Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Experimental Elicitation of An Out of Body Experience and Concomitant Cross Hemispheric Electroencephalographic Coherence
Experimental Elicitation of An Out of Body Experience and Concomitant Cross Hemispheric Electroencephalographic Coherence
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
ThemeIssue:ExperimentalNeuroTheology
ExperimentalElicitationofanOutofBody
Experienceand
ConcomitantCrossHemispheric
ElectroencephalographicCoherence
KevinSaroka*,BryceP.Mulligan*,ToddR.Murphy*
andMichaelA.Persinger*
Abstract
Brief exposure to a counterclockwise global externally applied magnetic field
generated from an array of 64 solenoids designed to affect the cerebral fields
associatedwiththeleftandrighthemisphericcorrelatesofconsciousnessevokeda
powerful out of body experience (OOBE) in a single naive subject. The energy
availablefromtheappliedfieldwithinthecorticalvolumewaswithinthesameorder
of magnitude as that associated with the sum of action potentials in all cortical
neurons.DuringtheOOBEtherewasamarkedgeneralizedincreaseincoherencein
quantitative electroencephalographic activity between the left temporal lobe and
rightprefrontalregionwithspecificabnormallyhighincreaseswithinthe4to7Hz
and 15 to 21 Hz band. These results are congruent with the experience of
"consciousness"detachedfromthebodyandmovingthroughspace. Thediagonal
congruenceismoreconsistentwiththeexistenceoftwoquantizedfieldsoraglobal
field with opposing polarities whose vector determines various emergent states
experiencedasOOBEsorsensedpresencesduringbriefperiodsofperturbation.
Key Words: out of body experiences, weak magnetic fields, interhemispheric
coherence,thetaactivity,Schumannresonances
NeuroQuantology2010;4:466477
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
NeuroQuantology|December2010|Vol8|Issue4|Page466477 468
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
as mild brain injury (Persinger, 1994), during The next experience he recalled was
appropriate electrical stimulation within the awakening in the hospital. This man's passion
temporoparietal regions (of the right and profession was working as the clerk of a
hemisphere in particular), or during extreme large company that sold automobile parts.
metabolic states that typically diminish the Tests of various hypotheses are most
blood flow or perfusion rates that are optimally verified within the laboratory under
approximately 10% higher in the right controlled conditions but without the life-
hemisphere. These suppositions have been threatening conditions associated with
supported clinically and experimentally traditional OOBEs. Normal volunteers whose
(Bancaud et al., 1994; Persinger and Meli, cerebrums have been stimulated by
2008). extracerebrally applied weak (1 T range)
Both OOBEs and the sensed presence magnetic fields whose patterns were designed
frequently occur in a sequential order during to simulate natural phenomena, commonly
near-death experiences (NDEs). From the report sensed presences as well as out of body
perspective of the vectorial hemisphericity experiences. Both occur, although at various
hypothesis, the enhanced vulnerability to times during the experiences, within 15 to 30
diminished blood flow or hypoxia of the right min of continuous exposure while sitting in a
hemisphere during the conditions associated darkened, quiet room. However the externally
with near death would encourage the applied fields are focused over a restricted
intrusion of the left hemispheric processes region of the brain volume.
into right hemispheric "space". Hence the For the following experiment we
sense of self and the prominence of "thought" reasoned the following. If there are two
in determining outcomes of experiences would quantum fields representing the left and right
predominate. The content of the perceptions hemisphere, then an experimental condition
reported by individuals who experience NDEs that produces a coherent stimulation over
are compatible with this interpretation. most of the cerebral volume and allows the
However the normal compensatory penetration of the field associated with the
changes in blood flow within the right sense of self into the right hemispheric
hemisphere would then occur within the order condition there should be an associated
of tens of seconds and a reversal of the process powerful OOBE. Because the left
would ensue. The subjective experiences temporoparietal region is strongly associated
would be expected to involve the awareness of with the sense of self (Joseph, 1982) and the
the sensed presence and "returning" to the right prefrontal region is associated with the
body. Acquired verbal labels and associated reconstruction of the organization of space
verbal images, determined by the person's with respect to the self (Buckner and Petersen,
cultural history, would affect the details of the 1996), we predicted increased transient
sources and of the attribution for these neuroelectromagnetic coherence between
experiences (Persinger, 1999a). these areas. The frequency of coherence
Such "analytical overlay" would be should be within the theta (4 to 7 Hz) range
responsible for the richness and variability of based upon previous reports (Tart, 1967;
detail which do not always reflect the 1968) from people who could voluntarily
"classical" forms reported in the popular produce these experiences as well as the
media. For example one of our patients who theoretical calculations that the general
sustained a mechanical impact to and frequency ranges associated with
subsequent haemorrhage within the right consciousness exist as second and third order
parietal lobe during a snowmobile incident derivatives within the 5 to 6 Hz range
suddenly felt himself detached from his body (Persinger, 1999b).
