Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MTS Report Compiled 1.1
MTS Report Compiled 1.1
Authors
Arti Mishra
Rukshana Praveen
Reza Mohammad Khan
Sumeet Kumar Pandey
Host Organization
Faculty Guide
Prof. Alok De
Approval Page
Bhubaneswar
Arti Mishra
Rukshana Praveen
Is hereby APPROVED
Prof. Alok De
KSRM 4
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Executive Summary
KSRM 5
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Acknowledgment
In preparing this report a considerable amount of thinking and informational inputs from
various sources were involved. We express our sincere gratitude to everyone who contributed
First of all we would like to thank dignitaries of Udyogini, CEO, Mrs. Vaneeta Vishwanath,
COO, Mr. Arvind Malik, our Business Development Manager, and Mr. Sandeep Mishra for
giving us the guidelines for successful completion of this report. We would like to thank our
reporting officer Ms Ketaki Narkar for her valuable support and feedback.
We would also like to thank all our respondents for their response without which this study could
not be possible.
We also take a special mention of faculty of KSRM, Prof Alok De for his valuable inputs.
Thank You
KSRM 6
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Table of contents
Lists
. Glossary
1. Introduction
The agriculture has potential to create economic growth in rural areas. It generates jobs
opportunities in adding value (as in food processing industry), in bringing agriculture products to
the customers (market linkage), and in providing support (infrastructure, information, quality
control and training). Agriculture is still the mainstay of the State's economy, as about 71 percent
of the population is still dependent on agriculture. Agriculture in the state is still traditional and
mostly rain fed. There is high proportion of low value crops with low productivity. Agricultural
holdings are fragmented. Madhya Pradesh has unique topography, soil and weather, which is one
of the major reasons that the impact of green revolution had been negligible on the agriculture
sector of the state
About 74% population of M.P. resides in rural areas. Around 65 percentage of the total land
holdings belong to small and marginal farmers occupying only 26 percent of the cultivable land.
The net sown area is about 147.90 lakh hectares. The gross cropped area is 202.16 lakh hectares.
The ratio of Kharif to Rabi crops is 1: 0.79 during 2006-07. The total irrigated area of the State is
43.3 % and remaining area is rain fed. The cropping intensity of the State is 136%.
The State is divided in the following 11 Agro Climatic Zones: (1) Chhatisgarh plains (Balaghat
district falls in this zone) (2) Northern hill region of Chhatisgarh (Districts of Shahdol,
Mandla, Dindori, Anuppur, Umaria and part of Sidhi fall in zone) (3) Kymore plateau and
Satpura hills (4) Central Narmada Valley (5) Vindhya Plateau (6) Gird region (7) Bundel Khand
(8) Satpura Plateau (9) Malwa Plateau (10) Nimar Plains (11) Jhabua hills. Agro ecologically
the state falls in three zones namely, Zone –VII (Eastern Plateau and hills Zone), Zone VIII
(Central plateau and hills Zone) and Zone IX (Western Plateau and hills Zone)
The major Kharif crops are: Paddy, Jowar, Maize, Bajra, Tur, Urad, Moong, Soybean,
Groundnut and Cotton etc. The major Rabi crops are: Wheat, Gram, Lentil, Peas, Mustard and
Linseed etc.
KSRM 10
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
As part of the Management Traineeship Segment, the major persona was feasibility study of
distribution of agriculture inputs and farm equipments on lease through VLSC. A study of
business analysis in both financial and operational aspect of different opportunities was carried
out to understand the various perspectives for the initiatives undertaken by Udyogini. In order to
identify challenges for the organization in current and future context different concepts that were
learnt in the classroom were utilized. The period of the study was from the 6th of July to the 6th
of September 2010.
Total world nutrient trade in 2001/02 rose by 4 million tonnes (6.6 percent). International
fertilizer trade occurs almost equally in developed and developing countries. Exports of nitrogen
KSRM 11
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
and potash decreased by 1.5 and 1.9 percent respectively, while those of phosphate increased by
2.1 percent
India, Pakistan and Bangladesh remain the main fertilizer consuming countries in South Asia.
The sub-region is facing considerable population pressures, with very limited reserves of good
agricultural land. Fertilizer consumption rose by 3 percent to 2.2 million tonnes. Tentative
forecasts show an average growth of 2.4 percent. The growth should be faster on phosphate (3.1
percent) than on nitrogen (2.1 percent) and potash (2.7 percent).In India, the largest fertilizer
consumer and producer in the sub region, nitrogen, phosphate and potash consumption increased
by 3.6, 4 and 6.4 percent respectively. Imports of nitrogen, phosphate and potash also rose by
12.3, 16.9 and 6.5 percent respectively. Higher increase in the consumption of phosphate and
potash relative to nitrogen is a welcome trend towards balanced use of nutrients. India’s
production of nitrogen fertilizers decreased by 2.3 percent while its production of phosphate
fertilizers rose by 2.7 percent. India’s New Pricing Policy for urea intends to gradually move in
the direction of parity with international prices and will be implemented in stages. The new
scheme is expected to promote production efficiency through cost saving measures and efficient
economic practices at par with international norms by the domestic urea producers. Subsidy on
decontrolled phosphoric and potash fertilizers is given under the Concession Scheme, which
varies per State. The government has linked their pricing to import parity from April 2002
onwards. Hence, natural gas prices register significant increase. The growth in urea demand has
been stagnating. The reasons for this change are the development of large grain surpluses, in
spite of a growing population, and the need for crop diversification using compounds rather than
urea.
