Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The T graft is constructed by anastomosing the proximal Ejection fraction ranged from 0.20 to 0.70. Operative
end of the free right internal thoracic artery to the side of mortality was 1.7%.Twenty-six patients had postopera-
the attached left internal thoracic artery. Besides adding tive graft visualization, and 94.7% of the grafts were
considerable reach to the right internal thoracic artery, open. All 45 bypass grafts from the left internal thoracic
this technique allows the left anterior descending coro- artery were patent, and 91% of those from the right
nary artery and its branches to be bypassed with the internal thoracic artery were unobstructed. This proce-
attached left internal thoracic artery. Two hundred dure requires technical skill with internal thoracic arter-
eighty-seven patients, aged 34 to 86 years (mean age, 64.6 ies, but it has the potential of significantly improving
years) received an average of 4.4 internal thoracic artery long-term event-free survival and reducing the need for
to coronary artery anastomoses. Sixty-nine patients had reoperation in patients undergoing coronary artery by-
left main disease, 33 were undergoing first-time reoper- pass grafting.
ations, and two were reoperated on for the second time. (Ann Thorac Surg 1994;57:33-9)
A B C
Fig 1 . Technique of T-graft anastomosis. A 1 cm parallel incision is made into the attached left internal thoracic artery (LITA). The proximal end
of the detached right internal thoracic artery (RITA) is anastomosed to the side of the LITA with a continuous suture. (A) The anterior surface is
sutured first. The RITA is then turned over and lifted out of the chest, and (B) the posterior row is completed. (C) Completed amstornosis.
anterior wall of the ITA when making the arteriotomy. use perpendicular side-to-side anastomoses because they
The anastomosis is constructed with a continuous 8-0 are at risk of narrowing. Because native arteries do not
monofilament suture (Fig 1).The edges of the pedicles are run in a perfectly straight course, gentle curves are made
sutured together to prevent twisting at the anastomotic in the ITAs between each anastomosis. Terminal end-to-
site. The clamp is removed, and the LITA and RITA are side anastomoses are constructed either parallel or per-
checked for adequacy of flow and pulse. If the flow is pendicular to the coronary artery. The ITA pedicle is
questionable or the pulse is diminished in the RITA, the attached to the epicardium with sutures to prevent twist-
anastomosis should be taken down and redone because it ing or kinking.
is likely narrowed. The LITA pedicle is attached to the The causes of each operative death and major compli-
epicardium near the LAD. This makes it easy to measure cations are reported below. Postoperative infarctions were
the appropriate length of graft needed to reach the first diagnosed by electrocardiographic changes or myocardial
coronary artery or branch to be bypassed with the RITA enzyme level elevation. One hundred seven patients had
and LITA. postoperative stress tests, and 26 patients underwent
postoperative catheterization with ITA visualization on
CONSTRUCTION OF INTERNAL THORACIC ARTERY TO CORO- angiography. Data are expressed as the mean standard *
NARY ARTERY ANASTOMOSES. The ascending aorta or aortic deviation where applicable.
arch is cannulated. A two-staged venous cannula is intro-
duced into the right atrium, and a coronary sinus catheter
is placed for retrograde perfusion of cardioplegia. A
Results
13-gauge needle is inserted into the ascending aorta for Five patients (1.7%)died within the first 30 days after the
venting and infusion of antegrade blood cardioplegia. procedure. Three patients had cerebrovascular accidents:
Cardiopulmonary bypass and ischemic cardiac arrest are 1 patient had basilar artery insufficiency; 1 patient had
used. The myocardium is protected with antegrade and embolization to the brain, kidneys, and lower extremity;
retrograde cardioplegia as has been described by Buck- and 1 patient fully awakened and had a massive stroke 12
bergs group [21]. Cold blood induction cardioplegia is hours later.
