Professional Documents
Culture Documents
gated ion-channel activity using a pain strongly suggests this ion channel plays
an important role in pain transmission. At
the molecular level, TRPV1 responds to a
real-time PCR machine variety of stimuli including low pH, heat
(>42°C), capsaicin, and endogenous ligands
such as anandamide (14). This multiplicity
Derek S. Reubish, Daniel E. Emerling, Jeff DeFalco, Daniel Steiger, of agonists coupled with TRPV1’s impor-
Cheryl L. Victoria, and Fabien Vincent tance to pain states suggests that TRPV1
In Vitro Pharmacology Department, Evotec, South San Francisco, CA, USA may integrate several extracellular signals
of inflammatory and neuropathic pain,
BioTechniques 47:iii-ix (BioTechniques for Preclinical Development September 2009) doi 10.2144/000113198 thus making TRPV1 an attractive target
Keywords: Real-time PCR; temperature; heat; cold; ion channel; assay; TRP channel; thermosensor for the development of novel analgesics. As
low pH and the presence of inflammatory
Supplementary material for this article is available at www.BioTechniques.com/article/113198. mediators results in a decrease in TRPV1
gating temperature (15), temperature is a
physiologically relevant stimulus for the
The functional activity of a number of ion channels is highly sensitive to discovery and development of TRPV1
large changes in temperature. Foremost among these are the thermosensing antagonists as potential drugs (14).
TRP channels which include cold- (TRPM8, TRPA1), warmth- (TRPV3, TRPM8 is a member of the long or
melastatin family of TRP channels and
TRPV4), and heat-sensing (TRPV1, TRPV2) members. TRPV1, also was originally identified as an up-regulated
known as the vanilloid receptor (VR1), is activated by ligands such as transcript in a prostate cancer cell line (16).
It is expressed primarily in trigeminal and
capsaicin, acidic pH, and heat (an increase in temperature to ~42°C will dorsal root ganglia in both A and C fibers,
lead to channel opening). Screening against the thermal gating of TRPV1 almost exclusively from TRPV1- and
is generally performed using perfusion systems or water baths for tempera- TRPA1-expressing neurons (17). TRPM8 is
gated by menthol, icilin, and innocuous cold
ture control, in conjunction with electrophysiology or Ca2+ influx readouts (18–25°C; Q10 = 24). Recent results from
for direct functional assessment. These approaches are very useful, but have studies of TRPM8-deficient mice indicate
limited throughput or minimal thermo-temporal control. A standard real- that TRPM8 is necessary for proper cold
detection and cold-induced analgesia, and
time PCR machine with standard microplates allowed us to combine fluo- is at least partly responsible for mediating
rescent Ca2+ detection with precise temperature manipulation to develop a cold allodynia in neuropathic pain states
(18). Thus, it appears that TRPM8 could
homogeneous (Z′ = 0.53), cell-based assay that uses temperature as the ago- be a pharmacological target for indications
nist. A temperature response curve of TRPV1 was obtained, which provided involving cold hyperalgesia or allodynia.
a T50 of 46.1°C, and IC50 values against heat agonism were determined for Current TRP channel high-throughput
screening (HTS) assays are constructed
known TRPV1 antagonists. Furthermore, we expanded this approach to a around the use of either small-molecule
cold-activated ion channel, TRPM8. We developed and validated an analyti- agonists or other easily applicable stimuli
[e.g., capsaicin or protons (low pH) for
cal technique with broad applications for the study and screening of temper- TRPV1] to gate the channel and induce
ature-gated ion channels. Ca 2+ influx into cells. In these assays,
cells were first loaded with fluorescent
Ca2+-sensitive dyes followed by treatment
(K+), ClC-0 (Cl-), L-type (Ca2+), and transient with test compounds (antagonists). Cells
Introduction receptor potential (TRP) (Ca2+) channels were then exposed to an agonist and Ca2+
Temperature detection and regulation are (1–5). Perhaps most notable among these is influx was assessed by measuring changes
critical components of various homeostatic a set of TRP family members shown to be in intracellular fluorescence with platforms
and disease-related processes (e.g., thermal involved directly in thermal sensation with such as Flexstation or FLIPR (Molecular
adaptation, fever response, inflammation, cold- (TRPM8, TRPA1), warmth- (TRPV3, Devices, Sunnyvale, CA, USA). Interest-
etc.). Temperature-induced changes in ion TRPV4), and heat-sensing (TRPV1, TRPV2) ingly, to the best of our knowledge, there
channel conductance are one method by members (6–12). Additional members of this have been no published reports of microplate-
which biological systems receive and subse- family (TRPM2, TRPM4, and TRPM5) based assays using continuous temperature
quently quantify thermal information. were also recently shown to be temperature changes to trigger TRP channel opening.
