Professional Documents
Culture Documents
07 FinalReport PDF
07 FinalReport PDF
By Team #7:
Larae Baker
Maxine Bent
Jonathan Bush
Mike Heslinga
Adam Jones
Abstract: A new process to produce styrene monomer is under development by Dow
Chemical and Snamprogetti. Team #7 has designed and simulated an industrial plant to
produce two billion pounds of styrene monomer per year. An advantage to the new
process is that it starts with a less expensive raw material, ethane, instead of ethylene.
The process has three key stages: 1.) A distillation reactor alkylates benzene and
ethane are converted into styrene and ethylene respectively. 3.) A distillation train where
1 INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................... 4
2 THE CHEMISTRY .................................................................................................. 4
2.1 ALKYLATION ....................................................................................................... 4
2.2 DEHYDROGENATION ............................................................................................ 6
2.3 POLYMERIZATION ................................................................................................ 7
3 OBJECTIVES ........................................................................................................... 8
4 PROCESS DESCRIPTION ..................................................................................... 9
4.1 DESIGN ALTERNATIVES ....................................................................................... 9
4.1.1 Styrene from Ethylene and Benzene.............................................................. 10
4.1.2 Co-Production of Styrene and Propylene Oxide .......................................... 10
4.2 AREA 100 ALKYLATION .................................................................................. 10
4.2.1 Equipment Design......................................................................................... 11
4.2.2 Catalyst Design............................................................................................. 13
4.3 AREA 200 DEHYDROGENATION ...................................................................... 13
4.3.1 Equipment Design......................................................................................... 14
4.3.2 Catalyst Design............................................................................................. 16
4.4 AREA 300 SEPARATIONS OF AROMATIC PRODUCTS ........................................ 17
4.4.1 Separations Train and Column Design......................................................... 17
4.4.2 Separations Inhibitors................................................................................... 20
4.5 AREA 400 LIGHT GAS SEPARATION ................................................................ 21
4.6 HEAT EXCHANGER DESIGN ................................................................................ 22
4.7 PUMP, COMPRESSOR AND TURBINE DESIGN ...................................................... 23
4.8 MATERIALS OF CONSTRUCTION ......................................................................... 24
5 ENVIRONMENTAL, HEALTH AND SAFETY ISSUES.................................. 25
5.1 ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS ............................................................................ 25
5.2 CHEMICAL HAZARDS ......................................................................................... 26
5.3 SAFETY HAZARDS .............................................................................................. 27
6 CONTROL DESIGN .............................................................................................. 28
6.1 CONTROL DESIGN ON AREA 100........................................................................ 28
6.2 CONTROL DESIGN ON AREA 200........................................................................ 29
6.3 CONTROL DESIGN ON AREA 300........................................................................ 30
6.4 CONTROL DESIGN ON AREA 400........................................................................ 32
7 ECONOMIC ANALYSIS ...................................................................................... 32
8 UNCERTAINTIES AND ASSUMPTIONS.......................................................... 34
9 FUTURE WORK .................................................................................................... 34
1 Introduction
Styrene is a precursor to many polymer products such as polystyrene, acrylonitile
products. These materials are used around the world in a variety of ways including
food storage, packaging, and automobile parts.1 The market for styrenics has seen
overall growth in the previous decade despite a recent down year. The market is
expected to recover and see large gains in the near future. Therefore, now is an
excellent time to join the market, particularly if current styrene production cannot
The process of producing styrene is well established. It was first produced in the
1930s by I. G. Farben in Germay and Dow Chemical in the United States. Styrene
is a clear liquid at room temperature with an aromatic odor. It is currently sold with
a minimum purity of 99.8% but is more commonly produced at 99.93%. The price
2 The Chemistry
2.1 Alkylation
The alkylation is a basic Friedl-Crafts alkylation, where ethylene reacts with benzene
This reaction is exothermic and takes place in a distillation reactor system that is
alkylated as it passes through the catalyst.4 This alkylated product has a lower
boiling point than benzene and will therefore become the distillate product in the
and oligomerized products.5 The polyalkylated products that are formed come off in
(Rxn 1b)
The catalyst in this reaction is EBZ-100, also available through UOP, LLC.
These may either come off the top of the column or aklylate with benzene to form
heavy alkybenzenes. Other byproducts come from the raw materials; for example,
bottoms product.3
2.2 Dehydrogenation
FCC was chosen over other reactor systems because it has the advantage of
(Ga2O3), platinum, iron oxide (Fe2O3), potassium oxide (K2O) and silica suspended
H2
(Rxn 2a)
(Rxn 2b)
H2
These reactions are highly endothermic. The energy for the reaction is provided by
the catalyst in the regeneration reactor, where it is heated to 660C upon decoking.
The catalyst needs to be decoked continuously because two side reactions occur that
The coke deposits on the catalyst, reducing the number of active sites, and thus
lowering the conversion of the desired reactions, 2a and 2b.8 Toluene can also lose
another carbon to become benzene. These reactions account for total of 3% loss in
conversion.3 Reactions 2a and 2b are also highly selective with 90-94% and 90-93%
selectivities respectively.9
heavy aromatics. These byproducts are insignificant in terms of yield loss, but
2.3 Polymerization
Under the right conditions styrene can polymerize violently. This is an exothermic
production. Inhibitors are necessary to prevent this. For the storage tanks 4-tert-
Butylcatechol, or 4-TBC, is used in a concentration of 15 ppm. The tank is held
below 75F and oxygen is bubbled through the tank to increase the lifetime of the
These steps allow the final product to be sold at a purity of 99.93% styrene
3 Objectives
The following objectives were satisfied in the design:
1.) To design a plant with the capacity to produce styrene monomer at a rate of 2.2
billion lbs/yr with a purity at or above the industrial standard of 99.93 wt%
3.) To develop the design with the following design norms in mind:
a. Justice and caring Design decisions were made that consider the rights
b. Trustworthy People living around this plant need to trust that they will
trust the operators of the plant to have the amount of styrene promised at
will not only run continuously, but also at the required purity.
c. Stewardship Caring for the earth and all that is in it was a key motivator
necessary and also being sure that none of our starting materials go to
equipment allows the plant to operate using the less energy than non-
optimized.
and reactors.
4 Process Description
The process to synthesize styrene monomer from ethane and benzene can be
There are two major design alternatives prevalent in industry today. The first is the
The second is the co-production of styrene and propylene oxide from ethylene,
The production of styrene from ethylene and benzene is the most common industrial
dehydrogenated to form styrene.11 These are the same as reactions 1a and 2a,
Styrene is produced via the oxidation of ethylbenzene (formed from ethylene and
the market for propylene oxide because this process is a co-production. This process
also requires very complex and costly separations due to the aldehydes that form and
The distillation reactor system requires four distillation reactors (R-100) run in
parallel, one distillation column (T-100), and four packed bed reactors (R-101) run in
parallel. The process begins with benzene and ethylene reacting to form
ethylene (recycled from the ethylene and ethane separations process) enter a
distillation reactor. The distillation reactor contains twenty-five trays, but is packed
with catalyst in the upper 30 vol% of the reactor.4 It is 6.5m tall and has a 1.9m
diameter. Two streams enter the reactor system; one is rich in benzene and the other
is rich in ethane with 9.01 mol% ethylene. The ethane exits as the distillate of R-
100, thus removing a distillation column from the Area-300 design. The inlet stream
with ethylene can operate at concentrations up to 95% ethane, with the remainder
once the ethylbenzene is formed it falls down the reactor as the bottoms product.
This reactor design has several advantages over the more industrially common
2.) The benzene that comes off the reactor as the distillate is recycled back to the
reactor feed. A purge is added so that very light gasses do not accumulate. Only
3.) The continued removal of the alkylated and polyakylated products forces the
chemistry in Reaction 1a to favor the products. This also minimizes both the
which the reaction takes place is controlled by the boiling point of the mixture.
This has the further advantage that as the exothermic alkylation takes place the
5.) The rate of reaction and distribution can be well controlled by regulating the
system pressure. Thus, upon piloting this process, the distillation reactor
6.) Two stages are condensed into one; the first stage would consist of the reaction
reactor.
The bottom products from the distillation reactor are then sent to a distillation
column, where the polyalkylated benzenes (mostly di- and tri- ethylbenzene) are
packed bed reactor. In the presence of more benzene, the formation of ethylbenzene
are then recycled to distillation column T-100. The 99.78 mol% pure ethylbenzene
There are two catalysts used in Area-100. EBZ-500S is available from UOP and is
used in the distillation reactor. Its a zeolite catalyst in the solid -phase. It has a
spherical shape with a nominal diameter of 2.2mm and is absent of precious metals.
