tf 2045
2 2 2
Commercial/

parking garage parking garage podium elevated metro station subway station
Retail

detached retail strip retail supermarket

Cr tf 99
Cr tf 113
Cr tf 2168
2 2 2

Of tf 479
Of tf 2224
Of tf 7046
franchise retail big box retail shopping center

Si tf 22
Si tf 31
Si tf 58
Si tf 607
2 2 2 2

2 2 2
Industrial
Service /
Light

clear span warehouse utility equipment / office general light industrial gas service station

Mo tf 410
Mo tf 2539
Mo tr 4712
Mo tr 6780
2 2
Mobility

parking garage parking garage podium elevated metro station subway station

Of tf 479
Of tf 2224
Of tf 7046
2 2 2
Public Open Office

lowrise office midrise office highrise office

Po tu 11
Po tf 29
Po tf 55
Po tf 163
Po tf 1067
2 2 2 2
Space

community garden elevated plaza linear park plaza sports park

St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
2 2 2 2
Streets*

alley residential street commercial street boulevard

tdu = rate x # of dwelling units * streets not rated: shown for illustration only
tf = rate x GFA (sq. ft.) / 1000
2

tr = daily ridership
tu = rate x # of units (plots)
Public Open Office

lowrise office midrise office highrise office

Po tu 11
Po tf 29
Po tf 55
Po tf 163
Po tf 1067
2 2 2 2
Space

community garden elevated plaza linear park plaza sports park

St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
2 2 2 2
Streets*

alley residential street commercial street boulevard Rs +Ac+Of+Mo+Po


s

tdu = rate x # of dwelling units * streets not rated: shown for illustration only
tf = rate x GFA (sq. ft.) / 1000
2
t = trips
(pedestrian trips / day)
t ≥ 10 t ≥ 25 t ≥ 50 t ≥ 75 t ≥ 100 t ≥ 250 t ≥ 500 t ≥ 750 t ≥ 1000 t ≥ 2500 t ≥ 5000

o1.1
tr = daily ridership
Rs1 tdu 10
Rs2 tdu 25
Rsb tdu 259
Rsm tdu 538
Rsc tdu 838
Rss tdu 1487
Rst tdu 3368
Residential

t = 9898
tu = rate x # of units (plots)
single family detached two family rowhouse midrise senior housing midrise apartment midrise perimeter block highrise slab multifamily highrise tower multifamily

Ac tf 34
Ac tf 50
Ac tf 340
Ac tf 950
2 2 2 2
Academic

single story primary school collegiate courtyard multistory high school multistory middle school

Pu tf 164
Pu tf 252
Pu tf 547
Pu tf 917
2 2 2 2
Cultural
Public /

basilica plan church performance hall religious community center community center

Pu tf 392
Pu tf 1456
Pu tf 4784
2 2 2

Typological Hybridization
botannical conservatory hospital recreation sports center

Cr tf 250
Cr tf 508
Cr tf 2045
2 2 2
Commercial/
Retail

detached retail strip retail supermarket

Cr tf 99
Cr tf 113
Cr tf 2168
2 2 2

franchise retail big box retail shopping center

Si tf 22
Si tf 31
Si tf 58
Si tf 607
2 2 2 2
Industrial
Service /
Light

clear span warehouse utility equipment / office general light industrial gas service station

Mo tf 410
Mo tf 2539
Mo tr 4712
Mo tr 6780
2 2
Mobility

parking garage parking garage podium elevated metro station subway station

Of tf 479
Of tf 2224
Of tf 7046
2 2 2
Public Open Office

lowrise office midrise office highrise office

Po tu 11
Po tf 29
Po tf 55
Po tf 163
Po tf 1067
2 2 2 2

t ≥ 250 t ≥ 500 t ≥ 750 t ≥ 1000 t ≥ 2500 t ≥ 5000 optimization diagonals diagonals knight - one pass thru
Space

community garden elevated plaza linear park plaza sports park

St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
St tf 000
2 2 2 2
Streets*

alley residential street commercial street boulevard

t = 4337
Rs1 tdu 10
Pu Pu Mo tf 2539
Of tf 479
St tf 000
tdu = rate x # of dwelling units * streets not rated: shown for illustration only

t = 9898 t = 2986 t = 12882 tf 917 tf 392


Rsm Rsc Rss Rst Cr Mo Pu Of Pu Ac Rss Cr Si Of Mo Cr Pu Pu
2 2 2 tf = rate x GFA (sq. ft.) / 1000

tdu 259 tdu 538 tdu 838 tdu 1487 tdu 3368 tf 2045 tr 4712 tf 2224 tf 950 tdu 1487 tf 99 tf 58 tf 7046 tr 4712 tf 508
2 2
2

tf 917 tf 392 tf 392 tf 164


tr = daily ridership
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 tu = rate x # of units (plots)

housing midrise apartment midrise perimeter block highrise slab multifamily highrise tower multifamily supermarket elevated metro station community center midrise office botannical conservatory multistory middle school single family detached community center botannical conservatory parking garage podium lowrise office residential street
highrise slab multifamily franchise retail general light industrial highrise office elevated metro station strip retail botannical conservatory basilica plan church

tf 340
Ac tf 950
2 2

t = 8078 t = 4388 t = 5414 t = 4945


Ac tf 50
Mo tf 410
Rsc tdu 838
Mo tr 6780
Pu tf 547
Pu tf 1456
Cr tf 2045
Ac tf 340
Of tf 2224
Mo tf 2539
Si tf 607
Ac tf 34
Rs1 tdu 10
Rs2 tdu 25
Si tf 45
Mo tr 4712
Po tf 163
St tf 000
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

h school multistory middle school

tf 252
Pu tf 547
Pu tf 917
2 2 2

collegiate courtyard parking garage midrise perimeter block subway station religious community center hospital supermarket multistory high school midrise office parking garage podium gas service station single story primary school single family detached two family rowhouse clear span warehouse elevated metro station plaza boulevard

