Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Boston University African Studies Center and Board of Trustees, Boston University are collaborating with
JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The International Journal of African Historical Studies.
http://www.jstor.org
THE PRAZEROS AS
TRANSFRONTIERSMEN: A
STUDY IN SOCIAL AND
CULTURAL CHANGE1
Allen Isaacman and BarbaraIsaacman
Fifteenth-century maritime expansion precipitated an unprecedented exchange of ideas and technology between Europeand the indigenous societies of Africa, Asia, and Latin America.2While scholars
have focused on the broadpoliticaland economic impactof the overseas exploration,they have been less concerned with patternsof local
interaction and the concomitant processes of social change. Recently
social scientists have developed a number of analyticalmodels to interpret the outcome of culturalcontact between Europeanoverseas communities and the indigenous populations. These forms range from
pluralsocieties, with their separatistideologies, to new hybridcultures.
While interculturationhas been recognizedas a common phenomenon
on the frontier,3scholars have failed to consider the possibility that
'This paper originallywas preparedfor the SchoulerLectureSymposiumon Creole
Societiesin the Americasand Africa held at the Johns HopkinsUniversity,9-10 April
1973.The authorsare gratefulto Jack P. Greene, departmentof history,Johns Hopkins
University,and to his colleaguesfor the opportunityto participatein the symposiumand
for permissionto publish the paperin its present form.We also wish to thank Franklin
Knight for his concurrence;he will be editing a volume in which the Schoulersymposium, includinga version of this paper,will appear.We are indebtedto Peter Carroll,
Philip Curtin, Paul Lovejoy,StuartSchwartz,and StuartWagner for their penetrating
criticismsof an earlierdraft of this paper.Susan Isaacmanalso added significantcomments to a preliminaryversion,and John Modellprovidedextremelyvaluableassistance
was firstadvancedby Philip
with the demographicdata.The concept of transfrontiersmen
Curtinduringa series of lectureson comparativetropicalhistorywhich he presentedin
1966 at the Universityof Wisconsin.
2SeeW.H. McNeill, TheRise of the West(Chicago,1963), for an examinationof this
process of cross-fertilization.
3Fora general discussionof variousapproachesto the frontier,see Paul Bohannan
and Fred Plog, eds., Beyondthe Frontier(Garden City, 1967); Owen Lattimore,"The
Frontierin History,"in Owen Lattimore,ed., Studiesin FrontierHistory(London, 1962),
469-491.
TheInternational
JournalofAfricanHistoricalStudies,VIII,1 (1975)
ALLENISAACMANand BARBARAISAACMAN
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
ALLENISAACMANand BARBARAISAACMAN
THEPRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
In terms of composition,life style, and loyalty,the seventeenth-century prazero community fulfilled the broad expectations of the Por-
tuguese crown. The small group of prominent families included individualswho had been awardedestates in recognitionof their standing in metropolitansociety as well as royal agents who had performed
outstandingservices for the crown.Othersrepresentedin the elite were
priests, successful merchants,and former militaryofficers.As a group
they rigorously adhered to Lisbon's colonizing principles and saw
themselves as the progenitorsof a permanent Portuguese racial and
culturalcommunity.
Throughout the seventeenth and early part of the eighteenth centuries, the principal families enjoyed a virtual monopoly of wealth,
power, and prestige. As in Lisbon, they formed carefully calculated
marriagealliancesdesigned to reinforceand perpetuatetheir privileged
positions.22Perhapsthe most successful were the descendants of Sisnando Bayao.By graduallyexpandingtheir web of maritalunions, the
family created a personal empire which by the middle of the eighteenth century included nine prazos,several thousand warriorslaves,
2For a general discussion of the contractual relationship between the state and the
prazero, see Isaacman, Mozambique,95-101; Alexandre Lobato, ColonizaqdoSenhorial da
Zambezia (Lisbon, 1962), 97-116; Alexandre Lobato, Evolufo Administrativae Econ6mica
de Mo%ambique
(Lisbon, 1957), 209-225.
2"Lobato,Evolufao, 209-225.
22Barretto,"Informaao," 463-478; ANTT, Ministerio do Reino, Maco 604: Antonio
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
28Ibid.,473.
cathedralswere builton prazosLuabo,Cheringoma,Caya,and Monga,among
29Large
others.
