Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VOLUME 3 1:
I
Cover: Aplomado Falcon is featured
in two articles in this issue. Clay and Pat
Sutton write about the River of Raptors
in Veracruz (page 229), where Aplomado
Falcon is currently a local resident. At one
time this handsome falcon also inhabited
the grass-yucca plains of southeastern
Arizona and southwestern New Mexico, as
well as the yucca-covered sand ridges of the
lower Texas coast, described by David
Wilcove (page 224). The cover photograph
of this species, taken upon the bird's release
at Laguna Atascosa National Wildlife Refuge,
Texas, was taken by Steve Bentsen in 1993.
The camera was a Nikon F4, Nikon
400mmlf3.5 lens, Fuji Velvia film, at 15032,
f5.6 at 11250 sec.
267
283
293
NUMBER 3
JUNE 1999
A Birding Perspective
Editorial
Your Letters
The Forgotten Grasslands
A Birding Essay: Reflections on Southwestern Bird Life
by David S. Wilcoue
River of Raptors
Exploring and Enjoying Pronatura
Veracruz's Raptor Conservation Project
by Clay Sutton and Pafrici~zS l ~ f f o n
Rare, Local, Little-known, and Declining
North American Breeders
A Closer Look: Snowy Plover
by Peter VI! C. Paton
The Next New ABA Birds
Florida and Southeastern Gulf Coast
by Bill Pranty
Answers to April Photo Quiz
by Jinz Burns
Answers to the February Alternate Photo Quiz
by Alvaro Jaramillo
Gleanings from the Technical Literature
A Familiar Mystery-Polymorphisn~
and the White-throated Sparrow
by Paul E. Woods
Building Birding Skills
Rules to Bird By: Bergmann's Rule
by Edward H. Burtt Jr.
An Aleutian Canada Goose Success Story
by Nina Faust and Edgar Bailey
Tools of the Trade
Meade ETX-A Questar for the Rest of Us?
by Stephen Ingraham
Cats Indoors!
Campaign Gathers Steam
by Linda Winter
Book and Media Reviews
The Joy of Birding
A Eurasian Hobby More or Less
by Arlene Koch
New Photo Quiz
Advertiser Index: page 295
1-
Just over ten years ago Don Roberson of Pacific Grove, California, was asked to
gather a panel of birding experts and ornithologists from around the US. and Canada
to predict what species would be the next new birds recorded in North America.
After some thoughtful balloting, the predictions appeared in the December 1988
Birding. Now, we have assembled seven new panels, one for each of the seven regions
covered in 1988 (with only slight geographic alteration): southern Arizonalsouthwestern New Mexico, Florida and the southeastern Gulf Coast,Texas,western Alaska,
northeastern North America (Newfoundland to Delaware Bay), Pacific pelagic (British
Columbia to California), and Atlantic pelagic (mainly associated with the Gulf Stream).
Predictions again are being made as to what species might be considered most likely
candidates t o make an addition t o the ABAArea list in the foreseeable future. Here
is the third article in that mini-series, this one on Florida and the southeastern Gulf
Coast. Previously covered regions in the mini-series are shown in pink in the map
below.To check on more of the ground-rules for this seven-part mini-series,
see the first installment in the December 1998 Birding (pp. 4 8 4 4 9 I).
Palcific Pelagic
(BritistI Columbia
to California)
Texas
and Southeastern
Gulf Coast
:arner,, ,
Parish j
New
THE
BAI-WW
/1
county is Broward). The remaining four species occurred elsewhere in Florida, two in the Panhandle and two in the peninsula.
Monroe County, which includes
the western portion of Everglades
National Park and nearly all of
the Florida Keys, accounts for
two-thirds of all species new to
North America that were recorded
first from this region.
No species have been reported
first in North America from
coastal portions of Alabama and
Mississippi, or from the coastal
portion of Louisiana east of the
Mississippi River delta. Each of
these states, however, has recorded
a first North American record
from outside the boundary of the
region which we are discussing. La
,
:
!
g;
.
