Seminar

Menieres disease
Hamed Sajjadi, Michael M Paparella
Lancet 2008; 372: 40614 Department of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Stanford University Medical Center, San Jose, CA, USA (H Sajjadi MD); and Department of Otolaryngology Head Neck Surgery, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA (Prof M M Paparella MD) Correspondence to: Dr Hamed Sajjadi, Department of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Stanford University Medical Center, 2577 Samaritan Drive Ste 845, San Jose, CA 95124, USA otology@hotmail.com

Menieres disease is a chronic illness that aects a substantial number of patients every year worldwide. The disease is characterised by intermittent episodes of vertigo lasting from minutes to hours, with uctuating sensorineural hearing loss, tinnitus, and aural pressure. Although there is currently no cure, more than 85% of patients with Menieres disease are helped by either changes in lifestyle and medical treatment, or minimally invasive surgical procedures such as intratympanic steroid therapy, intratympanic gentamicin therapy, and endolymphatic sac surgery. Vestibular neurectomy has a very high rate of vertigo control and is available for patients with good hearing who have failed all other treatments. Labyrinthectomy is undertaken as a last resort and is best reserved for patients with unilateral disease and deafness.

Introduction
Prosper Mnire rst described this disease in 1861.1 His main contribution to its diagnosis was a description of the disease entity with episodic vertigo and ringing in the ears; he challenged general terminology at the time that named this disease apoplectic cerebral congestion, implying a disorder of the brain. Mnire described these episodes of vertigo and uctuating hearing loss as being associated with the peripheral end organ of the inner ear rather than with the brain. He and other investigators2,3 called it glaucoma of the inner ear. In 1927, Guild4 identied the endolymphatic sac as the site of outow of endolymph in his study of guineapigs. This study was a major insight into the mechanics of endolymphatic ow in the inner ear. Later that same year, Portmann3 described his rst endolymphatic sac surgery for the Menieres disease complex. Endolymphatic sac surgery has remained the main non-destructive form of surgical treatment for Menieres disease since the early 1900s. 1 year after Portmanns description of sac surgery, Dandy5 proceeded with vestibular neurectomy, trying to isolate the vestibular system from the brain and thus cure patients of vertigo. In 1943, Altmann and Fowler6 concluded that problems in production and absorption of endolymph can lead to Menieres disease. In a landmark study in 1967, Kimura7 investigated the rst animal model with guineapigs and showed that blockage of the endolymphatic sac and duct causes obstruction of endolymphatic outow, leading to hydrops of the inner ear.

Head and Neck Surgery (AAO-HNS) established a specic set of criteria for the diagnosis of Menieres disease (panel).9 Few articles have been published on the epidemiology of Menieres disease. In 1973, Stahle and colleagues reported a prevalence of 46 cases per 100 000 population.10 From 1975 to 1990, several studies from Japan, which were undertaken for a Research Committee on Menieres Disease and a Committee on Peripheral Vestibular Disorders, indicated a fairly constant prevalence of 17 cases per 100 000 population.11,12 Kotimaki and colleagues13 analysed the Finnish population of 5 million people between 1992 and 1996 with the AAO-HNS recommendations. They reported a prevalence of 43 per 100 000 and an average yearly incidence of 43 per 100 000 population.13 Most studies suggest a slight female preponderance of up to 13-times that of men.9 The disease seems to be much more common in adults in their fourth and fth decade than in younger people, although it has been noted in children;14 Meyerho and colleagues15 noted a 3% prevalence of paediatric Menieres disease. A strong positive family history exists in patients with Menieres disease; several studies have indicated that up to 20% of family members have similar symptoms.14,1618 Menieres disease also seems to aect more white people of northern European descent than it does the African and black races.19,20
Search strategy and selection criteria

Epidemiology
Menieres disease remains a dicult disease to diagnose, especially in the early stages when not all its symptoms might be present. Consequently, the incidence and prevalence of the disease in any population is dicult to ascertain.8 Frequently, patients with Menieres disease present to the emergency department with sudden onset of vertigo and are inaccurately diagnosed as having labyrinthitis and discharged home.8 In early stages, Menieres disease might present with only cochlear symptoms such as hearing loss and pressure or fullness in the ear without true vertigo or even ringing in the ears. In 1995, the American Academy of Otolaryngology
406

We searched Medline, ENT Rez, Pubmed, and the Cochrane Library for publications in the past 10 years, with the terms Menieres disease and Endolymphatic sac, Gentamicin middle ear perfusion, and Steroid middle ear perfusion. We largely used materials published within the past 5 years but did not exclude older publications that were commonly referenced and highly regarded. We also searched the reference lists of articles identied by this search strategy and selected those that we judged relevant. Several review articles or book chapters were included because they provide comprehensive overviews that are beyond the scope of this Seminar. Only references published in English were included.

www.thelancet.com Vol 372 August 2, 2008

Seminar

Panel: The American Academy of OtolaryngologyHead and Neck Surgery criteria for diagnosis of Menieres disease (1995) 1 Recurrent spontaneous and episodic vertigo. A denitive spell of vertigo lasting at least 20 min, often prostrating, accompanied by disequilibrium that can last several days; usually nausea or vomiting, or both; no loss of consciousness. Horizontal rotatory nystagmus is always present 2 Hearing loss (not necessarily uctuating) 3 Either aural fullness or tinnitus, or both Certain Menieres disease Denite disease with histopathological conrmation Denite Menieres disease Two or more denitive episodes of vertigo with hearing loss, plus tinnitus, aural fullness, or both Probable Menieres disease Only one denitive episode of vertigo and the other symptoms and signs Possible Menieres disease Denitive vertigo with no associated hearing loss or hearing loss with non-denitive disequilibrium

A study reviewing ve generations of the same family from Sweden showed a very strong familial trend for Menieres disease.10 Nine of 25 family members showed some problems of the inner ear, six of whom satised the AAO-HNS criteria for diagnosis of Menieres disease. Morrison21 studied 41 families in which at least one member had the disorder. Those ndings suggested a 60% penetrance in an autosomal dominant pattern in families with the disease, with strong anticipation, meaning that an earlier age of onset and more severe symptoms are detected in each successive generation with the disease. Histocompatibility antigens (HLA) have been intensively studied by several investigators.22 Arweiler and colleagues23 investigated 48 patients and detected a 90% prevalence of HLA-A2 in patients with a family history, and a 75% prevalence in those without a family history. These investigators propose a multifactorial aetiology for Menieres disease, combined with a genetic predisposition caused by mutations of the short arm of chromosome 6. Furthermore, Paparella16 detected a 20% incidence of positive family history in patients with Menieres disease in a review of 500 patients.