and riding as a passenger in a white limousine The brain can be approached as a
that was speeding down a narrow road. The complex space whose organization serves as
interior of the car was shining white. The car substrates for electromagnetic patterns that
stopped at a red stop light and the door are the quintessential sources of behaviour,
opened and he was about to exit. However his including consciousness. If electromagnetic
dead grandmother leaned into the car and patterns are the origin for consciousness
said "stay inside you are not ready to get out". (McFadden, 2002; 2009; McKay and
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
NeuroQuantology|December2010|Vol8|Issue4|Page466477 469
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
Persinger, 2006), then it should be modifiable fields overlaps with that available within the
by the appropriately patterned, applied entire cerebral cortices.
magnetic field. In the least, the magnitude of
the energy from our applied fields should Subject and Methods
approximate the magnitude of the The subject was a 27 year old male university
neuromagnetic correlations of consciousness student. He sat in a comfortable chair in a
within the whole of cerebral space so that small office with normal low lighting (400 lux)
potential interference or modification could and acoustic background (people walking in
occur. The quantum unit of neuronal function hallway). The subject wore a custom-
(Persinger, 2010), derived from the action constructed (by Todd Murphy) hat containing
potential, is approximately 2 x 10-20 J, the 64 solenoids (see Figure 1) obtained from
product of 120 mV (peak-to-peak voltage Radio Shack. The 64-solenoids were
change during an action potential) and 1.6 x distributed equally around the cerebrum in
10-19 Coulombs (charge per ion). columns of 8 separated by 45 deg.
The energy within the cerebral cortices Consequently there were 8 columns over the
of the human being exposed to the estimated left and right frontal, temporal, parietal, and
intracerebral strength of 1 T magnetic fields occipital lobes.
is calculated as J=[B2 (kg/A2) /2*4pi x 10-7 Shiva Neural Stimulation Software
N/A2] * volume. Because the cerebral cortices (Todd Murphy) was used to apply the
are .44 of the cerebral volume (1.1 x 10-3 m3), magnetic field through 4 USB audio devices.
this means the energy available would be This software was custom-designed by Todd
about 6 x 10-9 J. If there are on average 40 x Murphy to deliver weak-intensity magnetic
109 neurons within the cerebral cortices and fields to each of the 8 columns of solenoids at
each neuron's action potential is 2 x 10-20 J specified times with the same parameters used
and the average firing frequency is 7 Hz, the in previously published studies (Martin et al.,
energy associated with the "electromagnetic 2004; Richards et al., 2002). The actual
activity" of consciousness is 560 x 10-11 J or signals were audio derivatives of patterns
about 6 x 10-9 J (Mulligan et al., 2010). The converted to magnetic fields that are used
convergence of these values indicates that the regularly within our laboratory.
energy generated from our applied magnetic
Figure1.Lateral,frontalandtopographicalviewsofthecustomconstructedhatusedintheexperiment.Thehatcontains64
solenoidsarrangedincolumnsof8separatedby45degrees.
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
NeuroQuantology|December2010|Vol8|Issue4|Page466477 470
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
Figure 2. Elevated power at 2 Hz within the left temporal lobe with a concomitant increase in 9 to 13 Hz power at 7 sensor
positions during the outofbody experience relative to the eyes closed baseline. O1left occipital, O2right occipital, P3left
parietal,P4rightparietal,T3lefttemporal,T4righttemporal,F7leftfrontal,F8rightfrontal.
