Professional Documents
Culture Documents
deal more important that the Little Englander stance might seem to indicate.
We write these words with one eye on the SBS television evening news. As one
would expect of the Australian equivalent of Britain's Channel 4, major
coverage is being given to the annual con-ference of FECCA (the Federation of
Ethnic Community Councils of Australia) which, at its concluding meeting, has heard
further evidence for the divisive effects of suppressing the current beliefs as
well as the aspirations of individual ethnic sections of the Australian
community. Like it or lump it, myth or reality, the denial era past may well be
equally destructive.
Or is all this, like archaeology itself as some have long claimed, nothing more
than rubbish to be no sooner dug up than written down (McEvedy '67: 9),
nothing more substantial than the mechan -ism of dreams?
References:
ARNOLD, B. '91. The deposed Princess of Vix: the need for an engendered European
prehistory, in D. Walde & N. Willows, ed.), The archaeology of gender: 366-74. Calgary: U
of C Archaeol Ass'n. Proceedings of the 22nd Annual Conference of the Archaeological
Association of the U of Calgary.
BARFORD, P. '91. Celts in Central Europe and beyond, Archaeologia Polona 29: 79-98.
BARKER, P. '97. Land of the lost, The Guardian G2 22 December: 2-3.
CHAPMAN, M.K. '92. The Celts: the construction of a myth. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
COLLIS, J.R. '96. The origin and spread of the Celts, Studia Celtica 30 (1997): 17-34.
'97. Celtic myths, Antiquity 71: 195-201,
The Celts: Origins, Myths and Inventions (2003), Tempus, Stroud (John Collis's book
considers the continental Iron Age peoples as well as the islanders, and outlines in great
detail the intricacies of the development of notions about the Celts in modern
archaeological scholarship. It is aimed mo-re at the academic community, but is an
important book for anyone interested in the subject).
EVISON, M. '97. Lo, the conquering hero comes (or not), British Archaeology April: 6-9.
GRAVES-BROWN, Paul,
JONES, Sin & GAMBLE, Clive (eds)- Cultural Identity and
Archaeology: The construction of European communities, Routledge, '96 (A valuable
addition to the debate, cont-aining general papers on the nature and construction of
identities, past and present, plus several contributions on the Celts. See specially the
contributions by Renfrew, Collis and Fitzpatrick).
HAWKES, C.F.C. '73. 'Cumulative Celticity' in pre-Roman Britain, Etudes Celtiques 13: 60628. Actes du 4e Congrs international d'tudes celtiques.
HARKE, H.G.H. '98. Archaeologists and migrations: a problem of attitude?, Current
Anthropology 39(1): 19-45.
HOBSBAWM, E. & RANGER, T. (eds.)- The Invention of Tradition, CUP, 1983 (Contains
papers on the invention of the romantic motif of the Scots Highlander, and for balance, the
creation of many English 'traditions', during the 19th c).
JACOBSTHAL, P.F. 1944. Early Celtic art. Oxford: Clarendon Press; reprinted 1969 with corr.
JAMES, S. 1998. Celts, politics and motivation in archaeology, Antiquity 72: 200-209.
JONES, Sin- The archaeology of ethnicity: constructing identities in the past and the
present, Ldn: Routledge, '97 (A major study of how we think about ethnicity, and how we
can find evidence for it in the past; also, how we often create it when it wasn't really
there).
McEVEDY, C. '67. Penguin atlas of ancient history. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
McHARDY, S. The place of the Picts in Celtic studies, Pictish Arts Society Newsletter, Nov.
1996.
MEGAW, J.V.S. '70. The art of the EU Iron Age: a study of the elusive image. Bath: Adams &
Dart.
MEGAW, J.V.S. & M.R. MEGAW. 1995. Paper tigers, tilting at windmills and Celtic Cheshire
cats, Scottish Archaeo-logical Review 9-10: 246-52.
MEGAW, M.R. & J.V.S. MEGAW. 1996. Ancient Celts and modern ethnicity, Antiquity 70: 17581.
1997. Do the ancient Celts still live? an essay ..., Studio Celtica 31 (1998): 107-23.
MORSE, Michael A- How the Celts Came to Britain: Druids, Ancient Skulls and the Birth of
The Ancient Paths: Discovering the Lost Map of Celtic Europe. Tim Martin has his
eyes opened by an enthralling new history that argues that Druids created a sophisticated
ancient society to rival the Romans.