Pathophysiology
Menieres disease is characterised by intermittent episodes of vertigo lasting from minutes to hours, with uctuating sensorineural hearing loss, tinnitus, and aural pressure.24 It has been classied into typical Menieres disease, with all the cochlear and vestibular
www.thelancet.com Vol 372 August 2, 2008

symptoms, and atypical Menieres disease, with either cochlear symptoms (eg, hearing loss, tinnitus, aural pressure) or vestibular symptoms (eg, vertigo alone with aural pressure but no hearing loss or tinnitus).25 The primary histopathological correlate is endolymphatic hydrops. Paparella used the notion of lake-river-pond to explain the occurrence of malabsorption of endolymph leading to hydrops.26 This notion describes the endolymphatic sac as a pond, with the vestibular aqueduct (the river) connecting it to the endolymphatic uid space that is like a lake. When there is an obstruction near the endolymphatic sac or duct, a backlog of endolymphatic uid is created, leading to hydrops. Histological studies have suggested that endolymph is primarily produced in the stria vascularis, and some production also occurs in the planum semilunatum and dark vestibular cells.27 Endolymph is then absorbed in the endolymphatic duct and sac through an active transport mechanism. Longitudinal ow proceeds slowly, and radial ow rapidly, into the endolymphatic sac.27 Gibson and Arenberg28 suggested that because of obstruction of the endolymphatic sac, hormones such as saccin might be produced to increase production of endolymph to overcome the obstruction. Furthermore, the sac might also produce glycoproteins that osmotically attract endolymph towards it. As a result of overow of endolymph behind the obstruction, the obstruction might be relieved and the sudden outow across the sac could lead to vertigo. Kimura and colleagues29 devised an animal study showing that obliteration of the ductus reuniens causes cochlear hydrops. Many histological features have been seen in patients with Menieres disease by use of temporal-bone studies. These studies include ndings of perisaccular brosis,30 atrophy of the sac and loss of epithelial integrity,27 hypoplasia of the vestibular aqueduct,31 and narrowing of the lumen of the endolymphatic duct.32 We have shown that the sigmoid sinus is signicantly anteriorly and medially displaced in patients with Menieres disease compared with healthy controls.33 Our study suggested that the forwardly located lateral sinus can cause vascular compression of the endolymphatic sac leading to obstruction and hydrops, which would be a genetic predisposition of an anatomical abnormality. Revisional surgery on the endolymphatic sac has shown that surgical removal of perisaccular brosis can allow patients who had initially good results with an endolymphatic sac enhancement (ESE) to improve and reduce their symptoms.34,35 Revision of ESE surgery has contributed signicantly to our knowledge of the pathophysiology of this disease. Revisional ESE is undertaken for patients who have beneted from the primary endolymphatic surgery for at least 1 year postoperatively, and then have recurrence of their symptoms. Several investigators have noted substantial pathological ndings during repeat surgery, once ESE has been done.3436 These ndings have included
407

Seminar

a hypoplastic mastoid air-cell system with perisaccular brosis, discolouration of the silastic sheathing inserted in the primary procedure, and granulation tissue lling the mastoid and the perisaccular space, which all create compression leading to saccular obstruction. Complete decompression of the sigmoid sinus and the mastoid cavity is the most important surgical contribution to correction of the symptoms of Menieres disease.

Diagnosis
The clinical picture of Menieres disease includes uctuating sensorineural hearing loss accompanied by aural pressure, tinnitus, and episodic vertigo. The hallmark of the disease is its uctuation, waxing, and waning of symptoms. Typical Menieres disease includes all symptoms; the episodic vertigo lasts from several minutes to hours, with positional vertigo in between and during attacks. Furthermore, almost all patients note a sense of pressure or fullness in the ear and various forms of tinnitus. Most patients develop unilateral symptoms, and a large proportion might develop bilateral disease many years after the onset of the unilateral symptoms. Several studies have reported the rate of bilateral Menieres disease to be as high as 50% after many years of the initial diagnosis.37 The AAO-HNS subcommittee on Hearing and Equilibrium and Its Measurements has proposed various consensual statements to reach a denition of Menieres disease (panel).25 Menieres disease remains a clinical diagnosis; a detailed history and a complete physical examination are necessary for a diagnosis to be made. Once the history and physical examination have been completed, the essential tests needed to guide clinicians to make the diagnosis include a full audiometric assessment and possibly video nystagmography or electonystagmographic testing with bithermal caloric evaluation. Electrocochleography is an optional test to augment the diagnosis of Menieres disease. In all unilateral cases, MRI of the brain with views of the internal auditory canal with and without contrast is needed to rule out retrocochlear pathological disorders that can present with sensorineural hearing loss, tinnitus, and vertigo. CT-scanning of temporal bone is of little value in diagnosis of Menieres disease. Standard lateral mastoid radiographs could be obtained to aid diagnosis by documenting the forward location of the sigmoid sinus, which is seen in almost all patients with this disease.37 Most patients with Menieres disease present with an up-sloping low-frequency sensorineural hearing loss that, with time and after many uctuations, could lead to a at sensorineural hearing loss. In very few patients, a slight conductive component to the hearing loss might also be noted initially.36 This conductive loss is dicult to explain, but has led to incorrect diagnoses of Eustachian tubal dysfunction in patients with early presentation of Menieres disease. Serial audiograms are very helpful in
408