Unwanted side-reactions are minimized and it more resistant to poisons like water,
oxygenates, olefins, chlorides and sulfur. EBZ-500S has a life time of five years
without regeneration and can be regenerated up to three times, thus allowing the
catalyst to be used for 20 years before replacement.5 It is available from UOP for
approximately $105 per pound.12 When used in conjunction with EBZ-100 in the
the transalkylation. It is also a solid zeolite catalyst with no precious metals and has
a nominal diameter of 1.6mm with an extrudated shape. Its life time is five years
without regeneration and it can be regenerated three times, and needs to be replaced
every 20 years.13 Its cost is $40 per pound.12 Together these solid catalysts will
The fresh ethane feed and the ethylbenzene formed in Area-100 enter the
R-201 are used in parallel, allowing for temporary shutdown of one reactor. Here
Reactions 2a and 2b form the main product, styrene, along with ethylene. Side
The fluidized catalyst cracking reactor (FCC) has two reaction vessels, RV-200 and
R-201. Ethane and ethylbenzene enter R-200 and form the dehydrogenated products
ethylene and styrene respectively. At the inlet of R-200 the ethane to ethylbenzene
volumetric feed ratio is 4.08:1. At this feed ratio, the product of conversion and
selectivity for Reaction 2a is 48% and for Reaction 2b is 9.7%.7 R-200 uses the
Optimix LSi FCC feed distribution system available through UOP LLC. The
ethane and ethylbenzene carry the solid catalyst to the top of the reactor, where it
exits through special disengaging arms which generate a centrifugal flow pattern.14,15
This is designed to disperse the catalyst uniformly in the riser of the reaction vessel.
The catalyst remains fluidized by the reagent mixture in the gaseous phase. The
dynamics of the reaction vessel cause the catalyst to move downward (due to
catalyst. This causes thorough mixing between the catalyst and reaction
components. Ethane, ethylene, ethylbenzene, styrene, toluene, and benzene are the
major compounds leaving the FCC chamber, along with the dehydrogenated form of
the Area-100 byproducts. A solid side product, coke, is produced via Reactions 2c
and 2d, and deposits onto the catalyst.3 The gaseous products leave the reactor
through a solid filtering technique, known as cyclones. The cyclones extend towards
the bottom of the riser, but stop before the catalytic stripping part of R-200. This
design is common in VSS reactor systems available through UOP LLC. It contains
the hydrocarbons to the riser of the reactor and pre-strips the catalyst.15 The catalyst
falls further to an AF spent catalyst stripper, also available through UOP LLC. In
the catalyst stripper, absorbed hydrocarbons leave the catalyst particles. The catalyst
falls to the bottom of the stripping trays and is sent to regenerator R-201.16
In the regenerator the coke deposited on the catalyst is burned off via air at 560C,
and is combusted to produce water. By this process, the catalyst is heated to 680C
and transported back to R-200. The high temperature of the catalyst provides the
heat of reaction for Reaction 2a and 2b to occur. There are several reasons to use a
reactor-regenerator system:7
catalyst will not degrade over time. This means the operating parameters and
2.) The heat for Reactions 2a and 2b are provided by the catalyst, thus super-heating
3.) The re-mixing of the fluidized bed prevents hot spots from forming, which would
lower selectivity.
5.) The process can be made continuous without changing the operating parameters
6.) R-200 and R-201 are physically separate. This disallows mixing between the
selectivites.
This process is very catalyst-specific. Therefore, the design and development of the
catalyst is crucial. The catalyst in Area-200 is comprised of less than 10 wt% Ga2O3,
20 wt% Fe2O3, 100 ppm platinum, and the remainder alumina. The catalyst is
synthesized in a four-step process. The promoters are added to the carrier via an
aliquot. The sample dried at 150C and calcinated at 900C. The iron oxide and
remaining promoters are added to the carrier. The catalyst is dried and calcinated
for a given feed composition, data from Figure 1 was taken from US patents
#6,031,143:
300
Styrene Ethane
250
200
y = 498.18x-0.6678
R 2 = 0.9967
g/h/kgcat
150
100
50
y = 17.28x0.5396
R 2 = 0.9996
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Ethane/EB vol
750 kg/m3.17 OC-5 uses platinum as a promoter and is available at $115 per
pound.12
98%. This system uses seven distillation columns of which three are for the
prevent the polymerization of styrene. The components that enter Area-300 can be
In column T-300, light gases such as ethane and ethylene are vented to the light
gases area. Toluene and benzene are separated from ethylbenzene and styrene. To
ensure minimal styrene polymerization product the temperatures should stay low. T-
small pressure drop across each stage of approximately 0.05 psi. This minimizes the
temperature difference across the column and therefore the temperature necessary in
66 stages, with the feed entering in the 50th stage. The diameter is 2.04m and its
height is 40.23m. The reflux ratio is optimized at 12:1. The distillate product is rich
in toluene (49.6 mol%) and benzene (49.1 mol%), with some n-hexane (1.2 mol%)
and the remainder ethylbenzene (0.1 mol%). These products are sent to column T-
301.
In T-301, a column of 23 trays, toluene is purified and leaves as the bottoms product.
It has a purity of 99.8% toluene, which is then to spot sold as high-grade toluene. T-
301 is a sieve-tray column with a diameter of 2.04m (6.7ft) and a height of 14.02m
(46ft). Sieve trays are used because polymerization in not a concern, and is less
expensive. The operating pressure is 26.7 kPa. The reflux ratio is optimized at 3.4:1
and the optimum feed inlet is tray ten. The distillate is mainly benzene, with some
trays. This process is economically viable because the recovered benzene can be
recycled to Area-100. Like column T-302, sieve trays are used because costs can be
reduced without sacrificing product purity. The optimum feed inlet is in tray 28, and
optimum reflux ratio is 15:1. The diameter is 2.1m (6.9ft) with a height of 14.63m
(48ft). The operating pressure is 26.7 kPa. The benzene is purified to 99.85 mol%.
The bottoms product from column T-300 contains ethylbenzene (49.4 mol%),
styrene (50.4 mol%), the toluene (0.17 mol%) and the remainder heavy aromatic
byproducts. These are sent to column T-303, where the ethylbenzene is separated off
the top to be recycled to Area-200. Like T-300, this column uses Flexipac HC to
reduce pressure drop across the column. T-303 is 72 stages, with an optimum feed
inlet at stage 48 and optimum reflux ratio of 10:1. To further reduce operating
7.99 kPa. The diameter of T-303 is 5.33m and the height is 43.89m.
The remainder of the styrene product is then sent to T-304, where it is then purified.
Column T-304 incorporates the same packing as previously mentioned above the
feed inlet, and trays in the stages below the feed inlet. The advantage to designing a
hybrid column like this is due to some of the styrene monomer beginning to
polymerize. If any styrene polymerizes enough to form a solid within the column
then it will deposit onto the tray. Occasionally the column will need to be opened
and the trays cleaned to remove any solid polymer residue. This is easy to do with a
sieve tray and very difficult with packing. Since the highest temperatures are in the
reboiler, the polymers are most likely to form at the bottom of the column, on the
sieve trays. T-304 operates at a lower pressure (5.33 kPa) than column T-303. It has
a height of 27.4m and a diameter of 5.2m. The optimum reflux ratio is 0.75:1. The
total number of trays is 45 and the feed enters on the 24th tray. The bottoms product
is then further purified in T-305. The distillate is purified styrene and is sent to
structured packing from stages one to fifteen and sieve trays from sixteen to the last
tray, thirty. It operates at 5.33 kPa, with a height of 18.3m and a diameter of 3.3m
(10.9ft). The optimum reflux ratio is 1.29:1. The bottoms product is sent to column
T-306. The distillate joins with the distillate from T-304 and goes to storage and for
sale.
The final column in Area-300 is T-306. It has the same dimensions as T-305 and
same tray design. The only difference is that it operates with a reflux ratio of 15:1.
The distillate product in columns T-304, T-305 and T-306 are mixed to produce the
final styrene product available at a purity of 99.93 wt% styrene. The bottom
products of T-306 are the heavy side-products. They are mixed with the heavy
Polymerization would occur often, causing the columns to need to be shut down
frequently for cleaning. Therefore, the inhibitors that are used, and where they enter
the process, are important. There are two different types of inhibitors: retarders
(which slow polymerization) and true inhibitors (which stop polymerization in the
added in the liquid stream coming from the condenser on column T-303, the first
column where the styrene product is purified. It will then fall through column T-
303, where the concentration of styrene increases as the inhibitor moves down the
column. It is carried through T-306 and removed before the styrene is sent to storage
tanks.
After removal of the 2,4-dinitrophenol, but before storage, the inhibitor 4-TBC is
mixed into the styrene product stream. It stops polymerization by interacting with
the free radicals formed in the initiation step of the polymerization mechanism. In
the storage tanks, oxygen is bubbled through the tank to activate the 4-TBC. The
styrene product is sent to customers with the 4-TBC present. Customers remove it
The products from Area-200 are cooled to -50C and then separated in V-202 so that
the vapor products are rich in ethane, ethylene, nitrogen, and hydrogen and the liquid
products contain the aromatic products from the dehydrogenation. The vapor
products are then sent to Area-400, the light gas separations. Here the ethane and
ethylene are separated from the hydrogen and nitrogen via a series of compression,
ten two-phase separators. Under ideal circumstances, ten throttling valves would be
used instead of turbines that operate at 85% efficiency. However, HYSYS could not
correctly model an isoentropic expansion for this case. If throttling valves were used
a cost reduction could be seen in both the equipment savings and in the compressor
duty. Because the turbine is not 100% efficient, some of the enthalpy of expanding
the gas goes to entropy, which must be made up by the compressors. The two-phase
-168.2C in the last stage. The temperatures after compression get as high as 42C.
