Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SYSTEMS
PUMPSANDSYSTEMS.COM
SMART
PUMPING
Enhancing security & increasing
uptime with intelligent controls
K A L A M A Z O O R I V E R R E M E D I AT I O N D I V E R T S 5 . 9 B I L L I O N G A L L O N S | 3 Q U E S T I O N S A B O U T U S I N G I oT
ith 2016 now in full swing, Pumps & Systems is looking toward the future. As
technologies and services continue to evolve with each passing year, our desire is
to keep you up-to-speed with the latest innovations while not neglecting the processes
and concepts that have long guided the pump industry.
In this issue, we focus on smart pumpingmodern, computer-based capabilities that
allow pump users to monitor and control their systems reliably, safely and eciently.
While some believe the pump industry has been behind the times in terms of technology
adoption, many companies are expanding their product and service portfolios to include
smart pumping software and intelligent controls. As end users begin to implement these
new capabilities, they are seeing reduced life-cycle costs, lower energy consumption and
more reliable system operation.
As an example, a German ame retardant manufacturer recently incorporated
frequency converters to control its cooling water pumps and saw a reduction in energy
consumption by 80 percent. Turn to page 34 for full details on how intelligent controls
yielded these signicant energy savings.
On page 30, we continue our coverage of smart pumping with an overview of how
alternative control technologies can handle large volumes of data. You also dont want
to miss 3 Questions to Ask Before IoT Implementation (page 38), which outlines best
practices for Internet of Things adoption on an industrial scale.
While smart pumping may be the future, ensuring that your equipment can withstand
harsh conditions is an age-old problem. On page 24, we help you meet the challenges of
harsh operating environments with coverage of rugged seal technologies (page 24) and
tips for safely incorporating new hydraulic uids in your assembly (page 27).
This month, the Pumps & Systems team will be traveling to Tucson, Arizona, to
participate in the Hydraulic Institute 2016 Annual Conference on Feb. 11-15. We look
forward to seeing many of you there. In the meantime, if you have any questions,
concerns or suggestions, please dont hesitate to let us know. We love hearing from
readers and welcome your feedback.
EDITORIAL
SENIOR EDITOR, PUMPS DIVISION: Alecia Archibald
aarchibald@cahabamedia.com 205-278-2843
SENIOR TECHNICAL EDITOR: Mike Pemberton
mpemberton@cahabamedia.com
205-314-8279
MANAGING EDITOR: Amelia Messamore
amessamore@cahabamedia.com
205-314-8264
MANAGING EDITOR: Martin Reed
mreed@cahabamedia.com 205-278-2826
MANAGING EDITOR: Savanna Gray
sgray@cahabamedia.com 205-278-2839
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS: Lev Nelik,
Ray Hardee, Jim Elsey
CREATIVE SERVICES
DIGITAL PROJECT MANAGER &
SENIOR ART DIRECTOR: Greg Ragsdale
ART DIRECTOR: Melanie Magee
WEB DEVELOPER: Greg Caudle
DIGITAL COMMUNITY MANAGER: Amy Cash
PRINT ADVERTISING TRAFFIC: Lisa Freeman
lfreeman@cahabamedia.com 205-212-9402
CIRCULATION
AUDIENCE DEVELOPMENT MANAGER: Lori Masaoay
lmasaoay@cahabamedia.com 205-278-2840
ADVERTISING
NATIONAL SALES MANAGER: Derrell Moody
dmoody@pump-zone.com 205-345-0784
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES:
Mary-Kathryn Baker
mkbaker@pump-zone.com 205-345-6036
Mark Goins
mgoins@pump-zone.com 205-345-6414
Addison Perkins
aperkins@pump-zone.com 205-561-2603
Garrick Stone
gstone@pump-zone.com 205-212-9406
MARKETING ASSOCIATES:
Ashley Morris
amorris@cahabamedia.com 205-561-2600
Sonya Crocker
scrocker@cahabamedia.com 205-314-8276
This issue
COVER
SERIES
FEBRUARY
Volume 24 Number 2
COLUMNS
SMART PUMPING
PUMPING PRESCRIPTIONS
34
Allweiler
18 By Jim Elsey
INDUSTRY INSIGHTS
22 By Mike Pemberton
SPECIAL
SECTION
48
DEPARTMENTS
40 EFFICIENCY MATTERS
Peristaltic Pumps Offer Protection in
Mining Operations
By Tom ODonnell, Abaque, part of PSG
42 MAINTENANCE MINDERS
Creative Coupling Design Saves
Downtime at Utility Plant
By Jim Anderson, Coupling Corporation
of America
44 SEALING SENSE
What to Consider When Upgrading or
Changing Pre-Specied Gaskets
By Mike Shorts, FSA Member & President
46 HI PUMP FAQS
48
By Hydraulic Institute
2
6
53
54
56
p u mp sCircle
a n d s y102
s teon
m scard
. co m
Fe bpsfreeinfo.com.