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
NeuroQuantology|December2010|Vol8|Issue4|Page466477 472
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
However there was an additional "bimodal" There was also an enhanced coherence
peak in coherence (minimum=0; between the left temporal and left frontal
maximum=1) within the theta (3-7 Hz) and regions within the theta band during the
low beta (15-23 Hz) range during the OOBE OOBE. To control for possible confounding
only. These coherences were abnormally high variables, zero-order and partial correlations
compared to typical waking cerebral activity. were completed for the coherence values. The
The means and standard error of the means zero order coefficients for the theta band
for the coefficients of coherence within coherence were: T3,F7 vs F7,F8 (.68), T3,F7 vs
successive 1-Hz bands within the theta range T3,F8 (.91) and F7,F8 vs T3,F8 (.68). However
are shown in Figure 4 for the conditions of after partial correlation these values were .21,
eyes-opened, eyes-closed, and the OOBE. The .84, and .19, respectively, indicating that the
strength of coherence during the OOBE was source of the left temporal-right prefrontal
twice to three times greater on average coherence originated from the left temporal
compared to these values during the eyes- lobe and was not indirectly mediated between
opened or eyes-closed condition. the left temporal to the left frontal lobe and
then across to the right frontal region.
Figure3.Overallincreasedinterhemisphericcoherencebetweenthelefttemporalandrightfrontalregionsduringtheoutof
bodyexperience(OOBE)comparedtotheeyesclosedbaselinewithbimodalpeaksinthetheta(37Hz)andlowbeta(1523Hz)
frequencyranges.
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
NeuroQuantology|December2010|Vol8|Issue4|Page466477 473
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
Figure4.Meaninterhemisphericcoherenceforsuccessive1Hzbandswithinthetheta(37)rangeweresignificantlyelevated
during the outofbody experience (OOBE) when compared to eyesopen and eyesclosed conditions. Error bars represent
standarderrorofthemean.
The increased cerebral power within the range to 6 Hz and between 15 Hz to 22 Hz. If the left
of alpha rhythms over most of the cerebrum temporal region is associated with the sense of
during the occurrence of the experimentally- self and consciousness and the right prefrontal
elicited OOBE is consistent with reports of region is associated with spatial navigation,
other researchers. During partial sensory the reconstruction of autobiographical
deprivation subjects reported sensations of memory about when, where and with whom
the self being detached from the body during an event occurred (Buckner and Petersen,
increased amplitude of synchronous slow 1996), and "mental time travel", then this
waves with theta-like characteristics (Zubek et specific coherence could encourage
al., 1960; Coffer and Appley, 1964). Alphoid experiences consistent with the classical
activity, defined as synchronous activity 2 Hz OOBE.
lower than the person's fundamental alpha The left temporal-right prefrontal
frequency, was displayed in two different coherence might be expected to include the
special subjects who could voluntarily elicit feeling of separation of the self from the body,
OOBEs (Tart, 1967, 1968). "movement in space", "thought" as the central
The coherence results observed in the frame of reference to control this movement,
present study strongly support the hypothesis and the feeling of being somewhere else.
that OOBEs are associated with the protrusion These are classic features of OOBEs (Tart,
of the left hemispheric field into the right 1968). The remarkably enhanced amplitude of
hemispheric field. For this diagonal power within the 2 Hz band over the left
association there was a generalized increase in temporal lobe, from this context, could be
coherence between the left temporal and right considered the source of initiation. Partial
prefrontal region across all major frequencies correlation analyses with the strongest
(3 to 40 Hz) with specific peaks between 3 Hz coefficients of coherence support this
interpretation. The "left hemispheric field"
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
NeuroQuantology|December2010|Vol8|Issue4|Page466477 474
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
would have been directed into the "right was driven by the marked elevation of voltage
hemispheric field". originating over the left temporal lobe. This
It is relevant that the OOBE did not peak would be congruent with the subjects
occur during the presentation of either field initial vestibular experiences.
configuration. It began within seconds after If consciousness exists within a narrow
the termination of the 20+2 configuration of band of neuroelectromagnetic activity then
the counterclockwise rotating, global stimulation below that threshold would not be
extracerebral magnetic field to which the effective and magnitudes of stimulation above
subject had been exposed for 5 min. The that threshold would be aversive and
energy within the cerebral cortices associated potentially disruptive. Some spontaneous
with the application of the approximately 1 T cases of OOBE are associated with negative
strength burst firing magnetic field that was experiences such as dizziness, nausea and
rotated approximately 9.6 times per sec fear. In addition, not all NDEs are positive.
