Volume 1, Number 1, December 2003
WH Ecitoral 1
Aminath Faiz
Bl Message from the Minister of Health 2
Abmed Abdulla
I Accountability and Responsibility: important Attributes
toNursing 3
Hatoeza lbrahim
BJ Observations and Comments on Standards of Nursing
Practice in the Maldives 8
Aminath Faiz
Bll Providing an Environment Conducive for the Recovery
of the Hospitalized Children: A Literature Review 13
Asiya Ibrahim
Hi AIDS Stigma: Key note Addross Presented at the Nurse
Conference on the Intemational Nurses Day, 12 May
2003 17
thusana Ahmed
I Fational Drug Therapy in Pregnancy & Lactation 19
Dr Sajid Patel
Sickle Cell Thalassaemia in a Family: A Cinical Case
Finding 26
Ibrahim Mustafa
=ae=z Faculty of Health Sciences
stinmtsw — Maldives College of Higher EducationEditorial Board
Aminath Faiz, Editor
Aminath Riyaz, Associate Editor
Asiya Ibrahim, Associate Editor
Dr. Ahmed Razee, Medicine
Aishath Shaheen, Public Health
Aishath Shabana, Information Technology
Hafeeza brahim, Nursing
8.8, Mageswaran, Pharmacology
Mariyam Sihara, Medical Laboratory Technology
Mariya Warujeena, Student Association
‘Special Editorial Assistance
Margaret MeMilan
Vicki Parker
Dr. Hassan Hameed
Mohamed Ismail Fults
Husnia Razee
Maldives Journal of Health Scionces, volt, issue 1, 2003Important Attrbutes to Nursing
(pp.3-7)
Holistic nursing involves direct
inerventions wth human beings
and renders it necessary to
incorporate ethical considerations in
patient care. Thus the need for two
important attributes, responsibilty
‘and accountability to be practiced
in nursing in order that patients
receive quality care. The main
responsibiltias of nurses are to
recognize the unique nature of the
‘care-giving role and identify that
hisher role is caring and not only
curing, With the establishment of
the Maldives Nursing Coun in
1999, itis hoped that nurses in the
Maldives wil find that their
responsibilties and expected
standards of practice are mare
distinct. Some of the functions ot
‘Nursing Councils are to monitor and
take action for breach of
responsibilities. In addition such
bodies also safe guard practice,
give guidance, security and support
for exercising nurses’ rights,
Observations and Comments on
‘Standards of Nursing Practice in the
Maldives
(pp8-12)
Standards of practice is one of the
professional issues in nursing in the
Maldives. itis imperative that
Nursing practice is monitored and
Quided by a regulatory body, Until
recently there has been no
regulatory body to guide nursing
Practice. In Soptember 1989 a
Maldivian Nurses Council (MNC)
has been established. One of its
objectives is to establish/maintain,
‘and improve standards of
nursing/midwilery education and
practice. With the establishment of
the MNC a regulatory body now
exists to ensure that nursing
practice is within a code of
professional conduct. Ths anticle
addresses the issues regarding
standard of practice and the impact
of a regulatory body on nursing. A.
literature review will discuss
regulations, code of professional
conduct, accountability, continuing
education and nursing competence,
Providing an Environment Conducive
For the Recovery of the
Hospitalized Children: A Literature
Review
(pp.13-16)
Providing an environment
‘conducive for the recovery of the
hospitalized children needs to be
‘addressed as itis also considered
as one of the principles of
fundamental paediatric nursing
Practice. Hence a literature review
was conducted wit the aim to
review and analyse aspects in
providing a conducive environment
{or the recovery of the sick children.
‘The issues which mainly emerged
tom the literature included
psychological issues related to
hospitalization, effects and
influences of physical environment
‘on children and their parents,
importance of incorporating play,
preparation for hospitalization for
the psychological well-being and
the concept of family-centered! care
inproviding holistic care.