administered antegrade and retrograde, then cold main- Two patients died of cardiac-related causes. One pa-
tenance blood cardioplegia is infused every 15 to 20 tient had low cardiac output and cardiac arrest in the
minutes, or if cardiac activity occurs. Warm blood sub- intensive care unit. He was returned to the operating
strate-enriched cardioplegia is given antegrade and retro- room, and a saphenous vein graft (SVG) was anasto-
grade after completion of the last anastomosis. mosed to the acute marginal and the posterior descending
The ITA coronary anastomoses are constructed with 8-0 branches of the right coronary artery. Right ventricular
monofilament suture while the patient is on cardiopulmo- failure developed, and the patient could not be weaned
nary bypass during ischemic arrest after infusion of cold from cardiopulmonary bypass. The other patient was
blood cardioplegia. Details of the technique are described stable postoperatively for 8 hours and was not receiving
elsewhere [lo]. The side-to-side anastomoses are only any inotropic support. He had a sudden cardiac arrest and
c o n s t i ~ ~ t eparallel
d to the coronary artery. We no longer was returned immediately to the operating room and
36 TECTOR ET AL A n n Thorac Surg
TOTAL ITA REVASCULARIZATION 1994;5733-9
when both ITAs are dissected from the chest wall, are the
two main drawbacks of the procedure. Proximal injury to
the LITA can impair flow and be life threatening, as
occurred in 1 of the patients who died. If the left subcla-
vian artery is known to be obstructed at the time of
operation, the LITA can be detached and anastomosed to
the attached RITA as a T graft. If later atherosclerosis
causes obstruction of the left subclavian artery, a left
carotid-subclavian artery bypass, axillary-axillary artery
bypass, endarterectomy, or subclavian angioplasty can be
performed. In one instance, we detached the LITA and
anastomosed it to the ascending aorta. A bypass graft can
also be interposed between the ascending aorta and the
LITA.
The incidence of sternal infection was somewhat higher
in this group of patients, particularly in the patients with
diabetes. Mobilization of the ITA devascularizes the ster-
nal side from which it is dissected [26]. Strict adherence to
sterile technique, careful opening of the sternum in the
middle, tight secure approximation of the sternum with
many sutures, and elimination of dead space when clos-
ing the fascia are measures that will most likely assist in
Fig 3. Postoperative study of left internal thoracic artery graft placed reducing infections in the diabetic patients.
21 years ago by us. We have noticed inadequate perfusion by ITA grafts on
rare occasions through the years. Often this can be
detected, before or just after coming off cardiopulmonary
associates [22] reported that only 14% of patients studied bypass, by electrocardiographic changes or new wall
5 years after revascularization demonstrated progression motion abnormalities on the transesophageal echocardio-
of atherosclerosis or new atherosclerosis in their coronary gram. Immediate placement of an SVG to the area sus-
arteries distal to the anastomoses. Furthermore, bypass- pected of insufficient perfusion is usually the only mea-
ing just the LAD with the attached LITA and using SVGs sure that corrects the problem. The cause of this
for the circumflex and right coronary arteries has been hypoperfusion has been attributed to spasm [27] and flow
shown to significantly enhance survival 10 or more years capacity [28] of the graft. We believe, however, that
after operation [7, 10, 111. The ITA remains free from reduction in ITA flow is most often the result of even
obstruction because of its low risk of intimal thickening slight narrowing of ITA coronary anastomoses or kinking
due to a more elastic media [23] and its freedom from or stretching of the ITA. On occasion, when flow through
significant atherosclerosis [24]. We have seen ITAs at the ITAs after completion of the T graft was inadequate,
recatheterization that are widely patent and entirely free redoing the anastomoses resulted in excellent flow in both
from obstruction 21 years after grafting (Fig 3). limbs of the graft. Another time, inadequate flow to the right
Anastomosing the free RITA to the attached L E A can coronary branch was caused by kinking of the artery, from
bring the RITA as much as 10 cm or more closer to the the way the pedicle was sutured to the epicardium. Chang-
distal circumflex and right coronary artery branches. This ing the stitch released the kink in the ITA, and the
makes it possible for us to totally bypass nearly every electrocardiogram and echocardiogram immediately re-
patient with three-vessel disease with ITA grafts. With turned to normal.
