Professional Documents
Culture Documents
>j J
c.}i}!r
.rYl^ ."'"1+t ;K'
ffi ffi
,l',,18i,i
,'tl;11 :,tljli l
i:l**:;lll I *rm
ffiffi "ffi,w
4{ JJ jl lJ d&tis rs" u3i. l#lJ{Jsl
f.l rjr ,l'.rr.{ 3;tj.-ir1 ,ti.lgli* cr-.,
,e-sgt '..n.. l;!lr.i3t ^:lL-r,l .p-rit <'nr
13;r+ J !#* .i,*3 .,.aXa l'1 cll,ilt..li
0++ f**,l4JSl,p1A6ir lJ uLi'si-Ji
3 {r*'ai ,YJ# 3 JoBsr .r-ttfr!0B'*'l*
lJ 6Jr:. g{tjt .t } JJ J3i:J&. .,a#(lt
t ,.1, cr,-riai 0-rld-hrlJ,f*.l5 g;.it*ril+
rFlJt &rLi,l*lil,r U.liLi c'J$ cAL.{
S.rLIi c*Qj J !.ai,,JL"Jt,, p"nt3Q ol,1
;ry.o.!s
$p
nlJBl J.Xi
.r"!. ,.f)l*"
.\YAY ,ol-i;.| :jl*-..r,\. er\'c /:Yti- t3,& :;l.pl tr dj$- rrsi _9 rr:!
$p
olJgl J.t[
.',1
VJ.
gl J..r r<'.rfg
VJ. rlr3 o,l.rri
(oYl'L t,r-")
jY-, *LE:o.:'js o
siii- e.r!l ,Jr C>L
A F 6o;L"-.t
\rv^,l.l -L
\rAV fii uts
4i-lY.".:JL<J1"..:,
.riJ-6,./1- I Vh
221or"v\ t2r\ \fY1 :ot(-13;;.iI- ttf \.rY0 :o!l,-ujl .,-Kil:
-
http ://www. akhtaranbook.com Email: info@akhtaranbook.com
rsBN 978-964-75 l4-08-8 1VA-1rf*V0\f- "A-A :.SLi,
c,-l'[isi* ;L:l I ,-!i ,<l - .; "i- 4,K
lllllllllllilllllllllllllllll
j'
I
Y1
AT
VA
\"r
\YV
\f1
\lV
\AV
Y\T
tta
tfA
Ylf
cfL-" r.t+
Y1\ JL-)I j 6L-J-a
-.,l5.tii
Y.A *-r;-c qi.J*
..:-,91- ojb
.' \ r ;J,l;i I:
e-
;:i
ol/-lr> >-ri-.j gt3s r 5=*, 6LrcLi ;J-jf1--jl.5-
e-b.l rKlt JrF.j-Ll JKj 6 tf lr c-:'!l3 -,,-l ;^r
-rr-! -r,-t-: t,
oK;I 1".rVK ,c-K ,.-:lS ;L $t^e-! ,flf t J;- (JU, cJti c4! rJj
-JL" (_' :J\j-J_rG, aJtL ;jlJ -\,-ra lJ6-a.,
.:!.,1> >j' l-rin: :k-l
t-t1-t gV Uo, i;L;:661c-i 3,ca)^- L_4JU" o,L)Ss-srdt L_
,.--.+;
clk-l g-j;r,5i>l.;lr.!kt ,.-."1>j -'l-b -sr.-( at a7
5u; ,91)s ;>.pl-,! c,.rJL-l e Laa.a; Stt i* {.Jl.tc-!L-6"
-'b-r^c
6,:r, jUI,..s<iK* fu 7, y-l oU-)U, t>_t: Gst,Jt' jll-l
t-1
J- o:i-, na
o'.a-.a;: .5t't+l:; O':a: 6\a;y J. t"i) 6J) a t
; a.-4" -' e "K .
t o{ g- t-*l; ci 13 J,-l f \.ry -ri ly .f U; "y r-.o
,< : ,5^*,1 c-.i,I: Cs: ;tr-t il$Jsil )\ et tJ ",4.F
) ,?\i f{ e\l S)r + l; ..r^,-;b c^:'!l3 Jr+f^ 1, 2 u! "-\
.)7
f:ly.r ,E- sF,*-:U; ;l! ); *,K:T c-ulorfJ-r-y .r"-r;
\v I ,u,K:-
.;-iltr,- 3
6 Gt+- .tS ,-; -P ) tt, J 13 -i 9 c;L :y*; 3 tlly-l !-,1Ji :L; t-;
U
i-tj q t' rl.rl:.r. sk^i c,.r-6 .;l \ ;:ly Gf t tr. G-l* :2- el
,5* t ), t +u t' -e c-;b oL-l .r"^i dJr$ jl er ats
.7U-'jE .,t, cro-t 6,lJ * *->t- q b yri i-clytc,.:y ln,:T
,-s' ,r-b ,rt -fi-t )l u,.21-b 2,*1: i.'.lt..; s31 .';S Jt aly-l
rr
+L- s s o -a-1 | s CV oU jL6-
s
::r.: a:i J : b\)-?l )$ SV 6
t . I l,:
6t*; f:- 4- F$I o36 6 tir l4i ri<,s, -c--3,1: a:;'K -1:
Tr.c--t-7
s*, cV.t-i, ,)t j .t: t# S-l c-J;c,-bs .f is>.tV
jl 4. 6 rT bf t'jtr;I 'j oLI-l a, .f) Or* -,1:":d-i9iall9):
jl k:; oj ; arUUt -.t- -r ,f *-j-,JLi-,,l q jli,i^i f--: LG 11
-\, e: ,o
l-r f/l r+ t-ul",e-." f..o irl-,11" .51-U ,*-Ft J )J-bu ,;)il +' .-132
tfg,,.r,rr-l (.t -:s) q,L 4^"t- sr;V J .l:^4rd 1:y :3; il ;+:
jl dl :t qF .$-r -*l-t o.J sr g ,-g:l.u-l :J>; ucat 4)-ja *. o-Li
ilJ-l )ple,Eu;-,1: ,r.ol-4.:-t-; Ly C-l Ftetar,-l-r)lL
ir-l -r, :-t-; jl C--l)) J-l tSE ,:rsl. co-\) ,-,4)** .,jLUl
"*-"'
u*l)o:*i t* jr* as
2*r* J,-l r, 6 U#rff, f
;-l .tl.y*1 *-tr.d-l:.r-i a,l[*. Jtj;, olTl ,rrni oJE f dfe
e-y )l..*;l-: /"+t oiic- '-:9- 3t tf;*rb t^,JSlJ
;-l .-r5rL71t diT uoy :Ja,i -l g)t-l ;-:S a:-lt;* 6c-l Gl-f
jt6uT jl r cit- 1:l-u ;t-.5ETu ) $ )VT ,r;U allc,-T! ot_r+
c*l jJ.}:f -r, .JJ,s- ,Kur-n J s,t4JL-L ,u)9:*,6r-
c)syl jt-lfrqi * j :)GT u,c91; 'Jlc"-Tt 6;:-:;; J J--St$
*Jl +l- tt ,S-t.Sr* 6)s: ,-t 6LaJL.1-: 6;.;;,*-urt.-"1.-r"t+,I,-r
\ e : J.l J. > 65 t r.Ll ;r - i ...i|r.l Li r)i t JJH t'r 1>l-t f tc +
.t l
r
.-tjlorf ,l-t^li :J-i
1
.:'5:1-r.Ji"d.,& C-," 4Y tt
Y\ / rLKj-.
Lac__ilJrg
,J?J
.6 t .oT b)r : .*-b: ",r^le u),l.iil" i* cr! .f
Khun, Thomas. The Structurc of Scientific Revolutioru. Chicago, 1962
,)4)1,-/Jlo, 6.o 4l;"i:lJ :t ;r*Ga; '*s.6
.:;l-rj l.li*-o: a,L;c;J
c,)lr.6j rY \ 1 Jt*L- o-;1-; cl-t--or a..l.jcJ .el ..2 c.UcJ ,l'ap j; ,gla
ep;--l -,Yto. a^.o ;u,iL l.s a-tL a/-l j>\." A\S fl-P r^lF .l f f Y
j,);4'..)UK1,5)y ));qK 4,r-Sf*,-r5.J=^^J- L6i 4iJ -tjlJ*
.gl.:f o:li:-l ";.J' ,t f -* Jr" oJtL ,F :, ;,Kn. + .,
iLe.tl -ieJ :Q :J' 6 .t--J;ols LJL -2: 3 C+l J":l J*l1: );--.1
.ef I ..t-n:,_r" e.i!t c-r;,-l -2: jli;2: ca r:;lr (U "-r"f
\Y t )UK.:-,
,UT .c--l ttry *-^tK;t ) s:2G r 6r-r^:, crYLL J :5:! ,,-l .,1: .1
.6 1:6-t{3) 6112.rt2l: c--ll,i) tu (HAUSER) )))l^ :c,l) ,-t{;)
Lukacs, Georg. The Theory of the NoveL Cambridge. l97l
:\.6 s t1)j.a ol;9 6lr: ..$ ,r;Bf J u-sti \dLJ lJ[J: d,l3 .:15
Hauser. Arnold. The Social History of Art. Vol. lII. New York. 1959
.i-l o-[i a*] u-.sli * n.:tt u.cL4l trb il.rp ue; ,,o :t5;-l
.'S 1t,!.yl;, fJt C,*.5lr.1 .
Foucault, Mchel. Power/krawledge: Selected Interyiews and other
Witings. Ed. by Colin Gordin. pp.78-134
:ti:-;l a- b F* o|b dtjl;r 6-:ta-" I t;;Jan"U 1: .rtlf;-1,1 qSUT
Vl ,r it-oL-o.\ I
gl-9 a,(Bourdicv.) !-)).y. a- 2t7 1l Uf ;--:Utl.r ";r-:k; o-l,r*",gL.1 f
.Cf 1 ra.nLn" J-l ra.;v:* 6lA..atf
Greenblatt, Stephen J. S hakespearcan N egotiatio ra.
Berkelcy, 1988. pp.1-21
.6 : tylst ulrb 6;1L
Bourdiue, Pierre. Langudge and Symbolic Power. Cambridge. 1991.
rJt- ;*-e.,1: .-i.: .JUl ,.lT a, A i.tL;, S bl-f iJlj. ..:.fJ .\ O
c-.:,|:sL
.,5 ).r;)l))t;J .,"rt-C--"",a1 jl c-;;,-l ,:,'r
--13-,1 '1tiT
White, Haydcn. The Content of Form. New York, 1993.
.u5, y-, .t.5 ,f rtrr "c;;.t4 y b 4JU. jJ,-l J-lT.\ 1
f-e*
Althusser, l-ouis. rcading Capital. New York. 1979
*s
Lenin and Philosophy. London, 1971. pp.203-8
,;\L.6 ,t,-f Jl;t s, JL.,iT il :t*l r * J-l+t'u .26 y f 9 .\Y
.6 , .:*;2tf .1: gglo-tl-- -y'\ :ol rr-W bP;: 6:r"f tc:l
Foucault, Michel. "What rs an Authoy''\" in Language,
Counter-Memory, Practice. Ed. by Donald Bouchard. Ithaca. 1977.
pp. I 1 3-138
J)* u:.-;2: 3l ,-11 ,J-;f# i:-,21: ul.1 ;--l 2: u:litt rUT ;J.t f
.eS.2.c-lt^e(^;
(ieertz, Clifford. Interprctation of Culturcs. Ncw York. 1978.
pp.412453
Grr\ di-f i,UJ2.; J:,1.)- jl 6la-,)\;,-tI 2: aS *, G\bvi;t tt
.6s.,:f
After the Facf. New York. 1996
Lews, Bernard. Islam and the Zesf. New York. 1995. pp.342
YA r ,uK:-
irp .\ 1A \ ,Fr.ldX:- tV +;
-ug-r-JU-r i.r!l' j>t-rrt
2: .C-l .sl:s3i.r: q5l.;,-9 C-^al )l a-c1a.-rT .1:
*r'l iJt4' '\ C Y -Y f f
.c-l iJ .,;l.,,til j!/-1 a-JrU t -r))'oL,t-, oJ*!er.ndT "4"&"
d-1. c-t4V :t F- .stt .r t
.6 :
=t1;,-t1:
At-Azneh, Azz. Islams and Modemiftes. London' 1993' pp' 77-89'
1M-t22.
,;lgl llr-rr<i il.* )Lily
l.,r .rT
1j>{" GV :.t-lyr -i! t
j,.fl Ly a-l
..rlp b :l-tl s blt;;.W q;"{* ))FJ.6r, J":r t-;*.l"-l";
*K, q 11 :li; J/l ;".*f .C+lo:y 4:it- Jt<-l s 6ty C1-t,y dJ^;
.tLtar :-r--r;,r" Jl jt$l!., J f:Alll L.vt )t s 6go! L--2 C-;
o.{Vrf l; .lLi-l
,'a) nlora-i b t" lfdL:? cc-l-,1:L 3 -,1-r,"
Cy-" J^l .1ToL:7 3 o-L- r -,1: c*l cK) J;q 3 J Grle> 6 r-,11
.:.s\Ku. ttt rr jl
t .llr+;-Ls JL Jlj! t &-t;...,L-(..r1-Uf c-*"rlfo, q
i -L-o- +*^.rrl5,r j*:a{: jt ,"-l;l- S: s> \5..L;^1 o:l: JL"! jI
a-a-a
1\.urr.lcfj,
! c;-,1: '{ ;rqr\^<-
,5: .:;l: rtljli c*.,41 r S-3-, * rl ,fu e)l; J\) J eS?
U 6.ll:,_r, ,tE1i 6lola--y 4 "-t -*. u-":yt kJ oj l-., & & y-
\\
J^l jl .S-,L* .uorf ,u j,o:l-,l tlL-l: f SWitt LSJb-ir .*4'r!
.g,tiT _.1: ls u-yb r.eL, ,JL-l: ,r:!j c;l-i ,-l-l-l;
c-i! 6t^&-J .,P
\"'15.r' g-:l: of
6sl-t* i:t{.tl: / o)/ 4s els-1' lf '*
J dU JG-la, ccil: *-L ;t6-lK.9L^;Klt- ;l
a!
'*i tal3; eS
..:-1..r,-iT C*.s y 6; ;tT )l s d.t;.e* .5,-lrr ;;t
.;ulc-*rl, JT cS* ijlJ;l a, d-. ,fu e$ -'t5c't-3;"
;l F:t &T;u.or:--r L c-: o ,-/* g:G d* \:srt +1
-rb ,,>y u,3 j,,L s tSy? oK-r r-: JL- ':ji' 6 cG'* ';*91
"r
y\f u-rc!1,r" J:s sl7 C-* J.Ja,l.J"t;b JL-.t3ir 6';;otS
, c#ry> ro3)\-e * .g*L .+:;: JT e't' a+-- JH t'j oiJJ'\
-U"r"U;
*-1,.5.,- ^S ;ii.*
j :L-l jl 1-9-,!-1 6 o-v' 1i\:L- --1r""
JI^JL6 f I 9tt:Ja-yut.C-l o-u o:7 o! c'ri,.r" ?6 )l G?
-,11
'c* E:l;3
+.Ca3cr!..r,rl
Lj LA )l 6 s* -,31L gs\
ot-S; ta-;T -r: dUj )fi>;r; * jt yt,Sy,
,t-l cV r:;l: :j-3
S:*..c-t,61* .,--ti- 61"1p-l a-:L ubU.&r,.f ,)L.:; b ;t-
g:sLi .-U jt gl;j-l: j oJ:t)-s,r1Laor.6-- Llb..J- JJ dLj jl
u-s:i
i;11-1 1> 614:.t; 3 :J^i I Yf
'.,)-!-
Jr 6A
"y:,. . ;- t
rl,- + g rs+, rS F jU+" J Gi" J;l ir, L^ {f
.5
j
a-.'jl: F-* coL;:L- f elf 3 o[-:L .*l3> cl-,1 rlL:rr
,*--+1-, ;T
+lc*; 3 t*-\tr,, s 6:t c;-r-urK rysls 's-l s
Jt"Jl- J j!=t l-1 ,-*7 o-f : .*-Vs; i >.,2 :,i- r*-S
-l
'6'r "-b
Yr,rr; oL-i
-e :) W d ;"{* g S:K:;-:V L, t .-in bl; )l
,sV:_r ! ,-rt'6 ..,, 4 ., -/. Se9 t (- ,ttr-t .l: :;,- jl ,.f,W; E e
to
),.ae r,-s. f iVs -r c-, l.rj ..,,- E".6 J + e ? f ) ) r -r t**
.
"1,-
..ft-:-l3.;U i Js'yG, Lfr; * C4r.
"t'Li,rt
:rd-3,.,^.*16* 3;rlj g--rb )l u:z-lra5C;t:..r" tt' ,-#.
tab.u;*.,t 1: u-sls
aly-l 2:,g 11-t-t>; -9
:.r'J / f '
t\ l ,.r;*a g-ru,;:3_;t; >t2; 17, jVlr-
ioL;-! .'-".(1'1 u/) urg !!=1 o37 g-;tj ;r-l .,tr s,.
.r,t<.r
:rie cjj- )l u:a-lj)i1_d..:1lr 6\ali 6j\L-,r"i".-* J {,_t^"
.)+(./ Gs* oo.-:311 u,-lf:711-) )JF e5---rl, .rsr:* s
,
u"St O-t{c-;t;,- a1 *j tsl>r--1311 u,-lf: ,- at * 94 }) } I c--j tr l
\
.,;lS s:;[e r,tL;l ,;;* f--: *r .a-la:{l; j;-ri ;-r.i )l
a;-Vy.
i,*-r-oT ;r-l
"Q :: s
e-tT g "1i' -l c(.13 s d.^yt rAti UW-,J,
:6Qr !,L ,llij ,U 6a;.,1: -L-Li .*--r,g o*bi J.:?"1 6,iiF
-lls :F (dLj r-l- t J dU ;: .C*L L)JL-I uoy ,u-L.-1: jb. S[-t
f, r^ dqj'1',-;l:.,,,s j,z- ;G,-gt-ac-il3 s F :t l1 : 3; u' 3i pVZ
lOr'O rn.tcl.* ,r3- rO*5- c;l..ar rE)E tali ca;o ca,i,,L3 ic*L2
i,Bt1- ... C*1.6; rk- cCrr c ttrij:.* cA,aJ cv2.lj c;:1, iC-GirO t ,-,J-5;
c-*,r,-l,oojl-9 slla*.1 e-(-:-ri e*l
)lj; d_,-..s*:3n af c,lj:Jle(L
Lr . ,/4.-1 J;atr-tlu>L- .x*,e4*,Fu-u*t[";.3;,.\1
.AYA_AYV
Olrr-1 1: 6j,:-.)J"" J )J+ / A'
pl-; dl3--: ,jl+Ji 3 -Lilo:g jly: i-:Lr fl5r" os)) ,J-l Alf )l -K-t
'(AY ' .ro (FdL^) x'oJi:3'i'i'
li.r 4lJl6i -f, s ajt s.* o1--;ly-l ;l-u-l;l: rfti-.i*i 6:f arL,"l qt
af c-t o>f c-li'
L ,r-)t-,"| ",c3; o-l .c-; o-:tS irss" l^)i o
_*u-
4a ..ula,;S+t* ;11- .:! .rl ,, ef u{offi j: i;:i
J{u.a5 :,l>,-;b(Bergson) ;r31rs*tS ot,+ a, Jlil y-l ,J-jo)&-J,
.;l,o.rlt- -r q cr;" JL;l
:1 .(fJ c+-."t ;r'-l J"a;.'" *. qSly .\ V
Barthes, Roland. Mythologies. Tr. by unnette Lavers- N. Y. 1972. pp'
109-158
'eS)
Artz, Frederik B. The Mind of the Middte Ages. Chicago. 1980.pp. 360-69.
.eS: c.l-P t, Gtb f J4-r. )-b 63"1*;l*r: c.* 6ty
Arendt. Hannah. "The concept of History." inBenveen past And Fruure.
N.Y. 1968. pp. 41-91.
.glra; .-r,T 'u;l1i_ a{ 6;lj- g:f ;1. y o:-.4 (a-t> '&';P t6r;K 'f I
.V"r.\YAY
.eS) G^)l:.--l:-r cs.t:1 J(i i, sslt 'tl.) J d.b; ;Jij ea .5; '1 1
White, Flayden. Tlrc Content of tlte Fonn: Nan"ative Discourse and
Hisrorical Rep"esentation Johns Flopkins Llniversity Press 1987'
.6: .G*r) )Jr* d--:4;; ls"lX ,*lz t* 6l-; 'YY
e .6AU. V;Jtr.t Ll;:t- x.,r"aa GrU ,, 69? )y- cSt :r,r 'J}r t,.r-l
.Af '-\ ' v
Jy )l e-;: ,-!;; Z:yl t d J"l ! .Erl-,,-, )) (\-rue 0*y; F, f-f
ALJ- 4t:-.',-e- ot-:U -r:t ,rt:,r :-uty.r -l't!,-* o;L-l .-,i<* -t, t,sl-&-t
;i7. crj,-.v r-l- )l g" :l-.4 (\ 1 L,"a) x""l'jl.j../l b &-J- :L-l 3 r)l32
.oT t,.ill; '+)-, b:- I c-'.,.a.6* 3;E ,r-t- Sf cj!
+;
'q* : )r 3 -u;lr.r,
\-t@cular-centric)
"*4 -sy f1.-urr^:, ,l-t,
3 :[.ail-,1-,! U 6-L.:- c*!-j -l c;L: L-* )\ ii.;>
e-Jr, t.-,."1 -r,--r,= "fi o,l"ril .fi 6f ;1:614r" F uo:r,a cc-*!,
;)\\ )f )) ;ile s L6:,-S- +)-p r >Lily 6:i 6:l-r-*t -tL-
-t, ,31Ct,
o(- i ;;r o&T d-rL .>;i ari; Gr)) qL -,, .,*s: tti->
*13; e-|t:131e; il ,5-.(rl/r ) urfe >L 1; yl ,;lf obr
,>f ;s\y o,
".-F Jlr;e:llL Gk"-ti ! f K* ta;; o-fr!.13)14.<j;
JJ,$ 3, ) af-r"I t-r: .c-ilr ,-;- ;l-r,-.: 61>y- a-1; .c-i o-1."I e*l; f t ,t
q\-t -K .
