You are on page 1of 14

Exercise 5.

1
A TURNOVER PROBLEM AT THE FT.
LAUDERDALE HERALD
SCENARIO
Ms. Adalyn Saline, the Director of Human Resources for
the Fort Lauderdale Herald, has asked us to analyze the
recruitment and selection process and make specific
recommendations.
QUESTION 1
•What are the yield ratios for each step in the recruitment and
selection process across all recruitment sources?
•What are the implications of these ratios for future hiring?
•Could you also calculate a yield ratio for a particular recruitment
source?
•Why would that be helpful?
Exhibit 5.1.1 - Data on Recruitment Sources for Customer Service
Representatives, Last 3 Years

Recruitment Total # Recruitment


Sources Applicants Qualified Interview Offered Job Accepted 6 Months Cost

Corporate Web
Site 150 12 9 8 5 3 $200

Job Board 300 20 11 9 6 2 $690

Newspaper 115 78 64 56 53 24 $465

Walk-in 31 20 14 9 7 3 $295

Employment
Agency 37 19 7 7 7 6 $250

Total 633 149 105 89 78 38 $1,900


QUESTION 2

What are the advantages and disadvantages of the various


recruiting methods used by the Fort Lauderdale Herald? Where
should they focus their recruitment efforts in the future?
Advantages
• Understanding of labor market
• Recruit individuals from various sources
• In house screening for potential clients
– Understand candidates strengths and weaknesses
– Accurate view of their skills
• Abide Equal Employment Opportunity
• Hiring to promote diverse workforce
Disadvantages
• Providing inaccurate prediction of job functions
• Facing high turn over rates among customer service reps
– Work environment is noisy and hectic
– Mandatory weekend work schedule
– Expected to sit for long periods of time with little contact
with co workers
– Receive no additional remuneration for solicitation success
Future Recruiting Efforts

• Promote positive work environment


• Reward employees based on performance levels
QUESTION 3
Recommend at least three HR
planning/recruitment/selection/retention strategies
designed to do any of the following:
a.Improve customer satisfaction
b.Increase the efficiency of the customer service function
c.Increase the tenure of the Customer Service Reps
• Do not cold call customers during dinner time
• Management overlooking the paper routes should
address complaints to supervisors
• Assigning team leaders and teams will motivate
employees do better at their jobs
• Managers should have periodic meetings with each team
leaders to address employee concerns about
contradicting information given to the customer.
• Provide on-going training programs designed to build
team effectiveness and individual motivation and
improve the customer service’s performance and
mood towards their jobs.
QUESTION 4
What are the advantages and disadvantages of the various
recruiting methods used by the Fort Lauderdale Herald?
Where should they focus their recruitment efforts in the
future?
• Less employees means more money and benefits
available to be allocated to the satisfied employees
and less employee turnover.

You might also like