Three streams leave Area-400. The first is the bottoms product of the first two phase
separator and consists of mostly styrene, ethylbenzene, and other aromatics. The
comprised of 64.9 mol% nitrogen, 34.9% hydrogen, and the remainder ethane and
ethylene. This stream is sent to Area-200 and is burned in R-201 to provide heat for
the reaction. The third stream is the mixture of the bottoms of each two-phase
separator, and is rich in ethane and ethylene at 90.0 mol% and 9.98 mol%
respectively. This stream is fed to Area-100 and supplies the ethylene feed for
Sixty-six heat exchangers have been designed in the process. The fundamental
q = UATlm Equation 1
where q is the total heat transferred, U the overall heat transfer coefficient, Tlm is
the log-mean temperature difference, and A is the area used for exchanger design.
The overall heat transfer coefficient is estimated from design tables provided by
Peters, Timmerhaus and West.18 Water is the coolant for streams needing to be
cooled down to 15C. It is used in the condensers in Area-300 and on exchanger E-
202.1. The coolant, R-22, is available to -60C and is primarily used in Area-400.19
The reboilers in Area-300 use exhaust steam available at 150 kPa and 109.95C for
heating the product streams. However, one exchanger uses saturated steam at 3550
kPa and 243.38C. Area-300 accounts for a total of sixteen exchangers. Area-400
uses thirty exchangers for interstage cooling after compression. Eleven exchangers
are used in Area-100 and ten exchangers are used in Area-200. The pressure drop
across the tube and shell side of each exchanger can be calculated. An example
calculation can be seen in Appendix E.1. The pressure drops were also increased to
account for losses due to piping and to ensure that estimates are on the conservative
side. The specifications on each exchanger can be seen in Appendix A.2. The cost
There are fifteen places in the plant design where vapor compression is necessary.
operating at 75% efficiency are used in the process. The optimum arrangement
requires anywhere from one to six compressors with interstage cooling. Area-400
specifying that the duty on each compressor in one chain is equal, and a cost analysis
done for each case. This required over eighty various arrangements to be evaluated
and the optimum fifteen to be taken from this. The cost of each compressor was
determined from the material of construction, size and duty required. The cost of
each compression chain was the sum of the compressor and heat exchanger costs
There are ten turbines in the process; all of which are used in Area-400. Each
turbine is 85% efficient and used to cool the vapor into the two phase region. The
cost on each turbine is determined from the material of construction, size and duty.
There are four pumps needed in the process. They are on the benzene feed to Area-
100, benzene recycle from Area-400 to Area-100, and the toluene and styrene
products from Area 300. The cost of each pump is determined from its material of
construction, capacity, duty and pressure. Calculations and specifications for each
compressor, turbine and pump can be seen in Appendices A.1, A.6 and A.3,
respectively.
Carbon or stainless steel is used in all areas of the plant. Carbon steel is generally
less expensive than stainless steel, but has two problems. First, it degrades at
temperatures above 455C. Carbon will segregate from the piping, putting graphite-
like deposits into the process.19 Therefore, in all areas operating above 455C
stainless steel is used. This is most prominent in Area 200. Reactors T-200 and T-
201 reach temperatures above 600C. The product stream is cooled below 400C
after exchanger E-200. However, the product stream contains hydrogen gas. The
second problem with carbon steel is that hydrogen gas can imbed itself within the
material, degrading the steel over time.18 Therefore, carbon steel cannot be used
again until Area-300 and cannot be used at all in Area-400. The materials of
Christian engineers are called not only to design for profit, but to design in a manner
that glorifies Gods creation and respects His people. Therefore, the design of this
the well-being of all people that might be impacted by the plant or its products. This
One of the design objectives is to show stewardship and therefore minimize the
The environment consists of the land, water, air, animals and people near the plant.
One major byproduct is carbon dioxide. This is created from the incineration of
gaseous hydrocarbon side products and the burning of coke on the catalyst. Streams
306 and 311 are to be combusted to carbon dioxide and water. Purge stream 227
also contains carbon dioxide. All products are to be sent though scrubbers to reduce
the carbon monoxide content from side combustion reactions and bring the limits
within the National Ambient Air Quality standards of 9ppm per 8 hour non-
estimations of the side combustion reactions are beyond the scope of the design. As
of 2004, the average American produced 5.76 metric tons of carbon dioxide per
year.21 The designed process produces the equivalent amount of 5750 Americans in
one production year. This is a weakness of the design, and would need to be reduced
before implementation.
The other byproducts consist of heavy hydrocarbons. These are incinerated when
possible and treated when they cannot be incinerated. The modeling of this process,
and the reactions that govern it, is also beyond the scope of the design. Water
generated from the combustion of hydrogen in T-202 is sent for treatment as well.
The significant benefit to the process is that the dehydrogenation reactions (2a and
2b) occur simultaneously. Thus the designs for ethane to ethylene and ethylbenzene
to styrene plants are incorporated into one design. This is evidenced by the need for
two separations process, Area-300 and Area-400. A possible pollution reduction can
Caution should be taken when dealing with several compounds in the process.
Styrene monomer should not have contact with skin. If it does, the skin should be
washed with water for at least fifteen minutes. Styrene is extremely flammable and
can travel a considerable distance to an ignition source and should be put out using a
dry chemical, alcohol foam or carbon dioxide. Pure styrene has a penetrating odor.
The flammability limits lie from 1.1 wt% to 6.1 wt%. Styrene waste should be
mixed with a more flammable solvent and then be atomized into an incinerator.22
The precursor to styrene, ethylbenzene, is also dangerous. It should never be inhaled
and CPR may be needed after doing so. It is labeled as a severe fire hazard and the
same method of fire fighting used for styrene should be applied to ethylbenzene.23
Benzene is an eye irritant and causes nausea, unconsciousness, and a change in blood
composition when breathed in. It is also a fire hazard, and should be put out with the
same method as styrene and ethylbenzene. The flammability limits are from 1.3
vol% to 7.9 vol%. A self contained breathing apparatus should always be used when
around benzene that could enter the surrounding air.24 Ethane is non-toxic but can
rupture. The flammability limits are from 3.0 vol% to 12.5 vol%.25 Ethylene can
from overexposure. It is flammable, with limits from 3.1 vol% to 32.0 vol%. Fires
for both ethane and ethylene are best treated by removing or shutting off the
source.26
Safety is a primary concern in all areas of the process. There are three major
variables that affect equipment safety. They are the operating pressures,
construction (see sect 4.8) reduces the dangers associated with temperature and
certain chemicals. For example, carbon steel cannot be used above 455C or with
hydrogen gas, thus stainless steel is the appropriate material in streams which carbon
steel cannot be used. For equipment operating at high pressures, the thickness of
equipment must be increased. This is taken into account as a pressure factor used
when costing equipment. The flammability of each stream is also taken into
consideration. The only streams with oxygen present enter regenerator R-201. The
oxygen is consumed in the reaction. All other streams operate well above the upper
flammability limits. Using pressure, temperature, level, and flow controllers the
6 Control Design
Whatever can be controlled in the process should be controlled.27 Controls are vital
to the safety of a process and are, therefore, incorporated in the design to converge
the real-world variables to the design variables. They are designed to check for
unsteady states, minimize the occurrence of unsteady states, and then correct the
problem. As such, the time lag between the occurrence of a problem and the
correction needs to be minimized. This is done by placing controls where they can
The fresh benzene feed is to be controlled via a flow controller, which measures the
storage tanks and adjust the feed so that the benzene to ethylene ratio is 10:1 in R-
reboiler, so that it will have a direct impact on space time and reaction temperature
inside R-100. Since there are actually four R-100 reactors in parallel, the feed
controller needs to be on each incoming stream. This would allow for temporary
failure. R-100 has a flow controller on the condenser, which affects the ethane going
to Area-200. Column T-100 has two level controls; one on the reboiler and
condenser each. The bottoms of T-100 are sent to R-101, but with a flow control on
the purge stream. Like the benzene inlet control on R-100, this control varies the
The ethylbenzene and ethane from Area-100 is mixed with ethylbenzene from Area-
300 and fresh ethane feed. There is a feed controller on the ethane feed, controlled
based on the product from Area-100. The mixed stream is sent though exchanger E-
ethylbenzene is sent though a series of compressions and then mixed with inert gas.
This stream is sent though E-201, where the temperature entering the reaction needs
200 is sent through a flow control, which is modified based on the temperature after
E-202. After filtration, another temperature is used for exchanger E-204, so that the
temperature into the two-phase separator, V-200, is consistent and will cause the
aromatic products to be sent to Area-300 and the light gases to Area-400. Because
this controller determines the split in V-200 it will affect the entire process.
The air feed to Area-200 has a flow controller across a gate valve and then a pressure
controller on compressor K-201. This stream is heated by the product from T-201,
thus a flow controlled bypass is used to control the temperature of this stream. Its
temperature is vital because it causes the combustion in T-201 to occur, which
provides the energy for the reactions in T-200. The product stream from T-201 is
also heat exchanged with the hydrogen and nitrogen inlet from Area-400. A flow
controlled bypass is again used to control the temperature of both streams. The
product stream is filtered and another temperature controller used across the heat
is used, E-202 has a temperature control. When separated in V-200, the gaseous
nitrogen and carbon dioxide are sent across a flow control. This control varies how
much is purged and how much is sent to R-200 to fluidize the reactor bed.
