You are on page 1of 14

BHEL REPLY DATED 25/04/2013 RPCL/STEAG COMMENTS ON 11kV SCHMATIC DRAWING REV 02

Sl. No:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24

Drawing No.
35210078623-Sht 02

RPCL/Steag Comments
Noted & incorporated. Noted & incorporated.

BHEL Reply

Correct the CT Neutral formation in the GRP differential relay connections. Correct the CT Neutral formation in the GRP 35210078623-Sht 03 REF relay connections. Clarify the P1 philosophy 35210078623-Sht 04 Output contacts does not match with the typical functions in relay catalogue. Interlocks to other panels to be taken care of 35210078623-Sht 07 in respective drawings. Breaker in test,service,local,remote to ddcmis 35210078623-Sht 08 35210078623-Sht 04 35210078623-Sht 14

P1 is always on the breaker side irrespective of power flow direction. Noted & incorporated. Noted & incorporated. Noted & incorporated.

Correct the I/O list in all schemes to be revised. Noted & incorporated.

35210078624-Sht 08 86X contactor in incomer & Tie Feeder Noted & incorporated. 35210078624A-Sht 01 Wherever MCBs are given to be replaced with Noted & incorporated. 35210078625-Sht 01 fuse. 35210078626-Sht 01 35210078627-Sht 01 35210078628-Sht 01 35210078629-Sht 01 35210078630-Sht 01 35210078631-Sht 01 35210078632-Sht 01 35210078633-Sht 01 35210078634-Sht 01 35210078635-Sht 09 35210078636-Sht 09 35210078637-Sht 09 35210078637A-Sht 09 35210078638-Sht 10 Rename 27/27N/2M as 27/27N/2 35210078640-Sht 10 Legend to be revised for 75SA & TA

reply to be given for output contact rating

BHEL REPLY TO RPCL/STEAG COMMENTS ON 11kV SCHMATIC DRAWING Rev 00

Sl. No:
1

Drawing No.

RPCL/Steag Comments

BHEL Reply

2 3 4

Schematic drawing shall be confirmed to logic Drawing revised in line with revised 11kv diagram of 11Kv switchgear & shall be Logic diagram. Reference drawing no. of SLD 35210078623-Sht 01 mentioned in the drawing & Logic shall be incorporated in revised/as manufactured drawings Furnish legend details Legend of devices submitted. 35210078623-Sht 01 As per MOM Dtd 16-17th Nov'2012 pt 13 35210078623-Sht 01 BOM shall be furnishede 3 weeks before inspection. Panel number mentioned here is not matched Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. 35210078623-Sht 01 with SLD The closing & tripping logic shall be hardwired Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. control from ECP & DDCMIS seperately. 35210078623-Sht 01 Remote closing /tripping shall be wired as agreed in MOM dtd 4-6th june 2012. Furnish CT & PT details in this drawing also for Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. 35210078623-Sht 01 easy reference. Furnish Numerical Relay connection diagram Relay catalogue soft copy shall be sent by for SEL 751A & 2505 indicating P.S , I/O Ports , 15.02.2013. CT/PT connections & communication ports. Furnish BOM

35210078623-Sht 01

8 9

Furnish VCB breaker contact development 35210078623-Sht 01 diagram indicating 94, 52a/b,33SC contact configuration. Furnish OGA of VCB & details of FEB & BEB 35210078623-Sht 01

Shall be incorporated in revised/as manufactured drawings. OGA of VCB & FEB/BEB Scheme submitted.

Indicate reference drawings 10 35210078623-Sht 01

Shall be incorporated in revised drawings.

11

Since the relay manufacturer is not indicated in Shall be furnished as agreed. the keydiagram, calculations for the burden & 35210078623-Sht 02 knee point voltage shall be provided. 35210078623-Sht 02 Note: Shorting links are to be removed when CTs are connected in GRP circuit. R ,Y B Phase shall be shown Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. It may please be noted that Bus PT voltage is not required in IF scheme, as it requires only line voltage, which is provided by Line PT signals as shown in the scheme.Earlier it was shown inadvertently & hence it has been removed. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. MFTD is Multifunction Transducer which provides analog signals which can measure active, reactive power & energy at ECP. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment.

12

13

35210078623-Sht 04

14

35210078623-Sht 04

2-50 LBB function shall be indicated Indicate what are the parameters shown at MFTD output.Furnish details of MFTD.

15

35210078623-Sht 05

16

35210078623-Sht 05

Digital multi function meter

17 18 19

Watt transducer indicated in SLD to be shown Multifunction transducer provided instead of watt transducer which provides watt output 35210078623-Sht 05 alongwith other analog signals. 35210078623-Sht 05 Current y phase shall be indicated. DC supply supervision 35210078623-Sht 06 To be indicated in revised drawings. 80D aux Contactor used for DC supply supervision.Description will be indicated in revised drawings.

240VAC shall be derived from 415/240 VAC aux. transformer of adequate rating so as to have fault isolation on sec side. 20 35210078623-Sht 06

It may be noted that the 415V AC supply is being fed from AC distribution SWBD. In case of any short circuit, fuses at the AC distribution SWBD shall be blown protecting the bus.Also as the supply is taken from 1 phase & neutral alternately it will prevent the unbalance of current in a single phase. This future interlock is provided for any interlock to be used in future at later stage.