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
10
ALLENISAACMANand BARBARAISAACMAN
of the muzungos live more like Africans than the kaffirs live like
Christians."36
Throughoutthe eighteenth centurythe social and racialcomposition
of the prazerocommunitychanged dramatically.In partthe shift can be
attributed to the failure of several elaborately planned immigration
schemes, the largestof which resultedin the settlement of only seventy-eight men, women, and children.Of this group,fourteendied almost
immediately upon arrival.37As late as 1750 the governor of the Rivers
THEPRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
11
12
affected the demographic structure of the Portuguese community. Although detailed statistics for this period are unavailable, parish records
from Sena and Tete at the end of the eighteenth century illustrate the
joint effects of these variables (see tables 1 and 2). Despite the questionable quality of the statistics and the failure to distinguish actual
births from baptisms, the data reveal a dramatic loss of total population
each year. Such a conclusion is consistent with that drawn from a comparison of the general censuses of 1722 and 1802, which provides
graphic evidence of the inability of the Portuguese to perpetuate themselves. During this period the "white population" decreased from 300
to 282, of which a substantial number were recently arrived Indians.49
TABLE 1
AGE:
1786
1789
1790
1791
1792
0-7
7-15
15-60
8
17
19
30
42
18
22
22
22
24
375
379
375
369
358
over 60
6
9
9
8
8
Total
407
427
427
429
432
FEMALES
YEAR
AGE:
1786
1789
1790
1791
1792
0-7
7-12
12-40
over 40
Total
7
10
12
12
16
14
18
18
18
28
193
196a
196b
196b
239c
42
49
49
49
49
256
273
275
275
322
de Tette, 31 Dec. 1789; A.H.U., Moq.,Cx. 27: Vigariode Tette, 31 Dec. 1790;
A.H.U., Moc., Cx. 28: Fr. Vicente de Jezus, Vigario, 29 Dec. 1791; A.H.U.,
Moc., Cx. 29: Fr. Felix de S. Antonio Silva, 31 Dec. 1792.
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
13
TABLE 2
YEAR BAPTISMSDEATHS
BEARING
WOMEN
(12-40)
FERTILITY MORTALITY
RATE
RATE
1786
19
21
193
98
32
1789
1790
1791
1792
14d
17
24
24
39
34
30
35
196a
196b
196b
239c
71
87
122
100
56
49
43
46
This demographic trend can be explained either in terms of low fertility, high mortality, or a combination of the two. The data from Tete at
the end of the eighteenth century (see table 2) will be used to illustrate
the ways in which these variables interacted. The Tete community had
a rather high average fertility rate of 98 per thousand. Converted into
individual rates of reproduction, this meant that women who survived
to age forty would average between five and six live births. Nevertheless, the high rate of reproduction was outweighed by an even higher
average raw mortality rate of 42.5 deaths per thousand. Given the age
structure of Tete and assuming that it was a stable population,50 the intrinsic mortality rate would jump to 48 deaths per thousand.5 Viewed
50A theoretically stable population means one in which the birth rate and death rate
do not vary over several generations and which is characterized by neither in- nor outmigration.
5'From the information in table 2 an average fertility rate was computed for the
period by averaging both the number of child-bearing women and the number of births.
This figure was then used as a guide to locating a population with a similar birth rate and
age structure from the model life tables compiled from historical data on Europe and the
United States. See Ansley J. Cole and Paul Demeny, Regional Model Life Tables and Stable
Populations (Princeton, 1966). The Tete population was found to correspond best to the
southern variant. Utilizing the intrinsic fertility and mortality rates associated with the
southern variant and assuming a normal age distribution, which was far from the case, a
mortality rate of 48/1000 was calculated.
14
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
52During this period there were forty-eight deaths and thirty-two births in Sena.
AHU, Mog., Cx. 26: Francisco Joao Pinto, 1788; AHU, Moc., Cx. 27: Francisco Joao Pinto, 3 Feb. 1790; AHU, Moc., Cx. 27: Francisco Joao Piito, 15 Feb. 1791: AHU, Moc., Cx.
27: Francisco Joao Pinto, 1 Jan. 1792; AHU, Moc., Cx. 29: Francisco Joao Pinto, 1 Jan.
1793; AHU, Moc., Cx. 31: Francisco Joao Pinto, "Relaqao dos Habitantes da Villa de
Senna...," 1 Jan. 1794; AHU, Mo;., Cx. 32: Fr. Ant6nio de Santa Arma, Prior, 3 Jan.