Rational Drug Therapy in Pregnancy
& Lactation
(pp.19-25)
Drugs can have harmful effects on
the mother and fetus al ary time
during the pregnancy. Use of
‘medications during pregnancy
requires a careful assessment of
tisks and benefits for hem. During
the first timester teratogenic effects
are frequent. There is higher risk
{rom third to eleventh week of
gestation,
During the second and third
ttimester drugs may affect the
{growth and functional development
of the fetus or have toxic effects on
the fetal tissues, Drugs
administered shortly before term or
during labour may have adverse
effects on mother or on noonate,
‘The FDA has established five
categories (A,B,C, D, X) which
indicate the potency of a
systemically absorbed drug causing
bith detects. These categories are
indicative of the level of effects to
the fetus. The category X includes
the drugs for which there is enough
data to implicate thei teratogenicity
and the risk versus benefit ratio.
does not support the use of the
rug and hence these are
contraindicated in pregnancy, A few
drugs present variable risk to the
fetus depending on the time and
duration of their use, The use of
‘drugs in pregnancy is complicated
by their potential harmful effects on
the growing fetus, altered maternal
physiology and difficulties of
research in this field. Because
experience with many drugs in
pregnancy is severely limited it
should be assumed that all drugs
fare harmiul unti sufficient data exist
to indicate otherwise, Social drugs
(alcohol and cigarette smoking) are
definitely harrnful & their use should
bbe discouraged
‘The stage of gestation influences
the effects of drugs on the fetus. It
's convenient to divi pregnancy in
three stages: pre implantation (2
weeks from fertiization), the
orgenogenesis\embryonic stage
(hd to 8th week) and the fetogenic
stage (9th week tl term), Animal
studies suggest that interferences
wilh the fetus before 2 weeks of
gestation cause no harm if
pregnancy continues (James, Steer,
& Weigner 2000),
‘Sicle Cell Thalassaemia in a
Family: clinical case finding
(pp.26-30)
A larnly case report of sickle
thalassaemia syndrome shows,
diagnostic difficulties, such as to
differentiate sickle coll thalassaemia
from sickle cell disease due to wide
range of similar clinical picture. The
diagnosis of this syndrome could
bbe missed o1 confused with siokle
cell disease, and this is important to
‘a country like Maldives, where
prevalence of haemogiobinopathies
is very high. Around 18% of
Maldivian population carries the
‘gene for beta thalassaemia tal
The methodology used includes,
Hb electrophoresis by cellulose
acetate al alkaline pH and quantity
‘of Hb was done by HPLC,
Hematological parameters were
oblained by ERMA PC 170 Parlcle
counter. The findings are
suggestive of a thalassaemia trait
{and itis also consistent with sickle
cell anaemia. In this report
Thalassaeria is not contitmed but
recommended to do ONA analysis
{0 We out alpha thalassaemia,
because the homatological findings
of family gives picture of alpha
thalassaemia,
ii Maldives Journal of Health Sciences, vol.t, issue 1, 2003Editorial
Aminath Faiz
‘The Maldives Journal of Health
Sciences aims to publish up-to-
date health information annually
to enrich the awareness of
health professionals. The journal
intends to publish articles of
scholarly and research origin
from all areas of health
sciences.
This is an important step in
narrowing the inforrnation gap
by the dissemination and
sharing of research findings,
The journal shal also provide
information about important
events and programs occurring
within the health care system,
We have long wanted to
develop a journal where we
Could publish the results of our
research and scholarly work
Most research work are not
available to the general reader.
Maldives Journal of Health
Sciences encourages research
and jooks forward to publishing
articles, essays, short write-ups,
case reports and book reviews.
Maldives Journel of Health Sciences, vol,
‘The journal has an Advisory
Board whose expertise
embraces disciplines in the
areas of medical science and
health care. All material will
undergo a double biind review
by experts from the relevant
areas before publication.
