Timur Abimanyu,SH.MH Will ..!

Cabinet reshuffle Volume II Brings Change In Indonesia Government Wheels And Poor People Will Enjoy Change! Only time will tell ....

Jakarta - the cabinet reshuffle, especially the addition of the deputy minister has been criticized quite crowded and the most widely debated of people everywhere in the two-three days. Many people are happy, if a designated colleague, but more and more people are disappointed because it is not called. Therefore, the criticism appears more than recognition or praise to this policy. Just to talk, it's good if once in a while we try to see things from a background of government policy considerations that may be used. The first question, why the vice president appointed many ministers? Does he not know that many officials will cause a lot of expenditure? The answer of course is impossible. The following question, who is appointed as deputy minister? Generally speaking, that most of them are the younger generation who have recognized expertise. All of them have the potential to grow in the future. If so, what is the consideration or the background of this appointment ?

Apart from any political perspective, I do not have a bad notion to say that SBY is creating the concept of seniority. That is a habit that occurs in an authoritarian leader, to put distance between the leader of the first layer of seniority with the leader of the second layer. This assumption is refuted, first, SBY is not an authoritarian. Second, because SBY is not possible to extend his presidency for more than two periods. If the placement of the deputy ministers is composed of young people who are experts, we can expect that within five years we will have people experienced specialists. They certainly will be projected into the senior ministers are complete. Having the ability of science and experience. The question is, how many people among them who would be saved from the temptations of corruption which is still much attached to several ministries? It is up to their personal integrity of each that will be tested in the field.

Placement of the deputy ministers from among the technocrats, while the ministers most of the politicians give the instructions, that SBY intends to integrate the two forces on self dipuncak two leaders of a ministry. What I mean here is a mix of politicians and technocracy. Viewed from the perspective of leadership in development, there are some terms can be used to categorize the capabilities of each individual of the leading figures in their respective fields. First, the politicians. Although in daily practice the term is often the scorn of politicians, but in a positive sense, is meant by the politicians here are those that are capable of accommodating the aspirations of the people and process them into the surface as well as policies that pro-people. As an example of such politicians who are freedom fighters, both partisan and non partisan. They talk and fight on behalf of and for the people. They are ready to sacrifice anything for the interests of the people. Not vice versa, speaking on behalf of the people for the purpose of personal gain. Second, among the technocrats. They further suggested as an expert in a certain field of science. At the beginning of the New Order era, technocrats are usually interpreted as economic experts or graduates of American development experts. Namely people like Prof. DR. Widjojo Nitisastro, Prof. DR. Ali Ward, Prof.. DR. Emil Salim, Prof. DR. Sumarlin and others. In the United States, the technocrats in general is sometimes referred to as 'the U.S. Trained and educated people'. As a result, many people consider these technocrats as American stooges. In the implementation of development, among technocrats in general act as a handyman-skilled or skilled-worker, where policy and kebertanggungjawabannya to the people (accountability) in the hands of the leader. At the beginning of the Reformation era, the role of technocrats was taken over by those who are referred to as a technologist. Namely, the technocrats in the field of engineering or technology. Third, teknopol politicians or technocrats. Ie, the technocrats who not only worked as a handyman, but also capable and accepted by the community as a leader and is therefore accountable to the people. They are among others in the early period of independence can be mentioned as Mohd. Hatta, Sumitro Djojohadikusumo, Syafruddin Prawiranegara and others. Capacity as the technocrats and the politicians assembled in one person. Perhaps this Teknopol was originally drawn from the political parties, nonparty circles, the professors and others. They have the expertise and well rooted in the community. Therefore they are always able to bring the voice of the people and fight for the interests of the people. In the end, there are two remaining questions set associated with this cabinet resafel that still needs to be questioned: Is the appointment of deputy ministers from among the experts and ministers from among politicians, Mr Yudhoyono wanted to create teknopol, namely the ability of technocracy and politicians in two separate individuals ? How to reconcile or mengsinergikan these forces are, if each just to see the advantages yourself, rather than complement each other ? Data Sources: Zainal Abidin Said If the Cabinet reshuffle Volume II The second result does not carry berubahan for the people and nation of Indonesia, it will result in dissatisfaction tibul People and the Nation of Indonesia. The survey results Networks Voice Indonesia (JSI), which shows a trend decline in the level of public satisfaction with governance Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono during the last two years. Where "The level of satisfaction with the performance of the government of SBY have fallen, but it's still within the limits of not worrying," said Democratic Wasekjen Saan Mustofa in Jakarta, Sunday, October 23, 2011. Based on the survey JSI, the rate of satisfaction with the government of SBY-