The quantitative measure of temperature’s sensitive (13). However, the induction of stepwise, temper-
effect on a given channel is described by the TRPV1 is a well-described cation ature-mediated channel activation using
notation Q10, which denotes the fold change channel found in nociceptive neurons and buffers of differing temperature has been
in conductance over a span of ten degrees present in both C and Aδ fibers, as well as reported (19,20). While electrophysiology
Celsius. Specifically, large temperature in other neural and non-neural tissues (14). is another technology that can be used to
effects (Q10 > 4) have been documented for Transgenic mice lacking the TRPV1 gene do screen compounds using capsaicin and low
a number of ion channels such as the Shaker not develop inflammatory-mediated hyper- pH, it has a much lower throughput when
A Table 1. Comparison of hTRPV1 potency data obtained in the temperature and other assays for known
TRPV1 antagonists
Temperature assay Electrophysiology 3H-RTX binding assay
Antagonist
IC50, nM (sem)a IC50, nMb Ki, nM (sem)c
BCTC 5.37 (1.13) 4.40 6.18 (1.48)
I-RTX 6.06 (0.31) ND 7.97 (0.87)
SB-705498 44 (4) 357 95.9 (8.3)
AMG-9810 129 (0) 113 91.3 (16.9)
SB-366791 304 (58) 956 >2000
Capsazepine 3100 (1100) ND 1813 (402)
B aMean of 2–3 independent experiments. bSingle determination against 250 nM capsaicin. cMean of 3–6
independent experiments. ND, not determined.
purchased from Mediatech (Manassas, VA, a temperature between 37°C and 10°C, in
USA), Tocris-Cookson (Ellisville, MO, 3°C decrements, for 5 min. While no signif-
USA), Invitrogen (Carlsbad, CA, USA), and icant fluorescence was observed in heated
Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO, USA), respec- HEK293-TREx cells, some was observed
C tively. Other chemical compounds were syn- when cells were cooled to ≤10°C. Accord-
thesized in-house. ingly, background signal was subtracted
for TRPM8-expressing cells prior to data
Constructs and cell culture analysis.
The TRPV1 coding domain was amplified Z′ factor and IC50 experiments. Antag-
from a human DRG cDNA library (Clontech, onists were added to cells following the dye
Palo Alto, CA, USA) and the TRPM8 loading and cell plating steps. The following
coding domain sequence was amplified from programs were applied to the assay plate:
the Megaman human transcriptome library 22°C for 2 min followed by 50°C for 5 min
Figure 1. Heat-gated Ca2+ influx in hTRPV1 ex- (Stratagene, La Jolla, CA, USA). Full-length (for TRPV1) or 37°C for 2 min followed by
pressing cells. (A) Assay principle. The tem-
perature assay requires two components to be
coding domain sequences were ligated into 14°C for 5 min (for TRPM8), with fluores-
exchanged (DNA for cells and FITC for Fluo- pcDNA5TO and transfected into 293-TREx cence data collected throughout.