1796. The data for the year 1794 is missing from the archives.
53AHU, Mo;., Cx. 3: Fr. Fernando Jesus (MA), 13 April 1752; AHU, Moc., Cx. 19:
Comerciantes Portuguezes (Vitorino Joze Gracias, et al.) to Jeronimo Jose Noqueira, 29
April 1783; Ajuda, 52-X-2, No. 3: Jose Francisco Alves Barbosa, "Analyse estatistica,"
30 Dec. 1821.
54AHU, Moc., Cx. 15: pe Manoel Pinto da Concei ao, Vigario, 5 July 1777.
"The famous nineteenth-century prazeros Gambete, Ferrao, Bonga, and Chicucuru
were all married to daughters of the mambo.
15
TABLE3
Mulattos
Whites
BIRTHS
(1740-1801)
1340
188
DEATHS
(1775-1801)
179
120
SOURCE:
A.H.U., Moc., Cx. 40: "RellacaoCircunstanciadode Nascimentos, Cazamentos,e.... havidos nesta Frequeziade SantaCatharinade Villa
de Senna" (unsigned, undated).
tian births and deaths in Sena clearlydemonstratethe natureand direction of racialchange throughoutmuch of the eighteenth century (see
table 3).
There is no reasonto believe that a similarpatterndid not hold for Portuguese living in or near the towns of Quelimaneand Tete. Since most
of the prazerocommunity resided in isolated ruralareas, the growing
racialimbalancewas probablyeven more pronouncedamong this sector of transfrontiersociety.
Scatteredracialand demographicdata from Sena and Tete provide
diachronicindicatorsof the direction of racialchange. They, like the
previous statistics,must be treatedas suggestive, since the inaccuracy
of the figures as well as the unclear racialcategoriesused in the 1735
census limit their reliability.
The data presented above are consistent with a census of the entire
Zambezi conducted in 1819. Because this reportincluded the coastal
town of Quelimane,which historicallyhad a higher ratioof Europeans,
a somewhat smaller percentageof mulattos is to be expected. In 1819
56ANTT, Ministerio do Reino, Malo 604: Antonio Pinto de Miranda, "Mem6ria sobre
a Costa de Africa," 30-31, undated.
57Ibid., 44; AHU, MoC., Cx. 15: Balthazar Manuel Pereyra to the queen, 30 Aug. 1775.
16
ALLENISAACMANand BARBARAISAACMAN
TABLE4
1735
percent no.
22.8
188
16.2
147
60.0
489
1777
percent no.
1802
percent no.
14.6
103
23.3
253
Portuguese
Goans
18.5
130
Pardosa
66.9
471
76.6
666
(Mulattos)
aThe unclear categories in the 1735 census were filhos da terraand rol de
molhos.Both have been includedhere underpardos.
SOURCES:
A.H.U., Moc,.,Cx. 3: Jeronymede Sau,"Rol dos Frequesesde Santa Maria deste Frequeziade Senna," 1735; A.H.U., Mo?., Cx. 3: "Lista dos
Christaons,e Frequezosde Tette da Administracaodos Rios de Senna,"E. Fr.
Matteusde S. Thomas,6 May 1735; A.H.U., Mo?.,Cx. 15: pe Manoel Pinto da
Conceicao, Vigirio, 6 July 1777; A.H.U., Moc., Cx. 15: Antonio Jose Lobo,
"Pardose os Negros que existem nas tres villas do Districtodo Governo desses
Rios de Sena, 1802," unsigned, undated.
racially-mixed individuals comprised 61.6 percent of the total Christian
population, while Europeans and Goans represented 12.9 percent and
25.5 percent respectively.58 Oral testimonies relating to this period support this general conclusion. According to informants whose ancestors
resided on prazos in the Tete and Sena regions, the vast majority of
prazeros were mizungu.59By the middle of the nineteenth century there
were almost no Portuguese in the Zambezi Valley, suggesting that
racial absorption was virtually complete.60
Inextricably related to shifting racial patterns within the prazerocommunity was the process of cultural transformation. According to acculturation theory, the specific cultural configuration which emerges as
a result of contact is a function of whether the borrowed cultural elements are additive or substitutive, whether they are compatible with
the host culture, and whether the host culture can absorb change without fundamentally altering its core institutions. Because of the inter-
17
6'Bronislaw Malinowski, The Dynamics of CultureChange (New Haven, 1961), 58, 80;
Melville J. Herskovits and William R. Bascom, "The Problem of Stability and Change in
African Culture," in William R. Bascom and Melville J. Herskovits, eds., Continuityand
Change in African Cultures(Chicago, 1962), 6; Social Science Research Council Summer
Seminar on Acculturation, 1953, "Acculturation: An Exploratory Formulation," American Anthropologist,56 (Dec., 1954), 973-1002; M. Fortes, "Culture Contact as a Dynamic
Process," Africa, 9 (Jan., 1936), 24-55; Wilbert E. Moore, Social Change (Englewood
Cliffs, 1963), 13, 86.
