Verify

SANSPRO VERIFICATION TEST
Verification Test of SANSPRO V.4.7

SANSPRO is a general purposes structural analysis and design program, so the
verification of its functions can not be taken from just one model file. Several
reference model files are needed to verify every aspect of SANSPRO functions.
ESRC implements a tight quality control for engineering software development
because most of the software will be used for real engineering works. Various
tests have been done, including:
1. Validation of Numerical Algorithm for Equation Solver
2. Validation of Numerical Algorithm for Eigen Solver
3. Validation of Numerical Algorithm for Response Spectrum Analysis
4. Validation of Numerical Algorithm for Direct Integration Analysis
5. Validation of Numerical Algorithm for Element Stiffness Model
6. Validation of Numerical Algorithm for Element Load Model
7. Test for Element Assembly, Restraints
8. Test for Static Condensation, Constraint, Release
9. Load Equilibrium Test (External works = Internal works)
10. Stability of Finite Element model
- Patch Test (Shape effects)
- Convergence (Mesh size variation)
- Accuracy (Selective Integration, Rotational DOF)
- Efficiency
11. Stability of Numerical Solver
- Small and Large Problem
12. Test Model
- 3D Truss (Ref: Weaver)
- 3D Frame (Ref: Weaver)
- Plane Stress QPS8 (Ref: Grandin, Cook)
- Plate Bending QPB8 (Ref: Grandin)
- Shell QUAD4 as Plane Stress (Ref: Grandin, Cook)
- Shell QUAD4 as Plate Bending (Ref: Grandin, Cook)
- Shell QUAD4 as Shell (Ref: Cook, Weaver)
- Building 3D (Ref: ETABS, STAAD3)
- Slab-Wall (Flexible Floor) System
- Raft-Pile System
- Direct Integration Analysis
SUMMARY OF VERIFICATION TEST

Test Condition
Software
Test By
Test Date
Computer
:
:
:
:
SANS V.3.5
ESRC
7 February 1994
PII-266 MHz, 64 MB RAM
1. Truss Element
Filename : TESTT1.DAT
Test Problem
: 3D Truss Structure
Source
: Matrix Analysis of Framed Structures, Weaver, 1980, Table
5-22, p.339
Description : 7 Truss elements
Purpose
: Testing Element Stiffness and Element Force Calculation
Result
: Maximum difference = 0 percent
2. Frame Element
Filename : TESTF1.DAT
Test Problem
: 3D Frame Structure
Source
: Matrix Analysis of Framed Structures, Weaver, 1980, Table
5-26, p.357
Description : 3 Frame elements
Purpose
Result
3. QPS8 Element
Filename : TESTPS1.DAT
Test Problem
: 2D Plane Stress Structure using QPS8 Element
Source
: Fundamentats of Finite Element Method, Grandin, p.299
Description : 2x1 QPS8 elements
Purpose
Result
3. QPB8 Element
Filename : TESTPB1.DAT
Test Problem
: 2D Plate Bending Structure using QPB8 Element
Source
: Matrix Analysis of Framed Structures, Weaver, 1980, p.229
Description : Plate bending, clamped edge, mesh 1x1 dan 4x4
Purpose
Result
4. QUAD4 Element
Filename : TESTQ1.DAT
Test Problem
: 2D Plane Stress Structure using QUAD4 Element
Source
: IJNMIE, Vol. 33, p.19-38, 1992
Description : 4x1 QUAD4 elements
Purpose
: Testing the Effects of Mesh Distortion of QUAD4 element
Loading at tip, displacement at tip in loading direction
Result
:
Loading
Theory
Rectangular
Trapezoidal
Parallel
Extension
0.3e-4
0.3e-4
In-plane shear
0.1081
0.0972
Out-of-plane shear
0.4321
0.4223
Twist
0.0341
0.0294
In-plane Moment
0.0090
0.0092
0.3e-4
0.3e-4
0.1073
0.1028
SANSPRO QUAD4 Maximum error

MSC/NASTRAN QUAD4 Maximum error
: 3.0 %
: 2.0%
0.4241
0.4151
0.0294
0.0294
0.0093
0.0090
5. QUAD4 Element
Test Problem
: 2D Plane Stress Structure using QUAD4 Element
Source
: IJNMIE, Vol. 33, p.19-38, 1992
Description : Cooks Tappered and Swept Panel, 2x2 and 4x4 meshes
Purpose
: Testing the Plane Stress Stiffness of QUAD4 element
Unit Load at tip, Vertical Displacement at tip
Result
:
Mesh
2x2
4x4
Theory
23.90
23.90
QUAD4
22.99
24.18
%Error
3.8%
1.2%
6. QUAD4 Element
Test Problem
: Scordelis-Lo Roof
Source
: IJNMIE, Vol. 33, p.19-38, 1992
Description : Scordelis-Lo Roof, 2x2, 4x4, 8x8 meshes
Purpose
: Testing the Bending Stiffness QUAD4 element
Unit Load at tip, Vertical Displacement at center
Result
:
Mesh
4x4
8x8
Theory
0.3024
0.3024
QUAD4
0.2224
0.3029
%Error
16.5%
0.1%
Conclusion : QUAD4 element should be used with maximum 5 degrees of

curvatures
7. QUAD4 Element
Test Problem
: Spherical Shell
Source
: IJNMIE, Vol. 33, p.19-38, 1992
Description : Spherical Shell, 9x9 and 16x16 meshes
Purpose
: Testing the Coupling of Bending and Normal Stiffness of QUAD4
element
Unit Load at tip, Vertical Displacement at center
Result
:
Mesh
9x9
16x16
Theory
QUAD4
%Error
0.3024
0.0650
0.3024
0.0091
N.C.
3.4%
Conclusion : QUAD4 element should be used with maximum 5 degrees of

curvatures
Test Condition
Software
Test By
Test Date
Computer
:
:
:
:
SANSPRO V.4.7
ESRC
7 February 2003
PII-350 MHz, 96 MB RAM
8. Rigid Floor Diaphragm

Filename : TEST-RF1.DAT
Test Problem
: 4 Storeys Building with Rigid Floor
Source
: ESRC
Description : Effects of Rigid Floor Diaphragm on Natural Period of Building
Purpose
: Testing the Static Condensation Method
Result
:
Model
Open Frame, No Rigid Floor
Rigid Floor, No Condensation
Rigid Floor, 3 Dof/Floor Condensation
Filename To (seconds)
TEST-RF1 0.59808
TEST-RF2 0.59488
TEST-RF3 0.59446
Conclusion: 3 Dof/Floor Condensation will give accurate results
9. Rigid End Zone

Filename : TEST-RZ1.DAT
Test Problem
: 4 Storeys Building with Rigid Floor and Rigid End Zone
Source
: ESRC
Description : Effects of Rigid End Zone on Natural Period of Building
Purpose
: Testing the Rigid End Zone Transformation
Result
:
a. Rigid Zone at Beam and Column Length
Description
Alpha = 0.0
Alpha = 0.5
Alpha = 1.0
To
0.59446
0.55725
0.52131
T1
0.58734
0.55094
0.51594
b. Rigid Zone at Beam Length

Description
Alpha = 0.0
Alpha = 0.5
Alpha = 1.0
To
0.59446
0.57739
0.56084
T1
0.58734
0.57147
0.55616
c. Rigid Zone at Column Length

Description
Alpha = 0.0
Alpha = 0.5
Alpha = 1.0
To
0.59446
0.57513
0.55819
T1
0.58734
0.56758
0.55017
1. Truss 3D Verification
Problem:
7 Elements Space Truss System in 3D Space
Unit: Kips, inch, rad
Data File:
TESTT1.DAT
Source:
Matrix Structural Analysis, William Weaver, 1980, Table 5-22, P.339
Tested By:
ESRC, 1989
Test Results:
Test Item
3D Truss Element Stiffness
Axis Transformation for 3D Truss Element
Assembly for 3D Truss Element
Linear Equation Solver
Support Reactions Calculation
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Data File: TESTT1.DAT

*SANS*
SpaceTruss, Weaver, 1980, Table 5-22, p.339
kips, inches,rads
*MODEL*
5,1,1,1,1
*JOINT*
5
Joint X
Y
Z
1
120
0.0
0.0
2
0.0
240
240
3
240
240
240
4
240
240
0.0
5
0.0
240
0.0
*RESTRAINT*
3
0 0 0 1 1 1
1 1 1
1 1 1 0 0 0
4 5 1
1 1 1 0 0 0
*MATERIAL*
1 ISO 0 0 3e4 0 0
*SECTION*
1 SOLID 10
*ELSET*
1 1 1 0
*TRUSS*
7
Member JJ
JK Set
1
1
2
1
2
1
3
1
3
2
3
1
4
2
5
1
5
3
4
1
6
2
4
1
7
3
5
1
*COMB*
1 0 1
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
2
Joint Dir
Load
2
2
-20.0
3
3
-20.0
*TLOAD*
2 3
Set Type Load - Parameters
1
5
-0.0833333333 0.0 1.0
2
1
20
0.5
3
3
20
0.5
Member Set
4 4 1 2,3
5 5 1 1
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
SANSPRO - Output File - (C) Nathan Madutujuh, 1988-2003
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>
: Ir. Nathan Madutujuh, M.Sc, Bandung

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testt1.DAT
: SpaceTruss, Weaver, 1980, Table 5-22, p.339
: kips, inches,rads
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
5
:
1
:
6
:
21
: Space truss (xyz-space), Linear Elastic
: Static Analysis
Loading Combination : 1
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
Delta-Y
Delta-Z
1
0
0
0
2
1.477237E-02 -5.638278E-02 9.768969E-03
3
1.654134E-02 -2.503964E-02 -1.023103E-02
4
0
0
0
5
0
0
0
Truss Element Forces
Member
Axial-1
Span-2
M-Span-3
1
3.000000E+01
0
2
1.500000E+01
0
3
-2.211212E+00
0
4
-2.221121E+01
1.200000E+03
0
5
1.278878E+01
6.000000E+02
6
3.127125E+00
0
7
-3.943943E+00
0
Shear-2
Shear-3
Theta-X
0
0
0
0
0
Theta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
Shear-2
Shear-3
-3.000000E+01
-1.500000E+01
2.211212E+00
-1.000000E+01
2.211212E+00
-1.000000E+01
1.000000E+01
Axial-1
Theta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
-1.278878E+01
-3.127125E+00
3.943943E+00
1.000000E+01
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1 -5.000000E+00 3.000000E+01 3.000000E+01
0
0
0
4 -2.211212E+00 1.000000E+01 1.500000E+01
0
0
0
5 -1.278878E+01
0
-5.000000E+00
0
0
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM = -2.000000E+01 4.000000E+01 4.000000E+01
0
0
0
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
<<<<
End of SANSPRO for Windows Output File
>>>>
M-
2. Frame 3D Verification
Problem:
3 Elements Space Frame System in 3D Space
Unit: Kips, inch, rad
Data File:
TESTF1.DAT
Source:
Matrix Structural Analysis, William Weaver, 1980, Table 5-26, P.357
Tested By:
ESRC, 1989
Test Results:
Test Item
3D Frame Element Stiffness
Axis Transformation for 3D Frame Element
Assembly for 3D Frame Element
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Data File: TESTF1.DAT

