Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Countries
The Democratic Peoples Republic of Korea
The Democratic Peoples Republic of
Korea or North Korea is one of the last
remaining countries to use the Communist
economic system. The country is situated in
East Asia and shares borders with Japan,
China and South Korea. The country
became Communist after the Korean War
(1950-1953) and has remained in near total
isolation for over 60 years. Only now is it
loosening its Iron Curtain and releasing
more and more information, most of which
is most likely falsified. The Supreme
Leader, Kim Jong Un, is the dictator of the
country and decides most of the economic
decisions with his ministers. The Capital of
Figure 1
Pyongyang is the largest city in North Korea.
North Korea also possesses a large army with The map above shows North Korea, the countries it borders and its
nuclear explosive devices. location in the world. (2016)
2. The D.P.R.K.
2.1 What Elements of a free market or command economy has the D.P.R.K. implemented?
2.2 A description of the economic system. How does the government deal with key economic
questions?
2.3 What are the key economic components of the North Korean Economy?
2.4 What happened during the economic crisis of 2008? How did North Korea respond to it?
2.5 What can be deduced from the information above?
3. The U.S.A.
3.1 What Elements of a free market or command economy has the U.S.A. implemented?
3.2 A description of the economic system. How does the government deal with key economic
questions?
3.3 What are the key economic components of the U.S. Economy?
3.4 What happened during the economic crisis of 2008? How did the United States of America
respond to it?
3.5 What can be deduced from the information above?
5. Conclusion
5.1 Conclusion of Report
6. Works Cited
1.1 Introduction to the Compare and Contrast Report
This report serves to bring clarity into the subject of Economy and how different countries
implement different economic strategies to target Gross Domestic Product growth. Economic
systems can strengthen connections and promote stability in human societies. However, this
cannot be said about the D.P.R.K. and the U.S.A, as they are economic and military rivals. The
cold war has split these two countries in becoming exact opposites of each other. The
Democratic Peoples Republic of Korea, one of the last Communist States, is also one of the few
countries that admit to wanting to attack the Capitalist United States of America. In this report,
Authors Jack Allen and Kilian Schwarz will examine both countries economically and analyze
their response to the 2008 economic crisis. Additionally, they will compare and contrast the two
countries in terms of their economies.
2.1 What Elements of a free market or command economy has the D.P.R.K.
implemented?
The Democratic Peoples Republic of Korea or D.P.R.K. is one of the last communist countries
in the entire world and thus its economic system is heavily influenced by the old Soviet Union
and the Communist Manifesto by Karl Manifesto. North Korea is often known as an isolated,
authoritarian and totalitarian country. But what type of economy does it have? Does it have a
command economy or a mixed economy or even a free market economy? The answer is that
North Korea has a fully fledged Command economy with no elements of a free market economy.
This is because it is a communist country and that everybody gets the same level of food,
education and other living necessities. The government, under the control of the dictator Kim
Jong-un, decides what the country imports and exports and where the country is headed for the
future economically. The government decides most aspects of daily life of the North Korean
people. Everything that produces something for the state is owned by the government. The
D.P.R.K. has implemented an economic system that is severely bound to the command economy.
Additionally, it is focused on military power and on total obedience and discipline throughout
North Korea.
2.2 A description of the economic system. How does the government deal with key
economic questions?
The D.P.R.K. is a Communist state, which means that all economic questions are answered by
the government, as opposed to Capitalism, where the consumer decides what is produced. In
Communist states, the government dictates the production, import and export of everything the
country needs. Communism is an ideology that is supposed to make everybody equal. One major
flaw in this ideology is, that there is no bottom limit to this and that logically everybody could be
equally poor. This is what has happened in North Korea. In North Korea food is the main limited
supply, thus the country relies heavily on imports from China. Other, for us common objects, are
non-existent or banned by the North Korean government. Objects such as smartphones, personal
computers, and jeans are all banned in North Korea. The government is unimaginably strict
about the possession or use of these items and will often send people into prison camps or death.
The North Korean government only imports the minimum requirements to keep the citizens alive.
The years of tight isolation have made it necessary for the North Korean government to trade
with its trade partners. On the other hand, the leaders of the D.P.R.K. spend most of their annual
expenditure (3.3 billion [2007]) on their military. This shows that North Korea does not care
about its citizens much and is focused more on military technology. According to some sources,
the government of North Korea uses this deprivation of necessities to oppress the population and
uses its military to secure the current regime.
