{\rtf\ansi\deff0{\fonttbl{\f0 Times New Roman;}{\f1 Arial;}}{\colortbl\red0\gree

n0\blue0;}\paperw12240\paperh15840\margl0\margr0\margt0\margb0\sectd\sbknone\sec
ted\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plai
n\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\p
ard\plain\sl-279\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Orig
inally\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 published\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 i
n\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Susan\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Fainstein\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Scott\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Campbell's\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul\strike0 Readings in Plan
ning Theory\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 19
96.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Reprinted\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with
\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 permission\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i\ul0\strike0 Town\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i\u
l0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i\ul0\strike0 Review\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 .\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Vol.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 56,
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 No\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1,\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 5-20,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 1985.\par\pard\plain\sl-331\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-333\f1\fs36\cf0
\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Arguments\f1\fs36\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f1\fs36\cf0\b\i0\u
l0\strike0 and\f1\fs36\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f1\fs36\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Planning\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-282\f1\fs24\cf0\b\i\ul0\strike0 Richard\f1
\fs24\cf0\b\i\ul0\strike0 E.\f1\fs24\cf0\b\i\ul0\strike0 Klosterman\par\pard\p
lain\sl-303\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Formal\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 governmental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attempt
s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plan\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 direct\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 change\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 always\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 been\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 con
troversial.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 However,\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 academic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attention\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 peaked\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "great\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 debate"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1930s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1940s\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 between\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 proponents\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Karl\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mannheim
.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Rexford\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Tugwell,
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Barbara\par\p
ard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Wootton\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 defenders\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "free"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 laiss
ez-faire\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Friedrich\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Hayek\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Ludwig\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 von\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Mises.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 By\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1950s\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 debate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 had\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 apparently\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 been\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resolved:\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 grand\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 i
ssues\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 desirability\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pa

rd\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 feasibility\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 had\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 been\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
replaced\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 concrete\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 questions
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 concerning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 partic
ular\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 techniques\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alternative\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 institutional\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 structures\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 achieving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 objectives.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning'
s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 status\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\par\pa
rd\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 modern\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 society\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 seemed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 secure:\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
only\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 remaining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 q
uestions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 appeared\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Who\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 shall\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plan,\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 what\par\pard\plain\li1440\
sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 purposes,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 what\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conditions,\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 what\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 devices?\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 2\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Recent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 events\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Great\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Britain,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
United\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 States,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Western\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 societies\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 indicate\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning's\par\
pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 status\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 again\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 being\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 questioned\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "great\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 debate"\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 had\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 never\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 really\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ended.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 National\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\par\pard\plain\li
1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efforts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 been\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 abandon
ed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Britain\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 United\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 States;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 agenda\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 both\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 countries\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 now\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 focuses\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 deregulation,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 privatization,\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 urban\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enterprise\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 zones,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 host\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 o
f\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 proposals\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 severely\par\p
ard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 restricting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 government's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 role\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul

0\strike0 affairs.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul

0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 increasingly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 attacked\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 popular\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pre
ss,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 academic\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 literature,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 addresses\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Parliament\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Congress.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 3\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Graduate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 enrollments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-2
49\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 declined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dramati
cally.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 governm
ent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 retrenchment\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
round\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 world\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 has\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 severely\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reduced\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 job\par\pard\plai
n\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 opportunities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 professional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 planners\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 all\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 levels.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 4\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 At\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fundamental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 level,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 practitioners,\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 students,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 academics\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 increasingly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 view\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 n
othing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 way\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 make\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 living,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
ignoring\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 its\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 potential\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 serve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 vocation,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 filling\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 one's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
rofessional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 life\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 w
ith\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 transcending\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
urpose.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 5\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1
440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 In\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 this\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 environment\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 seems\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 essential\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 return\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fundamentals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 examine\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 carefully\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 case\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and
\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 against\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 modern\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 industrial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 context.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 This\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 article\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
will\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critically\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 e
xamine\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 four\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 major\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 types\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\
plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argument\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
been\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 used\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 two-edged\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rhetorical\

f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 swords\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 both\f0\fs2

2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 criticize\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 defend\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 government\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efforts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consider\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 implications\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1980s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 beyond.\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 analysis\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 will\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consider\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 only\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 formal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 governmental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efforts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
local\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 region
al\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 level\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lo\par\pa
rd\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 achieve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 desired\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 solve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
novel\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 problems\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 complex\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contexts,\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 what\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Britain\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 called\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 "town\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1550\colsr10\colno2\colw106
80\pard\plain\sl-343\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-116\f0\fs12\charscalex-133\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 1\par\pard\column\plain\sl-385\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-181\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 example.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mannheim,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Karl,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Man\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Society\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 i
n\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Age\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Reconstruction.\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Studies\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Modern\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Social\par\sect\sected\sbk
none\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-225\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Structure.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
York.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Harcourt,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Br
ace,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 World,\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1944.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 41-75;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Tugwell,\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Rexford\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 G.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 "Implementing\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li14
40\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 General\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 I
nterest",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A
dministration\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 1\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Autumn\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1940,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 32-49:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Wootton,\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Barbara,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Freedom\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Under\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Planning.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Chapel\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Hill,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 University\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 North\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Carolin
a\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1945:\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Hayek,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Friedrich\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0

\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Road\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri

ke0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Serfdom.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Chicago,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 University\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Chicago\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1944;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 von\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Mises,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Ludwig,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 F
reedom\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Other\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Essays.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 South\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Holland,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 Illinois,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Libertarian\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1952.\par\sect\sected\sb
knone\cols2\colno1\colw1550\colsr10\colno2\colw10680\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0
\fs12\charscalex-133\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 2\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Examples\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 here\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 include\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Schonfield,\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Andrew,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Modern\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Capitalism,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Oxford\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 University\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 1965.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\sect\sected\sbknone
\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 D
ahl,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Roben\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A.\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Undblom,\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Charles\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Politics.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economics,\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Welfare,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Harper\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 R
ow,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1953.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 quotation\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Dahl\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lin
dblom,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 5.\par\s
ect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1550\colsr10\colno2\colw10680\pard\plain\li1
440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-133\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 3\par\pard\plain\li0\sl230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rece
nt\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critiques\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 see\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Friedman,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Milton\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Friedman,\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Rose,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Free\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Choose:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Personal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 St
atement.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Harcourt,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Brace\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Jovanovich,\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1979:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Simon,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 William\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Time\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Truth.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Reader's\par\pard\
plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Digest\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1978:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Wildavsky,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Aaron,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "If\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Plannin
g\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Everything,\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Maybe\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 It's\f0\fs20\

cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Nothing".\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Policy\f0\fs20\c

f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Sciences,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 4\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 J
une\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1973,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 277-295.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw155
0\colsr10\colno2\colw10680\pard\plain\li1440\sl-118\f0\fs12\charscalex-133\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 4\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-225\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dramatically\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
declining\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enrollments\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
lanning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 schools\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ar
e\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 documented\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 analyzed\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\par\sec
t\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Krueckeberg,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Donald\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 A.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Depression\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Social\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Sciences",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Education\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Research.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 3\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Winte
r\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1984.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 78-86.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1530\co
lsr10\colno2\colw10700\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-143\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 5\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Fr
iedmann.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 John.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'Pl
anning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Vocation,"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Plan\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (Canada).\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 6\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 April\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 1966,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
99-124\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 7\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 July\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 1966,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 8-\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl
-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 26.
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop10142\shpright4320\shpbottom10142
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz90\shplid7533
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen
ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20

\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard

\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-299\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-243\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 country\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 planning"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 America\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "c
ity\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 regional\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning."\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 6\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 arguments\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consid
ered\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 below\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 necessarily\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 applicable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lo\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 national\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 done\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
by\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 organizations.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Also\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 considered\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 legal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
in\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 particular\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 constitutional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 common-law\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contexts\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Mannheim's,\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 7\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 which\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
had\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 little\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contemporary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 debate.\par\pard\plain\sl316\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Economic\f0\fs24\c
f0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Arguments\par\pard\plain\sl-301\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-19
8\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Contemporary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argu
ments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 abandoni
ng\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reduc
ing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 regulation,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an
d\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 restricting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 size\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\p
lain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 generally\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 accompanied\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 calls\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 incr
eased\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reliance\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enireprene
urship\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par
\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 forces\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 That\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 often\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argued,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 regulation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\par\pard\plain\li
1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 unnecessary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 often\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 har

mful\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 because\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 they\

f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 stifle\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 entrepreneu
rial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 initiative,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 i
mpede\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 innovation,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 impose\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 unnecessary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 financial\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 administrative\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 burdens\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economy.\par\pard\plain\sl
-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 These\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 find\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 historical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 roots\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 world\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Adam\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Smith,\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 John\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Stuart\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mill,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 others\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 classical\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 tradition.\
f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 8\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Emphasizing\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 freedom,\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reliance\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "impersonal"\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 forces\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mark
et,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rule\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 law,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 authors\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 called\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 minimal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 s
tate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interference\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 econo
mic\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 affairs\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 protect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberty\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promote\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 freedom\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 choice\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 acti
on.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 On\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pragmatic\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 grounds\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 they\par\pa
rd\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argued\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 could\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 relied\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 up
on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordinate\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals,\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 incentives\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 supply\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 t
hose\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 services\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 wants,\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 quantities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 desires,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 prices\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\