all religious community center community center

t = 9458 t = 3533 t = 538


tf 392
Pu tf 1456
Pu tf 4784
Po tu 9
Ac tf 50
Pu tf 164
Mo tf 410
Cr tf 2045
Mo tr 6780
Pu tf 547
Ac tf 950
Rss tdu 1487
Pu tf 392
Cr tf 99
Si tf 58 t = 3220 Of tf 479
Mo tf 410
Cr tf 2168
Po tf 163
St tf 000
Rsm tdu 538
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

servatory hospital recreation sports center community garden collegiate courtyard basilica plan church parking garage supermarket subway station religious community center multistory middle school highrise slab multifamily botannical conservatory franchise retail general light industrial lowrise office parking garage shopping center plaza boulevard midrise apartment

tf 250
Cr tf 508
Cr tf 2045
2 2 2

t = 3962
t = 6070
Si Cr Rsb Pu Pu t = 4657
Pu Rst Cr Cr Po Pu Cr Si St Rsc tdu 838
Ac tf 340
Cr tf 2168
Si tf 607
Po tu 9
2 2 2

tf 312
tf 99
2
tdu 239 tf 917
2
tf 4784
2
tf 917
2
tdu 3368 tf 250 2
tf 113
2
tu 9 t = 7436 tf 4784
2
tf 2045
2
tf 607
2
tf 000
2

strip retail supermarket

Cr tf 2168
2

midrise perimeter block multistory high school shopping center gas service station community garden
utility equipment / office franchise retail midrise senior housing community center recreation sports center community center highrise tower multifamily detached retail big box retail community garden recreation sports center supermarket gas service station commercial street

shopping center
t = 1670
Si t = 12832
Of Ac Pu Po Pu t = 1087
Pu Ac Rs Si Pu Ac Rs Rs s tdu 1487
Pu tf 164
Po tf 19 2

tf 607 tf 7046 tf 50 tf 4784 tf 35 tf 340 tdu 538 tf 45 tf 4784 tf 950 tdu 538
2
2 2 2 2 2
tf 917
2
tf 164
2 2
m 2

t = 6272
2 2
m

tf 410
2
gas service station

Mo tf 2539
2

Mo tr 4712
Mo tr 6780
highrise office collegiate courtyard recreation sports center linear park community center basilica plan church multistory high school midrise apartment clear span warehouse recreation sports center multistory middle school midrise apartment highrise slab multifamily basilica plan church elevated plaza

Of+Cr+Pu+Mo
t = 7272
t = 8798
Rss Ac Of Po Mo t = 5088
Ac Rs2 Cr Mo Of Pu Pu Rsb Rst tdu 3368
Ac tf 950
Pu tf 252
Mo tf 2539
Po tf 163
St tf 000
2 2 2 2 2

tdu 1487 tf 340


2
tf 2224
2
tf 35
2
tr 4712 tf 50
2
tdu 25 tf 250 2
tf 2539
2
tf 2224
2
t = 2612 tf 1456
2
tf 917
2
tdu 239

e parking garage podium elevated metro station subway station

tf 479
Of tf 2224
Of tf 7046
2 2 2

highrise slab multifamily hospital highrise tower multifamily multistory middle school performance hall parking garage podium boulevard
multistory high school midrise office linear park elevated metro station collegiate courtyard two family rowhouse detached retail parking garage podium midrise office community center midrise senior housing

midrise office highrise office


t = 3561
tf 163
Po tf 1067 t = 3241
Po tf 35
Mo tf 410
Rss tdu 1487
Pu tf 392
Pu tf 917 t = 10267
Mo tr 6780
Cr tf 2168
Pu tf 252
Po tf 1067
Pu tf 1456
Po tf 35
St tf 000
Rs1 tdu 10
St tf 000
Mo tf 410
Of tf 2224
Pu tf 917
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

t = 1489

sports park linear park parking garage highrise slab multifamily botannical conservatory community center subway station shopping center performance hall sports park hospital linear park residential street single family detached residential street parking garage midrise office community center

t = 7633
Po tf 35
Mo tf 410
Rss tdu 1487
Pu tf 4784
Pu tf 917 t = 1983 Pu tf 1456
Cr tf 508
Po tf 19
St tf 000 t = 1708 Pu tf 1456
Pu tf 252
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

linear park parking garage highrise slab multifamily recreation sports center community center hospital strip retail elevated plaza alley hospital performance hall

127
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse
Grid Composition

m02 m04 m06 m10

Hybrid Placement + Transformation Hybrid Phenotypes


k1.8 d2.1 d2.4

k1.8* d2.1* d2.4*


t = 9288 t = 3368 t = 4657

Hybrids + Nodes k1.7 k1.4 d1.6


t = 9288 t = 3368 t = 4657
d1.1
d2.4 o1.2
Rs +Pu+Pu+Cr+Po
s
Rs +Ac+Pu+Cr+Si
s
Rs +Pu+Cr+Cr+Po
t

o1.6
d2.1

?
o1.1

k1.8
o1.5
?

Rs +Pu+Pu+Cr+Po
s
Rs +Ac+Pu+Cr+Si
s
Rs +Pu+Cr+Cr+Po
t

Hybrids + New Grids

k1.7* k1.4* d1.6*


k1.7 t = 3561
k1.4 t = 3962
d1.6 t = 2612

t = 3561 t = 3962 t = 2612

Rs +St+Mo+Of+Pu
1
Rs +Ac+Cr+Si+Po
c
Rs +Pu+Pu
b

? ? ?

Rs +St+Mo+Of+Pu
1
Rs +Ac+Cr+Si+Po
c
Rs +Pu+Pu
b

Hybrids + New Fabric

o1.5*
o1.5

o1.1*+ o1.6*
t = 12832

t = 12832 o1.1
t = 18696
t = 9898

Of+Ac+Pu+Pu+Po
Of+Cr+Pu+Mo

o1.6 t = 8798

?
Rs +Ac+Of+Mo+Po
s

Transformation of Hybrids Of+Ac+Pu+Pu+Po Rs +Ac+Pu+Cr+Of+Mo+Po


s

o1.2* d1.1*
o1.2 t = 8078
d1.1 t = 12882

t = 8078 t = 12882
?
Rs +Ac+Pu+Cr+Si
s
Of+Mo+Cr+Pu+Pu

? ?

