Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Grade 3-5
Author: Kathleen V. Kudlinski
Title: Boy, were we wrong about dinosaurs!
Publisher: Scholastic
Summary: This book talks about dinosaurs
Evaluation
Plot- The book goes into depth about certain theories and how those
theories were proved or disproved.
Believabiltiy-8
Comment: This book talks about dinosaurs and you start to learn if
there was really dinosaurs.
Major dramatic question- 8
Comment: Every new theory that scientists come up with you wonder if
that theory is true or not. In the book it either will show how they
discovered whether if it is true or not.
Other Considerations-8
Style and Language-8
Comment: I like the style and language the author uses. This book is
informational but I think children will enjoy learning about dinosaurs.
Pacing-8
Character-8
Setting-8
Comment: I like how the scientists described what it was like back then
for dinosaurs.
Theme: 8
Comment: I think the theme of this story is that when you are learning
you can discover new things and become like scientists and prove
whether it is right or wrong.
Other considerations(mood,tone)-8
Is it a well-rounded piece?-8
OVERALL RATING-8
6- 9 years old
Author: Robin Page + Steve Jenkins
Title: How to clean a hippopotamus: A look at unusual animal
partnerships
Publisher: HMH Books
Summary: The book describes about animal symbiosis.
Evaluation
Plot- Children learn about how different animals help each other out.
Believabiltiy-9
Comment: Children can learn about why ravens follow wolves or why a
mongoose comes running when a warthog lies down. Children are able
to learn about why animals behave the way they do.
Major dramatic question- 8
Comment: I think children will wonder why those animals act that way
and how certain animals help each other out.
Other Considerations-8
Style and Language-7
Comment: The author does a good job on teaching children about
animals for example, how a crab and iguana help each other out.
Pacing-8
Character-8
Setting-9
Theme:9
Other considerations(mood,tone)-8
Is it a well-rounded piece?-9
OVERALL RATING-9
Comment: Children are able to learn about animals. They can learn
about their specific lifestyle and how animals have partnerships with
each other.