*SANS*
Space Frame, Weaver, 1980, Table 5-26, p.357
kips,inches,rads
*MODEL*
6,1,1,1,1
*JOINT*
4
Joint X
Y
Z
1
0
3
0
2
6
3
0
3
0
0
0
4
9
0
3
*RESTRAINT*
2
0 0 0 0 0 0
3 4 1
1 1 1 1 1 1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISO 0 0 2e+8 8e+7 0 0
*SECTION*
1 GENERAL 0.01 0.01 0.001 0.001 0.002
*ELSET*
1 1 1 0
*FRAME*
3
Member JJ
JK
Set
Alpha
1
1
2
1
0
2
3
1
1
0
3
2
4
1
0
*COMB*
1 0 1
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
3
Joint Dir
Load
1
1
120
2
2
-60
2
6
-180
*FLOAD*
1 1
Set Type Parameter
1
3
240 0.5
Member Set
1 1 1
1
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testf1.DAT
: Space Frame, Weaver, 1980, Table 5-26, p.357
: kips,inches,rads
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
4
:
1
:
12
:
78
: Space frame (xyz-space), Linear Elastic
: Static Analysis
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
1 -8.594097E-04
2 -1.176053E-03
3
0
4
0
Delta-Y
5.776353E-05
3.253162E-03
0
0
Delta-Z
5.007645E-03
5.255517E-03
0
0
Theta-X
Theta-Y
Theta-Z
2.393332E-03 -1.623169E-03 6.813313E-04
1.288427E-03 1.720936E-03 -7.714689E-04
0
0
0
0
0
0
Frame Element Forces

Member
Axial-1
Shear-2
Shear-3
Torsion
Moment-2
Span-2
Axial-1
Shear-2
Shear-3
Torsion
Moment-2
Span-3
1
1.055478E+02 -3.850902E+01 -1.260130E+02 2.946411E+01 8.656899E+01
2.914701E+02
-1.055478E+02 3.850902E+01 -1.139869E+02 -2.946411E+01 -5.049072E+01
-4.842667E+01
2
-3.850902E+01 1.445219E+01 -1.260130E+02 8.656899E+01 3.485750E+02
-1.595555E+02
3.850902E+01 -1.445219E+01 1.260130E+02 -8.656899E+01 2.946411E+01
4.542209E+01
3
1.836227E+02 9.192413E+00 5.967380E+00 -2.140403E+01 4.670331E+01
-6.220702E+01
-1.836227E+02 -9.192413E+00 -5.967380E+00 2.140403E+01 -7.771073E+01
5.606329E+01
Moment-3
M-
Moment-3
M-
-6.710038E+01
-1.639537E+02
-2.374379E+01
6.710038E+01
-3.218070E+01
7.994588E+01
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
3 -1.445219E+01 -3.850902E+01 -1.260130E+02 -3.485750E+02 8.656899E+01 -2.374379E+01
4 -1.055478E+02 9.850902E+01 -1.139869E+02 -7.589792E+01 -7.580817E+01 3.716262E+01
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM = -1.200000E+02 6.000000E+01 -2.400000E+02 -4.244729E+02 1.076082E+01 1.341883E+01
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
<<<<
>>>>
3. QPS8 Verification
Problem:
QPS8 element, Straight Cantilever, 2x1 and 4x2 elements
Data File:
TESTPS1.DAT, TESTPS2.DAT
Source:
Fundamentals of Finite Element Method, Grandin, p.299
Tested By:
ESRC
Test Results:
Test Item
QPS8 Element Stiffness
Element Stability and Patch Test
Assembly for QPS8 Element
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Data File: TESTPS1.DAT

*SANS*
Test for QPS8 element, Grandin p.299
lbs,in
*MODEL*
7,1,1,1,1
*JOINT*
15
Joint
X
Y
Z
Generate
1
0
0
0
3
0
1
0
1,3,1
4
0.5 0
0
5
0.5 1
0
6
1
0
0
8
1
1
0
6,8,1
9
1.5 0
0
10
1.5 1
0
11
2
0
0
13
2
1
0
11,13,1
14
0.5 0.5 0
15
1.5 0.5 0
*RESTRAINT*
3
0,0,1,1,1,1
1,3,1
1,1,1,1,1,1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISO 0 0 1e7 0 0.3
*SECTION*
1 FLAT 0.1
*ELSET*
1 1
1
0
*QPS8*
2
Elmnt j1,j2,j3,j4,j5,j6,j7,j8,j9 Set
1
1, 4, 6, 2,14, 7, 3, 5, 8
1
2
6, 9,11, 7,15,12, 8,10,13
1
*COMB*
1 0 1
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
1
Joint
Force
13
0,-100,0
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testps1.DAT
: Test for QPS8 element, Grandin p.299
: lbs,in
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
15
:
1
:
20
:
170
: Plane stress (xy-plane), Linear Elastic
: Static Analysis
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
1
0
2
0
3
0
4 -4.850743E-04
5
4.802308E-04
6 -8.585803E-04
7
3.244782E-06
8
8.497583E-04
9 -1.060369E-03
10
1.110365E-03
11 -1.102589E-03
12 -1.719120E-05
13
1.260468E-03
14
0
15
0
Delta-Y
0
0
0
-3.991147E-04
-4.011375E-04
-1.224454E-03
-1.168721E-03
-1.230219E-03
-2.336412E-03
-2.322550E-03
-3.428866E-03
-3.563321E-03
-3.761743E-03
0
0
Delta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Theta-X
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Theta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Theta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
QPS8 Element Nodal Stresses (Plane Stress)

Extrapolation of stresses calculated at Gauss points
Element Node
Sxx
Syy
Sxy
1
1 -1.188699E+04 -3.566099E+03 -1.430786E+03
4 -9.055142E+03 -1.564461E+03 -9.378362E+02
6 -6.228955E+03 4.182803E+02 -1.299777E+03
2 2.615366E+01 7.846097E+00 -1.209816E+03
14 2.898814E+01 -1.153226E+01 -7.823701E+02
7 2.615366E+01 -4.980722E+01 -1.209816E+03
3 1.177104E+04 3.531314E+03 -1.439733E+03
5 8.944858E+03 1.490919E+03 -1.077792E+03
8 6.113002E+03 -5.683728E+02 -1.570743E+03
2
6
9
11
7
15
12
8
10
13
-5.434512E+03
-2.038357E+03
1.499896E+02
-7.827733E+02
-1.788694E+02
-7.827733E+02
6.149990E+03
3.961643E+03
5.654881E+02
6.566131E+02
1.339101E+03
-2.004437E+03
-2.924853E+02
8.496786E+01
-3.563605E+03
-5.572764E+02
-4.848578E+02
-4.438465E+03
-1.940227E+03
-8.101035E+02
-7.187262E+02
-1.380392E+03
-8.610193E+02
-1.380392E+03
-6.156959E+02
-7.070732E+02
-1.837197E+03
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1
1.987691E+02 9.055537E+01
0
0
0
0
2
2.461726E+00 -8.209476E+01
0
0
0
0
3 -2.012309E+02 9.153939E+01
0
0
0
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM = -8.242296E-13 1.000000E+02
0
0
0
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
>>>>
4. QPB8 Verification
Problem:
QPB8 element, 1x1, 4x4 meshes
Data File:
TESTPB1.DAT, TESTPB2.DAT
Source:
Matrix Analysis of Framed Structures, Weaver, 1980, p.229
Plate bending, clamped edge, mesh 1x1 and 4x4
Weaver
Tested By:
ESRC
Test Results:
Test Item
QPB8 Element Stiffness
Assembly for QPB Element
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Data File: TESTPB1.DAT

*SANS*
QPB8 test problem : cantilever, 1x1 plate element, weaver p.227
kips,in.
*MODEL*
0,1,1,1,1 : model as general frame
*JOINT*
9
Joint
X
Y
Z
Generate
1
10
0
0
2
10
5
0
3
10 10
0
4
5
0
0
5
5 10
0
6
0
0
0
7
0
5
0
8
0 10
0
9
5
5
0
*RESTRAINT*
7
1,1,0,0,0,1 : plate on xy
6,8,1
1,1,1,1,1,1 : fixed cantilever
1
1,1,0,0,0,1 : no moment in x direction
3
1,1,0,0,0,1
4
1,1,0,0,0,1
5
1,1,0,0,0,1
*MATERIAL*
1 SPRING
0 0 0.0001 0 0
: soil stiffness
2 ISOTROPIC 0 0 1.0e4 3846.153846 0.3 : concrete plate
*SECTION*
1 FLAT 0.2
*ELSET*
1 2 1 0
*QPB8*
1
Elmnt j1,j2,j3,j4,j5,j6,j7,j8,j9 set Generate
1
6, 4, 1, 7, 9, 2, 8, 5, 3
1
*QPB8SP*
1,1,1 1 : elastic support for QPB8
*COMB*
1 0 1
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
3
Joint
Force
1
0,0,0.01,0,0,0
2
0,0,0.04,0,0,0
3
0,0,0.01,0,0,0
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testpb1.DAT
: QPB8 test problem : cantilever, 1x1 plate element, weaver p.227
: kips,in.
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
9
:
1
:
15
:
120
: General frame (xyz-space), Linear Elastic
: Static Analysis
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
1
0
2
0
3
0
4
0
5
0
6
0
7
0
8
0
9
0
Delta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Delta-Z
Theta-X
Theta-Y
2.687623E-01 6.508905E-03 -4.432909E-02
2.850944E-01 1.217775E-15 -4.220383E-02
2.687623E-01 -6.508905E-03 -4.432909E-02
8.074084E-02 3.278395E-03 -3.191388E-02
8.074084E-02 -3.278395E-03 -3.191388E-02
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
QPB8 Element Nodal Stresses