KSRM 12
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Udyogini - means woman entrepreneur. Udyogini, the organization, works with poor women to
improve their skills as producers and their knowledge of the markets they operate in, so as to
ensure long-term returns
Udyogini, an NGO set up in 1992, has been working for the capacity building of poor women
through micro-enterprise development and its management. Udyogini was set up to co-ordinate
and facilitate management training for women’s groups at the grassroots under the World Bank
Institute funded Women’s Enterprise Management Training Outreach Program (WEMTOP).
This was a three-year participatory action learning project aimed at strengthening the capacity of
intermediary NGOs to deliver management training to poor women micro entrepreneurs. The
training program consisted of Grassroots Management Training (GMT) carried out for women
producers and the Training of Enterprise Support Teams (TEST) for the trainers of GMT. In
2002, as a result of a strategic planning process, Udyogini made changes in implementing
strategy, deciding to initiate programs to engage directly with women producers at the
grassroots.
Back in the early 1990s, when Udyogini was established, the focus on microenterprise
management training was innovative at a time when even microcredit was a new idea. Udyogini
took an early lead in the domain by motivating smaller NGOs towards microenterprise in their
portfolio of programs for poverty alleviation for women. It enabled NGOs, through a program of
sustained support comprising training for enterprise awareness, management and counseling, to
move into developing microenterprise programs and having staff with orientation to
microenterprise. The NGOs that have grown and now have established microenterprise programs
such as URMUL, SURE and LUPIN in Rajasthan; NIPDIT and Samanwita in Orissa and
ADITHI in Bihar are distinguished alumni of Udyogini enterprise motivation and management
training.
In its intervention at Mandla district, M.P. The project began in 13 villages to support around
200 women. They work in two clusters namely Babaliya and Bakori at Mandla district. By the
end of 2005, Udyogini worked with nearly 1200 women from 60 villages.
KSRM 13
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
As part of the business development service, Udyogini has established a rural retail chain in the
form of Village Level Service Centers (VLSC) by imparting training and skill development of
women and by also giving financial support to open VLSC and enhance their livelihood.
Udyogini now desires to sell agriculture-inputs and farm equipments on lease through Village
Level Service centers (VLSC) and to develop a sustainable business model for the same. By this
the organization not only wants to strengthen the women entrepreneurs who are operating the
VLSC but also help the farmers at their agriculture activities with keeping the business intreste.
Though the contribution of the primary sector, which includes agriculture, to the total Net State
Domestic Product is gradually coming down, agriculture is still the mainstay of the state
economy, as about 71percent of the population is still dependent on the agriculture The work
participation rate in state is 42.74, out of the total worker 42.79% are cultivator 28.69 are
agriculture labourer, 4.01 are engaged in house hold industry and the rest are in other services.
Agriculture in the state is still traditional and rain fed. There is high proportion of low value
crops with low productivity, agriculture holdings are fragmented. Thus it clearly state that
agriculture is the major livelihood activity in the region but still it contribute least in the GSDP
and NSDP of the Madhya Pradesh.
41%
KSRM 14
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
The Mandla district our area of study is also representing the same picture. The major constraints
in the low agriculture productivity in the region are as follows
Thus there is need of understanding the demand of agricultural inputs and related services of the
people in the region and based upon this develop a business model/supply chain to fulfil their
needs at their own villages that too at fair prices. That can help them to increase the productivity
in near future.
The study is focused to the asses the feasibility of the distribution of agriculture inputs and
related services in the targeted villages with the long term goal of increasing the agricultural
productivity by providing the assistance to the farmers and thereby increasing the income of the
farmers. To achieve the goal following objectives are set
To estimate the demand for agricultural inputs and other related services in the targeted
villages
To develop business model/supply chain for the agriculture inputs and services in the
target village
The information, suggestions and opinions made can help in strategic planning for developing
the business plan for the distribution of the agriculture inputs and other related services to
increase the productivity in long term and thereby increasing the income of the farmer to
improve the quality of life of the farmers. The primary data collected regarding agriculture
demand, market analysis, competitor analysis and distributor interviews at sample village and
systemic knowledge generated by this will result in the creation of a resource for other future
study. The academic study that arises from the project will provide a model for similar work
elsewhere.
The time period was not sufficient enough for studying the different dimensions and details
which could be more beneficial.