Hybrid Phenotypes in Site


Rs +Ac+Pu+Cr+Si
s
Of+Mo+Cr+Pu+Pu

Up = sp+mp+pp / t
where : sp = site ( p = in reference to the pedestrian)

mp = mobility
pp = program
t = time

128
Christopher A. Roach PROPOSAL
Development Phase I

o1.1*

d2.1*
o1.6*

o1.2*

129
Constantine Bouras
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

BOTANICAL GARDEN

BRONX ZOO

BRONX MUSEUM OF THE ARTS


YANKEE STADIUM

urban catalysts [analysis]

range of landmarks within the tristate [ny_nj_co]

the grand concourse revisited_


YS
a larger scale approach
to bronx through a set of nw ne
landmarks, as vehicular
mobility indexes
w
MA s

BZ

map overlapping showing arrival at


BG bronx from NorthEast, Northwest,
West and South to the 4 landmarks

132
Constantine Bouras ANALYSIS

40’’51’44.42’’n
73’’52’34.54’’w

40’’51’03.84’’n
73’’52’36.80’’w

40’’49’45.56’’n
40’’49’49.26’’n 73’’55’35.22’’w
73’’55’12.70’’w

YS MA BZ BG

traffic volume // frequency diagram

J F M A M J J A S O N D

YS

MA

BZ

BG

133
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

THE
FABRIC
WITHIN
THE
FABRIC

TRAFFIC FLOCKS
VEHICULAR TRAFFIC THAT HAS THE POTENTIAL TO FLOCK

Yankee Stadium

Museum of Arts

Bronx Zoo

Botanical Garden

vehicular behavior surrounding fabric collaborating fabric


ENTRANCES TO PLACES
PARKING LOTS

134
Constantine Bouras ANALYSIS

arteries map axial map permeability map


[inweaved configurations of [depiction of the longest lines [potential vehicular behavior pattern
major road arteriers around of access through open space] in future engagement of the grand
the areas of focus] concourse in the road network]

croton aquaduct system

open spaces of bronx

network of city colleges within nyc

network of rail yards within nyc

135
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

urban matters [final project]


reclaiming infrastructure

136
Constantine Bouras PROPOSAL

the city, densified along the grand concourse, is being diffused mildly towards the reservoir, while
at the same time the landscape is being diffused towards the city through the plaza and the hard-
scape promenade. three distinct zones, the mixed used zone, the education zone and the softscape
zone, interweave with each other to create a new condition of urbanity for this area of the bronx.

masterplan
ute
bike ro

ail
tr
g
kin
l
wa
residential

dock
s

rse
cou
con
nd
vegetation
gra

train
station

garage

commercial+offices
education

137
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

open spaces
_singular entities
_network
_mediator

green spaces
_singular entities
_network
_mediator

cityscapes
_inside looking out
_outside looking in

138
Constantine Bouras PROPOSAL

139
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

strips
laminated edge
open space

solid
spacial urbanity
mixed uses

plane
permeable space
education

140
Constantine Bouras PROPOSAL

imagine a new city here

[view towards the tracey towers and the new skyline from the south bank of the reservoir]

the green spaces constitute singular entities and at the same time belong to a broader
network_more important is the fact that they act as mediators between the reservoir
and the grand concourse, thus extending the city to the waterfront and bringing the
open space to the city

141
Alpa Nawre
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

12
11
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3

280

240

CHANGING AXES: 200

160

Re-thinking Space 120

80

40

The project looks at the site through


0

the two-dimensional plane of sections


-40

and builds a model for mapping informa-


-80
Perception
tion on these surfaces. It is a different
280
way of looking at, mapping and designing
240
the site in a series of vertical planes
so that the space between the sections
200

becomes expandable or collapsible.


160

120

Information about the site is mapped in


80

four categories: perception, program,


40

ecology and history. Perception notes


0

information about perspective and views,


-40
Program
drop in land in relation to the datum
-80
280

of the Grand Concourse and underpasses 240

at the intersections. Program notes the 200

land-uses, metro exit/ entry points and 160

bus-stops. Ecology looks at the soil 120

characteristics and history maps the cut 80

and fill based on earlier topographic 40

maps. 0

-40

For the purpose of this exercise, the -80 Ecology


sections are taken along major roads 280

intersecting the grand Concourse. Al- 240

ternatively, a typology can be set up 200

depicting various conditions. Combining 160

information on one section from the dif- 120

ferent categories gives the conditions 80

and their interactions in one plane. 40

Combining information in one category 0

through the different sections sums the -40

site. -80
History

01 + 02 +03 + 04 + 05 + 06 + 07 + 08 + 09 + 10 + 11 + 12

144
Alpa Nawre ANALYSIS

280

240

200

160

120

80

40

-40

-80

280

240

MM MM M 200

MM MM 160

120
M M
80
M M
40

-40

-80
280

240

200

160

120

80

40

-40

-80

280

240

200

160

120

80

40

-40

-80

145
200

160

120

80

Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse 40

-40

07
-80

I - 95, Cross-Bronx Expressway

200 200

160 M M 160

120 120

80 80

40 40

0 0

066
-40 -40

-80 -80

170th E. Street

240 240

200 200

160 M M 160

120 120

80 80

40 40

0 0

055
-40 -40

-80 -80

167th E. Street

200

160

120

80

40

-40

4 -80

165th E. Street

240 240

200 200

160 160

120 120

80 80

40 40

0 0

-40 -40

-80 -80

3 161st E. Street

320 320

280 280

240 240

200 200

160 160

120 120

M M
80 80

40 40

0 0

2
-40 -40

-80 -80

149th E. Street

160 120

80 80
M M
40 40

0 0

-40 -40

-80 -80

138th E. Street

Perception + Program + Ecology + History

146
Alpa Nawre ANALYSIS

280

240

200

160

120

80

40

12 -40
0

-80

E. Mosholu Parkway S

240

200
M M
160

120

80

40

11 0

-40

-80

200th E. Street

280 280

240 240

200
M 200

160 160

120 120

80 80

10 40

0
40

-40 -40

-80 -80

194th E. Street

240 240

200 200
M M
160 160

120 120

80 80

40 40

9
0 0

-40 -40

-80 -80

183rd E. Street

200 200

160 M M 160

120 120

80 80

40 40

0 0

088
-40 -40

-80 -80

Tremont Ave.

