Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The use of crucibles and dishes made of platinum and its alloys in the preparation of samples has become an
essential feature of XRF analysis. The broad application of platinum results from its near-perfect oxidation resist-
ance and its excellent resistance to corrosive attack by metal oxide melts such as XRF uxing agents. However, a
few basic rules must be adhered to if platinum ware is to give satisfactory service. A number of platinum poisons,
which are commonly encountered in samples, can cause destruction within a few sample preparation cycles. These
poisons, the reasons for their corrosive eects and techniques for minimizing or eliminating their inuence are
outlined. ( 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
X-Ray Spectrom. 26, 132140 (1997) No. of Figures : 15 No. of Tables : 0 No. of References : 8
should be taken. These will be outlined in the following ments or supporting trays. Figure 3 (upper left) shows
case histories. cracking in the base of a Pt5% Au crucible that had
been used for preparing cement samples. The micro-
CASE HISTORIES graph shows the internal surface of the cruciblethe
outside was covered with a large number of pits and
residues of samples and lithium tetraborate ux. The
Silicon carbide other parts of Fig. 3 show part of the crack at higher
magnication and the local distribution of silicon and
A common cause of damage to crucibles during sample carbon.
fusion preparation in a furnace is contamination of the The presence of silicon is not surprising, as it will be
surface with silicon carbide either from the heating ele- found at high concentrations in a large number of
( 1997 by John Wiley & Sons Ltd. X-RAY SPECTROMETRY, VOL. 26, 132140 (1997)
134 D. F. LUPTON, J. MERKER AND F. SCHO LZ
Figure 3. Cracking in the base of a Pt5% Au crucible used for cement fusion showing Si and C concentrations.
samples, usually in the form of SiO . However, the silicon carbide heating elements. However, as these fur-
presence of carbon is a clear indication2that the damage naces are readily available and relatively economic, they
has been caused by unoxidized silicon from a silicon are commonly used in analytical laboratories. It is
carbide tray on which the crucible had been standing. important to ensure that platinum crucibles are posi-
Figure 4 shows the phase diagram of the PtSi system tioned well away from the heating elements and that the
with three low-melting eutectics. It can be seen that supporting tray is cleaned of carbide particles after
contact between platinum and unoxidized silicon can every fusion cycle.
cause melting at temperatures well below 1000 C. We Another example of corrosion resulting from SiC is
strongly recommend that platinum crucibles are never shown in Fig. 5, although it is not clear whether the SiC
placed on a silicon carbide tray. Alumina or fused silica came from the furnace or had been transferred acciden-
are greatly preferable. tally to the outside of the crucible because of inadequate
A further danger is spalling of silicon carbide heating cleaning after handling grinding media. The outer
elements. Small particles of silicon carbide adhering surface of the crucible base (Fig. 5, upper left) showed
either to the side of the crucible or accumulating on the numerous pits which, on closer examination (Fig. 5,
oor of the furnace can lead to the same eect. Of upper right), were found to be regions where localized
course, it would be best to avoid using furnaces with melting had occurred. Substantial concentrations of
( 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. X-RAY SPECTROMETRY, VOL. 26, 132140 (1997)
CORRECT USE OF PLATINUM IN THE XRF LABORATORY 135
Figure 5. Pitting and cracks in Pt5% Au crucible contaminated with SiC on the outer surface.
both silicon and carbon were found in these pits. of the base following the grain boundaries in the Pt5%
However, the actual cause of crucible failure was crack- Au alloy. It was not possible to ascertain whether the
ing, as shown in Fig. 5 (lower left). The cracks were also cracking was caused by the presence of carbon itself at
found to have initiated on the inside surface of the cru- the grain boundaries or by the reduction of platinum
cible and showed distinct traces of carbon contami- poisons in the sample.
nation (Fig. 5, lower right). It appears that carbon had Figure 6 shows a particularly dramatic case of local-
been released by the dissociation of SiC on the outer ized melting caused by SiC during sample preparation
surface and had then diused through the full thickness in a cement works. In this case, the crucible was heated
Figure 6. Catastrophic melting of a Pt crucible caused by localized SiC contamination on top rim.
( 1997 by John Wiley & Sons Ltd. X-RAY SPECTROMETRY, VOL. 26, 132140 (1997)
136 D. F. LUPTON, J. MERKER AND F. SCHO LZ
in an induction coil. Traces of SiC had been present on vated temperatures. The carbon has diused into the
the rim of the crucible. When this part of the crucible grain boundaries, leading to grain boundary separation
exceeded the melting point of the PtPt Si eutectic and porosity. The mechanisms of this process are not
3
(830 C), the platinum started to melt. A large drop of truly understood, but the eect is also observed in plati-
molten PtSi eutectic, still containing particles of unre- num catalysts exposed to atmospheres containing
acted SiC, ran down the inside of the crucible and con- hydrocarbons.
tinued to melt the platinum as it descended. When the It is essential that platinum crucibles and other
molten drop reached the surface of the ux, it dispersed utensils should not come into contact with carbon, e.g.
to some extent and the SiC attacked a larger area on by placing them on a graphite plate. Contact with car-
the inner surface of the crucible (Fig. 6, right). However, bonaceous materials should be avoided as much as pos-
the silicon content of the platinum was still sufficient for sible or, if contact cannot be completely avoided, e.g.
the melting process to continue until the base of the during the ignition of organic materials, the platinum
crucible was reached. Metallographic examination of should not be exposed to unnecessarily high tem-
the base showed particles of SiC embedded in peratures until carbon combustion is complete.
resolidied platinum.