ru ary 2016
or |visit
NEWS
NEW HIRES,
PROMOTIONS & RECOGNITIONS
RICH GREATTI
FLUID SEALING INTERNATIONAL
CORAOPOLIS, Penn. (Jan. 5, 2016) Fluid
Sealing International has announced that Rich
Greatti has joined the company as director
of sales and marketing. Greatti brings more
than 30 years of experience in the uid sealing
industry in sales, engineering and business
Rich Greatti
development with a successful track record
that includes international sales, product development as well as
managing a global sales force. He has helped develop several new
sealing products and a successful distribution/direct/OEM network in
the uid sealing industry. worldfsi.com
ALEXANDER SEVERT
& JIARAN SUN
WATER PLANET
LOS ANGELES (Dec. 7, 2015)
Water Planet has further
expanded its engineering team
with the addition of Alexander
Alexander
Jiaran
Severt as mechanical and
Sun
Severt
design engineer and Jiaran Sun
as research and development engineer. At Water Planet, Severt will
provide modeling, fabrication and design support to the membrane
and system design team. Sun will assist with the development
and commercialization of Water Planets PolyCera polymer and
membranes. waterplanet.com
MYLA PETREE
BALDOR ELECTRIC COMPANY
FORT SMITH, Ark. (Nov. 24, 2015) Baldor
Electric Company has appointed Myla Petree to
the newly created position of director strategic
program management. In this role, she and
a recently formed team of project managers
will be responsible for organizing, driving and
Myla Petree
successfully implementing key projects across a
variety of Baldor locations and products. Petree joined Baldor in 2011
as the companys director of quality. Petree has a bachelors degree
in mechanical engineering from the University of Oklahoma and is an
ASQ Certied Manager of Quality/Organizational Excellence.
baldor.com
NEWS
Massachusetts Water
Resources Authority Moves
Forward with Pump System
Optimization Program
PARSIPPANY, N.J. (Nov. 30, 2015)
Massachusetts Water Resources
Authority (MWRA), which provides
wholesale water and sewer services to
2.5 million people and more than 5,500
large industrial users, conducted an
in-house Pump System Optimization
(PSO) Program in November 2015
as a precursor to a pump system
assessment of all its facilities. The
PSO Program was developed by the
Hydraulic Institute for engineers,
operations, facilities, maintenance
and management personnel to
educate their staff about operating
pump systems more efciently. A.W.
Chesterton Company and WEG Electric
Corp. co-hosted this particular pump
system optimization training course.
mwra.com
To have a news item considered, please send the information to Amelia Messamore, amessamore@cahabamedia.com.
9
Q U A L I T Y . S E R V I C E . I N N O V AT I O N . I N T E G R I T Y .
7020 Series
PRESSURE?
NO PROBLEM.
The Shark 7020 Series Progressing Cavity
Grinder Pumps are ideal for pressure sewer
systems. For commercial and residential
sewage removal with high head requirements,
these pumps have an integral pressure relief
valve. Packages designed for new installations
and retrotting existing systems. Designed,
machined, assembled in the USA. Cast iron,
Cool Run design is fully submersible.
100% factory tested.
1-800-928-7867 | www.zoellerengprod.com
Circle 105 on card or visit psfreeinfo.com.
p u mp s a n d s y s te m s . co m | Fe b ru ary 2016
10
NEWS
Efcient Pump
Selection and
Control
THE SECOND IN A 6-PART WEBINAR SERIES FOR 2016
FREE
Dosing Basics
Sponsored by
11
EVENTS
011*38036)25
'))&8/7$33/&$7216
'85$%/7< (1(5*<
())&(1&<
6$9(<28021(<
2YHUSXPSPRGHOVLQ
&RUQHOOV0;031DQG63
VHULHVRHUYDULRXVVROLGV
KDQGOLQJKLJKKHDGDQG
VOXUU\SXPSLQJRSWLRQV
+HDGVWRRZVWR
*30DQGHFLHQFLHVWR
7ZRSDWHQWHGLQQRYDWLRQVZRUNHVSHFLDOO\ZHOOIRUPLQLQJ
&<&/26($/p0(&+$1&$/6($/6<67(0
1R)OXVK:DWHU
1R/HDNV
([WHQGHG6HDO/LIH
6\VWHPDQG0DLQWHQDQFH&RVW6DYLQJV
5('350(p'5<3501*6<67(0
)XOO\$XWRPDWLF
9DFXXPDVVLVWHGVHOISULPLQJ
GU\SULPLQJXS&)0
:LGHVW5DQJHRI'U\3ULPH3XPSV
WKRXJKGLVFKDUJHVL]H
(DVLO\+DQGOHV$LU/LTXLG0L[WXUHV
5DSLGO\3ULPHVDQG5HSULPHV
5H3ULPHVFRPSOHWHO\XQDWWHQGHG
/HDUQPRUHDERXW&\FORVHDOp5HGL3ULPHpDQGDOORXU
RWKHULQQRYDWLRQVDQGH[SDQVLYHSXPSVHULHVDW
:::&251(//3803&20
&251(//3803&203$1<y
k&251(//3803&203$1<
&RUQHOO3XPS&RPSDQ\LVDQ625HJLVWHUHG&RPSDQ\
p u mp s a n d s y s te m s . co m | Fe b ru ary 2016
12
PUMPING PRESCRIPTIONS
Troubleshooting & repair challenges
By Lev Nelik, Ph.D., P.E.