There are three parameters that need to be controlled in Area-300. They are: the exit
composition of each column, the column pressure, and the reflux ratio on each
condenser. The first controller is a flow controller used directly before T-300. The
column then has six controllers. Because this column operates under vacuum
pressure, the pressure control is crucial. Depending on the column pressure, the
temperature, reflux and flows will all change. Therefore, it is essential that the
pressure meets the specs by which the column was designed. The pressure control
can open a gate valve used to vent off gases in case the pressure is too high. The
temperature control is on the column. The equilibrium within the column dictates
connected to the reboiler exhaust steam. A level control varies what leaves T-300
through the bottoms and another level control is used on the condenser. On the
condenser, the level control operates a gate valve on the product stream. Its function
is to set the reflux ratio, which should be converged to the designed optimum reflux
ratio. Lastly, a flow controller controls how much reflux is sent back to T-300.
Since this is the first column in the distillation chain, it may be tempting to put two
temperature controllers on the column, each one to specify the composition on either
end. However, studies have shown that this creates many problems because the two
controllers are not mutually exclusive. One controller can interfere with the other
based on how much it tries to control the exchanger duty. Using only one
Columns T-301, T-302, and T-303 are designed in a similar manner, with six
controllers per column used to control the composition, pressure and reflux ratio.
For each of these columns, the reflux ratio is greater than one, and so the gate valve
for the level control on the condenser is positioned on the product stream. When the
reflux ratio is less than one, then the level control is on the condenser coolant, as
with T-304 and T-305. The flow control is on the product stream, and another flow
control manages the reboiler steam. A level control operates a gate valve on the
bottoms product. T-306 has a reflux ratio above 1, so there is a level control on the
distillate, and flow control on the reflux. However, the bottoms are designed with
the level control on the product stream, and the flow control on the reboiler steam.
The mixed styrene product stream is then sent to storage. There is a flow control on
Even though Area-400 has eighty two pieces of equipment, the control design is
simple. Every compressor has a pressure control. Every heat exchanger has a
temperature control and a flow control on the coolant. Every turbine has a pressure
control as well. Therefore, there are 102 controls used in Area-400 total.
7 Economic Analysis
Capital, utility and raw material costs along with revenue from the products
equipment, land and piping affect the capital cost. Of these, the largest contributor to
the capital cost is from the equipment. This is priced according the cost spreadsheets
available from Peters, Timmerhaus and West. Direct costs, indirect costs, and
working capital affect the total capital investment. A few direct costs are the
Indirect costs are things like construction and legal expenses, engineering and
supervision, contractor fees, and contingency costs. Working capital is the cash on
hand needed to start the plant. The total capital investment is 2,508.7 million dollars.
Raw material costs are from ethane, benzene, air, OC-5, EBZ-100, EBZ-500S, TBC,
and DNP. The annual cost of all raw materials is 731.5 million dollars. Electricity,
refrigeration, steam, water treatment, and cooling water usage determine utility costs.
The total is 197.8 million dollars per year. The revenue generated from the products
styrene and toluene is 1,976.2 million dollars per year. The selling price for styrene
is $0.99 per pound. The variable costs consist of raw material costs, utilities and
general expenses; projected at 1,084 million dollars per year. The fixed costs include
fixed charges, plant overhead and general expenses; and are 297.7 million dollars per
year.18
The price for the styrene is chosen by varying the Investors Rate of Return (IRR). If
the IRR is set to 15.0%, the price of styrene is $0.99 per pound as shown in Figure 1:
35.0%
30.0%
25.0%
20.0%
IRR
15.0%
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
$0.70 $0.80 $0.90 $1.00 $1.10 $1.20 $1.30 $1.40
-5.0%
Styrene Monomer Product Price ($/lb)
15.0% IRR is a common value and a good starting point.28 The Net Present Value
for this IRR is 1.99 million dollars, which is basically zero when compared to the
high capital costs. Equation 2 can be used to solve for the IRR:
n
CFi
0= (Equation 2)
i=0 (1 + IRR) i
The return on investment (ROI) stabilizes after the sixth production year, where it is
Most of the process specifications used in the HYSYS simulation came directly from
the patents. Generally, having some data is better than no data. This is true of the
data provided in the patents as well. However, the patents often provide one value
for one experiment. Without having multiple experiments run for each point, one
must trust the validity of that data point. In designing a pilot plant, this may not be a
In HYSYS, the design was simulated using the General NRTL fluid package. The
9 Future Work
Broadening the scope of the design would lead to the possibility to do a lot of further
work. Some of the most important work could be done to minimize pollutants. The
current design produces 33,098,000 kg/hr of carbon dioxide. This amount needs to
simulation of the combustion and side reactions should be done in HYSYS. A way
to model the formation of carbon monoxide would make the simulation more
realistic. This leads to stack scrubbing costs having an impact on the economic
analysis because the costs associated with the treatment of this gas can rise quickly.
Too much carbon monoxide production (or inadequate smokestack design) would
The fluidized catalyst cracking reactor could be designed with greater detail. If a
kinetic model could be developed and then used to design the various parameters of
the reactor, then the estimates on the reactor size could be improved. This would
help in pricing the reactor system. The reactor price is currently an educated
estimate. A more accurate price would improve the economic analysis as a whole.
FCC simulation software is also available. This would help because interpolated
values in the patents do not account for catalyst degradation. In fact, the values in
the patents are for a very specific system, using a specific catalyst and reactor set-up.
Any method for further modeling the FCC system that allows these parameters to
The computer simulation software, HYSYS, can simulate processes which involve
solids. However, the HYSYS software used for this design does not have this
license available. A solid modeling license would allow the catalyst regeneration
step to be simulated, thus making the simulation more realistic. Filters that remove
solid catalyst particles from the regeneration product stream could also be simulated.
A better estimate of the pressure drop across a filter could be determined. Currently,
The HYSYS simulation also has another problem: it cannot model throttling valves.
Therefore, the designed process used expanders that were 85% efficient. Since this
caused a loss of energy and increased equipment costs, the turbines are far less
There are sixty-six heat exchangers used in the process. The overall heat transfer
coefficients for each exchanger could be improved. Currently, all heat transfer
values are estimated using Peters, Timmerhaus and West, which gives a range of 250
to 600 W/m2K for medium organics cooled with water, and a range of 250 to 500
W/m2K for medium organics heated with steam.18 These temperature ranges can
vary the exchanger area significantly. Because the components are generalized and
the heat transfer coefficient given a broad range of possible values, it is likely that
the estimated heat transfer coefficients used for doing heat transfer area design are
(3) Kroschwitz, Jacqueline I., Raymond E. Kirk, Donald F. Othmer, and Mary Howe-
Grant. "Styrene." Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology. 4th ed. New York City:
Wiley, 1998.
(4) Smith, Jr., Lawrence A.; Arganbright, Robert P.; Hearn, Dennis. Process for the
preparation of ethyl benzene listed in US Patent #5,476,978; Nov 29, 1991.
(5) "EBZ 500S Catalyst." Ethylbenzene and Styrene. 2006. UOP. 20 Apr. 2006
<http://www.uop.com/objects/EBZ%20500S%20Catalyst.pdf>.
(6) Jones, Mark. "Ethane Plus Benzene." E-mail to the author. 18 Oct. 2005.
(8) Buonomo, Franco; Sanfilippo, Domenico; Iezzi, Rodolfo; Micheli, Emilio. Catalytic
System and Proces for Dehydrogenating Ethylbenzene to Stryene listed in US
Patent # 6,242,660; June 5, 2001.
(9) Buonomo, Franco; Donati, Dianni; Micheli, Emilio; Tagliabue, Lorenzo. Process
for the Production of Styrene listed in US Patent #6,031,143; Feb 29, 2000.
(10) http://www.novachem.com/productservices/docs/StyMon_Safety_Guide.pdf
(11) Watson, Keith. Calvin College, Grand Rapids, MI. 5 Oct. 2005.
(12) Cooper, Geoff. "Catalyst Costs for a School Project." E-mail to the author. 1 May
2006
(13) "EBZ 100 Catalyst." Ethylbenzene and Styrene. 2006. UOP. 20 Apr. 2006
http://www.uop.com/objects/EBZ%20100%20Catalyst.pdf>.
(15) FCC Vortex Separation Technology: The VDS Design and VSS Design
http://www.uop.com/objects/FCC%20Vortex.pdf
(18) Peters, Max S.; Timmerhaus, Klaus D.; West, Ronald E.; Plant Design and
Economics for Chemical Engineers. 5th Ed. University of Colorado. 2003.
(19) Perry, Robert H.; Green, Don W.; Perrys Chemical Engineers Handbook. 7th Ed.
McGraw-Hill. New York. 1997.
(20) http://www.epa.gov/oar/oaqps/greenbk/o3co.html
(21) http://pages.ca.inter.net/~jhwalsh/wfsesr.html
(22) http://msds.ehs.cornell.edu/msds/msdsdod/a98/m48796.htm#Section5
(23) http://msds.ehs.cornell.edu/msds/msdsdod/a401/m200166.htm#Section5
(24) http://msds.ehs.cornell.edu/msds/msdsdod/a49/m24066.htm#Section11
(25) http://msds.ehs.cornell.edu/msds/msdsdod/a328/m163906.htm
(26) http://msds.ehs.cornell.edu/msds/msdsdod/a194/m96822.htm
Chen, Kaidong, Alexis T. Bell, and Enrique Iglesia. "Kinetics and Mechanism of
Oxidative Dehydrogenation of Propane on Vandium, Molybdenum, and Tungsten
Oxides." J. Phys. Chem 104 (2000): 1292-99.
