The Royal Australian
and New Zealand
College of
Obstetricians and
Gynaecologists
6 October 2008 ABN 34 100 368 969
Excellence in Women’s Health
Collage House
254 — 260 Albert Steet
Fast Malbourne Vie 3002 Australia
Telephone: +61 3 9417 1699)
Focsimile: + 61 3 9419 .0672
E-mail: ronzcog@ranzcog.edv.cy
Dear RANZCOG Fellows and members
We are writing to you about the review of Maternity Services that has been commissioned by the
Federal Government. The document ‘Improving Maternity Services in Australia - a discussion
paper from the Australian Government’ is available on the Department's website:
itp www health. gov.awmatemityservicesreview. This has the potential to be one of the most
important issues to affect RANZCOG Fellows and members since the Medical Indemnity crisis, It
is important that the Fellowship is aware of the issues surrounding this review and the College's
response to it
When the Rudd Labor Government was clected in late 2007, they indicated that there would be
changes in the way health care was delivered in Australia. They had foreshadowed Maternity
Services reform with a possible increase in midwife led care.
The Federal Health Minister, the Hon Nicola Roxon MP, released the discussion paper entitled:
‘Improving Matemity Services in Australia’ in September 2008. Submissions to this enquiry have
been requested and close on 31 October 2008. The document identifies inequalities in maternity
care, particularly in rural and Indigenous women and looks at ways to address that. It raises
concems about Australia’s high rate of obstetric intervention and asks a number of questions about
Workforce and infrastructure. Ways of improving workforce support in rural and urban settings are
flagged to be explored.
Importantly for the College Fellowship, it is looking at ways to expand midwife led care across
antenatal, birthing and postnatal services and it is clear that the Minister is firmly of the view that
change should occur.
It also identifies key problems in postnatal care particularly with poor breastfeeding rates and
identification and treatment of postnatal depression.
Given that RANZCOG is a combined College, the RANZCOG Council has been acutely aware of
the problems that have arisen in New Zealand following the introduction of midwife led care.
Some of the problems our New Zealand colleagues have experienced have been:
* very poor or no perinatal data collection with virtually no consistent audit of the radical
changes made to New Zealand Maternity Services;
ancarly complete loss of GP obstetricians;
a great reduction in the availability of gynaecological services in rural areas;
a number of health enquiries being commissioned to investigate poor outcomes; and
@ quarantined maternal mortality report which reportedly shows a doubling in matemal
mortality since the introduction of midwife led care.Clearly the College is opposed to the introduction of a New Zealand type system for Australian
‘Matemity Care. Since release of the discussion paper, the RANZCOG Executive has met by
teleconference to formulate a response to the discussion paper. This response will be sent to you in
the next week for your comment,
is in Canberra to further the aims of
In the next three weeks, there will be six round table discus
the discussion paper. The topics for these are:
* Effective Data Collection, Monitoring, Reporting and Research,
Assessing and Managing High Risk Pregnancy,
Workforce Standards, Quality and Interprofessional Collaboration,
Altemate and Midwife Led Models of Care,
Indigenous Perspectives, and
Peer and Social Support in the Perinatal Period,
RANZCOG will have representatives at each of these forums and the Executive has carefully
considered our position for each.
The Executive Committees of RANZCOG and NASOG have had discussions, to try to ensure
that obstetricians have a united voice in opposing changes to maternity care that may have a
negative impact on outcomes.
The Executive and Council of RANZCOG welcomes your feedback on any aspect of this
Matemity Services review and request your support in our efforts to maintain safe and effective
systems of Maternity Care in Australia, Because of the tight timeframes dictated by the
Government, your comments need to reach us by Friday 17 October 2008 via e-mail
president@ranzcog.edu.au or ranzeog@ranzcog.edu.au .
‘Yours sincerely
Lae Th WWE
Dr Christine Tippett Dr Ted Weaver
President President Elect