240

200

160

120

80

40

-40

07
7
-80

I - 95, Cross-Bronx Expressway

200 200

160 M M 160

120 120

80 80

40 40

0 0

06
-40 -40

-80 -80

170th E. Street

240 147
240

200 200

160 M M 160

120 120
Program Flows Material

Healing Forgotten Wounds:


the Cross-Bronx Expressway

Between 1957 and 1968, construction of


federal highways undertaken in America
left about 330,000 urban housing units
and countless communities destroyed in
its wake. Many interstates, like the
I-95, in urban areas were often de-
pressed, leaving long gaping cuts. Heal-
ing forgotten wounds: the Cross-Bronx
Expressway addresses this infrastructural
negative space in Bronx, NY and reclaims
it to develop a productive linear land-
scape park over the Interstate that once
again sparks a dialogue between the two
sides of the highway cut. This project
explores the versatility of landscape
to shape a surface and an urbanism that
heals, connects, revitalizes, and is si-
multaneously productive and fun!

To develop this surface, the project


zooms in to a section of I-95 between the
Martin Luther King Blvd. and Macomb’s
Road, though the design can be set up
to work as a model for the entire In-
terstate. To implement the vision, the Manhattan
Bronx
project addresses programs through flows
and materials. Interstate-95

Program: Agricultural terraces + Univer-


sity, Recreation, Residential and Com-
mercial.
Flows: People and Water
Material: Earth and Architecture

148
Alpa Nawre PROPOSAL

I-95
Terrace Agriculture
Garden Terrace
Existing Commercial Public Parking Residential Existing
Buildings Buildings

Existing City
fabric
1400 ft.

Residential Residential

Agriculture

d
Agriculture
Roa
Blvd er
King in Luth

b’s
.

com

Residential
t
Mar

Ma

Recreation

Recreation Commercial
University
Commercial
University

Commercial

Existing City
fabric

149
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Full Sun

Light Shade

Medium Shade

Full Sun

Light Shade

Medium Shade
150
Alpa Nawre PROPOSAL

151
152
Ice - skating

Jan
Snowballing

Feb
Winter
Ice - carving

Mar
Spring Planting Festival

Apr
Spring
Films at Dusk
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Memorial Day Concert

May
Farmer’s Markets

Hip-Hop Festival

Jun
Latin Jazz Festival

Summer
Independence Day Concert

Jul
Rock-Climbing

Aug
Caribbean Bronx Festival

Bronx Arts Festival

Sep
Fall

Fall Harvest Festival

Culinary Competition
Oct

Bronx Ethnic Day


Nov
Winter

Winter Harvest Festival


Dec
Alpa Nawre PROPOSAL

01am 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 pm
Restaurants/
Retail

Agriculture

Office/ Public

Housing

University

Recreation/
Festivals

153
Mark Elliott Upton
poverty map of US

30-56.9%
below poverty line

Cross Bronx Expressway us census 2000

Livability and Infrastructure effects of cross bronx on socio-economic conditions along:

5-19.9% 20-29.9%
The Grand Concourse stretches across
the Bronx, connecting Manhattan (to the
South) to Van Cortlandt Park (to the
north). The Cross Bronx Expressway bi-
sects the Grand Concourse at approximate-
ly the Grand Concourse’s center point.
The Cross-Bronx Expressway will be the
focus of this analysis and proposal.
In the 2000 US Census, the Bronx was
one of the more impoverished areas in the
US with 30-56.9% of the population at or
below the poverty line. Along the Cross-
Bronx Expressway corridor, a concentra-
tion of impoverished areas are shown in
the diagram to the right, which indicate
the reduced land value adjacent to the
Cross-Bronx, as it is one of the less
desirable areas to live in the Bronx.
The Bronx is also contending with a lack
of affordable housing with an increase
in the homeless population. The lack of
affordable housing arose from the build-
ing boom earlier in the decade. Today,
the Bronx has not recovered the afford-
able housing stock pecentage it once held history of cross-bronx construction phasing
prior to the boom.
1948-1955 1953-1959
The Cross Bronx Expressway, a vi-
sion of Robert Moses in 1945, provided
an east/west connection from New Jersey
to I-95 a major north/south highway that
connects Queens to the south and Con-
necticut to the north.

section 1-2 section 3


156
Mark Elliott Upton ANALYSIS

% income to housing cost nyc metro physical characteristics

60-100%
income to housing cost
a_1

a_2

a_3

nodal
60-100%
40-60%
25-40%
10-25%

us census 2000

node a_3 and segment b_3 (please see below for node and segment designation)

30-39.9% 40-100%

city fabric with phasing

topography - east/west cut

the cross-bronx corridor_concept diagram


1959-1963

completion of links and bridges proposed phasing


157
procedure_node a_3
site aerial
major deegan expressway sedgewick avenue undercliff avenue

harlem river major deegan expressway

node a_3 node a_3 site analysis


Livability and Infrastructure region

When constructed, it cut through dense


urban fabric and is arguably the cause
for creating inequitable outcomes adja- river neighborhood (a) neig

cent its route.


