Professional Documents
Culture Documents
102
8
6
n
tio
ura
d
te )
nu 31
mi 26
t 1 ISO
a
cts to
ffe ing
h e cord
ct
t
l
ffe
ea ac
(H
ge
n
o
st r
t
ec
ry
Ve
eff
ng
o
r
st
ct
ry
ffe
Ve
ge
n
o
st r
ct
ry
ffe
Ve
ge
n
o
st r
ry
Ve
ct
ffe
ge
ur
n
o
ho )
t
Str
ec t 24 631
f
f
g e ng a SO 2
i
I
on
Str ll- be g to
e in
w
d
r
on o
ts acc
fec n
(Ef ratio
ble
du
ea
ble
tic
ea
No
tic
no
y
le
rdl
ab
Ha
ice
ot
n
y
le
rdl
ab
Ha
ice
ot
n
t
No
Acceleration [m/s2]
-1
-2
-3
Body
Drivetrain
Subframe
Frame
Axle
Axle
Operator cab
Frame
Axle
Body
Wheel
Axle
cab on a utility vehicle frame. Section C of the figure shows a connection between the axle
and the powertrain. Occasionally dampers are used between the powertrain or engine and
the body. However, in general, so-called engine mounts with a rubber-metal design including
hydraulic damping are used. Section D of the figure shows a double-wishbone axle with a
parallel spring and damper arrangement.
To better understand the vibration and
z
damping functions of the chassis, we will
first look at a single-mass vehicle
m
m2
suspension system (Fig. 5 top). The wheel
has zero mass and follows the
unevenness of the road surface. To
c
c2
k
k2
simplify matters, lets assume linear
spring and damping characteristics.
m1
k1
c1
Fig. 5:
Single-mass and dual-mass vehicle models
m2 Body mass
m1 Axle mass
This simple model does not correspond with todays damping force designs with non-linear
characteristics that are different in each direction of movement. However, it serves well for
the explanation of the basic physical interrelationships, in particular for the dependence
between damping on one hand as well as vehicle mass and spring rate on the other hand.
The non-dimensional damping factor (D), which characterizes the timed settling progress of
the vibration, is calculated from the differential equation at damped resonant vibrations.
The connection is slightly more complex with the dual-mass vehicle suspension system
(Fig. 5 bottom). The damping ratio of the wheel vibration (D1) is calculated as follows:
c1
For the body vibration damping factor (D2), the following equation applies:
v2
Resonant frequency of body
The natural body (sprung mass) frequencies usually range from 0.9 to 1.6 Hz, and the natural
axle (unsprung mass) frequencies from 10 to 18 Hz. The light-weight construction of todays
vehicles tends to increase the values for natural axle frequencies. Comfortable vehicles usually
have lower natural body frequencies.
Damping requirements
Stroke [mm]
Damping requirements differ. They depend on the absolute values of the wheel and body
masses, and also on the ratio of both masses
as well as the ratio of the tire and ride
spring rates. Additionally, the influencing characteristics specified in Figure 2 have to be
considered. And there are a few more damper-specific effects:
Ratio between damper movement and wheel movement (constant, or variable depending
on suspension geometry)
Utilization of damping properties outside of pure vertical body motions parallel to ride
spring, i.e., in connection with roll and pitch movements
Adaptation of the damping to the requirements resulting from the vehicle utilization in
regards to operational safety (sports suspension or comfort suspension).
The body damping factor should not be selected too high in order to ensure good comfort
and also maximum safety. If this damping factor exceeds critical values beyond D2 = 0.5,
certain exciting conditions will make the damper so stiff that the vehicle bounces on the
wheels. This results in an increase of the natural body frequency to an uncomfortable level for
humans. A body damping factor between 0.25 and 0.35 is a good range satisfying all
considerations.
Figure 6 shows the damper evaluation standards for different uneven road conditions and
functional requirements. The rolling comfort is affected by very minor road irregularities
throughout the entire frequency range of the damper
100
(range 1). Axle and body movements are definitely
5
associated with the natural frequencies of both
10
2
3
4
systems (2, 4). Out of phase vibration (3) usually
results from the interaction with other vibrating
systems in the vehicle. This type of vibration can be
1
1
only slightly influenced by the shock absorber design
without affecting the optimization of the actual
1
10
100
functions of the shock absorber. With low damping
Frequency [Hz]
and dampers with a short stroke, the stop effect
Fig. 6:
Evaluation standards for critical excitations
occurring during operation (mechanical/design stroke
1 Rolling comfort/harshness
2 Body movements
limit, 5) is mainly noticeable due to the noise it
3 Counter-phase vibrations (shaking)
4 Axle movements
5 Damper stops
generates. It can be avoided by using higher damping
or stroke-dependent damping systems.