strike0 willing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0

pay.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 9\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li14
40\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Building\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 foundatio
ns,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contemporary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 n
eoclassical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economists\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 demonstrated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 mathematically\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 t
hat\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ma
rkets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capable\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theory\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ot\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 allocating\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resources\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 efficient\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 manner.\par\pard\plain\li1440\
sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 That\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is,\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 given\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 initial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 distribution\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resources,\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market-generated\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 allocation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resources\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 cannot\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 b
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 redistributed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 make\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 some\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 better\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 off\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 without\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 simultaneously\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\par\pard
\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 worse\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 off.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 10\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 How
ever,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 this\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Pareto\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efficient\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 allocati
on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 will\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 occur\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 only\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 perfectly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 satisfy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 following\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 c
onditions:\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 large\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 number\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 buyers\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sellers\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 trade\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 identical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 services;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 buyers\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 sellers\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 possess\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 sufficient\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rational\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 choice;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumer\par\sect\sected\sbknone
\cols2\colno1\colw1550\colsr10\colno2\colw10680\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain
\sl-349\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-116\f0\fs12\charscalex-133\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 6\par\pard\column\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-391\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-181
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 similar\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 definition\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 proposed\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Alexander,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Ernest\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st

rike0 R..\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "If\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Pla

nning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Isn't\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Everyt
hing,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Maybe\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 It's\p
ar\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Something".\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Town\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review.\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 52\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 April\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1981,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 131-142.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\coln
o1\colw1530\colsr10\colno2\colw10700\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex
-140\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 7\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs12\charscalex-140
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 8\par\pard\plain\li4\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 Mannheim,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 cit.\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 These\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 writers\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 "classical"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberals\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 their\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 views\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
nd\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberty\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fundamentally\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 differe
nt\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw
12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 those\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 associated\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 contempo-\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rary\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 liberalism.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Classical\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 liberals\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 define\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 liberty\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 negative\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 sense\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\
par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-225\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 freedom\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 determined\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 extent\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals'\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 acti
ons\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exter-\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nally\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 constrained\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1440
\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 others;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 wider\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sphere\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 noninlerference,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 greater\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 individual's\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberty.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Thus\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 increase\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
(negative)\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberty\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decreasing\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 interference\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 stale,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 classical\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberals\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 call\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
a\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sharply\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reduced
\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 role\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
domestic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for

eign\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economy.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Con

temporary"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberals,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 on\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 hand,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 view\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberty\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 largely\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 positive\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sen
se\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 free\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 when\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 internal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 constraints\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 as\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lack\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 knowledge,\par\
pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resources,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 opportunities\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 restrain\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 actions.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 From\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 this\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspective,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 increasing\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 (positive)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberty\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals
,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 particularly\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 most\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 deprived,\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 requires\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 deliberate\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promote\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 welfare\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 reduce\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 int
ernal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 constraints\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
on\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 acti
on,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 even\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 though\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 this\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 may\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 restrain\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 negative\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberty)\par\pard\plain\li1440
\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 some\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Compare\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Friedman,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Milton,\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Capitalism\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Freedom.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Chicago,\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 University\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Chicago\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\par\pard\p
lain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1962.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 5-6:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Finer.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Herman.\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Road\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Reaction.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Boston,\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Little,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Brown\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Co.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 1945,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 22
1-228.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Contemporary\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 examples\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 classical\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liberal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argument\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 include\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Hayek.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit..\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Friedman\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Friedman.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 c

it..\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Friedman,\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Sorensen.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 Anthony\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 D.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Day.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Rich
ard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'Libertarian
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Town\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review,\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 52\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-225\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 (4)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 October\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 1981,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 390
-402.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1550\colsr10\colno2\colw10680\par
d\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-133\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 9\par\pard\pl
ain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Heilbroner,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Robert\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 L.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Worldly\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Philosophers.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Simon\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Schuster,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1969\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (3rd\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 edn.),\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 48-61:\par\sect\sected\
sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Friedman\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Friedman,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit
.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 9-27.\par\s
ect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1
440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 10\par\pard\plain\li0\sl230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 example,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Bator,\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Francis\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 M\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Simple\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Analytics\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 Welfare\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Maximization,"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economic\par\sect\sected
\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Review,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 47\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
(1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 March\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1957,\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 22-59.\par\pard\
plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-307\par\pard\plain\li6057\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 2
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop9221\shpright4320\shpbottom9221
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz78\shplid7596
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen

ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20

\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-344\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 selections\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 unaffected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preferences\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 others;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (
4)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pur
sue\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 solitary\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 objective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pa
rd\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 maximizing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 profits;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 (5)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perfect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 mobility\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exists\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 production,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
labor,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consump
tion.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 11\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li14
40\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 numer
ous\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 obvious\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 diverg
ences\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 between\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mark
ets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 real\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 world\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economists'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 competitive\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ideal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
justify\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 range\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fully\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consistent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 property,\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw5630\col
sr10\colno2\colw6600\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 libe
rty,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decentral
ized\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 choice
.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 12\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-254\column\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 increase\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competition\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promote\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\col
no1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 informed\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumer\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 choice\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 world\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 huge\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 multinational\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 firms\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ma
ss\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 advertising\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 hel
ps\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justify\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 restrictions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 combinations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 restraint\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 trade\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 prohibitions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
misleading\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 advertising.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Indicative\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pl
anning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efforts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 national\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 level\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 France\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 elsewhere\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 likewise\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justified\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri

ke0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 providing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0

the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 required\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rational\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 choice.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 municipal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 systems\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\s
l-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preparati
on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-range\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 forecasts\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 similarly\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justified\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promoting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 informed\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 choice\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 respect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 loca
tion\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decisions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 relevant\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 difficult\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 obtain,\par\pard\plain\l
i1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 experience\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limited,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
nd\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mistakes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exceptionally\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costly.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 13\par\pard\pl
ain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 More\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 important,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 both\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 classical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neoclassical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economists\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 recognize\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 even\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perfectly\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 require\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 correct\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
"market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 failures"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
involving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pu
blic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collective
\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumption\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 externalities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 spill-over\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 prisoners'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 dilemma\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conditions;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (4)\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 distribution\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is
sues.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 14\par\pard\plain\sl-316\par\pard\plain\li14
40\sl-215\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Public\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 good
s\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ar
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 defined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 two\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 technical\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 characteristics:\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 I\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 )\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 "jointed"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 "nonrivalrous"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumption\par\pard\plain\li1
440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 tha
t,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 once\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 produced,\

f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 they\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\c

f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enjoyed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 simultaneously\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 one\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 person;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "nonexcludability"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "nonappropriabilily"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 difficult\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 (in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 some\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 cases\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 impossible)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 assign\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 well-defined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 property\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rights\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 restrict\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumer\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 access.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 15\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
apples,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 bread,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an
d\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 most\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1
610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-205\par\pard\pl
ain\li1440\sl-116\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 11\par\pard\column
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-247\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Seventeen\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 restrictive\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 assumptions\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 including\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perfectly\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 divisible\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumer\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 goods\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 absence\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\coln
o1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 risk\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 uncertainty\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 identified\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 De\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 V.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Graaf
f,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 J.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Theoretical
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Welfare\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economics
.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 London,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cambridg
e\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 University\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1957.\par\sect\sect
ed\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-1
23\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 12\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\colu
mn\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 analyses\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 many\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 empirical\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 limitations\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 real\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lindblom,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Charles\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Poli
tics\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Markets:\
par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 World's\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Politics-Economic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Systems,\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 Basic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Books,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 1977,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 76-89\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 144157;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Heilbrone
r,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Robert\f0\fs20\cf0

\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 L.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\

strike0 Thurow,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lester\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 C.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Econ
omic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Problem.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Engl
ewood\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cliffs.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Pren
tice\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Hall,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1978\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (5th\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 edn.).\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 201-219.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw
10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 13\pa
r\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cohen.\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Stephen,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Modern\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 Capitalist\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning:\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 French\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Model.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cambridge,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Harvard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 University\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1969;\par\sect\sected\sbknon
e\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Foster.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Christopher,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 "Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 t
he\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Market,"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cowan,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Peter\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (ed.).\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Future\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Planning:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Study\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Sponsored\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theCentreforEnviro
nmentalStudies.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 London,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Heinemann.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1973,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 135-140.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Meyerson,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Martin,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
"Building\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-225\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Middle-range\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Bridge\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Comprehensive\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning,"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journalofthe
AmericanInstituteofPlanners,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 22\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1956,pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 58-\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 64;\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Skjei.\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Stephen\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 S.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 "Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Problems\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Theoretical\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Justification\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Planning."\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A
ffairs\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Quarterly.\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 II\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 March\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1976.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 323-344.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\c
ols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\c
harscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 14\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Thus,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 example,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Adam\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 Smith\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 recognized\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 that\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 must\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resp
onsible\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 I\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 )\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 "protecting\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 society\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1