Carbon Phosphorus
In addition to its inuence in reducing oxides of plati- Phosphorous is one of the classical platinum poisons
num poisons, carbon itself can be severely detrimental with one of the lowest eutectic temperatures (588 C,
to the structural integrity of platinum. Figure 7 shows a Fig. 8). Fortunately, phosphorus in most samples is
platinum wire that had been exposed to carbon at ele- present as a phosphate rather than in its elemental
( 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. X-RAY SPECTROMETRY, VOL. 26, 132140 (1997)
CORRECT USE OF PLATINUM IN THE XRF LABORATORY 137
Sulphur
state. Phosphates do not usually cause catastrophic cor- Whereas sulphur is relatively harmless in the form of
rosion but lead to a progressive surface roughening and sulphates, sulphides can cause serious embrittlement of
mechanical embrittlement : Figure 9 shows the forma- platinum crucibles. Figure 10 is a photograph showing
tion of brittle platinum phosphide at the grain bound- the bottoms of three crucibles. Crucibles 1 and 2 had
ary of platinum exposed to a phosphate glass melt.5 been used for the preparation of XRF samples of blast-
furnace slag containing 12% S with lithium tetraborate
ux. After 27 samples the crucible was still intact (No.
1), showing only an abnormal degree of roughness on
the inner surface. However, after 50 cycles the crucible
failed by brittle cracking over the whole base. Similar
crucibles used for low-sulphur samples, e.g. cement (No.
3) or steel slags, commonly achieve many hundreds of
cycles.
Figure 11 shows localized melting of a platinum cru-
cible which was accidentally contaminated with sulphur
when the analyst did not expect this element in the
sample. The melting has been caused by the formation
of a PtS eutectic with a melting point of 1240 C (Fig.
12, left). As this temperature is considerably higher than
the melting points of the eutectics described above, it is
easier to avoid catastrophic corrosion failure by sulphur
Figure 10. Cracking of Pt5% Au crucibles caused by 12% of
sulphur in blast-furnace slag : (1) 27 slag samples, no cracking ; than in the case of other platinum poisons. We recom-
(2) 50 slag samples, severe cracking ; (3) 650 cement samples (no mend using separate crucibles for the fusion of samples
sulphur), no cracking. suspected of containing sulphur to minimize the risk of
( 1997 by John Wiley & Sons Ltd. X-RAY SPECTROMETRY, VOL. 26, 132140 (1997)
138 D. F. LUPTON, J. MERKER AND F. SCHO LZ
Figure 12. Comparison of the eutectics in the Pt-S and Rh-S systems.
damage to crucibles which would otherwise be usable Some of the grain boundaries had separated in a
for very many sample preparations. manner which appeared initially to be brittle fracture
Platinum alloys containing rhodium are particularly (Fig. 13b, middle). However, closer examination showed
prone to corrosive attack by sulphur because the RhS the presence of a lm rich in copper at the grain bound-
eutectic melts at only 925 C (Fig. 12, right). aries which had melted during the fusion operations
(Fig. 13c, right).
A further problem with copper, and of course with
Copper other elements that can be taken into solid solution in
the platinum (e.g. iron, zinc and lead), is the danger of a
memory eect. Copper absorbed by the platinum in
Copper is not a platinum poison in the usual sense.
one fusion can be released into the sample during sub-
However, copper oxides have only limited thermodyna-
sequent fusions.2,6
mic stability and great care must be taken to ensure
that any copper present in samples is fully oxidized
during the preparation treatment. Figure 13 shows the
eect of inadequate copper oxidation. The sample prep-
aration had been carried out at a very high tem- Careless handling
perature, as can be seen from the coarse grain structure
in the base of the crucible, with grain boundaries across One of the most common causes of premature failure of
the whole thickness (Figure 13, left). platinum crucibles is careless handling. Figure 14 shows
Figure 13. Grain growth and local melting of Pt5% Au crucible after fusion of copper oxide samples with carbon contamination.
( 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. X-RAY SPECTROMETRY, VOL. 26, 132140 (1997)
CORRECT USE OF PLATINUM IN THE XRF LABORATORY 139
OXIDATION CONDITIONS
REFERENCES
1. D. Menzel, Pract . Metallog . 13, 211 (1976). 5. B. Fischer, Jena Advanced College of Technology, personal
2. H. Bennett and G. Oliver, XRF Analysis of Ceramics , Minerals communication.
and Allied Materials . Wiley, Chichester (1992). 6. K. Norrish and G. M. Thompson, X -Ray Spectrom . 19, 67
3. T. B. Massalski (Ed.), Binary Alloy Phase Diagrams , 2nd ed. (1990).
ASM International, Ohio (1990). 7. R. T. Rutherford, X -Ray Spectrom . 24, 109 (1995).
4. B. Fischer, Platinum Met . Rev . 36, 14 (1992). 8. J. Petin, A. Wagner and F. Bentz, Steel Res . 56, 215 (1985).
( 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. X-RAY SPECTROMETRY, VOL. 26, 132140 (1997)