diagnosis, by documenting uctuation of sensorineural hearing loss. Paparella and several investigators38,39 have recorded a so-called peak pattern of audiographical ndings with sensorineural hearing loss of low frequencies, with better hearing at 2000 Hz and worse hearing at frequencies greater than 2000 Hz. The most important nding in vestibular testing of patients for Menieres disease is the unilateral vestibular hypofunction seen on bithermal caloric testing.40 However, up to 50% of patients with Menieres disease might still have completely normal nystagmography and bithermal caloric assessments, even with incapacitating vertigo.41 In patients who are unable to undergo MRI because of installation of a pacemaker or other reasons, auditory brainstem response audiometry can provide a less accurate alternative to rule out retrocochlear pathological disorders.41 Patients who present with incapacitating vertigo, sensorineural hearing loss, and all the symptoms suggestive of Menieres disease should still undergo routine haematological tests to rule out more common causes of vertigo and ill feeling. These tests include a complete blood count to rule out anaemia, leukaemia, and other disorders, as well as a sedimentation rate to check for any occult inammatory processes. Tests of the thyroid functions; cholesterol, lipids, and triglycerides; a fasting blood glucose; and haemoglobin A1C are suggested to rule out diabetes and other lipid and cholesterol abnormalities. All patients should have a uorescent Treponema antibody-absorption test for syphilis. These tests are helpful to assess the general health of patients presenting with such incapacitating symptoms, and to avoid missing other medical problems that are correctable.42 Migraine-associated dizziness is a fairly new diagnosis that has several clinical similarities to Menieres disease, especially to the vestibular Menieres variant. 43 A detailed history of headaches with and without concomitant dizziness is very important for dierentiation between these illnesses. Patients with migraines frequently have an aura with their headaches, as well as nausea, photophobia, phonophobia, and visual scintillating scotoma. Patients with migraine-associated dizziness usually have normal hearing or symmetrical, incidental, non-uctuating hearing loss.44 Aural pressure, which is a hallmark of patients with Menieres disease, is mostly absent in those with migraines. Previously, many patients with migraine-associated dizziness might have been inadvertently diagnosed as having Menieres disease, thus aecting results of treatment outcome. Migraine associated dizziness should be recognised and dierentiated from Menieres disease early in the clinical work-up phase.

Medical and surgical management

Several medical and surgical remedies have been oered to patients with Menieres disease over the past 150 years. The plethora of medical and surgical therapies
www.thelancet.com Vol 372 August 2, 2008

Seminar

Diagnosis conrmed All patients Low salt diet, avoidance of caeine, chocolate, alcohol, tobacco products 36 month trial Diuretics Treatment failure Meniett device Treatment failure Endolymphatic sac enhancement surgery Treatment failure Gentamicin perfusion Treatment failure Vesticular neurectomy Treatment failure Labyrinthectomy Acute attacks Oral, intramuscular, or intratympanic steroids

patients with Menieres disease after starting immunotherapy for allergies.47 Patients with symptoms of Menieres disease react adversely to consumption of large quantities of caeine, chocolate, alcohol, and salt. However, the actual mechanism and pathophysiology of this adverse reaction is unknown. Some patients might actually have an allergy to some of these items. Therefore, food allergies should be investigated in patients with Menieres disease and should be treated and avoided as much as possible. All patients with Menieres disease are encouraged to reduce their salt intake to a maximum of 2 g per day, and to 15 g per day if tolerated. They are also asked to avoid all sources of caeinated products, to reduce their intake of chocolate, and to avoid all tobacco and alcoholic products as much as possible. As early as 1934, Furstenberg showed the relation between sodium retention and Menieres disease, and recommended a substantial reduction in intake of sodium.48 Several other investigators have also reported this relation and shown the ecacy of diuretics for reduction of these symptoms.49,50

Figure: Treatment algorithm for Menieres disease

Diuretics
Recent studies have suggested no relation between use of diuretics and Menieres disease; however, we believe that most of the time diuretics are a fairly safe option and are oered to all patients.51 Once diuretics are used, a repeat blood test should be done a week later to ensure that the concentration of potassium in the blood has not decreased; even though potassium-sparing diuretics are frequently used, there is always a slight chance of loss of potassium because of diuretic use. The most commonly used diuretic is a combination of hydrochlorothiazide and triamterene. Patients who are allergic to sulpha could use acetazolamide or chlorthalidone.42,52

signies that no one eective treatment is available for these patients. However, most will be helped by a combination of medical therapy, psychological counselling and reassurance, and lifestyle and dietary changes. The cure for this disease is yet to be discovered; it could lie in genetic re-engineering that might need a functioning labyrinth for an eective outcome. Therefore, destructive procedures that might preclude implementation of a possible cure for patients in the future should be avoided. For us to continue to be conservative by preserving the structures of the inner ear both chemically and physically and working at alleviation of the patients symptoms without destroying these structures, as much as possible, would be prudent. The medical and surgical options available to treat patients with Menieres disease should be oered according to the severity of the patients symptoms and failure to respond to appropriate therapy. The following options are listed in order of disease severity, and the gure gives a treatment algorithm.

Steroids
Steroid therapy has been used in treatment of acute and chronic symptoms of Menieres diseaseboth oral steroids and intratympanic steroid injections have been tried. Trials of steroids could be of substantial value to most patients since a large number with Menieres disease have allergies and also because of problems with immune-mediated occurrences. For acute attacks, intramuscular or intravenous methylprednisolone can be used to control the severe hearing loss and vertigo followed by oral prednisone at a dose of 1 mg/kg, given on a daily basis for 1014 days before a slow tapering dose can take eect for the next 2 weeks. If patients do not respond to the oral steroids and their hearing continues to deteriorate, intratympanic methylprednisolone or dexamethasone injections can be given. Patients who have a pronounced response to oral or intratympanic steroids might have other immunemediated inner-ear diseases and should have a complete work-up for autoimmune problems. Consultation with a
409

