Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Sotomayor Identity

    Uploaded by

    Tikvah
    595 views2 pages
    Peggy orchowski: no one really knows who exactly is a Latino, an Hispanic, a member of "la raza" or even a Chicano. She says the media has gone wild with the mantra "the first Hispanic justice" but it's complicated as the multicultural, diverse people of Latin america, she says. Orchowska: the problem with u.s. Identity politics is that it fits a political agenda, not a reality.

    Original Description:

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    Peggy orchowski: no one really knows who exactly is a Latino, an Hispanic, a member of "la raza" or even a Chicano. She says the media has gone wild with the mantra "the first Hispanic justice" but it's complicated as the multicultural, diverse people of Latin america, she says. Orchowska: the problem with u.s. Identity politics is that it fits a political agenda, not a reality.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    595 views2 pages

    Sotomayor Identity

    Uploaded by

    Tikvah
    Peggy orchowski: no one really knows who exactly is a Latino, an Hispanic, a member of "la raza" or even a Chicano. She says the media has gone wild with the mantra "the first Hispanic justice" but it's complicated as the multicultural, diverse people of Latin america, she says. Orchowska: the problem with u.s. Identity politics is that it fits a political agenda, not a reality.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 2

    adn.com | Hispanic identity has no easy definition http://www.adn.com/opinion/compass/v-printer/story/829350.

    html

    Hispanic identity has no easy definition


    COMPASS: Other points of view
    By PEGGY ORCHOWSKI
    (06/12/09 22:44:22)

    After living in Latin America and covering Latinos for years as a journalist, one thing is clear. No one
    really knows who exactly is a Latino, an Hispanic, a member of "La Raza" or even a Chicano. But ever
    since President Obama nominated Sonia Sotomayor as a Supreme Court justice, the media has gone
    wild with the mantra "the first Hispanic justice." Oh, really?

    Benjamin Cordoza was a Supreme Court justice in 1932. His name, Cordoza, is a familiar Spanish,
    Hispanic, Latino, Chicano name. By the U.S. Census definition today, he was Hispanic.

    But it's complicated -- as complicated as the multicultural, diverse people who are citizens of the
    countries of Latin America and the Caribbean today. You see, Benjamin Cordoza was Jewish. Does that
    make him not Latino? Born in New York City (as was Sotomayor), his family came from the Iberian
    Peninsula. His ancestors fled the Inquisition there and may have been Portuguese. Does that disqualify
    him as a Hispanic? Some say Portuguese are not Latinos.

    Spaniards are not considered by Latino advocates to be Latinos; Italians are not either. Activists usually
    define Latinos as those who come from Central and South America. Sotomayor's family is from Puerto
    Rico and some say that Caribbeans are not Latino. In addition, neither Cardoza or Sotomayor were
    immigrants -- Puerto Ricans are U.S. citizens and don't need immigration visas. Are they still
    considered to be Hispanic or Latino in the political sense?

    This is the problem with U.S. identity politics. Ethnic identity is used to fit a political agenda, not a
    reality.

    Central and South Americans don't bother with the nomenclature "Latino" or "Hispanic." In the
    democracies of Latin America there have been presidents not only with Spanish, Portuguese and
    indigenous heritage, but also with English last names (Fox), Arab (Menem) and Asian (Fujimori).

    During World War II, South America was extremely open to Jewish immigrants -- far more than the
    U.S.A. Millions of Jewish refugees from Europe and the Middle East settled and thrived there;
    generations of their children are now fully integrated South American citizens.

    "It's time for Latinos to make their top priority integration into the American mainstream," writes Frank
    Cisneros in his book "Latinos and the Future of the Nation." The key to such integration is dominating
    English and completing a high school and college education. Dozens of organizations such as Excelencia
    for Education are dedicated to helping youths of Latino heritage achieve this success. Sotomayor is a
    role model.

    The U.S. is enriched by the multiple national heritages of our citizens. Like most New World countries,
    the U.S. is a nation of immigrants. But our success is largely due to integrating these mixed heritages.

    Some Mexican advocacy groups who recognize the importance of integration call themselves "American
    Mexicans." That's a good idea. But it's too complicated for most. I for one am a proud quadra-lingual
    American/Californian with a Colonial/Tory/New England/Texas/English/Austrian/Dutch/Protestant
    /Catholic/Jewish/Mormon heritage. Many so-called Latinos have similarly mixed heritages that frame
    our world views. The only identity that makes sense is "American."

    1 of 2 6/18/2009 3:14 PM
    adn.com | Hispanic identity has no easy definition http://www.adn.com/opinion/compass/v-printer/story/829350.html

    Peggy Orchowski is the congressional correspondent for Hispanic Outlook magazine and author of
    "Immigration and the American Dream: Battling the Political Hype and Hysteria."

    Copyright © Thu Jun 18 2009 15:14:24 GMT-0400 (Eastern Daylight Time)1900 The Anchorage Daily News (www.adn.com)

    2 of 2 6/18/2009 3:14 PM

    You might also like