5
Damping principles
In the past, many different damping principles for vehicle applications were studied. From the
start of this century to the thirties, friction dampers were the preferred damping method.
They were designed with frictional parabolic springs or as special spring-loaded friction
dampers, usually in the form of lever or multi-disk dampers (similar to multi-disk clutches).
The possibility of pneumatic damping systems, in particular in connection with a ride-height
control system (air spring) had been studied and considered until recently. However, its
implementation failed due to its low damping capacity, especially for small strokes at wheel
natural frequencies.
In todays automobile design, the hydraulic-mechanical damping system prevails. The most
widely used form is the telescopic shock absorber, since it provides an optimum design due to
its small dimensions, low friction, precise damping, and simple construction. The following
sections provide more details on the hydraulic-mechanical damping principle with fixed and
variable or controlled settings. The promising principles of magneto-rheological and electrorheological damping are explained in the Trends and development goals section.
Hydraulic damping
The damping action of hydraulic vibration dampers is
generated by the differential pressure at the piston valve
(hydraulic resistance), which is converted to forces by the
piston rod cross-section and piston ring surface (Fig. 7). In
an ideal damper, the differential pressure ( p) is directly
Piston rod
proportional to the damping force (F), and the flow rate
quantity (Q) is directly proportional to the compression
velocity and rebound velocity (v).
Piston valve
F = A p
(5)
v = Q/A
(6)
A
Damper displacement surface area
Base valve
Figure 8 shows three hydraulic resistances as they can occur
in shock absorbers with the respective valve design i.e.,
single or multi-stage. The graph applies the respective
Fig. 7: Damper principles
differential pressure at the valve vs. the hydraulic flow rate.
The pure orifice cross-sections (bottom left), however, will not occur in real life applications,
since they cannot be implemented in the damper in this form. In most cases, the differential
pressure depends on the square of the flow rate with a linear percentage (top left), which
corresponds to the effect of the fluid
8
l
p
p
viscosity.
p =
Q
r
Figure 8 (right side) shows a simplified
F
Laminar
cross2 r
illustration of the function of a pressure
Pressure-limiting
section
valve
limiting valve. As long as the elastic force
l
A
is higher than the product of the hydraulic
Orifice
A
pressure and the effective surface, the
Static:
p A = F
Q
p =
valve remains closed and the flow rate
2 A
Dynamic p A = F
+F
equals zero. With increasing pressure the
0
0
Q
Q
valve will open as soon as the hydraulic
Fig. 8: Hydraulic resistances
force is higher than
4
Spring
2
D
Static
Static
Dynamic
Compression
force
Rebound
force
the elastic force. In real-life applications, the physical intenelationships are significantly more
complex, since the flow force actions during opening and closing also have to be considered
(see Literature: source [2]).
With
different
resistance
A
combinations
it
is
possible
to
v [m/s]
achieve characteristics with
degressive,
linear
and
0.52
0.26 0
-0.26 -0.52
progressive
segments.
A
v [m/s]
mechanical or servo-hydraulic
*25
*50
test machine is used to measure
*75
*100
these damper characteristics. At
constant speed (rpm), this
Constant speed for all strokes: 100 min (*=stroke[mm])
machine
produces
various
strokes
in
rebound
and
B
compression direction, and
subsequently different damper
compression
and
rebound
speeds. The resulting force vs.
stroke diagrams (Fig. 9, left side)
C
can be converted to force vs.
velocity diagrams (F-v diagrams:
Fig. 9, right side).
F-v diagrams are the commonly
used graphical form to illustrate
damper characteristics. They
Fig. 9: Damping characteristics
offer the advantage that the
A Degressive, B Progressive, C Linear
association between damping
force and compression and rebound velocity can be read immediately. However, they only
show maximum values of the damping forces in rebound and compression direction at
various strokes or compression and rebound rates. Therefore, it is advisable to also view a
damping force vs. stroke diagram in order to immediately find any inconsistencies in the
dampers force progress. Degressive, linear, or progressive characteristics curves can be
quickly recognized from the distances between lines.