Pumping Machinery, LLC, P&S Editorial Advisory Board
Neliks Response
Thank you for your question. It
does not surprise me that the
amount of wasted energy seemed
so high to you. Most folks think
more about a piece of machinerys
reliability than about its eciency.
The thought process is, If a pump
fails too often, water spills all over
the plant, and I get home late for
dinner. That is personal. But to
look at a running pump to see 10
percent eciency being wasted,
that is often too abstract.
Figure 1 (above). Live data streaming in. Figure 2 (below). Spectral (FFT) data is taken and
displayed continuously by the PREMS system.
13
14
PUMPING PRESCRIPTIONS
a. Rotor unbalance
b. Misalignment
c. Cavitation
d. Both a and b
e. a, b and c
Using Figure 1, we can compare
the original OEM performance,
shown with solid lines, to actual
performance, shown with multiple
data points outlining the evolving
curves. The system provides standalone data acquisition, combining
instrumentation with software,
to present a real, standard pump
curvelive and continually.
Interpretation of data is simpleit
is on the screen. The dierence in
eciency is calculated continually
and translated into yearly prorated
dollars wasted. Th is data can
help users decide between repair
(yearly energy cost vs. repair cost),
TFSEALSUSA .COM
TF-P214
packing 100% Pure
Graphite PTFE yarn
We Deliver!
sales@tfsealsusa.com
Phone: 1.713.568.5547
Fax: 1.713.758.0388
10620 Stebbins Cir, Suite E
Houston, TX 77043
PZ05
metal bellow cartridge
mechanical seal
TF-P241
packing Nomex fiber
and graphite PTFE
15
A better understanding of complete system operation
By Ray Hardee
Engineered Software, Inc.
In a previous column, we
discovered that the ow rate
through a pump can be calculated
by converting the dierential
pressure to head. Using the pump
curve, enter the value for pump
head on the vertical axis and move
horizontally until you intersect the
pump curve. Then move down to
determine the ow rate.
144 Formula 1
(Pin + Patm - P vp ) x
NPSHa =
144
=11.5 ft
48.9
Equation 1
Temp (F)
Density (lb/ft3)
Viscosity (cP)
Process uid
80
48.9
0.30
8.8
Process uid
120
47.3
0.25
16.4
Fluid
PXTK-120
ft
PXPI-120
psi
PXPI-121
psi
PX-LCV-120
position*
PXPV-122
level
PX-PV-122
psi
Current Operation
-2.0
65
78%
15
20
Validated
0.4
69.6
69%
15
20
p u mp s a n d s y s te m s . co m | Fe b ru ary 2016
16
<28575867('6285&()25
48$/,7<&21752/3$1(/6
6HH:DWHU,QFGHVLJQVDQGPDQXIDFWXUHVLQQRYDWLYHHOHFWULFDO
SXPSFRQWUROVKLJKOLTXLGDODUPVDQGSXPSFRQWUROSDQHOVIRUWKH
SOXPELQJ+9$&DQGRQVLWHLQGXVWULHV
$VD8/$DQG$FRQWUROSDQHOPDQXIDFWXUHURXUH[SHUW
WHDPRISURIHVVLRQDOVZLOOQGDVROXWLRQWKDWWV\RXUDSSOLFDWLRQ
6DPH'D\4XRWHV6DPH'D\6KLSSLQJ
BOOTH
5429
<RXU7UXVWHG6RXUFH)RU4XDOLW\&RQWURO3DQHOV
3KRQH
ZZZVHHZDWHULQFFRP
17
p u mp s a n d s y s te m s . co m | Fe b ru ary 2016
18
Background
I would estimate that shaft sleeves
have been used on pump shafts for
at least 100 years. My 1919 edition
of Pumping Machinery by Arthur M.