As some of the villages are not the operational areas of the organization, lack of the basic
information about village cause difficulty in data collection.
Poor and delayed transportation facility also delayed the data collection.
KSRM 16
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
2. Methodology:
Phases
Phase 1 Phase 2
(Background (Field
Study) Work)
Data
Discussion With Sample Questionnaire Collection
Udyogini Staff Design Development
Data
Analysis
Report
Writing
Phase 1:
The phase 1 of the project consisted of the background study on agricultural inputs used in
Madhya Pradesh, the demographic features and agricultural pattern .It include detailed
discussion with the staff of Udyogini, based on the discussion and background study the
questionnaires were developed.
Phase 2:
The phase 2 of the project consisted of the field work for the collection of data from the
respondents. Various statistical tools were applied to analyze the data. The final report was
prepared on the analyzed data.
KSRM 17
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
The area of this study is limited to 20 villages of Mandla and Jabalpur districts and the markets
of both these districts. The respondents for the questionnaire based survey were all in Babaliya,
Niwas and Maneri region of Mandla and Jabalpur districts whereas some information about the
current marketing practices was taken in from Jabalpur and Mandla.
In a stratified sample the sampling frame is divided into non-overlapping groups or strata of
farmer and non farmer. In this report the stratum is of farmers who have their own land. Then the
respondents are randomly selected based on their availability and willingness to participate in the
survey. The Farmers Households of the 20 villages of Maneri, Babliya and Niwas cluster were
the universe for the study with one farmer as unit of the study.
For primary data collection three questionnaires were designed in order to get information from
the stakeholders. First questionnaire was designed for the farmers who uses any kind of
agricultural inputs and services like fertilizers both organic and inorganic, tractors, thrashers etc.,
the second questionnaire was designed for the retailers to analyze the market and the third
questionnaire was designed for the distributors of Mandla and Jabalpur districts. The
questionnaire was framed with notable demographic and psychological variable. A psychological
instrument of their interest in agricultural inputs attributes and opinion statements were used to
KSRM 18
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
understand the respondent’s interest and opinion regarding further improvement in sector of
agricultural inputs.
Since the research involved analysis on both the product and the process, the data was collected
for both.
2.4.1. Product data collection – the data on product was collected from potential
customers. The data was collected through both questionnaire and discussion based
methodology. The data here was collected to know about the preference and usage of
farmers/consumer towards agri-input products and their perceived demand.
2.4.2. Process data collection – this data was mainly collected on what the ongoing process
is and how it can be improved. This data was firstly collected from retailers of the
local markets, how agri-inputs are availed from district level distributor and how do
they sell it to farmers, what is the potential demand and what is the seasonality.
Secondly the data is collected from district level distributors about how the supply
chain works.
2.5. Data Analysis
The data collected was processed or analyzed using various statistical tools after tabular and
graphical summarization of the raw data. After the data analysis the final conclusion were drawn
and these conclusion formed the basis for developing the marketing strategy.
KSRM 19
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
3. Literature Review
Fertilizer is key input in enhancing crop production. Fertilizer consumption and food grain
production is closely correlated. Presently fertilizer contributes about 50% to the total increase in
food grain production. Increasing pressure of population and shrinking land resources demand
for vertical expansion of agriculture where the role of fertilizers will further increase. At the
present level of nutrition, additional 150 million tons of food grain production has to be achieved
to feed almost 1.5 billion people by 2040. This estimate does not include demand for animal
feed, which will rise due to depleting grasslands. Thus, the crusade of higher production of food
grain has to continue with increased vigour using fertilizers along with the other sources of plant
nutrients.
Table: All India Fertilizer Consumption and Food Grain Production (Million Tons)
India has become third largest country with a total capacity of 11.757 million tons of N and
5.056 million tons of P2O5 in year 2000-2001. Domestic production of nitrogenous fertilizers
was 10.942 million tons in 2000-2001, whereas production of phosphatic fertilizers was 3.734
million tons, which are marginally high, compared to last year’s production. All India capacity
utilization has gradually improved
over the years and was maintained at almost cent per cent level. However, during 2000- 01
restrictions were imposed on capacity utilization for Urea at 92% as a consequence the
production of urea declined. The increase in production of total N is observed due to increase in
production of DAP and other complexes which also have 'N'. Production of DAP during 2000-01
was 10 % higher compared to previous year.
KSRM 20
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
agencies, cooperatives happen to be the main distribution agencies. The total number of fertilizer
sale points in India is more than 2,80,000 out of which about 72,580 (26%) are institutional
agencies sale points (mainly cooperatives and remaining 2,07,818 (74%) are controlled by the
private trade. On an average one-fertilizer sale point covers more than two villages. NE states,
Bihar, Orissa, H.P., M.P., Rajasthan have very thin spread of sale points and on an average one
sale point covers more than three villages. Distribution network in these states require
intensification.