62Fr. Joao de Pilar and Manoel Ant6nio Ribeiro, "Edital da Inquisicao de Goa," in
Joaquim Helidoro da Cunha Rivara, ed., O Chronistade Tissuary(Nova Goa, 1867), 274.
63Lacerda e Almeida, Travessia, 100-101.
64For an interesting discussion of the problems of the ethnographic present, see Jan
Vansina, "Anthropologists and the Third Dimension," Africa, 39 (1969), 62-68. Two
other valuable articles examining the interrelationship of history and anthropology are
Jan Vansina, "The Use of Ethnographic Data as a Source for History," in T.O. Ranger,
ed., Emerging Themes in African History (Nairobi, 1968), 97-125; Bernard Cohn, "An
Anthropologist among Historians," South Atlantic Quarterly,61 (1962), 13-29.
18
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
THEPRAZEROSAS TRANSFRONTIERSMEN
19
The remainderof this paperwill describeand explain the Africanization of the prazerocommunity. For the purpose of illustration, two
prominent nineteenth-century transfrontiersmenand their families,
the Pereirasand the Cruzes,about whom informationis abundant,will
be discussedin some detail.The generalconclusions drawnfrom these
case studies will then be tested against the less specific data on the
largerprazerocommunity. Implicit in the entire discussion is a juxtapositionof prazerosociety in the first half of the nineteenth century
with its late seventeenth-century frontierantecedents. While it is impossible to isolate intermediateforms or to determinethe natureof the
process of acculturation,such an approachenables us to make specific
diachroniccomparisonsand to suggest some preliminaryexplanations.
The Pereira family migrated from Goa around the middle of the
eighteenth century and rapidlybecame involved in the profitableivory
and slave trade north of the Zambezi River. As part of their activities
they amassed a large number of slaves. Towardthe end of the eighteenth century Goncalo Caetano Pereira,known more commonly as
Chamatowaor Dombo-Dombo, established a close relationship with
Undi, the king of the Chewa.In a gesture of friendshipUndi presented
either Chamatowaor his son Chicucuru with a maternal relative in
marriage.This marriageallianceproved mutuallybeneficial; when dissident forces within his kingdom rose against Undi, the Pereirasprovided direct militaryassistancewhich enabled him to crush the revolt.
In repaymentUndi presented the Pereiraswith the secessionist fringe
area of his empire known as Makanga.The gift not only carriedthe
customary political rights which Undi conferred on all his territorial
chiefs, but it explicitly authorizedthe subjugationof the hostile chieftaincies, which the Pereirasdid with the help of their warriorslaves.68
67Ajuda, 52-X-2, No. 3: Jose Francisco Alves Barbosa, "Analyse estatfstica," 30 Dec.
1821.
68Interviews with Chiponda Cavumbula, Conrado Msussa Boroma, Leao Manuel
Banqueiro Caetano Pereira, Simon Biwi; joint interviews with Calavina Couche and
Zabuca Ngombe and with Chetambara Chenungo and Wilson John; "Viagem as Terras
da Macanga, Apontamentos colhidos d'um relat6rio do padre Victor Jos6 Courtois,
vigario de Tete, 1885," BOM, 29 (1886), 361; Jose Fernandes, Jdnior, "Hist6ria de Undi"
(unpublished manuscript, Makanga, n. d.), 17; AHU, Moc., Cx. 8: Manoel de Caetano, 5
March 1760; BNL, Pombalina 721, fol. 300: Francisco Jose de Lacerda e Almeida to D.
Rodrigues Coutinho, 21 March 1798; AHU, Mot., MaCo 38: Nicollo Pascoal da Cruz, ca.
1810.
20
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
Having gained recognition as sovereigns, Chicucuru and his successors legitimated their position by stressing their marriage alliance
with Undi and their personal identification with the Chewa king.
