Plasma Chemical Process Laboratory

Clean Technology Research Center

Antonius Indato
----------------------------------------------------

Prof. Dr. H. Frank

J. of Toxicological and Environmental Chemistry

University of Bayreuth
D-95440 Bayreuth, Germany
Fax: +49-921-552334
E-mail: toxenchem@uni-bayreuth.de

Re: 2021rev3_AA_Indarto_060705

Dear Sir,

We received your mail which has date: August 24, 2005 and we thank
for your great attention on our manuscript. Actually, yes, that we
want to continue the submission process of our manuscript. With your
’guideline’, we tried to improve and ’clean-up’ our manuscript. We
hope, the revised manuscript will be in better format compared to the
previous one.

Regarding the next process of our manuscript, we are welcoming for

the information on it. Question on this manuscript and for quickening
the process, please let me know by sending email to:
indarto_antonius@yahoo.com.

On behalf of team member, once more thank from us to you.

Best regards,

Antonius Indarto
 Some explanations on Editor questions

1. We added some additional information related to the specification

of instruments that we use. Especially name of the country or
region. Also, in the GC specification, we added information of
length and i.d. of the packed column.

2. To avoid the ambiguous of the meaning, we changed the

sentences (page 7) to explain that in the higher concentration,
although DRE is lower, the molecule collision is more effective that
at lower concentration. It is calculated by multiplying the
converted chloroform concentration x flow rate x initial
concentration.

3. In case of 50% of remaining carbon, we can only propose that it

can be converted into solid (soot) or liquid products. In this
experiment, the exact calculated carbon is just coming from CO
and CO2 which is around 50%. Other 15% can be from CCl4.

4. Some other information have been added also including picture

(figure).

Thank you very much for your attention. We are respect so much on
your help on our manuscript.