I6 s, 6;l-r.;,t*",
c
& gh- .:br..' ;.:
s o-.
u
r rKr r rjl
J j )\ -fi-r.aE;: .(1f /\ ) to>L--1 1:^;, *-, .'-r3- *i-[--,, ,'*-f;1
(d),tt)l e
O- o\r:*-f o, ,+.- \-a-?, ;, ,r{-, d_F ;, .(t f O/t
.(A/Y ) tr;\ ,\ (-t;T r;l-r jT
C- "Jtr,,!l * .. L: ;T
.l-U-11-l ,;l-, lL c,rJL+l iLa3l jl ,-, nt ti)\1 cQ,l. ,-^bl ;;
,_rl
nlJ-1: .-r,ilorj, :! ;I + )JJ, ,J, ,,, #r: -ui_r. 6--..1 o-,.,f
;> o>f '{s> \ jtr;-* e(JL ,^ 6 si-t: r 6 c,Ujl ;1r,
f
"!316:llii*;J! 6C U3)t;fj;3.:;1r g4,,r:i (JL lf ,*o
&l u-r- *, I t" f , L i s E -r.J ,4. c-l -\r J I r *i r-t e-; lr, a,LJ- -u,
I I
L_
.;uJl:..r".h r
e-r.'*.-* t* n L!3)lofi ,-,1-,1 eJil :> cJ\t* gL f : ;l -r*
jl c*l o)f,u J.-os 31 [ a,Il3r 6;!lji Jf 6>,t\-r
-fi{. .()f J
G> o*-e .Sy;< 1 1; o-eL_ .''!- "U-rl Jl c(1ff /y) ru:t, p(i
Cr-l jl f; .-url;I.r" .:i-J # ,u;K gU, 6-, \: r))\Ks,l)
;u;L l:-* i-. Jl:-r +- l;
,*-r:1 prlr,-l ;L-
,.1: .*;lqg;l,Ss c,L-l-l_,
c-) t;r, Jlj; c.-13; t f b ;^F L..e>i.rb-cl t_; y.i-, J 1A-,j1,;*;1.
t' s\hs >3- *.Jl; oL*l: ur*a.r;lr .1-, ey
+ d("
f
::f ,-[3"U ;t,51-9l.ir:- t +.! 1; c rL(- ;1 f l-, -r'-L- 3 -i'lo>l>
"!il
,4, c^Ktr3l a.l.Il-r-.r ti* Jl.," ;, ..::Ko, ,fu u.-a )c a\ a{ ':-l
c*> 4rL -t -K &y..---r
dJl-r.r..,-,.! o-,h 31r16;t 4iL* lr
.'"q+- :c*,1
'1 :\JlJL4;1 -,: ;:})rll eV :-L-b jt$,
7--r,-rl,--ll'
J;A)$, oLitifr$ t dL.UtJa 1-r gllrt &-{Z7.'L_L L 3 c-l
$!-J JIF n,-rl;:" L::, 1:l .!ld[- \tJ\a-'aLaf 6lr, jl, 6 oai 6
.(rv/r )
:t il-fr-r 6.*klr ) Gyo &-*t,!3)l6fj.; 6h! jt s_,L*
) c"l; +_'tJ.rr- ,Rt.rf* sL-L- -r;1.-r,-r 3l i;[;: F-* *
GV clr s-r i-,!-,, 6or r! fi, ;:Vr utf t s!3,e tt*a.
a ?l y G f , >_r:" r-9U:l 1 ;lL-o
): 1 r 6 *;l : )V t r,-l: .qd
&_r.l.J-,- t.c-l )-rs sl -3-, srr 6;L;l ,-r-r;> t rjaJ.f
.rall
.(q,\/t ) n.:F ;l c-*r31;- c*"1; ,-,1;,-r cua,=-i;
+ cao -r,11: tLt .,:;L ,r(, "gjlr; f"t; 1lr,.lafc^-il-, y-l .ll
-,:,!* ) -f- ) g;;[.^ r> 6;;]gLa c.-+ # c="ol,r, ,A -b
ao "!3)l;fj; sr,r-S os_ra tl-* ,-r-)jl Jk.f t dbr c!17-t
.Jtiq 6)- ,s..1: or-)L b ,-,-,.r -rlF -,s ;I fb c;L y_l
g-1";.c-K* rrc,.Jl lil)): rr *!L- c-r !U7 ,JL*iI ti 6u:rS
-t"r-- o3i jl g;1-* rstani--r 6;K 6 c--t gE :! ;11 c;g,
;.: cp:jl.:.r" ?-p )\ uVl, SJ" t, n* o_r-f b 6cl, ,r-.r:,tL-l>
e(,, c;t$* 6t^>f: JtJ ,l t: ,tf : S* 1.6>\- ,tL-t>
.-ijlrcr I v ur^b:o ;KsLil
.:y "!j)lafj;c(.-, c;L i; -le .:!
-,, ;:* c-r.,T h-il b 4a.:l
Ci 1J
r;Ljl.a(i,Jt+t 6P ,oIxi-$) c;L n,
r,.tt3-,r" Jt-
cc.,eL rrit-llo e, a, >y* ..re L:rl ..i!- Sll.
,l 16 y c,o,lq cal
1: ,r,-l-oa; -rrl -r..a .c*l -u;L; .,!)\;l Sl*--b J et-i p et
a-f
6lr- ;l-l t" tst ot;r"q rf J -L-q,-j J Vl-rr c-;* 6>; q!*
L-a 3:l+1. o-*'t ,lf t Ll c.r,;lr o-r;rL ;i 6r; ltrf
"fL.:rl
.c-t-ar:_-r":l af C_l +1".1:t c!3)lofj; j_ro;
,y ol3 *..-rj.,1-r-.,-
l, ;L;l G-J,.rf 6*i;..,l.f*r l: t l-r L.:1l 6Loa-i-r:l ,rl:,c/
"f
,tlrr,:,4.i,:-L>; 9 ))2; l 2'
"!tr
2\ /:-r,;r'Ur!l;f-ri 5J-.: ara; )V\)-
":;K
j,t, .s:lS o*-Fci* 6-r;-r,l r olt 1^,3 1, 6 oK ,,^l
'rr"
;L l;-aif c--.3 '7 r;t,"-'Jt;"\ n--{g t.ll>,s- coye bT}t ) # i
.(la/t ) e*cff: Ll-*,r^,*,c
61-, fj) S\^\.s o!,,tU ,g."T:6 rri;> r!3)16fj; s4:l f f
jlij ,J-*"1;" q;I tt c,u:.il: e(; r,,r-oL*l i:31r,
"l)\_;t ,L(-t
?d / :t; _, ,U_rYl;fij >t4 oarr, lVi-
L-s s
-pW 6"-!rt"t t4.; d gT;: 6* rs,U 6:W s -r,-_i,:,.Jq c-ulr*,
.t'fe p-t- ;;LL- .-(_ ,_*t, ,U3)t6rt$ g;tJ3l .c-,t;trt;
,-u.*; :,r.
? ,b c--c l*- t pr^,o U -U Jf n:- j, c(L
-,1, 6 ,i,
I l-,1 r,
o.Jt grt ,olyl r6f- > 6l-$ c.-tS.-.l: '(rrr/t ) n-u-Li 6;:13
r) (:r) :1rf et*.r,/J -!t, 1-56*t o[n il;U d s, J )))
jly .f r*ae ff ** sJ-lJj .6tj<jl f*lf J q>; eiL
"*lf
g-,tot gt L--,) (f.n) s..-re \, o.s f l.-\:"IJ, d,,:.! r.r,1 .;l- La ..tf
fY I 't+r'Ur)i;fii )J*i {r+, iGlJ-
.S.r^U f :
l-., j;Jl i : \-y'r* s,
c,s 3
t ib,; ) Jt* .r- .ss* 6a &Trt )s.: r< --:y ;tili, :J:=-
(\ \ di \ ) n.r.j:l:,r^ ;rkttt rl -rj.r,.-,+.r 1 tf 6 rW;
p, .-K *-" e l, iT ii 4fu :;tKl) t! l; G-*: ue tai c
-rr^-6.f l; !, : c-*:JJl d\ I : -r,T-.1, ,r(,- ,ra olKsi 1l a5.:-l
6;1:*-i u*--yt f t .Srtrrg C*3: Li: C-;4 i c^K o*.\.s c;-
.(Vf /\ ) n-:-e,, -,11-r,-; l)if;-r-(i 6 sr-S:t- ,:--'r-7
13 it-fi-1!: 1,
^i e U, -,156rj:
Jt la;; d rQj)l;fJi JVv?
;a.tSu.Lbl .rt - e F-:, a-S ;-jl J;lar-! -,1: t rrlK6"
..r5,:r;tU- 6 C-r )t e of -r;-r;Ur-.r-b t l; c*t- )l )l;-l
.rt--ra ,'S g-t:1e .hG *. 65s .[:sr.# ':T '1/\ ) rrJ:v
(\
.-rJg- ,AL. rs\^si gd f ty jl ,r(- c.re[':-l ]tJ jl c;03'a:
JjlSi:- ,t-lrt:.t: s,t-i,3*; )1 u--,-. 1sy rt>12-3t SeJt)
o."a-: u:;;"G;:1 cJriL 011 e(U;lt (E)t-|3) ,ll7l dl'i:*.1"--t;l
?\ / :t;J,UJYl;rSii tJ+' !1* 1V t
,-
c-{? jl j[irt-" L c;-f..-',1t, :--ap p:o pl"rfU &_1; *1.*? jtr -r.i-r.-7
.rL--le(--:i q,sT :j, 6;Ljy j r;:,.J .t=1.l_:j." ,tU^,-llf;T
6.-a
.,i-t(-.,1: .(Y 1Y/ \ )
r3j* Jl;,' I
rrJ-2b ! r g.rY .ry .rl_j'b
"[5tr
J, t Krjlli- ,r:.cL*: \tSrUr rS6fr+,-"f,-,
ef"uT-.lr ,-*
-t3
Goldziher. lgnaz, Introduction to Isla,rnic Theologt, Tr.by Andras and
Ruth Hannor.
.r;3I;, oVt* * b# t -r,_f: L s* G)frr 4t.-.,,1 -ti..u;3ly.V
/
)ly-l 1: 6,1;-:.r^; 9 :-u / VY
.6)
Brown, Norman, Apocalpse and/or Metamorphosis, Berekeley, 1991, pp'
1 82-85.
',,:-:1.t' t rhly :.r*; iJL.-.r*:t: ,S-tl-::S: d:!LLcrfl .-9Ql'-.1: 'A
.6 ,JU" 6,111 .'')) {''}; JT
Toulmin, Stephen, Cosmopolis: The Hidden Agerda of Modernity,N'Y',
1990.
.,-ri; 4; s) o'-r)ss 5n; (-t J elf-r: J;- ;.lt;: ,rf F.-*: cSlr
6)
Elias, Norbert, The History of Martlers, Vol'l, Tr. by E' Jephcott, N'Y',
r978.
.6,; tsJz.j;: rrqgll-t Ja LgL' '1
Jay, Martin, "scopic Regimes of Modernity," it Vision And Visuality'
".:"arr
J Jr:,|
. e j"a: ;.:- J; I
.,.)I.-l ; !L :,! r J d/(J ja 6lr1.f A f _f V 1,lL{j
6)
Nicholson, Reynoid, Ibid,pp. 3-20
crk5y- )t -fl-, ,5 ,$-T ,s_r."!,r!r;fjj o[-l: -u+ jt 6dr:",jT . \ f
o-UF S.e,lyf.<,-;:.c*et :,Utf qtt' +lJ;l-,1: G:*,.tL;a;
Lr;:;r-;--l ;:;*J a.-:l-l .-rL-l>.;Yf: f. ,t*lj*rt*-f s ,4
Ll ..r"T cj* j;*;_l ! ;*,r , U< j*
! & ?\ 6)s.s.c_.-,*L.
..rKit ,- osQ- Lr>.)r,.:T 4r; I -r,-: L ,y,ls 6
-T ,1 )st.(- U r; ;
2s \ sj> ;f 6l ciK a,,.1 .f"rl&jt^; c4 J) t-.r,t u t r c;K
^t|, 6t
..u:!;t'AI ;t;;7"L,1 .5-r,-11 ,tta.rl: -r,-L vf lt,itjilf:rtU!
.q1 l-, l-,-rL:y l;.5T q",l+ ar* Lsl;;K , c;tul lyo.1: ort>- t+!2
.14 .f .JJl LrS-icl*oLarr...:; 6,:T l_t "-,
f F
K;-la, "!3Yl;f;u ;t ret,*f u*JK;t4; t:3; LrL.;: cs.r:T.l o
*-li-o 1 t-:< ,5;r, G-lrt J)
E! r, .rL; oT 1: 6.15,r, 4illl i 3 olul
.d5-2 :f *;.s iV:-.tqrq F.rL^ jl
,r,-l-:3,
Attar, Farid Al Din, Muslim Saints and Mystics: Episodes_from The
Tadkirat-al-Auliya, Tr. by A. J. Arberry, London, 1990.
)l:T )lLe dc*l -b e-l t )tLe LU ,sdl dJ,lt.9klti,;: 7-t ,,-.j.1 l
.6-, .c-;l:,-r,
"f* i.-J"ljl (+ ,r*{--;t, ,;
Meier, Fritz. 'The Spiritual Man in The persian poet Attar.,' in spiitual
Disciplirles: Papen From the Eranos year Books, N.y., 1960, pp.267-304.
,p:: JL-,-15,-f-; ,n6r:K 3;:tf L;<i<t ,-(tlg r6-:,K .lV
.\ Y V .r.a c\ 1"1 1 tt4,g3: i-2L-l
18. Thomas of Aquinas (1225-74)
William of Occam (1285-1349
.eS2,.u*bif 't*:l*lca .5|1 .1 1
Artz, Frcderich B, The Mind of the Middte Ages: An Histoica Suney:
cllJil ;: 6j-;-rJ+ J )Jai / Yf
Blumenburg. tlans, The legitimacy of the Modern Age,'h ' by M' Wallace,
Cambridge, 1988.
&, t, i ,:K_:t )l 6;a -i : CY Otj:"-r' o* lK-ts.jl.,;J 'Yf
"*;31."r.;:l: l3;! ;il;s * 3 'Eil: c-: 6)\>
J<--ytl t,+ri J!:r .r!-
,F t .e 3 6r,K-' "4;3 )> "-v. ;VT 6tf;z' ,J-j f )l
6 t6*'i;
"16:g g-, o>t$; raLl 'r'-'l-7,rct: ;'lx g;q icil:
f{' ,r'-' * ,rtu
qllra: c6;;'.j;61.l;L; L,-f+ (GWI Jtrl .6; x',fg *-l-6 ! 9'tl
.\-\.'crc\YAV
.62 co)z* O.l Jl^.| ,.:- 6!.Yf
Kolakwski, Lesdzek, Religion: If There is no God: On God' The Devil, Sin
1r
.-:-(,1, J rl-q 4b :t 6 6*-LT r,!*l Jl,; JJ.: )) j4rt) Ls
lt
",5-lr-,6-r.,*,
ca,LL CE:.r* c;L u!)\;; *FA.)JJI -\,--r,,
o:t* c.:-ilr
ls: 9l )l .*.i-. J, gly ;r 6,r-.;0.:L ..r- ,l .f 'b t
I
.r: l-, t".rT 3 ,{:* & s6,srsly c-l s> 4.;i: u 'r,! oK
6 c\j.l c,)J,.; q L UT .u-t1 cr,"t-- :* t.5v:*.;;lS g)lt;lyt7
,-* * ! 'p5.r$ ':r a tr ''rT :: :-t-'i ''t-tf *.s; ;;;;
3 ai--rJlc;L r oV 6 +-: f.^lJ, Cl-'bl S-l a' r;V(*.,ui,.!:
i.E-.J ,iT )) ) )y. rir-; jU"".^ s ya d,k.7 dJ!-i jl .9"r^- glij
i-r^, dljr'i: 6\s:l { t fi oT )l ss-t
d q:t c,,>.,-;b
"[,rl1lc-r
AK*--; )l tti 6,Ju cs-212^ cs:V;, ,u,.5*y )i ,;-e J;r),
* &-f $i -s: l-s Jj.,,\..,T: gi[ c-::i; ,iL:<^g J-yol * C,f
''-1 JK
Cllu-,s-;: cUt:.-l 6-tf fg a:-il: cq5-t^- ! jt"jf^ o Ga.
tt.rr5o-2t-i,l jU jl ,r,:l o:Li:-l Oss-t' * r$;t:*
g:r, if ty
)l-Li ;S- J--t ,g3-s t>l "v; \ of )-ts oU ,:;r 661:,r"
jqj ki * 6tti o,YV.c-l;-!-'*f u.(lf tsss ,1*-ru-lfy:
; ,rrt^:-71 ,r:-,o -r)t.i* J .iLli 6ll-* L5t^a+d I Jl-)s-."| i
)lJ.l 'r)Jr; cis-l )l 7a. i ru,-lf:j'.c-![ oll d-,L:l a, A JLl 6:S
rLa:il rC-L- cosl'vf J, f.6- ),cl a,. (self-assertion) 6: jt :9- j
c-f# u>-1U L<.i a, a:*.;l-r.i cJu:*il:.r^ olf l J:fL l-2 .g,r^- a,-51
6-u":,r" dL":.; OI;.J<J 31. ,.l.619*- : )S- r;, bl^(*.-E-j;l: crrL;,l
b jr)l:\ J -Ui;a 6r&- fa;6;trl r.rl:-u;. jl 6r!*i Jg,J>VJ
r. ' - i
,-L:-i,.-;..rr cJ>2^ ,1) Jg *. u*l \l5rl_: ag-r.r-cJu:-*;I:,r,_,rI-Ln^.r,
I1SU lral
jl .r*e. g;l-ru- oL-:L^ J--Wjl -r, L c:y t,S ;T ;:* 3
,t1r.,-1 ;: 61-:-:.r-?=i 3 ,J..i / Af
d,- Llp-r >-r4 af-ury alS c-\ J :^lil r'r;':-9r >'u'i ..r'i
Lt.:; l-r
7l ; u* s > -5 t,,fu
i y" r -l rs U)- ).r-rE,J 3 e3:"U r;
-fi-, . \
61r.. is\ 15U':-*1 .l Et(,.t-t I j> U.-l ,:-lr- -r> .,-Ll -$ 6-tr'-
ojLt 3 tf $\.:llE-;16lojb 6--r\lr.lr
-Fe :> cr;1,! b :l>
.-r.:L ,Jly-l .* ---r, 6L"f-, Ll re.iU';ly .L>\"; -t'--i'-
A0 / ol^E:t- c:ra 3 4jru >t4 e,.4 ;li\-
o(!, !!.r )r L?f Gt rKl ,,i- dt-t, s> ) u:f sss t>r.:o
.t-f ;I.1'rv se) nc*; ( Frjl-r ok+ n-,,3 {rr ,l lr 3l o{:-stt
11 sl 6*yr*6r:lJ-;".A*re;*'b,c
oj1,, qgLo+i--l.ilj A12V
*rr.r:ilrrr, jq, *j.-f-l-r: b **c;-r,ci jl G;/..JS6,lr'T
-,1: :f Lo:l )li ,g
,KaT ,g-1-*t .' a.;) )l ,-t r- ;rl f l,Jf -p
.t' sts-s ,SFJs.ttg":- Lgt^ailJ,-t OU*I(JJI "t ;t-K- *;'1
6 rf (r oc*r jl .r!- itr-tr 1: oly.r, ,5$;oy;t S-l $ll*.
l-1
ot- a,u J,.L; oSC*t; jl )l j :-s-9i GJrs );; (&LdU -rK)t, .--l*,
t-+iT .(V. ,r) t-uL ,tt-- c-.n^q 6 ty ;f s+;i
-J,
J) p J f--t-r,_/ l) o:i*.)).9-r+.gtojtf;3U*-t; s u.u-ys
(o-L+r- 6a;* ;:g
J"l -S I co3)Lc a, .J5,s,.-/- c6'r* c-(; ,-t-L; oj
nuLll:: SFti r-r!;:,r-c-rr L.9.t*-Jl-t--r-,1r 61',-r-* l-, e;
:^gd; u",KiT ,ul6t -:3; qgLra.;-ljlil ef s p ] eb ) tt
(interior .ad-:' c-Fis-,t jl .,;tr.r"." :
1E| &-rJl-r-;16
.c*lmonologue)
L ^Jt- Ft .ti ,s-L- ,-fu s-ts7 y W caa;; ;l ,glx f j-
sl S:G J ;-fctU:-r- t o5Fl+"# jl *tq e.(,- ;l y,6.1---111
(cg:i ;9>1 ilylt jl ;LI3 j5;
J-l F I cC+l :J>.:" itL*il "-l-i o!
s _y ,tl ," 4*J d.p!) dr)tc. y ;^Ku^ 6 1-:sT:L- a1 ,*y J-* l-,1
ra
,oli L 0u*t(itfu^A,:,lll jl ,K" ,* "6jT j- iT
ct-tij,rr a-1,
.r19T 1^:, q oJto. 6- ;t ,gto;,1',.tt;-;;K; L;Kle t ,K;cnq jl
e
,rr-Ji 6t^4-:"--r i-r!-.r) q uK Ot i J:; ,'tj :! ;: 6*- eaii
^+T
alp; r,l .9-r*- n5;jU; d/-l li .d-*i cr.F,-sr $l4r< lJl:--
l-1
+-S 6 :f V>t oli e.rLJ_+ .(Af crp) r,.r5.; J-r., ,--n ,_*
,J'K, g:l-u 6-.lJi \: oiGsatt+iT, *"T d \?-f;: c*-jceJLL
,Kf ;.rl; t-l cl.j, 4:d 6Jtu,.1t"J3-.,, 4JtL i,i| cc.rlT_l ;r ccj[
s\ ts c)y )J>j pj)rt" af,r,t, ) cS-. J-l 6+-U 6/-: ) :y. ,.1ts)))
jl erjy i-l- L .l:l-r: tal 3 c;Ldl=.S,.,rtj i j3;:g e
.-r_P:,t'r.:tFy
:J*i dL-.;l 6tLS)j:3>9 )lr,ln :-* ol-* a, +lLL f t rry\o 1
l-,1
)J\ )Ji t-d, 4.;.(Ar) (J:4 dr-r, *.Al r{;t *,-,*ts jtsr >_i
dt', ru\y-blKu". i ,.r{.r-t o+lrll9-;5a, J c*l r; tS aS
! J^lr.f dJ J c-*l ot$lr.-t il: ,r_*.(Af L',) JS$" t', c{J,
t';1: c-(Lu r,;uf*, c.^,jLM 6f , r.1,, C,- ,.-,--f e 6'5
JJ+3 t ,-l :JU ,iJl, oT;: l., oL- ...-r-:;,-*1 ." t b Jl J c))
t i<b 6FeSJ- lf.ttrt..r"U.c^,.1,1:r, : J*, ;r;--.4G
'i*
6\ r c*r SyS ! b .t - L t_rf 3 -.f ,-;
"4&-K- djq;
.(Af r-[jl-Ut Lj..;; p \ &r jl
"rp) lq J _U-L rl-d.-l
t- ,-rjj,_r
-,- ,j^L- jl 5, ,6 -S I cc,L t(> .r-l .rk , ,r-r,
1 Sl 6l-a;-1*l I &, J-f "r*K- <-, ,J.;,.SL-, c*) 6aJ )l GILL F I
.(l,f u"; {);q {-l-i ,l:*.1 ;lyl stl att t$\;K;s\g o.)s\C.j -rjlcJl'r'o
Jll :! >)-r )) s-3-, f# L(: ! E>ut ;l ,l'" 'ltaLi ,l ,--L- ; I
*-Ss ;r-t 7)l.a- 2: lr J!^eG J e<L lV. -1: Lc*l J.)J; f5e
j J-ojrr 6 n-fg13y-u, cdVs.JL-A.r: aA.urrf ?lf arJ d<L
) .ri.".S { Jlf--, ) )F I GKs:6 t.r:z +! cc-la:--ti c.,:Lp
sT s: c-.--o\ Ct4- j c.-ot-L 6Us 6Ju+ r:l r"F.u-t-b
t)2;'A jca
6Ju ); c.K*-U rr"tl-o[-:U- Jr;ar./! t: S S-&-t L<j
:t ,$ g i:,6rJ,-t jL^ .c-lrltoL; J)ri c-^c.t)*-Jtfrl ''-4a ;rLrr
G\i tct-l*- t-JT .ul6;* f';: 1) c.-o-s c-:^-61 -,L .1: 6h:-,1 ,, I
o,
yarsh a ter. E hsan. ft e r, r, i);' iii)i;*, ro*)',,i,jlil tr:;;
Cambridge 1988.