Important if true was the phrase that the 19th-century writer and historian
Alexander Kinglake wan-ted to see engraved above church doors. It rings loud in
the ears as one reads the latest book by GRobb, a biographer and historian of
distinction whose new work, if everything in it proves to be correct, will blow apart
two millennia of thinking about Iron Age Britain and Europe and put several
scientific dis-coveries back by centuries.
Rigorously field-tested by its sceptical author, who observes drily that anyone
who writes about Druids and mysteriously coordinated landscapes, or who claims
to have located the intersections of the solar paths of Middle Earth in a particular
field, street, railway station or cement quarry, must expect to be treated with
superstition, it presents extraordinary conclusions in a deeply persuasive and
uncompromising manner. What surfaces from these elegant pages- if true- is
nothing less than a wonder of the ancient world: the first solid evidence of Druidic
science and its accomplishments and the earliest accurate map of a conti-nent.
Robb begins his journey from a cottage in Oxfordshire, following up a handful of
mysteries that had teasingly accrued as he assembled his Ondaatje Prize-winning
travelogue The Discovery of France.
They had to do with the Heraklean Way, an ancient route that runs 1,000 miles in
a straight line from the tip of the Iberian Peninsula to the Alps, and with several
Celtic settlements called Mediolanum arr-anged at intervals along the route. After
examining satellite imaging (difficult for the private scholar ev-en a decade ago) and
making several more research trips, Robb bumped up against two extraordinary
disco-veries. First, the entire Via Heraklea runs as straight as an arrow along the
angle of the rising and set -ting sun at the solstices. Second, plotting lines through
the Celtic Mediolanum settlements results in li-nes that map on to sections of
Roman road, which themselves point not to Roman towns but at Celtic oppida
farther along.
Viewed in this light, the ancient texts of the Italian conquerors begin to reveal
sidelong secrets about the people they supplanted. Piece by piece, there emerges
a map of the ancient world constructed along precise celestial lines: a huge
network of meridians and solar axes that served as the blueprint for the Celtic
colonisation of Europe, dictated the placement of its settlements and places of
worship, and was then almost wholly wiped from history. We are, to put it mildly,
unused to thinking like this about the Celts, whose language is defunct and whose
reputation was comprehensively rewritten by those who succeeded them.
Greek travellers from the sixth century BC onwards described a nation of
sanguinary brutes and mad-men who threw their babies in rivers, walked with their
swords into the sea and roughly sodomised their guests. It does not take an
anthropologist to suspect, Robb observes drily, that what the travellers saw or
heard about were baptismal rites, the ceremonial dedication of weapons to gods of
the lower world, and the friendly custom of sharing ones bed with a stranger.
Later on, clean-shaven, toga-sporting Roman visitors to what they called Gallia
Bracata and Gallia Co-mata- Trousered Gaul and Hairy Gaul respectively- were
horrified by the inhabitants practical legwear and love of elaborate moustaches,
and marvelled to hear them discoursing not in gnarly Gaulish but in perfect Greek.
As the Roman military machine rolled over Europe, depicting the Celt as a woodsdwelling wild man became not just a matter of Italian snobbery but one of
propagandist utility. According to Robb, when the Romans arrived this side of the
Alps, they found a country whose technical achievements were diffe-rent from, but
competitive with, their own.
Mapped and governed by a network of scholar-priests according to a template laid
down in heaven, covered by a road network that afforded swift passage to fleets of
uniquely advanced chariots (nearly all the Latin words for wheeled vehicles, Robb
notes, come from Gaulish) and possessing astronomical and scientific knowledge
that would take another millennium to surface again, Gaul remained a deeply
enigmatic place to its military-minded conquerors. When Julius Caesar swept
through, on a tide of war-fare and genocide that would lead his countryman Pliny to
accuse him of humani generis iniuria, (crimes against humanity), much of its
knowledge retreated to the greenwood, never to emerge.
Most significantly, suggests Robb, Caesar failed to work out the Druids. To most of
us even now, the word conjures up the image of a white-robed seer with a sickle,
an implausible hybrid of Getafix and Glastonbury hippie (Robb suggests, following
the design on a Gaulish cauldron, that they tended more towards a figure-hugging
costume patterned like oak bark: much better for melting like smoke into the trees,
a trait of Druid-led armies that Caesar vigorously deplored). The Druidic curriculum
took two deca -des to train up its initiates, but these men of science put nothing in
writing. Like their wood-built hou-ses, their secrets rotted with time. How could we
hope to reconstruct them?