Alternatively to the above, damper characteristics can be determined at constant stroke with
various speeds (rpm) in form of so-called VDA (German Automotive Manufacturers and
Suppliers Association) characteristics.
The fluid used in a hydraulic damper consists of mineral oil with special additives suitable for
the damper. Due to the constant throttling action of the damper, the oil should have very
good shear strength. Only mineral oils have this shear strength. The inside components
require good lubrication properties. Additionally, the oil must have a very low cavitation
tendency over the entire operating temperature range in order to keep the noise level and the
foaming tendency at high damper speeds at a minimum. Other viscous media, e.g., silicone
oil, were studied. However, they were found unsuitable. So-called bio-oils were developed
and marketed; however, they still are not used due to a minimal demand.
-1
Compression
Damping force
Rebound
supply chamber. The piston rod seal consists of two sealing elements. A garter spring presses
the lower sealing edge on the piston rod. To ensure a good lubrication, the seal is equipped
with two small sealing edges at a distance of 0.5 mm. This design feature increases the life of
the seal. The so-called dust-lip provides the upper seal. It keeps foreign material and dust
from entering the damper or the seal. Both sealing elements are elastic in order to absorb
transverse shifting due to tolerances or deflections of the entire component.
A piston rod dust tube
Rebound
protects the dust-lip at the
Bleed control
B characteristics
seal and the piston rod,
High-speed
keeping dirt from entering the
control
Piston spring
damper
and
preventing
Piston spring
damage from stone impacts.
A
The cylinder diameters for
passenger car suspension
range from about 22 mm to a
Bleed control
maximum of 36 mm. Usually,
the same dampers are used
for utility vehicles (trucks) with
High-speed
control
some applications requiring up
to a maximum of 70 mm bore
diameter.
Utility
vehicle
dampers have a more robust
High-speed
A, B
control
design, since they have to
Bleed control
withstand
higher
forces,
Spring plate
operating
pressures,
and
temperatures. The seals are
Compression
usually made of Viton. NBR
characteristics
only can be used for
Piston speed
temperatures up to 100C,
whereas Viton is suitable for
much higher temperatures.
The requirements for the damper valve design differ within the passenger car area and
among utility vehicles. The F-v characteristics can be linear (as mentioned above), however,
various degressive characteristics are desirable today. Figure 11 shows a few damping force
characteristics for passenger car dampers. They are associated with two different valve
designs. Design A only works with clamped spring washers providing almost linear
characteristics (blue). Design B provides pressure limiting valve-like characteristics (red). Due to
todays light-weight axle construction, a degressive curve is preferred in many cases.
Mounting joint
Piston rod
Protective tube
Rebound stage
Piston valve
Working cylinder
Separating piston
Gas
Mounting joint
Compression stage
Fig. 14: Design and function of a monotube gas pressurized damper
Due to the high pressure level, another seal type is used other than in the twin-tube damper.
A rubber disk that is preloaded by the inside pressure, preloads a Viton seal. This preloading
and a precision machined, chrome-plated piston rod surface ensure tight sealing of this
damper under extreme operating conditions with operating pressures in excess of 110 bar (11
MPa). The monotube damper is usually used as a stand-alone shock absorber or in a coil over
arrangement. Trials to use this design principle for spring struts failed in large series
applications.
Twin-tube Damping
Monotube Damping
Valve Function
Characteristics
Damping
short strokes
with Good
Friction
Better
Low
Construction
length
Installation position
limited
Weight
12
Fig. 15:
Coil over shock
13
Function
Design
A
Stroke-dependent damping during opening
and closing
Reduce seat vibrations
Damping of drive vibrations
Prevent belt slippage and belt wobble
Avoid vibrations at the steering linkage
Avoid power peaks in the brake cables and
wheel standstill
40
48.8
2
33
10 0.3
20
R2
R3
R2
20
13
24
29
9
8
7
6
5
90
R2
75
57
40
32
450 100 N
10
45
10
4
3
2
1
0
35
10
20
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Figure
19
shows
an
example for a compression
stop and the associated
spring characteristics curve.
In coil over shocks, the
compression stop is also
used as an auxiliary spring,
where it works parallel to
the usually linear helical
spring.
Spacer sleeve
Each of these mounts can withstand
2
2
different articulations. The maximum
F
Fig. 20:
Damper end mounts
16