Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Through Creativity
Search For Common Ground
Jakarta Indonesia
Saadiya Usmani
Table of Contents
Description
Number
Page
1.1
Dedications
1.2
Executive Summary
1.3
Key Words Description
1.4
Acknowledgments
1.5
Introduction
1.6
Internship Description
1.7
Statement Of Relevance
1.8
Literature Review
1.9
Learning Objectives
1.10 Methodology
1.11 Presentation of the Key Findings
1.12 Challenges Faced
1.13 Conclusions
1.13.1.1 Recommendations
1.13.1.2 Next Steps
1.14 Appendices
1.15 References and Bibliography
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
15
24
26
26
40
43
44
47
48
50
Dedications:
This Thesis and My Masters Degree is dedicated to my brother
Ahmed Ali Usmani for showing me the power of persistence,
perseverance and unconditional Love.
And for Maitreya; for shining His ever guiding light on me each
and every step of the way.
Executive Summary:
Indonesia is a country of many paradoxes. It is the worlds second
largest democracy, and it is also houses the world largest Muslim
population along with five other major religions. Indonesia has seen
many violent conflicts erupt ever since colonization and to this day
the country seems to be ever divided on culture, identities, religions
and religious philosophies.
Indonesian history has been tainted with mass scale killings, based
on differing religious, political and societal ideologies. On the other
hand, it has also seen its fair share of fighting for independence.
Under the Dutch rule, the Indonesian people put up a united front to
eject the monarchy; as with the concept of colonization amongst
many countries, where there seems to a poor governance, lack of
independent thinking and weak leadership. The country has been
unable to find a united vision ever since its independence
undoubtedly due to the divide and conquer vision that the history of
colonization is based upon.
Recently, Indonesia has seen one of the highest rates of
radicalization of its youth, as well as seeing religious, extremism and
intolerance grow significantly in a matter of just a few years. This
internship was focused on looking at the various methods of
countering a violent extremist narrative with a more positive
perception of community and peace building.
This internship was conducted at Search For Common Ground
Indonesia, located in Jakarta. SFCG is an International NGO providing
peace building and conflict transformation services across 53
countries in the world.
Acknowledgements:
For this Internship report I first and foremost like to thank The Divine
for allowing me the means and the ability to pursue my ambitions
and dreams of cultivating large-scale change.
I would like to thank Mari Fitzduff for taking me under her wing and
agreeing to be my advisor, as well as helping me in navigating a
somewhat interesting and at times intense Internship. Also, for
being a sounding board when times got tough, and telling me that
this too shall pass.
I would also like to thank the program administrators, Marc Kiredjian
and Sandra Jones, without their help; I would not be able to immerse
myself in such a great learning experience.
I would like to thank the Administration Staff at Search For Common
Ground Indonesia for their love, support, smiling faces and above all
their perseverance and their ability to shine even in times of
extreme adversity. Pramita Handayani, Anggi Arini, Valleria and
Gressia, you taught me the power of kindness.
Last but not least, I would like to thank my parents: My father,
whose constant words of encouragement, extreme hard work and all
encompassing support made this Masters program possible; and for
my mother for her grace, humility and for encouraging her children
to always follow the right path, no matter how difficult it maybe.
Introduction:
This internship was carried out at the country offices of Search For
Common Ground (Search) in Jakarta Indonesia. Search has been in
operation in Indonesia for the past 11 years, and has worked on a
variety of projects, focusing around the field of peace building and
dialogue. In addition to peace building work they have also carried
out programs in prison facilities, youth empowerment and women
empowerment in Politics.
Though the majority of the work that Search Indonesia carries out
has been mainly towards conflict transformation, more recently
Search Indonesia has been actively working towards achieving
gender equality, promoting religious tolerance as well as cultivating
creativity for at risk youth. They have produced comic books, radio
shows and films that enhance as well as compliment the work in and
around the Asia Pacific region.
