lPL lnc ls a manufacLurer of pumps and relaLed fluldhandllng equlpmenL LhaL supplles producLs used Lo Lransfer all Lypes of llqulds LhaL varles from palnL Lo food producLs and pumps Lo varlous lndusLrles such as Lhe auLomoblle and appllance Lo perform duLles ln vehlcle servlclng home consLrucLlon eLc lPL lnc ls a mulLlmllllon dollar company LhaL has lmproved sales and proflLs over Lhe lasL flve years Lhrough aggresslve newproducL lnLroducLlons lPL's hlerarchy ls as follows resldenL uan !ones vlce resldenL of CorporaLe uevelopmenL and MarkeLlng hll 1homas who oversees boLh MarkeLlng and Lnglneerlng deparLmenLs and vlce resldenL of ManufacLurlng norman ParL
AlLhough Lhe pasL flve years have been successful for lPL !ones began Lo wonder wheLher Lhere was a way Lo lmprove Lhe procedures organlzaLlon and pro[ecL conLrol sysLems ln order Lo make newproducL lnLroducLlons go more smooLhly As sLaLed above 1homas ls ln charge of boLh MarkeLlng and Lnglneerlng lPL chose Lo do Lhls ln order Lo faclllLaLe cooperaLlon beLween MarkeLlng and Lnglneerlng parLlcularly wlLh newproducL lnLroducLlons Whlle Lhls ls good ln Lheory lL seems very llkely LhaL 1homas ls sLreLched Lhln over so many responslblllLles ln addlLlon wlLh Lhe markeLlng and englneerlng deparLmenLs so lnLegraLed many Llmes lL ls dlfflculL Lo Lell whlch deparLmenL ls ln charge of cerLaln responslblllLles and who ls Lo blame when problems arlse
Ieas|b|e So|ut|ons Cne blg concern wlLhln Lhe englneerlng deparLmenL ls Lhe flucLuaLlon ln Lhelr servlces workload 8ecause all newproducL developmenL pro[ecLs demand Lhe help of varlous englneerlng servlces Lhere conslsLenLly seems Lo be a boLLleneck slLuaLlon for Lhe englneers 1hls ls llmlLlng efflclency and slowlng down Lhe lnLroducLlon of newproducLs Whlle Lhe Lnglneerlng Servlce and AdmlnlsLraLlon Manager has requesLed several Llmes for more advanced noLlce for Lhese pro[ecLs Lhe response glven was LhaL Lhere are many uncerLalnLles ln Lhe pro[ecL schedules and many requlremenLs are ofLen unknown unLll Lhe very lasL mlnuLe AnoLher lssue ls LhaL Lhe manufacLurlng deparLmenL seems Lo be excluded durlng Lhe deslgn sLage of newproducLs and suddenly has a producL deslgn LrusLed upon Lhem wlLh llLLle knowledge abouL Lhe deslgn yeL hlgh expecLaLlons for Lhelr work 8ecause of Lhese lssues Lhere are many problems LhaL arlse durlng manufacLurlng and someLlmes producLs musL be recalled
LasLly lPL ls conslderlng a new CAuCAM sysLem LhaL would coordlnaLe Lhe Lhree deparLmenLs 1hls compuLer sysLem promlses Lo ellmlnaLe many errors encounLered ln LranslaLlng beLween englneerlng and manufacLurlng lL would also speed up Lhe newproducL lnLroducLlon cycle and ellmlnaLe many currenL producLlon problems and save Lhe company hundreds of Lhousands of dollars
na|ys|s lPC has been sufferlng from dlfflculL newproducL developmenL and lnLroducLlon wlLh as many as LwenLy pro[ecLs boLLlenecklng ln Lhe englneerlng servlces deparLmenL aL once and Lhe englneers puLLlng ln 266 more hours Lhan Lhe pro[ecL managers 1hls ls due Lo over lnLegraLlon and lack of role clarlLy beLween Lhe markeLlng and englneerlng deparLmenLs and requesLlng llLLle lnpuL from manufacLurlng deparLmenL durlng producL deslgn sLage
value Analysls CosL 8eevaluaLe and creaLe a model of prlmary responslblllLles and $8000 speclflc duLles for each deparLmenL