Inthis fist issue, "Rational
Drug Therapy in Pregnancy and
Lactation” presents information
fon some important drugs and
their effects on pregnancy. It
has implications not only for
those prescribing but also to
those taking care of the
pregnant woman,
“Providing an Environment
Conducive for the Recovery of
Hospitalized Children” is about
‘oteating the right environment
{or hospitalized children,
“Accountability and
Responsibility” is an article on
{wo important attributes of
nursing, Thalassaemia major is
a significant problem in the
Maldives. "Sickle Cell
Thalassaemia in a Farry’
addresses the complexity of
differentiating sickle cell
thalassaemia from sickle cell
disease
To develop and maintain
good standards of practice we
must identify errors and search
for solutions, “Observations and
‘Comments on Standards of
Nursing Practice in The
Maldives” is about the
implication of regulations on
nursing practice, dealing with
cultural differences,
‘communication and other issues
intelation to nursing in the
Maldives
| appreciate the
‘encouragement from the MOH
and the Rector of the Maldives
College of Higher Education for
‘our work, | thank Professor
Margaret McMillan and Vicki
Parker of the University of
Newcastle, Australia tor their
encouragement and advice in
the development ofthis
journal =
issue 1, 2003 1Message from the Minister of Health —
Ahmed Abdulla
| would like to congratulate the
Faculty of Health Sciences for
Publishing the Maldives Journal
of Health Sciences. My sincere
thanks and good wishes go to
the Faculty’s able Dean Mrs.
‘Aminath Faiz and her dedicated
team, Itis a very important
initiative taken by the Faculty in
this age of information and
‘communication. We Maldivians
are very fortunate that our
Goverment is investing heavily
on human development. Our
economic and social progress
has been tremendous due to
our Govemment's decisive
Policies. We are extremely
grateful to President Maumoon
Abdul Gayoom for
spearheading our country's
development and progress,
resulting in far reaching strides
inall spheres of lf. The
Government has attached great
importance to science and
technology in development.
Science and technological
progress has great significance
in the modernization and
achievement of development
goals,
Therefore, itis very
heartening that our institutes of
training are giving greater
importance to the leaming and
imparting of scientific.
knowledge in many areas. itis
particularly relevant that the
county's leading health
personnel training institute -
Faculty of Health Sciences
‘embrace this vital development
In order to achieve optimal
results in the fields of scientific
learning and application of this
knowledge for the health
services of the country, Maldives
Journal of Health Sciences is a
big step forward,
We ate very proud of the
Faculty's pivotal contribution in
training a large number of
personnel for the health sector
‘The quality of the Faculty’s
training has improved
remarkably. The Faculty has
made many achievements by
training quality health personnel
and hence we are very pleased
for the Faculty's reputation as an
institute of quail and
excellence.
Its very important for the
Faculty to have the necessary
means and facilities to provide
information and knowledge to
teachers and students.
Information and communication
technology has made it possible
to access knowiedge to people
in all comers of the world and all
walks of ile, Access to scientific
knowledge and research is
available in a large amount
What is very crucial is to choose
‘900d and reliable information
and credible research,
Therefore, there should be a
reliable way to determine and
select the best information and
knowledge for you, Otherwise,
there can be many problems
and confusions that will be
harmitul for the process of
leaming, | feel that the Maldives
Journal of Health Sciences
‘would be a valuable source to
bring reliable information for
student's scientific leaning
Itis also essential that
students and even teachers
always try to reach the bountiful
horizons of knowledge. The
knowledge acquired in every
‘course of study must be
refreshed and updated to keep
abreast with the fast
development and flow of
knowledge and sciences
| hope that the stuxdents at
the Faculty and all those serving
in the health sector would
greatly benefit from the Journal
also hope that our dedicated
and knowledgeable health
professionals would contribute
to enrich the Journal. #
2 Maldives Journal of Health Sciences, vol.1, issue 1, 2003,Scholarly Articles
Accountability and Responsibility: Important Attributes to Nursing
Hafeeza Ibrahim, my, an, aw
Lecturer, Faculty of Health Sciences, Male’, Republic of Maldives
Abstract Holistic nursing involves direct interventions with human beings and
renders it necessaty to incorporate ethical considerations in patient care
Thus the need for two important attributes, responsibilty and accountability to
be practiced in nursing in ofder that patients receive qualily care. The main
responsibilities of nurses are to recognize the unique nature of the care-giving
role and identify that his/her role is caring and not only curing. With the
establishment of the Maidives Nursing Council in 1999, itis hoped that nurses
in the Maldives will tind that their responsibilities and expected standards of
practice are more distinct, Some of the functions of Nursing Councils are to
‘monitor and take action for breach of responsibilities, In addition such bodies
also safe guard practice, give guidance, security and support for exercising
nurses’ rights.