4) for the real-time PCR machine to provide a cells to generate stable TRPV1 or TRPM8-
cell-based assay where channel activation is expressing cell lines. Cells were cultured in Data analysis
controlled by temperature and monitored by DMEM, supplemented with 10% fetal bovine Raw results were exported to Excel for the
fluorescence. (B) Fluorescence time course serum (Hyclone, Logan, UT, USA), 100 U/ extraction of the fluorescence data collected
for cells treated with TRPV1 antagonist BCTC
(orange trace) or left untreated (green trace).
mL penicillin, 100 µg/mL streptomycin, 200 at the starting and ending temperatures,
The arrows indicate the time points chosen for µM glutamax, 5 µg/mL blasticidin and 200 which were used to calculate a fluores-
determining the fluorescence ratio (see “Mate- µg/mL hygromycin. TRPV1 (or TRPM8) cence ratio. IC50 (half maximal concen-
rials and methods” section). TRPV1-mediated expression was induced by adding 1 µg/mL tration) and T50 (temperature at which half
Ca2+ influx was observed upon exposure to doxycycline to the cell medium 24 h prior maximal signal is observed) curves were
50°C (green trace) while addition of BCTC to the assay. generated by fitting the fluorescence ratio
(300 nM) antagonized this response (orange
trace). (C) Temperature time course. Note the
data with a 4-parameter sigmoidal curve
correlation between high temperature in (C) Experimental protocols equation using GraphPad Prism (GraphPad
and signal induction in non-BCTC–treated cells Cell preparation. Media was removed Software, La Jolla, CA, USA):
in panel B. from the attached hTRPV1- (or hTRPM8-)
expressing cells and a 1-µM Fluo-4 AM dye
solution in PBS was applied for 30 min at
(top + bottom) ,
y = bottom + é ù
(log EC50 - x )*nH ûú
temperature is used as the channel-opening 37°C. Cells were then detached from the 1-10ëê
modality (21). In the current study, we tissue culture dish using EDTA, centri-
describe the use of a standard real-time PCR fuged, resuspended in PBS, counted with [Eq. 1]
machine to develop a cell-based, functional a hemacytometer (Model no. 1483, Hausser
assay employing temperature as an agonist Scientific, Horsham, PA, USA), and plated where EC50 is the concentration of agonist
for ion channel gating. We demonstrate this at 100,000 cells/well in a 96-well conical eliciting a response halfway between
assay’s potential for compound screening bottom PCR plate (Model no. EK-19280, the baseline (bottom) and maximum
and its use in the analysis of small molecules Greiner, Monroe, NC, USA). Temper- response (top), nH is the Hill slope and
targeting TRPV1. Furthermore, we subse- ature control over the cellular environment x = log(concentration or temperature).
quently describe the application of the assay was accomplished with an ABI 7700 Z′-factor and assay window (AW) determi-
to another temperature-sensitive TRP instrument (Applied Biosystems, Foster nation were performed using the following
channel, the cold sensor TRPM8. City, CA, USA). equations:
Temperature response curves. Cells
were plated and assayed one column at a 3 * ( sd max + sd min )
Materials and methods time as follows: for TRPV1, 22°C for 2 min Z′ = 1-
Mean max - Mean min
Reagents followed by a temperature of between 36°C
Tissue culture reagents, 5′-iodoresiniferatoxin and 54°C, in 2°C increments, for 5 min;
(I-RTX), Fluo-4 AM, and capsazepine were for TRPM8, 37°C for 2 min followed by [Eq. 2]
A B C
Figure 2. Assay characterization. (A) Temperature response curve for hTRPV1. TREx-hTRPV1 cells were exposed to a temperature curve (increasing in
increments of 2°C) and fluorescence ratios were calculated for each temperature. The temperature at which half of the hTRPV1 response is observed
is T50 = 46.1°C (95% confidence interval: 44.6–47.6°C). This experiment was performed independently three times and the results were combined
for analysis. Normalization was applied in order to control for ratio fluctuations between experiments and was calculated by dividing the ratio from
each temperature by the maximal ratio (in this case, obtained at 52°C) for that experiment. (B) Assay robustness as determined via Z′ factor analysis.
hTRPV1-expressing cells were plated in a 96-well format. In a checkerboard fashion, buffer or a buffer with BCTC were added in alternating wells.