With the withdrawal of subsidy and concessions the prices of fertilizers will increase. In the
totally decontrolled scenario, the stability and uniformity of fertilizer prices is not likely to be
achieved. Indian farmers who were getting fertilizers almost at the uniform price throughout the
country may not continue to avail this opportunity. They may also witness fluctuating market
price of a fertilizer within a short span of one crop season. Such price variation may affect
farmers purchase decision as well.
A feasibility study is essentially a process for determining the viability of a proposed initiative
and services and providing a framework and direction for its development and delivery.
Verify the community needs for the proposed activity or services and asses the overall
value the same. (Demand analysis )
Asses the market condition. (Market analysis)
Determine the required resources e.g. Capital and operating. (Technical analysis)
Determines the costs and financing strategies. (Financial analysis)
Socio-economic analysis.
Formulate the delivery options and recommend the most effective delivery strategy.
(Business model development)
Demand analysis for agriculture inputs and related services was done in two phases. The first
phase was idea generation phase in which first of all the desk research was done to understand
the agriculture scenario at Madhya Pradesh, Mandla district and then at the target block of the
district. This phase also included extensive and productive discussion with the organisation staff
for target village identification and questionnaire development.
The second phase was field study to understand the demand of agriculture inputs and related
services at the study villages.
Mandla District
Agriculture
Overview
Total geographical area: 965,559 hectares.
Net sown area: 23% of total geographical area. Fallow land and land not available for
cultivation accounts for 13% of the total geographical area.
Forest: 60%
Land holding
(a) 40% of the farmers have very small holdings, avg. 0.45 ha accounting for 7% of the
total cultivated area.
(b) 38% of the farmers have relatively large holdings, avg. 4.89 ha accounting for 79%
of the total cultivated area.
The field study includes the survey of 20 sample villages to assess the demand of Agriculture
inputs and Farm equipments on lease in the villages. 297 farmer HHs were surveyed with the
sample size of 25 percent.
Most of the farmers at the surveyed villages are having the small land holding, the following
table and graph shows the land holding pattern at the surveyed village.
The graph shows that only 13% of the total land holding is irrigated, which follows the state
picture of rain fed agriculture with little or no irrigation facilities and use of irrigation inputs.
87%
The two important food grain crops of the region are Paddy and Wheat, which contribute about
53 percentage of the total production and 68.34 percentage of the total food grain production.
Pulses collectively contribute about 8.42 percentage of total food grain production. Along with
Paddy, Wheat, and Pulses; Maize and Minor millets are also grown abundantly in the region.
Among non food grain crops oilseeds like Ramtila, Rai, Alsi and Tilli are cultivated in the region
and contribute approximately 5.20 percentage of the total production.
At present, about 31.69 percentage of the total cropped area is under Paddy and about 21.25
percentage of the area is under Wheat. The oilseeds are cultivated under 9.11 percentage of the
total cropped area.
KSRM 28
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Major
0% 0%
Crops and Production
1% 4%
6% Paddy Wheat
32% Maize Rahar
8%
Urad Rai
4%
Ramtila Masoor
3%
Kodo Kutki
6%
Chana Batra
1% 5%
21% Tili Alsi
8%
As the agriculture in the region is mainly rain fed, land fertility is low and most of the farmers
still rely on the traditional agricultural practices the demand of the agriculture input is not
satisfactory and less then the expectation of the organization. Although the demand of the
agriculture input is low still the study villages show the potential for the agriculture inputs and
related services.
The study show that among all the agriculture input Urea, DAP and Herbicides are mainly used
by the farmers in the villages. About 59 percent of the farmers use Urea at their fields and mainly
used for the Wheat cultivation. DAP is consumed by 28 percent of the farmers and about 5
percent of the farmer use Herbicides with the approximately volume of 62.81Liters. Total
demand of the Urea in the sample village is approximately 788.33 Quintals and that of DAP is
about 334.37 Quintals. The Framers buy Urea and DAP mostly from the cooperative at
subsidized rate or from the market. The purchase from the cooperative depends upon the land
holding. The major constrains for the use of the Urea and DAP by the farmers are
Other than Urea, DAP and Herbicides the demand of other agriculture inputs are nominal.
Pesticides and Vermicompost are used by only 4 percent of the farmer each inputs only that too
at some villages only. Vermicompost is used in the villages where MPRLP is at operation and
Vermicompost pits are built free of the cost. The use of other fertilizers like MOP, SSP, and Bio-
fertilizers is negligible in this region as only one farmer of the sample use MOP and one farmer
Bio fertilizers.