Lifestyle changes
A strong association with seasonal allergies and circulating immune-complexes exists in patients with known diagnoses of Menieres disease.45,46 Simple allergy-avoidance and changes in lifestyle could alleviate some of the allergy symptoms associated with this disease and allow for improved quality of life for patients. Some studies have reported a signicant reduction (up to 62%) in both frequency and severity of attacks of vertigo in
www.thelancet.com Vol 372 August 2, 2008

Seminar

rheumatologist who is interested in taking care of such patients can be very benecial.42 In a randomised and blinded controlled trial at a tertiary referral centre, Morales and colleagues53 randomly assigned patients to oral acetazolamide or oral acetazolamide and prednisone and assessed their responses. The investigators ndings suggested a signicant reduction in patients refractory vertigo and tinnitus with oral prednisone therapy, but they noted no change in patients aural fullness or hearing.53 Intratympanic dexamethasone injection has been used by several investigators to control symptoms of vertigo and hearing loss in patients with Menieres disease. In a 2-year prospective placebo-controlled double-blinded randomised trial, Garduno-Anaya and colleagues54 studied the eect of dexamethasone perfusion of the inner ear in patients with unilateral Menieres disease. They concluded that dexamethasone at 4 g/L injected into the ear transtympanically under local anaesthesia showed an 82% complete control of vertigo compared with 57% control in the placebo group. They noted a 48% subjective improvement in tinnitus, 35% improvement in hearing loss, and 48% improvement in aural fullness compared with signicantly lower proportions in the control group.54 Since most patients with Menieres disease can present with sudden hearing loss, intratympanic steroids might also be of benet to those with sudden hearing loss in Menieres disease.5559 In a study to assess the results of intratympanic steroid therapy with dexamethasone in patients with cochlear hydrops, Hillman and colleagues60 concluded that hearing improved in 40% of patients, was worse in only 4%, and did not change in 56% who received intratympanic steroids for hydrops.

Gentamicin transtympanic perfusion

Destructive treatments can be used in patients with intractable vertigo. One such treatment, with intratympanic aminoglycosides, was rst used to treat unilateral intractable Menieres disease more than 30 years ago.61 The present drug of choice seems to be gentamicin, which causes direct damage to both the sensorineural epithelium and the dark cells of the labyrinth, thus aecting vestibular function and cochlear function. Nedzelski and colleagues62 presented his preliminary report on 33 patients given intratympanic gentamicin between 1988 and 1989 for intractable vertigo. Hearing improved in 36% of these patients, was unchanged in 39%, and worsened in 25%. He reported an 897% control of vertigo. Parnes and Ridell61 also showed a similar proportion of hearing loss in their preliminary series of patients. Driscoll and colleagues63 proposed a low-dose single treatment with gentamicin for Menieres disease. He concluded that low-dose intratympanic gentamicin was a safe and simple procedure that was eective in the control of denitive episodes of vertigo in most patients with unilateral Menieres disease; control of vertigo was
410

obtained in 84% of patients with a low incidence of hearing loss. McFeely and colleagues64 studied 25 consecutive patients given intratympanic gentamicin for Menieres disease between 1992 and 1996 and reported a 20% prevalence of pronounced sensorineural hearing loss and 8% prevalence of total deafness after gentamicin treatment. They also reported an 88% complete control of vertiginous spells with another 12% substantially controlled. Kaasinen and colleagues65 investigated 93 patients with intractable Menieres disease who were given serial injections of intratympanic gentamicin and followed up for 2 years. They reported a complete resolution of vertigo in 81% of patients, with an 11% prevalence of total sensorineural hearing loss. The investigators concluded that this method was a safe and eective way to treat vertiginous attacks in patients with Menieres disease. Minor66 devised a protocol using transtympanic gentamicin injections for patients with vertigo in Menieres disease, titrating it to development of signs of unilateral vestibular hypofunction, as shown by total loss of caloric stimulation response on video nystagmagraphy or electrode nystagmagraphy tests. He reported a very low prevalence of sensorineural hearing loss in only one patient (3%) and a 91% control of vertigo.66 Initial studies had recommended a complete ablation of vestibular function with gentamicin to obtain successful results in patients with vertigo.67 However, results from studies now recommend that a partial ablation could be just as eective with less risk of sensorineural hearing loss.68 The main risk of intratympanic gentamicin treatment for vertigo is the sensorineural hearing loss and associated disequilibrium, which are common complaints after this treatment. Many studies suggest that a complete ablation of function is not necessary for control of vertigo, and that partial ablation could reduce the risk of hearing loss to just 2021%.68 An important indicator for intratympanic gentamicin therapy seems to be the control of vertigo in nonserviceable earsie, speech reception threshold worse than 50 db and speech discrimination score of less than 50%or in patients who have failed endolymphatic sac surgery.63 Transmastoid labyrinthectomy has traditionally been oered for non-serviceable ears in patients with Menieres disease. This method has been the gold standard, and it is very eective in eradication of vertigo in more than 94% of patients. However, transtympanic gentamicin therapy can provide a minimally-invasive ambulatory means with low morbidity and few side-eects, which is very cost eective for management of vertigo in these patients with non-serviceable ears.69 Marzo and Leonetti70 have also shown the ecacy of intratympanic gentamicin therapy for patients who have failed endolymphatic sac surgery, thus reducing the need for vestibular neurectomy in those with intractable disease.
www.thelancet.com Vol 372 August 2, 2008

Seminar

Colletti and colleagues71 reported auditory results after 209 patients had undergone vestibular nerve section and compared these ndings with 24 patients who had received intratympanic gentamicin injections. The auditory data indicated a slight drop in scores for speech discrimination in those who had vestibular nerve sections, from 85% to 82% postoperatively. However, in the group who received gentamicin, scores dropped from 87% to 65% after treatment. This signicant dierence between the two groups suggested a much higher rate of sensorineural hearing loss in the gentamicin group than in those who had vestibular neurectomy. The control of vertigo in patients who had vestibular neurectomy was 958% compared with 75% in those who received gentamicin. Patients have to be counselled about the substantial risk of sensorineural hearing loss and disequilibrium that might result after gentamicin therapy. Furthermore, they should be informed that intratympanic gentamicin therapy is a chemical ablation of the vestibular system, and as such it remains a destructive procedure.