1
I
RED-LEGGEDTHRUSH
In order, the Top Six most likely additions to the ABA Checklist
from the Florida and Gulf Coast
region are the following: Cuban
Emerald, Red-legged Thrush,
Olive-capped Warbler, Bahama
Yello\vthroat, Piratic Flycatcher,
and Greater Antillean Bullfinch.
With the exception of the flycatcher, which is from tropical
America, these species all occur
cominoidy in the Bahama Islands,
and some occur also in Cuba. Perhaps not surprisingly, published reports in Florida for all species but
the flycatcher exist, but verifiable
evidence is lacking in all cases.
Birders who wish to study potential West Indian strays have two
widely available field guides at
their disposal: Birds of the West
lndies (Bond 1990) and A Guide to
the Birds of the West lndies (Raffaele et al. 1998), prefaced in Raffaele (1998). Bond (1990) is smaller
-,.
BI
HALL-.
I 'I
I .
Cuban Emerald
(Chlorostilbon ricordii)
Native to the northern Bahamas,
Cuba, and the Isle of Pines, this
species was by far the run-away
winner, included in the lists of all
seven birders from the Florida
peninsula. It was the top choice of
Anderson, Atherton, Biggs, Goodwin, Pranty, and Robertson, and
the second choice of Hoffman. It
has been reported in Florida about
14 times, most recently in May
1991 at Everglades National Park,
Miami-Dade County, when
Atherton, Biggs, and others saw
it, but it has yet to be documented
verifiablp All seven panel members from peninsular Florida
agreed that it is just a matter of
time before this species is photographed or videotaped in the
state.
The Cuban Emerald is slightly
larger than a Ruby-throated Hummingbird, with a straight bill with
a mostly reddish lower mandible.
Males have an all-green body with
white undertail coverts; females
have grayish underparts. Both
sexes have a small white postocular spot (males) or stripe (females)
and a long, deeply-forked tail,
black in males or brownish in females. Brace's Emerald (C. bracei), which is known from a single
specimen collected from New
Providence Island in 1877 and presumably is now extinct, may have
been indistinguishable in the field
from Cuban Emerald.
Red-legged Thrush
(Turdus plumbeus)
Native to the Bahamas, Cuba, the
Isle of Pines, Puerto Rico, Hispaniola, and other Caribbean islands,
this species has been reported
FLORIDA AND SOUTHEASTERN COAST
March 1960 at Miami, MiamiDade County, Florida. The observers considered the bird to be
an escapee, although no sourcc
was mentioned. Robertson and
Woolfenden (1992) considered
such an assessment to be unnecessary and cited the report of a presumed vagrant at Grand Cayman
Island. Pranty chose this species
over other potential Caribbear
strays such as West Indian
Whistling-Duck, Cuban Grass
quit, Cuban Bullfinch, and
Greater Antillean Bullfinch vecause he felt that the thrush was
least likely to be kept in captivity,
and any verified Florida record
was likely to be accepted as a genuine strap
The Red-legged Thrush is about
the size of an American Robin.
Birds from the Bahamas are a dark
gray overall, with a black throat
and a white chin. Birds from central and western Cuba have a darker chin and a reddish-brown belly
In all races, the tail is black with
large, white terminal-spots; tht
soft parts (i.e., legs, bill, and 01
bital rings) are red.
"v
Bahama Yellowthroa
(Geothlypis rostrata)
Native to the northern Bahamas
(Abaco, Andros, Cat Island,
Eleuthera, Grand Bahama, and
New Providence), this species has
produced.three North American
reports, all from Florida. The first
report: by Paul Sykes, was of a
bird mist-netted at Loxahatchee
NWR, Palm Beach County, on 19
October 1968 (Sykes 1974). It was
examined briefly, then escaped before it could be documented fully
The second report, from the west-
BRUCE HALLETT
ern Florida Panhandle on 8 October 19-4. probably should be discounted until details are published. Dunn and Garrett (1997)
mention an additional Florida report: remains of a bird found in
the stomach of a tiger shark (!)
captured off llelbourne Beach,
Brevard County, on 11 May 1976.
Bahama Yellowthroat is slight
larger than a Common Yellowthroat, with a longer, more robu
bill and all-yellow underparts.