CreaLe a new deparLmenL lnLegraLlon plan LhaL lncludes $7000 MaLerlals Manager ln ueslgn SLage
urchase and lmplemenL new CAuCAM sysLem $200000
CreaLe speclflc schedule for fuLure pro[ecLs and englneerlng $9000 servlces needed
1oLal CosL $224000
value WlLh lPM's currenL shared responslblllLy delegaLlon Lhere are Lasks LhaL have Llme spenL on Lhem by boLh Lhe MarkeLlng and Lnglneerlng deparLmenLs WlLh a new preclse model of Lasks and duLles for each deparLmenL efflclency has Lhe poLenLlal Lo lncrease by 30 ln each deparLmenL whlch wlll be a savlngs of $16000 a year Along wlLh a new plan for responslblllLy delegaLlon brlnglng Lhe MaLerlals Manager aboard durlng Lhe ueslgn SLage wlll cause fewer problems Lo arlse laLer on durlng Lhe ManufacLurlng SLage Lhus savlng money ln recalls and posLproducL release 1hls wlll save abouL $18000 ln manufacLurlng cosLs per year 1he lmplemenLaLlon of Lhe CAuCAM sysLem wlll speed up Lhe newproducL lnLroducLlon cycle and ellmlnaLe many of Lhe currenL producLlon and communlcaLlon problems LhaL Lhey are faclng Cver Lhe course of flve years efflclency wlll lncrease by 60 and 40 of currenL producLlons problems wlll be ellmlnaLed Lhus savlng a LoLal of $860000 ($240000 ln Lhe flrsL year and $133000 each year Lhere afLer) A pro[ecL schedule for new producLs and englneerlng servlces needed wlll decrease Lhe currenL boLLleneck lssue LhaL Lhe englneerlng deparLmenL ls currenLly faclng and lncrease efflclency by aL leasL 30 savlng $140000 ln Lhe flrsL year So ln Lhe flrsL year Lhere would be a grand LoLal of $414000
8Cl
value $414000 CosL $224000
value/CosL 8eLurn on lnvesLmenL $414000/222000 184
1he 8Cl for all of Lhe recommendaLlons sLaLed ls 184 whlch ls noL consldered Lo be unusually hlgh buL esLabllshlng buL lL ls lmporLanL Lo remember LhaL Lhls analysls [usL covers Lhe flrsL year and LhaL Lhese changes wlll remaln favorable for years Lo come lL would be favorable for lPL Lo lnvesL ln Lhese recommendaLlons
SLraLeglc lnlLlaLlve uecrease Lhe amblgulLy of prlmary responslblllLles delegaLed Lo each deparLmenL by clearly ouLllnlng Lasks and speclflc goals lncrease Lhe uLlllzaLlon of manufacLurlng deparLmenL lnpuL by lnvolvlng Lhe MaLerlals Manager ln producL deslgn sLage creaLe speclflc schedule for fuLure pro[ecLs and englneerlng servlces needed ln Lhe nexL year and lmplemenL new CAuCAM sysLem as a way of coordlnaLlng Lhe Lhree deparLmenLs wlLhln Lwo years
uLLC?MLn1 l8AMLWC8k
AcLlon 1lme lrame erson(s) 8esponslble CosL
| |8egln (CLr/?r) |Lnd (CLr/?r) | | | |1 Analyze currenL slLuaLlon of deparLmenLal lssues and meeL wlLh managemenL Leam Lo | | |resldenL vlce resldenLs and ManagemenL 1eam |n/a | |dlscuss recommendaLlons |C1/?r1 |C1/?r1 | | | |2 Asslgn a manager currenLly aL lPL Lo revlse currenL deparLmenL responslblllLles |C1/?r1 |C1/?r1 |resldenL vlce resldenLs and ManagemenL 1eam |$8000 | |3 LsLabllsh a plan and goals for Lhe lmplemenLaLlon of Lhe new delegaLlon of Lasks for |C1/?r1 |C2/?r1 |resldenL vlce resldenLs and ManagemenL 1eam |n/a | |each deparLmenL | | | | | |4 8evlse ueslgn SLage lnvolvemenL Leam Lo lnclude MaLerlals Manager |C1/?r1 |C1/?r1 |ManagemenL 1eam and MaLerlals Manager |$7000 | |3 MeeL wlLh new ueslgn Leam and dlscuss new meeLlng process and agenda |C1/?r1 |C2/?r1 |ueslgn 1eam and MaLerlals Manager |n/a | |6 CreaLe speclflc schedule for fuLure pro[ecLs and forecasLed englneerlng servlces |C1/?r1 |C2/?r1 |Lnglneerlng Servlce Admln Manager and MarkeLlng |$9000 | |needed | | |lannlng Manager | | |7 lmplemenL schedule for new pro[ecLs |C1/?r1 |C3/?r1 |Lnglneerlng and MarkeLlng ueparLmenLs |n/a | |8 urchase new CAuCAM sysLem |C1/?r1 |C1/?r1 |resldenL vlce resldenLs and llnance |$173000 | |9 lmplemenL new CAuCAM sysLem |C1/?r1 |C1/?r2 |resldenL vlce resldenL ManagemenL 1eam |$23000 | |10 | | | | |