Pressure pulse treatment

A fairly new non-invasive method for treatment of intractable vertigo in patients with Menieres disease has been positive pressure provided through a pulse-generator into the ear canal.72,73 The device for this procedure is called a Meniett (Medtronic Inc, Jacksonville, FL, USA). Odkvist and colleagues74 compared the Meniett device with a placebo (a similar device without any pressure delivered). They noted a signicant reduction in the frequency and intensity of vertigo, tinnitus, and aural pressure in the group using the Meniett device compared with the placebo group. Densert and Sass75 studied 37 patients with a diagnosis of denitive Menieres disease and active vestibular symptoms. They concluded that the pressure treatment provided by the Meniett device was eective in control of vertigo in a large number of patients with intractable Menieres disease. No signicant side-eects were associated with use of the Meniett. However, Boudewyns and colleagues76 have shown that the long-term ecacy of the Meniett device is poor.

Endolymphatic sac surgery

Endolymphatic sac surgery for Menieres disease was rst proposed by Portmann3 80 years ago; it has stood the test of time and continues to be oered to patients with Menieres disease, who receive substantial improvement in hearing and attacks of vertigo. The endolymphatic subarachnoid shunt procedure was made common practice by William House77 in 1962, and the endolymphatic mastoid sac-enhancement surgery by Paparella and co-workers78 in 1980. The endolymphatic sac to mastoid enhancement operation has proven safe and eective in alleviation of intractable vertigo in more than 76% of patients.79,80 Paparella and Fina81 reported
www.thelancet.com Vol 372 August 2, 2008

75% total elimination of vertigo and 90% improvement of vertigo after sac enhancement surgery. The main technical feature of endolymphatic sac surgery has been a wide decompression of the sigmoid sinus, localisation of the endolymphatic sac, and insertion of a custom-made Silastic sheeting along with Silastic spacers in the sac and perisaccular area. The risk of sensorineural hearing loss after endolymphatic sac decompression is less than 2%. Paparella and Fina81 investigated more than 2000 ESE surgeries that were undertaken over 35 years and noted an incidence of revision of only 5%, usually 34 years later. Preservation of hearing was maintained in more than 98% of patients, and up to 40% of patients had better hearing outcomes after ESE than they did before the procedure. Only 2% of patients sustained serious sensorineural hearing loss after ESE. However, Thomsen and colleagues82 concluded that ESE surgery had no advantages compared with a placebo operation.82 Although the research has been cited by sceptics of ESE surgery extensively, the investigators conclusion was that both the ESE surgery group and the placebo group had 70% success in controlling vertigo attacks. Their follow-up study in 1986 stated the same conclusion.83 In our opinion this study was awed in several areas. First, it was a very small study of only 30 patients. Second, patients in the placebo group had a complete mastoidectomy under general anaesthesia. Many factors during general anaesthesia can aect body haemodynamics and uid balance, thus aecting the composition of inner-ear uid in patients with Menieres disease. Furthermore, a complete mastoidectomy is not a placebo treatment, since this procedure might have inadvertently decompressed the tight Trautmanns triangle and improved endolymphatic sac aeration and function. We have shown that the main feature of ESE surgery is the decompression of the sigmoid sinus, which leads to improved endolymphatic sac decompression.80 The most important part of ESE surgery is a successful complete mastoidectomy, which was oered to patients in the placebo group in Thomsens study. Ostrowski and Kartush84 investigated the long-term ecacy of ESE-vein decompression surgery on patients with classic Menieres disease. The investigators reported a 72% long-term improvement in control of vertigo and concluded that benecial long-term outcome of this method supports its continued use as a rst-line treatment option in patients with intractable Menieres disease. Huangs study85 of more than 3000 cases indicated a 90% chance of achieving complete or substantial control of vertigo in the short term (over 3 years). Revision of endolymphatic sac surgery has been done on patients who have initial successful results after primary endolymphatic sac surgery. In 1988, we reported an incidence of revised cases of endolymphatic sac surgery of 7%.86 A further study by Paparella87 also corroborated that revision of this procedure is rarely
411

Seminar

needed and that ESE surgery has excellent results in control of recurrent attacks of vertigo in patients who have initial successful results from the primary surgery complete control of vertigo was reported in 21 of 22 patients who underwent revision of ESE, with the remaining patient needing a vestibular neurectomy. The safety of ESE surgery has also been established in elderly patients with Menieres disease.88 In 62 patients aged 65 years and older who underwent a total of 78 ESE surgeries, no signicant complications, sequelae, or perioperative deaths were recorded. The investigators recorded a prevalence of 16% of major complications, mainly cardiac arrhythmia. 77% of the elderly patients undergoing ESE had complete resolution of their vertigo for up to 2 years after surgery.

substantially reduced the number of patients with intractable vertigo needing vestibular neurectomy.

Vestibular rehabilitation
Vestibular rehabilitation is a form of physical therapy designed to improve vestibular function and mechanisms of central adaptation and compensation. It can be quite successful in helping patients prevent the signicant sequelae of vestibular loss and vertigo; vestibular adaptation exercises to prevent falls have proven to be particularly eective. However, the treatment is only successful for patients who have stable, non-uctuating vestibular loss.100