The project was constructed in three
distinct phases, which included section
1-2, section 3 and finally the con-
struction of bridges at each end of the
expressway. This historical analysis of +0-+35 +35-+70 +70-
the Cross-Bronx expressway provides a
phasing approach to design, which will be
used to facilitate a redefinition of the
Cross-Bronx, and those it serves.
This project will focus on node a_3 as parks network

parks
shown in the prposed phasing diagram on
the previous page. This project is to
provide services and housing that would
borough
address the lack of affordable housing river neighborhood (a) neig

and space for new jobs. The project will


also connect to regional infrastructure
for those seeking jobs outside the Bronx,
reducing the need for extraneous commut-
ing. The intention of this project is
to provide an equitable solution to an +0-+35 +35-+70 +70-

inequitable living environment created by transportation and utility


multi-family buildings

an aging infrastructure.
vacant land
one-two family buildings
industrial and manufacturing
parking facilities

node a_3 does come with physical land use public facilities and institutions
open space and outdoor recreation
mixed use residential and commercial
region to Poughkeepsie, amtrac regional hub

complexity as the area changes in eleva-


tion approximately 140’. This project
line

will address the change in elevation


on
huds

while considering park links, land use


as it relates to its physical elevation
and mobility. Each of these issues are
river neighborhood (a) neig
addressed through the procedure to the
right.

grand central station


+0-+35 +35-+70 +70-

mobility
158
Mark Elliott Upton ANALYSIS

elevational cuts @ node a_3 major deegan expressway


3d diagram of procedural layers
exposing land use by layer +0-+35

sedgewick avenue
+35-+70
undercliff avenue
+70-+105
city
edward l. grant expressway
+105-+140
neighborhood
(b)

neighborhood
(a)

+0-+140
river

river neighborhood (a) neighborhood (b) city

+0-+35 +35-+70 +70-+105 +105-+140

node a_3 compilation and concept

ghborhood (b) city

-+105 +105-+140 +0-+140

ghborhood (b) city

-+105 +105-+140 +0-+140

ghborhood (b) city

-+105 +105-+140 +0-+140

159
node a_3 phasing
phasing

phase I phase II phase III

+0-+35 +35-+70 +70-+105 +105-+140

Cross-Bronx Expressway
node a_3 node a_3 concept diagram
Livability and Infrastructure
Project phasing also occurs along proposed link to parkway

these vertically zoned areas within node higher density along


river to provide
a_3. Each extension of the city toward economic stimulus to
waterfront
the waterfront provides living condi- potential built areas
based on low density and
tions that address the complexity of city null and open land use
large scale land use
services and use that each level create. diagram
concentration areas
For example, the river level addresses
the river and its connection to the city
through a series of parks connections,
the neighborhood levels are to provide
services within the local environment,
and the city level provides services
and housing to the larger city context.
Phasing for these extensions will be car- higher density residential

storm water remediation


ried out in order of the lowest to high- (large development plan)
parks link to high bridge
est elevation. regional bus stop for
regional business use
Park links are provided that connect
node a_3 phasing massing
the bronx to the waterfront, and across
to harlem. This is done through utiliz-
ing existing infrastructure as well as
reclaiming null or unused land that is
accompanying the rail line adjacent to high bridge
the harlem river. high bridge park
Phase I_study area will be shown in proposed parks link

more detail to establish some means for


roberto clemente state park
livability within node a_3 identifying (recreation center)

connections to transit infrastructure and


developing spaces for affordable housing
and jobs. The project will also address
pedestrian links to the waterfront by parks_concept massing
briding over the Major Deegan Expressway.
Park links will use this bridging in or-
der to provide connections to existing
phase III

phase I

phase II

built_concept massing

160
Mark Elliott Upton PROPOSAL

type study
urban edge_phasing diagram

roberto clemente park

proposed pedestrian
link from roberto clemente park
to harlem
proposed city and river edge
proposed pedestrian impovement
along edward l. grat highway
landscape improvement along
proposed city and river edge

+0-+140
regional mass transit link
(hudson line)
high bridge
(existing pedestrian link to
high bridge park)

phase I_morph phase II_morph phase III_morph

node a_3 urban edge_site plan node a_3 urban edge_parks/phasing

infrastructure

roberto clemente state park


(recreation center)

pedestrian links to boulevard


phase II deck over major deegan expwy for
event area
park intervention, phase II transit connection (bus and regional
(tree path) train)
loop road extension to connect to
sedgewick avenue

pedestrian connection to
programming
edward l. grant highway

phase I_study area

regional connection to hudson


line

washington bridge
waterfront trails @ bridge
locations
storm water catchment basin restoration areas, restaurant,
for remediation walking/biking trails, arts
spaces, and exhibit areas

park system continued @ train adaptive management


network

george washington bridge

phase III

adaptation
high bridge park

high bridge

+0-+140

roberto clemente park and high


bridge park
water run-off remediation for the c.b.
trail modification between exist.
parks in non-infrastructural areas for
flexibility
easy adaptation

161
phase I_node a_3
axonometric perspectives
community center

view toward northwest

phase I_node a_3 phase I_massing


Livability and Infrastructure

existing parking structure

neighborhood plaza

undercliff ave
river plaza

proposed parks link


to bronx

bronx river terrace

sedgewick avenue

river park (proposed)


on-ramp to major deegan

on-ramp to major deegan

major deegan expressway

regional train line

river park (proposed)

162
Mark Elliott Upton PROPOSAL
PROPOSAL

residential tower

residential bar

bridge over major deegan

city site entry

view toward northeast

phase I_node a_3_system phase I_node a_3_use diagram


residential community commercial transit service

tower b

residential towers tower a


_22 stories_132 units
tower b
_26 stories_156 units
tower a
total units @ 288
25% affordable units @ 72

cores to parking and public space _typical tower level


levels

towers

core to public space

mid level units


_3-5 stories_156 units
community facility
_5000 sf

_low rise residential

residential bars

core to mass transit


lower residential bars

residential entry

community facilities (community


community facility
services)
_4000 sf
mid level units
_3-5 stories_156 units
professional offices commercial
_3 stories_120000 sf

neighborhood retail _mixed use

community and commercial

parks / city link (plaza)

community facility
regional tain platform and bus _2000 sf
stop (hudson line) entry to residential
_6000 sf
commercial
_75000 sf
neighborhood retail
mass transit and public space _community_commercial

sedgewick avenue (neighborhood


auto connection)

parking structures

parking structure 1
750 parking spaces

major deegan expressway (regional parking structure 2


auto connection) 250 parking spaces

rail line (regional connection mass transit link


with link to manhattan)
_service_transit
service/parking

163
phase I_node a_3 proposed project perspectives
river to city

river

phase I_node a_3 city links to river_sections


Livability and Infrastructure
parks through a series of parks infra-
structure, program, and brownfield adap-
tation. city
connect
Phase I_study area provides a platform
for establishing community and tran-
sit services within one facility. This harlem river rail maj. sedgewick ave.
example of ‘multiplied grounds’ intends section_a
deegan

to bolster jobs through the creation of


commercial needs at different scales and
provide accessibility to transporta-
tion, connecting those in need of work to plazas city
connect

a larger/regional context. Affordable


housing is also a part of this project,
which must maintain a certain percentage section_b
harlem river rail maj.
deegan
sedgewick ave.