Boediono in January 2010 by 70 percent, in October 2010 by 62 percent, and in October 2011 was 53.2 percent live. Public discontent against the government, because of public expectations of government performance is so high at the beginning of a new government is formed. "Sometimes expectations exceed reality is obtained. JSI survey says, the government of SBY and Boediono still can not get out of the economic and legal issues. Achievement of the government in two areas, the community still considered bad. The largest portion of public dissatisfaction in the legal sector is in cases of corruption. In connection with the reshuffle to II in Volume II, who declared Fadel; Not Objective Democrats said SBY has considered the ethical factor in doing reshuffle. In connection with the issue Deputy Secretary General of the Democratic Party, which declared SBY has considered various factors to remove Fadel Muhammad from the post of Minister of Marine and Fisheries to consider the ethical aspects of politics, which he said the president prerogative. If the reason for dismissal reshuffled and to raise the performance of the saw and follow the perintahan wheel is running, because during this time many argue that the State of Indonesia perintahan wheels did not move, seen from the cases of corruption, poverty and education and many more issues that are not possible on the street in Volume II of this government policy. =================== Ilustration By Timur Abimanyu, SH.MH.

little people's lives and education expect only a dream, and whether the reforms bring about change and to provide benefits for them .... it's all just illusions and mirages ... a dream ...

Cabinet reshuffle by the addition of the deputy minister would interfere with the performance of the fore wheels of government would arise where conflicting policies. Many questions will arise: Why many vice presidents appointed minister ? Does he not know that many officials will cause a lot of expenditure? The answer of course is impossible. Who is appointed as deputy minister ? Generally speaking, that most of them are the younger generation who have recognized expertise. All of them have the potential to grow in the future. Is the appointment of deputy ministers from among the experts and ministers from among politicians, Mr Yudhoyono wanted to create teknopol, namely the ability of technocracy and politicians in two separate individuals ? How to reconcile or mengsinergikan these forces are, if each just to see the advantages yourself, rather than complement each other ? If so, what is the consideration or the background of this appointment ?

According to my opinion and analysis of these questions: 1. Analysis of the question No. 1 is to increase state spending on facilities that will be issued by the state for the deputy minister, such as housing, cars and other facilities. 2. Analysis of question No. 2 is in general to the scientists they are young but outwardly aged over 45 years, if this can be referred to the younger generation! 3. Analysis No question. 3 is not among the political and technological means knowing the bureaucracy in the cabinet could have been they did not know at all, because all this is truly an expert in his field is frofesional among the real experts in their field. 4. Analysis No question. 4 is where the two forces are already under way since the days of the old order, and it is embedded for a long time and has been rooted, and it is very difficult to do the synergy of two camps and consequently to improve performance will not be achieved. 5. Analysis No question. 4 is a political element that is already visible for-for the seat as well as to protect the party members in trouble with the law, if any political element still has the power to regulate the cabinet, I personally really do not believe that this reshuffle will smooth the wheels of government that has not had power to bring change ketaraf run a better life in accordance with the mandate of the 1945 Constitution. Final conclusion that from the perspective of leadership in development, there are some terms can be used to categorize the capabilities of each individual of the leading figures in their respective fields. First, the politicians. Although in daily practice the term is often the scorn of politicians, but in a positive sense, is meant by the politicians here are those that are capable of accommodating the aspirations of the people and process them into the surface as well as policies that pro-people. The SBY government should not have to do a reshuffle, and long enough to sustain cabinet minister in trouble with the law is replaced with a more professional and honest and moral, with the Demand to the cabinet / ministers to make the program in a systematic, targeted and accountable with sanctions if it can not improve the performance and welfare of the people and nation of Indonesia, it will be replaced with someone more professional. source of data : Http://www.yahoo.com http://www.googlecom http://www.detik.com http://www.Viva.news