Their Mission statement is as follows:
Internship Description:
My Internship was based in Jakarta, Indonesia, with limited travel to
local project areas. The start date for my internship was July 29th
2015 with a proposed end date of November 30th 2015. During my
time at Search Indonesia, I was a project intern responsible for
overseeing ongoing projects, providing inputs on improvements,
looking for new projects and funding, finalizing and submitting final
reports for projects completed and devising ways for innovative
mediations and conflict transformation procedures. I was heavily
involved with working with the project team responsible for dealing
with Countering Violent Extremism within youth. I also worked on
identifying new project opportunities, as well as drawing up
Expressions of Interest Statements (EOI), Concept Notes (CN) and
Request For Information (RFIs) for various projects with a number of
international donors and funding organizations.
Statement of Relevance:
Dialogue is instrumental when trying to engineer peace. My decision
for choosing to do my internship with Search Indonesia was
predominantly based on this ideology. Search Indonesia has had
over 11 years of building acceptance tolerance and a strong
commitment to bring coexistence for communities within the
Indonesian context.
Indonesia has seen large-scale colonial and societal struggles, some
of which continue to this day. When Search Indonesia started its
operations in Jakarta nearly 11 years ago, the idea for dialogue as
well as bringing various communities together was still in its infancy.
The history of Indonesia is rich not only in culture but also in its
struggles. It faced many occupations mainly by the Europeans, the
most recent being the Dutch occupation. An important aspect to
note however is that prior to the colonial occupation, there was no
country called Indonesia, it was mainly large islands, with various
cultures, religions and people living in cohesion and accepting each
other and their values.
The colonial period and the years following independence have been
the bloodiest and conflict ridden in this regions history. There had
been large-scale arrests and deaths of citizens that believed in an
alternative political view. Author Antoine Dake elaborates in his book
The Spirit Of The Red Banteng (2002) where he talks about the role
of military dictatorship in Indonesia and the ensuing conflict that
continues to this day. He argues that the premature death of
communism led to various conflicts and the downfall of the peaceloving Indonesian people. His critical analysis of the role of the
United States meddling in the affairs of the Indonesian people he
says is the sole reason why the country is in such disarray.
10
11
12
13
Regulations can on certain events can work both ways: in majorityChristian Papua last month, Muslims fought a memo demanding that
no prayers should be held on a religious holiday; the ensuing clash
left one dead and a mosque razed. Where a mosque was accidently
burnt when perpetrators tried to set fire to the food stalls, could
have been much more serious, but the dialogue between the local
church and the mosque helped in diffusing the situation. Young
politicians in the area have asked for more interfaith dialogue and
training, as well as more religious freedom for all minorities. Young
leaders are also emphasising the need to have a shift in the
communities, religious mindset as well as a shift in perception and
manner of thinking and to devise ways to encourage empathy and
religious tolerance.
One of the main issues that Indonesia faces is the rising number of
youth that are so often the victims of brainwashing due to their age
are unable to decipher right from wrong. The terrorist recruitment
cells have cashed in on this and the recruitment efforts have only
increased overtime. In July 2015, 3 young men were sentenced to
prison over attempting to join an Islamic extremist group Eastern
Indonesia Mujahideen led by Indonesias most wanted man Santoso.
The presiding judge Kun Marioso told the North Jakarta district court
that three men Ahmet Mahmut, 20, Altinci Bayram, 29, and Tuzer
Abdul Basit, 23, had broken anti-terror laws and were guilty of an
"evil conspiracy".(Jakarta Globe, July 2015)
The new generations of Jihadis that are coming to the forefront on
the war against the West are young, more determined, and some
may say a result of the constant brainwashing they have received
over the past decade. Most of these young adults have chosen to
follow this route due to a lack of clear direction, an obvious vacuum
in programs for youth as well as lacking a vision towards a peaceful
future. The recent cases in Aceh also provide a much deeper and
14
troubling insight into the religious intolerance where laws are being
manipulated into deepening the religious divide. Aceh is also
troubling to witness as the number of women who have turned to
radicalization and extremism has grown drastically. Aceh also
remains one of the historic cases where the number of female
fighters who had voluntarily joined GAM was significantly large.