Keywords responsibilily, accountability, code of ethios
Introduction
In this article, the author illuminates the
importance of accountability and responsibility in
nursing practice and highlights the significance it
has for health care in the Maldives. The iterature
review that follows explores the different views of
various nursing authors on this aspect of ethical
practice. The article concludes with a discussion
of the relevance of these views to our own context
inthe Makdives.
Responsibility and accountability are not the
same but they go hand in hand. While
responsibilty is making independent decisions,
accountabilty is being answerable to the
decisions that are made (The Concise Oxford
English Dictionary of Current English, 1990), The
nursing/caring role involves direct interventions
with human beings and this requires acting
ethically and responsibly and being answerable
all actions. Responsibily is an important element
in caring because it affects rapport and
development of trust needed in the nurse patient
‘lationship, Consequently it affects the quality of
pationt care
‘The nurse is a professional practitioner,
accountable to her patients and also to her
employer for her actions, and bearing a moral as
‘well as an organizational responsibilty for her
Practice (Wilmot, 1992), Our main conoem as
nurses is the caring relationship between the
nurse and patient. According to de Casterle,
Gastmans and Roelens (1998), this personal bond
Calls for nurses to be responsible for those in their
care, Fry (1989, cited in Warelow, 1996} suggests
that a caring relationship is not possible iit fails to
include certain prescriptive qualities such as
empathy and consideration of the welfare of
others as its foundation.
Significance of accountability and
responsibilty to nursing
Nursing is about caring and holistic nursing
involves being responsible for the well being of our
patients, Our numerous responsibilities include
iving safe and holistic care and advocating for
the patient: This includes facilitating autonomy, the
patients’ right to independent decision-making to
informed consent and above all not doing any
harm, the ethical rule of beneficence (Mitchell &
Lovat, 1993). These roles need to reflect the moral
‘and ethical values that our profession and our
‘culture are based upon. In the Maldives, the
culture and religion of the people influence the
issue of for example, informed consent. tis often
‘seen that patients do not receive adequate
information about their conditions or of
Maldives Journal of Health Sciences, vol.1, issue 1, 2003 aprocedures done on them. Itis accepted practice
for a guardian to give consent on behalf of the
patient
Direct interventions on human beings for
‘example, invasive procedures may have major
impacts on peoples’ ives and they sometimes
determine fife and death. Therefore, these actions
require ethical considerations, making all health
care workers accountable for their actions.
Consequently, nurses are faced with ethical
lemmas in their daily lives and need the support
of governing bodies such as the Maldivian Nursing
Council (MNC), A number of peak nursing bodies
‘such as the International Council for Nurses (ICN),
the United Kingdom Central Nursing Council
(UKCO) have developed Codes of Ethics that has
been used as a guide to nurses’ actions, Nurses,
‘also depend on this guide to make judgments
‘when faced with challenging situations involving
patients’ rights and nurses’ rights and
responsibiities. Similarly these governing bodies
are Important sources of support while carrying
‘out the numerous respons\blties that are required
inher role as a nurse (kistenwizon, 1390). For
instance the distinction between the nurses! role
and the doctors role in gaining informed consent,
While itis the nurses’ duty to ensure that patients
are adequately informed, itis the doctors’
responsibilty to explain the potential benetit or
harm that may result from the procedure.
From the writers view, nursing is claimed to
be a profession, which requires responsible,
independent decision-making. As nurses move
away from the medical model, to continue to
develop their own professional concepts and
further define their role, further responsibilities are
recognized. Providing holistic nursing care
requires better understanding of the pationt,
degper knowledge and insight to see the patient
{rom a holistic perspective. A patient should not be
Viewed as a case of appendicitis or asthma, but a
human being with feelings and values. He /she
may be now suffering from an illness but may
have been well before, They may have left behind,
possibly a family and given up hisfier job
temporarily only to be claimed as ‘hospital
property, Hence, the nurses! role involves more
than carrying out doctors’ orders. lis the nurse's
responsibilty to recognize the unique nature in the
ccare-giving role and identity that his/her role is.
caring and not only curing. Gone are the days
when nurses followed doctors with a basin and
towel! Nurses of the 21st century will not, hopefully
let this continue.