Through additional information from the D.P.R.K., I have found out that the North Korean
government shows its power and superiority through its military. The website states that the
military empowers the government and is the pride of the state. Other countries warn about the
threat North Korea poses. An example is the Intelligence Chief of the United States of America,
James Clapper, that a North Korean Uranium enrichment plant is resuming production.
Additionally, he expressed: North Korea has been operating the reactor long enough so that it
could begin to recover plutonium from the reactor's spent fuel within a matter of weeks to
months. This has resulted in sanctions being raised against North Korea, which has had a large
effect on its economy.
2.3 What are the key economic components of the North Korean Economy?
North Korea, a state governed in isolation, has one of the smallest economies in the world. Its
official 2013 GDP is estimated by the CIA World
Factbook at about 28 billion. It reaches this GDP by
selling rare and common minerals and metals to
China, its main business partner. Some minerals
and metals that it exports are North Korea also
produces a large amount of military products and
machines for its military, which it wants to measure
with the military of the United States of America.
Even though the labour force of the D.P.R.K. has
an estimated labor force of 15.21 million, the
unemployment rate of North Korea is estimated at
an extremely large 25.6% according to 2013
statistics.
Different information could not be found because of the strict policies of the North Korean
government that forbid any actual information to be leaked. Information such as equity of
income, % of population below the international poverty line, gross national saving and many
others could not be found. All of the above information are estimates from credible sources such
as the CIA world factbook and University resources.
2.4 What happened during the economic crisis of 2008? How did North Korea
respond to it?
In 2008, the North Korean
citizens suffered under a
horrendous famine, which was
largely caused by the 2008
economic crisis. To find out
why this happened, China,
North Koreas largest trade
partner, must be examined in
more detail. Following the 2008
economic crash, many countries
suffered including China. As an
example China lost 4% of its
GDP growth rate from 2007 to
Figure 4
2008, this caused many of the
Chinese markets to shrink. This graph shows the GDP per quarter in North Korea. Observe the drop in the late
Because China was struggling 2008/early 2009 quarters. (2015)
itself, it could not aid North
Korea and continuously provide resources and food. This caused a wide-spread famine and
caused up to an estimated 3.2 million deaths since the 1990s when the famines first began.
Before the economic crash of 2008, North Korea was in a relatively stable position and the
citizens of the D.P.R.K. were not living in famine, however, the economic crash influenced
China and ultimately caused a new famine to start. North Korea could do little to counter or
evade the economic crisis because of its insignificant world influence. A very active black
market grew out of the famine. Illegal items, smuggled in from neighbouring countries were sold
to the local population. However, the North Korean government used extensive measures to
counter the black market. Because the government did not and could not help the people, the
famine raised a lot of international awareness and many countries such as South Korea and the
U.S.A. sent care packages to North Korea to aid the population, however most specialists believe
that only a few care packages reached the starving citizens, the government is believed to have
confiscated most of them. In terms of its GDP, North Korea suffered a loss of up to -2.25% over
3 quarters. This alone makes a lot of impact on the economy, but it must be kept in mind, that
before the 2008 economic crash, North Korea only had an annual GDP growth rate of 1% per
year. As a result, North Korea slightly loosened its isolation and now lets more and more people
into the country, which was characterized by tight isolation for decades.
At the end of 2009, the North Korean Won significantly started to suffer under inflation. North
Korea rapidly carried out a redenomination of its currency. This means that it capped the amount
of the old North Korean currency that could be exchanged for the new notes. Basically, North
Korea changed its currency to stop the inflation and avoid a possible hyperinflation.
3.1 What Elements of a free market or command economy has the U.S.A.
implemented?
A free market economy is a market in which vendors and consumers set goods and services for
free. Free laws and forces of supply and demand from the governments intervention and the
authority and monopoly price-setting.
A command economy is an economy where the government determines things and they get
involved with the productivity, investment, incomes and prices within the country.
The USA has a mixed economy. It is a mixed economy because the USA has businesses which
are private and also the government is playing in two important roles. One important role is the
Fiscal policy. Fiscal policy is when the government uses their own money and money collecting
method to create an influence on the economy. The second role is the monetary policy which is
when aggregate supplies are brought in by the government to make more influence on the
economy.