Element Node
Moment-Mxx
Moment-Myy
Moment-Mxy
1
6 -6.104499E-02 -1.831350E-02 -1.693507E-03
4 -3.103447E-02 -4.939147E-03 -5.790733E-04
1 -1.044993E-03 8.365042E-03 5.353599E-04
7 -5.948803E-02 -1.784641E-02 3.626588E-16
9 -2.947750E-02 -4.472057E-03 -2.157284E-16
2 5.119727E-04 8.832132E-03 -2.324045E-15
8 -6.104499E-02 -1.831350E-02 1.693507E-03
5 -3.103447E-02 -4.939147E-03 5.790733E-04
3 -1.044993E-03 8.365042E-03 -5.353599E-04
Theta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shear-Qy
Shear-Qx
-1.219366E-15 3.474427E+00
-7.673927E-03 -3.229260E+00
1.534785E-02 2.566197E+00
2.355644E-16 4.521358E+00
-1.889014E-13 -1.501156E+00
-3.852200E-13 4.975473E+00
5.790976E-15 3.474427E+00
7.673927E-03 -3.229260E+00
-1.534785E-02 2.566197E+00
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
4
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
0
0
0
0
0
0
6
0
0
7.053170E-03 -3.761552E-03 1.038604E-01
0
7
0
0
-7.410634E-02 -1.816602E-14 3.922790E-01
0
8
0
0
7.053170E-03 3.761552E-03 1.038604E-01
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM =
0
0
-6.000000E-02 -4.324666E-14 6.000000E-01
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
>>>>
Data File: TESTPB2.DAT

*SANS*
QPB8 test problem : 4x4 plate element mesh, Weaver, p.229, clamped edge
kips,in.
*MODEL*
9,1,1,1,1
*JOINT*
81
Joint
X
Y
Z
Generate
1
0
0
0
9
8
0
0
73
0
8
0
81
8
8
0
Q
1,9,73,81,1,9
*RESTRAINT*
32
1,1,0,0,0,1
1,9,1
1,1,1,1,1,1
18,81,9 1,1,1,1,1,1
10,64,9 1,1,1,1,1,1
73,80,1 1,1,1,1,1,1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISO 0 0 3e4 0 0.3
*SECTION*
1 FLAT 0.25
*ELSET*
1 1 1 0
*QPB8*
16
Elmnt j1,j2,j3,j4,j5,j6,j7,j8,j9 set Generate
1
1, 2, 3,10,11,12,19,20,21
1
3,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2
5
19,20,21,28,29,30,37,38,39
1
3,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2
9
37,38,39,46,47,48,55,56,57
1
3,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2
13
55,56,57,64,65,66,73,74,75
1
3,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2
*COMB*
1 0 1
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
1
Joint
Force
41
0,0,1.0,0,0,0
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testpb2.DAT
: QPB8 test problem : 4x4 plate element mesh, Weaver, p.229, clamped edge
: kips,in.
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
81
:
1
:
99
:
2502
: Plate bending (xz-plane), Linear Elastic
: Static Analysis
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
1
0
2
0
3
0
4
0
5
0
6
0
7
0
8
0
9
0
10
0
11
0
12
0
13
0
14
0
15
0
16
0
17
0
18
0
19
0
20
0
21
0
22
0
23
0
24
0
25
0
26
0
27
0
28
0
29
0
30
0
31
0
32
0
33
0
34
0
35
0
36
0
37
0
38
0
39
0
40
0
41
0
42
0
43
0
44
0
45
0
46
0
47
0
48
0
49
0
50
0
51
0
52
0
53
0
54
0
55
0
Delta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Delta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5.433739E-04
0
1.070019E-03
0
5.433739E-04
0
0
0
5.433739E-04
1.753318E-03
2.924525E-03
3.405275E-03
2.924525E-03
1.753318E-03
5.433739E-04
0
0
0
2.924525E-03
0
6.268018E-03
0
2.924525E-03
0
0
0
1.070019E-03
3.405275E-03
6.268018E-03
7.915372E-03
6.268018E-03
3.405275E-03
1.070019E-03
0
0
0
2.924525E-03
0
6.268018E-03
0
2.924525E-03
0
0
0
Theta-X
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
9.271791E-04
0
1.992263E-03
0
9.271791E-04
0
0
0
4.787473E-04
1.373202E-03
2.102879E-03
2.303558E-03
2.102879E-03
1.373202E-03
4.787473E-04
0
0
0
8.618012E-04
0
2.705092E-03
0
8.618012E-04
0
0
0
-6.776264E-19
-4.851805E-18
9.757820E-18
1.611451E-17
1.474515E-17
7.560616E-18
5.637851E-18
0
0
0
-8.618012E-04
0
-2.705092E-03
0
-8.618012E-04
0
0
0
Theta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-4.787473E-04
0
-6.234162E-19
0
4.787473E-04
0
0
0
-9.271791E-04
-1.373202E-03
-8.618012E-04
-1.734723E-18
8.618012E-04
1.373202E-03
9.271791E-04
0
0
0
-2.102879E-03
0
-9.053088E-18
0
2.102879E-03
0
0
0
-1.992263E-03
-2.303558E-03
-2.705092E-03
-1.387779E-17
2.705092E-03
2.303558E-03
1.992263E-03
0
0
0
-2.102879E-03
0
-1.528725E-17
0
2.102879E-03
0
0
0
Theta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5.433739E-04
1.753318E-03
2.924525E-03
3.405275E-03
2.924525E-03
1.753318E-03
5.433739E-04
0
0
0
5.433739E-04
0
1.070019E-03
0
5.433739E-04
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-4.787473E-04
-1.373202E-03
-2.102879E-03
-2.303558E-03
-2.102879E-03
-1.373202E-03
-4.787473E-04
0
0
0
-9.271791E-04
0
-1.992263E-03
0
-9.271791E-04
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
QPB8 Element Nodal Stresses

Element Node
Moment-Mxx
Moment-Myy
Moment-Mxy
1
1 1.734723E-18
0
0
2 -6.180694E-03 -2.060231E-02 -3.842182E-03
3 -1.503807E-02 -5.012693E-02 -4.069914E-03
10 -2.060231E-02 -6.180694E-03 -3.842182E-03
11 -1.335790E-02 -1.335790E-02 -1.392997E-02
12 -8.790189E-03 -2.945742E-02 -2.040332E-02
19 -5.012693E-02 -1.503807E-02 -4.069914E-03
20 -2.945742E-02 -8.790189E-03 -2.040332E-02
21 -1.146459E-02 -1.146459E-02 -3.312227E-02
-9.271791E-04
-1.373202E-03
-8.618012E-04
-1.040834E-17
8.618012E-04
1.373202E-03
9.271791E-04
0
0
0
-4.787473E-04
0
-3.767603E-18
0
4.787473E-04
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shear-Qy
-1.804112E-16
-1.480731E-01
5.050206E-01
-2.775558E-17
-2.114799E-01
-1.214419E-01
1.526557E-16
3.034253E-01
4.087197E-01
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shear-Qx
-3.191891E-16
-2.775558E-17
5.551115E-17
-1.480731E-01
-2.114799E-01
3.034253E-01
5.050206E-01
-1.214419E-01
4.087197E-01
3
4
5
12
13
14
21
22
23
-1.503807E-02
-2.746181E-02
-3.647939E-02
-6.087168E-03
-3.264858E-03
2.963597E-03
1.178604E-02
2.985439E-02
5.132888E-02
-5.012693E-02
-9.153935E-02
-1.215979E-01
-2.864651E-02
-4.205131E-02
-4.410229E-02
-4.489407E-03
1.011343E-02
3.607008E-02
-4.069914E-03 5.050206E-01 1.471045E-15

-3.351062E-03 1.193170E+00
0
-4.336809E-18 1.051444E+00 -1.804112E-16
-2.229029E-02 -1.214419E-01 3.120267E-01
-1.447479E-02 -3.117974E-01 -1.530071E-01
-4.027092E-03 -6.962136E-01 -1.968871E-01
-3.149765E-02 4.087197E-01 3.443064E-01
-1.658552E-02 7.819409E-01 -8.611232E-02
9.588230E-04 1.596915E+00 3.257764E-01
5
6
7
14
15
16
23
24
25
-3.647939E-02
-2.746181E-02
-1.503807E-02
2.963597E-03
-3.264858E-03
-6.087168E-03
5.132888E-02
2.985439E-02
1.178604E-02
-1.215979E-01 -6.071532E-18 1.051444E+00 -4.163336E-16

-9.153935E-02 3.351062E-03 1.193170E+00 8.326673E-17
-5.012693E-02 4.069914E-03 5.050206E-01 1.387779E-16
-4.410229E-02 4.027092E-03 -6.962136E-01 1.968871E-01
-4.205131E-02 1.447479E-02 -3.117974E-01 1.530071E-01
-2.864651E-02 2.229029E-02 -1.214419E-01 -3.120267E-01
3.607008E-02 -9.588230E-04 1.596915E+00 -3.257764E-01
1.011343E-02 1.658552E-02 7.819409E-01 8.611232E-02
-4.489407E-03 3.149765E-02 4.087197E-01 -3.443064E-01
7
8
9
16
17
18
25
26
27
-1.503807E-02
-6.180694E-03
-8.673617E-19
-8.790189E-03
-1.335790E-02
-2.060231E-02
-1.146459E-02
-2.945742E-02
-5.012693E-02
-5.012693E-02 4.069914E-03 5.050206E-01 -2.359224E-16

-2.060231E-02 3.842182E-03 -1.480731E-01 2.775558E-17
8.673617E-19 -1.734723E-18 1.387779E-17 -8.326673E-17
-2.945742E-02 2.040332E-02 -1.214419E-01 -3.034253E-01
-1.335790E-02 1.392997E-02 -2.114799E-01 2.114799E-01
-6.180694E-03 3.842182E-03 -2.220446E-16 1.480731E-01
-1.146459E-02 3.312227E-02 4.087197E-01 -4.087197E-01
-8.790189E-03 2.040332E-02 3.034253E-01 1.214419E-01
-1.503807E-02 4.069914E-03 7.910339E-16 -5.050206E-01
19
20
21
28
29
30
37
38
-5.012693E-02
-2.864651E-02
-4.489407E-03
-9.153935E-02
-4.205131E-02
1.011343E-02
-1.215979E-01
-4.410229E-02
-1.503807E-02
-6.087168E-03
1.178604E-02
-2.746181E-02
-3.264858E-03
2.985439E-02
-3.647939E-02
2.963597E-03
-4.069914E-03
-2.229029E-02
-3.149765E-02
-3.351062E-03
-1.447479E-02
-1.658552E-02
-1.821460E-17
-4.027092E-03
-2.359224E-16 5.050206E-01
3.120267E-01 -1.214419E-01
3.443064E-01 4.087197E-01
-1.387779E-16 1.193170E+00
-1.530071E-01 -3.117974E-01
-8.611232E-02 7.819409E-01
3.608225E-16 1.051444E+00
-1.968871E-01 -6.962136E-01
39
3.607008E-02
5.132888E-02
9.588230E-04
3.257764E-01
1.596915E+00
21 1.876123E-02 1.876123E-02 -2.987304E-02 3.443064E-01 3.443064E-01