Nurses need motivation and enthusiasm to
promote and further develop the profession and
maintain its image of the caring role. This is
necessary for recognition, to develop standards
and improve training. in some developed
countries, nurse practitioners are filing the role
previously performed by general practitioners, in
order to do this, nurses need to further thelr
knowledge and keep up-to-date with the recent
advances in patient care and patients! rights
Literature review
According to The Concise Oxford English
Dictionary (1990) - accountable means
responsible, required to account for en's own
conduct. Responsibility is defined as the state or
fact of being responsible er authority, the ability to
‘ot independently and make decisions, According
to Pennets (14¥/, p.162) "accountability is the
requirement that each nurse is answerable and
responsible for the outcome of his or her
professional actions.”
Responsibility and accountability are seen as
a wey of life for expert nurses. However, junior or
student nurses may need advice to guide their
practice. Even expert nurses ned backing and
guidance in certain situations of moral and ethical
dilemmas and this is where the Code of Ethics,
ICN or the Code of Ethics, UKCC come in, The
ICN Code for nurses is accepted and followed
throughout the world
Ahtip:fonw.ion.chvabouticn him).
Nurses’ numerous responsibilities include
advocacy for her patients, and The UKCC views
advocacy as protection and promoting the safety
of patients. This includes patients’ rights,
‘autonomy and informed decision making (Willard,
1996). In this country, it is important to note that
the educational background of patients must be
considered while gaining consent as the patient
‘may misinterpret unfamiliar issues or terminology,
Similarly nurses’ understanding of concepts such
as advocacy need to be considered as
misunderstandings may result in unsafe or
Unethical practice. Hence, it could be argued that
Not all nurses are competent to carry oul their
4 Maldives Journal of Health Sciences, volt, ssue 1, 2003functions in a responsible manner. When a nurse
is competent in taking responsibly for the care
that the nurse gives to his/her patients, his/ner
actions can be termed as ethical endeavours (de
Casterie et al. 1998). Nurses’ responsiblity does
not end with patient care. Hissher responsibility is
also towards the profession and includes
promoting and maintaining professional standards
(Thompson et al, 1994). Therefore nurses need
knowledge and competency along with awareness
of the professional codes of practice to safeguard
their actions in what is now a multifaceted role,
Nursing Iterature suggests that the Code of Ethics
is stil the ‘corner stone’ of clinical nursing practice
(Esterhuizen, 1996), However, the code should not
be viewed as a solution to all problems, but
considered to be a guide to safe and effective
patient care.
Inthe developed world, nurses have taken on
an added responsibilty, which is prescribing even
though froma limited pharmacopoeia of
‘medicines, This calls for a greater degree of
responsibilty in decision making and
accountabiily for those decisions (Luker et al,
1998). Although this new role may be helpful to
patients and nurses in the developed wortd, it
‘could create problems for nurses in the
developing countries. Nurses’ new role in
prescribing may be viewed by doctors as
threatening to the latter's profession and may even,
wrongly believe that prescribing is beyond the
soope of nursing
‘nthe nursing literature, responsibility and
accountabilly has been discussed with
autonomous nursing practice, dilemma, morality,
ethics and codes of professional practice. In
addition, maryy authors agree that competence,
advocacy, patient's rights and patient safety
cannot be discussed without the former concepts,
(Esterhuizen, 1996, Pennels 1997, Willard, 1996 &
Romig, 1998). This suggests the necessity for
nurses to demonstrate these attributes in thelr
practice.
Responsibility is linked with freedom, as
described by Holden (1991), because real
responsibilty is connected to self-discipline and
selt-estraint. According to the above author,
possessing these two conditions are prerequisites
for treedom to choose to do otherwise, The
responsibilities of a nutse seem endless and this
ccan be daunting to junior nurses. Holden (1991)
states that nurses need effective emotional and
self management to prevent 'bum out' by having
clear understandings of limits and extents to one's
responsibilities. When discussing the nurses"
responsibilities further away from us, it is pertinent
to examine that in our own setting.