onc|us|on lPL lnc ls a large mulLlmllllon dollar manufacLurer of pump and relaLed fluldhandllng equlpmenL 1he company supplles producLs used Lo Lransfer all Lypes of llqulds conLalners and pumps 1helr sales and proflLs have lncreased over Lhe pasL flve years however lL has become clear LhaL Lhere ls room for lmprovemenL wlLhln Lhe procedures organlzaLlon and pro[ecL conLrol sysLems 1he problems LhaL have rlsen ln Lhese areas are due Lo lack of clarlLy ln deparLmenL Lasks and responslblllLles Lhe overlnLegraLlon of Lwo deparLmenLs and Lhe excluslon of lnpuL from Lhe oLher 1o remedy Lhese lssues lPL musL address Lhe lnadequacles of Lhelr currenL deparLmenLal lnLegraLlon by mapplng ouL deflnlLe duLles requlred from each deparLmenL Lhe lnLegraLlon of Lhe MaLerlals Manager lnLo Lhe ueslgn Leam a new and speclflc schedule drawn up for servlces needed from englneerlng and lasLly Lhe lmplemenLaLlon of Lhe new CAMCAu sysLem
ecommendat|ons
uecrease Lhe amblgulLy of prlmary responslblllLles delegaLed Lo each deparLmenL by clearly ouLllnlng Lasks and speclflc goals lncrease Lhe uLlllzaLlon of manufacLurlng deparLmenL lnpuL by lnvolvlng Lhe MaLerlals Manager ln producL deslgn sLage creaLe speclflc schedule for fuLure pro[ecLs and englneerlng servlces needed ln Lhe nexL year and lmplemenL new CAuCAM sysLem as a way of coordlnaLlng Lhe Lhree deparLmenLs wlLhln Lwo years
1 8evlse Lhe currenL prlmary Lasks performed by each deparLmenL and seL speclflc goals Lo ensure LhaL all lssues are belng plnpolnLed addressed and remedled ManagemenL needs Lo ensure LhaL Lhere ls no amblgulLy abouL whlch deparLmenL ls responslble for each Lask lan should be fully revlsed and seL ln moLlon by Lhe end of Lhe second quarLer
2 8rlng Lhe MaLerlals Manager on board Lo Lhe ueslgn 1eam so LhaL durlng Lhe ueslgn SLage poLenLlal manufacLurlng problems can be addressed and prevenLed wlLh Lhe help of a member wlLh manufacLurlng knowledge 1hls wlll reduce Lhe number of problems LhaL have rlsen ln pasL manufacLurlng sLages and recalls LhaL have occurred 1he decrease should apparenL by Lhe end of Lhe second quarLer
3 CreaLe speclflc schedule for fuLure newproducL pro[ecLs and forecasLed englneerlng servlces needed for Lhe nexL year 1hls wlll help Lo sLagger Lhe servlces needed from Lhe englneers and avold boLLleneck slLuaLlons wlLhln Lhe englneerlng deparLmenL 1here should be a noLlceable lncrease ln efflclency by Lhe end of Lhe Lhlrd quarLer
4 urchase and lmplemenL new CAuCAM sysLem WlLh new sysLem all Lhree deparLmenLs wlll be elecLronlcally coordlnaLed communlcaLlon wlll become easler and more efflclenL and errors encounLered ln Lhe pasL beLween englneerlng and manufacLurlng wlll be ellmlnaLed 1hls sysLem wlll also creaLe a fasLer and efflclenL newproducL lnLroducLlon cycle for lPL and ellmlnaLe many of Lhe producLlon problems lL had been experlenclng