Conclusion
Menieres disease continues to aict hundreds of thousands of patients every year on a global scale. Patients of all ethnic and racial backgrounds have been aicted with this chronic illness. It is true that we still do not have a cure for this disease, as with many other illnesses in medicine. However, substantial improvements have been made over the centuries in dealing with this illness, especially in the past decade, and several safe and eective medical and surgical therapies are now available to help patients cope with the disorders sequelae. Physicians treating patients who have Menieres disease need to remain optimistic and convey a positive attitude when dealing with patients aicted with this illness.
Conict of interest statement We declare that we have no conict of interest. References 1 Mnire P. Maladies de loreille interne orant des symptomes de la congestion cerebral apoplectiforme. Gaz Med de Paris 1961; 16: 88. 2 Knapp H. A clinical analysis of the inammatory aectation of the inner ear. Arch Ophthalmol Otolaryngol 1871; 4: 20483. 3 Portmann G. Vertigo: surgical treatment by opening of the saccus endolymphaticus. Arch Otolaryngol 1927; 6: 309. 4 Guild S. The circulation of the endolymph. Am J Anat 1927; 39: 57. 5 Dandy WE. Menieres disease: its diagnosis and method of treatment. Arch Surg 1928; 16: 112752. 6 Altmann F, Fowler E. Histological ndings in Menieres symptom complex. Ann Otol Rhinol 1943; 52: 5280. 7 Kimura RS. Experimental blockage of the endolymphatic sac and duct and its eect on the inner ear of the guinea pig. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1967; 76: 466487. 8 da Costa SS, de Sousa LCA, Piza M. Menieres disease: overview, epidemiology, and natural history. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 2002; 35: 45595. 9 da Costa SS. Central causes of vertigo. In: Souza SD, Claussen C, eds. Modern concepts of neurology. Mumbai: Prajakta Arts, 1997: 31031. 10 Stahle J, Stahle C, Arenberg IK. Incidence of Menieres disease. Arch Otolaryngol 1978; 104: 99102. 11 Nakae K, Komatuzaki K. Epidemiological study of Menieres disease. Pract Otol (Kyoto) 1984; 69: 178388. 12 Tokumasu K, Tashiro N, Goto K, et al. Incidence and prevalence of Menieres disease in Asgamihara City, Kanagawa-ken. Pract Otol (Kyoto) 1983; 1 (suppl 3): 116575. 13 Kotimaki J, Sorri M, Aantaa E, Nuutinen J. Prevalence of Menieres disease in Finland. Laryngoscope 1999; 109: 74853. 14 Paparella MM, da Costa SS, Fox R, Yoo TH. Menieres disease and other labyrinthine diseases. In: Paparella MM, Shumrick DA, Gluckmann J, Meyerho WL, eds. Otolaryngology (3rd edn). Philadelphia: WB Saunders, 1991: 1689714.

Vestibular nerve section

Jackler and Whinneys review89 of surgery on the VIII cranial nerve indicated signicant uctuations in the degree of interest in vestibular nerve section during the 20th century. In the mid-1900s, section of the VIII nerve that was made common practice by Dandy90 was largely replaced by the endolymphatic sac procedure and labyrinthectomy.91 There was renewed interest in vestibular nerve section after House introduced the middle-fossa vestibular neurectomy in 1961.92 Investigators such as Fisch and Glasscock and colleagues9395 modied Houses middle-fossa approach to include inferior vestibular neurectomy for improved control of vertigo. Silverstein and Norrell96,97 described the rst retrolabyrinthine vestibular nerve section for Menieres disease. However, the retrolabyrinthine approach proved to be dicult because of the forward location of the sigmoid sinus and diculty in accessing the lateral aspect of the internal auditory canal for patients who had poor cleavage between the vestibular and cochlear nerves. Silverstein and others98 modied the vestibular nerve section to include a retrosigmoid/internal auditory canal approach, in 1985. This modication proved to be eective in exposure of the vestibule-cochlear cleavage and in providing access to the cerebellopontine angle, and later this technique replaced the retrolabyrinthine method. Silverstein proposed a combined retrosigmoidretrolabyrinthine vestibular nerve section that ensured a complete cure of vertigo in about 85% of patients and a substantial improvement in another 7%.99 Preservation of hearing remained excellent, with only 20% of patients showing a slight change in levels of hearing compared with levels before surgery, and up to 4% showing signicant hearing loss. Combined retrolabyrinthine/ retrosigmoid vestibular nerve section has remained the gold standard in vestibular neurectomy procedures.99 However, at most otological centres, vestibular neurectomy is undertaken far less now than it was in the mid-1980s. Eective medical treatment and dietary control, combined with intermittent use of oral steroids and middle-ear perfusion of steroids or gentamicin has
412