(Worldwatch.org)
Overall, these cases highlight the pressing problem of violent
extremism and recruitment that persists in Indonesia. Reducing the
risk of violent extremism among at-risk youth and offenders in
Indonesia, is the only way towards a peaceful region.
Literature Review:
15
16
electronic media, and other tools that bring the world to your fingertips, the nature
of conflicts has also advanced; with this, ambiguity as well as multi state
complexities also comes to light.
Levinger has neatly outlined five main dimensions of conflict and how they can be
used to identify, prevent or mitigate conflict; they will be one of the tools I will be
using to identify and outline conflict in the Indonesian standpoint as well as using
them to describe and elaborate on the counter terrorism narrative. Brief
descriptions on how these dimensions will be utilized in the internship report are
described below.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
The Political Dimension: This dimension deals with the subrogation of power at
national and sub national levels. This also identifies the key players, regions and
conflict hotbeds. Political dimensions are extremely important in understanding as
well as assisting in setting up policies and procedures. This dimension also
provides an in-depth insight on the political landscape and its importance in
dealing with local hubs of political power.
17
18
Conflict and Terrorism are two words that are sometimes used synonymously
however the differences between them are stark, though the lines where conflict
ends and terrorism begins can sometimes me muddied.
Bruce Hoffman talks about Terrorism in a completely altered light to what the
general perception of terrorism maybe. In his book Inside Terrorism, he discusses
that the history of terrorism comes from governments trying to use force or terror
to subdue its people, and strike fear amongst them.
He uses a political definition to explain the concept of terrorism better:
A system of terror.
Government by intimidation as directed and carried out by the party in
power
A more generic definition of terrorism as given by the Oxford English Dictionary is
as follows:
A policy intended to strike with terror against whom it is adopted; the
employment methods of intimidation; the fact of terrorizing or condition of
being terrorized.
19
terror, we are still very much in the throes of conflict, many of which seem to be
escalating as time progress.
The ideology behind terrorism has evolved over time, where first terrorism was
associated with governments trying to subdue their own people without their
wishes, to what the recent perception of terrorism is; A group of people using
arms, ammunitions and destruction to instill fear, cause large scale deaths to their
perceived enemies as well as becoming outlaws of society resulting in extreme
turmoil and struggles for others as well as the terrorist themselves. An interesting
find however has been the difficulty I have faced when conceptualizing terrorism,
as the media biases of today seems to skew all perceptions of terrorism by the
wayside. In a study conducted by David Rappaport he merges the old definition
of terrorism with a new one and outlines the concept of terrorism as below:
Terrorism is a politically motivated tactic involving the threat or use of
force or violence in which the pursuit of publicity plays a major role.
The recent cases of ISIS and its actions and policies for the Islamic caliphate is
extremely interesting, as it outlines how glorifying the religion and even the idea
of being a part of the Islamic caliphate seems to be very appealing to many
people. The videos and Internet channels that promote ISIS openly show
beheadings, as well as delivering a constant stream of indoctrination propaganda
to aggrandize the political power and flex its violent muscles to instill fear
amongst their enemies.
Terrorism and religion as unfortunate as it maybe have often become tantamount
when analyzing world conflict. With the likes of Boko Haram in Nigeria, the
Taliban with its various factions in Afghanistan, Pakistan and the neighboring
regions, the radical attacks in France, ISIS in the middle east as well as various
militant Jihadi organizations have dragged religion into what they know is a very
touchy and petulant issues for many. However, it must be noted that in order to
understand terrorism and its root causes, one must understand the instigating
factors that help to create the brainwashed mentality that leads to large scale
acts of violence.
20
Most at risk individuals for being brainwashed are the youth between the ages of
16-25, who are constantly at threat for being used for purposes that are more
sinister than what meets the eye. During various interactions with the youth in
Indonesia a troubling discovery was made, where a lot of the radicalized youth,
found no hesitation that they would completely support Hamas, ISIS or even at
times Al-Qaida. Many wanted to go and live in countries like Syria so that they
could spread the message of Islam and work towards a peaceful afterlife.