22 2.075374E-02 -2.022207E-02 -2.480952E-02 1.254303E+00 -8.611232E-02
23 1.934010E-02 -7.055919E-02 9.588230E-04 2.804998E+00 3.257764E-01
30 -2.022207E-02 2.075374E-02 -2.480952E-02 -8.611232E-02 1.254303E+00
31 5.867407E-02 5.867407E-02 -2.769367E-02 -5.864163E-01 -5.864163E-01
32 1.341641E-01 8.524059E-02 -9.873001E-03 -1.081836E+00 1.727944E+00
39 -7.055919E-02 1.934010E-02 9.588230E-04 3.257764E-01 2.804998E+00
40 8.524059E-02 1.341641E-01 -9.873001E-03 1.727944E+00 -1.081836E+00
41 2.376342E-01 2.376342E-01 -8.673617E-17 2.499182E+00 2.499182E+00
23 1.934010E-02 -7.055919E-02 -9.588230E-04 2.804998E+00 -3.257764E-01

24 2.075374E-02 -2.022207E-02 2.480952E-02 1.254303E+00 8.611232E-02
25 1.876123E-02 1.876123E-02 2.987304E-02 3.443064E-01 -3.443064E-01
32 1.341641E-01 8.524059E-02 9.873001E-03 -1.081836E+00 -1.727944E+00
33 5.867407E-02 5.867407E-02 2.769367E-02 -5.864163E-01 5.864163E-01
34 -2.022207E-02 2.075374E-02 2.480952E-02 -8.611232E-02 -1.254303E+00
41 2.376342E-01 2.376342E-01 -7.979728E-17 2.499182E+00 -2.499182E+00
42 8.524059E-02 1.341641E-01 9.873001E-03 1.727944E+00 1.081836E+00
43 -7.055919E-02 1.934010E-02 -9.588230E-04 3.257764E-01 -2.804998E+00
25
26
27
34
35
36
43
44
45
-4.489407E-03
-2.864651E-02
-5.012693E-02
1.011343E-02
-4.205131E-02
-9.153935E-02
3.607008E-02
-4.410229E-02
-1.215979E-01
1.178604E-02 3.149765E-02 3.443064E-01 -4.087197E-01

-6.087168E-03 2.229029E-02 3.120267E-01 1.214419E-01
-1.503807E-02 4.069914E-03 5.551115E-17 -5.050206E-01
2.985439E-02 1.658552E-02 -8.611232E-02 -7.819409E-01
-3.264858E-03 1.447479E-02 -1.530071E-01 3.117974E-01
-2.746181E-02 3.351062E-03 1.387779E-17 -1.193170E+00
5.132888E-02 -9.588230E-04 3.257764E-01 -1.596915E+00
2.963597E-03 4.027092E-03 -1.968871E-01 6.962136E-01
-3.647939E-02 1.127570E-16 1.609823E-15 -1.051444E+00
37
38
39
46
47
48
55
56
57
-1.215979E-01
-4.410229E-02
3.607008E-02
-9.153935E-02
-4.205131E-02
1.011343E-02
-5.012693E-02
-2.864651E-02
-4.489407E-03
-3.647939E-02 -8.673617E-18 5.828671E-16 1.051444E+00

2.963597E-03 4.027092E-03 1.968871E-01 -6.962136E-01
5.132888E-02 -9.588230E-04 -3.257764E-01 1.596915E+00
-2.746181E-02 3.351062E-03 1.804112E-16 1.193170E+00
-3.264858E-03 1.447479E-02 1.530071E-01 -3.117974E-01
2.985439E-02 1.658552E-02 8.611232E-02 7.819409E-01
-1.503807E-02 4.069914E-03 -4.163336E-16 5.050206E-01
-6.087168E-03 2.229029E-02 -3.120267E-01 -1.214419E-01
1.178604E-02 3.149765E-02 -3.443064E-01 4.087197E-01
10
39 -7.055919E-02 1.934010E-02 -9.588230E-04

40 8.524059E-02 1.341641E-01 9.873001E-03
41 2.376342E-01 2.376342E-01 -1.040834E-16
48 -2.022207E-02 2.075374E-02 2.480952E-02
49 5.867407E-02 5.867407E-02 2.769367E-02
50 1.341641E-01 8.524059E-02 9.873001E-03
57 1.876123E-02 1.876123E-02 2.987304E-02
58 2.075374E-02 -2.022207E-02 2.480952E-02
59 1.934010E-02 -7.055919E-02 -9.588230E-04
-3.257764E-01 2.804998E+00
-1.727944E+00 -1.081836E+00
-2.499182E+00 2.499182E+00
8.611232E-02 1.254303E+00
5.864163E-01 -5.864163E-01
1.081836E+00 1.727944E+00
-3.443064E-01 3.443064E-01
-1.254303E+00 -8.611232E-02
-2.804998E+00 3.257764E-01
11
41 2.376342E-01 2.376342E-01 -9.194034E-17 -2.499182E+00

42 8.524059E-02 1.341641E-01 -9.873001E-03 -1.727944E+00
43 -7.055919E-02 1.934010E-02 9.588230E-04 -3.257764E-01
50 1.341641E-01 8.524059E-02 -9.873001E-03 1.081836E+00
51 5.867407E-02 5.867407E-02 -2.769367E-02 5.864163E-01
52 -2.022207E-02 2.075374E-02 -2.480952E-02 8.611232E-02
59 1.934010E-02 -7.055919E-02 9.588230E-04 -2.804998E+00
60 2.075374E-02 -2.022207E-02 -2.480952E-02 -1.254303E+00
61 1.876123E-02 1.876123E-02 -2.987304E-02 -3.443064E-01
-2.499182E+00
1.081836E+00
-2.804998E+00
-1.727944E+00
5.864163E-01
-1.254303E+00
-3.257764E-01
8.611232E-02
-3.443064E-01
12
43
44
45
52
53
54
61
62
63
3.607008E-02
-4.410229E-02
-1.215979E-01
1.011343E-02
-4.205131E-02
-9.153935E-02
-4.489407E-03
-2.864651E-02
-5.012693E-02
5.132888E-02
2.963597E-03
-3.647939E-02
2.985439E-02
-3.264858E-03
-2.746181E-02
1.178604E-02
-6.087168E-03
-1.503807E-02
9.588230E-04
-4.027092E-03
1.066854E-16
-1.658552E-02
-1.447479E-02
-3.351062E-03
-3.149765E-02
-2.229029E-02
-4.069914E-03
-3.257764E-01
1.968871E-01
1.304512E-15
8.611232E-02
1.530071E-01
-4.163336E-17
-3.443064E-01
-3.120267E-01
8.604228E-16
-1.596915E+00
6.962136E-01
-1.051444E+00
-7.819409E-01
3.117974E-01
-1.193170E+00
-4.087197E-01
1.214419E-01
-5.050206E-01
13
55
56
57
64
65
66
73
-5.012693E-02
-2.945742E-02
-1.146459E-02
-2.060231E-02
-1.335790E-02
-8.790189E-03
-1.734723E-18
-1.503807E-02 4.069914E-03
-8.790189E-03 2.040332E-02
-1.146459E-02 3.312227E-02
-6.180694E-03 3.842182E-03
-1.335790E-02 1.392997E-02
-2.945742E-02 2.040332E-02
-8.673617E-19 -1.734723E-18
-6.938894E-17
-3.034253E-01
-4.087197E-01
-1.387779E-16
2.114799E-01
1.214419E-01
5.551115E-17
5.050206E-01
-1.214419E-01
4.087197E-01
-1.480731E-01
-2.114799E-01
3.034253E-01
-2.775558E-17
74 -6.180694E-03 -2.060231E-02
75 -1.503807E-02 -5.012693E-02
3.842182E-03 1.480731E-01
4.069914E-03 -5.050206E-01
0
2.636780E-16
14
57
58
59
66
67
68
75
76
77
1.178604E-02
2.985439E-02
5.132888E-02
-6.087168E-03
-3.264858E-03
2.963597E-03
-1.503807E-02
-2.746181E-02
-3.647939E-02
-4.489407E-03 3.149765E-02 -4.087197E-01 3.443064E-01