Diephouse, Dan, Scott Dykstra, and Derek Ferwerda. Hot for Hydrogen. Grand Rapids,
MI: Calvin College, 2004.
Dreise, Manuel, Randall Elenbaas, and Eric Smith. Bond...H-Bond. Grand Rapids, MI:
Calvin College, 2004.
Egloff, Gustav. Production of Styrene listed in US Patent # 2,376,532; May 22, 1945.
Iezzi, Rodolfo; Bartolini, Andrea; Buonomo, Franco. Process for Activating Catalyst
Percursors for the Dehydrogenation of C2-C5 Paraffins, and a Catalytic
Composition Activated by the Process listed in US Patent # 5,414,182; May 9,
1995.
Ogunnaike, Babatunde A., and Harmon W. Ray. Process Dynamics, Modeling, and
Control. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994.
Seider, Warren D., J D. Seader, and Daniel R. Lewin. Product & Process Design
Principles. 2nd ed. New York City: Wiley, 2004
Stichlmair, Johann G., and James R. Fair. Distillation Principles and Practices. New
York: Wiley-VCH, 1998.
Styrene Producers Price Capacity. http://www.the-innovation-
group.com/ChemProfiles/Styrene.htm.
Wankat, Phillip C. Equilibrium Stated Separations. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice
Hall, 1988.
Wood, Andrew. "Celanese, Dow Revisit Catalytic Route from Ethane to Ethylene."
Chemical Week, 15 June 2005, 25.
Zhou, Ying; Cavis, Stephen M. Dehydrogenation Catalysts and Process for Preparing
the Catalysts listed in US Patent # 5,219,816; June 15, 1993.
Appendix Table of Contents
Appendix A: Equipment Spec. Sheets
A.1 Compressor Specifications
A.2 Heat Exchanger Specifications
A.3 Pump Specifications
A.4 Tank Specifications
A.5 Two Phase Separator Specifications
A.6 Turbine Specifications
A.7 Distillation Specifications
Appendix C: Separations
C.1 Separations Hand Calculations
C.2 Estimates of Column Height
C.3 Fenske Equation
C.4 Dimensioning of Packed Columns
C.5 MathCad Packed Column
C.6 Summary of All Columns
C.7 Optimization Reflux Ratio
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (97.0%), Water (2.5%)
Vapor Effluent 8477 kgmol/hr Trace: Carbon Dioxide
Water (100%)
Liquid Effluent 1904 kgmol/hr
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) 25.0 Temperature (C) 25.0
Pressure (kPa) 128.8 Pressure (kPa) 128.8
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 6.93
Diameter (m) 1.98
Material of Construction Carbon Steel
Volume (m3) 21.34
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (3 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-102 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Nitrogen (97.0%), Water (2.5%)
Vapor Feed 8477 kgmol/hr Trace: Carbon Dioxide
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (99.4%)
Vapor Effluent 8268 kgmol/hr Trace: Carbon Dioxide
Water (100%)
Liquid Effluent 208.5 kgmol/hr Trace: Carbon Dioxide
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -50.0 Temperature (C) -50.0
Pressure (kPa) 261.9 Pressure (kPa) 261.9
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 4.27
Diameter (m) 1.22
Material of Construction Carbon Steel
Volume (m3) 4.99
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (4 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-400 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Ethane (58.0 mol%), Nitrogen (23.7%), Hydrogen (12.0%),
Vapor Feed 19080 kgmol/hr Ethylene (6.3%)
Outlet Flows
Ethane (58.0 mol%), Nitrogen (23.7%), Hydrogen (12.0%),
Vapor Effluent 19080 kgmol/hr Ethylene (6.3%)
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -68.6 Temperature (C) -68.6
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 9.60
Diameter (m) 2.74
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 56.61
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (5 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-401 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Ethane (58.0 mol%), Nitrogen (23.7%), Hydrogen (12.0%),
Vapor Feed 19080 kgmol/hr Ethylene (6.3%)
Outlet Flows
Ethane (55.5 mol%), Nitrogen (25.2%), Hydrogen (12.8%),
Vapor Effluent 17920 kgmol/hr Ethylene (6.5%)
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -115.3 Temperature (C) -115.3
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 8.00
Diameter (m) 2.29
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 32.95
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (6 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-402 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Ethane (55.5 mol%), Nitrogen (25.2%), Hydrogen (12.8%),
Vapor Feed 17920 kgmol/hr Ethylene (6.5%)
Outlet Flows
Ethane (17.3 mol%), Nitrogen (46.8%), Hydrogen (23.7%),
Vapor Effluent 9642 kgmol/hr Ethylene 12.2%)
Ethane (100%)
Liquid Effluent 8281 kgmol/hr
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -116.0 Temperature (C) -116.0
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 9.60
Diameter (m) 2.74
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 56.61
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (7 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-403 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Ethane (17.3 mol%), Nitrogen (46.8%), Hydrogen (23.7%),
Vapor Feed 9642 kgmol/hr Ethylene 12.2%)
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (51.1%), Hydrogen (25.9%), Ethylene (13.3%)
Vapor Effluent 8831 kgmol/hr Ethane (9.7 mol%)
Ethane (100%)
Liquid Effluent 810.2 kgmol/hr
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -123.1 Temperature (C) -123.1
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 5.87
Diameter (m) 1.68
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 13.01
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (8 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-404 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Nitrogen (51.1%), Hydrogen (25.9%), Ethylene (13.3%)
Vapor Feed 8831 kgmol/hr Ethane (9.7%)
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (54.9%), Hydrogen (27.8%), Ethylene (13.0%)
Vapor Effluent 8222kgmol/hr Ethane (4.3%)
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -132.0 Temperature (C) -132.0
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 5.30
Diameter (m) 1.52
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 9.62
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (9 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-405 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Nitrogen (54.9%), Hydrogen (27.8%), Ethylene (13.0%)
Vapor Feed 8222kgmol/hr Ethane (4.3%)
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (58.7%), Hydrogen (29.7%), Ethylene (8.8%)
Vapor Effluent 7697 kgmol/hr Ethane (2.8%)
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -136.2 Temperature (C) -136.2
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 5.33
Diameter (m) 1.52
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 9.67
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (10 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-406 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Nitrogen (58.7%), Hydrogen (29.7%), Ethylene (8.8%)
Vapor Feed 7697 kgmol/hr Ethane (2.8%)
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (61.8%), Hydrogen (31.3%), Ethylene (5.3%)
Vapor Effluent 7304 kgmol/hr Ethane (1.6%)
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -141.4 Temperature (C) -141.4
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 4.80
Diameter (m) 1.37
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 7.08
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (11 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-407 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Nitrogen (61.8%), Hydrogen (31.3%), Ethylene (5.3%)
Vapor Feed 7304 kgmol/hr Ethane (1.6%)
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (64.2%), Hydrogen (32.5%), Ethylene (2.6%)
Vapor Effluent 7038 kgmol/hr Trace: Ethane
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -147.9 Temperature (C) -147.9
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 4.80
Diameter (m) 1.37
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 7.08
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (12 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-408 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Nitrogen (64.2%), Hydrogen (32.5%), Ethylene (2.6%)
Vapor Feed 7038 kgmol/hr Trace: Ethane
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (65.6%), Hydrogen (33.2%)
Vapor Effluent 6890 kgmol/hr Trace: Ethylene, Ethane
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -155.6 Temperature (C) -155.6
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 4.80
Diameter (m) 1.37
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 7.08
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.5: Two Phase Separator Specifications (13 of 13)
Two-Phase Separator Specifications
ID Number: V-409 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Two-Phase Separator Prepared By: LJB
No. Required 1 Checked By: MJH
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Nitrogen (65.6%), Hydrogen (33.2%)
Vapor Feed 6890 kgmol/hr Trace: Ethylene, Ethane
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (66.1%), Hydrogen (33.5%)
Vapor Effluent 6832 kgmol/hr Trace: Ethylene, Ethane
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) -163.4 Temperature (C) -163.4
Pressure (kPa) 101.3 Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Data
Type Two Phase Separator
Position Vertical
Height (m) 4.27
Diameter (m) 1.22
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 4.99
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.6: Turbine Specifications (1 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-400 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 1st Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 497960
58.04% Ethane
23.67% Nitrogen
Vapor Composition (mol%) 11.99% Hydrogen
6.30% Ethylene
Trace Amounts Heavies
Inlet Temperature (C) -47.5
Outlet Temperature (C) -68.63
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 173.5
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 549770
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 4739