.\ A^ oa r\ yA \ r,llrg rJl- .t;: .rrr_*
Jl;", .*;*" (Lsy:" .\
r\ YV \ r.rl_p i\ .t)- cu-yLi o:l 1:
1t4,.xC-*{qr_t&n r;l+ "lrdJlC<L .y
.\ aY .r
-t: :L.s.. Ll tb-j.t':'lltd/-l .\ A s,a r '\ YVF ol_# rg.r.* ccL) cJ-jt .f
.(+l o.ru; ?4 \ &.^; Of;fji;f*u Lt-.'_
u)sr"l
\ uo.l- Ol^^ c.t>3e )l J- t .O
.\
;zS: 6taT Glj;* dpi :t .eSy c6t- Z2L.2t 6jur"l Jl)b) j> 6\..\
c\ Ylf rdL+, rp:: .rL7 c6-1.*
"r &.* rSi .1,13;_L5c-! p3_r+
'1r- Jl- .uL.tlr'l .t;t'-t'|J L5-lutr "J*,k-+ .<^ j_.* r I yu_if O
.V. f-11 \,," . \ 1AA/ \ ylf
6h*b c,l olt_i
:\y, s rL-q.- 6la"t Lt- 65;;K 66T G;; u)gl, _ )tW GlrI i1fi,
c,,il:-:L 6l*Pr;", j;L f;.,, .r-kt J-* ,s-1..=- ::l:T
e.;u-L rr
(reader UU- - o'uJl3*;n aL"*--E.Jjl{,i 6llD :JL rr:[ o'-l -l: '\ 1
.t^qrL o,l c* GIJ .i>y -tlrs*t dls\S ,ys.t )l ft 6tll- Jr oriente)
(norty; u7:.1 dl;- *..6;
lul;5;:
Eco, Umberto. Interpretation and Over - Interpretation' N'Y' 1997'
:7-6s ,1g'fi t '-llstt
a-F S a-lss I gJj-- At:
'*.
Miller, J.Hillis. Reading Narrative. Norman' 1998'
:a, e-f; r6L;l ,,.o--ll J rr- Jk ,t dV'4 t:- 6'lt'.
,--* d -t, i
Rorty, Richard. Contingency, Irony and Solidarifl' Cambridge' 1989'
:\.6s t*-ir-t 1e-(-)\frr 9 xs6*l'11 6 G* e'* qgl-rr 'Y '
Bloom, Harold. The Western Canon. N.Y" 1996'
:t.c5r .c-,1 g-r-@ ;[I ;e-.r, ,F * ;t & u:' oKT ' j-Lv l-rt-" 'Y \
:is
F-riedrich, Hugo. Montaigne. Tr. by Dawn Emg. Berekel ey. 1967.
:*..t5;6T.ri;U ot(-g -9
4Jl,a" (<,- i-_rb 6taa.:,J csll .y \
Auerbach, Erich. Millesis. 1942. pp. 249-2:73.
:1 .CtJ ,.,,[
-,-_l^ ) AV"4\l-) &- qsl,r,, .y y
Anderson, Imagined Communities. N.y. 1993.
.c-f; r:.ui ! ,:I !, 9 c; j 6la+:"--Ul .,3L, +-e s;yJl, C,a 6111 .yy
:AJ
Weber. Max. The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. N.y.
1959.
6\11\ ;> 6P).r+ : :-r+, / \''
- -K-' ud *T- c-,.r-rb ,tqj ;gf 3: dr-tjt .r(_ .c;tS ,tS +.611t 6aS 3
"*DrL-,t
;:efc[il:,i3l 6l-aj;.t lc-l -G:&3l o3)\c!.rrc-l ):*lI*
c,r-LL;-o : a: .6-t x.:;l: 6lu 15lajJ-t-;l ! .l-t+-,lt^ :4:d-J.=, jk
d
.\ \ \-\ .1 .ra 6iOYA.JL,.d 66-r& cs<> .)F
*- ) 6[) o;L;:;YG. \6;Ju j gst;fi,a.;9a:. cu,-L"erUC-r.Of
.f 1V-YAf cJz.\ YAV ,ol-.,# ..r-L ;R-2 29ox ,5yTrf .rg-t*
ulo-u-i_9S'6;11_l 2: e*$.- *.
'c-:ls d J"l jl .,>J .0,
l;
6-il-L. cJl.-
j-p yTOr* c-;,* 6r-h; + JlsJ;;El, i-!-o: o;Ja 1,rJ9,r I r,.:--Yj,
;: ts .ul^; ojr^ 6 7:f +;_.r;l1y cj-f.r, 6lu gp) t-"_Fg">$ ..rr_-
5:-: t .ef, .c*l (-i-6 i,_Ylu +'U ,-irfy ((4r; cJi; )t e , e:;
.a\4i f yJJ- .6.r*- ..1.."t f; .(15J.e;6f ;: c-)3u ..rJ" r,r">t-)t
.Y \-\ cr.\ f 1f
.4, f ,y .l-,Jt^ q3t* .>LJ_{.d lt
,t!1i ;: 6;-:...)J".i J .)Jni / \'Y
e(,- ;:
f-, ,tlll ;> cl..-rti "r+i -l G'"*Ll" '=-!G .:L13;
-,i Ct-> ..-- ^++ 1, ;ly-l !U;l3r i .-1,1a:;l > )) 6l;-tl4S;
ilL rt s-&-, r +-1/d 4,"q j-d G-p )\ ts- e f .-v;t>o,
ulet ,--" l) c)-o;U, ; ?-f J) -* ,![,.f o:-lS G;sl>*-L;*
'r)U-. J-l dJJ) 6[a4i-; 3 -r;:-ilr,r"
. u;-rl> c-"-Vs. ;*{ a, Laci"KU
i-;..>l o)-1
e-lJ,5t-".r-t-r" L-i -*t fi
r-,* e;>-\, *-ts.rf tlf
;.--...-;t-tl*.L:,n.5,!k* 3,-;LL ;k-l>n -:,\: fT*.1* *t
: StQt ,G-r..: -S f 69 u'Vl;:
, i:,-13; cl 3;''*;i/
iir^ l,"l .c^-; ;l-jt ,rl-,.9Li, Jg : ,-*Vt) I ,L! r ,ol:, u!>lslg
.(or
?ted\ *1 djr-, .;ru)l 4J(-
"r;
).'G)e * t' 6tKg:b ) 3.si1f LK-.lf a:- ) l)#- 6>
C ,H -r5;: .r,ai- Etj'l er:l: c.Jl-> -tl ls Csy ,ero, \
:-Lr-y..rr y \ A-u5,r,
./lr -r oU31
,tr-*: J>t- I &! s ,? u.gtKt-., (r)_f
"*4 J oer-;s S,]F 6S: )l fk gr, l -,,,-q 4.-,-iq.,-
.(t. .r) -r:-r.i lr U-L;i c;.;-
u") -t$.?"<
t' jl f- s :r'a*,y t ./15ij!*.9 -r,rr
t'
t
'(vr
c+) r , tbJ.Fi, 6;lj.rl SFlt:;*"$ glJ,l
e_Jtj + ei \-S
)) &, rui., qJL .r-a:ia + {.ry s#-, .c*l O--qr! qlylg rr)t_l
U .-fok rc*l ;:L I t-r,, l1 ,JLi".l r,Jtit*n :*Ko..i}-l
;.*a r o.,1Lil
.o;l: o-;L;l ,i Ciy d,:r$ 1;31 clAnl,ara; l-1
.rrlK ot^+;
qcjJtr* t l-r o:rL:; 6 ri 61,,L- k" Jb,
e)-r 6:s\V
;l*g-f Cr: 6L.l U(Jtp-; * .c;-41o,1 av6f
ic(
J )_f -* J;p ,-r:-o* ;l;,t-Y j l* +.<.1 t 6 xtls>
4t: t^>Uo,69;l-ii !l_*l:;* jl
dtJ,:tC:r rLf: tu c>.*1
4.i (),;i +! .-,"b ip ;Ut af;t_x: .:!t ltj
g*+ EJb
ft-l:; o.'-{*.6.? i.stl*;ll\ s G\:-r.l ,r,-l;Ir(J c : e
)\ 4s ^t;:T ,*;.-r.ilo>y,
u7 s ./ a-:-rf;bt-:rt,
=-Lr
.(f ' t '-:1-r; ,l; ,rS slt
"";
6ol- ef eV s s>le:s\ 6ki-L- q Jl- ar r' t'(Jl6*l
J4iu cl-rt-;l r>y g;rL.a:!l a-f-r I .lF "fy ,1+'-l c-.(- r) 4'i
s;9. usa* J E Jl; .:!3f L g* >fi;r,i,n:'r--;r,r' ':;l.r
?ls, s,.:LrJ- 3 .:!f Lr, .r-+ Jaf I tSs\-t J (f 1' ',")
r:{
.*lrr I x6L3; or c,-t j) 4V ":! ei-r) 6,* f ;,, fr, t6t^it
t JV ,y-rr,-rl- Ff'(\Y1 "r) (rroLr; --,.:",-i, &--bc-r
:3 -rar gLL 1-, t ln" .rLrlrt-f nf -ul ;I
t>9 ,a39* ,;. 6 c)\.:t -*-i grlT t Jt* crr tt "':{ 6f}, 1tS-
..:i1: ,'al-,raL-c
! +L ; &.:y.g !l-, jly.: -,<* tib-,li! : l.^q-{*
'1-(i-
\o1.4 4,- .q.<1 f ,W -P :> s -j:f c- &:- s;)s-r
.(ff O ,r; *r1: ;1r,! ,Jl;L ,--,I..:-(.a
,,-rLr-,B.iF jl .-.irL, J st;t- 6\Pl.ot-g-f o4l;
f*,
.,(1 +T.r ,.t; f 9J b ci* ci:-,l .-ui,& gt@t1t;:
dd[a ,rf
J dl&iJ-u! S ty.;--l ,.11;.1 , ?-f ,P g:\-*;tf-,!t
j jl
,t L^,r-(; J\J sr\s +;k-l e-Jt t ily-l 91;1'r-.*!-
",.-r "'-o
G.:\;- up b. q- c(. i;V-tJl L-s,t,; oG ss-P ''rj>l.: c*:
\ \1 / :-r'.;.r grly'lp--, :t4 17; l?l-
i s
1996.
Lewis, Bernar d. Islam a.ntl the Wesr. N.y.
oJ-X {"iJ; ?p :: (Moderniry*) :.1*; i;L;:
r;l Jt-.u7 r> 6.r*L. .y
:.6.; r:-t-; JlJ, $lte& 6l-r,,.-Ll).&:"
Giddens, Anthony. The Consequence,s oJ Modeiziry, Stantbrd, 1990.
.e5-.; ccJ j
l9ptu uz_14 a\r d& 15t
Andcrson, Benedict. *r*:,J r.*:,::,,,:r,"1",t!t
r nndon. 1ee5.
..,, .\ f A Y r;lra ,&.u; J e)t ;: xst&d'rl ' F;,t cu:;z=' c4;3;9 '6
.YV1
.rS.1t>l:">3; dJA + s ;d :> Oqj rr- i;L;: ili;;: t...2 6lr' '1
Rorty. Richarrl. Contingency, Irony and Solidairy- N,Y' 1989' pp'3-23'
.c) .-l
is
Calasso, Roberto. The Ruin of Kasch. Tr. by W. Weaver. Cambridge.
1994.
.osi n;"is 613lS 6.9a1-s;9 ,--a-r. Jlt' :::l ,-..1, ,
) ,-rV o6 i;U1: .\ 1
:a, .e-f.;')f.
Savyory, Roger. Iran
Savyory, Iran Under the
tlrc Safavids.
Safavids. N.Y. 1980, pp. 91-103.
;l c-,r:;l> rt LP t.c-i-.rb
ct:t-\2;.,-o 3 cr:- 1 c"-t3; .K1
cjl .r;,-rt*+ ;1-t otV 1 L- c6j1; uU: ;oi c-!L 3 c.-L.q#l3
.:f ol; o,
&; t b .[i -r::*l;,r, tsrcl ,lrr;bL:, -&-, ,;)t*4'-
l; :f c*!* ,k .t-& r.f-r" ttgl6l.6.:sr+, rl1l -r,L; t l-*
,)t<.- ot-Cr:* U-r.r .r.r! elf-rt: ,.!,, 1.\ oll : *S aFf,
:6 x{o, b.:l rly, af * l rlt ,L_r-.ue3 o, afi5*.! L[f
-f ;:
U 6)tae \-..ll
-b;, dLKj; t.ty-L, ...p U-t,r,t^, j *-ty
-,,-! Vf 66-p e,Ll: .lr dl'l-i,;l .rF Gy, t' .f-it .ll
Y \..-it, Lt-
J*" CI )!) tu.l-e,
#l_,rl:
jb 0,x,4-lI o,t:'lf Jl. # rlr-,11r,3 oe .9t tt:,-l1sJ) (o3ye 4J
.uf sl )l .s"-*f )
\, h t-, ,-r;t Itt ) c-,r-b r-r-,r" &S :yr.,:;: oli a* 7
&ls.rhr,-!-,il gt L-r; jl .5 \? p s> ,:--S,n-a; iq:
:.r5..r" tc:oi
a- j.: ...o.rrl; > 3V $g osV s ,F il6r: .l y_l o: y I
"p
j'.r
6tS .r.6 ; ctt S.t-;u;-, 6la-.yt-rj1K) ... J$ otS,
c-*> es)...ry e;qitsi-- .:f .1U! G:*- .-r:51> <f :s S of
. >
:5; + r,; .,f
I l.: .r"_1*.6a fo
-t tr c<. rt c<? g t<.^ -f :*
gr-u! ! ...5; ..r;L k+-f al o, otK; ;rT
lrT,J,
*t.*I.t {r-r5,r"
ujls! l)Iofry c-.r--- ) ? t--la
_r, lr dr-l .)-1;. ./l.*Clr -hV ot-i, dU.,"
e-y )l
"r.:ilr 16.rf ".lr
b F ,f.-,
G--r- )l Bl o-,rL:, ol.lr./
t' *Urr- f-, 6fa;-
t* lt, u- ,.>V...i-,-tl OJ ,, t' 1, $rr:*r:,t.:;ti- i'rrc
+i ol-tV e-\ s> i*,.f L-..r*oke ? t -L"!Jl- d,"t sr.af
f l- Jt- L? )t &.6\1 g/-)V s :-b JI t'lr K rKt * ,Rt .rf
ils-;* g- JU-ri C-F:\ ta aK * :s: isT af -r,to:3, sn jr dLs
.dl-U Q5)t} dLl JF 1, u)s? 6a oU C-6-r-y,,'ti 6;!;,7
! oT.fUl rsfJ. taa"[r*- gl r>l*;:- d.*jl .5" "!l
.c*l c,*!, ,-r-r- cf:p ,5i; 6[n:.,1JU-) Jl .F" .-.f l..,. JL-
Lf jd *-C .-V ,1ou, :) &: issj :: ,-&, osV *
*.; rlr L-t'ie ,!nt t c*La.;
.:-tn, r:i;.e .lcJ3, iEl-i,"t*
;l:;k-l ,A-b *;: fc*r cll g:rr s *6,9 .; -y.e"v; a;\t
) o.;;, c -b \: lrr Lt' F; ,Sn: ,o y r5 .-uf,r, ,*V syl
c-K;\t; o,rt.rrlr,r, rt1 oI t> rLl-r" 1l i; cJ3r j .r,1:,r";,+U*-r;
clt',r ol;.1 *F -p :, ,glfyr 3 ri; S\<-*l; d-Wjl .,(--
.c.*1
E>/ il-: olj J dpi li+ ui't:; o"o3,e;rr j c^-1"- rrsd
6-,,-;6;3 g[; ct jj,l crrk]JIrr,t^o,.-:L! -LaJ )) lfol.-ir,-rJlr","ti
k;: d.r ,\ -p "- yl .5,"!- 6UU* o-u jl rl;'! t cc-il: )p
6ta;.^-arr 6.:-1 ,.:-,k f ,'\rr. o-Q o\f \-r, a, ;lo;Lil
"*l ru.ud ./f
a,
,:;l;Bl t*-*-r c*!- -tV :, d-yb ,f., ,>;Lo I
,K;t ..-,t oV-f s lrifr!-.: ;1\ 6-*a dk.:!/i, sl"ssl.s-L- c;L
u,-y )) cJjr c;L a, oyLil ,tKu,-UtrL JL", t>lr r),;T *:-r-
:*--Se Lct'-y rylf-r, jaI I>.t Jt.,rrk jlrr qJT.c*lo:j
\s u,u.-y cJ9> .:Lj;-- : 6115* CtE
1r ;\-;3,*N-::.l ctllr
.(c*1 ;,, jt +f U) u.* fj) f a,rt jt d*. J ,;l-',
rn
r1.-u^r,r,
6--C.] +.:.,t-o l; [:I
a,--dlJ,r'tj eca?i .)t {ef or,-)s srl:T >! g r, F 4l
",.-l_r.
c-i ;t:'i 6:l'I;l't tL;
,.',L -u,I
s-;-t JrJ a
- --- ,'_ t*lr*l g"* clLll usr,*_t, g_"r"I
ol; +r I ta."e-."-; .f-rj,-f ,--or,- cp*t*
dl (ffst
u.\ e-5 t3- o:k--.l oS-- r>g 6:l;I c-r:;-*:c/ (S,./
-t*l-el * *-{::;r a:-.i^i ,r(- ,r=5.r" ;K,=, orf
.Jt- d(" flfr^ .)_y o)f U *t: e-{,,(1 +tr '*l-tl rK*
' '.-u.;l; 6:11l
6La._1L".)p.,! *-J:tj ;:* oLi 617:i; 6tra-;;,., d*,.,,
t t
usrqi *--a1 tara* jl g-,t t s, .rf o-F l-s.-ltalr^-t s sl \s:l
rt:-l ,":*r J-^,_,,- ? *;: ,.$tlpl 3 ol; 6 g*Vl;l 6la.at., .-ui
f
6 Sl7f-,-l*; ,l C-* u,gi *U- gLr 3 rYc.*l f. iT
ff ! oLj ;I 6'as:l \ Gi &l)\- p siots ,tf;, i3,"*,
.))F
.>jj .:f e.L )r tl_r oV,+i 6 r-,, t,r-,I J+l g;l"!KU,
dLF.f. .c;la1 6lrr-l ;: ,.,"l*Jt-l )\.t c-iJfn--* -t \l-s sl t(-rt-, L,rrt
c;* tr, l, !.rrt .tt]t* fE tt.rf f lGj-l ,-$;l c^s7 tsl-i
t'
! r;- i:lrSli- Uo_* J5!.L.i 6,Sr-:l_r
^f.a
jl *e,c/
lJ 1_11r:*__C..- .l o-.,j _r$;: -r,->
Ej)l_, L,-l-,l ;lrl-r^*t"-
oi,3 .,r1=lL .t;l *)s,t .c- .,1,E p>T._,."T 1--)> e,.,3y; a;l;lV
s ol-* Gss sl drJG 1 csll> ,4;;: a;E F -*'y:".-* :U c*.,,
0.:,,UL- o-r-.Ic g-a,.:Llr,-;l lli.("t -u)L/ oUt .rrf
J ,.r:n
(.*, r/
,i;.-ul.r" "l_*.ci. o1; rLir Fl.rr+lfFf U
t'
,r1Lii;: tt ltr;l .5laiL,r, tl^; ;4:;ra;3 c-lEj}. .;;Jrg; !