KSRM 30
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
We had a sample size of 25% of farmer house hold at each village
We had an assumption that 80% of House Holds are farmers at the village
46%
The major Farm equipments on lease or agriculture services used in the villages are Tractor,
Thresher, Irrigation inputs like Diesel pumps, Electric pumps, and Spry pumps. 43 percent of
surveyed farmers take Thresher on rent, 22 percent farmers rent Diesel pump, 10 percent Electric
pump, 15 percent of the farmers take Tractor on the rent and 10 percent take Spray pump. Only 8
percent of the farmers surveyed take Plough on rent. The use of these equipments depends upon
the resources availability and geographical location of the villages. Most of the time the farmers
hire these equipments at their own village from the co villagers and some time they have to rent
these services from the neighboring large villages or market centers like Babliya, Niwas,
Pipariya,Pipariya, Dhanpuri, Kundum. The rent mainly depends on the place of hiring. In all
surveyed villages we observed that the rent on thresher is paid on kind that is on an average 10
Kgs per quintal.
KSRM 32
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
10%
Electric Pump
22% Diesel Pumps
44%
Tractor
Plough
Spray Pump
Thresher
8% 15%
2%
Total Consumption
Category Village name (Quintals) No. of HHs
Mawai Rayyat 1.06 3
Melhari 1.35 3
Sukram 2.13 8
Bandariya 3.65 5
Malthar 4.5 7
Mawai Maal 4.55 6
Katang Sivni 6.23 16
Low (1-7Q) Terbani 6.5 31
Katangi 9.15 9
Jamgaon 10.55 21
Banar 10.65 21
Chapra 11.58 20
Majhgaon 12.35 16
Lehsar 12.75 11
Chekdehi Rayyat 13.65 22
Salehpani 13.75 21
Medium (8-15Q) Mehrasivni 14.4 14
Amdari 19.48 11
High (15 and Lohari 20.15 17
Above) Mehgaon 29.75 28
Total
Total No. of Consumption
Category Village name HHs (Lit)
Katangi, Sukhram
,Bandaraiya,Mawai
No consumption
Mall,Katang 0 0
(0)
Sivini,Terbani, Jamgaon,
Banar, Chapra,
KSRM 35
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Majhgaon,Chekdehi
Rayyat, Mehra Sivni
Mawai Rayyat 1 0.75
Amdari 1 0.1
Low (1-2 HHs) Melhari 1 2
Lohari 1 2.75
Malthar 2 2.5
High (5 and Mehgaon 5 1.5
Lehsar 6 2.5
Above)
Salehpani 9 3.4
Total
Total No. of Consumption
Category Village name HHs (Lit.)
Katangi, Sukhram
,Bandariya,Mawai
No consumption Rayyat, Jamgaon,
0 0
(0) Chapra,Chekdehi
Rayyat, Mehra
Sivni,Salehpani, Lohari,
KSRM 36
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Malthar
Majhaon 1 2
Amdari 1 0.1
Melhari 1 1
Low (1-3) Mawai Maal 2 2
Katang Sivni 2 1.25
Banar 2 0.7
Terbani 3 1.5
High (4 and Mehgaon 4 13
Above) Lehsar 5 3.5
Total
Consumption
Category Village name (HHs)
Mawai Rayyat, Malheri,
Sukhram, Tarbani,
No Consumption Chakdehi Raiyyat,
(0) Lohari 0
Mawai Maal 1
Malthar 1
Katang Sivni 2
Bandariya 3
Chapra 4
Low (1-5 HHs) Katangi 5
Medium (6-11 Amdari 8
HHs) Mehra Sivni 11
Majhgaon 12
Lehsar 18
Salehpani 18
Jamgaon 19
High (12 and Banar 23
Above HHs) Mehgaon 30
Total
Category Village name Consumptio
KSRM 38
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
n (HHs)
Tarbani,
No Sukhram,
Consumptio Katangi,
n (0) Salehpani, Chapra 0
Mawai Rayyat 1
Chakdehi Rayyat 1
Bandariya 1
Melhari 1
Low (1-3 Lohari 2
HHs) Mawi Mall 2
Katang Sivni 2
Lehsar 2
Amdari 3
Malthar 3
Medium (4- Jamgaon 5
6 HHs) Banar 6
Mehra Sivni 7
High (7 and
Majhgaon 9
Above HHs) Mehgaon 11
Total
Consumptio
Category Village name n (HHs)
Mehra Sivni,
No Lohari, Malthar,
Consumptio Sukhram, Lehsar,
n (0) Salehpani, 0
KSRM 39
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Mehgaon
Mawai Raiyyat 1
Katang Sivni 1
Low (1-3 Mawai Maal 2
Chakdehi Rayyat 2
HHs) Bandariya 2
Melheri 2
Majhgaon 3
Amdari 4
Medium (4-
Malthar 4
7 HHs) Chapra 7
Banar 9
High (8 and
Jamgaon 18
Above HHs) Tarbani 21
Total
Consumption
Category Village name (HHs)
Mehra Sivni, Amdari, Mawai Rayyat, Mawai
Maal, Majhgaon, Chapra, Chakdehi Rayyat,
Malthar, Bandariya, Katang Sivni, Sukhram,
No Consumption (0) Jamgaon, Malheri, Tarbani 0
Lohari 1
Banar 1
Low (1-5 HHs)
Mehgaon 1
Katangi 3
Salehpani 13
High (10 and Above HHs) Lehsar 15
KSRM 40
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Total
Consumption
Category Village name (Quintals)
Majhgaon, Mawai Maal, Tarbani, Katan Sivni,
No Consumption (0) Katangi, Jamgaon, Mehra Sivni, Chapra, Banar, 0
Sukhram, Chakdehi Rayat, Lohari, Bandariya
Mawai Rayyat 1
Low (1-3 HHs) Melhari 1
Aamdari 2
Mehgaon 4
Medium (4-7 HHs) Salehpani 6
The village were ranked according to the Average consumption of the Urea and DAP at the
villages by the farmers.