around the circumference of the head would About 7 to 10% of these cases are extremely
have been in the order of 10-9 J. We selected negative affectively (Persinger, 1974). The
this intensity because it would be within the imagery, which involves the cultures labels for
same order of magnitude as the energy aversive sensations, is mood congruent. Such
generated by action potentials of the non-linearity between the number and valence
approximately 40 billions neurons in the of NDEs would be expected based upon the
cortices. Even if only 10% of neurons' annular-like organization of reward and
neuropatterns were coherent per second, the aversive areas within the limbic system.
approximately 100 msec duration of a percept Aversive areas surround and suppress
(Koenig et al., 2002), the energy would be pleasure centers.
sufficient to interact with the cohesive or There would be a point where the
"binding" factor (Llinas and Ribardy, 1993) microcurrent induction from the conditions
that organizes the cerebral manifold. associated with the NDE would exceed the
Theoretical calculations suggest the existence lower threshold pleasure areas and diffuse
of a recondite second or third derivative into the surrounding aversive areas. If the
contained within the 5 to 7 Hz band magnitude of the induction was too high there
(Persinger, 1999b). would be a complete disruption of the process
We suggest that the global magnetic and hence complete amnesia. In other words,
field generated by an array of 64 solenoids was most people would remember nothing. It may
sufficient to initiate instability within the be relevant that the transition from intrinsic
holistic parameters that define the functional hippocampal patterns that promote normal
state of the whole brain (Wackermann, 1999). memory consolidation to those that reflect
When this field stopped suddenly the paroxysmal, epileptic seizure activity (and
compensatory changes in the cerebral hence amnesia) occurs mathematically as an
magnetic field during this period of all-or-none, catastrophic event.
stabilization produced the conditions for the The occurrences of the left temporal-
left hemispheric field to intrude into right right prefrontal coherence within the theta
hemisphere space. In fact the holistic and low beta band have two major
measures of complexity decreased over the left implications both for OOBEs and for the
temporal and right prefrontal regions nature of consciousness within brain space.
concurrent with an increase in coherence First the diagonal nature of the coherence
during this transience which was associated would not be consistent with a fixed
with the OOBE. structuralist model whereby two hemispheres
The nature of the hemispheric field interact laterally through the corpus callosum
interactions might be considered analogous to and anterior commissure. The asymmetry
the transient disruption of the constrained might be considered representative of a
polarity of the geomagnetic field from the fundamental, holistic standing wave derived
penetration of opposite polarity flux lines from the beats or emergent organizations
during shear disruptions from the solar wind from the rapid alternations from reciprocal
before the "reconnections" occur. In the inhibitory control between the two
present case, the initial vector for penetration hemispheres and the ascending input from the
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
NeuroQuantology|December2010|Vol8|Issue4|Page466477 475
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
brain stem. This cohesive field moves in a amplification of a gravity wave is near the
rostral to caudal direction through the cortical second global Schumann harmonic around 14
manifold with repetition rates and phase- to 15 Hz. The second peak of coherence
modulations within the 10 to 20 msec range between the left temporal lobe and right
(Llinas and Ribardy, 1993). prefrontal region occurred within this band.
Within an equilibrium system where Whether or not these similarities could
there are periodically shifting polarities, such explain the acquisition of information from
as the solar magnetic field, one would expect distal sources during OOBEs remains to be
at least four fundamental states or briefly examined. Throughout the last two millennia
stable configurations within the three planes. there have been repeated claims of
Along the horizontal (x,y) plane the first two "projections" into distal spaces. Although
would be: left frontal-right caudal and right most experiences are easily accommodated
frontal-left caudal. Along the z-axis or vertical through the nuances of normal neuronal
plane one would expect two similar polarities chemistry and neuropsychological processes
more homogeneously integrating both associated with fantasy and confabulation, the
hemispheres but differing in the focus over the occasional reports of information not
rostral or caudal dorsal frontal pattern. In fact accessible to the experient within this
these four patterns are very similar to the "cerebral noise" may be worth pursuing.