Greene mentions sacricial shaft
liners. I do not know exactly when
the rst pump shaft sleeve was put
into service, but I assume it was
not long after someone adjusted
the packing incorrectly on an
expensive pump.
Shaft sleeves serve multiple
purposes. The most important is to
protect the main pump shaft from
wear caused by packing abrasion,
followed closely by prevention of
erosion and corrosion. In some
pump designs, the sleeve serves
additional purposes. For example,
in some horizontal split-case
pumps, the sleeve also serves
(in conjunction with a threaded
shaft nut) as an adjustable means
19
Non-Contacting
Measure Flow
from Outside
the Pipe
Designed for dirty
or aerated liquids
like wastewater,
slurries, sludge
and liquids with
bubbles or solids
DFM 5.1 Doppler
Flow Meter
Low-Flow or No-Flow
Pump Protection
888-473-9546
info@greyline.com
www.greyline.com
p u mp s a n d s y s te m s . co m | Fe b ru ary 2016
Flow Measurement
and Control
20
Current Practices
Many pump owners continue to use old
design shaft sleeves when using new
design cartridge mechanical seals. There
are some good reasons, such as corrosion/
erosion mitigation, for continuing this
practice. In most cases, however, there
is no other reason than that is the
way we have always done it. I would
say that, for a given system (curve) and
the consequential pump operation on
its curve, the pump life would be much
longer if the shaft design was solid versus
sleeved. The pump would be more reliable,
and the mean time between failure and
repair (MTBF/R) would be longer.
21
Jim Elsey is a mechanical engineer who has focused on rotating equipment design and
applications for the military and several large original equipment manufacturers for 43
years. He is the general manager for Summit Pump, Inc., and the principal of MaDDog
Pump Consultants LLC. Elsey may be reached at jim@summitpump.com.
22
INDUSTRY INSIGHTS
Trends & analysis for pumping professionals
By Mike Pemberton
n intelligent pump is
more than a pump; the
product is a combination
of a pump, process instrument(s)
and variable frequency drive
(VFD) with related intelligence
embedded in the microprocessor
motherboard. While variable speed
drives (VSDs)both mechanical
and electronichave been applied
to pumps for decades, the drives
on intelligent pumps were the rst
commercially available VFDs that
used pump protection logic to alert
end users during upset conditions.
Today, several manufacturers oer
intelligent pumps with varying
performance monitoring and
asset protection capabilities. An
intelligent pump also typically
includes standard process control
functions, such as proportionalintegral-derivative control (PID)
and power (kilowatt) consumption
monitoring.
The rst intelligent pump was
introduced near the beginning
of the new millennium. Th is
technology has been instrumental
in changing many facets of the
pump industry. One change has
been the development of a new
understanding that control valves
do not have to be the de facto
ow control device for pump
systems. Embedding pump
intelligence into VFDs also has
led to the view that the pump
along with the instrumentation
and control valvesis a key
component of industrial
automation architecture.
Advantages of
Intelligent Pumping
From a process control standpoint,
the primary dierence between
a VFD and a control valve is that
the VFD electronically changes
motor speed to maintain ow,
pressure, level or temperature at
set-point, while the control valve
mechanically adjusts its opening to
meet process control requirements.
Both approaches maintain process
ow at the required rate but dier
signicantly in how they impact
energy use, equipment reliability
and process control performance.
VFD speed reduction lowers head
(pressure) at the square root of
speed, while ow is reduced at the
cube root of speed. For example,
a small reduction in speed can
result in a moderate head reduction
and large energy reduction. The
reduction in head (pressure) and
the accompanying reduction
in energy usage are primarily
the result of fully opening or
eliminating the control valve.
Standard and intelligent VFDs
provide the same level of energy
savings but can dier signicantly
in the amount of maintenance
savings they provide. Embedded
pump protection can alarm, slow
down or turn o the pump when
the system encounters conditions
such as dead-heading, dry-running
or cavitation.
The introduction of intelligent
VFDs signaled the rise of variable
speed pumping as an alternative
to control valves, especially in
Limitations to Adoption
While plant operators and
engineers typically congure
standard VFDs through a keypad
or laptop in the motor control
center (MCC), the PID algorithm
and control logic in the VFD are
infrequently used. Normally, the
control engineers opt for using the
same control functions that found
in the distributed control system
(DCS). The DCS then outputs a
speed signal back to the VFD over
an analog cable (4-20 mA), a step
similar to sending an analog signal
to a valve positioner to change the
percent that it is open or closed.
Digital bus communication can be
used, but the majority of plants
built before the new millennium
use analog signals to communicate
from the DCS to the eld
instruments and valves.
Because the VFD and DCS are
in dierent locations, operators
and engineers are often unable
to congure the intelligent pump
23
PROTECT PUMPS
$29 25..).'