www.thelancet.com Vol 372 August 2, 2008

Seminar

15 16

17

18 19 20 21 22 23

24 25

26 27

28 29 30 31

32

33

34 35

36 37

38 39 40

41

42

Meyerho WL, Paparella MM, Shea D. Menieres disease in children. Laryngoscope 1978; 88: 150411. Paparella MM. The cause (multifactorial inheritance) and pathogenesis (endolymphatic malabsorption) of Menieres disease and its symptoms (mechanical and chemical). Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 1985: 99: 44551. Paparella MM. The natural course of Menieres disease. In: Filipo R, Barbara M, eds. Proc 3rd International Symposium on Menieres disease. Amsterdam: Kugler, 1994: 920. Bernstein J. Occurrence of episodic vertigo and hearing loss in families. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1965; 74: 10111. Caparosa RJ. Medical treatment of Menieres disease. Laryngoscope 1963; 73: 66672. Nsamba C. A comparative study of the etiology of vertigo in the African. J Laryngol Otol 1972; 86: 1725. Morrison AW. Anticipation in Menieres disease. J Laryngol Otol 1995; 109: 499502. Koyama S, Mitsuishi Y, Bibee K, et al. HLA associations with Menieres disease. Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 1993; 113: 57578. Arweiler DJ, Jahnke K, Grosse-Wilde H. Meniere disease as an autosomal dominant hereditary disease. Laryngorhinootologie 1995: 74: 51215. Paparella MM. Pathogenesis of Menieres disease and Menieres syndrome. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl 1984; 406: 1025. Committee on Hearing and Equilibrium: Guidelines for the diagnosis and evaluation of therapy in Menieres disease. Amer Acad Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg Foundation Inc. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1995: 113: 17678. Paparella MM. Pathogenesis and pathophysiology of Menieres disease. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl 1991; 485: 2635. Arenberg IK, Lemke C, Shambaugh GE Jr. Viral theory for Menieres disease and endolymphatic hydrops: Overview and new therapeutic options for viral labyrinthitis. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1997; 830: 30613. Gibson WPR, Arenberg IK. Pathophysiologic theories in the etiology of Menieres disease. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 1997; 30: 961. Kimura RS, Schuknecht HF, Ota CY, et al. Obliteration of the ductus reuniens. Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 1980; 89: 295309. Zechner G, Altmann F. Histological studies on the human endolymphatic duct and sac. Pract Otorhinolaryngol 1969; 31: 6583. Sando I, Ikeda I. The vestibular aqueduct in patients with Menieres disease: A temporal bone histopathological investigation. Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 1984; 97: 55870. Ikeda I, Sando I. Endolymphatic duct and sac in patients with Menieres disease: A temporal bone histopathological study. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1984; 93: 54046. Paparella MM, Sajjadi H, da Costa SS, et al. The signicance of the lateral sinus in Menieres disease. In: Nadol JB, ed. Proc 2nd Intl Symposium on Menieres Disease: pathogenesis, pathophysiology, diagnosis, and treatment. Amsterdam: Kugler Publications, 1989: 13946. Paparella MM, Sajjadi H. Endolymphatic sac revision for Menieres disease. Am J Otol 1988; 9: 44147. Paparella MM, Sajjadi H. Endolymphatic sac procedures. In: Brackmann DE, Shelton C, Arriaga MA, eds. Otologic surgery (2nd edn). Philadelphia: WB Saunders 2001: 37184. Arts HA, Kileny PR, Telian SA. Diagnostic testing for endolymphatic hydrops. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 1997; 30: 9871005. Paparella MM, Sajjadi H. Natural history of Menieres disease. In: Harris JP, ed. Menieres disease. The Hague: Kugler Publications, 1999: 2938. Paparella MM. Methods of diagnosis and treatment of Menieres disease. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl 1991; 485: 10819. Paparella MM, McDermott JC, de Sousa LC. Menieres disease and the peak audiogram. Arch Otolaryngol 1982; 108: 55559. Dobie RA, Snyder JM, Donaldson JA. Electronystagmographic and audiologic ndings in patients with Menieres disease. Acta Otolaryngol 1982; 94: 1927. de Sousa LC, Piza MRT, da Costa SS. Diagnosis of Menieres disease: routine and extended tests. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 2002; 35: 54764. Sajjadi H. Medical management of Menieres disease. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 2002: 35: 58189.

43 44 45 46

47 48

49

50

51

52

53

54

55 56

57

58

59 60

61

62

63

64

65

66

67

Lempert T, Neuhauser H. Vertigo as a symptom of Migraine. Med Klin (Muncih) 2001: 96: 47579. Battista R. Audiometric ndings of patients with migraine associated dizziness. Oto-Neurotol 2004; 25: 98792. Derebery MJ, Valenzuela S. Menieres syndrome and allergy. Otolarynol Clin N Am 1992; 25: 21324. Yang WH, Dorval G, Osterland CK, et al. Circulating immune complexes during immunotherapy. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1979; 63: 300. Derebery JM. The role of allergy in Menieres disease. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 1997; 30: 100716. Furstenberg AC, Lashmet SH, Lathrop F. Menieres symptom complex: medical treatment. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1934; 43: 1035. Boles R, Rice DH, Hybels R, et al. Conservative management of Menieres disease: the Furstenberg regimen revisited. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1975; 84: 513. Jackson CG, Glasscock III ME, Davis WE, et al. Medical management of Menieres disease. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1981; 90: 142. Thirlwall AS, Kundu S. Diuretics for Menieres disease or syndrome. London: Royal Berkshire Hospital ENT Department, 1953. Corvera J, Corvera G. Long-term eects of acetazolamide and chlorthalitone on the hearing loss of Menieres disease. Am J Otol 1989; 10: 14245. Morales-Luckie E, Cornejo-Suarez A, Zaragoza-Contreras MA, Gonzalez-Perez O. Oral administration of prednisone to control refractory vertigo in Menieres disease: a pilot study. Otol Neurotol 2005; 26: 102226. Garduno-Anaya MA, Couthino de Toledo H, Hinojosa-Gonzalez R, Pane-Pianese C, Rios-Castaneda LC. Dexamethasone inner ear perfusion by intratympanic injection in unilateral Menieres disease: a two-year prospective, placebo-controlled, double-blind, randomized trial. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2005; 133: 28594. Battista RA. Intratympanic dexamethasone for profound idiopathic sudden hearing loss. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2005; 132: 90205. Garcia-Purrinos FJ, Ferri E, Rosell A, Calvo J. Combined intratympanic and intravenous dexamethasone to control vertigo in Menieres disease. Acta Otorrhinolarygnol Esp 2005; 56: 7477. Xenellis J, Papadimitriou N, Niolopoulos T, et al. Intratympanic steroid treatment in idiopathic sudden hearing loss: a control study. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2006; 134: 94045. Selivanova OA, Gouveris H, Victor A, Amedee RG, Mann W. Intratympanic dexamethasone and hyaluronic acid in patients with low frequency and Menieres-associated sudden sensorineural hearing loss. Otol Neurotol 2005; 26: 89095. Margo SJ. Intratympanic steroid perfusion for sudden sensorineural hearing loss. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2005; 131: 73032. Hillman TM, Arriaga MA, Chen DA. Intratympanic steroids: do they improve hearing in cases of cochlear hydrops? Laryngoscope 2003; 113: 190307. Parnes LS, Ridell D. Irritative spontaneous nystagmus following intratympanic gentamicin for Menieres disease. Laryngoscope 1993; 103: 74549. Nedzelski JM, Bryce GE, Peiderer AG. Treatment of Menieres disease with topical gentamicin: a preliminary report. J Otolaryngol 1992; 21: 95101. Driscoll CL, Kasperbauer JL, Facer GW, Harner SG, Beatty CW. Low-dose intratympanic gentamicin and the treatment of Menieres disease: Preliminary results. Laryngoscope 1997; 107: 8389. McFeely WJ, Singleton T, Rodriguez FJ, Antonelli PJ. Intratympanic gentamicin treatment for Menieres disease. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1998; 118: 58996. Kaasinen S, Pyykko I, Ishizaki H, Aalto H. Intratympanic gentamicin in Menieres disease. Acta Otolaryngol (Stock) 1998; 118: 29498. Minor LB. Intratympanic gentamicin for control of vertigo in Menieres disease: vestibular signs that specify completion of therapy. Am J Otol 1999; 20: 20919. Hone SW. Nedzelski J, Chen J. Does intratympanic gentamicin treatment for Menieres disease cause complete vestibular ablation? J Otolaryngol 2000; 29: 8387.