1.011343E-02 1.658552E-02 -7.819409E-01 -8.611232E-02
3.607008E-02 -9.588230E-04 -1.596915E+00 3.257764E-01
-2.864651E-02 2.229029E-02 1.214419E-01 3.120267E-01
-4.205131E-02 1.447479E-02 3.117974E-01 -1.530071E-01
-4.410229E-02 4.027092E-03 6.962136E-01 -1.968871E-01
-5.012693E-02 4.069914E-03 -5.050206E-01 6.800116E-16
-9.153935E-02 3.351062E-03 -1.193170E+00
0
-1.215979E-01 3.903128E-17 -1.051444E+00 -3.469447E-16
15
59
60
61
68
69
70
77
78
79
5.132888E-02
2.985439E-02
1.178604E-02
2.963597E-03
-3.264858E-03
-6.087168E-03
-3.647939E-02
-2.746181E-02
-1.503807E-02
3.607008E-02
1.011343E-02
-4.489407E-03
-4.410229E-02
-4.205131E-02
-2.864651E-02
-1.215979E-01
-9.153935E-02
-5.012693E-02
9.588230E-04
-1.658552E-02
-3.149765E-02
-4.027092E-03
-1.447479E-02
-2.229029E-02
3.556183E-17
-3.351062E-03
-4.069914E-03
-1.596915E+00 -3.257764E-01
-7.819409E-01 8.611232E-02
-4.087197E-01 -3.443064E-01
6.962136E-01 1.968871E-01
3.117974E-01 1.530071E-01
1.214419E-01 -3.120267E-01
-1.051444E+00 2.053913E-15
-1.193170E+00 4.163336E-17
-5.050206E-01 4.302114E-16
16
61
62
63
70
71
72
79
80
81
-1.146459E-02
-2.945742E-02
-5.012693E-02
-8.790189E-03
-1.335790E-02
-2.060231E-02
-1.503807E-02
-6.180694E-03
0
-1.146459E-02
-8.790189E-03
-1.503807E-02
-2.945742E-02
-1.335790E-02
-6.180694E-03
-5.012693E-02
-2.060231E-02
-8.673617E-19
-3.312227E-02
-2.040332E-02
-4.069914E-03
-2.040332E-02
-1.392997E-02
-3.842182E-03
-4.069914E-03
-3.842182E-03
0
-4.087197E-01
-3.034253E-01
-1.526557E-16
1.214419E-01
2.114799E-01
2.775558E-17
-5.050206E-01
1.480731E-01
6.938894E-17
-4.087197E-01
1.214419E-01
-5.050206E-01
-3.034253E-01
2.114799E-01
1.480731E-01
-9.714451E-17
0
1.665335E-16
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1
0
0
2.676699E-01 1.097806E-03 -1.097806E-03
0
2
0
0
-1.142105E-01 1.219174E-01 -8.692614E-02
0
3
0
0
-6.989165E-02 -7.162760E-02 7.661286E-02
0
4
0
0
1.075482E-01 -2.078608E-01 -5.592511E-02
0
5
0
0
-3.645621E-01 -3.343095E-02 -1.734723E-16
0
6
0
0
1.075482E-01 -2.078608E-01 5.592511E-02
0
7
0
0
-6.989165E-02 -7.162760E-02 -7.661286E-02
0
8
0
0
-1.142105E-01 1.219174E-01 8.692614E-02
0
9
0
0
2.676699E-01 1.097806E-03 1.097806E-03
0
10
0
0
-1.142105E-01 8.692614E-02 -1.219174E-01
0
18
0
0
-1.142105E-01 8.692614E-02 1.219174E-01
0
19
0
0
-6.989165E-02 -7.661286E-02 7.162760E-02
0
27
0
0
-6.989165E-02 -7.661286E-02 -7.162760E-02
0
28
0
0
1.075482E-01 5.592511E-02 2.078608E-01
0
36
0
0
1.075482E-01 5.592511E-02 -2.078608E-01
0
37
0
0
-3.645621E-01 9.853229E-16 3.343095E-02
0
45
0
0
-3.645621E-01 1.665335E-16 -3.343095E-02
0
46
0
0
1.075482E-01 -5.592511E-02 2.078608E-01
0
54
0
0
1.075482E-01 -5.592511E-02 -2.078608E-01
0
55
0
0
-6.989165E-02 7.661286E-02 7.162760E-02
0
63
0
0
-6.989165E-02 7.661286E-02 -7.162760E-02
0
64
0
0
-1.142105E-01 -8.692614E-02 -1.219174E-01
0
72
0
0
-1.142105E-01 -8.692614E-02 1.219174E-01
0
73
0
0
2.676699E-01 -1.097806E-03 -1.097806E-03
0
74
0
0
-1.142105E-01 -1.219174E-01 -8.692614E-02
0
75
0
0
-6.989165E-02 7.162760E-02 7.661286E-02
0
76
0
0
1.075482E-01 2.078608E-01 -5.592511E-02
0
77
0
0
-3.645621E-01 3.343095E-02 6.349088E-16
0
78
0
0
1.075482E-01 2.078608E-01 5.592511E-02
0
79
0
0
-6.989165E-02 7.162760E-02 -7.661286E-02
0
80
0
0
-1.142105E-01 -1.219174E-01 8.692614E-02
0
81
0
0
2.676699E-01 -1.097806E-03 1.097806E-03
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM =
0
0
-1.000000E+00 8.234949E-15 -3.594347E-15
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
>>>>
5. QUAD4 Verification
Problem:
QUAD4 Straight Cantilever, Rectangular/Trapezoidal/Parallel shape
Data File:
TESTQ1a.DAT, TESTQ1b.DAT, TESTQ1c.DAT
Source:
IJNMIE Vol. 33, p.19-38, 1992
Cooks Tappered and Swept Panel
Tested By:
ESRC, 1992
Test Results:
Test Item
QUAD4 Element Stiffness
Assembly for QUAD4 Element
Loading
Theory
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Rectangular
Trapezoidal
Parallel
Extension
0.3e-4
0.3e-4
In-plane shear
0.1081
0.0972
Out-of-plane shear
0.4321
0.4223
Twist
0.0341
0.0294
In-plane Moment
0.0090
0.0092
0.3e-4
0.3e-4
0.1073
0.1028
0.4241
0.4151
0.0294
0.0294
0.0093
0.0090
Data File: TESTQ1A.DAT

*SANS*
Straight cantilever beam, rectangular shape
lbs,in
*MODEL*
10 1 1 1 1
*JOINT*
14
Joint
X
Y
1
0
0
2
1
0
3
2
0
4
3
0
5
4
0
6
5
0
7
6
0
8
0
0.2
9
1
0.2
10
2
0.2
11
3
0.2
12
4
0.2
13
5
0.2
14
6
0.2
*RESTRAINT*
2
0,0,0,0,0,0
1
1,1,1,1,1,1
8
1,1,1,1,1,1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISOTRO 0
0
1E7 0 0.3
*SECTION*
1 FLAT 0.1
*ELSET*
1
1
1
0
*QUAD4*
6
Member n1 n2 n3 n4 set opt
1
1
2
8
9
1
3
2
2
3
9
10 1
3
3
3
4
10 11 1
3
4
4
5
11 12 1
3
5
5
6
12 13 1
3
6
6
7
13 14 1
3
*COMB*
1
0.00 1.00
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
1
Joint dir Load
14
2
-1.0
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testq1a.DAT
: Straight cantilever beam, rectangular shape
: lbs,in
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
14
:
1
:
72
:
1188
: General shell (xyz-space), Linear Elastic
: Static Analysis
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
1
0
2 -8.250005E-04
3 -1.500003E-03
4 -2.025009E-03
5 -2.400012E-03
6 -2.624983E-03
7 -2.699790E-03
8
0
9
8.249995E-04
10
1.499996E-03
11
2.024991E-03
12
2.399988E-03
13
2.625017E-03
14
2.700210E-03
Delta-Y
0
-4.138003E-03
-1.577601E-02
-3.341401E-02
-5.555202E-02
-8.068996E-02
-1.073276E-01
0
-4.137997E-03
-1.577599E-02
-3.341399E-02
-5.555198E-02
-8.069004E-02
-1.073283E-01
Delta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Theta-X
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
QUAD4 Element Nodal Stresses

Element Node
Stress-Sxx
Stress-Syy
Stress-Txy
Moment-Mxx
Moment-Myy
Moment-Mxy
1
1 -8.250031E+03 -1.677358E-01 -4.996855E+01
0
0
0
2 -8.249969E+03 1.594286E-01 -4.996855E+01
0
0
0
9 8.250031E+03 1.594286E-01 -5.003145E+01
0
0
0
8 8.249969E+03 -1.677358E-01 -5.003145E+01
0
0
0
2
2 -6.750145E+03 -2.297171E-01 -4.985523E+01

0
0
0
3 -6.749855E+03 2.856495E-01 -4.985523E+01
0
0
0
10 6.750145E+03 2.856496E-01 -5.014477E+01
0
0
0
9 6.749855E+03 -2.297171E-01 -5.014477E+01
0
0
0
3 -5.250416E+03 -4.577617E-01 -4.958359E+01
0
0
0
4 -5.249584E+03 5.196120E-01 -4.958359E+01
0
0
0
11 5.250416E+03 5.196120E-01 -5.041641E+01
0
0
0
10 5.249584E+03 -4.577617E-01 -5.041641E+01
0
0
0
4 -3.750874E+03 -4.532954E-01 -4.912582E+01
0
0
0
5 -3.749126E+03 2.335761E-01 -4.912582E+01
0
0
0
12 3.750874E+03 2.335761E-01 -5.087418E+01
0
0
0
11 3.749126E+03 -4.532954E-01 -5.087418E+01
0
0
0
Theta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shear-Qy
Theta-Z
0
-7.755019E-03
-1.410007E-02
-1.903521E-02
-2.256041E-02
-2.467535E-02
-2.537822E-02
0
-7.754981E-03
-1.409992E-02
-1.903479E-02
-2.255959E-02
-2.467465E-02
-2.538178E-02
Shear-Qx
5 -2.250995E+03 1.769198E+00 -4.900519E+01

0
0
0
6 -2.249005E+03 -3.576378E+00 -4.900519E+01
0
0
0
13 2.250995E+03 -3.576378E+00 -5.099481E+01
0
0
0
12 2.249005E+03 1.769198E+00 -5.099481E+01
0
0
0
6 -7.474644E+02 1.422879E+01 -5.253555E+01
0
0
0
7 -7.525356E+02 -2.236795E+01 -5.253555E+01
0
0
0
14 7.474644E+02 -2.236795E+01 -4.746445E+01
0
0
0
13 7.525356E+02 1.422879E+01 -4.746445E+01
0
0
0
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1
3.000000E+01 5.028292E-01
0
0
0
2.464500E-04
8 -3.000000E+01 4.971708E-01
0
0
0
-2.464500E-04
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM =
1.667999E-11 1.000000E+00
0
0
0
1.210764E-11
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
>>>>
Data File: TESTQ1B.DAT

*SANS*
Straight cantilever beam, trapezoidal shape
lbs,in
*MODEL*
10 1 1 1 1
*JOINT*
14
Joint
X
Y
1
0
0
2
1.1
0
3
1.9
0
4
3.1
0
5
3.9
0
6
5.1
0
7
6
0
8
0
0.2
9
0.9
0.2
10
2.1
0.2
11
2.9
0.2
12
4.1
0.2
13
4.9
0.2
14
6
0.2
*RESTRAINT*
2
0,0,0,0,0,0
1
1,1,1,1,1,1
8
1,1,1,1,1,1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISOTRO 0
0
1E7 0 0.3
*SECTION*
1 FLAT 0.1
*ELSET*
1
1
1
0
*QUAD4*
6
1
1
2
8
9
1
3
2
2
3
9
10 1
3
3
3
4
10 11 1
3
4
4
5
11 12 1
3
5
5
6
12 13 1
3
6
6
7
13 14 1
3
*COMB*
1
0.00 1.00
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
1
Joint dir Load
14
2
-1.0
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testq1b.DAT
: Straight cantilever beam, trapezoidal shape
: lbs,in
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
14
:
1
:
72
:
1188
: Static Analysis
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
1
0
2 -8.116878E-04
3 -1.378051E-03
4 -1.971980E-03
5 -2.282636E-03
6 -2.539322E-03
7 -2.617089E-03
8
0
9
7.117078E-04
10
1.470940E-03
11
1.912852E-03
12
2.329755E-03
13
2.520763E-03
14
2.617296E-03
Delta-Y
0
-4.598507E-03
-1.333358E-02
-3.355351E-02
-5.054936E-02
-7.957609E-02
-1.027912E-01
0
-3.090374E-03
-1.619315E-02
-2.966537E-02
-5.516586E-02
-7.451259E-02
-1.027930E-01
Delta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Theta-X
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

Element Node
Stress-Sxx
Stress-Syy
Stress-Txy
Moment-Mxx
Moment-Myy
Moment-Mxy
1
1 -6.603960E+03 1.899594E+01 -1.088847E+03
0
0
0
2 -8.632373E+03 -4.657169E+01 -9.408524E+02
0
0
0
9 6.579938E+03 -1.945666E+02 1.087561E+03
0
0
0
8 8.608351E+03 -1.289990E+02 9.395657E+02
0
0
0
2
2 -6.743644E+03 1.746312E+02 9.338478E+00