The difference between radicalization and militancy can get blurry, as has been
witnessed in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Nigeria, and Indonesia to name a few. The
constant coaching about spreading the words of a religion as well glamorizing
such acts of terrorism and comparing them to martyrdom is a concept known to
all. The teachings in madrassas, the unionizing in universities and colleges as
well as various religious leaders spreading false information about religions all
leads to chaos, confusion and more destruction for the nave minds.
Effects of Radicalization on Youth
The effects of radicalization and brainwashing on youth can be catastrophic. As
we are seeing with the recruits who willingly join ISIS, from across the world, or
the young soldiers that had joined the Tamil Tigers, Al Qaeda, the Taliban has
presented generations of militancy and flawed mindsets, which leads to larger
communities and societies being affected for decades to come.
The need to have the youth understand the difference between terrorism, conflict
and faith is a strong one. In the recent United Nations AMMAN Youth Declaration
signed in Jordan earlier this year is a proof that the world is now shifting its views
from that of countering militancy with conflict, to countering militancy and
terrorism by educating and changing the mindsets of the youth. First hand
accounts of the Arab spring, show us the true power of the youth, where
supposedly infallible leaders like Hosseini Mubarak could not withstand the
pressure brought on by his own people.
Indonesia is no exception and has seen how influential and coercive the youth
can be. In 1998, the New Order was singlehandedly brought down by the young
university and college going students. Similarly youth has been responsible for
21
22
23
Learning Objectives:
24
25
26
Methodology
The internship report was based on qualitative research, combining
reading materials provided during lectures with Indonesian policies
and news narratives. I also spent many hours at the Central Jakarta
Library to comb through books and historical data on the various
conflicts that happened in Aceh, Papua, East Timor etc. I also
conducted research by holding informal interviews with the students
and participants who had partaken in the countering violent
extremism program. I additionally held many hours of political
debate sessions with my co-workers on their ideologies and political
thought patterns when it came to military dictatorships and what it
means to have a vision of a country they would like to be a part of.
One of the most important questions that I felt which brought up a
lot of emotion from people was what kind of country would you want
to leave for your children. Informal interviews and political dialogue
sessions gave me a lot of insight on how people felt, their emotions
as well as their passions towards making a change in society,
something that is often missing in desk research. In addition to
working on this internship report I also assisted in drafting
proposals, outlining activities, setting up reflection meetings as well
as conducting psychological testing for participants in the
Countering Violent Extremism program.
27
29
IndonesiaimpingesonAustraliasdeepeststrategicpreoccupationsintwo
ways.Becauseofitsproximityandsheersize,ithasthestrategicpotentialto
poseaseriousmilitarychallengetoAustraliadirectly.Anditisalso[theonly
countryinSoutheastAsia]strongenoughtohelpdefendourneighborhood
againstanintruder.Whetheritisstrongorweak,therefore,Indonesiaoffers
bothpotentialprotectionandpotentialthreatstoAustralia.(LowyInstitute,
2007)
However that is not to say that Australia has had a tempestuous
relationship with Indonesia, but has maintained a widely peaceful
and cordial relationship with its neighbor. However, Indonesia has
often accused Australia of displaying white supremacy views and
ideologies. With the recent rise in extremism and pro fundamentalist
ideologies, Australia has accused Indonesia for not doing enough to
curb such fanatic views. A detailed table outline of Australias
strategic policies is provided in Appendix A. Despite its ups and
down Australian-Indonesian policy agrees on the general support of
US policies in the Pacific region.