-l - r :T .t t'
.r.ot-:>l y_---l jl-5."1 -, -h; y. q-rt): )JJI./ gr rf ,3-,.*-"
rl1r11 ;: g;;;-:.la; : ,-l+ / \YA
JO"-, .rf glu":-l ,** ,Jtl, .+"1 fJ"5 elt. csY"- f U,r-rl
eS-r.r! t .r>i,l) r
6+- o)Kdp-r,-: boT-r, 6;
J) O: r<-
16Jj,.Jt-r-t t|-" Jl.r;l-ui .,t-.- -r:, ,fu-
'l{?'s
;4tn ssToro SlfV.c.*.r.: i:tr;l+"i-l.1r (-r,-f) i3l) )J)g
0r.dlr; dj
+,- jt,jU d bjr., eTl> oLi ofr; .t ;I +-l n,ir
*.\*-r Jtjj jl c<,- 6^ 6-ui o-r,.: ,JI rr ,r:-LL ;lj;tf 3)La o;ry
-l: u,L**: o.) 6 >X JLI- ;tlL itrl, b* -l r-r.:-j!U ol*a
-* t ss r.l-U t' djd ,-,U ctfr[ dy"W og s t,;:!;- ets.F
olJ "r:- I : J )-fu. oli 19\ .J1,o 2 6 ur-rj
-rl cJ-r)I.*l -r: dly-t
:t--se
...orl-i c(-ltr"*. g..ry c-13; cj3y)Ll :l 6,-5* ts,
. Fyd r-:*,1 ,fu* 4j..' .l aJL o:-,11.43 o>;* olja- 1)>
6tdjrr.- Ct- .*,;:* ,t-t ut r?*.c--!,r, g-ea
-rcV sl Alt e cl:rr g,"! ....ulL ajl>r,. .$; "rf .Urf 5 ,t
6t."':,,
iT .rfed# .Jjl ..t:,r. 6,r>f
e--r3.'>-l L* -1, r;;*.; C}
^tn4 6f--, f{. c-l L oti s,
jl lry r.b{ c}LA:-h n, )r,:, ol.,;t-il -,11 s .l a JlrclO tauUrL
.r!L .rtj -,1) 6o[i c*t., r c.rL: t btir rrf tr I OtSrt ,.jS
.t L:
4-r1l; ,r:-l-, a,\; t>'io ) # f,t rfi, G--t- sl lil .:y o-u
ctaa,lj *.;: d.l? t>j t:*i33ejlJ, ,:(1r,, &s toL: etaTL cnjl-r,
is
Shapiro, Michael. Langtage And Politics. N.Y. 1984. pp. 1-i3 and
it
Lukacs, G., Theoty of The Novel. N.Y. 1975.
3 :-l*i ,,.a-ox Jt-191 ) t-\S-- )l +i S ;!u . "-l32,lla .f3lit u* C;l-l . \ t
;: ,r,)\-l & ctsA; ! UI.l"l, i s6-y U-l o-t |c,;F e-1 a\,.\ ,
:l.5.2 tf-> G--r- )l;l*{,-l qk- 9 j-6--jl .slJlo. Gl-slKi-Lj
Celik, 7.eyneh. Displaying The O"ient: Architecture of Islam at Nineteenth
Centrtry Worlds's Fairs- Berkeley, 7992-
\.e ,ky P) &-i r: ul;rn-.Y \
.\ f A u" ,&S ly ,it-, y ol) C-.llr-"t; otlV LU13r.Y Y
:of l:B olKr--l ;r1 -i-"U Jt^f U s5:Lj c*'*1r :*-Dl.r".Li .0--( .r<*:
,u'^^ ,*,, .z"l:a uJlL iJtt.prj r-^ ;<r;tr-^r,-jr l-j,t* .;r,
'\A o'
.\1..f c,1La.YY
'Y ' ,;a tE!; lv ,iu 2> oa O'-i\-"1: ollv L[;3; 'ff
lt-.. e-f
db .*, )! o..yu:c*l ;,;; dL;l ol; ,:r:,,i rd-9- a;ly.YA
6-: d-- ct'--Fe.J! b .s-,! t ,F: ,tl .-t,:l:sl u.a31\ r\) oo'6:6W)-L;.
4tf t"!l lit t -t;:tT u.)' 6)\
t' r U)," e i1l ir-l :' .$,5t ,toes :
.\f e t($l y'\ oA 6'-ilr.aL LUrr- 1,.:l: 1;,- ol1r,.s-
.6.5.,_t_* ) ,saC4> +og"oL.lt "o;L;: d* 6lr,.Y1
Arenclt, Hanna. Human condition.
.\VY
"rrsLr.YA
.Y b ,-e rgL-o .Y 1
.Y Y . .r ,&!S 7* ,iu 2> oA o,--l\et ollV LL;3; .f .
.\ YA 1,,r' rgLa.f \
.Yf .-YlY Y
"rcdkA.f
\ .f rgLa if 1.9J-&" (l:--l.tA .f f
.A
.e!.1 c.t:{u"
Foucault, Michel- Di,tcipline an.d puni,vh: 'fhe Birth oJ'The prison 'r'r.
by
AIan Sheridan. N.Y. i977. pp. 190-202.
.\ , sa c6La c,r-ir..;.f V
.rJ qgl^:l-r".;; jl _9 fb, ,__J c_: ctf .f A
,r,_Lo-:L; s5lo*:-_9;
-p )l ;a
6L-L. ;nT-r b-;l Gb* U &; t- s, .*jT e V-t : \F
r, ol-i J3t
1983.p.8
.:F-r: lr,,-3l i-t- Jr -,r 6.' I ;\1-l ,eV, j:8 :-P r'aj t-*'
jl 611.* .A:il-rjl a,-L 6lyl Ll+ glrn* L, -t ,-*K ,O-SV-S
b rrlU,slrr./)-1>L;111c",'lJJ) J,-l i s s Sh: c*!- rSt<5Uf
b c,r,)\-l lr)Ltl b Ss-,*,-,)\.iil;l c-i"-lJI u*!,1tbtt
,*1.^l;1. -11
I
)J, cJ L . r
-y i F -Sr, $.-, j
F c-tc-ei r: Li
u, )g 0,. ) I
t.*+.f
,
t>J .;r-r!r-r! ,+l-s ) t eK.^ o3)\eq
t l> .-J .\
-elJl& c.a(- 6V*
q/t* )l"u:-t ^:f ;:T irlU ,-;j- r: d,r.o ,)Lr-, irle:t- ccJ3>
Et3.,t-a-rl *_*
ygrj: *t-cf f:: C-lfti.st,.r 31 c,:-,1
tll. esrd 4. J t))4jl r[L.- q5r,-;* g;.:L'a:!l J)\.i:*l :Jq s trlKrS
v..r5,r" l.p calL
f- ;[;f
slslr- ls.rf s\-*l g-lf;:l;l i:;JtJ y'>f aS c>,-ta:
s ,-y
";
)f tl))i;L;:.c*l u* c;* G)S:LI o;l> r"16",r^6; c-tjl:,r,
'2 oV3;u*,3 too-r,:-i 3 tao-Lr tl e*- 6lac3^--.;1 :-\d-Jrs,
3 p tf cili a, gtr ta:, ;t').t1...J1r+, )l ,f'_f .:L3J
dL"el\
yljl oj;r;: :5. .-n 2.5.^{ 1)-b ) .f } o:* pb r:!l-i^p:.:-16
.:tr.i'.; ,1 a:1>1,1 irU:-l J & *--q ,-,e; Gs: ,)s \ n.,-,I I Y
.:',1 ,: , -J)-bEi , )-t>i / \AY
.ie 6f.
: o)L-r 6U:r(:; j )ljL* :lS s *S )l J"a-a, / t +-
.c*\ -&rS JIJ-I re\'.:!rl;:
f Kq a.f :;1: ;L-yle:
t' oL;: 6 Sg e-t-e3l;6jtjj-t ls JK) dJ.- g.r! rllr.6; ;:
Sl )l e,.)Jn CLi o: r13> olr^-a cal 6)rJl,;-rr 6 -u"__yg S $g
fu-r: t tou(grlr+) ai-,o t>;l'j iJ;t.,,. L J J-ri ,J:,+t- ,i.[^r-,
.:l:l ,r.:-i"li
t/ Ef 6,".,> 6;l*or7J).)-r dlJ# .1,_r?:-.St{:j dJ}ls>l,l
+eL.i ol-Xe -r: ;U ,tI b af :9 ,5li,Li, ;l 6;\-a>r73))).)1r .jb
t'
rir* f n : rro[l--1 latrr -ri-ii..rr )l)- 6r" 1,6 6-WT + ;:r, ..r-,9i
;,-t
"? -,-, e> 3 .rj:;-ef olX+ t \s 6r C-l 6 S-:\ d)l ...{"86,
jl.iLJL y br", -r,-ui k;I r1-r" obyf 6b;lyJ.:; ! ,;- ,t1r... ;, ,.r-t(.;l
6 o>;c-.iK; r J\-S Jrj .r ,;t-rf nrf-l rrt c!; ;L-_t-ib * nf
I; t4I s-r..I 3 c.ru-iL n:!; rly-a JI -r J;p St-rL; ,S_-
";*3u^, 1..l::-:1.:,r, ".
xf dl,"j lt"lJJ+E d)\e jl F_
^{ ig l-r;!L; .*I,riJ# t t' dy."15r &-,"_i"t 6+-! ,Jy-,
;tf.ril, .- J+ l^31)g fr *.,r2 6;r?r.; J dl,f ,f S* p.
;-l 6;;1113r ,a .:lrt.. L-V s tt;t*r- ,Jt-.i-r,I;r .-u:!L_ ** e?
b *5j+ t4JL rvn..rj.; Lt r>) 6rt*-tr- \ cS13*n e{ >,
l)-r
, Ft j o!,-S 3 -r- ) )b, Llt, ,*l; .iiL -r-I3 ..:!1 .*_$ ,IL:
.-r.J:;jI s: #L a,3 o:f Lo; l; f Ar,,tt2.Jr 3 a(;;: )
^S)g J g_,b
AjK:i-. :--hr ;L; 15 1, sI U- .l"rt ;)ltr< jpr. jl
;>-/ jl 6JL-t
":i<6-.-r:.:jl.:,r, ,,SL.Jl;T ,*)\" ;f dfi j, *.jL : u.*.l(t..r,
J ?l d 3 -\::-r i d 6- 6r4J dUJ+ af [-r:.-a] ..r,LaJr,. oka)
rI t oLj 41 ,-# li J- J5$" 6r * t +t- ) -r , olf o:*
;l"r-,.6Q,t51.r aft; f.a t UJ, ;.,.* e(-ry ^{Lra"....-r-Jd
+r -U:J o>1j\ ;r4b
f t -,r- r
;+ftJliJJ-- p)LJl.;t.r s, ,rb
\P\ I :"6,- 1 .rt 4; 1L**l ,o ;> t,l2i
f 1n.l:.r{r,
.*,.; t"d*it al l"- s
-*-sls lif j-::^ ,JV ,fr, .Jl c:j-r"! frr, 1 \ ,-i::;-r$ i--i
f*A q .5:1.'u-l .rL"l$l ;,-l .9)a,Y .Ls +- +i c-[il:,rr iJ3:
-t(-t
\?Y / )r^;to\; Sls>l ,a ;> >La)
:r,.6.1 .,iu, .l
Leszek Kolakowski, Modemity on Erdless Tial, C)icago, 1990, pp.3-13.
:.e5..2 rcr)9; J-l .,i)t lJ,r-!-ggtoa.-d-- cAll.Y
Reinhart Koselleck, Citique ard Crisis: Enligftterunent ad the
Pathogercsis of Modem Society. Cambridge. 1988.
:.6.; c:J{ rr dt j 7:p J* W ta 6la.Y
Reinhart Koselleck, Futures Past: On the Sernartics of Historical Time,Tr.
by Keith Tribe, Cambridge, 1985.
:.6.s ,Jy;;,-l ,rlf rl-l i-1t.,1:.rrU,S&- cgL, .f
Robert Adams, *Metropolitan Opera",New Yor'lc Review 25, 1991, pp.
48-51
:.6.s J-s +.i. ar:J-; ;-r.,1 6rLr:,r;L:.;-,1r ')- 6ly.
Carl E. Schorske, Fin de siecle Wenna, New Yorlg 1981.
:..5.; ..:f J-*. J.,ai ,".12 6r;,-{ 1tL: J-r; ,y-l -fy L[::..0
Mchel Foucult, Discipliru ard Punish: The Birth of the Prison Tr. by
Alan Sheridan, N.Y. 1979.
:.6..,1 irJri t: -.g5 *r(discourse) rlU I JtL
db Jr^, e.* dtl .1
Jean-Francois Lyotard, 'Notes on Legitimation", The Oxford Literary
Review. Vol.9, Nos. L:2, 1987.
.Y ,"" citL.a .Y 1
.YV\ rr(dL^.YY
.1"1.|" ,." (dL^.Yf
.AVd ,z (dLs.Y F
.1 .. (dL^ .l A
",,a
:.6.1 crrf..1 J G--f U,J!".i,ld c.* cAll.Y1
Walter Benjamin, 'The Storlteller", Illuminations, Ed. by Hannah Arendt,
N.Y., 1969. pp. 83-111.
27. William Shakespeare, Hamlet, Act II, Scene Il, Penguin Edition, N.Y.,
1985, p.69.
28. Lucien Goldmann, The Philosophy of the Enlightertnent: The Burgess
arrd the Enligfitervnent, Tr. by Henry Mass, Cambridge, 1973.
.d-\
rllLr rqgr4.i.Y 1
ua-a
.1 ,.rr c,",-.ri llra: c6.r$.Y ,
.l . d, r,tLr .,1",1
.\ , oa (dLa .f Y
.1 I r,itL.o.!"1"
'r
.\Y ,f (dL^.f F
.1 Y A ,z ,t .* c6rai .Y d
.Y Y 1 .r,a (dL^.f 1
f^ d".^
eJ[-. dr"'b ;J; o(l,.ar-;- ,l-2,*," ras +i r$ -L> i-,1j: ;:
;: .cj-,1.r" JL:" at_l alsrl, f_:b -1: u"o* a_;;r.^* clLl .tT r-r
f^; :JU f^ +Y ,_K-t LA -p b olJLL1jr, :,*-t3.":!.-*t
o.9L5;rl:l $Al-)J).J"Ll
lt<^:.-r .srr iu ...:f -r-al_r; l* ,rr-
o:* i, .tli
15r*, * _l: r.)lL 6*-.J,jl i:._r.rT *C_l ,ro..
*rj,t,
,.t::S ,1rr:;; ,:-L eF ,;r,6.s-\srt i s: t_; t, ,S t:,lt",,W 3
-j
6 L ,.rL,-l ;, :^,,y J_t * f r .-*+ -<fo. i"td t, 6tpt +: ,*-
g; c-l-rtf dr+*Vt*lf^ Utf t_1, ,s)s.t .t,-q gJ.e,o_r.,j +b
l")r)))G o-t_j,)ri S 6 j* 6lr;
e -S-t cstAc:.j s-tQ,;r pJ: al-ys ie(rStF,l Lr; 6tyt l
*tfrs
e.(,t- rt af;t.tj.; r .fu Ly :\_nt 1i 3 iVu-t^.
JU:
J JIJ+i c;-- 4! )\fi-
djLG 4J cr) t--.:.$.]t.:, ,*t_s 6fJiy
in ^ t jLiJLiT J *5)_* *$ L;itau::i Gf s: , .,i,t;7._S
.f -*. a-" oytf.-u utf 't-tu J o.L;; --lt.:r-ti gV:lrl
:l:;lj -t-.t2; .glr7L _ss 3l .tq
"Ji 1o-:lj,r.ci cS-r*: .rL- .rtEJl*l
ar:..o q St_r\lt ! c;;t(. +.;_1lg.il -* st' oW.t 4l;9: -,1: .- -,i.i
3 xi u.2: a, ol-u^rJl;
'r)-.
,r7 )l ejn 1 -|.:,.rt! .t-f rg P Ly:n
.rrl.r( ,-)sj *.-,,1j!.;:c,r,-)6;L- cl1 ;3) 6P;l c-lrt2l; Ji'l
,s;l -p 6.,,;""" Je:3,J",irleFa:a,ol.,1 c.=;)t-el>t 3;l-t"
\VY I :=r,'.; 4:*, oj.54)* sl*l ,a 2: >Jai
";j,l-t.i
r oUT ,-,-cL:>l JL- j oV) 6r-1 4 ,G.-p "UJl .r*-
":-, j.; jl c-L jl c*; "!
65)gl) J FIJ-el"u c ,\d s .t_l ,rs--
\VV / :.u di- e .jtf+l-- li.al ,* -> :,t-r
r..J* Cl- -r: r.# 3 ...c*11 6nt tl-t ,f p i:-.!j L;i ) o+1,
tnur- c.Kl- c*L {2j
-, 3 ;rJ a,.d!j J ...-ut.,, ,K:1 1, Aro
'uBe
:.:*l ; ; t(.4,se -r _sl & ;:l flS, s : s- t g
l $ j6 7l-( *.
o
Y1n.g1:l;6..r-a
fl+ 6/cr r,ll, *r,"-,
d/ d-l+, ! r>-r...i olf jl G f dl* t rJ:- y-i coj6 ol3 +,
s *>-*3.rtu[-.9-,1-\,-r-
j.i; lV tl J*ti" jl ,ri, oLt lt r-l
-r^; ,,\,ie !.1 ,r.9T is3a 4.-,b ,-[' rf l; ;> 31 )i<6'
"),\uplr7
-uily./ J-iJ c*(- r gbr'Sc*l t.!,a.o dj'LL L-Ln ;': W :'f
lr
l)\-lJlri-tff Ulo:t G\,J4',lK$oaf 'oti t')trun''f
.:r-^, .:-l gj) tSf] ,ltf LJ$lc'i5;L"'o J r..^a Jb il\-f \
"f-lU
l, .:.3.-- ,036 6\3 o,.cg4L;jrr .'ritarr.rUl3 2 '>L-a; rl jl l-r
ciU 3 taE: J ,-rrb,-,t5.-r;; c(;t/r": 6 Gfu t'e:; 4j 6-Jr
3 cjl> ."ar*. 1; l-ri j JL;I Alalr t *lt-St f)J" Jlj tlr_di
;t-a^jl; j:.-t q>L-t1> Ll .:r^-.i J,-lj 6Jrl l-, ;-,t-:-, 6fuV
.,1j .:i-r; ..r-i. ;l.u;r'r! 3 ; ) no'.re dU J) ..r--: okJr;
^-+y
3 .ril:,r, GGss'^LL )le;\;>,lt.fL.fl;
l'r- 1>tf-;3 'r:1n:!! l;
\A\ i :-r.; *1l* j ,eKd-, ;L*rl ,p; -; 3-1^;
rA.-,.;rl.,j
! ot";^" (Ji-;>r, aiVs:;-lrl -r$; ? 1:lo)q i ll-*
f s;Vl k-) ol1-l;rl [,.l:l -t, t _1.:l-)Lel
l: r, ,Sc^rL-..r" g*
t '*N(r 6)s:i:st 3 ,;- ,r(11; G-r \ .,--ti*- dr o(-
otj,rT fJh 6t"J& ) rfd U-|WT JE,l3 ,.it;!:;13 >3LJlr:L-
-r: -, f-rQa. 1-* ,t )yel ;r1,ta:^- ^A J-fl Lrt iJ>t
.J"-i -r, 6l: ,-p
r1n.-r,r.,,f,r,
,Jait* t bL, &.1'.rJfr c-xl.: 6L jUl;
"-i..e
.rl)l;* c,r+.r-. ,--a,; ;l lyt rS.i tp s> ojfS;tf-u--r: c.Jl
jl 6J[* rrr:3r^ .!"1 *:y $b. ) -r:;L-i,cf -* a-t* 0f,3 Gf l..1
,.{-y slS -tt a*.E -l .:3,- r, :G .t(.i j; ,-* s> ) -rj:-l-a-i Otf;l ;l .rl;
ojt5afp;.r" .tf ;I r I cr:-t^j ,-,[-r-
fj)\, ..r(* ,r;-rf; Ga;r
FKt t 4rio^ j6:l 4-l 1;{y }\1, JtJ-t G:-.:^-r, y ,*,1+
.,- ,*rl:cf ;-ra; Lj;:13 \ )J)) bltr;T ;t
c*;; ojlS;tf-u--; crr,t)!, s$3 u--l;l pL I lf+,LI iJta,;:
l* .*i, cj>u:""t a(j ,tl7-l .,:; Lt- 1.r af.r;;l>y,r, & .r_l Ci \
,llrr-l ;> ig;,:-:"q., J ,Ja"i / \AY
'\ Y1'
:13+ gl,. c-.fc;; cjfJ 2: o:lj,j;,j:n-- i;L;: *J+ c-? q5lr,.\y
E*i.st.iirr- c;{* c-sf;, GVt* 6J:- S.sr.a-Yfg;
..5.2
.\f 1Y dl..g eJ,
,rV "^-.j .,*,-JUJEg .
.7t ,.: ,r>t 1> clL 3;l I oLtr) .J)t- .L-uf . \ f
.\ Vf - \ 6Y ..,o.\ lAA tu,,\ c:lj,:el ..rS-i ..ry."
occula-centrist _\ A
i;L;: ,r*l-
i.(5-.; .:-rz; cS! - \ 1
-
Toulmin, Stephan, Cosmopolis: The llidden Agenda of Modernity, N.\..
1990.
i.6.;
r:.I>i dI .f t-;*l r ,tL; cf_lJg e"- .rt .t V
'rt__r !
Lukas. G., Theory of the Novel, Lonclon, 1975; and Kundera. Milan.
Theoty o.f the Novel, N.Y. 19B8.
.\ \ J;fIY i\ . i;k; r.t--11 i;-e> c035.\A
c\ 1Y
"r.A r\ t Y . ;i-rj \ A cf \ i;L; 1036.\ 1
"r
.1-A ,"" c\ 1Y . a" f . -Y\ i;t-^i r,o3l5.Y .