0
0
0
3 -6.205086E+03 5.761142E+02 5.630471E+02
0
0
0
10 6.928213E+03 2.240549E+01 2.448917E+01
0
0
0
9 6.389655E+03 -3.790774E+02 -5.292195E+02
0
0
0
3 -4.980089E+03 1.382605E+02 -6.062701E+02
0
0
0
4 -5.426983E+03 2.574036E+02 1.966217E+01
0
0
0
11 4.771445E+03 -3.685287E+02 4.665558E+02
0
0
0
10 5.218339E+03 -4.876718E+02 -1.593765E+02
0
0
0
4 -3.731061E+03 2.356063E+02 -3.022871E+01
0
0
0
5 -3.322967E+03 2.797513E+02 3.530370E+02
0
0
0
12 3.858816E+03 -1.035144E+02 -5.505630E+01
0
0
0
11 3.450723E+03 -1.476594E+02 -4.383221E+02
0
0
0
Theta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shear-Qy
Theta-Z
0
-8.089695E-03
-1.338956E-02
-1.954371E-02
-2.243364E-02
-2.510494E-02
-2.589374E-02
0
-6.530018E-03
-1.457970E-02
-1.866926E-02
-2.302288E-02
-2.479267E-02
-2.576536E-02
Shear-Qx
5 -2.050934E+03 9.971545E+01 -3.711114E+02

0
0
0
6 -2.447085E+03 6.146200E+01 -1.122883E+02
0
0
0
13 1.964660E+03 -1.973610E+02 2.838625E+02
0
0
0
12 2.360811E+03 -1.591075E+02 2.503954E+01
0
0
0
6 -8.832547E+02 9.646599E+01 -3.663625E+01
0
0
0
7 -7.582546E+02 -1.724272E+00 3.243714E+01
0
0
0
14 9.593665E+02 -7.079767E+01 -9.256295E+01
0
0
0
13 8.343664E+02 2.739259E+01 -1.616363E+02
0
0
0
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1
3.000000E+01 7.476900E+00
0
0
0
2.818787E+00
8 -3.000000E+01 -6.476900E+00
0
0
0
-2.818787E+00
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM =
1.200817E-12 1.000000E+00
0
0
0
-1.571721E-11
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
>>>>
Data File: TESTQ1C.DAT

*SANS*
Straight cantilever beam, parallelogram shape
lbs,in
*MODEL*
10 1 1 1 1
*JOINT*
14
Joint
X
Y
1
0
0
2
.9
0
3
1.9
0
4
2.9
0
5
3.9
0
6
4.9
0
7
6.0
0
8
0
0.2
9
1.1
0.2
10
2.1
0.2
11
3.1
0.2
12
4.1
0.2
13
5.1
0.2
14
6
0.2
*RESTRAINT*
2
0,0,0,0,0,0
1
1,1,1,1,1,1
8
1,1,1,1,1,1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISOTRO 0
0
1E7 0 0.3
*SECTION*
1 FLAT 0.1
*ELSET*
1
1
1
0
*QUAD4*
6
1
1
2
8
9
1
3
2
2
3
9
10 1
3
3
3
4
10 11 1
3
4
4
5
11 12 1
3
5
5
6
12 13 1
3
6
6
7
13 14 1
3
*COMB*
1
0.00 1.00
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
1
Joint dir Load
14
2
-1.0
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testq1c.DAT
: Straight cantilever beam, parallelogram shape
: lbs,in
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
14
:
1
:
72
:
1188
: Static Analysis
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
1
0
2 -7.360754E-04
3 -1.291313E-03
4 -1.759201E-03
5 -2.119100E-03
6 -2.367741E-03
7 -2.524302E-03
8
0
9
8.367717E-04
10
1.383193E-03
11
1.833133E-03
12
2.173277E-03
13
2.402455E-03
14
2.530805E-03
Delta-Y
0
-3.186563E-03
-1.326317E-02
-2.848892E-02
-4.786445E-02
-7.029401E-02
-9.724530E-02
0
-4.755089E-03
-1.592463E-02
-3.206083E-02
-5.213552E-02
-7.505296E-02
-9.723859E-02
Delta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Theta-X
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

Element Node
Stress-Sxx
Stress-Syy
Stress-Txy
Moment-Mxx
Moment-Myy
Moment-Mxy
1
1 -8.867968E+03 3.101558E+02 9.764634E+02
0
0
0
2 -6.855626E+03 4.982737E+01 1.040475E+03
0
0
0
9 8.880935E+03 -1.418462E+01 -9.718659E+02
0
0
0
8 6.868594E+03 2.461438E+02 -1.035878E+03
0
0
0
2
2 -6.255934E+03 3.475221E+01 4.940658E+02

0
0
0
3 -4.599951E+03 6.721078E+02 1.131421E+03
0
0
0
10 6.225439E+03 3.475221E+01 -5.245614E+02
0
0
0
9 4.569456E+03 -6.026034E+02 -1.161917E+03
0
0
0
3 -5.096203E+03 3.901848E-01 1.537971E+02
0
0
0
4 -3.963542E+03 7.262375E+02 8.796444E+02
0
0
0
11 4.996983E+03 3.901848E-01 -2.530168E+02
0
0
0
10 3.864322E+03 -7.254571E+02 -9.788641E+02
0
0
0
4 -3.789076E+03 -5.199511E-01 -3.907577E+01
0
0
0
5 -3.117904E+03 6.477637E+02 6.092078E+02
0
0
0
12 3.688036E+03 -5.199511E-01 -6.196413E+01
0
0
0
11 3.016864E+03 -6.488036E+02 -7.102477E+02
0
0
0
Theta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shear-Qy
Theta-Z
0
-6.762292E-03
-1.229623E-02
-1.700713E-02
-2.069288E-02
-2.330024E-02
-2.506201E-02
0
-8.435078E-03
-1.385856E-02
-1.832940E-02
-2.172469E-02
-2.408805E-02
-2.547880E-02
Shear-Qx
5 -2.469943E+03 -9.498429E+00 -2.199432E+02

0
0
0
6 -2.271415E+03 5.099193E+02 2.994746E+02
0
0
0
13 2.350946E+03 -9.498429E+00 1.009463E+02
0
0
0
12 2.152418E+03 -5.289162E+02 -4.184715E+02
0
0
0
6 -1.030374E+03 -3.511024E+01 -5.484840E+02
0
0
0
7 -1.883406E+03 1.912561E+01 -4.638810E+02
0
0
0
14 9.366074E+02 -6.547737E+01 3.891509E+02
0
0
0
13 1.789639E+03 -1.197132E+02 3.045479E+02
0
0
0
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1
3.000000E+01 -1.231590E+01
0
0
0
-3.687403E+00
8 -3.000000E+01 1.331590E+01
0
0
0
3.687403E+00
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM = -3.332445E-12 1.000000E+00
0
0
0
-7.389644E-13
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
>>>>
Problem:
QUAD4 Cooks Tappered Panel, 2x2 and 4x4 mesh
Data File:
TESTQ2a.DAT, TESTQ2b.DAT
Source:
IJNMIE Vol. 33, p.19-38, 1992
Tested By:
ESRC, 1992
Test Results:
Test Item
Mesh Convergence
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

*SANS*
Cook's tappered and shape panel, 2x2 mesh
lbs,in
*MODEL*
10 1 1 1 1
*JOINT*
9
Joint
X
Y
1
0
0
3
48
44
1,3,1
4
0
22
6
48
52
4,6,1
7
0
44
9
48
60
7,9,1
*RESTRAINT*
3
0,0,0,0,0,0
1 1,1,1,1,1,1
4 1,1,1,1,1,1
7 1,1,1,1,1,1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISOTRO 0
0
1
0
0.333333
*SECTION*
1 FLAT
1
*ELSET*
1
1
1
0
*QUAD4*
4
1
1
2
4
5
1
3
2
2
3
5
6
1
3
3
4
5
7
8
1
3
4
5
6
8
9
1
3
*COMB*
1
0 1.00
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
3
Joint
dir
Load
3
2
-0.3
6
2
-0.4
9
2
-0.3
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testq2a.DAT
: Cook's tappered and shape panel, 2x2 mesh
: lbs,in
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
9
:
1
:
36
:
522
: Static Analysis
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
1
0
2 -1.616331E+00
3
3.716811E+00
4
0
5
6.608065E-01
6
9.815946E+00
7
0
8
7.770092E+00
9
1.740845E+01
Delta-Y
0
-4.231605E+00
-2.164580E+01
0
-4.824004E+00
-2.189432E+01
0
-5.461442E+00
-2.299327E+01
Delta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Theta-X
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

Element Node
Stress-Sxx
Stress-Syy
Stress-Txy
Moment-Mxx
Moment-Myy
Moment-Mxy
1
1 -1.371565E-01 -9.814801E-03 3.739649E-02
0
0
0
2 -1.304516E-01 4.912298E-03 1.869083E-02
0
0
0
5 -6.728472E-02 2.361796E-02 1.198589E-02
0
0
0
4 -7.398965E-02 8.890859E-03 3.069156E-02
0
0
0
2
Theta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shear-Qy
4 -1.025767E-01 5.362878E-02 2.543789E-02

0
0
0
5 -3.276326E-02 -4.665487E-03 -6.308029E-03
0
0
0
8 2.298446E-01 2.708043E-02 -7.612150E-02
0
0
0
7 1.600311E-01 8.537470E-02 -4.437559E-02
0
0
0
5 -6.091002E-02 -2.721632E-02 -1.821157E-02
0
0
0
6 -6.161902E-02 -1.729440E-02 -6.758061E-02
0
0
0
9 1.224498E-01 3.207463E-02 -6.687160E-02
0
0
0
8 1.231588E-01 2.215271E-02 -1.750256E-02
0
0
0
Force-Y
2.387505E-01
Force-Z
0
Shear-Qx
2 -2.606658E-01 -1.010062E-02 1.260086E-02

0
0
0
3 -2.154287E-01 7.134732E-03 -1.025367E-02
0
0
0
6 -4.035133E-02 2.998928E-02 -5.549072E-02
0
0
0
5 -8.558837E-02 1.275391E-02 -3.263617E-02
0
0
0
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
1
6.409854E-01
Theta-Z
0
-9.321583E-02
-7.850550E-01
0
-3.142230E-01
-8.397254E-01
0
-4.712575E-01
-1.169166E+00
Moment-X
0
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
0
-4.091742E+00
4
8.998474E-01 3.974275E-01
0
0
0
4.464577E+00
7 -1.540833E+00 3.638220E-01
0
0
0
-3.728345E-01
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM =
2.509104E-14 1.000000E+00
0
0
0
6.838974E-14
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
>>>>
Data File: TESTQ2B.DAT