Three independent experiments were performed for this Z′ factor determination and representative results are shown. (C) IC50 curve of TRPV1 antago-
nist BCTC. An IC50 curve was obtained for BCTC in TREx-hTRPV1 cells using a stimulation temperature of 50°C. The IC50 value obtained for BCTC is
5.4 nM (mean of three independent experiments) and a representative curve is shown (mean ± sem, n = 8).
A
The International Journal of Life Science Methods
Figure 3. Cold-gated Ca2+ influx in hTRPM8-expressing cells. (A) Temperature response curve for
hTRPM8-mediated Ca2+ influx. TREx-hTRPM8 cells were exposed to a temperature curve (de-
creasing in increments of 3°C) and fluorescence ratios were calculated for each temperature.
This experiment was performed independently twice and the results were combined for analysis.
Normalization was applied in order to control for ratio fluctuations between experiments and was
calculated by dividing the ratio from each temperature by the maximal ratio (in this case, obtained
at 13°C) for that experiment. The temperature at which half of the hTRPM8 response is observed
is T50 = 18.0°C (95% confidence interval: 17.1–18.9°C). (B) An IC50 curve was obtained for BCTC
in TREx-hTRPM8 cells using a stimulation temperature of 14°C. The average IC50 value obtained
for BCTC is 436 nM (95% confidence interval: 274–695 nM). This experiment was performed
independently twice and the results were combined for analysis (mean ± sem, n = 2).
BioTechniques
and higher-than-average threshold, and the temperature assay for other published E-Alerts
this integration will result in a shallower TRPV1 antagonists can be seen in Table 1.
response curve. All antagonists tested were capable of inhib- BioTechniques Weekly
iting heat activation of TRPV1. However, Weekly newsletter with industry insight
Assay characterization we, like others (25), found SB-366791 to for life scientists: news, new products,
In order to validate this assay for screening appear less potent than originally predicted grants deadlines, employment opportuni-
purposes, the statistical parameters of the (26) and capsazepine displayed a relatively
assay data were evaluated in 96-well format high IC50 as well. Interestingly, the ranking ties, and events.
using BCTC as a positive control. As can order of these compounds is mostly
be seen in Figure 2B, this temperature assay conserved in the three widely different Advance Online Publication (AOP)
displayed a Z′ factor of 0.53, above the assays chosen for comparison: calcium Monthly alert with select research papers
generally accepted threshold of 0.5 value influx with heat activation, electrophys- published online ahead of the print.
indicating that an assay is suitable for high iology with capsaicin stimulation, and
throughput screening (24). Additionally, binding with [3H]-Resiniferatoxin ([3H]- Table of Contents (TOC)
the assay window was calculated to be 0.38 RTX) displacement. These results are
fluorescence ratio units. consistent with the hypothesis that heat Monthly alert listing current papers and
activation of TRPV1 is susceptible to the their links allowing you to browse the
IC50 determination for known same inhibitory molecular mechanisms latest issue immediately.
TRPV1 antagonists to which other agonist modalities are
The inhibition of capsaicin- and low sensitive. Register today at
pH–activated TRPV1 by BCTC has www.BioTechniques.com/newsletters
been well characterized (22). We used this Application of the temperature
temperature assay to determine its potency assay to cold-sensing TRPM8
against heat-activated hTRPV1. Our In addition to TRPV1, the activation of
experimental data indicates that BCTC multiple other TRP channels (TRPV2,
is a potent inhibitor of heat-activated TRPV3, TRPV4, TRPA1, and TRPM8)
hTRPV1 calcium influx as well (Figure has been shown to be temperature-
2C, IC50 = 5.4 nM). Potency values in dependent. Gating by temperature across
a broad thermal spectrum can be seen for of equipment and personnel skills already 5. Dha k a, A ., V. Vis wa nath, a nd A .
TRP family members as both heat (e.g., present in most biology laboratories. Patapoutian. 2006. Trp ion channels and
temperature sensation. Annu. Rev. Neurosci.