Toward this end Chicucuru's heir apparent adopted the title chissaca
maturi, which was one of Undi's most prestigious praise names. To
strengthen their claim, they also negotiated marriage alliances with
principal amamboand village headmen and adopted a number of rituals
and symbols of kingship. Each new ruler of Makanga underwent extensive rites of investiture after the council of elders and land chiefs
had selected him from among Pereira family members, gave ritual approbation to newly appointed amambo, and helped to propitiate the ancestor spirits in times of national crises.69
While the adoption of these aspects of kingship tended to increase
their legitimacy by blurring their differences from the indigenous
population, there is no evidence that this represented a calculated effort
to enhance their prestige and power. It was more likely part of a larger
process of acculturation which dramatically altered their life style, cosmology, and mode of social organization. In 1830 one Portuguese
official described Chicucuru as "an ignorant individual of dark complexion, who lives like the Africans and their chiefs, not only dressing
like them but adopting all their customs, beliefs and superstitions going
so far as to have a house full of remedies [charms] to protect himself
against evil."70 Oral traditions collected among the people of Makanga
and from a descendant of the Pereiras confirm this general portrayal of
Chicucuru and his heirs. According to these testimonies, they dressed
in capulano, or African loin cloths, ate African foods, generally lived in
African thatched huts, and spoke Chi-Nyanja rather than Portuguese.71
Their adoption of the Chewa cosmology and religious system most
graphically demonstrates the extent of their acculturation. Like the
members of the local population they believed in ancestor worship, ac69Jose Fernandes, Jdnior, "Narra9ao do Distrito de Tete" (unpublished manuscript,
11:
Makanga, 1955), 105; AHM, Fundo do Seculo XIX, Tete, Governo do Distrito, Cx.
FunAugusto Fonseca de Mesquita e Solla to Governador de Tete, 26 June 1888; AHM,
do do Seculo XIX, Governador do Quelimane, Cx. 7: Anselmo Joaquim Nunes de
Andrade to Joao de Souza Machado, 12 April 1858; AHU, Mop., Pasta 30: Anselmo Joaof
quim Nunes de Andrade, 28 Nov. 1875; personal communication on the borrowing
the praise name with Harry W. Langworthy, 11 Dec. 1968.
da
70BOM, 3 (1861), 13: Jos6 Manoel Correia Monteiro (Major Ex-Commandante
Feira do Aruangoa do Morte, Commandante da Praca e interino da Villa de Tete) to
de
Manoel Joaquim Mendes de Vasconcellos Cirne (Governador da Capitania
1830.
Quelimane e Rios de Sena), 13 June
7Interviews with Chiponda Cavumbula and Leao Manuel Banquiero Caetano
Pereira; joint interviews with Calavina Couche and Zabuca Ngombe and with Chetambara Chenungo and Wilson John.
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
21
knowledgingthe midzimuas the vital link between man and the distant
deities. They maintainedburialshrines, or kucisi,and an elaborateroyal
grave site which they visited periodicallyfor religiousceremonies and
in times of crisis.72At these ceremonies they propitiatedthe midzimu
and beseeched them to providerain,insure fertility,help them against
their enemies, and give them wisdom to make importantdecisions.73
Thus before negotiating a treaty with the Portuguese in 1875,
Chicucuru'sdescendant Saka-Sakaconferred with the ancestor spirits
to determine the wisdom of such an act.74Over time the burial sites of
22
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
their family was thought to have been responsible for the murder of
the reigningmonarchof Makanga,and before he could become eligible
to replace the dead ruler he had to undergo muabvi19
The system of socialorganizationalso became modifiedover time, although the evidence on this factoris less conclusive. The Pereiraswere
incorporatedinto the local clan, Malunga, practiced polygamy, acknowledged the primacy of the senior wife, and adopted a unilineal
system of inheritance rather than retaining the Indian practice of
coparcenary.80Despite these shifts, throughout much of the nineteenth century they remained committed to patrilinealityratherthan
recognizingthe preeminenceof the matrilineage.The firstfive Pereiras
to rule Makanga,for example, were all related to Chamatowathrough
the male line. The royal descent system was challenged after 1870
when matrilinealsegments of the rulingfamily,which had been frozen
out of positions of status and power, forced the selection of Chicuacha
and later Chigagawith the supportof a number of importantChewa
amambo.The local historian,Chimpazi,explained their success in the
following terms: "This was consistent with the indigenous rules of descent, by which nephews or cousins always enjoy the right of inheritance when their claims are supportedby groupsof powerfulmen with
great influence or force."81While the appointmentof members of the
matrilineagewas undoubtedlyrelatedto the adoptionof other Chewa
culturalforms by the royalfamily,the fact that each of these kings was
subsequentlyoverthrownby a member of the patrilinealsegment suggests that the descent system remained in flux. The Portugueseconquest of Makangain 1901 ousted the Pereirasbefore a clear patternof
bilateralityor matrilinealityhad emerged.