Significance to Maldivian Nurses
Nursing in the Maldives is no longer just an
honoured vocation but a profession in its own
right, Until now much of the professional
accountability rested with the moral integrity of
individuals. However, with the establishment of the
Maldives Nursing Council in1999, nurses in the
Maldives, like our international counterparts will be
supported to attain a high degree of professional
accountability, among the other attributes, to claim
that nursing is @ profession
For nurses to be accountable in a cout of law
we need good documentation of our nursing
actions, Careful recording and prompt reporting
should be routinely used, despite the distractions
while carrying out a task and lack of time avaliable
together with the many administrative chores of
nurses every day life on the wards, According to
Ehrenburg et al. (1996) the patient record is an
important too! to ensure sataty, continuity and
quality of care. Moreover, with the advancement of
technology more and more hospitals have
computerized their records. This adds to the
responsibilty of nurses to upgrade their skills in
this regard and promote the development of
nursing practice and research,
‘With the employment of international staff and
considering the different taining institutes from
which our graduates received their training, itis
imperative that standards of care are established
in ordar to ensure a higher level of care provision.
Accountability requires knowledge and
‘competency (Pennels, 1997). Thus it holds
implications for us as nurse tutors to give students
‘adequate training and for clinical staff and
supervisors to understand the liability that they
have for actions of students, According to the
same author, student nurses cannot be held
responsible for their actions until they have
successtully completed their training, However, i
needs to be pointed out that students do have a
certain degree of responsibilty and that they are
Maldives Journal of Health Sciences, vol.1, Issue 1, 2003 5answerable to their supervisors and repeated
misconduct or negligent actions will be cause for
‘action at the level of the training institute
Nurses should be learning continuously and
upgrading their knowledge and skills, Senior
nurses have a role in teaching junior nurses the
‘appropriate attitudes apart from the correct skills
and imparting accurate knowledge. Furthermore,
nurses need to educate themselves to understand
present technology, nursing research and modern
changes to practice, Nurses should be faciitated
in finding information and given access to
continuing education. It may be in the form of
procedure review meetings or case presentations.
{tis usoful to have access to the Interet and
library and thase facilities should be used more for
productive and educational purposes. itis not the
duty of every nurse to initiate research projects,
But each nurse can contribute to research by
recording accurate and clear findings on patient's
records and being generally aware of differences
in practice. For exampie, considering how one
method of treatment is different from another or
listen to patients’ concems that may contain
valuable data for recording and later researching.
While these theories are meaningful and lagicatit
is necessary to see how relevant they are to our
practioe
Application to clinical practice
With the advancement of technology, more and
more invasive procedures are being cartiad oul.
‘This requires greater accountability on the part of
health professionals. The responsibilities of nurse
educators in clinical settings and classrooms have
increased due to the growing need for
improverent in the quality of teaching and
leaming
The nature of the caring role involves nurses
being in close ‘encounters’ with patients, thereby
increasing the risk of breaching patients’ rights.
‘During such times the Code of Ethics is the
‘guiding light. Therefore, even though the actions
that can be taken by bodies like the Maldives
Nursing Council may be seen as threatening, the
‘monitoring, support and guidance offered by them
are invaluable in protecting the rights of nurses
With the increase in the number of post
‘graduate nurses in the country, there is reason to
booliove that these nurses wil initiate nursing
research in the future. Research will open up
further avenues for demonstration of responsibility
‘and accountability. In addition it will change the
image of nursing in the Maldives.
Conclusion
Inthe past, ethical considerations has
remained the integrity of individuals. However, with
the establishment of the Maldives Nursing Council
(1999) itis envisaged that the Council wil begin
exercising its rights, thereby alerting nurses and
other health care workers in relation to ethical
issues. The nursing profession and the community
at large will appreciate the benefits that the
Council has for nursing and the general publi. It
is our responsibilty as nurses to be accountable
for our actions, if we claim our profession to be
‘autonomous and inclependent to decision-
making. *
References
de Casterle,8.D., Roelens, A. & Gastmans, C. (1998) An
ajsted version of Kohlberg moral theory:
discussion ofits val for research in nursing
ethics. Jounal of Advanced Nursing. 27 (8), 829-
835
Ehvenburg, A, Ehnfors, M, & Thorel-Exstrend, |
(1996) Nursing documentation in patent records
experience of the use of the VIPS mode! Advanced
vou of Nursing, 24(4), 858-887,
Esterhuizen,P. (1996) Is the professional code stil he
Cornerstone of cirical nursing practice? Journ of
‘Advanced Nursing. 23 (1), 25-31
Holden RJ, (1991) Responsibility and autonomous
‘nursing practice. Jouma of Advanced Nursing. 16,
398-403,
btiwwerine ohlaboutton htm (27. 05 2003)
Lukes, Hogg.C., Austin, Fergusen.® & Smith K,
(1988) Decision: making: the context of nursing
prescribing, Journal of Advanced Nursing. 27 (3)
657-665,
Maldives Nursing Council (1999) (Leal) (Avalable
trom Ministy of Health Male’, Maldives).