TRPV1) and cold (e.g., TRPM8) can Similarly, a radioactive 45Ca 2+ influx 29:135-161.
lead to channel opening. Accordingly, we assay—where TRPV1-expressing cells were 6. Pe i e r, A . M . , A . Mo q r i c h , A .C .
applied this temperature assay to cold- placed in a 45°C water bath—was published Hergarden, A.J. Reeve, D.A. Andersson,
activated TRPM8 to assess the utility recently and can be used to characterize G.M. Story, T.J. Earley, I. Dragoni, et al.
of this assay platform for studying and select compounds (20). However, this 2002. A TRP channel that senses cold stimuli
screening against cold-sensing channels. approach does not provide the kinetic, and menthol. Cell 108:705-715.
7. McKemy, D.D., W.M. Neuhausser, and D.
A protocol similar to that followed in real-time read of channel activity nor the Julius. 2002. Identification of a cold receptor
TRPV1 experiments was utilized with the thermo-temporal control over the cellular reveals a general role for TRP channels in
exception that TRPM8 cells were initially environment that the approach herein thermosensation. Nature 416:52-58.
held at 37°C before their temperature was provides. Importantly, temperature acts 8. S t o r y, G . M . , A . M . Pe i e r, A . J .
subsequently lowered to sub-physiological as an activation mechanism for multiple Reeve, S.R. Eid, J. Mosbacher, T.R. Hricik,
levels. As shown previously with TRPV1, other TRP family members, some of which T.J. Earley, A.C. Hergarden, et al. 2003.
ANKTM1, a TRP-like channel expressed
a temperature response curve depicting do not have well characterized direct in nociceptive neurons, is activated by cold
the activation of TRPM8 as a function small-molecule agonists. The technique temperatures. Cell 112:819-829.
of decreasing temperatures could be presented here may be useful in studies of 9. Peier, A.M., A.J. Reeve, D.A. Andersson, A.
obtained (Figure 3A) with a T50 of 18.0°C, these channels. Moqrich, T.J. Earley, A.C. Hergarden, G.M.
consistent with the thresholds reported The potential importance of charac- Story, S. Colley, et al. 2002. A heat-sensitive
for TRPM8 activation using electrophys- terizing an antagonist’s ability to inhibit TRP channel expressed in keratinocytes.
Science 296:2046-2049.
iology in mammalian cells heterologously heat gating of TRPV1 is exemplified by 10. Gu ler, A .D., H. L ee, T. I id a , I.
expressing TRPM8 (6,7). Each data point capsazepine. This TRPV1 antagonist Shimizu, M. Tominaga, and M. Caterina.
was obtained from an independent set of inhibits capsaicin-activated rat TRPV1 2002. Heat-evoked activation of the ion
naive cells that were not previously cooled. completely, but displays only partial channel, TRPV4. J. Neurosci. 22:6408-
The TRPV1 antagonist BCTC is also an inhibition of heat-activated rTRPV1 and 6414.
antagonist of menthol-activated TRPM8, has no effect on activation by low pH. This 11. C a t e r i n a , M .J. , T. A . R o s e n , M .
Tominaga, A.J. Brake, and D. Julius. 1999.
albeit at much higher concentrations (27). decoupling of inhibition toward different A capsaicin-receptor homologue with a high
Application of BCTC to cold-activated activation mechanisms was hypothesized threshold for noxious heat. Nature 398:436-
TRPM8 expressing cells prevented Ca 2+ to be responsible for the lack of efficacy 441.
influx at high concentrations (10 µM) and observed in pain studies conducted in 12. H a y e s , P. , H . J . M e a d o w s , M . J .
its IC50 was determined to be 436 nM rats treated with capsazepine (25,28). In Gunthorpe, M.H. Harries, D.M. Duckworth,
(Figure 3B), a result consistent with the these regards, a screening approach using W. Cairns, D.C. Harrison, C.E. Clarke, et al.
2000. Cloning and functional expression of a
values obtained against menthol-activated temperature as the agonist may hold human orthologue of rat vanilloid receptor-1.