.\ .r r\ 1Y \ Fl \ Yi\ . "o;l*; r-t,r- i;y.: rojg..Y \
.Y ae t\ 1Y . o-ylj Y Y rYl i;Li co,ets.Y Y
E;rL: rrr5.: ,r,-lrl J )Jp ,JL-,j .c*l;l> r:.X-X rrr.fr .,1l:rr *.31 ,,V )p
,-ts!* gtll;tf .r" J J)jd
3 3 *>3, c*5 ce;tL. >f tr;lbl 1>
\rfe JuortEj ou 6)t)lt.t(f,g/lr !,s-r! tt? ))
Glfl; : ,-rJ l..rtF tJ ,rU1;I q ty -Ll .r-l-r"e f prrL okf I
\ urS:,r,-l>n .:-: ,r2 sK;3;.-rIgtfr:tt" g-; 6o[of .g-r-: >rl3
)-rT ,.*lt L, j:-, ,lI .+,',, gla--,r-i- (-: ;l .>rS
+J 6,i,i; .f
.)j a*jl;s 1 4^^ j[--l-6*r) .f )-91 ot(,_rU E1:Lu ;t, o, c(13.f 6lo-;-i"
l; 6,t'-, ,tb)3 eS c. 'tj-> .gltl j>d dJU
t' .-L &- S)S:
r+ .dlri c-l{ 1 ,tSt, q!,-, .f )r-rl J g*a l.l ..,t5.Err! .r)}
f * oy:- -,t<A -rl yr 6S.f.rjlF !1, ci" r rl; ! ls -.,V{ sl6.b*
tr f*- g-rrL t.J1- d,.f )) J )i) g.5, * J,.,:,J r .)-y J-)l-r*
..r,1* 6;G )l ;*ls o;t; olj;t/l;)lit- e(_ rsj; c-l.-"q a.f
cs3.s isl y-* t, ta=t-r,
Cil.r r, ft 1,l/ 1, +5J+ JL .-r
.rf Ali.g l.l, aL:ti d/."JlF Jii" 13tld-.rul\l4e
l:
'e-r6u; gLna-i_-r J 6lo.r.i &S ;t*t jt i-r d<s,
.r.'!13:-r:"; ,oS*J..c^-* ;"a, rr+:_2 -ra,i. .f-I4-jIjFlJ
5l.rr!
,l> .* ))f ):.rgr,K;; -1.:.c. .*il.:.rr ol *a {J*ti).9> U tJ
"!-al
,5u; & t* et l.:-ry -.yEI c;K;l rdlTl -r> .$>-r 5r^<"
,J1r-1 1: d'J-:-r-- , ,.t-1; / \AA
ti* J.-l jl AiKt Jl,)U rliT L, Sfy )-p ) >;q o-t-: olr^o
.r1 ,.r-_.;L-
o;ly^a .f ! .r:-V ;K;iyl;LiU;>1; ;1 gL)U ;r--rJl-.,^-, +-
,tT
l+,.flr+ ory f-* Ll c.:y .s\rsrJ, G\s\; -,loljlr:r..- $1:;j
Ll c-r,>!
eJla,jt"
j3b c*L- ) P sI;> af :y ,t:l .rF
"!
f+ q ,-f )l 6pJ, J;l-d .>sf ls.i-L- ?fr )\ rL(t
"[j.!
,> ;is|l Lple 4()! G)l)oa+" lf"*<r ,-lrLi; -r,-L: **'lK
;! ,-- .*-L:: l; ;tJI ;l r$ ,-!)Bl 6 "l * tff t c;b>-rf c*l-f
c#->l l;.u.i* 6lo.u- -/ ) )J\V 6-u"jl>n l;31 1L:;.il g-l ,3f
\
,y-tr+Ftjlt dlJ,-lrJ,,i,f) c,:iy,5,-Lt * )-ul-,; tol-ui*
G4;J" ,f\ ,i.::t,17-; ...>b c*r jl l: >F Jl-Uj-p &i4-y t
raa.a y-l! rrc*; $N:yd U; ,r-l;r gL>Li -5t -b
Y
J 4.;l;;
"1*t.9,Jly
\A1 / :.r+ eJ.:- 3 ol,)L: ;,,-.rJlij ;Lual ,+l ;: :-r^'
!1n.c-l ii.L
d-L*r) t5:t>,r-" ,l-uLo ,.}i;g ;lril g:V rlr;>
6-, t :rr!^* *Fb* ?f ,6;j ...n--J." *":\t: ,5:;
c--*, l) )\E JIJ^- O,l Jte "^L;: Y ' rr.c-*; jJf c.a J;u
JL ot+-,: .i.,, b Ln c-.xl: skf.c-:l:,r, iS;lJ a:t\..K.a;> sly-t
r, Jf aa-a ;) Ll c,-,! { ,eK t,J.;s K,g.;:.il, 6F ;,-l-,11 ,4,
"fjI
,, GlSt ) 6+g) r'rL*iir c**, I
^++ .l:
Y
u.J>[iil ..JL.f
ol y 6jls.g.!-re/
-lf *d{;'_r, c:;r o-L.i jGIrt uis, s fi s
r Y
tr; lJa, 6 lr,, l rK u*V; I -r,, 6.r;1 >,r, Ji rr l+7,re .t:r
rr.-r":5-,* I r
f
Utatc,-lt-rr g;:f eiL-rrl1, )r.i fr- t' .lr 6; g rc;L-
..:*l
:-L dly-l .Jl- *.-p &l:,1;r jl cl-
.cil:,r- 5*-* cfr oL.:L: l) fii dr--l !>\-" 4--*
ta-ti l;i;, r-r+, :! )r rt G-l-ol| ,:-tu.tt,jl .,(- -1: r.(t;-r\
dl.,, rdLrt-:1v.,.:-l o.tily* :-r-'.i &l ,ft\s uG-b 63\*^;{ tt ocy
t te g\5.;S r i v- .c;1> qb .t-it c-r-xL o.!13,- lr 6*-*ig\); 6
u ,'rl
\rvr
,f : iLrjl t f U
"+L.l
,5** 4-l ;\ ;i-ca s u\rct uu!+y,
1514:JE U--*. )l 6u-*, ,r>;Ku,gL.:B .*xl> 6;A ;xt-, s
cJtui-LI ) 1.-.oi)V ...6to-o:l.ril g,- ), r*...s,.yrT
;rti ) {Ft j d }*\-* ,r+ ...r; h** r t -* -,1-',-r
\.rz.c-. j^:*,- )) A...ty) Jr ;+15J 3 ol5t-fr:l1! 4t{ ooli
cc*31r*-1: t6 rFu-r .."t'ttd3 c*l"),tiai c "^ 4+jT 6-ul:.r" a.f
J-l r,-! |:=*iil 1; !-r;Lrr cirt- J;, t 1.: -r*! jl-fl-t 6 1-,
",b-,^,
) t*--f : *f;Ljt, s Gr3 -r fW S :-y* l( *;! 6JorL ;.rJ
;t:l*i.:lr.b 3.r*l,JT
.Y ,r r\ IAA
L ;: \ 6t:Li .:l-r.L 6-)l gz.a, ;$ *.6 6la;,:,e; la; ra;l:,r, af t-gl b
f- ,r-rG +1 JI jl 6l+.")[- 6 c*l 6tlJL 6ET 6l;5> il\-) q.:,lt )h;
tlr-3, tre-S:l' g6;il 14 L;: l2 dL:L, 6)-Fjl.5trT U6LJ-,i ,i:i
:.e-f., ;L_l "dl-; 6111 .:9..:ulg 4 c* J*
Ch:-l O,l c0" ol^< a,3 r.la:,re
Boroujerdi, Mehrzad. orientalism in Reverse: Iranian Intellectuals and the
Wert, 1960-1990. Ph.D. Dissertation. American University. 1990.
pp.130-140.
.-^.:^<- -r* -t cbT ;rlt b-y.ul-t 5rtrJt 6GT "dt-rt al*,
t 6tt-*,t c>l)rg css>i-r1t;.e5., e-,b \ 4l-) )l.i-l4,ii1 L>V als
c.re r\Y11 Jl+U rY 'o;l^-i rg-laj; cn"L; gl-r-l cxa-31.13 6-t^frr-X
.Y1\ -rvb
6Lj^b ;lr;l -,, \ ,9t )a:; Lt,*,{-t,, jl
,r-St ,h, J.-.s ,lL:t i .f
,{ obb t Jl u;} 3 .*lKt J ,ljit st;.i"[ A^a iaL-.c.*:lj<,-,l;f
,1# 4)tra, a'aT ,4lv teV oL; ufu;x t;r,--llr*t .t:" --rS, coL>L; .\ f
.f 1f -f dV c\ Yf . :l:r, rf i;L; c6;
"r
C.. ; jl dt64jJni pl, .r1=;: ! 4L:Li ;l aJt;" .u7 # J\ 15: .\ f
ee -;; jl 6,-b4jJ^; (Jy? F, (G*:.t5.).c*l o:;3T ti tod ,-*:b
cbT ;llt d1-1" b..,6"e| t.*li-r.\ f AV cdlJj cp-r: -J7 cy"L- 4;b
'ff'"1F'
.\ . Y 9z ct=oka.\ A
.\ Y (e-6ss3 .r!ru rrtL:l-i.\ 1
"r .\
'f .f (t?;La ..,il .\ V
c:4lL cs-Vi3; s 6--t8,1i .t rr
j)l;T s. cs)y
nr -{-K-;ie J) 4"-i ,J-6*!.rt- 6;u-\e
.\ ' gr ,rSS A-*; -ra".; isL>l-i.\ t
.f 6 ,-e sl+rtL.o .Y .
.\ V iladLa .Y 1
.\ 1
"f rlrok-o.YV
.\ ,
"f
t-ta clagLl .Y A
.\ \ .f c.ua o!;: igL:L: .Y 1
.\? ,r c6;; tsr)l; c6L:ti .f .
.\ ' Y c,n, (ladL! r,r=." .l \
.\ 1 cJz c-l;r o! ;: cOL:L- .Y Y
.\f e r$,1L-o .lf
(rrt'::k+ C-) sl.s, *.*S-.L); -La t6'-.itr;;.!" c,1L:li.ff
cl.,Grn
CV* A,L.)tV -, l-r- dl.61 s-l J.a:s d:;l: Ja 213>l ,r-l.rLi !,.rJt?
J ?pJ 3.s;-ti1 q \ o-i t' t l-p -" .Su!* il )l Lslojlt Le
:.e-f..,'>t" .Ju:*; el-t5z..a ,'r dl.,
9lr.-1 ;> 6r;-:Ja"'J )J-?.i / Y'A
LJ\4i (,oi)jrl ;Ll i"il cjLl*;--o Jf* L-J LJlj<it;j) r>;19:l c-L*
.\ YVV
:1 .5.-, c+,,"3' g-l irtr: ,rJl jn 6ly .AY
Manohester, William. A Warld Lit Only By F'ire. N.Y. 1993.
.-il:uo (q;ka rr;L)Li .Af
.\ , ,1," rl3,1L-o .6 A
.q)l:rr t&;1 a;r)t; (oL)Li .01
.11 .r ,u!;;,:t-; ,4.by
.-il:uo cr(;S a,tjj .6h
cr rl+,tLa.Al
.1Y
rtroLa.l .
.AY
'C
L r ef , ,f;f qgL:sl, ilz* G-1, C-l lltr s, tlai- 6l4li^;: gL:t, .1 \
s>,--9+.a3,F-;b fly 6t--gg id L C*l ,s--giS6-t:-L.f-,6,t!j
q9;9T:L- (JG ,f;:.c^-l ,:rf .r--y;[-, t-b \ c,:b;t1 t e(,o;
jl U 4L*il l11.tutt ) cts -,K \ lg;t csln ol:-l: a.l5x a"Lal.};: 6 S6
.\ 1A u/ .t?Ob:.(f.;.xo.:f ,-J- dL-l)
j l-oa.i_.u;l ol sl:: "r,-! l-,
"*l-,
\ ,t:6 O!j, .irJlF -r. ' .6L:Li .1Y
c-!.6->;l ,;tk-,- ,JL- lE:: 'o;L-: r..'Lis;L,--6L ,r,l*,-fr. ojU apLo"
.11 ..f c\ Yf .
.ll
\ 1 .f rF,tt*a
.11 .r rFdki.lf
.\ L o? cj;; ;-r-; -r..;*; rgL:ti .14
. \ 1 A d, ,&;1 cstjl; (oL)t :, .1 1
.A\ d rl+ul*-o .V Y
"\\\ (r11.:,:L-o.VY
.\ 0A ,J", cl+.tL.o .Vf
.y\ ,r ceK; s::lj rdLrL-.VA
.Y\ e rL76L-o .Vl
.Y\ ,f rtr,tk-o.VV
:.CS.r.J;f.," o! ,y- .*;K.:t qrl^all", jl *(_;: l:
F ,l;:;,_l oL)D.VA
Shadman, S.F. "Muhammacl Ancl I.Iis Mission,,' lslamic Retiew.
vol.XXVII, No. 2. Feb. 1939.p.70.
l2 ot;lis,-rL:: a;rT pLL; .:,);r; ,jra;: *.6laJG,;:6L:D.Vt
_r> 6ls-l
"b* J ?1",- u*,{'t-j 2: \ olil)2 .:t-)Lpl e}., \ s S,? o_ts.
:.ef.; ..rr-k-.r",:l;j
Shadman, S.F. "Ilclucation In Iran, ,'The Asiatic Review. ian. 1937,
vol.XXXIII, No. 113, pp. 765-173.
.11
.f ,J;_r, ;-w;i; cgL:l, .A.
.\ . \ .r cladL-o.A \
r\ Yf \ d))jp c,-.,L.fg1.-,--rl, rxsL:L;
J--J|FJ.- ,S:1 cgL:E .Ay
'\ A.r
.\ \ y c&;; 6:jt; igL:l",i.Af
"r
.\ lY ,r cl-;La.Af
. \ F 1 ,.;" rl-dLa .A A
:(t.rJL; s911 .o>..,f c*olf *.iJ:a;; taaj6al -:>stu"{G.xt
weber. M.rx- Tlte Protestan Ethic and the Spit'it oJ'capitoriun. N.y. 1984.
pp.3-22.
.\ A\ cr, (t?,JLa cgL:1,.AV
.\ A 1 4l i{-;l^.r .AA
.\ A 1 ,, rt-gL-e .A 1
.Yf Y -'" "l+il,*.1 .
.,ij".- :;l; .Slj .\ \
I ,..1 'r. i ^\"' Mris. N.1'. 1967
\ \t
.--: ' i.- -1 'r.-e . .. I" : Ll . I Y
.\ 't , ,r., .|,-..-'Ll .\Y
,.llr,r-l .1.: 6;;.:-:J.?.i J .:q.i / Y\'
.\ D1 g,e cl=r.lL-o.tf
. l g'e rbrtLa .l A
\ A
+jlr"#ot+}r?'*
..,,*f Jd"
&J.ir" ctt"i.,r*
1.9+i*
"#llU*.u
'+jlr..'*01{+J +l.ra
,.fS.4-L--j gl"c.-j )) eJ*, t d)Jr-, rj,: oljo t )J.1;
t'
t+,F;r.c+l 7l1l r*lr. g:b ,S:ffu-.:t"eJl9 crl-.a:!lruJ3
isV ,y ;:13 *Ll .-rjlc*jlr ;.r+; ,tL-.f j1-'* l; .- ,-l-ra csk-l: -,1: 3
q .q,-*, ul-r+ tc:l;_l 6rl.r -r-oly; JL.iLr,- it-ra;Bf r) )-r^-o
:11: ;r1-: :-r+; ,:.: - 1 ,il..r(* e|-:sT $t -l,t t<i c.rl-r^
"# -9 .r;-S-l;'.= t
a'" -!-\i t--l|j;. ._r*(- .sj-;: ji ,r-Lir c;(* J ,s*t-i,
.31 ;lil;'--- :'*.- - . ._j.. " . - .._*t_ra-:* e
.
.!)Jl+eal1:
o:3-,-rlf ll rrz,-j-\,.;r ., ,--a !ftj r-!-!,, t1*l
7s<.* 6tCL -r:
6- ,- u"-S t-S tf,:l ;_1a-lJ< J ).rn; cf,_-rb 6taU,-; Y..l,l
.L;t.:-.(; l, ;t- .))r1..,
,;* il- ,-el-rT ,>315 q> 6,u rl.nl..r,L; :-q; cl-1s1{ a; ,,
-s>
6c*ui-i:-r,,,.; cf r ,i:V *.r*,lKl3;ta.- ujr;f.i,r3 r l,
.-[:-r ) *; rel -,r5"-ilr,1!-,13r-l: S ce rSel )-]r.,ll\* ,ag
tr' )-- J-
\
)-f J "r; d, g;rL, r-r*-; r.ry ...lI 't*qt JKJ|jt ,r(_ igrl-r.r;
f
O,lJ, JL ct' -t::-ra; .:y (ocularcenter) ;l-r,":q c;- u:lsJe
.*;I-r; e.,l7l;t..rJ^" asl7 ),);L-1,* o6t" _,,6 rr
rlrz"l;13
.ri.;,rt St L-p ,r.), );eu' 6-l-l dr?l ;l .fr-, 6_ C-lfr;
:r.i A.-i:lo-r,lr; ;lajlj3rjl Jl. G_lFr;6 >,
*ra,; s> 4lf>; g-l
)J ;?"i g* : rj,-U<sir G-* -t s .,;iU s ,*V
-$ ,-n
c;L-i ,r+ F-, kl .df ,lj c..fL 1l ,5t.rL- c,-l3r ..r3,ltr)
olr-1 ;: dj.:-:,r:; : ,-r+; / Y\f
*r-.'b : +?^i drf .1., 6-,.:lt ' rrc*31a, g.*-r$ c.a,l gL-r1 ;l G f
dJ--l jl JJ.,"
.r,ii -9 -u*L.i,r" ; l; ..rll"b o-r.?.i 6ta:; sV-> t?t
6t- UU.--trl; "9 Lryl cJr;: cl-6,Lic i:)gLt 2 c>-,1 ;, Jl.iI -ul.
obss \.K-t ;1 ;t,tKaK.c.-* EoI t d+r st,l: e56r .>;tr
a, 1.1
;lu*t U.,,- tJ;: trol;r Ll ,6! g;1c."-b U
fIr ji e=alj f-I.-,
r,.gr!.f gtjl ;13a, 4;11 4;lo>1 oI jl r ps\ u, JV
;t e(-;t; ;Ul .-ulK- 4. ,s.lr 3: o3-rjl s * ,s>jlt, U-p -,t
alrr-1 ;: qg;;->J..j J )Ja.j / Y\t
G1.b4-:- ,a-, C-njl3 c*l JL,I ;JL- .,u j)" s Es :l_Fr e-r
fr* ) q;!'u s* : d ,!..-s.r eKl t, Kt* rt ?T*
.Jjtc<,_jli Ark-
e(-jt; .11jl-6-1 cdt*jl 61+-i ) gs<;V *:--o ,1 3;K1s\a
;l-r, ;:;-3I ! -r .** oLj ,-4.L,r tf )f 6 *e n,rJf r o;l-e*,o
tf ty ,5n, ".j+ L:* .r) ,r.r.>t sD ,eK &,ll-r./
s-fl-t ojf tre l.r; nc-f rr ,t-l t_S 6t-dr JCt, o9 ,s;1. sl1
J',tj JU-.X r,.,l1t - ;-: .;r::+..rr er)Liil ;: l, ;I3rJU S ,S:V ;S*
U-* ,r\ >; 61;*l Fl g;tao-r- i,i->b: jl-\:,,:.n rl 6la.JL)L
..:*1 o;,,> ;l :1-r-o )) L,!,lLf f r,c-r-l-r-n j *>f ,-JL.*f.*!.j
,-* UjJ*l;7f c.>-lol.j.*l, -:L- c,JL; ssT*ss-tKa{(&r"
.:+)ti )J." t t6:; ;l ;l 5z;,K11 c*-\ u,:Li t gt*il .,;jt, $:,".!
6.-t !,- ,-it* tai rc*.r-L* ,t-V: rEf .4-f ki .,.!;,\-
.;-l o:-, _5)" .,- f .*!_j J o-u 4:d-j [a-i
_, )-,.r,.t d"-_rb Hf L 6c.- tl-r-a,r:-L: s# ,,;+
Cl:;,
cgt-' silte ur-.t c.:;r- 7 jl ..r-'l: &j- ,c-*\ >Lai;: Gj ,_#
rl
Q;r:4f o, :-f * ,,t;i;r .r.!'1 c+)\; f t.e :;: ;'-l dL;r t'si
,p ttn.d'ro, f)f 6\t ;,5-7e{ 61tn,4. .rE s> /gn
t &i;l jll-*,,tlyc/ at l; ,ll7l lfK '" Je 1 c'-l-r'r JL)'
!; oly-lir-J[ I ,S\^2,.K;\ sl s-rd '':-;l.: c+}; 'i;'W Ssi
l; la;T.,.:-31 )J- dP) L-l:y *, s:rl-r; ;--rb ':l$ll 1 ;h+
.s*jl.: ,t-S G4.jl .f U.+!- ) e-lss ol-rc/
.:t- er rt,FKl61y ':-6:)t '6"o13*tc,}'[JL tg-ry'Je
+5c-=r.-rt9 !-a; I F", * rc^p)\i ,r-) )l su ,so:V e:J'y )
sly jljrl .,jtij $ 6;2K>t'dT J jr- o'a $,\1c'*6la)*2
rS:l;
,rl-y./ 6 s-i? c*l-r t lKt-# J .r,\*'g4 ,-i1qL t l; >J- -r;lri 6-r-
\v..:*l J!;
dl, s) )f)l rr6lqLrr
:!--l cc'-il:y J+t'P ;.1 ol; ;r
t G)-p $t- Jtritt :t 6 sf7 t-f Je 1t6
t'..r,-Go7-l>
dt!,J-" ,-p-lss'*sf "f t', oy)s: : 's-*vl r.r;L; .r:'"'a
oS c-*6l:,,-P l-l*, ;:\ ff -l, 3 -r:-(:.r-'-1, l; q#! J ;l'"j
.*!.*h 1l>' ;>,;t J e 61.,, -t-alj+,r"
1-F, co-u o>r^; c,-l-ra tt,r:!tl;rr -rE\ sf o! cGi u>b s> g?