The villages are ranked according to the Number of the Farmer HHs using/ hiring the farm
equipments at the villages. Farm equipments are Tractor, Thresher, Diesel Pumps, Electric
Pumps, and Spray Pumps.
The Key market segment for agriculture inputs and related services are the farmer of the 20 study
villages which include farmers from the Babaliya, Niwas, and five villages of Maneri cluster of
the Mandla and Jabalpur district. The Maneri cluster is not the operation area of the organization.
Most of the villages are remotely located and approximately 5-6 Km away from the nearest
market/weekly Haats. Although the organization wants to start the business with villages where
it is having its Village Level Service Centre (soon) but it also wants to expand to other remote
villages of the clusters.
Major Market Centers for the study villages are Niwas, Babliya, Pipariya, Maneri, Dhanpuri,
Kundum.
In the absences of any related Secondary data or information and reliable primary information
we assumed that total demand came out after the research is the market size for our study. The
Market size/ demand for agriculture inputs and farm equipments on lease are as follows.
As per the Demand analysis Urea and DAP can be the main agriculture inputs, the other inputs
can be herbicides and pesticides. The Urea and DAP are having very small product line and the
major brand sold in the regions are Kisan Urea, Chambal Urea, IFFCO Urea, Navrata Urea, IPL
DAP, PPL DAP, Navratna DAP.As compared to Urea and DAP Herbicides and Pesticides are
having more product line and brands.
Demand analysis shows that farm equipments on lease not only have less demand due natural,
physical, economical constraints like low soil depth, lack of irrigation facilities, lack of proper
KSRM 43
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
electricity supply and low purchasing power but also the people can get these equipments at
that their own villages .
The study shows that both agriculture inputs and farm equipments on lease have inadequate
supply at the villages.
The analysis was done at the villages which are market centers for Agriculture Inputs and Farm
Equipments for the study villages. The villages for competitor analysis are Babaliya, Niwas,
Maneri, Dhanpuri, Barela. Along with the competitor analysis Distributor interviews were taken
at Mandla, Jabalpur and Barela to get further information required. The competitors of the
business are categories in two groups.
Recove
No. of ry Rate
Products/Se Avg. Price
Category Competitor villages on
rvices Volume Range
Covered Credit
sales
Adim Jati Seva Urea 20 ton 282/ 50 kg 25%
Sahkari Samiti DAP 29 20 ton 528/ 50 kg
(Maneri) SSP 8-9 tons 170/ 50 kg
Urea 60 ton 282/ 50 kg 35%
Adim Jati Seva DAP 15 ton 528/ 50 kg
Sahkari Samiti SSP 34 2 ton 169/ 50 kg
Government (Niwas) Loan NA NA
Grain seeds 25 Q NA
Urea 12 Q 280/ 50 kg 70%
Kisan Krishi DAP 25 Q 530/ 50 kg
Kendra Pesticides 50 40-45 Ltrs 650/ 500 ml
(Babliya) Grain seeds 140 Q NA
Pulses seeds 11 Q NA
KSRM 44
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
A) Strength
1. Competitive advantage at Capital and investment capacity.
2. Good Soft Structure , policies, and plan.
3. Good repertoire with customers.
4. Fixed share in fertilizer production.
5. Strong distribution channels.
6. Deep penetration (Villages).
7. Also provide technical Support.
B) Weakness
1. Not proper implementation of policies and plan.
2. Black Marketing.
3. Demand is more than supply.
Private Retailers
A) Strength
1. They can sell the products in loose and at credit.
2. Good repertoire with customers.
3. Save transportation cost as they don’t have to sell the product at villages.
4. Agri.-Inputs and equipments Centers are located at the market centres.
5. Updated pricing strategies and mechanism.
6. Diversified portfolio as most of the retailer take it as a side business and the retailer
who are dealing just in this business have diversified portfolio along with good
penetration.
B) Weakness
1. Most of the retailers are not having any Licenses except the one who are just engaged
at the business of Agriculture inputs and equipments.
