Drawing on the right Side of the brain (1979, 1989, 1999) was written by Dr. Betty Edwards. Modern research disputes many of the right / left hemispheric theories presented before 1995. Studies show that both brain hemispheres interact in complex ways during activities such as drawing.
Drawing on the right Side of the brain (1979, 1989, 1999) was written by Dr. Betty Edwards. Modern research disputes many of the right / left hemispheric theories presented before 1995. Studies show that both brain hemispheres interact in complex ways during activities such as drawing.
Drawing on the right Side of the brain (1979, 1989, 1999) was written by Dr. Betty Edwards. Modern research disputes many of the right / left hemispheric theories presented before 1995. Studies show that both brain hemispheres interact in complex ways during activities such as drawing.
The four sections of this tutorial discuss the functionality
of different parts of the brain and the art of creativity with
uncomplicated terminology and illustrations: Busting Brain Myths Comparing Right and Left Hemispheres Functions of the Four Lobes Exploring the Art of Creativity Busting Brain Myths One of the most innovative and popular drawing books of all time, Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain (1979, 1989, 1999), was written by Dr. Betty Edwards. The books theories, techniques, and exercises for teaching students how to draw have greatly inuenced pop cultures perception of the Right/ Left brain dichotomy. To some extent, Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain was based on what was ground-breaking research during the 1960s and 1970s. Today, modern research disputes many of the Right/Left hemispheric theories presented before 1995. Over the last two decades, functional similarities and differences between the two hemispheres of the brain have been extensively researched and studies show that both brain hemispheres interact in complex ways during activities such as drawing. ISBN: 978-1-927539-37-8 Copyright 2013 Drawspace Publishing and Brenda Hoddinott. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transferred, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, digital, mechanical, recording, photographing, photocopying, or otherwise, without the purchase of a licence from drawspace.com or the prior written consent of Brenda Hoddinott and Drawspace Publishing. Drawing on Both Sides of Your Brain An introduction to how your brain works with a focus on hemispheric functionality and creativity Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level: 13.7 Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease: 36.1 Drawspace Curriculum 2.2.R2 - 8 Pages and 11 Illustrations ArtSpeak Creativity: The ability to create unique, original, and functional ideas beyond the familiar or established. Neural: Relative to, or located in a nerve or the nervous system. Lateral: A strong neural response on either the left or right brain hemisphere. Bilateral: Neural responses on both left and right brain hemispheres. Interhemispheric: Pertaining to both hemispheres of the brain (right and left.) Neuroscience: The scientic study of the human bodys nervous system. 2 Drawspace Curriculum 2.2.R2 ISBN: 978-1-927539-37-8 Copyright 2013 Drawspace Publishing and Brenda Hoddinott. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transferred, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, digital, mechanical, recording, photographing, photocopying, or otherwise, without the purchase of a licence from drawspace.com or the prior written consent of Brenda Hoddinott and Drawspace Publishing. Neural responses in both the left and right hemisphere have been noted during virtually every task associated with drawing from the initial conception of an idea through to the execution of the nal work. In addition, both hemispheres are active during the early stages of the most important aspect of drawing: visual processing. This bilateral processing produces a far more accurate exchange of visual information than either the left or right hemisphere alone. In fact, almost all brain functions are bilateral to some degree. Even lateral functions often involve some neural activity on the opposite side of the brain. Comparing Right and Left Hemispheres Each hemisphere of your brain interacts primarily with one half of your body. If the human body were logically designed, the right hemisphere would control the right side of the body and vice versa. However, the wires somehow got crossedliterally! In fact, the right hemisphere of the brain interacts with the left side of the body, and vice versa. For the most part, the functionality of the left and right sides of the brain is symmetrical. For instance, the section of the left hemisphere that controls the right hand is located in the same section of the right hemisphere that controls the left hand. As an Aside During the 1960s and 1970s, Dr. Roger Wolcott