of required affordable housing to al-


low the air-rights over the Major Deegan
and the rail line with assistance from
the city in re-shaping the waterfront by plazas
city
minimizing the rail infrastructure in connect

place.
This project addresses the inequitable harlem river rail maj. sedgewick ave.
deegan
outcome from the implementation of an in- section_c
frastructure that meant to serve a larger
public. Today, these projects must both
serve the larger context, while address-
ing the needs of local communities. The
use of ‘multiplied grounds’ provides the
means necessary to establish the connec-
tion between the community to larger/re-
gional contexts, providing more equitable
urban spaces.

164
Mark Elliott Upton PROPOSAL
PROPOSAL

plaza city

perspective from city city to river

city

plaza

river
165
Andrea Pavia
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

October 9, 2009

Goals
This line of inquiry investigates the relationship between the
mobility
October 9, of the larger ethnic groups that have been populating
2009

the Borough in the last century, and the physical character of the
Borough neighborhoods.

Method of Work
The investigation occurs in four phases:

01-Constructing the Generative Matrix


Mapping Ethnic Territories The first phase of the investigation generates a matrix diagram to
in the Bronx Borough illustrate the relationship between the location and the density of
the different racial-ethnic groups within the Bronx Borough in the
last 100 years.

- The matrix is constructed using data from the US Census Bu-


One of the most distinct characteristic
of the Bronx Borough through its history reau and The Bronx Data Center at Lehman College.
has been the multi-ethnic composition of - Four major groups are identified for the analysis.
its population. - The definition of racial-ethnic groups refers to the US Census
Bureau definition from the year 2000.
Different groups have been moving in and
out of the area leaving their diverse so- - The unit used for the density analysis is the urban block with 10
cial imprinting, and participating in the or more inhabitants.
shaping of the “DNA” of the Borough. - If 51% or more of the inhabitants of the single block belong to
at the present time this process is still
the same group, the block is assigned to that group.
underway.

This line of inquiry investigates the re-


lationship between movements, locations,
and densities of these ethnic groups,
and speculate on their relation with the
contemporary physical attributes of the
Borough.
00-Defining The Physical Limits Of The Investigation:
The Bronx Borough Built Form Evolution 1776-2008

ANDREA PAVIA - 1/8 pages


ANDREA PAVIA - 1/8 pages
168
Andrea Pavia ANALYSIS

02-Discovering New Territories - At the neighborhood scale by identifying key study areas for
Based on the finding from the matrix diagram the investigation each of the territories, and investigating their physical attributes
leads to the production of two maps for each group showing: and their use by the inhabitants. In particularly looking at:
A) Building typologies, maintenance and reuse;
Cores: areas occupied by the same group for 3 generations B) Use of public realm, open spaces;
or more; Peripheries: areas occupied by the same group for 1 c) Social event;
generation or less. D) Memories (street names, demolitions, special events).

The resulting combination of all the Cores maps generates a 04-Evaluating New Territories
new map called: Map of the Stable Territories; By comparing the findings from the exploration the research
The resulting of all the Peripheries maps generates a new map will seek to answer main issues such as: What is the relation
called: Map of the Unstable Territories. between the social-cultural mix and the built environment? Is
the social mix a pre-condition to better living conditions, or an
03-Exploring New Territories impediment to these? Does ethnic and social segregation signifi-
Those maps identify two new landscapes within the urban envi- cantly affect the built environment, or is it the result of it?
ronment. The last part of the exercise seeks to investigate their
qualities and characteristics by collecting material evidence at
two scales:

- At the large scale by confronting those new territories with


relevant Borough indicators:
A) Economic (real estate value map);
B) Mobility (public transportation map);
C) Identity (tourist map);
D) Safety (criminality index map).

169
> The matrix has been constructed for the most part using data from the US Census Bureau and The Bronx Data Center at Lehman College.
> Four major groups have been identified for the analysis.
> The definition of racial-ethnic groups refers to the US Census Bureau definitions from 2000.
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse > The unit used for the density analysis is the urban block having 10 or more inhabitants in it.
> If 51% or more of the inhabitants of the singe block belonged to the same group, the block has been assigned as belonging to that group.

Non-Hispanic Whites
193,650
A person having origins in any of the
original peoples of Europe, the Middle
East, or North Africa. It includes people
who indicate their race as ‘White’ or
report entries such as Irish, German,
Italian, Lebanese, Near Easterner,
Arab, or Polish.

ANDREA PAVIA - 3/8 pages

es
ANDREA PAVIA - 3/8 pages

01-Constructing the Generative


Matrix
ANDREA
The first phase of the investigation PAVIA - 3/8 pages
gen-
erates a matrix diagram to illustrate the
relationship between the location and the
density of the different racial-ethnic
groups within the Bronx Borough in the
last 100 years.

- The matrix is constructed using data


from the US Census Bureau and The Bronx
Data Center at Lehman College.
- Four major groups are identified for
the analysis.
- The definition of racial-ethnic groups
refers to the US Census Bureau definition
from the year 2000.
- The unit used for the density analy-
sis is the urban block with 10 or more
inhabitants.
- If 51% or more of the inhabitants of
the single block belong to the same
group, the block is assigned to that
group.

170
ANDREA PAVIA - 4/8 pages
Andrea Pavia ANALYSIS

No Absolute Majority Hispanic/Latinos Blacks or


Non-Hispanic

77,295 644,700 African Americans


Includes all other persons not included Respondents providing write-in entries 416,330
in ‘White’, ‘Hispanic/Latinos’, and such as multiracial, mixed, interracial, Black or African American. A person
ANDREA PAVIAor
‘Black or African American’ categories. a Hispanic/Latino
- 3/8 pages group (for exam- having origins in any of the black racial
ple, Mexican, Puerto Rican, or Cuban) groups of Africa. It includes people who
in the ‘Some other race’ write-in space indicate their race as ‘Black, African
are included in this category. Am., or Negro’, or provide written
ANDREA PAVIA - 3/8 pages
entries such as African American,
Afro American, Kenyan, Nigerian, or
Haitian.