Remarkably, Robb has an answer to this, and it forms the centre of a book almost
indecently stuffed with discoveries. One of the most consistently baffling things
about Celtic temple sites to modern survey -yorsis their shape: warped rectangles
that seem none the less to demonstrate a kind of systematic irreg- ularity. Using
painstakingly reconstructed elements of the Druidic education, which placed
religious em-phasis on mapping the patterns of the heavens on to the lower
Middle Earth of our world, Robb co-mes up with an astonishing discovery: these
irregular rectangles exactly match a method for construct-ing a geometrical ellipse,
the image of the suns course in the heavens. Such a method was previously
thought to be unknown in the West until the 1500s.
Other suggestions follow thick and fast, backed by a mixture of close reading,
mathematical construc-tion and scholarly detective work. Building on meridians
and equinoctial lines, the Druids used their maps of the heavens to create a map
that criss-crossed a continent, providing a plan of sufficient latitu-dinal and
longitudinal accuracy to guide the Celtic diaspora as it pushed eastward across
Europe.
The swirls and patterns in Celtic art turn out, Robb surmises, to be arranged along
rigorous mathema-tical principles, and may even encode the navigational and
cartographic secrets that the Druids so labo-riously developed.
Robb manages his revelations with a showmans skill, modestly conscious that his
book is unfurling a map of Iron Age Europe and Britain that has been inaccessible
for millennia. Every page produces new solutions to old mysteries, some of them so
audacious that the reader may laugh aloud. Proposing a new location for
Uxellodunum, the site of the Gauls final losing battle in France, is one thing;
suggesting where to look for King Arthurs court, or which lake to drag for Excalibur,
is quite another. But both are here.
Amid such riches, readers of The Discovery of France- a glorious book that mixed
notes from a modern cycling tour with a historical gazetteer of pre-unification
France- may still be itching for the moment when the author gets back on his bike.
Beautifully written though it is, The Ancient Paths can tend to dryness at times, but
some of its best moments come when the author gets out into the field.
One example will suffice. Certain references in Caesars writing indicate that the
Gauls operated a vo-cal telegraph, composed of strategically placed teams
yodelling news overland to one another, which pas -sed messages at a speed
nearly equivalent to the first Chappe telegraph in the 18th c. To judge how this
might have worked, Robb takes himself off to the oppidum above Aumance, near
Clermont-Ferrand, where he reports on the car alarms and the whirr of traffic still
audible across countryside four kilo-metres away.
He goes further. Aumance was one of around 75 places once known by the name
Equoranda, a word with an unknown root that resembles the Greek and Gaulish for
sound-line or call-line. All the Equo-randa settlements Robb visits turn out to be
on low ridges or shallow valleys, and would, he writes, ha-ve made excellent
listening posts. Examined in this light, one word in Caesars account becomes
fruitful: he observes that the Gauls transmit the news by shouting across fields
and regios, a word that can be translated as boundaries. An ancient Persian
technique for acoustic surveying, still current in the 19th-c south of France, involves
three men calling to one another and plotting their position along the direc-tion of
the sound. Put the pieces together and you end up- or Robb does- with the
scattered remains of a magnificent network that could have acted not just as a
telegraph system but as a means to map the Druids boundaries on to the earth.
Its a magnificent piece of historical conjecture, backed by a quizzical scholarly
intellect and given a personal twist by experiment. So, for that matter, is the whole
thing. Robb describes in his introduction the secretive meetings with publishers in
London and New York that kept a lid on the books research until publication, and
watching its conclusions percolate through popular and academic history promi-ses
to be thrilling.
Reading it is already an electrifying and uncanny experience: there is something
gloriously unmodern about seeing a whole new perspective on history so
comprehensively birthed in a single book. If true, very important indeed.
Comment: a) Like the Aryan Vedas, the Japanese Kojiki, and the mysteries of the Plains
"Indians", many itiner-ant ancients kept their traditions oral and passed it from mouth to
ear like the Masonic tokens, so that they may not be twisted, lost to those who do not
deserve them, or be suborned to serve false kings i.e. tyrants and con-querors. The paths
that were went much further. The Druids (Dravids) are the original (encicephalic, fair,
idola-trous, Lilith worshipping) Semites and the paths went all around the Mediterranean
and stretched through Me-sopotamia into India.
This sounds like a rewrite or update of The Druids (1995) by Peter Berresford Ellis.