At approximatelythe same time that Chicucururuled in Makanga,
the da Cruzfamily,more commonly known by the Africanname of the
Bongas,establishedits hegemony over the patrilinealTongachieftaincies located near the confluence of the Zambezi and Luenha rivers.
Like their counterpartsto the north, the Bongas were of mixed Asian
and Africandescent. The firstCruzcame to Mozambiquein the middle
79AHU, Mot., Pasta 30: Anselmo Joaquim Nunes de Andrade (Capitao-Mor do Distrito), 28 Nov. 1875.
80Interviews with Chiponda Cavumbula, Leao Manuel Banqueiro Caetano Pereira,
and Simon Biwi; joint interviews with Calavina Couche and Zabuca Ngombe and with
Chetambara Chenungo and Wilson John; AHU, Moc., Pasta 30: Anselmo Joaquim
Nunes de Andrade, 18 Nov. 1875. For a discussion of coparcenary, or collective ownership among the three generations of male descendants (sons, grandsons, and greatgrandsons) of the deceased, see A.M. Shah, "Basic Terms and Concepts in the Study of
Family in India," Indian Economic and Social History Review, 1 (1964), 10-14.
8"Fernandes, Junior, "Narracao," 110.
THEPRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
23
24
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
THEPRAZEROSAS TRANSFRONTIERSMEN
25
culture and skills facilitatedtheir adaptationto a new and difficultenvironment.Borrowingitself was not proofof significantculturechange,
since artifacts, except for those with symbolic value, tended to be
culturallyneutral.It createdno conflict, therefore,for the nineteenthcentury prazerosto adopt aspects of the local material culture while
maintaining others from their Portuguese past. The premium many
placed on specific wines and European luxury items supports this
point.96
90The mhondoro, or national guardian spirit, is a characteristic religious institution
among all Shona peoples. For a brief discussion of the mhondoro,see Allen Isaacman,
"Madzi-manga, Mhondoro, and the Use of Oral Traditions," Journal of African History,
XIV, 3 (1973).
9lInterviews with Conrado Msussa Boroma, Chale Lupia, Domingo Kunga, and Chacundunga Mavico; AHM, Fundo do Seculo XIX, Tete, Governo do Distrito, Cx. 11: Anto'nio Joaquim Goncalves Maceiras to Governador de Tete, 6 Oct. 1888; Castilho, Relatorio de Guerra, 35; R.P.R. Wallis, ed., The Zambesi Expedition of David Livingstone
1858-1863 (London, 1956), I, 42.
92Wallis, Zambesi Expedition, I, 42.
93Interview with Conrado Msussa Boroma.
94Castilho, Relato'riode Guerra,35.
95Interviews with Joao Pomba, Zacarias Ferrao, Jose Antonio d'Abreu, Antonio Vas;
joint interviews with Tomas Chave and Oliveira Sinto.
96Importlists from the beginning of the nineteenth century indicate a strong demand
for wine and other metropolitan luxuries. See Antonio Norberto de Barbosa de Villas
Boas Truao, Estattsticas da Capitania dos Rios de Sena no Anno de 1806 (Lisbon, 1889).
26
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
27
and the orderingof the universe which clearly fell outside the bounds
of Christianityand Hinduism.
The prazerosviewed witchcraftas one element in a complex belief
system which interpretedthe relationshipbetween naturalphenomena
and the moralorder.The worldwas thought to be divinely orderedby a
distantcreatorGod who in conjunctionwith ancestorspiritsprovideda
supernaturalumbrella for those mortals who acted properly. Given
these assumptions, it is not surprising that many estate holders
established ancestralshrines, participatedin first fruit ceremonies, and
invoked the midzimuin times of crisis.102The causal relationshipbetween moralityand divine intervention is a substantialdeparturefrom
both the Judeo-Christianbelief that God often lets his servants suffer
(as in the Book of Job) and the Hindu metaphysicalsystem premised
on dharma and kharma.103
The indigenous belief structureprovidedan explanationfor the random occurrence of serious illnesses, barrenness, and other misfortunes. These problems were particularlydifficult to understandif, as
often happened,the injuredpartywas a respectedmember of the community and the situation appearedto be a case of unmerited suffering.104This apparentcontradictionwas resolved by recognizingthe existence of evil forces whose power had to be destroyed-thus the
reliance on muabviand the use of charms to counteractthe threat of
sorcerers.