171
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse
Based on the findings from the matrix diagram the investigation leads to the production of two maps for each group showing

Cores: areas occupied by the same group for 3 generations or more.


Peripheries: areas occupied by the same group for 1 generation or less.

02-Discovering New Territories


Based on the finding from the matrix
diagram the investigation leads to the
production of two maps for each group
showing:

Cores: areas occupied by the same group


for 3 generations or more; Peripheries:
areas occupied by the same group for 1
generation or less.
Based on the findings from the matrix diagram the investigation leads to the production of two maps for each group showing:
The resulting combination of all the
Cores
Cores: areasmaps
occupied generates
by the same group fora3 generations
new map called:
or more.
Map of areas
Peripheries: theoccupied
Stable Territories;
by the same group for 1 generation or less.
The resulting of all the Peripheries maps
generates a new map called: Map of the
Unstable Territories.

ANDREA PAVIA - 5/8 pages

03-Exploring New Territories


Those maps identify two new landscapes
within the urban environment. The last
part of the exercise seeks to investi-
gate their qualities and characteristics
by collecting material evidence at two
scales:

- At the large scale by confronting those


new territories with relevant Borough
indicators:
A) Economic (real estate value map);
B) Mobility (public transportation map);
C) Identity (tourist map);
D) Safety (criminality index map).

- At the neighborhood level by identi-


fying key study areas for each of the
territories, and by investigating their
physical attributes and their use by the
inhabitants. In particularly looking at:
A) Building typologies, maintenance and
reuse;
B) Use of public realm, open spaces;
ANDREA
c) PAVIAevent;
Social - 5/8 pages
D) Memories (street names, demolitions, 02-Discovering New Territories: Maps of Cores and Peripheries
special events).

172
The resulting combination of all the cores generates a new map called: Map of the Stable Territories.
The resulting combination of all the peripheries generates a new map called: Map of the Unstable Territories. Andrea Pavia ANALYSIS

02-Discovering New Territories: Map of the Stable Territories and Map of the Unstable Territories

ANDREA PAVIA - 6/8 pages


eks to
ecting

ories

areas
cal

ents)

03-Exploring New Territories: Collecting Material Evidence ANDREA PAVIA - 8/8 pages

173
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

The Cross Bronx Expressway (I-95): Today

The Cross Bronx


Expressway

History/Functioning
The Cross Bronx Expressway is a major Facts Freeway System in the Bronx Borough
freeway in the New York City borough of
the Bronx, conceived by Robert Moses and
built between 1948 and 1963. It carries
traffic on Interstate 95 through the The Cross Bronx Expressway (I-95): Construction Phases
city, and serves as a portion of Inter-
state 295 towards Long Island; a portion
is also designated U.S. Route 1.

Problems
During the site analysis the team (A.
Nawre, A. Pavia, and M. Upton) identi-
fied major issues afflicting the area of
study, between the Grand Concourse and
the Cross Bronx Expressway. Among those:
persistent laceration of the fabric of
the neighborhoods crossed by the Express-
way; land-uses that are unresponsive to
the large infrastructure; a weak East/
West public transit connection through
the Borough; inaccessible and discon-
nected open spaces; a chronic economic
under-development and social segrega-
tion; lack of catalytic programs in the
area; increasing traffic congestion on
the Expressway; Pollution and resources
mismanagement. The Cross Bronx Expressway (I-95): Problems/Goals - The Operative Matrix

Goals
The team identified major goals on which
the broad strategy for the area is de-
veloped: provide catalyst spaces for the
regeneration of the neighborhoods, and
new centralities for the Borough; create
a strong East-West transit connection;
reconnect the river fronts to the city;
provide economic engines to drive diver-
sified growth; enhance the quality of
life in the neighborhoods; diversify mo-
bility options for the inhabitants at the
neighborhood and at the regional scale;
mitigate pollution and the environmental
impact of the freeway.

174
Andrea Pavia ANALYSIS

Sequence Of Nodes, Underpasses, And Bridges Subway Lines and Railways Crossed Program Crossed

Land-Use

Earnings

Opportunity Areas

Early Strategy

The Cross Bronx Expressway (I-95): Functioning and Geographic Impact

175
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Open Space Connector Proposed Light-Rail Line Proposed Node and Segments Proposed

Project Site

The Cross Bronx:


Bridging the Gaps
A Broad Strategy:
The Cross Bronx Expressway (I-95) As Spine For The Regeneration Of The Borough
The proposed plan aims to resolve the
physical and social divide created by the
Cross Bronx Expressway between the fabric
of the Southern and the Northern portion
of the Borough.

This divide is overcome by transforming


the space of the Expressway into a multi-
layer, multi-use infrastructure, able to
connect (or re-connect), the different
neighborhood’s fragments, and becoming a
major spine for the internal East-West
mobility of the Borough.

The plan seeks to be the trigger for a


larger process of requalification and
A New Architectural Typology:
upgrading of the broader area. Reconnecting The Fragments -
Preliminary Sketches

Cross Bronx - Existing Condition

Cross Bronx - Proposed

Reestablishing East Tremont:


Covering Portions Of The Cross Bronx
Will Allowed For The Reestablishment
Of The Historic Neighborhoods
176
Student Andrea Pavia PROPOSAL

Reestablishing East Tremont Neighborhood:


Open Space + Public
Proposed Strategy

Cro
ss B
ron
xE
xpre
ssw
ay

Cross Bronx Expressw


ay

Land Use - The New Architectural Typologies Re-Connect Fragmented Land Uses
Patterns And Introduces New Community Services

Land Use Proposed

Open Space + Public


Open Space + Private

Mobility - New Mobility Exchange Nodes (Car/Subway/Light-Rail/Bike/Pedestrian) Are