If the market falls by too much (7%), the government stops all trade and waits for a few days
while it tries to restart the economy. Banks also get a lot of money when there is an economic
crash because banks are a way to restart the economy of a country.
3.2 A description of the economic system. How does the government deal with key
economic questions?
US is a free market but the government still intervenes with the system. They government has to
intervene to keep up the pace with everything because if they dont something could go wrong
and the market would have to make a lot of changes. The government usually intervenes with the
market when they are allocating resources
inefficiently. When they intervene they stop
the market flow and stop all trading.
The US provides food and supplies by
importing and exporting goods and products
with many countries, the trade mostly with
Canada, China, Mexico and Japan, but they
trade with a lot more places than this.
3.4 What happened during the economic crisis of 2008? How did the United States
of America respond to it?
GDP in the USA was contracted further until 2009 just after the economic crisis. This was the
longest downturn since the great depression. The cause for the 2008 economic crisis was in the
U.S.A. itself. Because the U.S. imported 55% of the oil it needed, the economy was majorly
affected. The 2008 economic crisis was a build-up of different events such as the doubling of
crude oil prices between 2001 and 2006. Additionally, the home prices were at their peak,
therefore the higher gasoline prises negatively affected consumers' budgets and many of these
consumers fell behind their mortgage payments. Between 2006 and 2008 the oil prices increased
by 50% and banks, that owned the properties, started to foreclose them. In addition to the above,
in 2008 falling home prices, low credits, investment bank flops and the international economic
downturn pushed America into a recession. Not only America has affected, but many other 1st
world countries were affected too. The US congress, which relies on banks, established a
Troubled Asset Relief Programme worth 700 billion USD in the October of 2008. Most of this
Troubled Asset Relief Programme (TARP) was returned by 2011. Following the events of 2008,
the US Congress and the president Barack Obama passed a fiscal stimulus that was worth an
additional $787. This was to be used over 10 years. It was intended to create more jobs for the
recessed economy and this was achieved. In the years following the 2008 economic crisis the
United States reached a budget deficit of an estimated 9% of the GDP at that time. Gradually, the
Deficit shrank to 7.9% of the GDP.
4.5 Which system is better? What are the Similarities and Differences?
There are very few similarities and differences
between Capitalist and Communist governments
and there are even less between North Korea and
the U.S.A. A similarity of the two countries is that
both have subsidized their agriculture and military.
Both nations are trying to innovate the military
market by pouring million and even billion of
USD into this sector. Both countries are trying to
produce food in order to supply the population that
lives within its borders. The most common trait of
nearly all governments is that they strive for
power; land resources and people. This trait
connects nearly all forms of governments.
Additionally, both political systems are theories Figure 7
based on industrial economies.
Depicted above is a picture of Wall Street in New York. It is the
Some of the main differences of the two political largest economic stock trade centre, but also is a hotspot for
systems are that Communism tries to care for the Bureaucratic corruption. (2014)
people socially, whereas Capitalism is based on the
survival of the fittest. Capitalist and Communist economic systems have such high amounts of
differences, that it is necessary for me to list them one by one. Firstly, Communism follows a
totalitarian government while the Capitalist system follows a political system of democracy. All
of the land is state owned in Communism, as are many other things. Capitalism however, is
based on the human want instinct and greed which allow private ownership. When not abused,
all of the wealth a country produces is split equally throughout the population. In Capitalism
everybody must produce for themselves and there is little social help or equality. There is a
hierarchy in Capitalist societies; this is the opposite of Communist societies, where everybody is
considered to be equal.
Different countries require different political systems. This is a fact, but another fact is that
almost every Communist state has collapsed in the recent decades. This however is not a fair
example because both economic systems need countries with large industries to work well. This
was never the case in any Communist country ever. Most countries in which the Communist
party took over were agricultural countries. It is needless to say that in the roots, Communism is
a good political system. It allows an escape from a totalitarian society and brings large amounts
of social equality to the country. However, it often happens that the leader of the country forgets
the original idea and exploits and oppresses the common people in order to collect the riches.