this procedure, the principle of bypassing the LAD (the If there is any doubt about the adequacy of flow, the
most important coronary artery) with the attached LITA, safest approach is to place an SVG to the suspected area
the graft with the greatest patency, is preserved [25]. Leg before removing the patient from cardiopulmonary by-
incisions and their complications are eliminated. The use pass. Initially we were extremely cautious of hypoperfu-
of other arteries that are more prone to spasm and intimal sion, but as we attain experience with T grafts we rarely
hyperplasia is avoided [23]. No graft is anastomosed to see this problem.
the ascending aorta, reducing the chance of embolization It would be ideal to obtain postoperative visualization
and the hindrance of a graft on the aorta in the event that of the grafts in all 287 patients. Postoperative studies are
an aortic valve operation is necessary at a later date. becoming more and more difficult to obtain because of
Sternal reentry is safer if required in the future because refusal by the patient, insurance companies, and Medi-
the ITAs are well out of the way, and the chance of care. The graft patency in the 26 patients who underwent
atherosclerotic emboli from dissecting near the bypass postoperative graft visualization is acceptable. It was
grafts as seen in the SVG is eliminated. encouraging to see that the high patency of the LITA
Reliance upon the attached LITA to supply sufficient attached to LAD, as attained in the past, was achieved in
flow to meet the demands of all of the revascularized this group. The one T-graft failure may have been a result
areas, and the increased incidence of sternal infection of competition of flow with the first circumflex marginal
38 TECTOR ET AL Ann Thorac Surg
TOTAL ITA REVASCULARIZATION 1994;5733-9
branch that was bypassed and had minimal disease. The 9. Ochsner JL. Institutional variations influencing results: arte-
greatest incidence of graft failure occurred at the distal rial versus venous grafts. Ciirculation 1982;65(Suppl 2):81-5.
end of t h e RITA. Stretching or kinking of t h e graft, o r 10. Tector AJ, Schmahl TM, Crouch JD, Canino VR, Heckel RC.
Sequential, free and Y intemal thoracic artery grafts. Eur
possibly the presence of diffusely diseased right coronary Heart J 1989;1O(Suppl H):7--7.
artery branches, m a y be responsible for these closures. 11. Acinapura AJ, Jacobowitz IJ. Kramer MD, Zisbrod Z, Cun-
Another possible reason for the closure of the RITA ningham JN. Internal mammary artery bypass: thirteen years
end-to-side anastomosis is that the superior epigastric o r of experience. Influence of angina and survival in 5125
musculophrenic branch was used. Although s o m e au- patients. J Cardiovasc Surg 1.992;33:554-9.
12. Tector AJ, Schmahl TM, Canino VR. Expanding the use of
thors [29] report increased graft closure i n these vessels the internal mammary artery to improve patency in coronary
when used as a Y graft, we have found satisfactory artery bypass grafting. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1986;
patency i n the Y grafts we have placed. 91~9-16.
Total revascularization with the ITA, the most ideal 13. Sauvage LR, Wu HD, Koivalsky TE, et al. Healing basis and
bypass graft, has the potential to significantly increase surgical techniques for complete revascularization of the left
ventricle using only the internal mammary arteries. Ann
long-term event-free survival and dramatically reduce t h e
Thorac Surg 1986;42:449-65.
need for reoperation i n patients with three-vessel disease. 14. Mills NL. Physiologic and technical aspects of internal mam-
The procedure can be performed w i t h acceptable mortal- mary artery coronary artery bypass grafts. In: Cohn LH, ed.
ity i n patients of all ages, including those with poor Modern techniques in surgery. Cardio-thoracic Surgery. Mt.
ventricles o r left m a i n disease, and even i n some patients Kisco, NY: Futura, 1982;48:1-19.
requiring reoperation. The average cost per case i n pa- 15. Sauvage LR. Extensive myocardial revascularization using
only internal thoracic arteries for grafting the anterior de-
tients operated on t h e first time w i t h reasonable ventric- scending, circumflex and right systems. In: Meyens WO, ed.
ular function was $18,000, and t h e average cost per CABG update. Part 11. Cardiac surgery state of the art
multiple-vessel a n g i o p l a s t y i s more than half t h a t reviews. Philadelphia: Hanky and Belfus, 1992;6:397-419.
a m o u n t . In patients requiring a second angioplasty, total 16. Kouchoukos NT. Coronary artery bypass grafts: how many?
revascularization w i t h T grafts could be the more cost- What kind? Ann Thorac !hrg 1976;22:60&2.