6-o-k Ls+l/:.iL i c-*l ,ev e"o ,3t-r'' ;tFl: t'6 ,F
.:jl.:rr,r" !# a/l ,pt" ,Sl_i
,jrssG s *-sf d d"r;*,ri^'-l r:l>;*1t" otJtr"l'9 t^i
...*--ig ,-r-r\; J &-l*e t' rt ('r,-il'ii\r! d, tr -l r*jer
fuU !,1 air.; clt * ), 6"V ,sJ s +.! *-!; olrl.rr
"p
L): 3 SrJ F t-\,-r,)J) r -rjJ*lf ) *>sf 6 f*
t4,T r,,-ro* .;*, UT 6n, -r*:lK>t t ot-:r; jl'-'l.,1i!t'!
"
t -S 4r-S J >jr -iS.r, P -p.6 4T'la* s"->-r-r 6-
\^.r;1,
fj! (* ,-rrr ,5n: tstr. r-. J* c'- * i)K
Y\f / e(;; *"gq. -e cr-tJ-r
.** Siftr+ J,ri)l rrn
.;k-l: ;> '),:, 6tr: n ! :U: 013; O{l s-Ll -e6 .r:sV r--r,, oL;t
e -t;los eE #J, :7b 6,*";l-;;t;y*.rf ly.J.J.S..r"
)J) J -u:-.n 6-;\U..r:.-, jl fu. (o}-t ,, ,-*.r_\,
1tf T X._i:;),rr
.".1 d oK;f c-rjr-u; #;,'6+ s t* 6 pt-* Fto-r)r 1
rt_;"a
.o)JJt* oL;-,1 t g"t<+ r;Irl3 c5)ti
r 6h.<i crl-r,t;Bf ;r al
.g.^ d .,+! jl 1.glo-u-i , ,s* t F tf Jt:
s,
l. trz*, :& caf ,* JK5 t &r 6g;-
6b,r;t- ...
.)jpdt J|ri. c,,-l.r.o af-r,>y ,Sl.rL- gb;-* oF -rl ,-r+, oIr[i oLf
*1, : ,sf G\:1 c,-l-r-o nJE> f ) s G.ttsf 7i i* s-,ljT -,>
a- o;t*;l ;: rcltj- Al-s .ut-S tt-iil rU t 11 .rL"-.; J rt..5*;) :J4j
:-\,-lLl,V +,Jl3ri
J*; ;))" ri*Ji U-l ...re rr* i< ^K e*-.,rt .-5- )11 (5"
a t>y o>f u;;1*6I i;t"-rc g-sV: s -ti>y ori c-t1 s o>f
.rl.e dt' ofu.t, ,*- s* a^(.! cJ-q;-,.,rr JF qi
l.rtljl
t' "*Kr *f ecr) l, ,Ktl- as\()r, d)J* di-l;L"!
t+I ..:Lr-e co3)\- .-i,>f,r, dJG "L.i-lrr;* ,* S-:f )\
.rJ. L*--* ,k
.c.*l .:L.,ar t.: ,tLiljl ).^''i Slfri Jtd \t dLjl a, cil-r-a ot(,
t ocl,- j oslp*lq jt-;l ,'*Jtd*ry ,tL(u-l J G;fu'J);L-rL
Jid, U-l -tL.: c,r.Jc " ".,'lru J i++ t'A-r"
k
Lt as:6)s:J Y0.".a
,p s>,(jr; or5.;; -fi-t\ -q..A-6
(,-rl-La 1,1 -r-al,*7 t,
'is
Kolakowski, Leszek. Modemity On Endless Trail, Chicago, 1990- pp.3-14-
.,-rL-, -r.a :!-Uyf .Y
{rp-..y;-Lr
,4
u,,t Ly 3: ;l r.:!G- )l 6lae 3.a, I ,3i'$Ji. st c-r--} 'h
f,*t'-r-r-
r;,x r,-!> -, c-l (Llij;l g,.*t.r- r.:*i, ,5- .*--F.e Cfu
:*..c51.(l:i-rl.i,
Foster, Hal. (Ed.)Tfte Anti Aesthetics: Essays on Post Modem Culrure.
Seattle 1983. pp. ix.xv.
:1 .6-,,,.r*okr yl&- 6l;.t
Lukacs, Gregory. "The Metaphyics of Tragedy," in Soul And Form- Tr. by
YYf / e(,-jtj r c-iuo ,;* ,gaf"a J s1)l )r*;
",;ot{-
Anna Bostock, London, i977; Goldmann, Lucie[, The Hidden God: A
Stndy of Tragic Vision in the Pensees of Pucal and The Tragedies of
Racine. Tr. by Philip Thody, London, 1977; Steiner, George. The Death
of Tmgedy London, 1961; Williams, Raymond. Modem Tragedy. London,
1966.
er J-
gLa" 6La:;l 1,Ut:-l oL;>L j_,,t3 ,1i_ s)ss *--r*
s-y-s
jl .t; rhU .rE "FiVl
.-ljt* ! .;+ .Jnl a! .lK:.U o(. 3t*f a, cuLLL
.-:t--l43Ib tSss &, rc;l-r.j .riJ,tl ;l.u- iE
db ! -r ,_r .fE
/- aa .:K; oLiL .rg o-li t-_ra ,,g_f.-l>; o.r.J r.r,-lr:-3;
'\'"-, ttl-, rF J tr dr" j rf ,J.'tJ,rf;r; I . t-: o; l-.-, -ri >9 c rfrt
.p- L;
. .
Yrf
dl gl-r, q of)!:
ory sgV*Ssrr-l c,.,^-n r,+-e
G-*s ts,+ rl.tl r i{;l "hlr )yl ;l.,(,- q oL:r[ -,11(l
"+-*
,lL; l;
J*?l O-"1 (Coleridge)
e)-S :t 6s* \ c6l-r.ai ..";tJj
.tftI q, r.-ulo.r,l-ei
W -fi-:r, (Suspension of Disbel ief) rs-,r
!U
-rr -!-ti ,FlrA;l,, 6;U; oT \ s g"--,-l.y .r--/it 6t-iL; a,,f
J #! dke (-u,f dll,-" ,1*. 6fr!-l ;,0! + o;l-n-a aSi-f Crr
6la:!L l1 oI -,.,"ta f* JS r.c>-,\ n6ri,9-srl cJUL s
'* -t> 6rlls-*
pTst;t J ere ,fsrr l-r.rL-, f L,.-:K;L.,jrF)Ji.;-
..rr clQloti>L_ o-t ,f t, gK c+: r.t-ul3i jl6t"i t,g.:t-!
o-r:L ls Gst ca:-,,rl3 j LS;a i-r,_rll ot*. j-," ,@;-f U
,tI
.l: ,,*"r dts, &-,a "*-La-
c-d)
t' J f"lq 1-r
t' ,-rLa* s y-l,;ef
c*l o,-uilri s,Ssls;L,;; :l>-1lr.! ,et LLS? jl ,a s> ;*
t o!-rl; oK."So,.x1l_r yl;I;r-;I yk-;. s jg s.r-1 o(
g1.r1 1: 6;;-:J".j J ")J?=i / YY,
,;J; -r: J )Jt( l; i:u-lj.1 ,3r,I tb ,t-* .r'i :'r' a' 6-r:Jll,./ Jgi
g;,L.*, s if 4j lJ d-,-iok-lr: ,y' grl-r 6F : &-; cril 6!*
c,slra-\ 13yl AKu---r ot, -r, .'ril-r' r'i-'*'a : 'lr 4-i 6 ''';f \u
.c.*lc,-13; U U) ;t5Jl- a-jc*1.;llji,5r"-rL, ,-;t*'
ol.1
: o:L- cf L- f )\\-t a^"L glrJ" J ,J[i oL- cc'-:L j o4t 1:: ob)
.rb; k;
t' U,r-"3 ftc o;1> al>y sS,6.q,lL;-r-L dbl+ "Nt_
Er) ;r ) )te
-r'lrc/ .rlJ* orfl'9 'jl:r" or5- e-t. s &s
-e
uir Ptt :, f \.c-.(- d.dl .t, &-r J GtP c-*t o'K u{ 'p s
((S)))rP
,n. ,, it."T rt rl.i.U ,,o cr;lr L.i! , ,. *\;7tt 4{ U,\*
J- oj 9Ll cL dt"j t ".:",r1(,lrLy-l\'n,-i:lr:K U) J J, ) *-T
6sKulol;3 -r,T,r, ;:\sr tr t Jt"Ka,--i' a-f:l'r.[ a;'5c*13-I
.$:c/
"fBl-,
;^: .i:*,1{rt ;a^j Syl ,-{ ,)*,.rka t:lr;'! 6lij! yl
coj)\rl
.-,6- t>;-tt 63)li W
^;f l:c,S.ll-, kr .c:K1.JUj gl t
U- o;
=6
(4--A J\>y )o*-iT1, eL; oE- d-S t\- ,S-\ ry-&,.;r.,!r-
!J--l,
6-# .r.J)r gI ,, o.rL sgto;til olyc/ l; rrf- , " ', oL)) .c-*l ))::* 2
p s> .u;-sT ry irf * ilg 6.u.syyf oleK ellt a-f .-*;t:
6;rU c6lo;;I-l 6trEU; f b d: -.,-: j-, ,1, a-f - .; l: )V t*-! ,JL
,t' 6,, )-\, -,
'l v-r,l0-rllyo-
J^- J -+)f "L:;- l-. Jli!- oL j ,- ,,1 a,Uj
\^.c..1
6a1-; ,l; Lgl.lr.r-bl i;o; &; )J, (<j;1 J, 1
6L;.al; i*; \ e(lL* ,l*-, jt .ttrf tjh staoL-1, t ,t13li ai
J) !?*^;-: l;..rr[.!ifLc;,.1 r 6lo;[;l ,-rl-rc/.r:- \1.r;l.l,-!-;*
? J^ .tr;,4f Af u3f,"bt c,.! jt c.*-.-r c.i.p. l;-.rf
/.r -h-
t 6*.f bc*tsrt 4 -p s *se 9lr**.6 jt .,(. ;;.: ,5t-t *
g.1r, dl oL-:L ,=5 ;I;t ,L,3 3 c-:"tt jI ,*^ uoV &s
"*i
.r1y-1 ;> 6;-;,:J"i J )J^i / YYf
&-t\ "ra ! ,-u-lj is; 6lo1.1p-l ob) ib:J c;i"ls ttul u"-{rs
.o.l..i, rL, Li-,,i\ o3li:a 6L* -er l d ,P;:3 c*l !# r
",r-lj
s si s, dr-l.jL.-? ;l; o,"s:; e.'l g-"a ,b s tSP
*';L "lU,,(i
.frlj ki n, dlrJ,. 3t.-i,lo-r":i t' ;> ccrtfJ3D ;: o;1-9^-o l>3*
JU.3F jb-l) )gaSJ r6rt,.:.rJ;1 6;V rr* oUj 6ly l.1 !L--a
s
YY..t*,--91 6 ,L,tT,,1
1r ro;ljl-;n G-F .lLj s -6,-o+sl: cVr+t
,see:\.rJl#' Cp!.:1.r o! -r: ltoU ,tl-r .:*l-e,-.r" flf u(-
sgl-r- q-.lj- 3 o:j c+.r qtj- i)t ,.rt5;i, u.lil -r, (f -ft,
"
.+! .r-U G\: e *;lj cL; ,r:+!
s\ *,r Ji,l ai;l> .,:ai jl s,-1.(-;t, efuI ,r.,i tu{ ,p s>
;r, rl(,l .:;l-r, t, 3?3tj tJ-rr-rl3 *; C--S.-t;jd fK.rU
n-i--ui
.9 c-.i(,- ur- s
t;FrSrll t':l:5-rlr.t<* ) eQL\L; ) ;il3
a;os3 aJ)! 3.j.ki
erlr b U3)l6,5j;J *{b!/;1.'r--rsT,r" qtt,
&-
J &-'r' LGf J o*:b tX 6u bl;.S s>.-rjli:..4!l-9 yl ;->La, t*t
ifb;:6yB "^>.+
Org P: fTr:-S* 6tagL*lr 1;111L-T
.-r;l.-r,-il -r-lj G;
t':[ltr t? t e?-ss>
sl; 6h13 cf,--rti c..,r3, ;: l1 yl sl*Ut 1.J J'i, J) rr"lf
-r>
+iJi i;l-r:l r,.i-,l,".1 frt -rl gldt S 3.tU J* -,r.-r-o>.re
YAo-,,iL
,S-l s> o4t ,;.:s> yj^i> -lE[: ,tl:r, 3 ,fo lla-;l
"btf f
l; dL-lr Jj ,J["JP ;--E ir-lt .JS6..rl- e* : q;) c;- a-r7
?*)V r) t<j 6c;b )V * qL 3) r: *:l> ,,ltAJl i*lr t !-!
;L-i r, ?.i<, ) F ,Ss ul$lrr ijl-e 6c*t ;{by iSla-"--r;l
cisssl-l. sl s*tV L c.:*31 (r.&'n jl ,; "cK * 6cgj otil (',:t,.r
; ld; j _. :? : ; : :,?:;;,T
(Unio Mentalrd
;tc"--ul ii-r..--e a.-fc*t CG Sf \$ ,,
r;
r;i.i..r,1-9 r5--r,l r,Jt"-.1 ei"-r;t ;T-1> a-fc*l 6l&^J u--{,g._r.:i13>,r,
c>lsj,.a:
db "l "$t dl" ,Jr;*" uL<a -r -:;a-i "rla- c6111 j ,- tljl
rY.,.:*l
cJL ,rl c(_, .tI ,S -tta.K. a.L-.r o*;;
t'.,r ,r,-try
t;ls-; s g-s, &rl: ,g.T -f ;: .cul o:jo3-rjl Jt* .,,i 1;.
gQ, , f t'! ;l 6t^; f .r;l{-.jl) -u^i_rl i e.,\ b-o\ 7 co.:jga
rr.e 1,r :.lif f+ q
ii ,-lf ;> j* 6-t*z- 6lail.Jt- d", J) J :_rlr
,rl$rt,3 :LIKU jl.rLr"r: ,,o [-r: s -I s* t'.-,Ie(;16I
;l1r-, a\r--l 6c.*l ;tJ.K;)yr oL-I.l c*l ;L*I e-(r,;I
.l-,*,.f )V"..l;.-$ 1r )131 3 tt';11:
c3i- c-ril:,r,,.,4Ui l, tae-(- ,6f lJ.,:-L r ,6;LS:;
l-s L-J) 6t"f-j L)))T
.:-,t--+ s *\f cg . la.:r-Il -^,-j,; -b.lI
c-*l(Grail) gt+ ,\ ,1-, ,;-111a{cu*} <!
rr.-u.;r,t,-rl
"*-ri"
) j.
ay;lnll.:- .-.,.1 6-s,:r* c*tn I ,&-; rL.j .:;,- ,.6 f F_
t o.u
,-rU l;-l : 1, g.r^ K,, .if o-l;, ;l j K;;-:; j j t :l s[ | ss
6.
-,r:l-r )\1 -uKs,.-u:-jl.:.r, LI.j^^, l) GT &)u* ol.-! A\r"- ,
tt.*r-., [r.; l1 -:;: ,i.f
_l
,cS t ass> u,.a, l5lla.K o--.-r:1+;jlr )-*; s.-c;fe-(, l,
rv.c-,|6;-,.1I ,I
c*,.1(androgenous) cr-a ,:J +Lr6-J c=-:ry af
e-(r6l G-r;:T r-: a-fc-:il> cf 1- #.,>L c.'.l,L u-_le
"UT';,.)ri2M
-e t_,
,J1r-1 J) .9-p).l*: J )re.; / Yf Y
Vl .uol p:
Lacr.ill.l.lt-l
18- Jung. C.G. Plychologlt And Alclrcnt1,.Tr. by. tr.C. IIull Vol. 12 of
Panthcon Books. Ncw York. 19-50, P. 184.
.Yf . -YYd e)) 6J-) 6togL-l: -9 1^; cgL-;l*tjrJp .\ I
c,r-;G u.:l
.YV-f V ,'z (t?Jk^ ci{l 5;l.r-jl .\,
.il; .urLe:L. G-yX)l a-l,o-n s:'j", c;J-e j t-?!t*" r;2|;.Y \
.A - Y Y ,," A lV o;lJ cp-l: JL
loumey to no end
Conclusion of all that
ls inconclusible
Speech without word and
Word of no speech
Grace to tlrc Mother
F'or the Garden
Where all love ends.
:*..,5.t tYf tl"6;y' A1L
Eliot, T.s. Collected poetns: 19U)-1935.
New York, 1967, P.62.
:.ct.J ')\i, igl:rr c+5 )5 oi)3 yL,";l 7;L.;: tt"at crt 'Y A
"'1
Arendt, Hannah. Essays in (Jnderstonding: 1930-1954' Ed' by Jerome
Kohn, Harcourt Brace and Company, New York, 1944 pp 1-50
lJ u.!-tA4-l-J s t:Sct o;l3l +-i,3;rla, r,r,T Ja" tt *:-t^d;= -t> i:2|*":L.
.)_iJ.
:.6.1 1: ,SM ,oi e* stt .Y 1
Lukacs, Gregory. History And Class consciousness' Tr' by Rodney
Livingston, Cambridge, 1971.
:.e5.2 c6,r;,1 fa : ;:\-, i a)) ), 6rF\V. ;\; J'.;' e-= cstr 'f '
Blumenberg, Hans. Work On Myth. Tr. by Robert M' Wallace, MIT
Press. Cambridge, 1990,
:.(t., (dl= L-l^;3;r1 i* cs!.Y \
Jakobson. I{oman. "'fhe Don'rinant" in Readings in' Rrt's|;ian I'oetics' F'd'
by Mateika aucl Pomorska. MiT Press, Camtrridge, 1971' pp 82-87'
YtV / .,.T E" .rr)" 5;.fr-u J si)l ).Itu'
i:
Chitooras, Jeff. Gnosis: A Journal O.f The Welitern Inner Tradition. No. 2
(Sp. 1e93), pp 36-40.
:.tS.1r,o'T cy" \ tsT Jy -t fE e.? 6lJ .f A
Jung, Emma and Marie-Louise Von Franz. The Grail Legend.
Tr. by Andrea Dykes. Sigo Press, 1920 P 16-5.
Budge, E.A. Amulet,y And Superstition. Dover, New York, 1978, pp 86-87
ard 323-325.
:.e5.1 cg.T G...- -r) igl-B &- cSlJ .f V
Starhawk, The Spiral Dance: A Rebith Of fhe Ancient Religion Of the
Great Goddess. Harper, San Francisco, 1,987, P. 42.
.A1 .qgLa ,fJl9.t5.; c,r:."a,1:L fl. C-1 6r.f A
"f .FdL^ ,'K .e9., ith* ;, I e.*,1 G! .f C
f-/ t d LLil -6 -r"E t- J,
"-
:.t5..1 c7 j,4* S-l
Neuman, Erich. The Great Mother. Tr. by Ralph Manheim, Princeton
University Press, Princeton, 1991.
rFska.f .
.Y. Y-A o',
.Y 1 1 6FJL-a c)y-f .6.-t c6J,3l.tl oKrt..K re"- cs! .f t
""a
:.d.f.2 rx.r,I c4;-,, ,; Lsly .f Y
.lk-l -l f";u 6r*, r1.,"-r a-f 16;, gl c^, j d<"- 3 1(: ;j;t
al;L-;r )-t 3 t-v;6f u;[" .-;),U iA :) n{ c7l9o 6t," r-r]*--i1
l, -r,--r-1. F jl 6l;+0 X- ,-:l;- : 6,:.1 i,aJ*,-: gl ,-r-r:l;: J ui
n-f c*ii ::*. .Sor-. -*l ,:_.;T *-* _srf-r; .r!K; ,-r,rr:L.
,;c-f.r" )l+* Jr*" .r^-b 9*;; 1s a)i SL-*:
*$r,u,k+ otl *a
.l ; r) .9 ,i)J>; e )-L>j / YA'
r . r- .r a.-
1,
C_rU J ,J[.6;
,6i) J-l e_rti jl 6l+b.J d-rr) jl gfJr .:11: ,i:.L:
.,f+t Jt-- -r> t;\o>f ,rln jl L- c.r:5 L-7 !e,:.; t-,r!.:lt e -3-,
>l-u:-l o_*J;: .-r.i.1l-r.i uot(*j ,.:+r;, ja 6;K[- 3 -t::"{o, 1.j,a,
f
K : b.r-r+JlJ, .L<rb o;1;,.,r sT;: ,JLil .:L'-i d--a a5610>j
i."o a(61.:j;riL L7 ;,-1 )) ) Lo)!.*ltr3* ;t.L::t- G\^;!&.-<
t6i ro,u;./rT r1.',* u/\f ) e*kJ.l ^b?< t' jl jLjl 6bJJr,
.c-lc-e c-;* i 5*--;T Ju-p 1,1..- ' I ;o s>\1cJLjl.LCL'
\dY I i2;-;-;,- -:Ji <: -Lu; o -.1 ,r--
os* iI ,:3 ^-' i-L r-j ) f* t -r:fs" l-Sfr lr rrL ,,-1.: lti
1
u-a-L
."r ,*j r: J.:-r ,,Sn),p.:
e - \ JJo;l-l
r
';
J- J*,6;;Dpka cLl
i
o.r,; a;i-r., taCL!1 : *;l;t^.lb ;l c,JI r,5U-
Err,. e;L:y-., Slr-,.1! 3
JLJ ,l ) ,i:3U 3 tQ Jt(.:;t * \; 6;K\s-,b .r)- ;ll:
"r-l
.tl rl ,), -:-,)-l^i , )-t^i / YAY
1\lgse*: c-K ul9 q:I 6-r:1>.r" ..rf -i:-ol3* ,lt* g-6., -r lls
6;s\ s.:*l -,1^- t.: :F 4...r o>rr 6.:;l: ,Jl.eil 3l .,*,'l 1-i.a, ,t-
p. 7s: t-t-"T-1l-r--r 1 o)/,r, l-,,r .9 c;l-r:ly oV +-S
riyld
tS s s tlr3T; ;l.r:J-.Ll
;$jll G s s\:f )\i JU -il .,,- \ r u.rl:i
-tu
\att.-ial;- d,+
;*rr gi;l>dlrif .J[> d1.f ;> rt-n 6'iJ) /) '(Fg
-S t ,,y-f-, el, f-, .s$-d ,6 ;:{o, ,-h i,-lL*,-p-{ xo-ui-'r,l
.+T.r 1.r; c.,; ;\ ,1a- ssl:
t'e e\ *.,.:-l o> 5nl-r-l 1-2c; e.t-a,) or 4'c--,,:; 6j\; W 4\Vl
J.\JJ
\1c.r:5,r,1+, ,
l-6^j? t,l ,, o{ dj( AL, ,gF J o& )/ 611".*l crl,ij o-fr o;s+
tt n.or!-
\ (t' .,,t3 ! t l ..ri'r,-: r,i,cj ;*..o c-; il "' P) J. o-f
))) \ )r-rjlELl .rjt- "F,t";L 3.>*l >yy t3* t-S-tS> s> s\i* i:\ g.-
.rr\jiir)) oLa:1 ots\rj c-' I u')\'ijl;lJ* dI cL
c* c.-ai c*L; .;,L; >9 jr"obA t, f \ r:;1.: i3-t- 6;t!:l,o Ll
cJL o>jlj> ,:-l'K;l ,ru, o)t) gT -.1: .S -r-413,- .4i lt1jl7^'r o'-L,
-tl-t* :-{y,Jl.;r., q 6tt o*t L)Ft-! sp s\:* ':*n
a'"!:l .r5-l
;L:
a' ,rr-r; alJ* (J^t^ J *-s.tG. rt-rl-a:rr*U,.rL, t .tj." f^
Lukacs G eorge. H isto ry and c s -" o
tas
Cambridge 1978.