A.6: Turbine Specifications (2 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-401 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 2nd Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 497920
58.04% Ethane
23.67% Nitrogen
Vapor Composition (mol%) 11.99% Hydrogen
6.30% Ethylene
Trace Amounts Heavies
Inlet Temperature (C) -25.4
Outlet Temperature (C) -115.3
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 3000.0
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 549740
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 25280
A.6: Turbine Specifications (3 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-402 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 3rd Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 463070
55.50% Ethane
Vapor Composition (mol%) 25.20% Nitrogen
12.77% Hydrogen
6.54% Ethylene
Inlet Temperature (C) -15.7
Outlet Temperature (C) -100.3
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 3000.0
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 511190
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 24900
A.6: Turbine Specifications (4 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-403 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 4th Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 214070
17.27% Ethane
56.84% Nitrogen
Vapor Composition (mol%) 23.74% Hydrogen
12.15% Ethylene
Inlet Temperature (C) -50.0
Outlet Temperature (C) -123.1
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 3000
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 237330
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 10820
A.6: Turbine Specifications (5 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-404 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 5th Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 189700
9.68% Ethane
51.14% Nitrogen
Vapor Composition (mol%) 25.91% Hydrogen
13.26% Ethylene
Inlet Temperature (C) -50.0
Outlet Temperature (C) -132.0
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 3000
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 210370
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 9811
A.6: Turbine Specifications (6 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-405 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 6th Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 171600
4.28% Ethane
54.93% Nitrogen
Vapor Composition (mol%) 27.83% Hydrogen
12.96% Ethylene
Inlet Temperature (C) -50.0
Outlet Temperature (C) -136.2
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 3000
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 190400
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 8963
A.6: Turbine Specifications (7 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-406 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 7th Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 156600
2.80% Ethane
58.67% Nitrogen
Vapor Composition (mol%) 29.73% Hydrogen
8.80% Ethylene
Inlet Temperature (C) -50.0
Outlet Temperature (C) -141.4
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 3000
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 173860
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 8209
A.6: Turbine Specifications (8 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-407 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 8th Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 145370
1.59% Ethane
61.83% Nitrogen
Vapor Composition (mol%) 31.33% Hydrogen
5.25% Ethylene
Inlet Temperature (C) -50.0
Outlet Temperature (C) -147.9
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 3000
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 161500
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 7634
A.6: Turbine Specifications (9 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-408 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 9th Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 137780
0.74% Ethane
64.17% Nitrogen
Vapor Composition (mol%) 32.52% Hydrogen
2.58% Ethylene
Inlet Temperature (C) -50.0
Outlet Temperature (C) -155.6
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 3000
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 153180
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 7276
A.6: Turbine Specifications (10 of 10)
Turbine Specifications
ID Number: M-409 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: 10th Turbine Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 1 Checked By: LJB
Fluid Properties
Process Feed Flow Rate (kg/hr) 133540
0.26% Ethane
65.55% Nitrogen
Vapor Composition (mol%) 33.22% Hydrogen
0.97% Ethylene
Inlet Temperature (C) -50.0
Outlet Temperature (C) -163.4
Inlet Pressure (kPa) 3000
Outlet Pressure (kPa) 101.3
Design Specifications
Expander Type Centrifugal
Orientation Horizontal
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Design Capacity (kg/hr) 148560
Adiabatic Efficiency 85
Power Output (kW) 7136
A.7: Distillation Specifications (1 of 8)
Distillation Specifications
ID Number: T-300 Date: 5/11/2006
Description: Toluene/Ethylbenzene Distillation Column Prepared By: MSB
No. Required 1 Checked By: ACJ
Function
Feed Fluid
Operating Conditions
Feed Distillate Bottoms
Flow Rate (kg/hr) 236400 7924 228500
Vapor Fraction 0 1 0
Outlet Flows
Nitrogen (79.2 mol%), Water (20.4%)
Vapor Effluent 10380 kgmol/hr Trace: Carbon Dioxide
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) 554.7 Temperature (C) 712.6
Pressure (kPa) 134.3 Pressure (kPa) 134.3
Design Data
Type Regenerator
Position Vertical
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 220.4
Tube Diameter (m) 1.4
Tube Length (m) 14.2
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
A.8: Reactor Specifications (3 of 4)
Reactor Specifications
ID Number: R-200 Date: 5/8/2006
Description: Alkylation Reactor Prepared By: MJH
No. Required 4 Checked By:
Process Stream Conditions
Inlet Flows
Ethane (83.5 mol%), Benzene (7.6%), Ethylene (8.9%)
Vapor Feed 31144 kgmol/hr Trace: n-Hexane, Toluene, Ethylbenzene, Nitrogen
Outlet Flows
Ethane (99.99 mol%)
Vapor Effluent 11060 kgmol/hr Trace: n-Hexane, Nitrogen, Ethylene
Outlet Flows
Diethylbenzene (23.4 mol%), n-Butylbenzene (2.1%)
Liquid Effluent 441 kgmol/hr Ethylbenzene (74.4%)
Trace: Cumene, Toluene, Polyalkylates
Operating Conditions
Inlet Exit
Temperature (C) 121.4 Temperature (C) 155.6
Pressure (kPa) 135.8 Pressure (kPa) 135.8
Design Data
Type Packed Bed
Position Vertical
Material of Construction Stainless Steel
Volume (m3) 17
Void Volume (m3) 0.75
Packed Volume (m3) 0.25
Tube Diameter (m) 1.1
Tube Length (m) 19.1
Additional Equipment
Heat Exchange Required? N Agitation Required? N
Appendix B: PFD / PID / Layout
B.1 PFD: Alkylation Unit Area 100
110
113/ Byproducts
Ethylene and Ethane 105/ 324 To Separations
From L.G. Separations 452 119
E-100
118
1
106
116
12 112
R-100 49 111
R-101
T-100
109
115
102
101 103
100
Benzene Feed
P-100
B.2 PFD: Dehydrogenation Unit Area 200
Hydrogen and Nitrogen 213/
From L.G. Separations 455
216 217
E-207
208 209
E-208
Air Feed K-201
230
215
218
210 214
R-200
E-206
R-
201
207
219
212
E-201
206
E-203
231
K-200 211
236/ Light Gas
K-200 401 To L.G.Separations
PFD pg. 6
205
232 233 234 V-202
E-204 E-205
235/ Products
E-200 301 To Separations
PFD pg. 6
204
K-202 221
Ethylbenzene 203/ 226
316
V-201
From Separations K-202
Water treatment
inerts 311
Incinerated
T-302
Steam
308
Benzene
327
To Alkylation
Light Gases 312
Vented inerts
306
P-302
T-301
Steam
Toluene For
310
309 Sale
307
P-301
Products 235/
From Dehydrogenation 301
303 304 305
T-300
Steam
E-300
inerts
Products 453/
From L.G. Separations 302
313
203/ Ethylbenzene
314
316 To Dehydrogenation
K-303
T-303
Steam
Styrene Finish
315
To Separations pg. 2
B.4 PFD: Separations Unit Area 300b
inerts
329
Styrene
E-301 P-303
E-302 to Customer
inerts
and Storage
P-1017
FC 319
inerts
321
Steam
318
T-305
P-1019
Steam
320 T-306
Steam
322
415 416 417 418 V-403 420 421 422 423 V-404 425 426 427 428 V-405
430 431 432 433 V-406 435 436 437 438 V-407 440 441 442 443 V-408
449
To Treatment
453/ Products
302 To Separations
B.6 PFD: PFD pg. 6 Compressor Chains
Dehydrogenation L.G. Separations
K-200 K-403
L.G. Separations
K-407
L.G. Separations
K-402
435. 435. 435. 435.
435 436
1 2 3 4
409. 409. 409. 409.
409 K-407.1 E-407.1 K-407.2 E-407.2 K-407.3
1 2 3 4
L.G. Separations
409. 409. 409. 409. K-408
5 6 7 8
402.5
L.G. Separations
K-409
FC
114/ Ethylbenzene and Ethane
108
202 To Dehydrogenation
110
LC
V-93
113/ Byproducts
Ethylene and Ethane 105/ 324 To Separations
From L.G. Separations 452 119
E-100
118
1
106
116
12 112
FC
R-100 49 111
R-101
T-100
LC
109
115
FC
102
101 103
100
Benzene Feed FC
P-100
B.8 P&ID: Dehydrogenation Unit Area 200
Hydrogen and Nitrogen 213/
From L.G. Separations 455
TC TC
FC PC
216 217
E-207
208 209
E-208
Air Feed K-201
230
215
218
210 214 TC
R-200
E-206
R-
201
207
FC
219
212
E-201
206
TC E-203
231
K-200 211
236/ Light Gas
K-200 401
TC
To L.G.Separations
P&ID pg. 6 TC
205
E-204
232 233 234
E-205
TC E-200 226
235/ Products
301 To Separations
P&ID pg. 6
204
K-202 221
Ethylbenzene 203/
FC
From Separations 316 K-202
Water treatment
E-202
TC
FC
Ethane Feed
227 Purge
B.9 P&ID: Separations Unit Area 300a inerts
LC
PC
inerts 311
FC Incinerated
T-302
TC FC
Steam
308
LC
LC
PC Benzene
327
To Alkylation
Light Gases 312
Vented inerts FC
306
P-302
T-301
TC FC
Steam
LC
LC
Toluene For
310
PC Sale
309
307
FC
FC P-301
Products 235/
From Dehydrogenation 301
303 304 305
T-300
TC FC Steam
E-300
inerts
Products 453/ LC
From L.G. Separations 302
LC
313
PC
203/ Ethylbenzene
314
316 To Dehydrogenation
FC
K-303
T-303
TC
FC
Steam
LC
Styrene Finish
315
To Separations pg. 2
B.10 P&ID: Separations Unit Area 300b
inerts
FC
329
E-301 E-181
E-101
inerts
LC
PC FC 319
inerts
321
Steam
FC
LC 318
T-305 TC LC
FC
PC
Steam
FC
LC 320 T-306 TC
FC
Steam
LC
322
410 414
415 416 417 418 420 421 422 423 425 426 427 428
430 431 432 433 435 436 437 438 440 441 442 443
449
To Treatment
453/ Products
302 To Separations
B.12 P&ID: P&ID pg. 6 Compressor Chains
Dehydrogenation L.G. Separations Controls for each Compressor and
K-200 K-403 Heat Exchanger in the Process F
L.G. Separations
K-407
L.G. Separations
K-402
435. 435. 435. 435.