440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the

\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 violence\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 invasion\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 independent\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 societies";\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'establishing\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 exact\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 administration\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justice";\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (
3)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "erecting\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 maintaining\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 those\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 institutions
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 those\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 works,\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8230?\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8230?\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
a\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nature\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 profit\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 could\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 never\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 repay\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 e
xpense\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 small\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 number\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals."\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Smith.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Adam,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 An\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Enquiry
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 into\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Nature\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Causes\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Wealth\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Nations\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (edite
d\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Edwin\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cannon),\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Modern\par\pard\plain\li
1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Library,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
1937,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 653,\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 669,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 681;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 his\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 third\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 category\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justified\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 state\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 functions\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 discussed\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pages\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 681-740.\par
\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Other\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 functions\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 recommended\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 classical\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 economists\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 include\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 regulation\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 u
tilities,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 establishment\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 insur-\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ance\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 systems,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enactment\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 protective\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 labor\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 legislation,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 compensatory\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 fiscal\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\

fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 monetary\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 policy.\f0\f

s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Robbins,\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lionel.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Theon'\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Economic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Policy\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 English\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 C
lassical\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Political\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Economy.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-225\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 London.\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Macmillan,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1952.\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 esp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 55-61.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\c
olno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 15\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 literature\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 extensive.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 excellent\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 reviews\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Burkhead,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Jesse\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Miner,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Jerry,
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Public\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw
12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Expenditure.\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Chicago,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Aldine,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1971.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Head.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 John\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 G.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Goods\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Public
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Welfare,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Durham,\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 North\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Carolina,\pa
r\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Duke\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 University\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 1974.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 68-92\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 164
-183.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 In\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liter-\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ature\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Moore.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Terry,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 "Why\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Allow\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-2
30\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 do\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 What\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 They\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Do?\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Justification\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 From\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Theory",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 institute\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pa
rd\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-307\par\pard\plain\li6057\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 3
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop8074\shpright4320\shpbottom8074
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz73\shplid7623
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}

{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}

{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen
ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-344\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 "normal"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumer\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exhibit\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 neither\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 characteristic;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 once\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 produced,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 they\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 b
y\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 only\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 one\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
time.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 It\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 thus\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 easy\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 restrict\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 access\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an
d\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 charge\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 price\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 their\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
enjoyment.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 On\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 hand,\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 open\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 air\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
concerts,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 television\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 broadcasts,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 healthy\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pleasant\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 environment\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 simultaneously\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefit\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 one\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 individual,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 because\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 one\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 person's\par\pard\plain\li1440
\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enjoyment\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 d
oes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 prohibit\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 another's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enjoyment
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (except\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 any\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 congestion\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects).\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\par\pard\plain\li1440
\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 controlling\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
access\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 either\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 difficult\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (scramblers\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 must\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 installed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 restrict\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 access\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 television\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 broadcasts
)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 impossible\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (clean\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 air).\par\par

d\plain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Compet
itive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effectively\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alloca
te\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enjoyed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 only\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 if\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 they\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 purch
ased;\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 prices\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
willing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pay\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alternative\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 accurately\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\par\pard
\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preferences\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 goods.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
ublic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefit\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 receive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dependent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 total\par\pard\plain\li144
0\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 supply\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 good,\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contribution\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 toward\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 its\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 production.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Thus,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 vo
luntary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contributions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pay\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 say,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 environmental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 prolection,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 free\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 understate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 real\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preferences\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 environmental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 quality
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 hope\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 others\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 will\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 continue\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
pay\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 its\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 protection\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8211?\par\
pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enabling\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 them\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "free\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ride
rs,"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enjoying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pleasant\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 environment
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 personal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 expense.\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 course,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 if\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 every
one\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 did\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 this,\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 money\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 required\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 protect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st

rike0 environment\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adequately\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u

l0\strike0 would\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 longer\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 available.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Individuals\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 may\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 also\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 underestimate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 others'\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 willingness\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contribute\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 "overpay,"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 thereby\par\pard\plai
n\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ending\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 up\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fewer\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 they\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 really\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 desire.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
In\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 either\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 case\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 aggregated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 preferences\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 do\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 accurately\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 reflect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pre
ferences\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alternative\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8211?\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "invisible\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 hand"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fumbles.\par\pard\plain\sl-310\p
ar\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Similar\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 made\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 prov
ision\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 quasi-pub
lic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 education,\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 health\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 programs,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 transportation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 facilities,\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 police\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fire\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
protection,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
simultaneously\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefit\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl
-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 particular\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ind
ividuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provi
de\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 shared,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nonrati
onable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefits\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 whole.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 used\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justify\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 over\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 96\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 percent
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 purchases\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 services\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str

ike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 almost\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\f

s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 open-ended\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 range\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 activities.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 16\par\pard\plain
\sl-316\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Externalities\
par\pard\plain\sl-301\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Closely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 related\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 t
o\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 concept\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 externalities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 spillover\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 production\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumption
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 taken\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 into\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 account\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
rocess\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 voluntar
y\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exchange.
\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 17\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 classic\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 example\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 polluting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 indust
rial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plant\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 imposes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 aesthetic\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 health\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 neighboring\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 firms\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 indi
viduals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 includ
ed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 its\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 production.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Similar\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 spill-over\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revealed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 land\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 developers\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 who\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 freely\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ignore\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 congestion,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 noise,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 loss\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 privacy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 high-intensity\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 imposes\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neighboring\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 landowners.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Positive\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economies\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 include\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 increased\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 land\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 values\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
ssociated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 construction\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 new\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 transportation\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 links\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 large-scale\par\pard
\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improvements,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adjoining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 landowners\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul

0\strike0 enjoy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 without\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st

rike0 compensation.\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 true\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 divergence\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 betwee
n\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefits\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 associated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\par\pard\plain\l
i1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 externalities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 causes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 even\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
perfectly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 m
isallocate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 servi
ces.\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-367\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-181\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 44\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (4)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 October\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 1978,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 387-398.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 discussion\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 below\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 generally\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 follows\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 that\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Bator,\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Francis\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 M.,\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 Question\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Government\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Spending:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Needs\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Private\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Wants,
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Collier\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Books,\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1960.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 80-102.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno
2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
16\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Bator,\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 p.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 104:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Friedman\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Friedman,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dt
.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 27-37.\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Similar\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 used\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lo\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 justify\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\s
l-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pr
ovision\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 highway
s,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dams,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'decreasing\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cost"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 large\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 initial\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decreasing\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 marginal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs:
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Bator,\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit..\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 93-95.\par\sect\sected\sbkno
ne\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-118\f0\fs
12\charscalex-15\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 17\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-225\column\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 relevant\f0\fs20\cf0

\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 literature\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 here\f0\fs20\cf0\b

0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 extensive\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 well.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 excellent\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
reviews\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mishan
,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 J\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Postwar\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Literature\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\par\sect\sected\sbkn
one\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Externalities:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 An\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Interpretive\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E
conomic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Literature.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
9\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 March\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1971,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1-28,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 Head,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 184-213.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 In\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 literature\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 Lee.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Douglas\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 B.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Jr\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Land\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Use\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 Response\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Market\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Failure"\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 de\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Neufville,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Judith\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (ed.).\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Land\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Use\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 De
bate\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 United\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Slates.\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 Pleneum\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1981,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 153-154.\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl307\par\pard\plain\li6057\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 4
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop11981\shpright10800\shpbottom11981
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz106\shplid7650
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen
ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20

\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\sect

\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw3270\colsr10\colno2\colw8960\pard\plain\sl-200\
par\pard\plain\sl-344\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\charscalex96\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Profit-maximizing\par\pard\column\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-3
44\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 firms\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 concerned\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 only\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 maximizing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 revenues\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 controlling\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 are\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-25
4\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 encouraged\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 increase\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 output\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 even\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 though\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 associated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 negative\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 vastly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 outweigh\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 any\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl
-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 increases\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revenue\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 because\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external,\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 reflected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 production\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 costs.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw9210\colsr10\colno2\colw3020\
pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Neighborhood\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 beautification\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 projects\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 similar\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 positive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external\par\pard\plain\li0\
sl-254\column\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 similarly\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl
-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 tend\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 underproduced,\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 because\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 entrepreneurs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cannot\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 appropriate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 full\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefits\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
ctions.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 In\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 both\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 situations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "invisible\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 hand"\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 again\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fails\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 accurately\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 needs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 desires\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 members.\par\pard
\plain\sl-320\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Prisoner
's\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 dilemma\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 condition
s\par\pard\plain\sl-301\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Similar\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 difficulties\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revealed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 circumstances\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individua
ls'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pursuit\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 own\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 self-interest\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 does\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik

e0 lead\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lo\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\

fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 optimal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 outcome\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 involved.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Consider,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 example,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 situation\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 faced\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 landlords\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 declining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 neighborhood\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 who\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 must\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
whether\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improve
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rental\par\
pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 property\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 invest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 money\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
elsewhere.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 18\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 If\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 landlords\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improve\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 property\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 others\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 do\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neighbo
rhood\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 will\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 continu
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lo\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decline,\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 investment\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 financially\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inadvisable.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 On\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 hand,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
if\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 landlords\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 do\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 property\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 others\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 improve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theirs,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 genera]\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 impro
vement\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neighborhood\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 will\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 allow\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 landlords\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 raise\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rents\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
without\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 investing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
any\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 money.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 each\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 self-inter
est\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 make\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improvements;\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 however,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 if\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 they\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 all\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 refuse\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
do\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 so,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neighborhood\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 will\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decline\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 further,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 things\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 worse\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 everyone.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0

An\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 identical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inev

itable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 logic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 leads
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 overutilize\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 "common\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pool"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 resources\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limited\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 su
pply\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 free\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 access,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 wilderness\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 areas\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 healthy\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 environment.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 19\par\
pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fundamental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 probl
em\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 here,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 externalities,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lies\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
interdependence\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 between\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl
-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 act
ions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 accompanying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 disjunctio
n\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 between\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individu
al\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefits\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 versus\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 benefits\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 costs.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on
ly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 solution\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 all\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 three\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cases\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 deal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 external\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 neglected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 th
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pursuit\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 gain.\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Solutions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 declining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neighborhoods\par\
pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 include\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 compulsory\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 building\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 codes,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 acquisition\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 improvement\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 entire\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neighborhoods,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "envel
oping"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8211?\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pub
lic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improvements\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 t
o\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neighborhood\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ext
eriors\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 will\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 encourage\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 investments.\par\pard\plain\sl-316\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-215\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Distributional\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\s
trike0 questions\par\pard\plain\sl-301\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0