^rroutrfo.;.;'.'ff1-Hl
,t-t e)j c^;* ilr t I e(:! tV * ajr E rf $'U *( ;rr J,-!.y
-9 ,-rl.u.,;-.,r .J:f.,- S-l;-^ 6prt- )Sfl S )Sy-t oL-:t- jl t: fa g
;J U ,*-65[-1u(.,^l-c :r> 7 ur:tgi
e)l ,f -,, 6 i2il ja Olf.i:. .>2
e$ l) )r-
"os ,$ ulol; ::T t\ & i Je t >)tT e )[ 4J lJ (.,# dJ-)D
.'f
.A \ -AY rrrrg;K.lf
c;L-o
./t, ,;a r;L^ cg;-lK.tf
.01 .f c;L^ t6r;K'\ O
16- Manuel, Frank E-anc1 lrrank P. N{anuel. Utoptan thought in the
.1 \ i;l^. r6-:K.f V
(-l,
.11 .,,z (c"-.r- ,6r:ti .f t
.1 \ di;l^ar6_r*:K.Yl
'dti,** cro*r.l.rl
-
:t) y' t tu-F S ;;l-*r_t l; J:o.u;...:J:i,r+ Fr^ C.G6:T 6;,, I
.J4ai-r)
& r, rru;lr;"1-- igtll.rtq;r 11lL; CiT LL a-fs.;l:,r,
) e.b -t :-{-* 6;lr'.1 tr>Ko, JL &f .1.: .cal tturtf- fF
JL JIF 3Kafaq- -e c.-l g.:.4 g1r.=l :;;,, 6 6.n:*-, ..c!1^-
c-t"
.r5,r^; fl.Lrl fj) .:L.r; *<^;ol+ c;5rt-f ;l-rtl, ,,-*)t-,- s
ssy ls 1l c>=a;*) J:l f S ;: 3 ...-rjjl:l,d 4-_ti ;t;;1 a, ...1.ri1
6,- *rlr,r, \6x.-r,11.:7,,r, Jl ue;:t.;L:5a, bf ,l-ljl -q: J5.,,
+.o:- c>ral; glo-!r -r.-l tSk+U ;: a.f t-6I b a:l 61g -e f Ln
lrJ rt-* f lr 6rlr./ Jl-ua !rlJj j s b:1 t 1n.r;1, i5lo-u:.f
=,
*->f ,*;3rr *r-.r 6sf ;:t;-_*
l. ".laL:;;t *( .rf [ 6;1.r-
1ly u,.S+ {Glf a> j ) G j,""* 3 oLs, U:;. {)l6Ltt []7 S4l S
f ::-c al:K-r ) Li Lsi6 y-)> ;:6*--r,-.: iy-7-j;'^,-;e
J:}-* jt-!,-, 'rLjl:+ dp *.: El.:-:.: )x* 61::L*; iU.p
-r Elo-r-i :(r dg"k"-tt: t<"F ..j?"i ) el : lsf tst
! 6.*k*[; I ;lorl: nlJl,jl;. ,l-* ;t JL ,_kt.* ;r 6 4Vss,
cr! t'.*tC_t: glo:":;l> K;r"t .:r[- -,l}-* \ ss;y ,>1\L.J-rl,;,
.f-^,--,!-i,rs)-l -ra+ dnt d,"* jt Wr&.; )l ) l{.tf 6- yV
"r_t \V,,...-t-:rj
..\ -l- +
v s\ ,F GVr 6+ .,!)\;l ,<+ "r-t 1. o1)v-
&,of 4'f
..rfr+, trJ*
c/y: cSlaJLo o-rl-5*-o t" o*t? -2t ,KjdJ,11 1sl-u ca>l JL -r-', ;:
\A
,r.G t a^:* ; I l- Jl 5.;3 ) s, c-L 3.,* 1 J*o 1 > 6t-JI .;- .c--i,b
+:*-Ul .gEi ,tt- )l -*.1-: La4;"$l ,-r.,lr-ti-t-;,r" ?lf 4;lS./)Li.ll
.#, !; cL -^lnl 6t.r1 ,Kl t' jJ- .c i.l.ij :91uoc j,e) 6n:o
L- oJir--n! 'oih;; oK j u4 ey-t e-fs ) goto;6lao*7 UF
a,1-; ,s-fli
E[.k-r,oo;;.>.rqil:,r, k G\6e).a> u!l;'^L;:-u
c-i:Soj;t- L- n!ti- :1; sLdL a:"-lt l 6oT 6E 1 rol-rlt:
c-*.JtFli-- j e:d.:. ))J \.rJt"ti dt65l; sL;rB.,, *l-fg
;f are; 5u: 6 *sytt +5't .,*r, ) l, ,s) a,.e r5.r,
oK-, rril;r.rr ,-N yrr;.--lJl3 ,o:3JI .-bJLi,
'Lt-..o, C r Jl-
JV-
.r
. -i:J! < i 3:s; . -:i :-t*-
"lK
.c*\r urgrtS xp.iJ?a.oagL, ;lrdl afll:,.r" Jl .c*{ itl,-
to
F- rjtT-l "-I-tr;!T 3 -u--Jl-u."\ Cr, t ...utt;I{ : "[,oLjrrjl
.:;l: tjlTI Us-tu t.lJltil o;13, -*bl ;: l-l .x-f*,
"9r[Lil.rJ
otr .rr) J.l) a)t-tlj6 Jr 3K- rt, Glt-l -* )P 6 t-y. $:*" Jl
it Xi j rg-l*,lt1" G;l-e G))-t' f.f at;' p-<- ^- J.)rlr
J ,/l;&-/ rrlJ-"*J;l J:*rr ir^- ,.."V c^gu^Y1r,.*.g;L
.r, tu tr5!.-*
G4-- GP lG y.c--.{ jt::l/l oov 41,r-71-.--:, ,,1
Y^r-tJ5;,
!-- ..r:,-,r tc*La.-,iy' ,*-S ".d1- J .,">G "f i.1tt
Yqr,.a-L
.*)r s Jsf st rs*J,a.
J*l :-# 3: erlrr-l i:E : 6'^; ;, ,.?t:< i,l r3l jGK *
.,.r.-"-t. ,5u,*li 5* Jt ) r-r.:.,l!r *r".r-J<-*( .c;t,
.9+- $T 6j$;.rL^qL il -*- 1 *rs:l-1T 6*J"? alr^jrt,
,;13,-,.*qg:$T J-et;t sl'*-s:" s|st,_t cS_,1-r:F ruy4-*
t^r! t' l.r l;T pl :l; :Tu ;-K*". i- ;Lil a*-t ;l rr: 7 6 :l;-l
rr.p . o .
f rr,J-'rl-
e c-*,;-t { C GVt.5 '!* .r5*"7r-
iLj, ot-
s & oV ;: f a f 6t^ a-? rt ) ) o-lL--e r i--1 J^ d/ I 61 4 +l*a i r4-7
l-,1
6i'atl )J-, -d:*- u.;13,, ,' ,.) jl :l;1 +5-rJlJ,r- j3;, *. ,,s14.
vY
o
".*E
t \Y1Y .:1.:rr ;.: d>rf o-r-oti 6la;-i;;i ;> o1-r*/ \: -b -#
it*I J- jl;; F,-'I.ryi ox c;.i;:f f y ".* -*; \ ) t*
;Fr- 6+-.:y o:fL, JLfetl3L,.lL o**-, U"t{,6c^-t iUf
\ (r-S \ f ) )_y, \ t 6 S:-r.:lJL." .:F! -il Ir$1r c-r--rsr
oL*.11 i-,!t: r>sli,3...rf *-"ti ;tf :L^aSl i &r;
"r ;*,
.11lr-,.r,1 ...&-i * ubl* iol J)Sl o{rt aL*,4 J yTo-p
;,-r o{ y-ra. s 3'r-. I r..e : f} L-;.: . J: gl:i )sy\E .- yl;
'tL-l o>f c-'t; |\'f a. >y
cl-l; q -r;l i> JT ,.r f ;s""; 3;*l
t
YA\ / iE*,<-r-* uil ,s;ftt+ _,. si)l ),raj
;t aU f \ (-\n k,l t' -u-U j Ql- brr ,5-u .rc-r.. J c^:;-y rr, oI,jlJ:
3 o-r-- g-lr" u",)U- 1 c>y oJL C! dk- j) .,.,JU dU jl$,1i J jll-l
6.r.i;rr l; 6j)J, cJ9-; ri..-r,jL ,K:\ S Q Gjf 1 3 -t;51r, o;\V
6lr,-l -2t,3 ;;->-t*; i :.t-7.,- / YAY
1f
y(t**.; :l,a* pU t ir,"U; 6) 6,1*ti. ;: .Jl3-,rr og1i A'ljT
s $lf uLlj* --S- tf V,,1.,1 aQ l$, G:'t:LadL*il-t'-J-'",q
jl lt .gQ J (+ 9l a, ,j:l-,rl jl ;S AJ-a) *;'' 'i:l-2ll tf e-e
c-j I a gsl--21K1 1 .r [- J t-. -l .a.,,e,rr)t-
. l -: I u
c5jlJlf+;: Ll cd-jlr.J)ti.il
J-." r,-! ,y,lS*.r11 u:,5*rr,*j
;A ;: cdliJrl JL:,I"iJ il.--l af 7
,-'1s.e J-l * -;: 'c*'il> uS'-x'
.Y- \
'lA "f ttL*;*l o;131 '\ D
.\'Y e (Jlni-T c3l6l'\ 1
.1 .f I rteOka .\ V
d,:.^ 1u* J i ,sf--' 6t?"t*-9 r;l JL..tc- 2> cu1Qy" 6ri- 6li4
y-l 2> .;L.f r, .,t st g-Frr* .-tjlo:l: ot-r *(;J, ,*$u; Gr, frg*
,..4 1 *Y cs'ai-l: ,r-.lJ -tt 6K;;\ s* df$ ar> i J.)s^ lK ol)
6* 66T 5-r: jl l: AKi\,-f Lg -b ,=v *. Ly.rn tt-lg; .>20;-- : -E
'1+; c+!
.\ D ,," c(s ii-T :t.f ,
.Y L o2 cla,lLa .f \
ilLl 2: ,g;r:-:Jd ) ,Ji I \A2
.l 1 .f ctTokr .f Y
l1 .ta.tLa .f \"
"f
rGV.t,.Sr.+-.f f
.'\f 1V .blra .b' t) 6U!.;l&
.1 \'A ,,a,!1.* c.f 0
.LY e cta,tLr .f 1
a ti u ';-T ,:.f V
A 9LJv-
.f
.\Y .e rlL c.FA
.\ ua t1l-l;it-l .Jt?: .f 1
A\ ,f c !L c.0.
.YY ,f rtTrtLa .0 \
.1 I .f c$crLa .0 Y
.\ A .f cl'7,-rkr .0 f
.c*Ls.Uli,r) d+ rye;.U-$ .Xt'.,., rt-dL$.AA
-f V ,r ct7,tL-o.Ot
.A'l
.1 V\" .,"a...rt-Tcf.gl .AV
.1 A .f ,+,lL^.1 \
.1 . 1 .f c2!-Ju,Ll 0.2t2.1 .1 1
lY rrc[rlLa.V.
.'\
.\ Y ,f rrtt :-,a
6-l .V \
e ctTrlkr.VY
.YY
.Y .A .f L(r pIs:.YY
.f 11 ,,a slarlL.a.Vf
oL-u,i-l rt". 1 i11-.1 rt i-- .nt-o:L- .;l&.GVt L5J:*-.VO
=-*T, . ,f c'l .l"0
.Yf Y
.0 Y .f (f.f ,rTr:.V1
c\ l' d Y .5: ct" . f i JL: rt-*- crrtr.:U : iI, ..51 &, u1V-* dJ:a- .V V
.l .6 ..e
1.0.f ct7rtLa.VA
;7,;:i;:;:
.Y \ \' (t-dLi \
.r." "A
0 ,"a cta,JL-o .A Y
.Y 'l
JJa.sJlJ Ar-
JJa-JJIJ s+JJ-
."L_I q-1,, cri- ig)L r5l
.sr)f :s:lF-ttsPi
;Lat3"rtr jl ..,Lj oLr -r: .:-y. s?_tss;:lr; rl o1,-*e drr...^.y, jn
Z;l2T j.:;r, ,tlr,6; ot(,::1, jL- rL-l .t>)l>
1l1o-1sL*l ..,r1+i;,)lJl
,*:Eo" .j *t (;ls^Ie tl-t-S J c,!) t b3,r, ,>L-lS* 3 cu!.a:
d--t tt {-l -r;l:.'. ; $8s,1 .,:*l xg17-l .,*1;a*,L ,ti3l;!l
-r>
rLe )) 6oUI , j G- ,l_s >f ) Jij -Ei<s, .g,.1 n,--l! JL.frr ,tya
Y
yI C*3"(- J-9"r1 -Lf 1<"In, aU-4? ;lr^ I; ";,1;l 6ln)p 'c;L; * ;p;: l;;+ 'k
'*l
Y16 i.i"L-Jl : ,AJ*
cJl-rr lr
"L-;l 6 j: +S V ,*-b r5> .-r;l>a ,-,)\,rjl ;l 6;*
>
153l.j f "J
-rl I Jg : ,Sr, i;jl.: ,r I s ro-r* 3 >11I i:-.: J:
a,
")..a1
.r:;l>;3L rr.tLl ,ryr- 1 J"tf,*,-L-c
l&.9 ,f U)F e'-a- 9 >y I Ss
ll;j
(d
"*)
6>\1-l ,>K 2 &-,* l, 4t-a -Tt Gs:;r"s ;ln *_L;
rl: -1f
,-i:g y: rS C"le-;:-l t'; t..:-t ,-1l:,tL,-l ,Jt;-J) rra"-ro"rrl t'
j*i *.ttt+.Crl t --t-* c,L,..Jo 4;ryLrL;: o.(T f ) d. t L):t
L-iL,> Ll co>;1 t - -,t'5gl.r,B 6-r.r>,r, oLi
"&:lJKd"LlJ>
.:K.r-l .4'b o-a: l* .:!;: ts.-,(, "U;"* * ;;i;.s1.-> ,)j*l
Jyt )*l d,i" ./L-tj l*-i ,\Al \ cJL-1: 6 GU: JL' jl ..r5.,.; .rL;l
,6 ui-y #-l -r,-U d-[:-, ;:T t dl;]-- )l ,f1-r-ux e;31- ;i c,"r(.-
Yr.,:*i.-r"I
,JL J,t,, a"l; )l Jlrf Vjlts- sy )\ s,:1 *-:\
J-,l ,<ba;,Jl , 'L -i.:-l );.* '-- ,l il ,l- -0.*e -!> r,L-r,,."tt
J J v - Jt J .Jr I J-l J r 9 ..9 -
vlrilll
Lacgih.rt-r
jL* c;:L-l f
r j e)lK;t (.lJ , ;\J-a jS, ,s;lr;.,'" GU .\
1 rt 6G;
,ri3iQ ,- -".lKss.tt.o*y; -' ,r*-r-o:.cf.; r \ Y A Y ;^g fro" ,,
.Y-1 u, t\ YAY oL; rf "o;ki e,rrt..7l lJi, LU rr.,tl1l ;:./L-4*t?
-,r.,-lfl .r;-: qgbr;.o (&-J-o d*y; ,5 xri.iK.i-tt tgss# da"-.Y
.\ Y
"f IVY
r\ c6lr4: t6,i>-a
l-y" i fll crl^t:rj
4-zl9 6Lj jl,r :'s., qi3 o>l).-al i;L;: U--S g-"-- ;S> t)l:' 6\ .Y
Karl Popper, T'he Open Society antl Its Enemy, Vol. tr, Nerv York, 1979.
:t.e.f .O.t t
L.eo Strauss, The Ciry and Man, Chicago. 1978, pp. i-13,
F: L[)L- ;> LliuLt,-f (*:rr rdy;l :rr,.r4-r..an ,Ar_*1 sig_;l:.\ Y
.Y A p>\;
\ - AV ua cu\.t-'z
.\ V. .f 16l*o r,jg.'l f
.\ \ ,-r" rrJki r63J.#.\ f
:1"; 3 Berlin, op. cit,pp. 49-90 '.a".(.f.g ro;L;,-l ::
G*.611 . \ A
Richard Rorty, Contingency, Irony and Solidari4t, New York, 1980, pp.
3-96.
,&\b 6j .t:-l aLil.r" y-l jl .,<,- (Madison) ;-_{ -t-* dt" dL: .\ 1
:.e5...r
James Madison. "Federalist Paper 10," Federalit l,apers, New York, 1948.
;: ,r1i .iit.- aT c;trlq ! ,rq,-r- jt, .rJt^ >)-ra )t.Y Y . "r rqlLa . \ 1
.lA\ d, rdLa:d.e-f.; r\f f Y :l:r;
.\ VV-Af u, .OLA'yi (-uldl_rlj Vq .fl ;: -r-oljj .Y .
Qt Ar-J-a r5: ati,3: U-;qr-i., cf_y.,s.*,r! :l 6 tSs*,r*_ .gUT.Y t
,i)rS 615^t jl ,ra64tt-jf U1 :-r-_5,;,r, 6\l; Ll;-l *i * ca;-) g-l s>
ljt j.
".,- Ol-t:-" de ;JLrl .,n ul*.,a| ) bl);; ! d.ui.f LVut t:LZ
.\ Y rr r,jLa rGjJ-6,:.c.f.6 x.c--;
toal-a O@)G r:f: a"l;:L ;: 6.r.01-u." tt ;'_lS-, a, :l:r" Y A cSbrff,r .Y Y
.\\1-\f \
"r
:l s,Ab r5: .:lc),tl c.*3 3 ;j,r;l $.r.-",,f ,.ral:-er- e,J& O,l .yy
6l-L;j;:...0L -u-i*l f:kf r.-*.: r-;,i5-: )ss s> cs)s;c, j L?91,r L,tI
Ury ,t 1ar-tir1; (r*_J-o &*y;.uL_,,1t_t, d (dL"6, L-r ei 3',{A
.t ..,r" r\ YIY rdkj ,4&_?.1 u4, *.?y;,c,t.-.+
:.e.f .; cc* a_l Jai.
ai ,s121 .\f
Aristotle, The Athenian Constitution, tr. by R. J.Rhodes, New York. 1986.
pp.9-372.
srtls J5r
tugira aiifs
oti6J!, tr
g;.l3sl+q
4rliJ.o ail.r.
calmard, Jean, (tLd.) Etudes suJavides. Insritut ljrancais
de Itecherche e,
Iran Paris--fehran. 1993,pp.3u3
(JL# - s*22\ cail.,,it,r-L;;ly-l
3^;l c6$"a -'i]lL^c(rL;r,.;);UK;lj
YAY :;la;p r\ 11Y
Melville, Charles.(Ect.)Safavid persia: The l.{i.ttot1- arul pttliric,t
o.f an
Islamic society.r.B. 'r'auris & co. publishctl in Associarion
with the
centre of Miclcile E.stern studies of thc tlniversityr of cambricige.
London. 1996, pp.4}6
.c.iL: y
gl'-a;r.r,i: (\vyl-\d. \) tu_:ra.p tae s>f -,,-r- sly_t
T:l.i
u.k -r J)f fyrl jlr'-l .,*r :--L i-, 6;;- i\ ",*; 6 >9 ol23>
i,6 5l^.;t- J+; .r-i jUI ,51,;b j-(i )
e!-;> L,r;l ! ;;f
*-y^e .r.cs.;ka ;.: )\ : .*rf
-*U J!-l ;: q)t.,r3> a"+! r) ,-r+; f^
: >rin,lk* ,.-'o .
,til L ,-rt<*".r! r,rjjl c,,l;r; ,r;_.rJl;3.l .:l-$l
in
J
tloEl;lrg-
f*:-{KS 1-, +; oko ,.o"s> 6t-li{gr g,---,,te53;
.r* ,l,r*fr!)bl -;5il 3 lr.ue), c*<- af -:y ,JIJJ) .:ka ,5 .c;L
.c:rf e.'J+- j[ *...")t* ;:i;tg-rr gJ:l5rr
91-rrl ;: 6;-;->J"i J )J+i / Y't
-,;-:* oK 6 jV 6 lsl iJ tL ;J . c* I
+ t- ;; 6 St ri.:* j I oJ la" r: I
r_9 iJU" ;.: ,tLL_l 6t, ovj !: r[.r ,r-1"_ .iyrl+. t "i
,r;-rb
..r: r"!,ti" )) .r;lo)f a) c**-,b .,.g-+ &_U- ) d1-al ol*\lslc.
d 6 rf Atr-,r- rtS;tjti,,,.xLj #1, t' rh_, .;stsl ei,:*tl f I
t t.*,
a rl!. J," *)- , v-..tl -1r ,e-L.ai il :11$ \c.4*
j.
r9 - \-:;t.',-l .JlL .sLl
)J-r- rtjl U 6c.*lg:,ell;Ica,L;-9t- 3;171el;b:-i.lp jlts-
.lLj -,, Llcc.*l ui;./
;6*.oitr;., g,-l;; r!11 ) C.fi &,JL lli a.-
J*- $1"p I tS t^ dpt j I ..,(- j je \, afr , --* oi s ; ;I .#, f" ; b 6
1
":,
J d Uj .i)J,. i b ;t k, d ., t, 6 tiT .c*1 f st; -t eV; -h, )l
u>
,-rlsl,i : >y ,-,}all ;-l i5l7l j! F" dl.-,-f S oSt\3 ,.;cja c..-^1
"1,_+c
-tl; t 6: \ s -**.:Ult" ;r 1|;3 I,j tlf r.ry,, f :]:.{
Y
YAILI Y1
tacuil.u!