435 436
1 2 3 4
409. 409. 409. 409.
409 K-407.1 E-407.1 K-407.2 E-407.2 K-407.3
1 2 3 4
L.G. Separations
409. 409. 409. 409. K-408
5 6 7 8
402.5
L.G. Separations
K-409
3.59m.
3.80m. 3.80m. T-303
T-305
Dehydrogenation
Dehydro Dehydrogenation
2.12m.
T-300
0.80m.
T-301 3.64m.
3.80m. 3.80m.
5.61m. T-306
0.34m.
T-
Dehydrogenation Dehydrogenation
30 T-304
2
AREA 200 --
DEHYDROGENATION
1.90m. 1.90m. 1.90m. 1.90m.
V-406
V-405 V-404
3.55m.
10.00m.
10.00m.
10.00m.
T-300
Dehydro Dehydro
Tr Tr Tr Tr
a a a a
n n n n
s s s s
10.00m.
Al Al Alkylation
Al Al
k k Tower k k
yl yl
T-304 yl yl
T
at at at at
-
or or or or
3
0
2Alkyl Alkyl Alkyl Alkyl
ator ator ator ator
T-306
T
-
3
0
10.00m.
1
V-400 V-402
V-401
V- V- V- V-
V- V- V-
40 4040 403
40 40 40
6 7 5 8 4 9
Appendix C: Separations
C.1: Separations Hand Calculations (1 of 3)
Calculations for Column Diameter in Separations Unit : Tray Column T-300 Bottom of Column
3
atm ft
P := 0.2631 atm R := 1.314 lbmol K T := 368.69 K
lb lb
MWv := 85.187 MWl := 105.15 3
lbmol lbmol v := 7.3254 10 cP
2 lb lb
v := 5.1336 10 l := 51.077 NumberOfTrays := 66
3 3
ft ft
Wl := L MWl
Wv := V MWv
Wl
= 28.833
Wv
0.5
Wl v
Flv :=
Wv l
Flv = 0.914
From Wankat equation 12-10e for 24-in tray spacing
2
logCsb := .94506 0.70234 log( Flv) 0.22618 ( log ( Flv) )
Finding Csb:
logCsb
Csb := 10
Csb = 0.121
0.2
K := Csb
20
K = 0.123
v = 0.051
l = 51.077
0.5
l v
uflood := K
v
uflood = 3.878
fraction := 0.75
uop := ( fraction ) uflood
uop = 2.909
0.5
( 4 V MWv)
Dia := ( )
v fraction uflood 3600
Dia = 6.6 ft
Diameter := Dia
30.48
100
Diameter = 2.012 m
C.1: Separations Hand Calculations (2 of 3)
Calculations for Column Diameter in Separations Unit : Tray Column T-300 Middle of Column
3
atm ft
P := 0.2631 atm R := 1.314 lbmol K T := 363.45 K
lb lb
MWv := 85.187 MWl := 105.15 3
lbmol lbmol v := 7.3254 10 cP
2 lb lb
v := 5.1336 10 l := 51.077 NumberOfTrays := 66
3 3
ft ft
Wl := L MWl
Wv := V MWv
Wl
= 28.833
Wv
0.5
Wl v
Flv := Wv
l
Flv = 0.914
From Wankat equation 12-10e for 24-in tray spacing
2
logCsb := .94506 0.70234 log( Flv) 0.22618 ( log ( Flv) )
Finding Csb:
logCsb
Csb := 10
Csb = 0.121
0.2
K := Csb
20
K = 0.123
v = 0.051
l = 51.077
0.5
uflood := K
l v
v
uflood = 3.878
fraction := 0.75
uop := ( fraction ) uflood
uop = 2.909
0.5
( 4 V MWv)
Dia := ( )
v fraction uflood 3600
Dia = 6.6 ft
Diameter := Dia
30.48
100
Diameter = 2.012 m
C.1: Separations Hand Calculations (3 of 3)
Calculations for Column Diameter in Separations Unit : Tray Column T-300 Top of Column
3
atm ft
P := 0.2631 atm R := 1.314 lbmol K T := 332.23 K
lb lb
MWv := 85.187 MWl := 105.15 3
lbmol lbmol v := 7.3254 10 cP
2 lb lb
v := 5.1336 10 l := 51.077 NumberOfTrays := 66
3 3
ft ft
Wl := L MWl
Wv := V MWv
Wl
= 28.833
Wv
0.5
Wl v
Flv :=
Wv l
Flv = 0.914
From Wankat equation 12-10e for 24-in tray spacing
2
logCsb := .94506 0.70234 log( Flv) 0.22618 ( log ( Flv) )
Finding Csb:
logCsb
Csb := 10
Csb = 0.121
0.2
K := Csb
20
K = 0.123
v = 0.051
l = 51.077
0.5
uflood := K
l v
v
uflood = 3.878
fraction := 0.75
uop := ( fraction ) uflood
uop = 2.909
0.5
( 4 V MWv)
Dia := ( )
v fraction uflood 3600
Dia = 6.6 ft
Diameter := Dia
30.48
100
Diameter = 2.012 m
C.2: Estimates of Column Height (1 of 3)
Separations Unit at 100% Capacity
T-304 T-306
T-305
T-101
Column Diameter
Top 3.55 m 11.65 ft
C.3: Fenske Equation (1 of 3)
Hand Calculations for Minimum Reflux using Fenske's equation
Styrene/Cumene Split
By Products MW Bp K alpha Mol fraction
Hydrogen 2.02 -252.6 8.72E+03 0.0000
Nitrogen 28.01 -195.8 4.31E+03 2.02 0.0000
Ethylene 28.05 -103.75 3.11E+02 13.84 0.0000
Ethane 30.07 -88.6 2.46E+02 1.27 0.0000
n-Hexane 86.18 68.73 1.18E+00 207.78 0.0000
Benzene 78.11 80.09 7.85E-01 1.51 0.0000
Toluene 92.14 110.65 2.70E-01 2.91 0.0000
Ethylbenzene 106.17 136.2 1.01E-01 2.67 0.0000
Styrene 104.15 145.16 6.86E-02 1.47 0.9800
cumene 120.19 152.41 4.39E-02 1.56 0.0028
n-p-benzene 120.19 159.24 8.49E-03 5.17 0.0005
1M3-EBenzene 120.19 161.33 3.52E-02 0.24 0.0057
-methylstyrene 118.18 165.5 2.70E-02 1.31 0.0078
m-DiEBenzene 134.22 181.14 1.30E-02 2.07 0.0000
n-Butyl-Benzene 134.22 183.3 0.0099538 1.309709 0.0037
T-306
EBC 2.30 Distillate
EBS 1.47 Bottoms
SS 1.00
CS 0.64
zEB 0.000
zC 0.003
zS 0.98
FRA,dist 0.9983
FRB,dist 0.9983
Nmin 28
FRC,dist 1.00
C.4: Dimensioning of Packed Columns (1 of 2)
Values used in Calculation the Diameter of the Packed Column
At 100% Capacity
T-300 T-303
Molar Mass: Liquid Vapor Molar Mass: Liquid Vapor
Molar Mass (kg/kgmole) 105.15 85.19 Molar Mass (kg/kgmole) 104.18 106.11
Viscosity Viscosity
cP 0.30367 0.007325 cP 0.41967 0.0063562
kg/m*s 3.04E-04 7.33E-06 kg/m*s 4.20E-04 6.3562E-06
Flows Flows
kmol/h 2421 102.8 kmol/h 1199 1222
kmol/s 0.6725 0.0286 kmol/s 0.3331 0.3394
T-304 T-305
Molar Mass: Liquid Vapor Molar Mass: Liquid Vapor
Molar Mass (kg/kgmole) 104.23 104.16 Molar Mass (kg/kgmole) 104.51 104.16
Viscosity Viscosity
cP 0.46345 0.006295 cP 0.46407 0.0062951
kg/m*s 4.63E-04 6.30E-06 kg/m*s 4.64E-04 6.30E-06
Flows Flows
kmol/h 360.7 838.3 kmol/h 73.27 287.4
kmol/s 0.100194 0.23286 kmol/s 0.02035 0.07983
C.4: Dimensioning of Packed Columns (2 of 2)
T-306
Molar Mass: Liquid Vapor
Molar Mass (kg/kgmole) 119.68 104.16
Surface tension
dyne/cm 23.651
kg/s2 0.023651
Viscosity
cP 0.47297 0.006295
kg/m*s 4.73E-04 6.30E-06
Flows
kmol/h 1.634 71.64
kmol/s 0.000454 0.0199
C.5: Dimensioning a Packed Column
Taken from Fair, J. and Stichlmair, J. p. 457
Liquid Phase Gas Phase
kg
kg
Molar Mass Ml := 105.15 kmol
Mg := 85.19 kmol
kg
kg
Density l := 818.17 3
m g := 0.82233 3
m
kg
Surface Tension := 0.021913
2
s
4 kg
l := 3.04 10 6 kg
Viscosity m s g := 7.33 10
m s
kmol Liqflow := 0.6725 kmol
Gasflow := 0.0286
s s
0.5
Flow := 2.0 Pa
Flow
ug :=
(g0.5)
m
ug = 2.205 s
Mg
Vg := Gasflow
g
3
m
Vg = 2.963
s
Cross section Ac
Vg
Ac :=
ug
2
Ac = 1.343 m
0.5
Ac
Dc := 4
Dc = 1.308 m
C.6: Summary of All Columns in the Process
Separations Unit
Column Height (m) Column Diameter (m) Packing Height (m) Packing Diameter (m)
T-300 40.23 2.12 11.58 1.31
T-301 14.02 0.80
T-302 24.38 0.34
T-303 43.89 5.63 12.19 6.38
T-304 27.43 5.61 19.51 5.88
T-305 18.29 3.59 19.51 3.44
T-306 18.29 3.64 17.07 1.72
Alkylation Unit
Column Height (m) Column Diameter (m)