Sperry studied epileptics who had already had their right and left brain hemispheres surgically disconnected to treat their seizures. Based on his studies of these specic patients, Dr. Sperry applied the following broad conclusion to the human brain in general: The two disconnected hemispheres function independently and in effect have each a separate mind of its own. Each of the separated hemispheres appears to have its own private sensations, perceptions, thoughts, feelings, memories. Each hemisphere has its own inner visual world, each cut off from the conscious awareness of the other. ArtSpeak Ambidextrous: Demonstrating the ability to use both the left and right hand equally well to perform such tasks as writing, drawing, or playing sports. Asymmetry: An imbalance or lack of equivalence (symmetry) between parts of a whole. Cognition: The process by which the brain recognizes and understands information. Cortex: The folded brain matter that makes up the outer layer of the cerebrum and plays a critical role in consciousness. Divergent thinking: A thought process that explores various possible scenarios to generate creative concepts. Localized: Associated with a specic area of the brain. Visual-object intelligence: Ones ability to process the visual properties of an object, such as texture, shape and color. Visual-spatial intelligence: Ones ability to process the ways in which objects are spatially oriented and relative to one another in space. ISBN: 978-1-927539-37-8 Copyright 2013 Drawspace Publishing and Brenda Hoddinott. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transferred, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, digital, mechanical, recording, photographing, photocopying, or otherwise, without the purchase of a licence from drawspace.com or the prior written consent of Brenda Hoddinott and Drawspace Publishing. 3 Drawspace Curriculum 2.2.R2 A major exception to this theory of functional symmetry is specic to language and spatial cognition. Studies of stroke victims indicate that damage to the left hemisphere impairs their ability to speak or comprehend language (Aphasia), whereas damage to the right hemisphere causes very little impairment to these abilities. Right Hemisphere Strengths Studies indicate that the right hemisphere (Figure 1) is more active than the left during the following: solving problems intuitively generating stories using memory for navigation looking at images of faces shifting the gaze to the left processing stimuli that evoke fear and pessimism maintaining alertness and vigilance processing pain Left Hemisphere Strengths Studies indicate that the left hemisphere (Figure 2) is more active than the right during the following: reading and writing in English shifting the gaze to the right experiencing pleasure processing motivation Bilateral Functions The right and left hemispheres (Figure 3) are considered equally active during the following: identifying categories of objects looking at objects and living beings such as buildings and human faces and bodies using landmarks for navigation Figure 1 Figure 2 Figure 3 Temporal lobes (Figure 5) are located on the sides of the cerebral cortex and contribute to perception, memory, and the ability to decipher auditory stimuli (hearing). 4 Drawspace Curriculum 2.2.R2 ISBN: 978-1-927539-37-8 Copyright 2013 Drawspace Publishing and Brenda Hoddinott. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transferred, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, digital, mechanical, recording, photographing, photocopying, or otherwise, without the purchase of a licence from drawspace.com or the prior written consent of Brenda Hoddinott and Drawspace Publishing. Functions of the Four Lobes The Frontal lobe (Figure 4) is located at the front of the brain (duh!). This lobe is the most active section of the cerebral cortex during creative endeavors, and contributes to several functions including reasoning, planning, parts of speech and movement, emotions, and problem-solving. ArtSpeak Frontal lobe: One of the brains four main lobes, located in front of the central sulcus. It is associated with such functions as motor cortex (parts of movement and speech), reasoning, emotions, planning, and problem- solving. Temporal lobe: One of the brains four main lobes, located below the lateral ssure. It processes memory and hearing. Occipital lobe: One of the brains four main lobes, located at the back of the brain behind the temporal and parietal lobes. It processes various aspects of vision. Parietal lobe: One of the brains four main lobes, located behind the central sulcus. It processes such stimuli as pain, pressure, touch, and temperature. As an Aside Both right-handers and left-handers are among the greatest artists ever known. For example, Pablo Picasso was a righty and Leonardo da Vinci a lefty. As an Aside Realistic drawings rendered by ambidextrous artists tend to be more detailed and accurate when the artists use their left hand. In theory, the left hand has a more direct access to the perception processes localized in the right hemisphere. Figure 4 Figure 5 Figure 7 As an Aside Research by Bhattacharya and Petsche (2002, 2005) measured and compared electrical activity in the brains of artists and non-artists. The results indicated that even when the artists were not actively performing a creative task, there was greater activity in their right hemisphere than in their left. These results were signicantly less pronounced in non-artists. ISBN: 978-1-927539-37-8 Copyright 2013 Drawspace Publishing and Brenda Hoddinott. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transferred, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, digital, mechanical, recording, photographing, photocopying, or otherwise, without the purchase of a licence from drawspace.com or the prior written consent of Brenda Hoddinott and Drawspace Publishing. 5 Drawspace Curriculum 2.2.R2 As an Aside Interaction between the Temporal and Frontal lobes dubbed the fronto-temporal network (Figure 6) is critical for regulating creative expression. Decits in the Temporal lobe can increase the type of frenzied creativity sometimes observed in manic states. Decits in the Frontal lobe can inhibit creativity. When theyre both functioning normally and working well together, they can inspire original artistic concepts and creations. The Parietal lobe (Figure 7) is positioned behind the frontal lobe and above the Occipital lobe and contributes to your perception of stimuli such as touch, pressure, temperature and pain. The 21st century has ushered in a renewed interest in the mysterious phenomenon known as creativity. Even denitions of creativity still vary amongst experts on the subject. Most of these experts do agree, however, that a creative entity exhibits both originality and usefulness. When it comes to drawing, its clear that originality can make a drawing more creative. Usefulness, on the other hand, is more subjective. Illustrations or drawings created for educational purposes are considered useful. However, the process of drawing in itself must also be considered useful particularly as it helps artists gain new skills and enhance brain functions. Figure 6 6 Drawspace Curriculum 2.2.R2 ISBN: 978-1-927539-37-8 Copyright 2013 Drawspace Publishing and Brenda Hoddinott. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transferred, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, digital, mechanical, recording, photographing, photocopying, or otherwise, without the purchase of a licence from drawspace.com or the prior written consent of Brenda Hoddinott and Drawspace Publishing. Both sides of the Parietal lobe are active when drawing (Figure 8). ArtSpeak Electroencephalography (EEG): an electrical brain recording that measures voltage uctuations within the neurons of the brain. EEG recordings are sometimes used to study creative processing in the brain. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI): a scan that measures blood ow and neural activity in the brain. fMRI scans are the second most common tool used to study creativity in the brain, next to EEG recordings. As an Aside When artists are engaged in creative thinking, the medial prefrontal cortex and the brains sensory regions are more active than other areas of the brain. Therefore, this area is often considered the creative hub of the brain. The right hemisphere of the Parietal lobe (Figure 9) contributes to various creative functions involved with imagery and visualization. Its left hemisphere (Figure 10) is more involved with mathematics, reading, writing, and understanding symbols. As an Aside In the 2011 paper, Lateral thinkers are not so laterally minded: Hemispheric asymmetry, interaction, and creativity, AK Lindell describes creativity as a tool which has helped humans adapt and survive. The paper cites studies which suggest that creative people are actually healthier and more attractive to others. Lindell writes, Given that creativity is closely linked to general intelligence which is, in turn, linked to overall genetic quality, creativity can be seen as a signal of genetic viability (Haselton & Miller, 2006), presumably contributing to the greater mating success noted in creative individuals. As such, creativity is an important component of optimal human functioning (Bloom, 2001), enhancing problem solving, adaptability, and self-expression (Runco, 2004). The hallmark of creativity is divergent thinking: the generation of multiple novel solutions to a given problem. Figure 8 Figure 9 Figure 10 Exploring the Art of Creativity Humans tend to measure their uniqueness in the animal kingdom by their abilities to communicate using language and to create within the arts and sciences. While creativity is still considered a bit of a mystery, current research does agree that creativity requires strong cooperation and communication between both brain hemispheres. While the right hemisphere tends to show more activity than the left in creative processing, creativity depends on the exchange of information between both right and left hemispheres. ISBN: 978-1-927539-37-8 Copyright 2013 Drawspace Publishing and Brenda Hoddinott. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transferred, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, digital, mechanical, recording, photographing, photocopying, or otherwise, without the purchase of a licence from drawspace.com or the prior written consent of Brenda Hoddinott and Drawspace Publishing. 7 Drawspace Curriculum 2.2.R2 As an Aside Modern science has provided researchers with innovative tools to study creativity. For example: during the creative process, an artists brain can be examined with an Electroencephalography (EEG) recording to capture electrical activity in the brains cortex. A functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) scan can also be used to record changes in the brains blood ow while a person is engaged in creative pursuits. In her 2008 paper, Both Sides Now: Visualizing and Drawing with the Right and Left Hemispheres of the Brain, University of Southern Maine professor, Dr. Irene Schiferl cites neuroscience research conducted since 1995 using fMRI, PET and EEG scans which indicates that visual processing requires cooperation from both hemispheres. The Occipital lobe (Figure 11), located at the back of the brain behind the Parietal lobe and Temporal lobe, processes many aspects of vision. Even though the four lobes dont have precise boundaries, research suggests that each plays a specic role in the process of creating and appreciating art. For example, when you examine an artwork, the Parietal lobe may process the spatial layout, the Temporal lobe may give names to the subjects, and the Occipital lobe may process contrast, form, and other critical elements of vision. The Frontal lobe, in addition to being involved in the business of the other three lobes, may also determine how long you look at the work before turning away. As an Aside In a survey of 69 patients, Miller, Boone, Cummings, Read, and Mishkin (2000) compared cerebral blood ow in patients with and without enhanced creativity following the onset of an illness. Their ndings suggest that decits of the left temporal lobe lead to an increase in right hemisphere activity and subsequent enhanced visual creativity. Figure 11 8 Drawspace Curriculum 2.2.R2 ISBN: 978-1-927539-37-8 Copyright 2013 Drawspace Publishing and Brenda Hoddinott. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transferred, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, digital, mechanical, recording, photographing, photocopying, or otherwise, without the purchase of a licence from drawspace.com or the prior written consent of Brenda Hoddinott and Drawspace Publishing. As an Aside All creative individuals encounter times when new ideas are hard to nd. The old adage, My muse has left me often echoes in their studios. According to the ancient Greeks, creativity was the result of the actions and interventions of one of their nine muses. Philosophers and theorists, from Plato to Popper also considered creativity to originate with a mystic, instead of the cognition of the artist. In fact, even the most strongly lateralized processes, such as language articulation, involve some activation and integration of processes across both sides of the brain. Todays research implies that artistic training, such as learning to draw, enhances creative abilities. The long-held assumption that artistic abilities are strictly genetic is now giving way to the theory that both nature and nurture contribute to creativity. Such ndings also suggest that creative training such as learning to draw or paint enhances communication between the two brain hemispheres. Creativity is unique to each person. Your mind is inseparably linked to your ve senses, which help you gather information about your environment. Creative thoughts during the process of rendering art are connected to your own interpretation of your environment. As an Aside Right or left handedness often affects the directionality of an artists subjects, especially when they are drawing from their imaginations: Right-handers tend to draw subjects, such as faces in prole, facing the left and left-handers tend to draw them facing the right. Right-handers usually render subjects in motion, such as a horse or car, travelling toward the left whereas left-handers are more prone to draw them moving toward the right. As an Aside Studies indicate that left-handed individuals have greater cooperation between their right and left brain hemispheres. Hence, left-handers are more likely to engage in creative professions, score higher on creative thinking tests, and display a greater capacity for divergent thinking than right-handers.