Professional Documents
Culture Documents
As the focus of the bildungsroman, Pip is by far the most important character in
Great Expectations: he is both the protagonist, whose actions make up the main
plot of the novel, and the narrator, whose thoughts and attitudes shape the
readers perception of the story. As a result, developing an understanding of Pips
character is perhaps the most important step in understanding Great
Expectations.
Any serious discussion of Wuthering Heights must consider the complex point of
view that Bront chose. Lockwood tells the entire story, but except for his
experiences as the renter of Thrushcross Grange and his response to Nelly and
the inhabitants of Wuthering Heights, he repeats what Nellie tells him;
occasionally she is narrating what others have told her, e.g., Isabella's
experiences at Wuthering Heights or the servant Zillah's view of events.
Consequently, at times we are three steps removed from events. Contrary to
what might be expected with such narrative distance from events, we do not feel
emotionally distant from the characters or events. Indeed, most readers are
swept along by the impetuosity and tempestuous behavior of Heathcliff and
Catherine, even if occasionally confused by the time shifts and the duplication of
names. Bront's ability to sweep the reader while distancing the narration reveals
her mastery of her material and her genius as a writer.
What makes a work Gothic is a combination of at least some of these elements:
a castle, ruined or intact, haunted or not (the castle plays such a key role that it
has been called the main character of the Gothic novel), ruined buildings which
are sinister or which arouse a pleasing melancholy, dungeons, underground
Unfairness dominates the lives of Tess and her family to such an extent that it
begins to seem like a general aspect of human existence in Tess of the
dUrbervilles. Tess does not mean to kill Prince, but she is punished anyway, just
as she is unfairly punished for her own rape by Alec. Nor is there justice waiting
in heaven. Christianity teaches that there is compensation in the afterlife for
unhappiness suffered in this life, but the only devout Christian encountered in the
novel may be the reverend, Mr. Clare, who seems more or less content in his life
anyway. For others in their misery, Christianity offers little solace of heavenly
justice. Mrs. Durbeyfield never mentions otherworldly rewards. The converted
Alec preaches heavenly justice for earthly sinners, but his faith seems shallow
and insincere. Generally, the moral atmosphere of the novel is not Christian
justice at all, but pagan injustice. The forces that rule human life are absolutely
unpredictable and not necessarily well-disposed to us. The pre-Christian rituals
practiced by the farm workers at the opening of the novel, and Tesss final rest at
Stonehenge at the end, remind us of a world where the gods are not just and fair,
but whimsical and uncaring. When the narrator concludes the novel with the
statement that Justice was done, and the President of the Immortals (in the
Aeschylean phrase) had ended his sport with Tess, we are reminded that justice
must be put in ironic quotation marks, since it is not really just at all. What
passes for Justice is in fact one of the pagan gods enjoying a bit of sport, or a
frivolous game.
One of the recurrent themes of the novel is the way in which men can dominate
women, exerting a power over them linked primarily to their maleness.
Sometimes this command is purposeful, in the mans full knowledge of his
exploitation, as when Alec acknowledges how bad he is for seducing Tess for his
own momentary pleasure. Alecs act of abuse, the most life-altering event that
Tess experiences in the novel, is clearly the most serious instance of male
domination over a female. But there are other, less blatant examples of womens
passivity toward dominant men. When, after Angel reveals that he prefers Tess,
Tesss friend Retty attempts suicide and her friend Marian becomes an alcoholic,
which makes their earlier schoolgirl-type crushes on Angel seem disturbing. This
devotion is not merely fanciful love, but unhealthy obsession. These girls appear
utterly dominated by a desire for a man who, we are told explicitly, does not even
realize that they are interested in him. This sort of unconscious male domination
of women is perhaps even more unsettling than Alecs outward and self-conscious
cruelty.