T-101 29.87 3.55
HETP assumed as 2 ft
C.7: Optimization Reflux Ratio (1 of 6)
The amount of EB recovered is not a specification in this optimization due to the degrees of freedom restriction on the distillation columns
1.2E+08
0.1400
8.0E+07 0.1000
0.0800
6.0E+07
0.0600
4.0E+07
0.0400
2.0E+07
0.0200
0.0E+00 0.0000
3 5 10 15 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Reflux Ratio Reflux Ratio
1.6E+08 0.6700
0.6400
1.0E+08
0.6300
8.0E+07 0.6200
6.0E+07 0.6100
0.6000
4.0E+07
0.5900
2.0E+07
0.5800
0.0E+00
0.5700
3 5 10 15 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Reflux Ratio Reflux Ratio
C.7: Optimization Reflux Ratio (3 of 6)
The amount of toluene recovered is not a specification in this optimization due to the degrees of freedom restriction on the distillation columns
Column 100 Figure 1A: Optimization of Reflux Ratio Figure 2A: Optimization of Reflux Ratio
Optimal Reflux Comp Recovery of Toluene = 0.9999 Comp Recovery of EB = 0.9999
Pressure(kPa) 26.66 1.20E+08 3.50E+08
Condenser Temp (deg C) 51.90
Reboiler Temp (deg C) 96.27 3.00E+08
Comp Recovery of Ethylbenzene 0.9999 1.00E+08
Reflux Ratio 12
2.50E+08
Total Trays w/o C & R 67
40
Vessel Parameters
Vessel Reboiler Condenser 0.0000
30
Diameter (m) 1.193 1.193
Height(m) 1.789 1.789
3 0.0000
Volume(m ) 2.000 2.000 20
Liq Vol. (%) 50.000 50.000
Level Calculator Horizontal cylinder Horizontal cylinder
10 0.0000
Fraction Calculator Use levels and nozzles Use levels and nozzles
Vessel Delta P (kPa) 0.00 0.00
Fixed Vessel P Spec. (kPa) 26.66 26.66 0 0.0000
Tray Section 3 5 10 12 15 20 30 40 50 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Diameter (m) 1.500 Reflux Ratio Reflux Ratio
Tray/Packed Space (m) 0.550
Tray/Packed Vol.(m3) 0.972
Hold up (m3) 0.088
C.7: Optimization Reflux Ratio (5 of 6)
General Trends:
Reflux Ratio Solved by HYSYS
As the number of columns decreases the duty on the condenser and reboiler increases
As the number of columns decreases the mol fraction of ethyl benzene exiting in the distillate increases
As the number of columns decreases the purity of styrene increases because of the amount of ethyl benzene exiting in the distillate,
but there is a point where you start getting less purity of styrene.
$15,000,000.00
$14,500,000.00
$14,000,000.00
Cost Annually
$13,500,000.00
$13,000,000.00
$12,500,000.00
$12,000,000.00
$11,500,000.00
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
# Compressors
D.3: Compressor Hand Calculation Example
Assume polytropic behavior that approaches adiabatic (Perry's page 10-37)
( k 1) / k
p
T2 = T1 2 (10-67)
p1
3 mol
M := 13841 10
hr
T2 := ( 273.15 + 122.03)K T1 := ( 273.15 + 86.93)K
3 3
p 2 := 263.38 10 Pa p 1 := 135.78 10 Pa
5 kg G
G := 5.8282 10 M W :=
hr M
R c := 8.314
J 1
k := 1.1204
mol K M W
( k 1)
k
k R c T1 p 2
Had := 1 (10-64a)
k1
p 1
4
Had = 4.882 10 Sv
6
Pad = 7.904 10 W
Appendix E: Heat Exchanger Design
E.1: Example Pressure Drop Calculation (1 of 2)
Tube Side Pressure Estimation of E-1000
From "Plant Design and Economics for Chemical Engineers" Pg. 667
Tube Diameter: Mass Flow: Visocity (At Bulk and Wall):
kg
Di := .15 m M t := 519200
hr := .00956 poise
Totherin := ( 60 + 273.15) K
Length:
Length := 6 m Constants:
Density: n p := 2 Kc := 0.3 S := 0.5
kg
:= 2.224 kg m
3 kconstant := 0.000163
m 4
s A
Equations:
2 Mt
Ac := Di G :=
Ac NP
2 (
0.5 n p 1 ) Di G Cp
k := ( 1 S) + Kc + Re := Pr :=
np kconstant
Tin + Tout .2
Taverage := f := 0.046 Re
2
T1 := Totherin Taverage 0.28
0.51 k n p T1
w
0.14 B := 1 +
:= 1.02
2
w (Tout Tin) Pr
3
2 B f G2 Length n
P :=
p
Di
P = 80.234 Pa
E.1: Example Pressure Drop Calculation (2 of 2)
Shell Side Pressure Drop Estimation E-100 Coolant
From "Plant Design and Economics for Chemical Engineers" Pg. 706-707
Known:
kg
M t := 1435000
hr := .41330 poise
kg
:= 1465 w := .4251 poise
3
m
Ds := 2.5 m Pd := 0.1 m
Lb := 3 m
Ls := 6 m
Pt := 0.2 m f := 0.025
t b := 0.1 m
Do := 0.1 m
Equations:
Ds Pd Lb Mt
Sm := Gs :=
Pt Sm
4 0.86 Pt 0.25 Do
2 2 Ls
De :=
Nb := 1
Lb + t b
Do
De Gs
Re :=
4 f G 2 D ( 1 + N )
P :=
s s b
0.14
2 De
w
P = 5.542 Pa
E.2: Styrene Tank Heat Exchanger Size
Twin := 283.15K Two := 293.15K
xsteel := 0.075m
h := 36m D := 20m
2
A := D h +
D 3 2
A = 2.576 10 m
2
q 2
A := A = 274.11 m
Uhe Tlm
Appendix F: Reactor Sizing
F.1: Dehydrogenation Reactor Size
1 Time := 8000 hr
GHSV := 225 hr
mole
Molar_Flow := 19158000
hr
3
Molar_Flow m
Vol_Flow := Vol_Flow = 110.223
mole s
48.281
3
m
Vol_Flow
Vol :=
GHSV
3 3
Vol = 1.764 10 m
Numreactors := 4
Vol
Vol reactor :=
Numreactors
3
Vol reactor = 440.891 m
Appendix G: Economic Optimization
G.1: Investment Summary
Styrene Monomer Production Process
TOTAL
Direct Costs
Purchased Equipment Costs: $384.6
Delivery Costs: $38.5
Installation Costs: $198.8
Instrumentation & Controls: $152.3
Piping: $287.7
Electrical Systems: $46.5
Buildings: $76.2
Yard Improvements: $42.3
Service Facilities: $296.1
Total Direct Costs: $1,523.0
Utilties
High Pressure Steam $0.006 per lb of Styrene $12.1
Low Pressure Steam $0.000 per lb of Styrene $0.8
Cooling Water $0.003 per lb of Styrene $6.8
Refrigeration $0.040 per lb of Styrene $79.5
Electricity $0.044 per lb of Styrene $87.7
Waste Treatment $0.005 per lb of Styrene $11.0
Total Utilities: $0.0100 per lb of Styrene $197.8 $197.8
General Expenses
Operating Labor $0.001 per lb of Styrene $2.7
Operating Supervision $0.000 per lb of Styrene $0.4
Maintainance/Repairs $0.066 per lb of Styrene $131.4
Operating Supplies $0.010 per lb of Styrene $19.7
Laboratory Charges $0.000 per lb of Styrene $0.4
Total Byproducts: $0.078 per lb of Styrene $154.6 $154.6
The Investor's Rate of Return (IRR) for this Project is: 15.0%
The Net Present Value (NPV) at 15% for this Project is: $1.99
Product Prices
Product Prices ($/lb) $0.75 $0.80 $0.85 $0.90 $0.95 $0.99 $1.05 $1.10 $1.15 $1.20 $1.25 $1.30 $1.35
Product Prices ($/kg) $1.65 $1.76 $1.87 $1.98 $2.09 $2.17 $2.31 $2.43 $2.54 $2.65 $2.76 $2.87 $2.98
IRR -0.8% 3.6% 7.2% 10.4% 13.2% 15.0% 18.2% 20.4% 22.4% 24.2% 26.1% 27.8% 29.5%
35.0%
30.0%
25.0%
IRR 20.0%
15.0%
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
$0.70
-5.0% $0.80 $0.90 $1.00 $1.10 $1.20 $1.30 $1.40
Styrene Monomer Product Price ($/lb)