Created At The Intersection Of The Proposed Light-Rail Line And The Subway System,
Mobility Proposed
Above The Cross Bronx

Open Space + Private


Node + Context

Open Space - A Linear Green System Accommodates The East-West Light Rail
Line, Bike Route, And Pedestrian Path, Provides A Buffer Between The Existing
Uses And The Cross Bronx, And Linkages To The Existing Green Spaces

Open Space System Proposed

Layering System

Open Space Character - Each Of The Open Spaces Between The Exchange Nodes Is
Thought To Have A Distinct Character To Enhance The Crossing Experience

Open Space Character - Proposed


Project Site

Comunity Nodes - Exchange Nodes Are Thought Also As ‘Community Nodes’; offering A
Mix Of Public And Private Services And Uses At The Lover Levels, And New Residential East Tremont Neighborhood: New Community Node Layering System
Units (Affordable + Market Rate) On The Higher Levels

Intra-Community nodes

177
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Private Uses - Commercial/Civic

Subway Line 4

Residential

Public Uses - Commercial/Civic

City Grid

Grand Concourse

Subway Lines B-D

Light Rail Line B

The Cross Bronx: Green Boulevard

Bridging the Gaps Parking

The project provides a space of mediation East Tremont Community Node: Layering System
(or re-mediation) between the regional
scale of the infrastructural piece and
the neighborhood crossed. It is also the
opportunity to move the barycentre of
community activities closer to the area,
by locating civic programs, as well as
commercial, and residential uses, on the
newly identified infrastructural node.
A new architectural typology is intro-
duced to be the physical medium for the
strategy.

East Tremont Community Node:


Aerial Views And Courtyard Sequence

178
Andrea Pavia PROPOSAL

East Tremont Neighborhood Community Node: Illustrative Plan and Longitudinal Section

Ground Level Housing Typical Level (180 DU @ 1,000 sf) Below Grade Parking

Transit Stop
Transit Stop

Light-rail Line

Open Space - Ground Level Open Space - Housing Typical Level Open Space - Roof Level

179
Paola Aguirre
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

URBAN DECODING
An Alternative Reading of New
York City
The city is a puzzle. It is integrated by
pieces which have been placed or built
defined with different social, technical
or historical background. Each piece is
unique, but several of them share physi-
cal characteristics: proportion, connec-
tion, orientation, and geometrical func-
tion. When several pieces have either one
or all this characteristics in common, we
call it a “pattern”. Nevertheless, a pat-
tern could also be manifested by the lack
of having anything in common.

New York is not an exception. The metro-


politan area of New York includes Man-
hattan, Queens, Brooklyn and The Bronx,
which happens to be our focus area in
this exercise. This mapping analysis fo-
cuses in defining the block patterns with
which the city is integrated, and it is
intended to decode the city through its
urban patterns.

This exercise about de-fragmentation of


New York in its pieces departs from the
following questions:
Which patterns are dominant?
How do these patterns geometrically work
and how they collaborate with others?
What are the possible degrees of satu-
ration of the patterns and what other
components can determine its function or
configuration?
How their different gradients interact
with other factors of the context?
What is the physical relationship of the
pattern and the physical form of the
block?
What is (or should be) the role of The
Grand Concourse within the patterns that
are among it?

182
Paola Aguirre ANALYSIS

decode
1. to translate (data or o
a message) from a code or
a pattern into the original
language or form. / 2. to
extract meaning from
(spoken or written symbols)

pattern
1. the combination of
qualities, attributes,
tendencies, etc., forming
a consistent or character-
istic arrangement. / 2. an
example, instance, sample
or specimen. / 3. the repeti-
tion of a unit in rythim and/or
geometry.

183
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse
Surface transformation study
revealed that although the surface
has expanded, not necessarily has
enabled access to the water

Shoreline mapping:
1890, 1900, 1916, 2009

Continuity study pointed infra-


structure as the major driver of
the connection between Manhat-
tan and the Bronx. Consequently,
both boroughs are connected
through the large-scale infrastruc-
ture, but lack of effective medium
scale spaces for continuity.

North-South Continuity

East-West Continuity

184
Paola Aguirre ANALYSIS

Identitication of program concentrations

Juxtaposition of current conditions:


Program + Access + Density

Major strategy intentions

185
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Double Connection
The South Bronx and the Two
Harlems
North Manhattan and the South Bronx could
share more than a physical interface.
They could have a more reciprocal rela-
tion that could contribute to enhance the
dynamics between these two sites. Never-
theless, this relationship must not nec-
essarily be direct and/or physical, but
can be more in terms of sharing certain
characteristics of its urban components
and some elements of reference.

The project departs from the current


condition of having prominent physical
barriers between the South Bronx and both
the waterfront and the neighborhood on
the other side of the Harlem canal: the
footprint of large-scale infrastructure
(expressway and railroad) and the water
canal, respectively.

The main strategy is to connect the


Southeast Bronx and the two Harlems, the
waterfront and the neighborhood. In order
to allow this connection, a new pattern
of organization will be introduced, which
is associated with the geometry that
evokes the proportion of the Manhattan
block through different urban elements,
but without replacing the current layout.

Thus, the main strategy of the proj-


ect introduces two main physical opera-
tions. Firstly, through new openings in
the existing fabric and buildings, and
secondly, through the addition of new
volumes to emphazise a visual relation-
ship between the two sides of the Harlem
River.

186
Paola Aguirre PROPOSAL

Ultimate Phase: Consolidation of Neighborhood


and Waterfront Connection

187
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

188
Paola Aguirre PROPOSAL

189
Elements 2009 : The Bronx’s Grand Concourse

Study of stable and flexible buildings

Buildings identified as object of intervention

Samples of stable (left) and flexible (right) buildings

The approach to the site required a study of the


existing structures in order to establish a new
relationship between the existing neighborhood and
the waterfront.

The proposed network of open spaces required the


adaptation of existing structures in order to increase
the permeability in the east-west direction. In addi-
tion, the lines of the extended grid will include the
existing open spaces.

190
Paola Aguirre PROPOSAL

191
193
194
195
196
197
198
199

You might also like