Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hume: Tis an establisd maxim in metaphysics That whatever the mind clearly conceives
includes the idea of possible existence, or in other words, that nothing we imagine is absolutely
impossible.
Samuel Clarke, accepted this maxim (What is conceivable, is possible) as did Richard Price, and
Christian Wolff, but they also accepted the principle that What is inconceivable, is impossible.
Humes maxim: if you can depict to yourself a consistent and coherent scenario in which
a certain proposition P is true, then you may infer that P is possible in the metaphysical
sense of possible.
The passage suggests that Reid reasons as follows: I cannot conceive how certain tactile
sensations convey the notion of extension, therefore It is impossible that those sensations
convey the notion of extension. This is the Maxim applied!
R.van.Woudenberg@vu.nl