Mitchell, K.8, & Lovat, T. (1993). Bioethics for Medical
‘and Health Professionals. N.S.W: Social Science
Press,
Pennels,C.JE, (1997) Clinical responsibly
Professional Nurse.13 (3), 162-164.
Romig.C.. (1998) Consumer protection a hot topic in
‘Washington D.C, AORN Journal. 67. (2), 485-467.
The Concise Oxtord Engylsh Dictionary of Curent English
(1990) Alen,RE, (Ed), New Delhi. india: Thomeon
Press.
‘Thompson, LE.. Malia M. & Boyed, KM. (1984)
‘Nursing Ethics. Chapter 3. {3rd ed.). New York:
CChurchil Livingstone
6 Maldives Joural of Heath Sciences, vol, issue 1, 2003,Warelow, PJ. (1996) Is caring the ethicl ideal? Joursal Wilmot S. (1992) Ethics, agency and empowerment in
of Advanced Nursing. 24 (4), 655-661 ‘nurse education, Nurse Eotication Today. 13 (3),
Willard, C. (1996) The nurses' role as patient advocate: Heise)
‘obligation or imposition? Journal of Advanced
Nursing. 24 (1), 60-66.
Maidives Journal of Health Sciences, vol.1, issue 1, 2008Observations and Comments on Standards of Nursing Practice in the
Maldives
Aminath Faiz, wv, an, aw
Dean, Faculty of Health Sciences, Mele’, Republic of Maldives
‘Abstract Standards of practice is one of the professional issues in nursing in
the Maldives. It is imperative that nursing practice is monitored and guided by
@ regulatory body. Until recently there has been no requiatory body to guide
nursing practice. In September 1999 a Maldivian Nurses Council (VNC) has
been established. One of its objectives is to establist/maintain, and improve
standards of nursing/midwitery education and practice, With the
establishment of the MNC a regulatory body now exists to ensure that nursing
practice is within a code of professional conduct. This article addresses the
issues regarding standard o practice and the impact of @ regulatory body on
nursing. A literature review will discuss regulations, code of professional
‘conduct, accountability, continuing education and nursing competence.
Keywords standard, nursing prectice, code of conduct, regulation body,
‘competengy, accountability
Introduction
Nurses comprise the largest group of health
professionals in the Maldives. They have direct.
influence on health care, health promotion and
disease prevention, Maintaining acceptable
standards of nursing practice is the responsibility
of the nurses. There is growing ooncem amongst
these professionals to improve the practice and
care rendered to patients.
A standard of practice is related to the
performance of a professional nurse. This paper
will discuss a review of literature and the existing
standards regarding nursing practice in the
Maldives. It will also address the issues pertaining
to nursing practice and the implications of the
registration body on nursing practice. As the
literature concerning nursing practice in the
Maldives is limited, personal views, experiences
and that of colleagues contribute a large part of
this article. Some readers may not agree with the
views expressed in this article.
Significance of the Topic
Standards of practice describe the responsibilities
for which nurses are accountable. It improves and
regulates the health care rendered to the
community. According to Salvage & Heijnen
(1997) a large proportion of the work of health
care professionals is detrimental and ineffective.
‘Therefore the need of a mechanism to scrutinize
What is appropriate and effective for patients is
essential
Literature Review
Some authors agree that the lack of a distinet and
generally accepted definition of the word.