*SANS*
Cook's tappered and swept panel, 4x4 mesh
lbs,in
*MODEL*
10 1 1 1 1
*JOINT*
25
Joint
X
Y
Generate
1
0
0
5
48
44
1,5,1
6
0
11
10
48
48
6,10,1
11
0
22
15
48
52
11,15,1
16
0
33
20
48
56
16,20,1
21
0
44
25
48
60
21,25,1
*RESTRAINT*
5
0,0,0,0,0,0
1 1,1,1,1,1,1
6 1,1,1,1,1,1
11 1,1,1,1,1,1
16 1,1,1,1,1,1
21 1,1,1,1,1,1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISOTRO 0
0
1.0
0
*SECTION*
1 FLAT
1
*ELSET*
1
1
1
0
*QUAD4*
16
1
1
2
6
7
1
3
2
2
3
7
8
1
3
3
3
4
8
9
1
3
4
4
5
9
10 1
3
5
6
7
11 12 1
3
6
7
8
12 13 1
3
7
8
9
13 14 1
3
8
9
10
14 15 1
3
9
11
12
16 17 1
3
10
12
13
17 18 1
3
11
13
14
18 19 1
3
12
14
15
19 20 1
3
13
16
17
21 22 1
3
14
17
18
22 23 1
3
15
18
19
23 24 1
3
16
19
20
24 25 1
3
*COMB*
1
0 1.00
*CASE*
1
*JLOAD*
5
Joint
dir
Load
5
2
-0.1
10
2
-0.2
15
2
-0.4
0.333333
20
25
*END*
2
2
-0.2
-0.1
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\esrc\doc47\verify\testq2b.DAT
: Cook's tappered and swept panel, 4x4 mesh
: lbs,in
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
25
:
1
:
120
:
3264
: Static Analysis
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
1
0
2 -7.563436E-01
3 -1.835343E+00
4 -8.984582E-01
5
4.315311E+00
6
0
7 -9.345007E-01
8 -9.536245E-01
9
1.567327E+00
10
7.305988E+00
11
0
12 -3.372687E-01
13
1.042167E+00
14
4.743356E+00
15
1.036874E+01
16
0
17
1.068038E+00
18
4.167627E+00
19
8.492080E+00
20
1.389770E+01
21
0
22
4.070326E+00
23
8.232914E+00
24
1.301713E+01
25
1.815709E+01
Delta-Y
0
-1.298496E+00
-4.666875E+00
-1.188875E+01
-2.257872E+01
0
-1.524336E+00
-5.045824E+00
-1.217770E+01
-2.285153E+01
0
-1.409499E+00
-5.301137E+00
-1.243797E+01
-2.343939E+01
0
-1.357806E+00
-5.549733E+00
-1.270332E+01
-2.381486E+01
0
-1.782231E+00
-5.830140E+00
-1.292540E+01
-2.418394E+01
Delta-Z
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Theta-X
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

Element Node
Stress-Sxx
Stress-Syy
Stress-Txy
Moment-Mxx
Moment-Myy
Moment-Mxy
1
1 -8.234107E-02 1.274875E-02 8.304969E-03
0
0
0
2 -9.885606E-02 -5.880620E-03 1.076513E-02
0
0
0
7 -1.170247E-01 -8.340781E-03 2.728012E-02
0
0
0
6 -1.005097E-01 1.028859E-02 2.481996E-02
0
0
0
2
2 -1.903519E-01 -5.297572E-03
0
0
3 -1.934476E-01 3.670387E-03
0
0
8 -1.438219E-01 1.022489E-02
0
0
7 -1.407261E-01 1.256933E-03
0
0
1.440168E-02
0
7.847184E-03
0
1.094291E-02
0
1.749742E-02
0
3 -2.639469E-01 -3.932755E-03 7.500966E-03

0
0
0
4 -2.493055E-01 5.220386E-03 6.394743E-03
0
0
0
9 -1.508890E-01 6.326609E-03 -8.246627E-03
0
0
0
Theta-Y
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Shear-Qy
Theta-Z
0
5.021409E-02
-9.154543E-02
-4.306671E-01
-8.120117E-01
0
-3.394767E-02
-2.425467E-01
-5.360046E-01
-8.487404E-01
0
-1.175808E-01
-3.609987E-01
-6.220747E-01
-9.462498E-01
0
-2.186839E-01
-4.374856E-01
-7.173215E-01
-1.053364E+00
0
-2.914993E-01
-5.740609E-01
-8.844224E-01
-1.329159E+00
Shear-Qx
8 -1.655304E-01 -2.826533E-03 -7.140404E-03

0
0
0
4
10
11
12
4 -2.167212E-01 -1.028201E-02 -2.220760E-03

0
0
0
5 -1.996044E-01 4.385848E-04 -2.144239E-02
0
0
0
10 -1.240537E-01 1.966021E-02 -3.855914E-02
0
0
0
9 -1.411705E-01 8.939608E-03 -1.933751E-02
0
0
0
6 -1.163887E-01 -1.003460E-02
0
0
7 -1.113041E-01 1.250691E-02
0
0
12 -7.055393E-02 1.175267E-02
0
0
11 -7.563850E-02 -1.078885E-02
0
0
2.464265E-02
0
2.539690E-02
0
2.031232E-02
0
1.955807E-02
0
7 -1.492253E-01 1.353483E-02 2.025195E-02

0
0
0
8 -1.382698E-01 -8.487216E-03 -1.570989E-03
0
0
0
13 -5.391894E-02 1.333572E-02 -1.252648E-02
0
0
0
12 -6.487444E-02 3.535778E-02 9.296455E-03
0
0
0
8 -1.611349E-01 1.015215E-02 -1.345005E-02
0
0
0
9 -1.464110E-01 -2.460661E-03 -1.945993E-02
0
0
0
14 -4.412301E-02 3.549214E-03 -3.418375E-02
0
0
0
13 -5.884683E-02 1.616203E-02 -2.817388E-02
0
0
0
9 -1.361869E-01 -8.885132E-03 -3.231679E-02
0
0
0
10 -1.375057E-01 -2.679228E-02 -8.101163E-02
0
0
0
15 -8.206902E-02 2.190257E-02 -7.969284E-02
0
0
0
14 -8.075022E-02 3.980971E-02 -3.099799E-02
0
0
0
11 -8.300524E-02
0
12 -6.323272E-02
0
17 3.773673E-02
0
16 1.796420E-02
0
4.267730E-03 1.608405E-02
0
0
2.683027E-02 3.204928E-03
0
0
3.970940E-02 -1.656759E-02
0
0
1.714685E-02 -3.688468E-03
0
0
12 -6.740152E-02 4.150820E-02 -7.911102E-03

0
0
0
13 -4.615566E-02 -8.996094E-03 -2.112226E-02
0
0
0
18 8.319992E-02 4.215059E-03 -4.236812E-02
0
0
0
17 6.195405E-02 5.471936E-02 -2.915697E-02
0
0
0
13 -5.240084E-02 -6.810140E-03 -2.050090E-02
0
0
0
14 -4.104795E-02 6.672498E-03 -3.772539E-02
0
0
0
19 5.900867E-02 2.389699E-02 -4.907829E-02
0
0
0
18 4.765578E-02 1.041435E-02 -3.185380E-02
0
0
0
14 -7.918118E-02 -1.794215E-02 -3.926981E-02
0
0
0
15 -8.012514E-02 -2.329373E-03 -7.289951E-02
0
0
0
13
20 -4.881348E-03
0
19 -3.937383E-03
0
3.130033E-02 -7.195554E-02
0
0
1.568755E-02 -3.832584E-02
0
0
16
7.240999E-02
0
1.329309E-02
0
3.500541E-02
0
9.412230E-02
0
17
22
21
14
17
18
23
22
15
18
19
24
23
16
1.383161E-02
0
6.441775E-02
0
2.807066E-01
0
2.301205E-01
0
-4.946253E-03
0
-2.665856E-02
0
-7.724470E-02
0
-5.553239E-02
0
6.575366E-02 -1.651421E-02 -1.472885E-02

0
0
0
7.196978E-02 1.025330E-02 -2.815605E-02
0
0
0
2.079950E-01 2.368049E-02 -3.437217E-02
0
0
0
2.017789E-01 -3.087020E-03 -2.094498E-02
0
0
0
6.148414E-02 -1.293176E-02 -2.329249E-02
0
0
0
5.223501E-02 7.188394E-03 -3.529194E-02
0
0
0
1.745320E-01 1.918784E-02 -2.604281E-02
0
0
0
1.837811E-01 -9.323165E-04 -1.404335E-02
0
0
0
1.044596E-02 -1.273999E-02 -3.539071E-02

0
0
0
20 -2.097155E-02 -1.657714E-02 -6.104974E-02
0
0
0
25 8.392227E-02 9.081900E-03 -2.963222E-02
0
0
0
24 1.153397E-01 1.291904E-02 -3.973186E-03
0
0
0
19
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1
2.907137E-01 1.384392E-01
0
0
0
-8.299693E-01
6
7.417246E-01 5.066375E-01
0
0
0
-1.127688E-01
11
6.828884E-01 2.732151E-01
0
0
0
5.269026E-01
16 -3.901689E-01 -1.083483E-01
0
0
0
1.223777E+00
21 -1.325158E+00 1.900566E-01
0
0
0
-8.079416E-01
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM =
2.864375E-14 1.000000E+00
0
0
0
-1.975087E-13
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
>>>>
Problem:
QUAD4 Scordelis-Lo Roof, 2x2, 4x4, 8x8 mesh
Data File:
TESTQ3a.DAT, TESTQ3b.DAT, TESTQ3c.DAT
Source:
IJNMIE Vol. 33, p19-38, 1992
Tested By:
ESRC, 1992
Test Results:
Test Item
Axial-Bending Interaction
Mesh Convergence
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

Output File:
Problem:
QUAD4 Spherical Shell, 9x9, 16x16 mesh
Data File:
TESTQ4a.DAT, TESTQ4b.DAT
Source:
IJNMIE Vol. 33, p19-38, 1992
Tested By:
ESRC, 1992
Test Results:
Test Item
Axial-Bending Interaction
Mesh Convergence
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

Output File:

Problem:
QUAD4 as Shearwall Element, no rigid floor
Data File:
TESTSW1.DAT
Source:
Tested By:
ESRC
Test Results:
Test Item
QUAD4 Element Panel Stiffness
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

Problem:
QUAD4 as Shearwall Element, rigid floor
Data File:
TESTSW2.DAT
Source:
Tested By:
ESRC
Test Results:
Test Item
QUAD4 Element Panel Stiffness
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
18. Earthquake Combination Verification

Problem:
Single Storey Building, Earthquake Combination Test
Data File:
TESTB1.DAT
Source:
Weaver
Tested By:
ESRC
Test Results:
Test Item
Frame Element Stiffness
Assembly for Frame Element
Rigid Floor Diaphragm
Eigen Value Solver
Static Condensation
Response Spectrum Analysis
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
19. Direct Integration Test

Problem:
Plane Truss, Direct Integration Analysis
Data File:
TESTDI1.DAT
Source:
Weaver & Johnston, p.120, p227, DDM, Initial Displacement
Tested By:
ESRC, 2000
Test Results:
Test Item
Truss Element Stiffness
Assembly for Truss Element
Direct Integration Analysis
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Data File: TESTDI1.DAT