What is future interlock for FEB & BEB 21 35210078623-Sht 07

22 23 24 25 26

35210078623-Sht 07 35210078623-Sht 07 35210078623-Sht 07

Furnish FEB/BEB Scheme Furnish the logic for this where it is derived

Scheme submitted Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Planned Logic is derived in numerical relay & the same has been furnished. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. LBB function is part of the numerical relay as mentioned in SLD. If required numerical relay contacts can be programmed. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Shall be incorporated in revised/as manufactured drawings.

86 not operated shall be taken for test closing circuit Furnish the details of planned logic where it is 35210078623-Sht 08 derived 50LBB function of relay shall be indiacted. 35210078623-Sht 09 LBB aux relay shall be provided for contact multiplication & use.

27

35210078623-Sht 09

28 29 30

35210078623-Sht 11 35210078623-Sht 11 35210078623-Sht 12

Breaker in Service indication shall be Amber Provide indicating lamp for closing circuit healthy indication 52a/b contacts not shown in sheet 07.

31 32 33

Indicate service description of all the contacts Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. shown Closing circuit unhealthy to DDCMIS Drawing will be revised to incorporate the 35210078623-Sht 12 comment. Breaker spring charged to DDCMIS Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. 35210078623-Sht 12 35210078623-Sht 12 Feeder/ Bus earthed contacts to DDCMIS. 75FET contacts are given to upstream breaker circuit for tripping the upstream breaker during Feeder earthing. However, it is not possible to provide feeder/Bus earthed contacts to DDCMIS as no electrical interlocks can be provided for the same. Drawing will be revised to incorporate the comment. Shall be incorporated in revised drawings. Time delayed no voltage protection feature is present in the numerical relay provided. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. No meters on ECP.Ammeter & Multifunction transducer provided Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment.

34

35210078623-Sht 12

35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43

LBB opearted contacts for alarm/ DCS & spare , 35210078623-Sht 13 to wire to Bus under voltage master trip relay & for tie breaker Trip Indicate what are the indications provided on 35210078623-Sht 14 relay front As per SLD time delayed no voltage protection 35210078626-Sht 03 shall be provided. 35210078626-Sht 05 Indicate the parameters displayed in MFM

Ammeter & watt meter transducer shall be 35210078626-Sht 05 provided to monitor the parameters at ECP Panel number mentioned here is not matched with SLD Also refer comments marked in IF type 1 from 35210078627-Sht 01 unit incomer Also refer comments marked in IF type 1 from 35210078628-Sht 01 unit incomer Also refer comments marked in IF type 1 from 35210078629-Sht 01 unit incomer 35210078627-Sht 01

44 45 46

35210078629-Sht 01 35210078629-Sht 01 35210078630-Sht 01

Panel number mentioned here is not matched Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. with SLD Indicate services of OG Feeder Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Comments same as on 629 Relay should be communicated to DDCMIS Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. All numerical relays will be connected through RS 485 port to the DDCMIS.Drawing will be revised to incorporate the comment. Function 50G will be shown in drawing Already shown in drawing as TDI. Shall be incorporated in revised drawings. Shall be incorporated in revised drawings. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. Function 50G will be shown in drawing Ammeter transducer already provided in Y phase. Technical manual to be sent by 15th feb 2013.

47

35210078630-Sht 02

48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59

Relay should cover sensitive earth fault 35210078630-Sht 03 protection by using CBCT as input 35210078630-Sht 04 Ammeter & transducer to be provided Indicate services Indicate logic diagram reference 35210078631,32,33,34Panel number mentioned here is not matched Sht 01 with SLD Also refer comments marked in IF type 1 from unit incomer Relay should have sensitive earth fault 35210078632,33-Sht 02 protection Current to be displayed at ECP, necessary 35210078633-Sht 03 transducer to be provided. Provide technical manual 35210078634-Sht 02 35210078634-Sht 03 Ammeter transducer to be provided

Ammeter transducer already provided in Y phase. Panel number mentioned here is not matched Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. with SLD Also refer comments marked in IF type 1 from Drawing revised to incorporate the comment. 35210078635,36,37,38unit incomer Sht 01

35210078635,36,37,38Sht 01 60

As per SLD time delayed no voltage protection Time delayed no voltage protection feature is shall be provided. present in the numerical relay provided.

RPCL

STEAG

BHEL

RPCL/Steag Comments
Noted

RPCL/Steag will review & furnish comments, if any. Noted

Noted Discussed on Rev 01 drawings.

Noted BHEL to include the numerical relay diagram in the respective schemes indicating all its contacts & ports. BHEL agreed to incorporate the same. Same shall be indicated in the revised drawings.BHEL agreed. RPCL/Steag will review & furnish comments/approval.

Same shall be indicated in the revised drawings.BHEL agreed. Not yet furnished.BHEL to furnish the same.

Noted Noted

Noted Noted

Noted Noted

Noted Noted

Noted

RPCL/Steag requested BHEL to furnish the write up on interlock & functioning of FEB & BEB. BHEL has agreed to furnish the same. RPCL/Steag will review & furnish comments/approval. RPCL/Steag will review & furnish comments, if any. Noted RPCL/Steag will review & furnish comments, if any. Noted. Noted.

Noted. Noted. Noted.

Noted. Noted. Noted.

Noted

Noted Same to be indicated in the drawing Noted Noted

Noted Same as in Drg No: 35210078623 Same as in Drg No: 35210078623 Same as in Drg No: 35210078623

Noted Noted Noted Noted

Noted Noted Noted Noted Noted Noted Noted Noted Not recieved. BHEL furnished soft copy. Noted RPCL/Steag will review & furnish comments/approval. RPCL/Steag will review & furnish comments/approval.

RPCL/Steag will review & furnish comments/approval.