New Zealand:
During my internship term, I saw that New Zealand had an
increased interest in the political, as well as economic interest in
Indonesia and its capacity building measures. Undoubtedly the close
proximity of Indonesia and its vast expansive region is of interest to
any country looking for not only survival but also envisioning the
future and future needs. Given the fact that New Zealand has
recognized the strategic importance of Indonesias archipelago and
its large natural resources base, and an economy that grows every
year in population by about the size of New Zealand itself, is a
30
ASEAN:
The foreign policy plan for any state head is continuously formed, by
the necessity to safeguard the country's dynamic interest and state
autonomy from external pressures. In an ever-changing geostrategic
setting, the peripheral risks facing Indonesia can be estimated to be
numerous as well as multifaceted; the same also goes for the other
31
32
33
Jakarta and New Delhi have always enjoyed a close relationship due
to their closeness in culture, history and political motives. As India
becomes Indonesias third largest ASEAN trading partner, it places a
greater emphasis on such strategic relations to prosper. In 2005
Indonesia and India signed a strategic partnership agreement,
where both sides agreed to work on Economics, Security, Regional
Cooperation and Diplomacy. Though the trade between the two
countries has been increasing, it is still fairly limited to a few
extractive industries such as coal and palm oil. To make matters
worst, in terms of strategic partnerships there are still no direct
flights between the two countries.
Also India has kept a close eye on the conflict on the ground in
Indonesia, specifically due to its closeness of the Aceh province with
the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. Both countries have signed a
joint cooperation agreement in 2001, but the implementation of
such an agreement has been slow to take off, and both countries
still deal with internal sensitivities as well as lack of confidence to
open up their military facilities to each other.
Other countries in the South Asian region also share close ties with
Indonesia, mainly due to the similarities in religion such as Pakistan.
However, more recently these relations have been soured by
numerous accusations of breach of trust, more recently the
Indonesian ambassador and his wife were killed in a helicopter crash
in the Northwestern Region of Pakistan, it has become exceedingly
difficult for business people to obtain visas to conduct business in
Indonesia and in Pakistan. Also Jakarta has repeatedly accused
Islamabad for not doing enough for closing the passageway for ISIS
fighters from Indonesia to Syria.
Strategically as a budding Indo-Pacific power, Indonesia has the
luxury to further its ability to form strong alliances across numerous
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
During this internship striking examples of how the youth can be led
by violence was extremely intriguing to watch. Speaking with the
few participants that were part of the Countering Violent Extremism
group, they talked about how innocently it all starts, and with the
constant brainwashing, things can get hairy very quickly. With
Indonesias sense of a weak nationhood (IPAC, 2014) it is fairly easy
to deter the youth from one path to another. With the military
forcing its own agendas the young men and women seem to be
without a leader who can guide them on the correct path. Many
young men that have joined extremist organizations have done so
because it gives them sense of morality as well as an identity, as
discussed previously.
Talking to one young person who was approached and somewhat
radicalized by the ISIS recruiters, he elaborated on what a surreal
experience it had been for him barely managing to escape the
recruitment process of ISIS. It started off with a fairly brief
conversation about the purpose of life, which then went deeper into
the purpose of human beings as Muslims and the west trying to
corrupt their minds. The recruiter who was asked me to called
Imam or a religious scholar, then promised him money, a passport
and a ticket to make it to Afghanistan, from there a handler, would
then take him to Uzbekistan and so forth. The example of ISIS
recruitment are many, where even street youth and women are
asked to join this organization all in the name of the religion.
Indonesia is a very fascinating country to observe when it comes to
violent extremism, though extremely pluralistic in many areas, the
hotbeds of fanaticism can put certain extremely conservative areas
of Afghanistan and Pakistan to shame. Youth movements are highly
influential and the youth seem to know and use their power through
violent means whenever they consider appropriate.
41
Social
media
and
technological
advances
have
not
eluded
42
Director of IPAC Sidney Jones has taken this matter seriously and
says If this is one unit, in one city then it may be higher than I
thought, referring to the number of Indonesians actively joining the
fight in Syria. Jones continues to say, It wouldnt take more than
two or three of them to come back and get a little unit into shape to
do something more dangerous than we have had in the past 10
years.
Self-radicalization is a growing concern and problem that Indonesia
is beginning to address. Violent extremist youth and groups such as
Jamaah Islamiyah, Jamaah Ansyarud Tauhid and Tauhid Wal Jihad are
becoming a breeding ground for such individuals who seek
freedom through extreme actions coupled with religion.
The
increasing use of social media has become their number one tool for
such indoctrination. If Indonesia and its government are not careful
on identifying the weak links, as well as breaking the chain of
recruitment, they may very well become the worlds worst case
study on the use of social media as a tool for extremist recruitment.
