Table D-2M, Allowable defect depth vs width across face (metric) Figure D-3, Flange surface damage assessment: Pits and Dents Allowable depth depends on gasket type; hard-faced or soft-faced. The inspection report states that the gasket in place is a spiral wound type, which according to Annex B of ASME PCC-1 is regarded as a soft-faced gasket. From the inspection report; (1) The radial width of the gasket seating face is w=9mm (2) Dent 1 the projected radial distance across the seating surface is rd=2mm, the dent depth is 0.6mm (3) Dent 2 the projected radial distance across the seating surface is rd=4mm, the dent depth is 0.3mm (4) Circumferential separation distance between dent (1) and dent (2) is 40mm The two dents do not interact Dent (1)
rd<w/4 (i.e., 2 < 2.25mm)
Allowable depth is 1.27mm (Table D-2M, ASME PCC-1)
Result: ACCEPTABLE, actual depth (0.6mm) < allowable depth (1.27mm)
Dent (2)
w/4<rd<w/2 (i.e., 2.25 < 4 < 4.5mm)
Allowable depth is 0.76mm (Table D-2M, ASME PCC-1)
Result: ACCEPTABLE, actual depth (0.3mm) < allowable depth (0.76mm)
Conclusion: The flange, with 2 dents on the seating face, is assessed as ACCEPTABLE according to the criteria in ASME PCC-1