17. Flemma RJ, Singh HM, Tector AJ, Lepley D Jr, Frazier BL.
effective form of treatment. Dedication to impeccable Comparative hemodynamic properties of vein and mammary
precision of technique i n the preparation and anastomosis artery in coronary bypaiss operations. Ann Thorac Surg
of ITA grafts is p a r a m o u n t to the success of this proce- 1975;20:619-27.
dure. We can recommend it to the cardiovascular surgeon 18. Daly RC, McCarthy PM, Orszulak TA, Schaff HV, Edwards
with extensive experience and interest i n ITA grafting. WD. Histologic comparison of experimental coronary artery
bypass grafts. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1988;9619-29.
19. Mills NL, Bringaze WL. Preparation of the internal mammary
We are indebted to all of the cardiologists for performing post- artery graft. Which is the best method? J Thorac Cardiovasc
operative angiography and graft visualization, to Mr Alfred Surg 1989;98:73-9.
Anderson for statistical advice, and to Kelly Tector for preparing 20. Fogarty TJ, Mollenauer KH. Preparation of the internal
the manuscript. mammary artery for coronary artery bypass grafting. J Car-
Supported by a grant from the St. Luke's Medical Center Foun- diac Surg 1991;6:322-5.
dation. 21. Buckberg GD. Antegradeiretrograde blood cardioplegia to
ensure cardioplegic distribution: operative techniques and
objectives. J Cardiac Surg 1'989;4:21638.
References 22. Kroncke GM, Kosolcharoen P, Clayman JA, et al. Five-year
changes in coronary arteries of medical and surgical patients
1. Demikhov VP. Experimental transplantation of vital organs. of the Veterans Administration Randomized Study of Bypass
(Authorized translation by Basil Haig, MA, MB, and B. Surgery. Circulation 1988;7S(Suppl 1):1&50.
Chin.) New York: Consultants Bureau, 1962:221. 23. Van Son JAM, Smedts F, de Wilde PCM, et al. Histological
2. Vineberg AM. Development of an anastomosis between the study of the internal mammary artery with emphasis on its
coronary vessels and a transplanted internal mammary ar- suitability as a coronary artery bypassgraft. AnnThorac Surg
tery. Can Med Assoc J 1946;55:117-9. 1993;55:10&13.
3. Goetz RH, Rohman M, Haller JD, Dee R, Rosenak SS. 24. Kay HR, Korns ME, Flemma RJ, Tector AJ, Lepley D.
Internal mammary-coronary artery anastomosis. A nonsu- Atherosclerosis of the internal mammary artery. Ann Thorac
ture method employing tantalum rings. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1976;21:504-7.
Surg 1961;41:378-86. 25. Tector AJ, Schmahl TM, Cainino VR. The internal mammary
4. Kolessov VI. Mammary artery-coronary artery anastomosis artery graft: the best choice for bypass of the diseased left
as a method of treatment for angina pectoris. J Thorac anterior descending coronary artery. Circulation 1983;
Cardiovasc Surg 1967;54:53544. 68(Suppl 2):214-7.
5. Green GE, Stertzer SH, Reppert EH. Coronary arterial by- 26. Seyfer AE, Shriver CD, Miller TR, Graeber GM. Sternal blood
pass grafts. Ann Thorac Surg 1968;5:443-50. flow after median sternotomy and mobilization of the inter-
6. Suzuki A, Kay EB, Hardy JD. Direct anastomosis of the nal mammary arteries. Surgery 1988;104:899-904.
bilateral internal mammary artery to the distal coronary 27. Sarabu MR, McClung JA, Fass A, Reed GE. Early postoper-
artery, without a magnifier, for severe diffuse coronary ative spasm in left internal mammary artery bypass grafts.
atherosclerosis. Circulation 1973;48(Suppl 3):190-7. Ann Thorac Surg 1987;44:199-200.