(Institute of Opinion, July 2014)
Not only has there has been no systematic efforts that have been
made either by various civil society organizations or by the
government to identify and challenge these groups, but there also
has been no policy framework in place to breakup the already
ingrained social media campaigns targeting the at-risk youth
population. The Indonesian government needs to invest and put
greater thought into countering terrorism online if Indonesia is
serious about combatting the growing concern that Indonesia will be
heavily targeted for extremist recruitment. (Institute of Opinion, July
2014)
Overall, these cases highlight the pressing problem of violent
extremism and recruitment that persists in Indonesia. By reducing
the risk of violent extremism among at-risk youth and offenders in
43
Challenges Faced:
During my four months internship, the word that can describe my
experience at Search would be best suited is a paradox. Whereas I
got a chance to learn a lot of valuable insight about Indonesia, its
political, geographical and economic significance; very little actually
came from the organization itself.
Challenges with Leadership: The initial two months of the
internship felt somewhat similar to that of an authoritarian regime,
where staff members were constantly scared and worried for
speaking or even giving opinions on day-to-day matters. As
someone who has had significant managerial experience, it didnt
take long for me to figure out that the dysfunction was a top down
managerial issue.
Due to the large number of female staff and the nature of the
passive and demure Indonesians, it was at times painful to watch
the chain of events unfolding on a day-to-day basis. The irony was
that this organization and more specifically the country director
constantly emphasized the importance of conflict resolution through
dialogue and the power of transformative peace building, where as
the ground reality was significantly different and completely
contrary to the organizations vision and missions.
After the country directors departure a leadership vacuum
transpired, , where no programs made progress, I being an intern
pushed the program department on submitting proposals to various
44
45
Conclusions:
To sum up this internship, masters program, thesis and putting into
action my experiences not only in Indonesia, but also observing the
46
47
The problem with this strategic plan was that there were no clear
guidelines on how this would be achieved. Government outreach
was only limited to print and media campaigns, but as it became
48
evidently clear by 2013 that not enough was being achieved and the
goals were not being met by far and wide margins, the government
decided to formulate a body within the government which would
allows for NGOs as well as Civil Society Organizations to partake in
peace building and dialogue processes to enhance the prevention as
well as strengthen early detection mechanisms for radicalization of
Indonesian people specifically the youth. With the formation of the
FKPT (terrorism prevention coordination forums) has allowed for
many Civil Society Organizations such as Search to step forward and
start working towards building relationships on a grass roots level.
The main goal, which has yet to be achieved, is to create a standard
methodology for the entire country that can then be applied across
the archipelago enabling citizens to unite for a specific purpose.
Though the idea on the face of it seems noble and worthy of
expansion, one must understand that Indonesia with its vast land
and thousands of tribes and cultures cannot be fit into a one size fits
all. The use of CSOs and NGOs is a useful tool in determining all
levels of societies are reached, however, the government needs to
ensure that the programs and project funding handed out by the
donors are effectively making an impact.
Youth Deradicalization:
When dealing with Youth and violent extremism one of the main
elements to keep in mind is to be able to deal with the youth on
their level or intellect as well as allowing them to pursue their
energies in a manner that is beneficial for their highest good. One of
the ways that youth engagement can be highly effective is by
promoting youth ambassadors and peace leaders, that understand
the concept of global peace building, are familiar with the issues of
the geographic regions they are presenting, as well as looking at the
conflict by a multi faceted lenses.
49
The CSOs and NGOs must ensure that when they are training such
youth ambassadors that special care is given to each region, where
the problems and cultures are defined and highlighted. The
solutions are not a generalized means of discussing and promoting
peace, rather are very much localized to have maximum impact.
Also, providing such trainers the ability and means to handle
difficult issues and allow them to have a to-go mentoring person
who can help in bridging gaps.