\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 was\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s

trike0 pointed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 out\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
above,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economists\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 demonstrated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
that,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 given\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 initial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 distributio
n\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resources,\pa
r\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perfectly\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 will\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 allocale\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 those\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resources\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 way\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 one\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefit\par\pard\plain\li144
0\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 without\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 so
meone\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 else\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 being\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 harmed.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 However,\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neither\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 initial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nor\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 final\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 distribution\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 assumed\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lo\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 any\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 way\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 optimal.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Both\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 determin
ed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 largely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inherited\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 wealth,\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 innate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 talent,\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 blind\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 luck\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 range\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 states\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perfect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 equality\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 extremes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
tremendous\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 wealth\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 abject\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pover
ty.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economic\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efficiency\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alone\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provides\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 criterion\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 judging\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 one\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 state\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 superior\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 any\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 way\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 another.\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\par\pard\plain\li1440\s
l-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 given
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 societal\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consensus\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 proper\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 allocation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 resources,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 example,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
all\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 babies\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 shoul
d\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 receive\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adequate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nutrition\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 eldrly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri

ke0 should\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 car

ed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 tax\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collection\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 income\par\pard\
plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 transfer\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 programs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 justified\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
achieve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 obje
ctives\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 minima
l\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interfere
nce.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 20\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1
610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-301\par\pard\pl
ain\li1440\sl-116\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 18\par\pard\column
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-343\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 This\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 example\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adapted\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
from\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Davis,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Otto\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Whinston,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Andrew\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 B.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 Economics\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Renewal",\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1
\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Law\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Contemporary\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Problems.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 26\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Winter\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 1961.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 106-117.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\col
w10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 19\p
ar\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 classic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 article\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Garret\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Hardin,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
'The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Tragedy\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Commons",\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Science,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 162,\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 13\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 December\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 1968,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\par\sect\sected\sbknone
\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 2
42-248.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 general\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 discussions
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Luce,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Duncan\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 Raiffa,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Howard,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Games\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Decision:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Introduction\par\pard\plain\li14
40\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Criti
cal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Survey,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 John\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Wiley.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1957.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 88-154.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 In\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 literature\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Moore,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.,\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw161
0\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-118\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 20\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-225\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Bator,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.,
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 87-89;\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Musgrave.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs2

0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 S.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i

0\ul0\strike0 Theory\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Finance:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Study\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economy,\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pa
rd\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 McGraw\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Hill,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 17-22.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Th
ese\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 points\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 do\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 course,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exhaust\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 arguments\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 against\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Thus,\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 while\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Friedman,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 7-21,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Hayek,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 43-118,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 defend\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 unrestricted\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 necessary\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 protect\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 liberty,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Barbara\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Wootton.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
cit.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argues\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plannin
g\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fully\par\par
d\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 compatible\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 whole\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 range\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 o
f\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cultural,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 civil,
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 freedoms.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-307\par\pard\plain\li6057\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 5
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop11981\shpright4320\shpbottom11981
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz93\shplid7677
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f

0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen

ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-209\
par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Implications\f0\fs24\c
f0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\s
trike0 economic\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\par\pard\plain\sl-301\p
ar\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 preceding\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 discussion\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 has\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 identified\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 range\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 f
unctions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fully\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 con
sistent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consu
mer\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sovereignty,\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 freedom\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 production\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 trade,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decentralized\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 choice.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 Each\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 these\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 functions\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justifies\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 major\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 area\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contemporary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 practice:\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 first,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 providing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 needed\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 f
or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 informed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 choice\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 through\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 indicative\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning,
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 development\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 urban\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 systems,\par\par
d\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preparation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-range\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
population,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 land-use\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
projections:\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 second,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provision\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 through\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 transportation.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 environmental,\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning;\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 third,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\pl
ain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 control\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 externalities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resolution\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 prisoner's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 d
ilemma\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conditions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
through\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 urban\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rene
wal,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 community\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 natural\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resources\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 use\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str

ike0 land\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 regulatory\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-25

4\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 devices;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lastly,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 health,\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 housing,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 forms\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
compensate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ine
quities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par
\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 distribution\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 basic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 services.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Specific\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 red
uce\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conflicts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 betw
een\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 incompatible\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 land\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 uses,\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordinate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 infrastructure,\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preserve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 open\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 space\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 historic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
buildings,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exa
mine\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-rang
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 impacts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 current\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 similarly\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justified\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 as\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nee
ded\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 correct\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 failures\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revealed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 physical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 city.\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\p
ard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 It\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 must\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 re
cognized,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 however,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 while\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 necess
ary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justify\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society,\par\pard\plain\l
i1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sufficient\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 do\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 so.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 This\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 true,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 first,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
because\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 those\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 act
ivities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 proper\par\pard
\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 responsibility\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nee
d\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 matters\f0\fs22\cf

0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 all.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul

0\strike0 Government\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
decisions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 concerning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provision\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods,\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 control\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 externalities,\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 so\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 made\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\par\p
ard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 number\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 w
ays:\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 profession
al\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 elected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 appointed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 officials.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 proclamations\par\pard\plain
\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 divine\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ruler,\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 pure\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 happenstance\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 involving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 deliberate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decision\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 process\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 all.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 If\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plan
ning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justified\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alone,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 impossib
le\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 differentiat
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 between\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nonplanning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8211?\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "government"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reduced\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 undifferentiated\par\pard\plain\li
1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mass.\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\pard\p
lain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 More\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 fundamentally,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 inability\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
existing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 allocate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 societ
y's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resources\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adeq
uately\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 does\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\pa
r\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 necessarily\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 imply\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provision,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 regulation,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 necessary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 even\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 advisable.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Suitably\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 defined\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 administered\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 performance\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 standards
,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 building\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 codes,\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 development\f0

\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 requirements\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 may\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 guide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 land\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 process\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effectively\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 master\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 zoning\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 techniques;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effluent\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 charges\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 often\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 control\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 pollution\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 discharges\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efficiently\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 direct\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enfor
cement\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effluent
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 standards;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 facilities\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 services\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 may\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 provided\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 equitably\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-25
4\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 leasing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 voucher\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 systems\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 directly\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 Thus,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 areas,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 appropriate\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 role\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 may\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preparation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 formal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 end-state\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plans\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 but\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 establishment\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 maintenance\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
n\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 appropriate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 syst
em\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 quasi-market
s.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 21\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\
sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 case\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 societ
y\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cannot\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 based\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 solely\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 theoretical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limitations\par\pard\plain\l
i1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mar
kets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 outlined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 abov
e.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Popular\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dissati
sfaction\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 free\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enterprise\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 system\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 based\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 appreciation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\f

s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 various\f0\fs22\cf

0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theories\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 failure\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 but\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
its\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inability\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 stable\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 growth\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adequate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 standard\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 liv
ing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 all\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 members.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Conversely,\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 informed\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 critiques\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 made\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ignorance\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 theoretical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limitations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 but\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 t
he\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 belief\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that,\pa
r\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 despite\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limitations,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 still\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 effective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
attempts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 centr
alized\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordination\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
by\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\
plain\sl-356\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 see\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Webber,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Melvin,\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Environment\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Change,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Part\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Two:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Per
missive\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Town\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 39\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 (4)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 January\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 1969,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 282-284:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Oxiey,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 .and\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lee,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 More\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 fundamental\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Marxist"\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critiques\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reliance\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 o
n\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competi-\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 tive\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 considered\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 below.\par\sect
\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440
\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 21\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230
\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Webber,
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 284-295;\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lee.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 cit.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0

158-164;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Friedman.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 84-107:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Moore,\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit..\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain
\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 393-396;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Foster,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 o
p.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 153-165.\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-307\p
ar\pard\plain\li6057\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 6
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop13133\shpright10800\shpbottom13133
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz108\shplid7713
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen
ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-299\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-243\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 government.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 22\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 re
sult,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 case\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 modern\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 society\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cannot\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 made\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 abstract\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 but\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 requires\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ca
reful\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 evaluation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 o
f\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effec
tiveness\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 relative\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alternative\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ins
titutional\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mechanisms
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 achieving\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 objectives.
\par\pard\plain\sl-320\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-215\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0
Pluralist\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Arguments\par\pard\plain\sl-301\par\par
d\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 against\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
lanning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 emerged\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 du
ring\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1960s\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1970s\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 complement\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\

i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 e
conomic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
considered\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 above.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Accepting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 econ
omic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 outlin
ed\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 above,\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lindblom,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Wildavsky,\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 critics\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 suggest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 should\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 guided\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 long-range\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attempts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 comprehensive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 coordination\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 but\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 increased\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
reliance\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 existing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 bargaining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 processes.\f0\f
s12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 23\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Underlying\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 analogue\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 lo\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economists'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perfectly\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competition\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 between\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 formal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 informal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups\par\pard\plain\li
1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pursuing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 range\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 divergent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goals\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 assumed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 place\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 all\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 important\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
issues\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 agenda,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 guarantee\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 group\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dominates\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arena.
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 maintain\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 politica
l\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 stability\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improve\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 intellectual\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 deliberative\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 skills.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 In\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 this\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 model\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 has\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 independent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 role\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 establishing\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 enforcing\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rules\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u