‘slandard' leads to difficulties in obtaining a clear
picture of the concept (Idavall, Rooke & Hamsen,
1997). According to Thomas, Hardinge & Cutting
(1997), a standard is an agreed, measurable level
of atiainment. This could mean the minimum,
accepted level of performance required for
professional members, The Canadian Nurses
Association provides a more comprehensive
definition in which ‘standard! is viewed as
pertaining to the performance of the individual
nurse. It involves maintaining standards in
enhancing knowledge, competence and discipline
of nurses (Canadian Nurses Association 1991
cited in Leipert, 1998). Concepts of accountability
and responsibility, ethics and law, competency,
safe practice, knowledge and respect are all
associated with standards of practice, A code of
professional conduct should encompass the
8 ‘Maldives Journal of Health Sciences, voli, issue 1, 2008above. A nurse must meet a particular standard in
order to practice nursing
Most countries if not all have regulation
councils that define criteria of admission,
‘educational standards, license to practice and
cother areas of jurisdiotion. A nurse's registration
council is not new to the profession but it is new to
the Maldives. Until the establishment of the
Nursing Council, Maldivian nurses practiced under
alicense from the Ministry of Health (MOH). There
was no code of professional conduct and nurses
practiced according to the rules and regulations
formed by the employing organization, Now all
nurses are registered at the Maldives Nursing
Council
‘The establishment of the Maldives Nursing
Council is seen as an enormous advancement in
the development of the nursing profession in the
‘country. As a regulatory body the councll willbe
responsible to maintaining order, consistenoy and
standards of nursing practice. A code of
professional conduct and an ethical code of
practice for Maldivian nurses have been
developed. The council is formulated under the
parliament Act G 1/68 Official Chapter 1 within the
rights given to the Ministry of Health, and
‘approved by the office of the President (Ministry of
Health, 1999). The WHO together with the MOH
assisted in ts development through internationally
recognized nursing professionals, This initiative
has provided recognition and contributed greatly
towards the advancement of the profession in this
‘country.
The literature indicates that each regulation
council is based upon a code of professional
conduct, which outlines the status of the
registered nurse, and her or his responsibilities to
protect the interests of patients and clients
According to Pyne (1998), the United Kingdom
Central Council (UCC) s0es the Code of
Professional Conduct as a portrait. According to
the portralt, the professional nurse is described as
person who will safeguard patients’ interest and
wellbeing. The nurse is accountable and
responsible for hisfher actions, and maintains
professional knowledge and competence,
protects confidentia information of patients and
Upholds the standards of the profession. itis also
referred as a model against which the actions of
‘misconduct are judged (ibid). A code of
professional conduct seeks to satisty the
requirements of the law and provide guidalines to
registered nurses on standards of professional
‘conduct. It is thought of as a weapon that fights
{or improved standards in order to prevent harm to
patients (Pine, 1987;cited in Kenworthy, Snowly &
Giling, 1996). The regulatory systems in many
counties including the Maldives are based on the
codes of the Intemational Council of Nurses (ICN).
Accountability and autonomy are two notions
considered as pillars of the code of conduct
(Bradshaw, 1997). Each registered practitioner is
responsible and personally accountable for his or
her actions. It is no defence for practitioners to say
that they were acting on someone else's orders.
(UKCC, 1996). Nurses are faced with difficult
situations where they make decisions with the use
of professional knowledge, judgement and skils.
‘The ability to act in such a manner depends on the
‘competence of the nurse, which largely depends
‘on his/her education,
‘The UKCC expects that all those seeking
registration should demonstrate their
Competencies in order to practice as independent
practitioners who are accountable for thelr actions
(UKCC 1986, cited in Bradshaw, 1997),
Competence is expected to increase with
‘experience (Benner, 1984). Competency
standards to be achieved by registered nurses
‘have been identitied in many instances but there is
ambiguily about haw this competency is judged.
Sound professional education is a prerequisite
to safe and competent nursing practice. Studies
have shown that continuing professionel
education can bring a positive contribution to
nursing practice, to the individual and professional
development of nurses (Perry, 19985). In the
Maldives, continuing education is an opportunity
available for very few nurses. The need to keep,
nurses’ knowledge and skills up-to-date is evident
(Ministry of Health, 1998; MNO, 1999). Some
nurses are undertaking higher studies using
government funds white others are studying on
their own expenses. Many nurses practice by
reflection ftom past experiences. With the
strengthening of nursing services, more
opportunities could be available for further
continuing education,
Maldives Journal of Health Sciences, vol.1, issue 1, 2003, 9