In addition to sorcerers, another category of diviners performed
magical feats which were not antisocial for members of the prazero
community.Before going on a dangeroustripor participatingin an im102Interviews with Chiponda Cavumbula, Leao Manuel Banqueiro Caetano Pereira,
Conrado Msussa Boroma, Chale Lupia, Domingo Kunga, Chacundunga Mavico, Andisseni Tessoura, and Dauce Angolete Gogodo; joint interviews with Tomas Chave and
Oliveira Sinto; AHU, Moc., Pasta 30: Anselmo Joaquim Nunes de Andrade, 28 Nov.
1875; "Viagem as Terras da Macanga, Apontamentos colhidos d'um relatorio do padre
Victor Jose Courtois, vigario de Tete, 1885," BOM, 29 (1886), 361; Newitt, "Historical
Interpretation," 82; AHM, Fundo do Seculo XIX, Tete, Governo do Distrito, Cx. 11: Antonio Joaquim Goncalves Maceiras to Governador de Tete, 6 Oct. 1888; Castilho, Relato'riode Guerra, 35; Wallis, Zambesi Expedition, I, 42; Joaquim d'Almeida da Cunha,
Estudo Ace'rcados Usos e os Costumes dos Banianes, Bathias, Pares, Mouros, Gentios e Indrgenas(Lourenco Marques, 1885), 93-98; Lacerda e Almeida, Travessia, 114-115.
103Dharma is defined as "action conforming to universal order" in Louis Dumont,
Homo Hierarchicus(Chicago, 1970), 251. Kharma is defined as "the effect of any action
upon the agent whether in this life or in a future one" in William Theodore de Bary, ed.,
Sources of Indian Tradition(New York, 1958), 39.
'04Lucy Mair, Witchcraft(New York, 1969), 11-12; Max Marwick, ed., Witchcraftand
Sorcery(London, 1970). The classic study of witchcraft in Africa was done by E.E. EvansPritchard, Witchcraft,Oracles and Magic among the Azande (London, 1937).
28
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
portant business venture, prazeros often sought the predictions of a diviner.105Livingstone portrayed the proliferation of specialized practitioners of magic in the Portuguese towns which he visited during the
middle of the nineteenth century.06 Similar practices occurred just
south of the Zambezi region in the town of Sofala and its hinterland.
The inhabitants of Sofala with the exception of the principalmen in
authority,and a few others, live in complete ignorance, being almost
rooted in the ideas and dominantsuperstitionsof the Kaffirs,in magic,
enchantments,etc., to the point of not sowing or harvestingtheir crops
without consulting a curandeirowho replies affirmativelyor negatively
accordingto the divinationof six cowry shells he carrieswith him.107
The broad system of beliefs to which the prazerosadhered was common to many African societies which lacked techniques for treating
everyday crises, most notably sickness.108To compensate for their inadequate knowledge, the prazerosnot only internalized indigenous cosmological assumptions but relied heavily on local herbalists, whom
they recognized as highly skilled medical practitioners.
[Dona Pascoa]... on hearing of Mr. Brown's death, expressed surprise
and grief, regrettingat the same time that Mr. Kilpatrickhad preferred
the Europeanpracticesto that of the natives, which she consideredto be
the only successful one.109
According to Governor Barbosa, Dona Pascoa's views enjoyed wide
support within the prazerocommunity, where any serious affliction was
immediately brought to the attention of an herbalist.110
To scandalized officials and travelers, the belief in witches and the
reliance on herbalists were unequivocal manifestations of cultural
regression. The level of illiteracy among prazeros reinforced this con'5Lacerda e Almeida, Travessia, 114-115.
106David Livingstone and Charles Livingstone, Narrative of an Expedition to the Zambesi and its Tributaries(London, 1865), 51.
'0Cited in Newitt, "Portuguese," 492.
'08"But there must be somewhere a theory of causation which can account for the
serious cases; and this is the theory that sickness, along with other misfortunes such as
barrenness of women or cattle, destruction of crops by a sudden storm, a bad harvest
when your neighbor has a good one, or even some unexplained accident such as falling
off a ladder, is sent by personalised beings, either spirits who have authority to punish
you or humans who envy or hate you. Death too, although it is irremediable, must be
assigned a cause." Mair, Witchcraft.9-10.
109W.F.W.Owen, Narrative of Voyages to Explore the Shores of Africa, Arabia, and
Madagascar (London, 1883), 81.
"OAjuda,52-X-2, No. 3: Jose Francisco Alves Barbosa, "Analyse estatfstica," 30 Dec.
1821. This is confirmed by AHU, Moc., Cx. 29: Jose Joao d'Araujo Aranha e Oliveira,
undated.