l0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0

game\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ratifyin
g\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adjustments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 worked\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 out\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 among\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 competing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Thus,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 assumed,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competition,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 like\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competition
,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 eliminates\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 independent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 planning,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 coordination.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 24\par\pard\plain\sl-305\pa
r\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Unfortunately,\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pluralist\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 model\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 subject\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lo\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 same\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fundam
ental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limitations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 face\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 model\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 perfect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 competition.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Just\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dominated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 gigantic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 national\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mutinational\par\pa
rd\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conglomerates,\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 arena\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 dominated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 g
roups\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 who\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 use\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 access\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 officials\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 e
lites\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 protect\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 status,\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 privilege,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 wealth\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 ensure\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\par\pard\plain\li1440
\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
acts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Particularly
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 privileged\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 corporate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 business\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 leaders\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 whose\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 cooperation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 essential\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
government's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efforts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 maintain\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 f
ull\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 employment\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 secure\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 stable\f0\

fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 growth.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 officials,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 particularly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 local\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 level
,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cannot\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 treat\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 business\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 only\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 another\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 special\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 interest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 but\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 m
ust\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 incent
ives\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 stimulate\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 desired\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 business\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 activity,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 tax\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rebates\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 low-interest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
loans\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attract
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 new\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 industry\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 downtown\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improvement\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 projects\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 encourage\par\pard\pl
ain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 retail\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 commercial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 activity\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 central\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 business\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 district.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Further\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 supporting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 busines
s's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 unique\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 position\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 group\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 bargaining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 process\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 unre
cognized\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 acceptance\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 needs\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 priorities\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 business\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 pervades\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 our\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 po
litical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 govern
mental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 processes,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
media,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cultura
l\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 educational\
par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 institutions.\f0\fs12
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 25\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Systematically\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exclude
d\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 group\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 bargaining\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 process\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 minority\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 low-income\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
groups\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 residing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decaying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 urban\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 centers\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rural\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 hinterlands.\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lacking\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 time,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 training,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 resources,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st

rike0 leadership,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\

ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 experience\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 required\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 participate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effectively\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 po
litical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 process,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 t
hese\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 effective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 voice\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 determining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
policies\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 shap
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 world.\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 By\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 thus\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 tying\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 individuals'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 voice\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 u
nderlying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 disparities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
ower\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resources
,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 current\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 politica
l\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 processes\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exacerbate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 existing\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inequalities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 income\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 wealth\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 fail\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pr
ovide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adequate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inf
ormation\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fully\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 informed\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 policy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 26\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Group\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 bargaining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 also\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 fails\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adequately\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 col
lective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno
1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\sl-295\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-1
16\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 22\par\pard\column\plain\sl-337\p
ar\pard\plain\li0\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 example.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Becker,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Gary\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
S.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'Competition\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Democracy",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Jo
urnal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Law\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economics.\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 October\par\sect\sected
\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 1958,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1
05-109,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Wolf.\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Charles\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Jr.,\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Theory\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Nonmarket\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Failure:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Framework\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Implementation\par\pard\plain\l
i1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Analysis",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 La
w\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economics.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 22\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 April\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1979.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 107-140.\par\sect\sected\sbknone

\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12
\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 23\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 example,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lindblom,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Charles\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 "The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Science\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Muddling\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Th
rough",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Adm
inistration\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
19\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 January\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1959,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 79-88\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Wildavsky.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
cit.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pa
rd\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 24\par\pard\p
lain\li1440\sl-225\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 25\par\pard\plain
\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Conolly.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 William\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
(ed.).\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Bias\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Pluralism,\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York.\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Atherton,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1969,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 3-13.\par\pard\plain\li0\sl225\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lindblom,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit..\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 170-233,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Elkin,\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Stephen\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 L.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 "Market\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Politics\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Liberal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Democracy",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Ethics.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 92\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (4)
\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 July\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1982.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 720-732:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 Miliband.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Ralph,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 State\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Capitalist\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 So
ciety,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Basic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Books.\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1969.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\col
sr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 26\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Gam
son.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 William\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A.,\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Stable\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Underrepres
entation\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Americ
an\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Society".\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Ameri
can\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Behavioral\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Sci
entist,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 12\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\par
\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 November/December\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1968,\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 15-21;\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Skjei.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Stephen\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 S.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Systems\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Advocacy".\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of'the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 American\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 instit
ute\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 38\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 January\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1972,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i

0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 11-24:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s

trike0 also\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 D
ye,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Thomas\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 R.\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Zeigler,\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 L.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Harmon,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Irony\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 of\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-307\par\pard\plain\li6057\sl-2
16\f0\fs24\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 7
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop11750\shpright4320\shpbottom11750
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz107\shplid7740
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen
ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-344\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 services\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 small\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefits\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 large\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 number\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 In\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 small\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 each\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 member\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 receives\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 substantial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 proportion
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 gain\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 good:\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 clearly\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 interest\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ensure\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 good\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provided.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 For\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 large\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 groups,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 benefits\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 s
o\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 small\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 organizational\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 so\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 large\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs2

2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 one's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\

i0\ul0\strike0 immediate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
common\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 good.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 "exploitation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 great\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 small"\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 small\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 narrow,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 well-defined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 \u8211?\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 doctors\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lawyers\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8211?\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 organize\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 effectively\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 achieve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
objectives\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 l
arger\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u821
1?\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumers\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 \u8211?\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 who\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 share\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
broadly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 defined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in
terests.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 By\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 turnin
g\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 power
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 over\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 most\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interested\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 parlies\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exc
luding\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 policy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 formulation\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 implementation\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 process,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 pluralist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 bargaining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 systematically\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neglects\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 spill-over\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\s
l-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 policies\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 unrepresented\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 group
s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals.
\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 27\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl
-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limitation
s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pluralist\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 bargaining,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 like\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limitations\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 competition,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theoretical\par\pard\plai
n\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justification\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 w
ide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 range\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 functions.\f0\

fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Accepting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22

\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critiques\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 comprehensive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Lindblom\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
others,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 some\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 auth
ors\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 propose\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limited\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "adjunctive"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 functions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li144
0\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 providing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
information,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 analyzing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 alternative\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 policies,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
identifying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 bases\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improved\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 gro
up\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interaction.\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 objective\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 here,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 indicative\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 planning,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 improving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 existing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 decentralized\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decision\par\pard\plain\li144
0\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 processes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 providing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 needed\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 informed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decision\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 28\par\pard\plain\sl
-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pluralist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 model\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 incorporated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 directly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 into\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 advocacy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 approach,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 which\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rejects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preparation\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 value-neutral\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "unitary"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plans\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 representing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 overall\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 community\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 explicit\par\pard\plain\l
i1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 advocacy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "plural\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plan
s"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 representing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 al
l\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 involved\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 physical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-25
4\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 city.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 29\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Recognizing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inequities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 existing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 processes,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 advocate\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 acted\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 primarily\par\pard\plain\li1
440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 advoc

ates\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's

\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 poor\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 minority\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 members.\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Particularly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 noteworthy\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 here\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efforts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cleveland\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Commission\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promote\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "a\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 wider\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 range\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 choices\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 those\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Cleveland\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 residents\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
who\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 few,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 if\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 any,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 choices."\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 30\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 Experience\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 has\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 demonstrated,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 however,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 advocacy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 shares\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 many\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limitations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 pluralist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 model\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 based:\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 urban\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neighborhoods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 homogeneous\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neighborho
od\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 easy\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 identify\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 true\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 community\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 level;\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 group\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 leaders\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\par\pard\plain\li
1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rep
resentative\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 group's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 membershi
p;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 easier\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 represent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 narrowly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 defined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-2
54\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preserve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 status\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 quo\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 advocate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 diffuse\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 widely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 shared\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 propose\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 new\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alternatives;\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (4)\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 officials\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 still\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lack\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri

ke0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike

0 required\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ad
equate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decision\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ma
king.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 31\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-3
43\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Democracy:\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 An\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Uncommon\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Introduction\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Politics.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 North\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Scituate.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Mass.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Duxbury\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 Press.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1975\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 (3rd\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 edn.),\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 225-284.\par\sect
\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440
\sl-118\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 27\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-225
\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Olson,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Manc
ur,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Logic\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Collective\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Action:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Public\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Goods\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Theory\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Groups,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Ca
mbridge,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Harvard\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\co
lno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 University
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1965;\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lowi,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Theodore\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 J.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Philosophy:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Interest-group\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Liberalism",\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Political\par\
pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Science\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 Review,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 61\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 March\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1
967,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 5-24.\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 extensive\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 discussion\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 forms\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
"nonmarket\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 failure"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 see\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Wolf,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.\par\sect\sected\
sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\
f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 28\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 example,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Rondinelli,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Dennis\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 "Adjunctive\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 Policy\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Development",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Affairs\par\sect\sected\sbkn
one\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Quarterly.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 6\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 September\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1971,\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 13-39;\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Skjei,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Stephen\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 S.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 "Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Problems\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Th
eoretical\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Justificati
on\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning",\f

0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Affairs\f0\fs

20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Quarterly,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 II\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 March\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 1976,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 323-344.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw
10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 29\pa
r\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Davidoff,\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Paul,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Advocacy\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Pluralism\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Institute\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Plann
ers,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 31\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (6)\par\se
ct\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 November,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1965,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 331-338.\par\sect\sected\sbknon
e\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs1
2\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 30\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Krumholz,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Norman,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cogger,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Janice\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Linner,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 John,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Cleveland\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Policy\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Report",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
the\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 institute\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners.\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 41\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 September\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1975.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 298-304.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Krumholz,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Norman,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 "A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Retrospective\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 View\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Equity\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning:\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cleveland,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1969-1979,"\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Association,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 48\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Spring\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1982,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
pp.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-225\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 163-174.\par\sec
t\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li144
0\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-13\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 31\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-23
0\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Peattie,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 L
isa\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 R..\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Reflectio
ns\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Advocacy\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Institute\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 34\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 March\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1968,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 80-88;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Skjei.\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Stephen\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 S.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 "Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Systems\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 Advocacy",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0