TRPM8 in-house [IC50 = 438 nM (95% particular value in drug development. This Pain 88:205-215.
confidence interval: 261–733 nM), data not study demonstrates the usefulness of this 13. Talavera, K., K. Yasumatsu, T. Voets,
shown] and reported previously by others technique with both heat- (TRPV1) and G. Droogmans, N. Shigemura, Y. Ninomiya,
using electrophysiology (27). These results cold- (TRPM8) activated ion channels for R.F. Margolskee, and B. Nilius. 2005. Heat
illustrate that this technical approach is screening and characterization purposes. activation of TRPM5 underlies thermal sensi-
tivity of sweet taste. Nature 438:1022-1025.
suitable for the study of the cold-activated 14. Sza l lasi, A., D.N. Cor tright, C . A.
ion channel TRPM8. Acknowledgments Blum, and S.R. Eid. 2007. The vanilloid
Under physiological conditions, temper- receptor TRPV1: 10 years from channel
ature can act as an endogenous agonist for We wish to thank Nina Orike, Alejandra cloning to antagonist proof-of-concept. Nat.
a variety of TRP ion channels. We have Acevedo, David Hackos, Michelle Rev. Drug Discov. 6:357-372.
developed a temperature-based Ca2+ influx Dourado, Joy Shen, and Joanne Kwan for 15. Olah, Z., L. Karai, and M.J. Iadarola.
assay that can be used to study and screen their contributions to this study. 2001. Anandamide activates vanilloid receptor
The authors declare no competing 1 (VR1) at acidic pH in dorsal root ganglia
for agents that alter the thermal response neurons and cells ectopically expressing VR1.
of these temperature-sensitive channels. interests.
J. Biol. Chem. 276:31163-31170.
Characterization of this assay for TRPV1, 16. Ts av a l e r, L . , M . H . S h a p e r o , S .
including a Z′-factor of >0.5, demonstrates References Morkowski, and R. Laus. 2001. Trp-p8, a
that it is amenable to screening within a novel prostate-specific gene, is up-regulated
1. Rodriguez, B.M., D. Sigg, and F. Bezanilla.
in prostate cancer and other malignancies and
drug discovery paradigm. For TRPV1 1998. Voltage gating of Shaker K+ channels.
shares high homology with transient receptor
antagonists, data obtained using this The effect of temperature on ionic and gating
potential calcium channel proteins. Cancer
assay produced IC50 trends similar to those currents. J. Gen. Physiol. 112:223-242.
Res. 61:3760-3769.
2. A l len, T.J. a nd G. Mi ka la. 19 98 .
observed in other well established TRPV1 17. K ob ay a s h i , K . , T. Fu k u o k a , K .
Effects of temperature on human L-type
assays. cardiac Ca2+ channels expressed in Xenopus
Obata, H. Yamanaka, Y. Dai, A. Tokunaga,
The effect of temperature on channel and K. Noguchi. 2005. Distinct expression
oocytes. Pflugers Arch. 436:238-247.
of TRPM8, TRPA1, and TRPV1 mRNAs in
activity has previously been assessed using 3. Pusch, M., U. Ludewig, and T.J. Jentsch.
rat primary afferent neurons with adelta/c-
electrophysiology and we propose this 1997. Temperature dependence of fast and
fibers and colocalization with trk receptors.
technique as a complementary approach slow gating relaxations of ClC-0 chloride
J. Comp. Neurol. 493:596-606.
channels. J. Gen. Physiol. 109:105-116.
for the use of temperature as an activation 18. Nilius, B. and T. Voets. 2007. Neuro-
4. Vo e t s , T. , G . D r o o g m a n s , U.
mechanism. The features differentiating it Wissenbach, A. Janssens, V. Flockerzi, and
physiology: channelling cold reception.
from electrophysiology include a 96-well Nature 448:147-148.
B. Nilius. 2004. The principle of temperature-
19. Bandell, M., A.E. Dubin, M.J. Petrus,
format, the ability to study cell popula- dependent gating in cold- and heat-sensitive
A. Orth, J. Mathur, S.W. Hwang, and A.
tions instead of single cells, and the use TRP channels. Nature 430:748-754.
Patapoutian. 2006. High-throughput random