It is also essential that when talks of youth deradicalization are
taking places that the youth has an alternate means of keeping
themselves occupied in order to ensure that an empty mind does
not become a devils playground so to speak. Another important
element to implement when involving multi-stakeholder dialogue is
the ability to facilitate many cultures and points of view with ease
and seamlessness.
That is not to say that when dialogues take place that conflict will
not occur, as that would be unnatural, however the case on point is
to make the youth understand the importance of learning how to
deal with conflict in a positive and transformative manner. Another
important element to emphasize is the idea that conflict not always
negative, as those experiences can lead us to have a deeper
understanding of not only ourselves but also of the society around
us. The importance of Alternate Dispute Resolution must be
emphasized with great vehemence and a lot more resources as well
as training is required for the Indonesian government and its people
to ensure that the next generation understand the various methods
available to them for resolving a conflict scenario.
Another important point is the idea of raising consciousness of the
masses, making them understand that the only way forward for a
harmonious planet is through cohesion, sustainable development
50
and getting in touch with ones own purpose and higher self. This can
be easily achieved if the youth are guided to meditate, involve in
creative activities such as arts, community development and
healing.
One of my biggest recommendations to the Indonesian government
as well as to Search For Common Ground would be to develop their
creative programs further, where each individual is allowed to fully
express their creative selves in a manner they deem fit. During my
internship Search had held a Festival called CiptaDamai in which the
students who were formerly part of radical groups had focused their
energies on coming up with visual and graphic arts projects. This
was a great festival to experience, however, the outreach for such
students was minimal and the results for this festival were
mediocre. Similar projects focusing on many different facets of arts
need to be explored, including, music, theatre and radio. This should
be combined with making the new generation understand the
importance of Ahimsa or Non-Violence. Combining arts with spiritual
learning is the only way of the future where human beings develop
empathy for themselves as well as understanding that violence does
not lead to a peaceful ending.
Next Steps:
In the immediate future, the Indonesian government has to find a
way of countering violent extremism and radical recruitment via
social media. With such a large population of youngsters constantly
hooked on to their phones and social media sites this threat is very
much real. Indonesia has passed various laws and has a system in
place for monitoring websites, however, the advancements in
technology have not caught up with the government just yet. CSOs
and NGOs also need to have counter campaigns (as have been
done by various countries for ISIS) to let teenage and young adults
51
52
Appendix B:
53
54
55
Chilkoti, Avantika. "Indonesia on Alert over Lure of Isis - FT.com." Financial Times.
N.p., 16 June 2015. Web. 09 Nov. 2015.http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/5db8e554-2ada11e5-8613-e7aedbb7bdb7.html#axzz3p0EE0eDW
Coch, Lucas. "What Do Indonesia and Australia Expect and Get from Aid?" The
Conversation. The Conversation, 26 Feb. 2015. Web. 09 Nov. 2015.
http://theconversation.com/what-do-indonesia-and-australia-expect-and-get-fromaid-37925
Cochrane,Joe."IndonesianArmsIndustrySeekstoDrumUpBusiness."TheNewYorkTimes.The
NewYorkTimes,13Feb.2014.Web.09Nov.2015.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/14/business/international/indonesian-armsindustry-seeks-to-drum-up-business.html?_r=0
Crenshaw, M. (1998) The Logic of Terrorism: Terrorist Behavior as a Product of
Strategic Choice, in W. Reich (ed.) Origins of Terrorism: Psychologies, Ideologies,
Theologies, States of Mind, Washington: Woodrow Wilson Center Press
Dake, A. C. A. In the Spirit of the Red Banteng: Indonesian Communists between
Moscow and Peking, 1959-1965. The Hague: Mouton, 1973. Print.
Dipa, Arya. "2,500 Flee to North Sumatra after Church Burning in Aceh Singkil."
2,500 Flee to North Sumatra after Church Burning in Aceh Singkil. Jakarta Post, 14
Oct. 2015. Web. 09 Nov. 2015.
http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/10/14/2500-flee-north-sumatra-afterchurch-burning-aceh-singkil.html#sthash.RcCAvjvC.dpuf
Gershman, John. "Asia Times." Asia Times. N.p., 26 Oct. 2002. Web. 09 Nov. 2015.
http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Southeast_Asia/DJ26Ae05.html
Harrison, Graeme. "Our Views." Why Indonesia, Why Now?, New Zealand
International Business Forum. New Zealand Business Forum, 28 Sept. 2012. Web.