American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Institute\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 38\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 I\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 )\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Jan
uary\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1972,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 11-24;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mazziotti,\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Donald\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 F..\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Underlying\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Assumptions\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Advocacy\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 Pluralism\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Reform,"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Institute\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners.\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 40\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 January\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1974.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 38.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
40-47.\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-307\par\pard\plain\li6057\sl-216\
f0\fs24\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 8
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop9912\shpright10800\shpbottom9912
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz94\shplid7767
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen
ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-399\par\pard\plain\li1440\
sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 there\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 remains\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 fundamental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 sector\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
who\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 represen
t\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 shared\par\p
ard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 community,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordinate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
nd\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consider\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-range\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str

ike0 current\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri

ke0 This\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 does\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 imply\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 shared\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 community\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 superior\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 to\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-term\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\par\pard\plain\li
1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 important\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dire
ct\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 immediate\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 impacts.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 It\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 assumes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 only\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 considerations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\par\pard\plain\li1
440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 particularly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 important\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 polilically,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 because\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 only\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
ensure\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 they
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 will\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 considered\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\par\pard\plai
n\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 all.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
32\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 It\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 foundations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 town\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 co
untry\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 hav
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 been\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 made.\par\pard\plain\sl-316\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-216\f0\fs2
4\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Traditional\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Arguments\par\p
ard\plain\sl-301\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 professio
n\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 originated\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 turn\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 century\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
response\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 widespread\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dissati
sfaction\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 results\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 existing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 processes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 reflected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 physical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 squ
alor\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political
\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 corruption\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 emerging\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 industrial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\

ul0\strike0 city.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri

ke0 profession's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 organizational\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 roots\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 architecture\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-2
49\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 landscape\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 archit
ecture\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 were\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflec
ted\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 early\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 views\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 "do[ing]\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 city\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 wha
t\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 .\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 .\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 .\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
architecture\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 does\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 home"\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8211?\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improving\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 built\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 environment\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 raise\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 amenity\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 levels;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 increase\par\pard\plain\li144
0\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efficiency\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 performanc
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 necessary\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 functions;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promote\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 health,\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 safety,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 convenience.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 profession's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 roots\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 progressive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 reform\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 were\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ref
lected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argument
s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 independent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 "fourth\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 power"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
promoting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 gene
ral\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 over\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 narrow,\par\pard\plain
\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conflicting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
groups.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Others\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 vi
ewed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mechanism\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordinating\par\pard
\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 impacts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
ublic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 land\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 uses\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adjoining\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 property\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 owners\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 considering\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 future\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl
-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consequences\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 o
f\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 present\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 isolation\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 day-to-day\f0\fs22

\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 operating\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 responsibilitie

s.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Underlying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 all\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 was\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
belief\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conscious\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 applicati
on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 professional
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 expertise,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 instru
mental\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rationality,\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 scientific\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 methods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 could\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effectively\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promote\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 growth\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 stability\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 unplanned\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 forc
es\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competition.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 33\par\pard\pla
in\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Implicit\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 many\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 m
ore\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 formal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 justifi
cations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 examined\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 above.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 independent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 function\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promoting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collective\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 obviously\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 parallel\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pluralist\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\par\pard\plain\li1440\s
l-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumptio
n\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 calls\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 comprehensive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordination\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 similarly\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 recognize\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dea
ling\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 group\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 action.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 And\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-24
9\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consider\f0\fs22\

cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-range\f0\fs22\cf0

\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 current\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 likewise\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 acknowledge\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 for\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 informed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 policy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making.\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Noteworthy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 its\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 absence\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 any\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 co
ncern\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 distributional\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 which\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 were\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 largely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ignored\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 att
empts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promote\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 collective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 interest.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 34\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\
pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 By\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 midcentury,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 scientists\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 who\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 had\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 joined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ranks\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 academic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 began\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 severely\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 question\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 each\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argument
s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sector\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning:\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 concern\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 physical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 city\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 was\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 viewe
d\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 overly\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 restrictive;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perceptions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 urban\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 process\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 seen\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 politically\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 naive;\par\sect\sected\sbknone
\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\sl-295\par\pard\plain
\li1440\sl-116\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 32\par\pard\column\pl
ain\sl-337\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E..\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Public\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Interest\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Criterion",\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Association.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 46\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 J
uly\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1980,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 330:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Barry,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 Brian.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 PoliticalArgument,\f0\fs20\cf0\

b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul

0\strike0 Humanities\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 1965,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 234-235.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw106
20\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 33\par\p
ard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 examples\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 each\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argument\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Robinso
n,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Charles\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mulford
,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 City\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning,\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 G.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 P.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 Putnams,\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1
440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1916.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp
.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 291-303\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (the\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 quotation\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 291):\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (2)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Howard.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 John\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
T.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "In\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Defense\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Commissions",\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Institute\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 P
lanners,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 17\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Spring\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1951,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 89-93:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Tugwell.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Bettma
n,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Alfred,\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 City\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 Regional\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 Papers\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (edited\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 by\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Arthur\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
C.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Comey),\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cambri
dge,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mass.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Harvar
d\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 University\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-225\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 5-30,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Dunham.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Allison,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 "A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Legal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an
d\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Basis\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 City\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Columbia\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Law\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 58,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
1958,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 650-671.
\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\pla
in\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 34\par\pard\plain\l
i0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
earliest\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 example\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 this\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 concern\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 literature\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 known\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 author\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 is\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Webber.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Me

lvin\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 M\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw1
2240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Comprehensive\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Social\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Responsibility:\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Toward\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 AIP\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Consensus\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Profession's\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Role\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Purposes",\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Institute\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 Planners.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 29\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 (4)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 November\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
1963,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 232-241
.\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-307\par\pard\plain\li6057\sl-216\f0\fs
24\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 9
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop11750\shpright4320\shpbottom11750
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz103\shplid7794
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen
ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-344\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 technical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 solutions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 found\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Protestant\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 middle-class\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 views\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 city\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 life;\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attempts\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 promote\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
collective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
interest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revealed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 serve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 primari
ly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 needs\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 civic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 business\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 elites;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 democratic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 comp
rehensive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordination\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 developme

nt\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 proven\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs

22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 organizationally\par
\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 politically\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 impossible.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 35\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Accompanying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critiques\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 were\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 new\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conceptions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 val
ue-neutral,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rational\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 process\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 problem\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 identification,\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 definition,\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 analysis,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 implementa
tion,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 evaluati
on.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 In\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 recent\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 years\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\pla
in\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rational\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 model\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 has\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 come\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 under
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 severe\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attack\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 well\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 failing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 lo\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 recognize\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fundamental\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-2
54\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 constraints\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 organizational\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decision\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inherently\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ethical\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nature\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1
440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
practice;\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 organizational,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 s
ocial,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 psychol
ogical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 realities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 o
f\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 practic
e.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\par\pard\p
lain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 while\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 providing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collective
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dealing\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 externalities,\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 so\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 remains,\par\pard\plain\li
1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pla
nning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 profession\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 c
urrently\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lacks\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 widely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 accepted\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 procedural\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 model\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 defining\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 problems\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 justifying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 solutions."\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 36\par\pard\plain\sl-320\par\par
d\plain\li1440\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\
strike0 Arguments\par\pard\plain\sl-301\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf

0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 recent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\

ul0\strike0 emergence\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theories\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 urban\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 de
velopment\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 has\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adde
d\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 new\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dimension\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 debate\par\pard\plain\li1440\
sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 about\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 desirability\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 feasibility\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 37\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 From\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspective,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 role\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in
\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contemporary\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 understood\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 only\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 recognizing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
structure\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mod
ern\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capitalism\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 relates\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 physical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
environment.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 That\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
is,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argued,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 fundamental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 institutions\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capitalist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
society\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 systematically\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 promote\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 thos
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 who\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 control\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 productive\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 over\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 those\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 r
emainder\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 societ
y.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 formal\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 organization\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 state\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 likewise\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 assumed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 serve\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-term\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 creating\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 maintaining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 conditions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conducive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 efficient\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 accumula
tion\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sector,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 subordinating\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 conflicting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 short-run\f0\fs22\cf0

\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i

0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fa
ctions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-run\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 capitalist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 class,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 containing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 civil\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 strife\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 threatens\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capitalist\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 order.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 These\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 legitimized\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 prevailing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 democratic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ideology\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 portrays\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 state\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 neutral\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 instrument\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 serving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
society\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 whole.\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxists\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argue\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fundamental\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improvements
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 only\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revolutionary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 activity\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li144
0\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 labor\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 replacement\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 existing\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 institutions\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefiting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 new\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 ones\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 serving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interes
ts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 large.\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Essential\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reforms\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 include\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 ownership\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 means\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 production\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a
nd\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 centralized\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 would\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 replace\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 existing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 decision\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 processes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols
2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-2
00\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-364\par\pard\pl
ain\li1440\sl-116\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 35\par\pard\column
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\
par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-206\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 examples\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str

ike0 now-familiar\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critiques\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul

0\strike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Gans.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Herbert\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 J.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Ci
ty\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 America:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Sociological\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240
\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Analysis"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Gans,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Herbert\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 J..\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
People\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Plans
:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Essays\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Problems\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Solutions,\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 Basic\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Books.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1963;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Altshuler
.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Alan\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A.,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Goals\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Comprehensive\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Planning".\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Institute\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
31\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (5)\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 August\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1965,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 186-195:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 Bolan,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 S.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Emerging\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Views\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning
".\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Institute\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 33\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (4)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 July\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1967,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 233-246;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Kravitz,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Alan\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 S.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Mandaranism:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Handmaiden\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-23
0\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Conservative\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Poli
tics"\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Beyle,\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Thad\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 L..\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lathrop.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 George\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 T.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 (eds.).\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Politics:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Uneasy\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Partnership,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-2
30\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Odyssey\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1970.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr1
0\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 36\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Critiq
ues\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rational\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 model\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 dominated\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theory\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 literature\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 last\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 d

ecade.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\c
olw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reviews\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 this\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 literature\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 their\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 implications\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contemporary\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 practice\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 see\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 DiMento,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Joseph\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 F.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Th
e\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Consistency\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Doctrine\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Limits\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Cambridge.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mass.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 Oelgeschlager,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Gunn,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Hain,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
1980.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 44-\pa
r\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 117:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Alexander,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 Ernest\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 R.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 "After\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Rationality,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 What?\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Revie
w\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Responses\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Paradigm\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Breakdown",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\par\par
d\plain\li1440\sl-225\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Association,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 50\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Winter
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1984.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 62-69.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\col
sr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-13\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 37\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Exa
mples\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 here\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 include
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Castells,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Manuel,
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Question:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Approach,\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Cambridge,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mass.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 MIT\par\sect\sected\sbknone
\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 P
ress,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1977:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Harvey
,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 David,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Social\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Justice\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 City,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Baltimore,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Johns\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 Hopkins\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 University\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1973,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 195-\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 238;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Paris,\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Chris\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (ed.).\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Critical\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Readings\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 Theory,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Oxford,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 Pergamon,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1982.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ar
ticles\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cited\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\pa
r\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 footnote\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 39\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 below.\par\pard\plain\sl-200\
par\pard\plain\sl-307\par\pard\plain\li6000\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0

10
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop10603\shpright4320\shpbottom10603
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz89\shplid7830
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen
ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-344\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 comprehensive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordination\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 investment\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decisions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 democratic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 procedures\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 formulating\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 priorities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
restricting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
conflict\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-term\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interes
ts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society.\f0\
fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 38\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Applying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 this\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 urban\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning,\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 scholars\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 been\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 highly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\par\pard\plain\li1440\s
l-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 prac
tice\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theory.\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 against\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 examined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 above\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dismissed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 as\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mere\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ideological\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rationaliza
tions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fail\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 recognize\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 material\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conditions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 historical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 political\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 forces\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 allo

wed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0

\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 emerge\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 define\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 its\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 role\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 society.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Accepting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limitations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competition\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 outlined\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 above,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxists\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interpret\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners'\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 each\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sphere\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 primarily\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-2
54\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 serving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 at\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 expense\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 re
st\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society.\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attempts\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\par\pard\
plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 goods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 control\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 externalities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 assumed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 serve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 needs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 helping\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 manage\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inevitable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contradictio
ns\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capitalism\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revealed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 physical\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 city.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attempts\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 employ\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 scientific\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 techniques\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 professional\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 expertise\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 seen\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 helping\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-24
9\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 legitimize\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 state\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 casting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 terms\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 neutral\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 professionalism,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 scientific\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rationality.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 And\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 attempts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 advance\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 int
erests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 deprived

\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dismissed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 merely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 coopting\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 groups,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 forestalling\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 structural\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 reforms\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ar
e\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ultimately\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 required\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 bring\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 real\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 improvement\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 positions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 39
\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 While\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 extremely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
valuable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 helpin
g\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reveal\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 underlying\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nature\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 contemporary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning,\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 has\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 obvious\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 li
mitations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 guide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 practice.\f0\fs12\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 40\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 strict\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 analysis,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sees\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 all\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 relations\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 all\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 serving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 o
f\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 identif
ies\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 mechanirim\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 reform\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 than\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ra
dical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 transformation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 whi
ch\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 highly\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 unlikely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 near\par\pard\plain\li144
0\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 future:\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 if
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 needed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reforms\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 only\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revolutionary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 action\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 labor\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 al
l\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attempts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 help\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plai
n\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 needy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 merely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 delay\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ne
cessary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 structural\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
changes.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 there\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 no\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 significant\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 role\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0

\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reform-minded\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners\par\pa

rd\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 who\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 occupy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
ambiguous\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 class\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 po
sition\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 between\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 lab
or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital.\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 And\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rejection\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners'\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 attempts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\par\pard\plain\li
1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 apply\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
rofessional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 expertise\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 scientific\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
methods\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 policy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 merely\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 legitimizing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\pla
in\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 maintaining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 existing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 relations\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 deprives\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 professional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 m
ain\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resource\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dealing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 actors\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8211?\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 claims\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 professional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
expertise.\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 was\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 true\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 lor\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ana\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 againsi\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 examined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 earlier,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cannot\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 evaluated\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 abstract\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 but\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 must\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 exami
ned\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critically\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 light\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 present\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
realities.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Thus,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 w
hile\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 may\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theoretically\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 desirable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 replace\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 existing\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
decision\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 processes,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
this\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 highly\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 unlikely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 happen\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 most\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Western\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul

0\strike0 democracies.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0

\strike0 lack\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revolutionary\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 role\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 planners\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 analysis\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 does\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mean\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 they\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cannot\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 work\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 effectively\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 short-term\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reforms\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 progressive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 professionals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 community-based\par\pard\plain\
li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 organizalions.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 And\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 while\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
contemporary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 may\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 indeed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 s
erve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital.\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 not\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 s
erve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interes
ts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alone\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 clearly\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preferable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 exclusive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reliance\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 fundamentally\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 flawed\par\pard\plain\li1440\s
l-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 processes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competition.\pa
r\pard\plain\sl-320\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-215\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Co
nclusions\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\strike0 Implic
ations\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pa
rd\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-341\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-116\f0\fs12\chars
calex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 38\par\pard\column\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl
-383\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Harrington,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Michael,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Socialism,\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Saturday\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1972,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 270-307;\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Baran,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Paul\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
A.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw
12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Longer\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 View:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Essays\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 Toward\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Critique\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 P
olitical\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Economy.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Monthly\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1969,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 144-\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 149.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Huberman,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Leo\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Sweezy,\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Paul\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 M,\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Introduction\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 Socialism,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0

\ul0\strike0 York.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Monthly\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0

\strike0 Review\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 1968,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 60-65.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\c
olsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 39\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 S
ee,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 example,\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Fainstein,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Norman\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Fainstein,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Susan\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 S.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 Debates\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Impact\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\
sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Theory\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Within\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 United\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Stales',\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 InternationaIJournalof\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Regional\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 Research.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 3\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 (3)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 September\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-225\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1979,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 381403:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Beauregard,\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Robert\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 'Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Advanced\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Capitalist\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 State'\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Burchell,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Robert\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 W.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par
\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Sternlieb,\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 George\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (eds.),\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Theory\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
1980s:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Search\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Directions,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Brunswick,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 N.J.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 Center\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 for\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Polic
y\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Research,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1978:\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Harvey,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 David,\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'On\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Ideology\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning'\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ibid.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Boyer,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 M.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Christine.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Dreaming\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Rational\f0\fs20\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 City:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 Myth\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 City\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Cambridge,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Mass.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 MIT\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Press,\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1983.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610
\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-123\f0\fs12\charscalex-10\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 40\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-230\column\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
The\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 discussion\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 he
re\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 draws\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 heavily\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs20\cf0

\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Fainstein\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i

0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Fainstein,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit.\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pa
rd\plain\sl-307\par\pard\plain\li4372\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 11
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop11750\shpright4320\shpbottom11750
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz103\shplid7857
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn shapePath}{\sv 4}}
{\sp{\sn fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn lineColor}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn posrelh}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn posrelv}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
{\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}
}}\sect\sectd\sbkpage\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\
sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Argumen
ts\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-344\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 preceding\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 discussion\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 has\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 examined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
variety\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argume
nts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 against\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 modern\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ind
ustrial\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 context.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 U
nderlying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 this\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 app
arent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 diversity\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 implicit\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consensus\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 about\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\par\pard\plain\li1440\s
l-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sector\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planni
ng\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perform\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 four\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 vital\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 functions\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 \u8211?\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promoting\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 common\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 community\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 considering\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 group\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 action,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\par\pard\plain\li1440
\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 base\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decision\f0\fs22\cf

0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 making,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i

0\ul0\strike0 considering\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 distributional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 private
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action.\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1
440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 firs
t\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 government\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resolve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
prisoner's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 dilemma\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conditions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collective\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumption\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 goods,\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 such\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 healthy\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pleasant\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 environment,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 which\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cannot\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 provided\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adequately\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 even\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 perfectly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competitive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 markets.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 second\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 res
ults\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inability\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 deal\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 costs\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 benefits\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 production\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consumption\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 not\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pr
ices\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revenues.\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 third\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflected\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
private\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\p
ar\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 improved\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-term\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 location\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decisions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 necessary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
making\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 adequately\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 informed\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decisions.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 And\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fourth\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 results\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fact\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 com
petition\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alone\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 incapable\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf

0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 principle\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i