*SANS*
Plane Truss, 3 elements, Weaver & Johnston, p.120, p227, DDM, Initial
Displacement
Kip,In
*MODEL*
2,1,5,1,1
1,0,0,0,0,0.6,0.3025,-0.1,0.001,10,0.02 :
eqc,r1,w1,r2,w2,gamma,beta,alpha,dtmax,freqco,tmax
*JOINT*
3
Joint X
Y
Z
Generate
1
0
0
0
2
150
200
0
3
150
0
0
*RESTRAINT*
2 0 0 1 1 1 1
1 0 1 1 1 1 1
3 1 1 1 1 1 1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISO 0 7.35e-7 30000 0 0.2
*SECTION*
1 SOLID
10
2 SOLID
6
3 SOLID
8
*ELSET*
1 1 1 0
2 1 2 0
3 1 3 0
*TRUSS*
3
Member JJ
JK
Set
Alpha
Generate
1
1
2
1
0
2
1
3
2
0
3
3
2
3
0
*MASS*
1.0 1.0 1.0
*COMB*
1 1 1
*DISPLACEMENT*
*INITDV0*
3
1 1 0.1 0.0
2 1 0.1 0.0
2 2 0.1 0.0
*VELOCITY*
*IMPACTLOAD*
*HARMONICLOAD*
*GROUNDACCEL*
*CASE*
1
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\SansPro\EXAMPLE\direct1.DAT
: Plane Truss, 3 elements, Weaver & Johnston, p.120, p227, DDM, Initial Displacement
: Kip,In
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
3
:
1
:
3
:
6
: Plane truss (xy-plane), Linear Elastic
: Direct integration Analysis (Newmark Beta - Hilber Alpha Method)
Damping Ratio
1
Omega Frequency 1
Damping Ratio
2
Omega Frequency 2
Newmark-Hilber ALPHA
Newmark-Hilber BETA
Newmark-Hilber GAMMA
Maximum Time Step
Cutt-off Frequency
Max Analysis Time
:
0
:
0
rad
:
0
:
0
rad
: -1.000000E-01
: 3.025000E-01
: 6.000000E-01
: 1.000000E-03
: 1.000000E+01 Hz
: 2.000000E-02
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
Delta-Y
1 -1.588187E-22
0
2
1.674167E-06 -1.255625E-06
3
0
0
Member
Axial-1
Span-2
M-Span-3
1
7.350000E-04
3.445312E-02
2
-1.905824E-19
1.240312E-02
3
2.094750E-03
0
Shear-2
Delta-Z
0
0
0
Theta-X
0
0
0
Shear-3
Theta-Y
0
0
0
Axial-1
Shear-2
Theta-Z
0
0
0
Shear-3
5.512500E-04
7.350000E-04
5.512500E-04
3.307500E-04
1.905824E-19
3.307500E-04
-9.187500E-04
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1
0
1.249500E-03
0
0
0
0
3
1.905824E-19 2.425500E-03
0
0
0
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM =
1.905824E-19 3.675000E-03
0
0
0
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
M-
>>>>
20. Direct Integration Test

Problem:
Plane Frame, Direct Integration Analysis
Data File:
TESTDI2.DAT
Source:
Weaver & Johnston, p.120, p227, DDM, Impact Load
Tested By:
ESRC, 2000
Test Results:
Test Item
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Data File: TESTDI2.DAT

*SANS*
Plane Truss, 3 elements, Weaver & Johnston, p.120, p227, DDM, Impact Load
Kip,In
*MODEL*
2,1,5,1,1
1,0,0,0,0,0.6,0.3025,-0.1,0.001,10,0.02 :
eqc,r1,w1,r2,w2,gamma,beta,alpha,dtmax,freqco,tmax
*JOINT*
3
Joint X
Y
Z
Generate
1
0
0
0
2
150
200
0
3
150
0
0
*RESTRAINT*
2 0 0 1 1 1 1
1 0 1 1 1 1 1
3 1 1 1 1 1 1
*MATERIAL*
1 ISO 0 7.35e-7 30000 0 0.2
*SECTION*
1 SOLID
10
2 SOLID
6
3 SOLID
8
*ELSET*
1 1 1 0
2 1 2 0
3 1 3 0
*TRUSS*
3
Member JJ
JK
Set
Alpha
Generate
1
1
2
1
0
2
1
3
2
0
3
3
2
3
0
*MASS*
1.0 1.0 1.0
*COMB*
1 1 1
*DISPLACEMENT*
*INITDV0*
*VELOCITY*
*IMPACTLOAD*
1
2 1 7 0.000,0.00, 0.001,0.15, 0.003,0.85, 0.004,1.00, 0.005,0.85,
0.007,0.15, 0.008,0.00
*HARMONICLOAD*
*GROUNDACCEL*
*CASE*
1
*END*
Output File:
<<<<
Licensee
Filename
Project
Units
>>>>

: C:\SansPro\EXAMPLE\direct2.DAT
: Plane Truss, 3 elements, Weaver & Johnston, p.120, p227, DDM, Impact Load
: Kip,In
Number of Joint
Number of Loading
Number of DOF
Total Col Height
Structural Model
Analysis Method
:
3
:
1
:
3
:
6
: Plane truss (xy-plane), Linear Elastic
: Direct integration Analysis (Newmark Beta - Hilber Alpha Method)
Damping Ratio
1
Omega Frequency 1
Damping Ratio
2
Omega Frequency 2
Newmark-Hilber ALPHA
Newmark-Hilber BETA
Newmark-Hilber GAMMA
Maximum Time Step
Cutt-off Frequency
Max Analysis Time
:
0
:
0
rad
:
0
:
0
rad
: -1.000000E-01
: 3.025000E-01
: 6.000000E-01
: 1.000000E-03
: 1.000000E+01 Hz
: 2.000000E-02
Joint Displacements
Joint
Delta-X
Delta-Y
1 -1.588187E-22
0
2
1.674167E-06 -1.255625E-06
3
0
0
Member
Axial-1
Span-2
M-Span-3
1
7.350000E-04
3.445312E-02
2
-1.905824E-19
1.240312E-02
3
2.094750E-03
0
Shear-2
Delta-Z
0
0
0
Theta-X
0
0
0
Shear-3
Theta-Y
0
0
0
Axial-1
Shear-2
Theta-Z
0
0
0
Shear-3
5.512500E-04
7.350000E-04
5.512500E-04
3.307500E-04
1.905824E-19
3.307500E-04
-9.187500E-04
Support Reactions
Joint
Force-X
Force-Y
Force-Z
Moment-X
Moment-Y
Moment-Z
1
0
1.249500E-03
0
0
0
0
3
1.905824E-19 2.425500E-03
0
0
0
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SUM =
1.905824E-19 3.675000E-03
0
0
0
0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<<<<
M-
>>>>
21. Concrete and Steel Design Test

Problem:
Plane Frame, Element Design
Data File:
TESTDSG.DAT
Source:
Tested By:
ESRC
Test Results:
Test Item
Concrete Beam Design
Concrete Column Design
Steel Frame Design
Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

Verify

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Verify

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

SANSPRO VERIFICATION TEST

Verification Test of SANSPRO V.4.7

SUMMARY OF VERIFICATION TEST

SANSPRO QUAD4 Maximum error

Conclusion : QUAD4 element should be used with maximum 5 degrees of

Conclusion : QUAD4 element should be used with maximum 5 degrees of

8. Rigid Floor Diaphragm

Conclusion: 3 Dof/Floor Condensation will give accurate results

9. Rigid End Zone

b. Rigid Zone at Beam Length

c. Rigid Zone at Column Length

Data File: TESTT1.DAT

SANSPRO - Output File - (C) Nathan Madutujuh, 1988-2003

: Ir. Nathan Madutujuh, M.Sc, Bandung

End of SANSPRO for Windows Output File

Data File: TESTF1.DAT

SANSPRO - Output File - (C) Nathan Madutujuh, 1988-2003

: Ir. Nathan Madutujuh, M.Sc, Bandung

Frame Element Forces

End of SANSPRO for Windows Output File

Data File: TESTPS1.DAT

SANSPRO - Output File - (C) Nathan Madutujuh, 1988-2003

: Ir. Nathan Madutujuh, M.Sc, Bandung

QPS8 Element Nodal Stresses (Plane Stress)

End of SANSPRO for Windows Output File

Data File: TESTPB1.DAT

SANSPRO - Output File - (C) Nathan Madutujuh, 1988-2003

: Ir. Nathan Madutujuh, M.Sc, Bandung

QPB8 Element Nodal Stresses

End of SANSPRO for Windows Output File

Data File: TESTPB2.DAT

SANSPRO - Output File - (C) Nathan Madutujuh, 1988-2003

: Ir. Nathan Madutujuh, M.Sc, Bandung

QPB8 Element Nodal Stresses

-4.069914E-03 5.050206E-01 1.471045E-15

-1.215979E-01 -6.071532E-18 1.051444E+00 -4.163336E-16

-5.012693E-02 4.069914E-03 5.050206E-01 -2.359224E-16

21 1.876123E-02 1.876123E-02 -2.987304E-02 3.443064E-01 3.443064E-01

23 1.934010E-02 -7.055919E-02 -9.588230E-04 2.804998E+00 -3.257764E-01

1.178604E-02 3.149765E-02 3.443064E-01 -4.087197E-01

-3.647939E-02 -8.673617E-18 5.828671E-16 1.051444E+00

39 -7.055919E-02 1.934010E-02 -9.588230E-04

41 2.376342E-01 2.376342E-01 -9.194034E-17 -2.499182E+00

-4.489407E-03 3.149765E-02 -4.087197E-01 3.443064E-01

End of SANSPRO for Windows Output File

Data File: TESTQ1A.DAT

SANSPRO - Output File - (C) Nathan Madutujuh, 1988-2003

: Ir. Nathan Madutujuh, M.Sc, Bandung

QUAD4 Element Nodal Stresses

2 -6.750145E+03 -2.297171E-01 -4.985523E+01

5 -2.250995E+03 1.769198E+00 -4.900519E+01

End of SANSPRO for Windows Output File

Data File: TESTQ1B.DAT

SANSPRO - Output File - (C) Nathan Madutujuh, 1988-2003

: Ir. Nathan Madutujuh, M.Sc, Bandung

QUAD4 Element Nodal Stresses

2 -6.743644E+03 1.746312E+02 9.338478E+00

5 -2.050934E+03 9.971545E+01 -3.711114E+02

End of SANSPRO for Windows Output File

Data File: TESTQ1C.DAT

SANSPRO - Output File - (C) Nathan Madutujuh, 1988-2003

: Ir. Nathan Madutujuh, M.Sc, Bandung

QUAD4 Element Nodal Stresses

2 -6.255934E+03 3.475221E+01 4.940658E+02