09 Nov. 2015.
http://www.nzibf.co.nz/index.asp?pageID=2145899173
Hoffman, Bruce. The Logic of Suicide Terrorism: Lessons from Israel that America
must learn. Atlantic Monthly, June 2003, P. 43
Hoffman, Bruce
Leonard_Weinberg_et_al__The_Challenges_of_Conceptualizing_Terrorism_
Terrorism and Political Violence Vol. 16. (2004)
Hoffman, B. (2008a) The Myth of Grass-Roots Terrorism. Why Osama bin Laden
Still Matters. Foreign Affairs, May/June 2008.
"IndonesianAuthoritiesDemolishChurchesinAcehBBCNews."BBCNews.BBC/Reuters,19Oct.
2015.Web.09Nov.2015.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-34570570
Jones,Sidney."CounteringViolentExtremisminIndonesia."CounteringViolentExtremismin
Indonesia.InstituteofPolicyAnalysisandConflict,30June2014.Web.09Nov.2015.
56
Jones, Sidney, The evolution of ISIS in Indonesia, Policy Paper, IPAC, September
2014.
Joshua Kurlantzick, Doing it Indonesias Way, Times 9th August 2007
Kell, Tim, The Roots of the Acehnese Rebellion, 1989-1992, Cornell University
1995
Kirsten E. Schulze, The Free Aceh Movement (GAM): Anatomy of a Separatist
Organization, Policy Studies No. 2 (Washington, D.C.: East-West Center, 2004);
Kuswaputra,Dandy."ImamSamudra'sSonKilledinSyria."ImamSamudra'sSonKilledinSyria.
JakartaPost,16Oct.2015.Web.09Nov.2015.
http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/10/16/imam-samudra-s-son-killedsyria.html
Levinger, Matthew: Conflict Analysis, Retrieved from Latte.Brandeis.edu
Lipman,Victor."TheWorld'sMostActiveTwitterCity."Forbes.ForbesMagazine,22Dec.2012.
Web.09Nov.2015.http://www.forbes.com/sites/victorlipman/2012/12/30/the-worldsmost-active-twitter-city-you-wont-guess-it/
Mackie, Jamie. "Australia and Indonesia." Australian Journal of International Affairs
55.1 (2001): 133-43. 2007. Web.
https://wikileaks.org/gifiles/attach/30/30737_Australia%20and%20Indonesia
%20Current%20problems,%20future%20prospects.pdf
"Military."Indonesia.GlobalSecurity,n.d.Web.09Nov.2015.
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/indonesia/industry.htm
Muryanto, Bambung. "Terrorism Suspect Arrested in Yogyakarta." Terrorism
Suspect Arrested in Yogyakarta. Jakarta Post, 26 Aug. 2015. Web. 09 Nov.
2015.http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/08/26/terrorism-suspect-arrestedyogyakarta.html
Nehra,Vikram."ANewRegionalStrategyforIndonesia'sNewPresident."CarnegieEndowmentfor
InternationalPeace.CarnegieEndowmentforPeace,24Jan.2014.Web.
http://carnegieendowment.org/2014/01/24/new-regional-strategy-for-indonesia-snext-president
Parameswaran,Prashanth."CogitASIACSISAsiaPolicyBlog."CogitASIACSISAsiaPolicyBlog.
CenterofStrategicandInternationalStudies,11Nov.2013.Web.09Nov.2015.
http://cogitasia.com/enhancing-the-india-indonesia-strategic-partnership/
Phillips,George."ISISinIndonesia:500RecruitsandCounting."GatestoneInstitute.International
PolicyCouncil,22June2015.Web.09Nov.2015.
http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/6002/isis-indonesia
Powell, Jonathan. Talking to Terrorists: How to End Armed Conflicts. N.p.: n.p., n.d.
Print.
57
58