The call note is a distinct tuck or
chyimp that lacks the "sh or j
qualities" of a Comnlon Yellowthroat (Dunn and Garrett 1997).
Olive-capped Warbler
(Dendroica pityophila)
This species is native to pine
ests of Cuba, Grand Bahama, and
Abaco. Robertson felt that the
Lower Keys are the most
spot for this species to sh
most
-'-
Piratic ~'iwatcherrp
OLIVE-CAI
Greater Antillean
Bullfinch
(Loxigilla violacea)
This species is native to the Bahamas, Hispaniola, and Jamaica.
The sole North American report
was of a male studied "as close as
10 feet for 20 minutes" by Cynthia
Plockelman and A1 Liberman, two
experienced Florida birders, at
Hypoluxo Island, Palm Beach
County, Florida, on 24 April 1977
(Kale 1977). This species was listed as an Honorable Mention by
Roberson's (1988) panel.
Greater Antillean Bullfinch is
slightly smaller than a Blue Grosbeak with a similar body shape
and large conical bill. Plumage is
black overall, with dull red eyebrows, throat, and undertail
coverts.
The Blue-and-white Swallow
and Pearly-eyed Thrasher received
the same number of points from
the panel as the Greater Antillean
Bullfinch. However, the bullfinch
was chosen by three panel members versus two each for the swallow and thrasher, so it was given a
higher ranking.
Twenty honorable-mention
species that did not make the Top
six list were also chosen by one or
more panel members. Ten of these
received from two to six points
each, while ten others received
BIRDING, JUNE 1999
.-151:
9"
- ,-g p p ;
%$& .2+--;
,:
'
.- *
<,!*
VENTIABA
Birding Camps
for boys and girls,
12 t o 18, who want
t o expand their birding
skills and natural
history horizons under the
tutelage of experts
----
d k ~ K - 5Tr+bEmh~~
LU-JU
\%mp & m d a
August 344,1999
with Barry LyonlRob Day
Ages 12-1 7; $1.050 from Seattle
To enroll contact:
Victor Emanuel Nature Tours
PO Box 33008
Austin, Texas 78764
8001328-8368
Scholarship information:
ABA, PO Box 6599
Colorado Springs 80934
8001850-2473
email: bellbird@iymis.com
The following species all received one point each: Softplumaged Petrel (Pterodroma mollis), West Indian Whistling-Duck
(Dendrocygna arborea), Gray
Heron (Ardea cinerea), Violet
Sabrewing (Campylopterus hemileucurus), Chestnut-collared Swift
(Streptoprocne rutila), Grayrumped Swift (Chaetura cinereiventris), Caribbean Martin
(Progne dominicensis), Smallbilled Elaenia (Elaenia pnrvirostris)-another "also ran" of
Roberson's panel, Giant Kingbird
(Tymnnus cubensis), and Cuban
Bullfinch (Melopyrrha nigm).
Literature Cited
American Birding Association. 1996. ABA
Checklist: Birds of the Continental
United States and Canada. 5th ed.
Colorado Springs.
American Ornithologists' Union. 1998.
Check-list o f North American Birds.
7th ed. Washington, D.C.
Bond, J. 1990. Birds of the West Indies.
5th ed. Collins. London.
Bradbury, R.C. 1992. First Florida record
of Variegated Flycatcher (Empidonomus varius) at Garden Key, Dry Tortugas. Florida Field Naturalist
20: 4 2 4 .
Cardiff, S.W., and J.V. Remsen Jr. 1981. A
Blue Bunting [Passerina (Cyanocompsa) parellina] record for the United
States from Louisiana. Auk 98:
621-622.
DeBenedictis, PA. 1994.1994 ABA Checklist report. Birding 27:367-368.
Dunn, J., and K. Garrett. 1997. A Field
Guide to Warblers of North America.
Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Hilty, S.J., and W.L. Brown. 1986. A
Guide to the Birds of Colombia.
Princeton University Press.
Howell, A.H. 1932. Florida Bird Life.
Coward-McCann, New York.
Howell, S.N.G., and S. Webb. 1995. A
Guide to the Birds of Mexico and
Northern Central America. Oxford
Additional S~ecies