0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 resolving\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 distributional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 questions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 socially\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 acceptable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 manner.\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 From\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 pluralist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspective,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 required\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 r
epresent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 broadly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 d
efined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 t
hat\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neglected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competition\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 between\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 organized\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 groups\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 representing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 narrower\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interests.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 And\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 it\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 required\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 represent\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decisions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 groups\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individuals\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
who\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 not\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 directly\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 involved\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 bargaining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 process.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Improved\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 sh
ort-\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 long-term
\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consequences\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 alternative\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 policies\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 required\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 facilitate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 group\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 barga
ining\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 process.\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 And\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 required\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 serve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 advocates\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 nee
diest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 members,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 who
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 systematically\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 excluded\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 group\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 bargaining\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 process.\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflect\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 representing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 collective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\

par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 community\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 calls\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 independent\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 function
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 government\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 charged\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promoting\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 interest.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 consider
ing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 effects\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 individual\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 action\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflected\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl
-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conception\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 comprehensive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordinati
on.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 From\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 this\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspective,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 required\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 provide\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ph
ysical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 development\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 city\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 long-range\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 implications\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 current\par\pard\plain\l
i1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 actions.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Distributional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 questions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 were\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 regrettably\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 largely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ignored\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 planning's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efforts\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 to\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promote\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 aggregate\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest.\par\pard\pl
ain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 While\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 largely\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critical\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contemporary\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 practice,\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 recognizes\f0\fs22
\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 each\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arg
uments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plannin
g\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 identified\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 by\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 other\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspectives.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 representing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 collective\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
interests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 community\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflected\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 prescriptions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 replacing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 existing\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\

i0\ul0\strike0 decentralized\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 markets\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 centralized\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inte
rests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 whole.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 The\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
considering\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 external
ities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 reflected
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 calls\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 comprehensive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 coordination\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 investment\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 decisions.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 From\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 M
arxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspective,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 forms\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 info
rmation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 primarily\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
serve\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest
s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capital;\par\
pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 thus,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 promote\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 fundamental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 change\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 are\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 called\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 upo
n\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 inform\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl
-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 underlying\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 rea
lities\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 capitali
st\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 And\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 need\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 correct\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 structural\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 imbalances\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 power\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 wealth\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 shape\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contemporary\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 society\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 underlies\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 call\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 radical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
reformation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 soc
iety.\par\pard\plain\sl-310\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 While\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 all\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 f
our\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perspectives\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 p
ropose\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planni
ng\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 required\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theory\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fulfill\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 fundamental\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 social\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 r
equirements,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 they\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
each\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 recognize\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 their\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 own\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 way\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 these\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 theoretical\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0

\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 are\par\sect\sected\sbknone\co

ls2\colno1\colw5350\colsr10\colno2\colw6880\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 insufficient.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Contemporary\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 economists\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-254\column\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 argue\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 market\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competition,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 properly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 structured\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain
\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 augmented,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 more
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 efficient\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 equitable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 than\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 forms\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 sector\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 re
gulation.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Critics\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
such\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Lindblom\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 revealed\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planners'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 models\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 centralized\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 coordination\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 impossible\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 decent
ralized\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 democratic\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
society.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 And\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critics\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 1960s\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1970s\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Marxist\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 critics\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 today\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 demonstrated\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 convincingly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 that\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 traditional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 practice,\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 while\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 couched\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 terms\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 neutral\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 technical\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 competence\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 interest,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 has\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 primarily\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 served\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 i
nterests\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 societ
y's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 wealthiest\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 most\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 powerful\f0\
fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 members.\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-365
\par\pard\plain\li6000\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 12\sect\sectd\sbkpag
e\pgwsxn12240\pghsxn15840\sected\cols1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pa
rd\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-359\par\pard\plain\li3600\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 Richard\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 E.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 Klosterman:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Arguments\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 For\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 Against\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pa
rd\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-399\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs22\cf0\b
0\i0\ul0\strike0 An\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 objective\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 evaluation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 sixty\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 years'\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike

0 experience\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 with\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
town\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 country\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Great\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Britain\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 United\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Sta
tes\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 must\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 recognize
\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 tremendous\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 gap\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 between\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning's\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 potential\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 its\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 performance.\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 While\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 there\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
have\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 been\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 severa
l\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 remarkable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 succe
sses,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 much\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 contemporary\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 practice\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 still\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 limited\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 the\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pr
eparation\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "boil
er\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plate"\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 plans,\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 avoidance\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 controversy,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 routine\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 administration\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 overly\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
rigid\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conserva
tive\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 regulations.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 4
1\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 It\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 is\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 thus\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 open\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 question\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 whether\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 currently\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 practiced\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs
22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 world\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 over,\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 deserves\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 high\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 levels\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 support\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 or\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 whether\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 ot
her\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 professional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 g
roups\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 institutional\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arrangements\f0
\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 can\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 better\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 perform\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 vital\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 social\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 functions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 identified\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 above.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 As\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 result,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 th
e\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 arguments\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 for\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 outlined\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 above\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 cannot\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 be\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 taken\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f
0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 defence\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 status\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 quo\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 but\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
must\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 serve\f0\fs22\cf

0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 as\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 a\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s

trike0 challenge\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 profession\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 learn\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 its\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 mistakes\f0\fs22\c
f0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 build\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0
\ul0\strike0 on\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 new\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 expanded\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\f
s22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 conceptions\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 public\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 interest,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 information,\f0\fs22\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 political\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 action\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 to\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 realize\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 its\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 ultimate\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 potential.\f0\fs12\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 42\par\pard\plain\sl-316\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-216\f0\fs24\cf0\b\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Acknowledgments\par\pard\plain\sl-305\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-198\f0\fs2
2\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 I\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 gratefully\f0\fs22\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 acknowledge\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 valuable\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 comments\f0\fs22\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 received\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 from\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Robert\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 A.\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Beauregard\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Rutgers\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-249\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 University,\
f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Jay\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 M.\f0\fs22\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Stein\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 the\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Georgia\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 Institute\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Technology,\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 th
e\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 anonymous\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 review
ers\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Town\par\pa
rd\plain\li1440\sl-254\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs22\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 Review.\par\sect\sected\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno
2\colw10620\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pa
rd\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-20
0\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\pla
in\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\
pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\p
lain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\pa
r\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\s
l-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard
\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-204\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-116\f0\fs12\charsca
lex-10\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 41\par\pard\column\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-2
00\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\pl
ain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par
\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl
-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\
plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\p
ar\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\
sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\par
d\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200
\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-246\par\pard\plai
n\li0\sl-181\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 al
so\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Branch,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Melvill
e\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 C.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'Delusions\f
0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Defusions\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 City\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 the\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 United\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike

0 States",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Management\par\sect\sected\sbknone\co
ls1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Scie
nce,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 16\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (12)\f0\fs
20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 August\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1970,\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 714-732,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Branch.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0
\strike0 Melville\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 C.,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\stri
ke0 'Sins\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 City
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planners",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Public
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Administration\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Review.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 January/February\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1982,\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1-5.\par\sect\sected
\sbknone\cols2\colno1\colw1610\colsr10\colno2\colw10620\pard\plain\li1440\sl-118
\f0\fs12\charscalex-14\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 42\par\pard\plain\li0\sl-225\column
\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 See\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Alexander,\f0\
fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 cit..\f0\fs20\cf0
\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 138-140:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i
0\ul0\strike0 Klosterman.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 op.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\
ul0\strike0 cit.:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Forester,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul
0\strike0 John.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 'Critical\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\
strike0 Theory\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Practice",\par\sect\sected\sbknone\col
s1\colno1\colw12240\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journ
al\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 the\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 American\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Association.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 46\f0\fs20\cf
0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (3)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 July\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 1980,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 275-286:\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Clavel,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 Pierre,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Forester.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike
0 John\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Goldsmith,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 William\f0\fs20\
cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 W.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (eds.).\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\
i0\ul0\strike0 Urban\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 Regional\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\s
trike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Age\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Austerity,\f0\f
s20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 New\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 York,\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Pergamon,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 1980:\par\pard\plain
\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Dyckman,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 John\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 W.,\
f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 "Reflections\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 on\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Practice\f0
\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 in\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 an\f0\fs20\cf0\b0
\i0\ul0\strike0 Age\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\str
ike0 Reaction",\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Journal\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\st
rike0 of\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Planning\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0
Education\par\pard\plain\li1440\sl-230\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 and\f0\fs2
0\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Research,\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 3\f0\fs20\cf0\
b0\i0\ul0\strike0 (1)\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 Summer\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\u
l0\strike0 1983.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 pp.\f0\fs20\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strik
e0 5-12.\par\pard\plain\sl-200\par\pard\plain\sl-307\par\pard\plain\li6000\sl-2
16\f0\fs24\cf0\b0\i0\ul0\strike0 13
{\shp{\*\shpinst\shpleft1440\shptop12442\shpright4320\shpbottom12442
\shpfhdr0\shpbxpage\shpbypage
\shpwr3\shpwrk0\shpfblwtxt1\shpz43\shplid7884
{\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 20}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipH}{\sv 0}}
{\sp{\sn fFlipV}{\sv 0}}

{\sp{\sn
{\sp{\sn
{\sp{\sn
{\sp{\sn
{\sp{\sn
{\sp{\sn
{\sp{\sn
{\sp{\sn
{\sp{\sn
{\sp{\sn
}}}

shapePath}{\sv 4}}
fFillOK}{\sv 0}}
fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}}
lineColor}{\sv 0}}
lineWidth}{\sv 0}}
lineDashing}{\sv 0}}
posrelh}{\sv 1}}
posrelv}{\sv 1}}
fArrowheadsOK}{\sv 1}}
fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}}