7. Loop FD, Lytle BW, Cosgrove DM, et al. Influence of the 28. Jones EL, Lattouf OM, Weintraub WS. Catastrophic conse-
internal mammary artery graft on 10 year survival and other quences of internal mammary artery hypoperfusion. J Thorac
cardiac events. N Engl J Med 1986;314:1-6. Cardiovasc Surg 1989;98:902-7.
8. Okies JE, Page US, Bigelow JC, et al. The left internal 29. Morin JE, Hedderich G. Poirier NL, et al. Coronary artery
mammary artery: the graft of choice. Circulation 1984; bypass using internal mammary artery branches. Ann Tho-
7O(Suppl 1):213-21. rac Surg 1992;54:9114.
Ann Thorac Surg TECTOR ET AL 39
1994;5733-9 TOTAL ITA REVASCULARIZATION
DISCUSSION
DR LEO CUELLO (San Antonio, TX): I rise to congratulate Dr DR TECTOR. Thank you for your comments. In answer to the
Tector for an excellent presentation and for his excellent results first question, I have thought about what would happen if
with the T graft. Second, I want to make the members of The obstruction to the left subclavian artery developed years after this
Society aware that this report is important as a piece of evidence procedure, and there are a number of ways that this can be
on medicolegal cases. remedied.
As you are aware, there are a few members of this Society who If the obstruction happens late, left carotid subclavian bypass,
axillary artery-to-axillary artery bypass, endarterectomy of the
are testifying for the plaintiff lawyers. Last year a very prominent
subclavian artery, or angioplasty could be performed. Also, in 1
member of this Society under oath told jurors that it is a
patient we detached the left internal thoracic artery and anasto-
physiologic impossibility for this procedure to supply the left mosed it directly to the aorta. You could also place a graft from
ventricle. He also stated that it would be absolutely impossible the ascending aorta to the left internal thoracic artery. In a few
for a patient to survive with such a graft when the right coronary patients in whom we have noticed subclavian obstruction at the
artery is occluded even if you had added a side branch to it. time of operation we have left the right internal thoracic artery
attached and anastomosed the left internal thoracic artery to the
DR TECTOR This group of patients and previous work in the right internal thoracic artery as a T graft.
past by us and other investigators around the world have to most I do not recall having to completely abandon the procedure,
everyones satisfaction demonstrated that the internal thoracic but there have been several instances where we have added
artery (that is properly prepared and constructed) is capable of saphenous vein grafts, particularly when we first started per-
supplying a sufficient amount of blood to the myocardium in forming this operation. We rarely add vein grafts any more.
almost every patient. As far as the T graft anastomosis is concerned, I think that the
patency of the T graft is considerably better than it is in the free
graft that is anastomosed to the ascending aorta. This is probably
DR DELOS M. COSGROVE I11 (Cleveland, OH): Doctor Tector, because the internal thoracic artery is considerably thinner than
I congratulate you on excellent results. I realize that your refer- the ascending aorta. Also, as I mentioned before, it does add
ence to the T graft may be the shape of the anastomosis but it also significant length and allows the right internal thoracic artery to
might refer to Tector. This is not an easy anastomosis to reach all the posterior branches of the myocardium.
perform. Obviously this is not to be taken lightly as one starts
ones career as a revascularization surgeon. DR JOHN W. HAMMON, JR (Winston-Salem, NC): Doctor
I have three questions. First, you are putting all of your eggs in Tector, I know it is difficult to recatheterize patients after these
the basket of the left internal thoracic artery; are you concerned procedures, but do you have any other objective data such as
about the development of atherosclerosis in the subclavian artery thallium exercise testing in these patients to document that they
or the potential for dissection or injury to the left internal thoracic are not having ischemia during exercise postoperatively?
artery? Second, how often have you had to abandon this proce-
dure for reasons of moderate flow? Finally, why do you find that DR TECTOR: One hundred seven of the patients have had stress
it is an advantage for you to anastomose to a small internal tests postoperatively, and 90% of these stress tests have had
thoracic artery as opposed to doing a free graft of the right negative results; we are in the process of trying to find out how
internal thoracic artery to the aorta? many patients complain of angina in the postoperative period.