2. Most of the project villages are far located.
3. Most of the Retailers are not having warehouses.
KSRM 46
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
The technical analysis is done assuming that the business is for the time period of five years. The
analysis is done for two approaches which are as following:
4.6.1 Technical analysis for the business of agricultural inputs products and related
services:
The essential requirements for the business of agricultural input products and related services are
enlisted below:
4.6.2. Technical analysis for the business of agricultural inputs products only:
Promotion
Product
Place
Price
Villages of Babaliya, Niwas Price derived by pricing
and Maneri Clusters strategy
KSRM 48
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Pricing Process:
The curve above describes the best way to decide about the pricing of the agri-inputs and
services provided by the organization. The curve above describes how the low pricing as well as
high pricing are harmful towards profit. If the product is priced too low, the organization tends to
acquire losses as it would not be able to compensate for its costs. If the product is priced too high
then also the organization would incur losses as its competitors would gain from it for they’d
provide the services to people at a lower rate than the organization. As such it is critical for the
organization to decide upon the price of the product optimally so as to benefit both the
organization as well as its customers.
The nearest big markets of agri-inputs and services are Mandla and Jabalpur of which Jabalpur is
the bigger of them. It is a hub of big distributors of agri-inputs and services in the whole Mandla
and Jabalpur. Dhanpuri is also a market for agri-inputs but not of that magnitude. The details of
the potential distributors for the business are described as followed:
Quantity Urea ty
Purohit Mandla YES Rs. Rs. 515/ Will be borne by YES
Traders 270/50 50 kg Distributor in off season or
kg Bag when Company give the
Bag Free on Road (FOR)
Aggarwal Jabalpur YES Rs. Rs. 518/ Have to borne by UJAS or NO
Brothers 278/50 50 kg Udyogini
kg Bag
Bag
Madhu Jabalpur YES Rs. Rs. 515/ Will be borne by NO
Fertilizers 270/50 50 kg Distributor in off season or
Pvt. Ltd. kg Bag when Company give the
Bag Free On Road (FOR)
1. Financial analysis for the business of agricultural inputs products and related services.
1. Financial analysis for the agricultural inputs products and related services:
Fixed Cost Analysis for five years (for Agriculture Input Products & Services)
Year Ware Licensing Vehicles Farm Manage Essential TOTAL
house Equipments -ment Maintenance
Cost Cost
0 0 3250 505000 293000 0 0 801250
1 36000 0 0 0 270000 19600 325600
2 36000 0 0 0 270000 19600 325600
3 36000 3250 0 0 270000 19600 328850
4 36000 0 0 0 270000 19600 325600
5 36000 0 0 0 270000 19600 325600
TOTAL FIXED COST FOR 5 YRS 2E+06
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1 161841 6645 452 6000 108000 87550 4944 21428 396860
2 168315 4652 484 6120 115560 93679 5290 22928 417026
3 175047 3954 517 6242 123649 100236 5660 24533 439839
4 182049 3361 554 6367 132305 107253 6057 26250 464195
5 189331 2857 592 6495 141566 114760 6481 28088 490169
TOTAL 2208090
*Assumptions:
2. It is assumed that there will be minimum four trips for the transportation of agri-input products
from CLSCs to VLSCs per annum
3. It is assumed that the procurement of agri-input products will increase by 7% as our sales will
rise by the same percent per annum
4. It has been assumed the warehouse insurance premium will rise by 7% as the procurement will
also increase by the same percent per annum
5. It has been assumed that the tractor insurance premium will decrease by 30% in first year and
thereafter it will decrease by 15% per annum
6. It has been assumed that the electricity bill will increase by 2% per annum.
CLSC to VLSC
Particulars Rate Quantity Amount (INR)
Urea Urea @ Rs 280/ 50kg Bag 200 Quintals 112000
KSRM 54
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
*Assumptions:
It is assumed that our pump sets will run for 5 hours for 5 days by one person.
Sales
Year Sales (in INR)
0 0
1 1518318
2 1624600
3 1738323
4 1860005
5 1990205
*Assumption: 1. It has been assumed that our sales will increase by 7% per annum
Total Fixed Cost 801250 325600 325600 328850 325600 325600 2432500
Total Variable Cost 0 396860 417026 439839 464195 490169 2208090
Total Cost (A) 0 722460 742626 768689 789795 815769 4640590
Total Sales (B) 0 151831 1624600 173832 186000 1990205 8731452
8 3 5
EBIT = (B-A) - 795858 881974 969633 107021 1174436 4090862
801250 0
Tax @ 2% pa 0 15917 17639 19393 21404 23489 97842
EAT = (EBIT- - 779941 864335 950240 104880 1150947 3993020
Tax) 801250 6
4.9. Net Present Value (N.P.V) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR):
The Net Present Value (NPV) is always positive for all the discount rates (i.e. 1% to 103.187%).
Note: The discount/interest rate used in determining the present value of future cash flows.