www.thelancet.com Vol 372 August 2, 2008

413

Seminar

68

69

70

71

72

73

74

75

76

77 78 79 80

81 82

83

Carey J. Intratympanic gentamicin for the treatment of Menieres disease and other forms of peripheral vertigo. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 2004; 37: 107590. Bauer PW , MacDonald CB, Cox LC. Intratympanic gentamicin therapy for vertigo in nonserviceable ears. Am J Otolaryngol 2001; 22: 11115. Marzo SJ, Leonetti JP. Intratympanic gentamicin therapy for persistent vertigo after endolymphatic sac surgery. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2002; 126: 3133. Colletti V, Carner M, Colletti L. Auditory results after vestibular nerve section and intratympanic gentamicin for Menieres disease. Otol Neurotol 2007; 28: 14551. Ingelstedt S, Ivarsson A, Tjernstrn . Immediate relief of vestibular symptoms during acute attacks of Menieres disease using a pressure chamber. Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 1976; 82: 36878. Densart O, Ingelstedt S, Ivarsson A. Immediate restoration of basal sensorineural hearing using a pressure chamber. Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 1975; 80: 93100. Odkvist LM, Arlinger S, Billermark E, Densert B, Lindholm S, Wallqvist J. Eects of middle ear pressure changes on clinical symptoms in patients with Menieres disease: a clinical multicentre placebo-controlled study. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl 2000; 543: 99101. Densert B, Sass K. Control of symptoms in patients with Menieres disease using middle ear pressure applications: Two years follow-up. Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 2001; 121: 61621. Boudewyns AN, Wuyts FL, Hoppenbrouwers M, et al. Miniett therapy: rescue treatment in severe drug-resistant Menieres disease? Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 2005; 125: 128389. House WF. Subarachnoid shunt for drainage of endolymphatic hydrops. Laryngoscope 1962; 72: 71329. Paparella MM, Kim C-H, Shea D. Sac decompression for refractory leutic vertigo. Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 1980; 90: 54146. Paparella MM. Pathology of Menieres disease. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1984; 93 (suppl 112): 3133. Paparella MM, Sajjadi H. Surgical treatment of incapacitating peripheral vertigo: endolymphatic sac enhancement. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 1994; 27: 381402. Paparella MM, Fina M. Endolymphatic sac enhancement: reversal of pathogenesis. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 2002; 35: 62137. Thomsen J, Bretlau P, Tos M, Johnsen NJ. Menieres disease: endolymphatic sac decompression compared with sham (placebo) decompression. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1981; 374: 82030. Thomsen J, Bretau P, Tos M, Johnsen NJ. Endolymphatic sacmastoid shunt surgery. A non-specic treatment modality? Ann Oto Rhinolaryngolo 1986; 95: 3235.

Ostrowski VB, Kartush JM. Endolymphatic sac-vein decompression for intractable Menieres disease: long-term treatment results. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2003; 128: 55059. 85 Huang TS. Endolymphatic sac surgery for Menieres disease: experience with over 3000 cases. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 2002; 35: 591606. 86 Paparella MM, Sajjadi H. Endolymphatic sac revision for recurrent Menieres disease. Am J Otol 1988: 9: 44147. 87 Paparella MM. Revision of endolymphatic sac surgery for recurrent Menieres disease. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 2002: 35: 60719. 88 Sajjadi H, Paparella MM, Williams T. Endolymphatic sac enhancement surgery in elderly patients with Menieres disease. ENT J 1998; 77: 9782. 89 Jackler RK, Whinney D. A century of eighth nerve surgery. Otol Neurotol 2001; 22: 40116. 90 Dandy WE. Treatment of Menieres disease by section of only the vestibular portion of the acoustic nerve. Bull Johns Hopkins Hosp 1933: 53: 5255. 91 Silverstein H, Jackson LE. Vestibular nerve section. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 2002; 35: 65573. 92 House WF. Surgical exposure of the internal auditory canal and its contents through the middle cranial fossa. Laryngoscope 1961; 71: 1363. 93 Fisch U. Vestibular and cochlear neurectomy. Trans Am Acad Ophthalmol Otolaryngol 1977; 78: 25254. 94 Glasscock ME. Vestibular nerve section. Arch Otolaryngol 1973; 97: 11214. 95 Glasscock ME, Kveton JF, Christiansen SG. Middle fossa vestibular neurectomy: an update. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1984; 92: 21620. 96 Silverstein H, Norrell H. Retrolabyrinthine surgery: a direct approach to the cerebellopontine angle. In: Silverstein H, Norrell H, eds. Neurological surgery of the ear (vol II). Birmingham AL: Aesculapius, 1979: 31822. 97 Silverstein H, Norrell H. Retrolabyrinthine surgery: a direct approach to the cerebellopontine angle. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1980; 88: 46269. 98 Silverstein H, Norrell H, Smouha E. Retrosigmoid-internal auditory canal approach versus retrolabyrinthine approach for vestibular neurectomy. Otolarngol Head Neck Surg 1987; 97: 30007. 99 Silverstein H, Norrell H, Smouha E, et al. Combined retrolab-retrosigmoid vestibular neurectomy: an evolution in approach. Am J Otol 1989; 10: 16669. 100 Dowdal-Osborn M. Early vestibular rehabilitation in patients with Menieres disease. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 2002; 35: 68390.

84

414

www.thelancet.com Vol 372 August 2, 2008