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
29
30
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
31
32
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
33
34
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
Cultural transformation had profound implications for government-prazerointeraction.Although a detailed analysis of the shifting
relationships falls outside the bounds of this paper, we suggest that
Africanizationof the transfrontiersmendirectlyaffectedtheir degree of
commitment to the metropole and motivated their resistance to Portuguese penetration from 1850 until the early twentieth century. By
operatingat a high level of generalization,it is possible to isolate trends
in their relations with Lisbon at differentpoints in time.
In the seventeenth century most prazerosthought of themselves as
imperialagents of the crown. SisnandoBayao, Ant6nio Lobo da Silva,
and Manoel Paes de Pinha, for example, were all willing to undertake
major ventures at substantial personal costs to demonstrate their
loyaltyto Lisbon.They acceptedthe feudal assumptionthat the king of
Portugalwas the legitimateand ultimate owner of all that his servants
had conquered.In returnthey askedonly that their limited holdingsbe
recognizedand that they receive symbolic rewardsfor their services to
the crown.
The highly formalizedrelationshipbetween king and subject contrastssharplywith the more typicalfrontier-metropolisconflicts of the
eighteenth century. During this period the prazerocommunity no
longer acknowledgeda subordinateposition and refusedto subsume its
interests to those of the state. Considerationsof patriotismand fealty
were replacedby a recognitionthat substantialareasof conflict existed
and that Lisbon lacked the capacity to enforce its restrictive legislation.135The prazerosmanifested their autonomy in a number of ways,
rangingfrom their refusal to pay taxes and provide militaryassistance
to explicit denials of the government'sclaim to be the ultimate owner
of their lands.136
Until the middle of the nineteenth century an uneasy modusvivendi
existed between the prazerosand the state. The inherent tension in
their relationshipwas obvious from the assessment by one officialthat
among any "groupof twenty prazeroseach one has nineteen enemies,
however all are the enemy of the Governor.'"37Hostilities remainedat
a minimum because local civilian and military officials refused to
challenge the autonomy of the prazeros;in those few cases when they
did the results were predictable."On being called up for his arrears"
one nineteenth-centuryprazero"threatenednot only the Governorof
the place but also the authorities at Mocambiquewith his slaves, in
135See Isaacman, Mozambique, 95-101.
1361bid.
'3'ANTT, Ministe'rio do Reino, Mapo 604: Inacio Caetano Xavier to Governador
Geral, 26 Dec. 1758.
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
35
39Fernandes,Junior,"Narragao,"50;
'40JoaquimCarlos Paiva de Andrada, "Campanhas da Zambezia," Boletim.da
Sociedade de Geografia de Lisboa, 7 (1887), 727-728.
36
ALLENISAACMANandBARBARAISAACMAN
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
37
38
Europe. Nomadic-sedentary conflicts, the growth of stranger communities within host populations, and the Chikunda diaspora suggest the
utility of frontiersmen and transfrontiersmenas analytical tools for the
study of aspects of precolonial African history.
APPENDIX
A List of Informants
Tape recordings of the oral interviews collected by the authors and
used in this article are deposited in the African Studies Association oral
data archives, which are housed in the Archive of Traditional Music,
Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana. The following is a list of the
informants interviewed, arranged by region.
REGION OFTETE
Boroma
Conrado Msussa Boroma, interview on 28 July, 17 Aug., 20 Aug., 29
Sept. 1968. T.T. #5(1), T.T. #5(2), T.T. #6(1), T.T. #6(2), T.T.
#6a(1), T.T. #6a(2); E.T. #3(2), E.T. #4(1), E.T. #4(2).
Village of Tete
Jose Antonio de Abreu, interview on 16 July, 22 July 1968. T.T. #3(1),
T.T. #3(2).
REGION OF MASSANGANO
Sena
Jasse Camalizene, interview on 6 Aug. 1968. T.T. #8(1); E.T. #5(1).
Esmail Mussa Valy, interview on 10 Aug. 1968. Untaped.
THE PRAZEROSASTRANSFRONTIERSMEN
39
Chemba
Ren9o Cado, interview on 13 Aug. 1968. T.T. #9(1), T.T. #9(2); E.T.
#6(1).
Tomas Chave and OliveiraSinto,joint interview on 14 Aug. 1968. T.T.
#9(2); E.T. #6(2).
Ant6nio Vas, interview on 13 Sept. 1968. T.T. #12(2); E.T.#9(1), E.T.
#9(2).
Caya