KSRM 56
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Profitability Ratio:
Net profit Margin Ratio 0.46
Operating Profit Margin 0.47
Ratio
Gross Profit Ratio 0.85
Management cost for Warehouse and Farm Equipment Leasing for 5 years
One Manager 8000/-
One Agri Input Expert (for Research, Development and 6000/-
Training)
One Supervisor cum Accountant(One for warehouse) 4000/-
One watchmen 2000/-
One peon 1500/-
TOTAL COST (for 1 month) 21500/-
Total cost for 12 months 21500/-*12= 258000/-
Total MANAGEMENT COST for five years 1290000/-
Total Maintenance cost for one year (Ware House) 3600
Total Maintenance cost for five years (Ware House) 18000
Total Fixed Cost for five years 1494500/-
Pesticides
Type 1 @ 201/liter*12Liters 2412
Type 2 @ 211/liter*13liters 2532
Herbicides
Type 1 @ 988/liter*11Liters 10868
Type 2 @ 960/liter*11liters 10560
Total Cost of Procurement 221922
Electricity Bill (350 per month*12) 4200
Total Variable cost for 1st Year 233697
*Assumptions: 1.It is assumed that the transportation cost may increase by 4% per annum
2. It is assumed that there will be minimum four trips for the transportation of agri-input products
from CLSCs to VLSCs per annum
3. It is assumed that the procurement of agri-input products will increase by 7% as our sales will
rise by the same percent per annum
4. It has been assumed the warehouse insurance premium will rise by 7% as the procurement will
also increase by the same percent per annum
5. It has been assumed that the electricity bill will increase by 2% per annum.
KSRM 59
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
*Assumption: It has been assumed that we will meet the 25% of demand in first year.
The Net Present Value (NPV) is always negative for all the discount rates (i.e. 8% to 300%)
Socio-Economic Analysis
The foremost aim of any NGO is to help the community to increase their socio-economic status
keeping in regards the business aspect of the intervention. The products and services provided by
the business would not only be beneficial to the farmers but also help in generation of additional
employment. This business reinforces the vision, mission and goal of Udyogini i.e. to empower
women as an entrepreneur as the products would be sold through VLSCs to the farmers in their
respective villages. The other benefits associated with the business are elaborated below:
Opportunity cost : Total cost method (TCM) has used to calculate the opportunity cost.
Total no. of hours in Ave. time spends *No. of men 32 12352 hrs.
a Year hrs.*386
Total no. of days In a Total no. of hrs. / working hrs. in 12352 1544
Year a day hrs. / 8 hrs.
Value of Agri Inputs Total on. Of days * wage rate 1544*70 Rs. 108080
Advantages:
The time consume by men can be saved if there would be the facility of agri inputs at their door
step in a reasonable cost which they can afford.
The opportunity cost which lies in this plus the social cost to the village is huge. This time can be
utilized by the people to do other jobs like working in NAREGA and other Govt. projects which
will surely enhance their livelihood needs.
The saved time can be use for productive work that can be an additional source of income for the
family. The Major portion of the income is consume by the family either rest of the income can
be save and then invest in infrastructure like ,hand pump, well, house, vehicle, home appliances
etc to get a good quality of life which will further give them an additional time to do some
productive work.
Or some part of the income can be spend for paying to the services which can give them
good quality of life. This services can be safe drinking water, electricity, bio- gas connection,
sanitation etc. These good qualities of life help them to save their time which they can further
utilize in any productive work.
The productive cycle of chain keeps on running until the saved time through good quality
of life is not utilizing by the person for productive work, increase expenditure on consumption or
give the preference to saving instead of spending on services or investment on infrastructure
KSRM 63
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Conclusion:
After research and analysis it is concluded that the business of distribution of agricultural inputs
and farm equipments on lease is not feasible due to various reasons such as:
The geographical conditions (poor soil quality, low soil depth, lack of proper irrigation
facilities, etc) of the villages are not suitable for extensive agriculture. Therefore the
demand of the products and services cannot be adequately increased.
The purchasing power of the farmers is not sufficient to invest in the scientific
agricultural practices. It is evident from the fact that most of them are dependent only on
agriculture and mono-cropping is prevalent in the region. Their secondary occupation
comprises of agriculture labour and wage labour.
The demand analysis shows that the demand for agricultural inputs and services is not
sufficient enough to start a new business. Market analysis shows that although the
competition is less in the region but due to the State government’s interventions it is at
disadvantage.
The financial analysis shows that although there is profit in the business but the amount is
not sufficient enough to recover the cost incurred to start the business. The breakeven
point of the business is not reached even in the 5 th year of the business. The Net Present
Value (NPV) at the discount rate of 15% shows a negative outcome which indicates that
it is wise not to invest in the business.
KSRM 64
Feasibility Of Distributing Agri-Inputs Through VLSC
Recommendation:
As the business is not financially viable and sustainable, the organization should not invest in
this business. The organization should instead be engaged in promotion of some livelihood
development activities and skill/ capacity building of the people so that their purchasing power
can be increased. This would help the organization in two ways:
Building repertoire with the community which will help the organization in their future
interventions.
Once the purchasing power of the community increases any intervention of the
organization would be positively responded.
If they still want to invest in the distribution business, it is recommended that they do it after they
are convinced that the community would respond positively to it.