Capitalism is not very different from the failure of Communism. Only the widespread use of it
saves it from collapse. Capitalism is also a very good idea. It allows the competent and smart
people to rise higher and higher and become richer and richer as a reward. This also is abused by
many corrupt people that exploit the middle and the low class workers. Many of the superrich
such as the Rothschilds and Rockefellers have gained so much money through banks. These
banks often take money from the low class and sometimes even from the middleclass and
continue to allow the rich to become richer. A superrich family such as the Gates family has a
total estimated net worth of 79.2 billion USD. This is not at all fair to all of the other people of
the world. In conclusion our judgment is that Capitalism mixed with Socialism is the best
political system, because it helps the poor to a certain degree but also rewards hard work with
more money.
Text sources
Cullinane, Susannah. "How Does North Korea Make Its Money." CNN. N.p., 10 Apr. 2013. Web.
4 Feb. 2016. <http://edition.cnn.com/2013/04/09/business/north-korea-economy-explainer/>.
N.A. "UN Security Council Approves Strictest Sanctions on North Korea in Decades." The
Guardian. N.p., 2 Mar. 2016. Web. 26 Feb. 2016.
<http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/02/un-security-council-adopts-sanctions-on-
north-korea>.
N.A. "Korea, North." The World Factbook. Central Intelligence Agency, n.d. Web. 31 Jan. 2016.
<https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/kn.html>.
N.A. "Economyand Foreign Trade." Naenara. D.P.R.K., 2016. Web. 28 Feb. 2016.
<http://www.naenara.com.kp/en/trade/>.
N.A. "U.S. Intel Chief Offers Warning about N. Korea Nuclear Threat." CBSNEWS. N.p., 9 Feb.
2016. Web. 20 Jan. 2016. <http://www.cbsnews.com/news/intelligence-chief-speaks-to-north-
korean-isis-cyber-threats>.
N.A. "United States." Central Intelligence Agency. Central Intelligence Agency, 2016. Web. 21
Feb. 2016. <https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/us.html>.
N.A. "Differences between Capitalism & Communism and Why Did It Start in Russia?"
Anonymous. N.p., 2015. Web. 16 Feb. 2016. <http://www.sahistory.org.za/article/capitalism-vs-
communism-and-russian-revolution-grade-11>.
N.A. "The Origins of the Financial Crisis." The Economist. N.p., 7 Sept. 2013. Web. 20 Feb.
2016. <http://www.economist.com/news/schoolsbrief/21584534-effects-financial-crisis-are-still-
being-felt-five-years-article>.
Picture sources
Figure 1: Scholastic. "North Korea." GROLIER ONLINE ATLAS. Scholastic, 2016. Web. 01 Mar.
2016. <http://go.grolier.com/atlas?id=mgas030>.
Figure 2: N.A. "Map: United States." Infoplease. Infoplease, 2016. Web. 01 Mar. 2016.
<http://www.infoplease.com/atlas/unitedstates.html>.
Figure 3: CIA. "Korea, North." Central Intelligence Agency. Central Intelligence Agency, 2016.
Web. 29 Feb. 2016. <https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/kn.html>.
Figure 4: N.A. "N.T." North Korean GDP Growth Rate, 1971-2011. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb.
2016. <https://www.google.com.sg/search?q=North+Korea+GDP+Growth+Rate,+1971-
2011&safe=strict&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjr9qrh7f3KAhXLno4KHcze
C3wQ_AUIBygB&biw=1366&bih=607#safe=strict&tbm=isch&q=North+Korea+GDP+Growth
+Rate+1971-2011>.
Figure 5: CIA. "United States of America." Central Intelligence Agency. Central Intelligence
Agency, 2016. Web. 12 Feb. 2016. <https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-
factbook/geos/us.html>.
Figure 6: N.A. "The Monuments of North Korea." ~ Kuriositas. N.p., 11 Dec. 2011. Web. 13
Feb. 2016. <http://www.kuriositas.com/2013/12/the-monuments-of-north-korea.html>.
Figure 7: Joyce. "The Wolf of Wall Street Guide." FluentU. N.p., 2016. Web. 24 Feb. 2016.
<http://www.fluentu.com/english/business/blog/business-english-finance/>.
North American Flag: N.A. "American Flag Clipart." Webweaver's Free Clipart. N.p., 2016.
Web. 01 Mar. 2016. <http://www.webweaver.nu/clipart/usa-flags.shtml>.
North Korea: NASA. "Google Earth (North Korea)." Google Earth. N.p.: Google, n.d. N. pag.
Print.
North Korean Flag: N.A. "Flag of North Korea." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 10 Jan.
2016. Web. 01 Mar. 2016. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_North_Korea>.