fundamental microstates that define the Pursuit of the neuroQuantology
human brain ontogenetically (Koenig et al., component of OOBEs may be revealing. We
2002). From this perspective the consider states of consciousness as conditions
neuroelectromagntic field associated with analogous to quantum states embedded with
states of consciousness are cohesive cerebral fields. The fields contain quantized
transcerebral fields that occupy the brain's points. A candidate for this quantum has been
volume. the 10-20 J associated with the quintessential
The second implication involves the digital component of information transfer
two bands of coherence. Both the theta and within brain space: the action potential
low beta band are very similar to the first and (Persinger, 2010). If the operating intensity of
second harmonic of the Schumann resonance. the cerebrum is about 10 pT, then the energy
It defines the essential standing wave, with the available within the cerebral cortices would be
usual range of 7 to 8 Hz, between the earth's 2 x 10-20 J. That the magnitude of the unit
surface and the ionosphere. This frequency reflects the magnitude of the whole would be
range is shared by the human hippocampus, an important component for the condition of a
the "gateway to memory", and has been field.
hypothesized to be a potential mechanism by In previous research (Booth et al.,
which the transient 20 to 30 min of electrically 2005) we applied the quantum nature of
labile state of experiences before they are electron energies during the presentation of
consolidated to protein structures and magnetic fields to the cerebral volume. The
dendritic spine growths could be represented Zeeman effect occurs when the application of
in extracerebral space (Persinger, 2008). a magnetic field "splits" the emission and
OOBEs are more probable in people with absorption spectrum of the constituents of
elevated complex (temporal lobe) partial matter into equally polarized components.
epileptic-like signs during periods of One solution for the equivalent Zeeman
moderately enhanced geomagnetic activity frequency is the product of the field strength
(Persinger, 1995). and charge divided by the mass of the
Secondly, Minakov et al (1993) have electron. For a field strength of 10 x 10-12 T and
shown theoretically that gravitational waves a unit charge of 1.6 x 10-19 A s, the frequency to
can be converted into electromagnetic waves. produce this effect in an electron with a mass
Gravity waves freely propagated inside the of 9.1 x 10-31 kg is about 2 Hz. Whether or not
earth-ionospheric resonator induce alterations the extraordinary peak of power at 2 Hz
in the boundaries as well as perturbations in within the left temporal lobe noted in the
the space-time metric. According to these present case was indicative of this effect
authors, the most powerful region of requires further examination.
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
NeuroQuantology|December2010|Vol8|Issue4|Page466477 476
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
NeuroQuantology|December2010|Vol8|Issue4|Page466477 477
SarokaKetal.,Experimentalelicitationofanoutofbodyexperience
Persinger MA, Richards PM, Koren SA. Differential Tart CT. A psychophysiological study of out-of-the-body
entrainment of electrocephalographic activity by experiences in a selected subject. Journal of the
weak complex magnetic fields. Perceptual and American Society for Psychical Research 1968; 72,
Motor Skills 1997; 85: 387-398. 3-27.
Richards MA, Koren SA, Persinger MA. Circumcerebral Twitchell P. Eckanakar. N.Y.: Lancer, 1969.
application of weak complex magnetic fields with Van Essen DC, Drury HA. Structural and functional
derivatives and changes in electroencephalographic analyses of human cerebral cortex using a surface-
power spectra within the theta range: implications based atlas. The Journal of Neuroscience 1997; 17:
for states of consciousness. Perceptual and Motor 7079-7102.
Skills 2002; 95: 671-686. Wackerman J. Towards a quantitative characterisation of
St-Pierre L, Persinger MA. Experimental facilitation of functional states of the brain: from the non-linear
the sensed presence is predicted by the specific methodology to global linear description.
patterns of the applied magnetic fields not International Journal of Psychophysiology 1999;
suggestibility: reanalyses of 19 experiments. 34: 65-80.
International Journal of Neuroscience 2006; 116: 1- Zubek JP, Sansom W, Prysiaznuik A. Intellectual changes
18. during prolonged perceptual isolation (darkness
Suedfeld P, Mocellin JSP. The "sensed presence" in and silence). Canadian Journal of Psychology 1960;
unusual environments. Environment and Behavior 14, 233-243.
1987; 19: 33-52.
Tart CT. A second psychophysiological out-of-the-body
experience in a gifted subject. International Journal
of Parapsychology 1967; 9: 251-258.
ISSN13035150 www.neuroquantology.com
Copyright of NeuroQuantology is the property of NeuroQuantology and its content may not be copied or
emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.
However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.