:.6; r1,Jl.ff rl ,silYrl .;*, JU; &- 6;ly ' \
Corbin, Henry. En Islam lranian: Aspects spirituel et Philosphiques. Vol.
IV. Galtimard. 1972.
u-;l 9T'. .6 ..s . ru ;.7[ t,r-k; ; \l ) t j4t e )<..x" 19: ;11 jl si )lf .\
t1r" 7;L:, (f,aA JL tuuVi;11-l r(t ) rrOh*l3L;l :> u-1"l.a i'iLD (Ol*;lJT
;> dJ-n (JL*;|JI u-;l9T 9 (AAt-Af A r\YVf ;il-.
atln-.,--a
"r
,.r r\ YVf ,iE-j ,;tk-,- 'orl^; ce;-,o JL- io-t:;gl-r-l ,(Y;uuf:*L-(t
'A\F-A'r
3. Bacque-Grammont, Jean Louis. "Documents Safavides et Archives de
Turquie," in Etudes Safavides, PP. 13-17.
4. Poujol, Catherine. "L'ambassade a Boxara de Florio Beneveni. ou
comment Contourner en Vain la Mer Caspienne: Chronique," in Etudes
S afavides, pp. 241 -257.
5. Herzig, Edmund M. "The Rise of the Julfa Merchants in the Late
Century," in Safavid Persia, pp.305-3'23
6. Kuhn, Thomas. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago. 1978.
7. Hairi, Abdul-Hadi, "Reflections on the Shi'i Responses to Missionary
Thought and Activities in the "safavid Period," in Etudes Safavides, pp.
151-165.
B- Richard, Francis, "L'apport des Missionnaires Europeans a la
Connaissance de L'Iran en Europe et de L'Europe en Iran," in Erucles
S afavides, pp. 251-267.
9. C-almar, Jean. "Les Rituels Shiites et le Pouvoir. Limposition du
Shi'ism Safavide: Eulogies et Maledictions Canoniques," in Etudes
Safavides, pp. 109-151. "Shii Rituals and Power II. the
consolidation of Safavid Shi'ism: Folklore and Popular Religion." in
-
Y\O / r-ra"r i.;1-
23. Afshar, Iraj. "Similar Farmans from the Reign of shah Safi,,, in
Safavid Persia, PP. 285-305.
24. "Le Tazkera-ye Nasrabadi, Ses Donnces Socio-economiques
et Culturelles." in Etudes Safavides, PP. 1-13.
-
oLi 6*JlJ*aB
Ammanat, Abbas. Pivot of the [Jniverse: Nasir al-Din Shah qajar and
the Question of lranian Monarchy 1851-1896. University of california
Press and Mage Publishers, Washington D.C. 1997-536 pages
6lr--l ,raf.i:L ak* 3 oli 6 L,Jlr."Lj:.lL- "4;: ts.le rcjl-l
AY1 c\ 11V c,r- a;, 6;K^;13 stiijl5"<.il1: r:l-.1L::;l r(\At1- \AA \ )
.{_Jl
ry*.(rt .c--.:1t
,5g,--r-./ t-I d<l ;Xa afc.*.1
"r;
,>o.i"o
,>U Jl-6a ! c,,:.a -1>
nEj* r
Ejrrr .r.,-T,lI rl3
;u19, lr # 4 t irP )l ,*-t- "*i
,.:>l;l -r,Lx .rfe )y GWI jsr tJ s> o\K 3 c-;yT6" 4jta[.i
o:-*I,;t,;l ;=.a jl 6c.il, tg\1A a4;; -^,"!l-, .-+ ore> '..,rte
;J,t t,S|*Jt JJ t4; i x G y r4!r q f 6 it * r1.(v 1 r,") ry
-\A-, 2,- -r-$ t tl6a: 6-r:to>1.: oL:-: ,tI s> 3 o>f ;\f1. &!.f J[-l
S*VLI: Eldlr ,:*\ >y, a;A,-Ko,;EI;.: 6.:! .&
.c,*i;l> oi_l t-b ,l-l -rr: c-.!!-
G*l l-i 6to.:l-r-;
4,, 2t j srn-* a,otf.:;Ll 6\s\ t.S-l ilt-619 j)V s.sl.))
.l> JJ gJ
*.J, *-. o: 2* -i
t * i ss! *+!: c,ra-r r*B 16 rr7
r[Y::T', ?: :: r"',
1.1ti.!l 31 c;ii
0..:;r,r3,-,LCl
J"- t. cglJ,- irl;L: a.f c*l ,t-l Ssls flf ,Sl_r*, ,l ;, _ttr:",1
,g-F,,*h. ;T;: -[>;ry r.; e,-llfr.: of"'ll- -r> -l (.a! t Elr,-l
1,,_l c._lj; a; co3)\e + .-:1.: 6[ :3.- ;t5;.: l1 3l i-r;o-! 63
;;--:; 6111
:6 ::3,.1 {, LLJ lptli y.L:f
-l [...] .i+> ,s" \\s 6;1,-*i6?a:-^ rn! L:, l5u_rf
,rL" f t
(s..;; ,*L (:;.i K;1\ u;^, t E.f) .ry Et-Lir*.l ;:V 4 \)a- s
aJ
"r)..l;tr- r:i^.
c;Ll6EI.7L- o:-t Jttc(*.(t . t nls\ ua;)tt s
f
f .;lfgt-r-.,1 jl C-rr-r -s, t s ,oV tr L?J )) 6 c-K ;l t: o,
s: ,;, ,_ a1;T ! iB.,,r; ls-* sl c-:Ll 6GT ,- t\j; cr-!r-l .f..rb
d--* -r,L; .r-11.: i:3Lr;
,,,-lo-rrlf
,-:-rI 6lsl Ogt9 #tt,JUS
,t3, cK.r-1,..:r^rf 6EI c-tl-9; o 6c;l: *5; I-! l; r>3G
t'n.fb "r-l-,,
)) cj[,] 6lsT fyl ir:,JL+;tjF !f: c.r;:l-rj ft-rr
l1 .(\f \ ,-'") r-11 rr;J:,a+ ,,af, -sV-lf ,-*Ll -,, *
"*;X.t
.tjl+ tr tV ,;i*-r l: ,"V ,\;, 6 >fo, vl oV ;rJlJ'r'L
"r)
(-l.,) )J* o:& f-* ol, L l-, t6ss7. 6\yl j*tt rf3 .(Y. f
.-t 7y c^.*!E !l;,j!!
6GI iJ-e.rJl.r ;-e .xjl1\r-t t' J) #-1 utf G f SV tW
o-1.1.,
L rL,tr c-e--ion c^.,>I 6tll .(aJL orl*, d) \ \ r3, oJL o:jiL: i:*rI
E:r,
irji;ty rt..r56)j dr! ,rL-j Ul6 +-e.c*:,l) s;-rb
.rti -r..*-. t I gXu -fu Jt.(r.'r; L4 -S GU-l .B e(,_ ;!s .1
O,'6tf .(\ 1A "r) ,f;li u-rr 112:l j o-r- gf ir,;L+lr IJICL -r:
eldLr 6Lo:l-r;.,1 U"Jf \F|.4 drr ol-r+ f{. c.;-.i:b
6j1'A:* s> b;aV2, ,-* o*r .+ fu t ,K ro-r- sI i-,,1+!
l; ol;n ,-.1 tf,*5L"rl iri
*';
AG ri6 -b .;, oLs-* ,-* s
"(,
>3* .r15;r d-:r.:f lgBI e{ 62jh;L^ .rfr! xL1l r:;-r3 c,:ji 61,
;'l r>^-e dtr .t+ J) )3,- c;Ll 6tsT3 -rjlo>l: ,-rLI ,Sj: rrlt-9 ;rtt
ossJ w 1 dt j O-ft-rt tS3-: elft;r c-r,lo>f .r--"U tr rtlK
co3>bq ..:-2 -r.ol3; -r:,;[-, dL- .ll^J -rt gLsy(- -r:!!-;.: 6,x:u ju,
J Els, o;t-il xe,t- c^'.Ier) ,Eql t J+ cit l 1SEI ,f
-t- a^i-.o
t, o tf \.t*.:1* l-;6--a.:l a-l yac e,t4,oB 6.i;p.r";3T:L-
oLi;15 ,Jlj3: fl* rn.r.iL),rr gr.-rT olr3,, GVs-: -i(1 t-6:; ,-,t* .r-l
s:{rrt btt' \ !oly.f d$.attc+l-r,-rlt-I.(fOr ,-e) >-y,
''' S*
9>lr j!3 Llc xera;
n, i"-a3 i;L;: t'
;1. .rt(;,.-r! ,#z eslGlr cp;, ,h. st
1l orU:-,1 ! u".<r 6f*.., .trt".f rs;y urEET cJy j s.iy; r:;.i!
jl .(t t , ,.,o) tf oL l..r -r,--rt P\t*o Jt*! ! .tt-tgl lrp
^,iU
,r:- coB 1K g ,...n 3 -rn r:-eLrt 6 y-r Ct" .,,t^a;* flGi-l
6-\- dt^+i" d/.liJr.(f f -;
q . t;tfg cx3 l-r na)l-;*.i[sL
tK,t; t &q .ruri rrL.t t' d&frr- A:; 1K.s> ,;- 6 j >
* ,rl: r_r &_* ot.i af:9 ,-rl-.r-l: Crs r).(ytA oo) n6l U.
C-ra * s >fg -*:* oLl;:L -1: ,rLl> * ,t J ,.JJ*"U ;t-64
) +;lj d)rJI lr -lf ..f .-u! dtj ;.*- ;ttL c..* -,,ptr 4<6,
* ,s--SW_L l-l ..r5rli,--l ,--L(t JIJ s> etass;tril r ti-r,l
.>l tctlf 6ial>;*rr
*>2 c--eSr"b.i r-ri,r..U d js glJr ot-,Si, J>,Lc.-t6tn,r-.t(f
6L*.,, ,r-- isl-;;I b 6.i17 i-ei .r;;.,s*t*-r yl;1 b
iL- ;!t ai ..:-ilAF;t:.;L:il 1r l; t:*;;l r.:;r uisll-l L3i^.
)e e:l JlJ. s>;lyl 6la.e; .,,lj! 4t+:( J* : t;tf eV
J c;lIl tW c ot^i..r.i Jo*
f (dUl- cr,ttil-n g! 6,* "4Kt
ct:.iLl 6t!I iA * &,rf s, \ r )l l; rr!--,1;5-j e>1)) ;:St
-*
e) >sr t^r*tKt .rLo. f F* -3-r 6.r- g1r jr,? o-- iI )l
..,1:{ *VL.o,'r i rL-e -jt e
' -"''\ .r(-- liUL-.f }-l jl (dte iiprr .-}-ej .(y .1
,r:-l
lr;!ly-l ,c(;L.Lr.:)-lr, 2t u*K;t,-ll.1_rl tt(z 6 6e
;L;lrr_lrr 6.r:l..re -r." J (y y,f) x,lrg rr6llcrr-r."> -l ,tL.l,; .,^Lrr
.
.(f tt t*-.6.!.r- JJj iqj LgJ c.!;ltJ-ue.6gUf ,..p..e \
"r;
,l!l ;l s5;.:-:Ja.j J .:J^i / f Y1
V1 c-::.p-:;l J9l
LaC.,ttl.l.lti
,gt; ^lli;jr gl; rsL; .rJ!Lr1 cc.-l-r,o :.e51 cu)v. 6T S*;,' 1i cl-y..d
;: l2 d6" )t JP r:!Lc.f Y. -f YY ,r c\ YYt roL+ rgo, .rlr .6)*U
;Jt_...11-y.f f Yf 4J.,
.f Yf ;r rFOL-o.1
.;4 1)**rl- r,r-;lJtf :.ei; r.rKJt aL;i )> o)* OT C_r- 9 &- qgl-.1 .V
9 ..u $ .4.,L ,.JU ;l .J9l .JL c-:.n,.,lis
,s
l: --
q
-1,,*);
-.JN
;,,b,: :.-rl(l itjl;
lJ-J-
c3,nt 1\ . /-o \ YYA .gq .,-r:l_i >;13:l pkrl
a o;lil .\ YA-'1 Y? oo.p\
..:-o=t- \ Y 1 '4*i..p ;: ;L.i- iu:l
.\ Yf ,r rt+OLr.A
coL;.ts 6r- .\ Yf A (Okj .dlJ-l s :S:'l .at:.,-;s cc*:T.1
"-*);:
ffr tt oEl* :J;u-goe.-=.ri 6Gf
(\ AFA -r"!r" g-,ka) \ Y1f Jl.9;
y^-! i-; i!: r ,\:ili ,u,"lK;t o2liu 2l>;lS.:},
dl.i ;{: **t(t :-l
\"Yl / .L: diJlr-[
J;J.a:e j usu." o$l ,-l r,tt .-",,! .r1 t (f AA_f \ \ e) r,9! JL_l:n
"lC
c;+ s fluo-t i*--r.;l 3 ,Kll .5rl-L * oS .u-V, arb );t iSl ;1,
r.u-_fl*" JS e;: Ll .(f AA ua) x*:f gJoJ.;j;l ca-Li 1:r_
,S
J*t-* :l 6. ut* d ()J+- -rob ox *'-Q,a*[Jyl .rkr eK; rl -r*],1
2: gl:j,4- -, ,Jtjh oS c--3rS-l 1l [...] -r"Tr: ol_i_l ;: u*Kt c*t*" c.rr,!
.',tjl.tl G-*, \ u-L 6k-,1: ,fytci- ;.: .-r_f rkj 1 lry ,t_s:*, Al.^l
f L-<(f AA oo) (.5s-L.fl:'l .r-y,,r.-l s ,sLs.'l.r y: r*K;Vl
co,A 69 r ,rJ!r qsla+* r;l )lj<i q-F
Ul nf.** & ef i \ 6)V
.rjl .d lJ .' "r_t
_ii, s ts:4 u,6
.\F ooc6lr'-1 3*{-*l ci-:,":T.\\
.V\ . c,r/ rl+ol-o.\ Y
.Y\d uz rl*,tko.\f
.VA 1 ll+,-ll*r r,.:*:f .\ f
g;r-osl+t+
c;)!i:;l i.j"-Jjl : cis$
,fl:;;:
b s f.: ti)\:;l 1l ..r,1.\,,cW.:'; y ;.a. uG C.r :'r'"i ili*"
1 ;s\
r'*')\'ijl-11 $ 6QL 1r
s> octe *.)'..s P,e'rSXc'r'"-lJT
,/1, ! ,;r* 6rry 6lo-r--e gk,t--* j-,! ..y-rt*" (u'-GcJle;-S
e:, S i* {f *.r?f g-r^j 3 >'r+, .+.1} r1 e('r:l
-\:!J )-\*.i
,.,3-, g3*;1 .;u>3JT c(-;rt;*-l oV-fi tl, f{" lE-;-l ,5-q
g;L* ,.r,!-.:Ul.,;
.;u- c-rr.:y >-r.ni ,11-rL ,*4 )\ 6 Gl*{ )l
:; ,*V 6lalb;> 1, >-i*J i.ll- c"^' corl;,rfr s r-*st o-t url;l
&*b c,Jl;.l ;: oPt* at cr.>\ gkJL'-,' LuPP J)'+5
"!--1:
csly-l ;r .-U14ii :-r.1; i;L;> s\t, ) tS'r+ tUT * ,}A1 ;\ 6\'>$
,\_r- s &W H\s ct;ss\>Li; c.rsr fFU." og iS:1;1
,5-r^--l 4! gtil .s\o>fr5t-t-r.1; r-r.*.i a$
a3{ 6ttn + g"!t*
rr\ / dJ-"-lc(t
t c-rJli, 6s-t 6P
5.,;-:,) J \ -fu '* ul "^l>ta 1:- o{ t>-7o'
)-ct n* ru.,{*.r,..(f c--:r ty ,Krr, q5t-o:;jL-:,-/Li,r
"r)
61L917-3rr J c-,x65[,i;;t Lst os)1ctt"F-i.* c,JLi.lgl-<a, c)-i^-'
cL--,;,1 t {l;& c1:45 6l{;, t c.tl: )f -P-F s> qr:I Jt(-:lt
66 ,f--, G--r- )\.rr\' ..r) (.r)r rt :'-;' jl g3l-t" c,*6-:La:;l
.>\); a\ )\ it\f 6 $)l)J,-# d/ iE- r,l d--, a, f-* s;.*-t
-r,L ;l3r,r" o;j(o .>:l> dlj.:-:"\*t olrt ! dljl-,9 .,i-t6llL.-l cl:L;
jl-rc/ f* ,-p 41 6l;7;r ")i af jq ;tll: GP rror-u L,)
.rl: ;J c,."--1b o\lf *.ls rrrJ;-rrtarr uJ; ;l c.:rL-
r-q; ,rl^el 6ba,-L ,l -fr-t,r( l"ra:- Jt- d,,,f ;> 6-r".--1 6ET
c-l+ ;*a ;) J .(f V .:-(F-.^,lrF *. j u*l:) > ;, o^KT, ;tt
"r")
.e)f J.-rt5.rUi glLr:oJ'': .r-'-.- 'a'Jt taf
r 6lo;t-il e? 6rt;;31 &-";ls'4-tb,;t; aKt tS>s\-f )) -t- \
;> Ll c.rS,r-" ;!":;1tr-t;:6-r^-1 6trl q f .rr\s;17-l ,pl-
,-\:{ -pr.e Jt-:i t' J o} qt t' ca:.,sl3 ;l; -r:i-.Ul,r" tf.1l gt*a!
6$ rlpl * tag.tl.ittl4;,;t.o {Jt-b 6 tf .:-r* jlyc/ .s-l dLl-l
')ti i5lo-u--e:
f .4i, ,,r,-!,rrl Jsl )l* .S-,* ,* rtil;l u:r-13,
1c"i.:aa. Lt'y -rK;t Ut i:*,r-;i! ./1-:f jU .-ui! g$r- \ e -*l;
)JJ".-!iL )l 6ia6 r*l-r ;, ,? ':rl-r,;lr-l t &: c,-i':'-\i; tb'-
6i!Ir,.r;5,r" tu4 p;*. c&-, oly-t;::rni rf.-;b 4U f ./Ke-y
rry / .Jr+l ct-t
1t"--l
(r-l .:-ra; ..rL-al i U ;U:tf t r-i--rr a, a.f rr-i--r;by> n,
.J:f.,"
f+^ lnt * is\s, &, s ).a;. t;" J, q.,t5_,1, ,')i
f.*s 611 6 Se o;t-il c..,!13 ; I r 6.i^-l 6LeT rJL y-l .o-r-T U
oJ\:*i ., .lE ;,,_lrt -r"-lJI +I.t, jl (dt .{l c-r,-:i 6GI ,r-} )l
Ci t J
cf -r s.ili<t- 1.1tfii;L 6;'b Jll_lJ) )q.; iI- e^,., r) (),
.ciL eL 6-r- e-n ;,rr[ l.1,ralyl (rf i {a ci
igtai"as -3-t u r-Su AF-, e-:., 6l* (A:rj 0*.6 r)
"L"ai;r t'
.c.*.rJt- r-r15
c.:,; 1,t6;U )fb Qtt 1: r) s;)r,:, lLif c.r.1l JL l+ -r,
dt-l ,,ij! ,*-; s ,*Q 6jl-ou314i JBf J_l J-i,l >l-r, .o-r.i
,S'1,
rr**1 i.r- c.-; U;.rn o.f .u,.;,5, e;-r-.-l 6trT ,'>U" .-^!-I,i p
6t!4,1+ jldrU* Ct-4 s s-t-t\>-r;lJK-:l; g;:[o.-:i;,;, g;tr.-n'
al3 tt"l (A \ .r) r.*-S J* ,* ,r -toj cai;-r., ,re t-ry! J ,*
JK-LI jl .r-,1, ":-=- i-r* )l tc,--t-, ,Ja 6l^it\- s)e ,i ri O"
,r(--*U--t, U #J;l cjUT(Haman) ;rL^ b c-t-.\;
"-.tKt.ui;
-,!ol t t' 6"u>l 6GI 6Je, i 1. Sl+L-s.t-t^$ a-l 6p J ) (
Vf -t,iI .3) jL
i*S;s aJLii.;t(+ 3.r ,r*,rli*,r ar-AJ.ilJ .Ji1j
s \T e ;tf ,. ; ufi p
e-rlslr c-.62 ;: n,31"-al s3-t1,,
.-r:r-{,_*;I c=s J) 3L"j
oe 2 cu;sS fB -r^
af a:l.:4?, -\,"ti f
Lroy g\ * i*) ;>
-.r+ ;: dU* J-,-
.*&.r s *S\ g s"-r u*V rrcjj> g-j.lrr
6troT;l 1.c*1 gj)" rrcj:i- g-j.;rr y-l :t G-fft ) * ! *tt
.,:-tj-JU s)J'i;1-t, c,' .161, rrG6j.,ln ailjl4, J! $I.rl,)"
I citi.lr3t;to o:)\, t.-r;;l>,rl!r c-*-alj a5--,1o:rl-9^-o gl-9ry
g-fr ) La 3 u,:ij- 6j;l y-l )-fr ) + c;t'i' sF s,;'-;b 6l;j:
g*+) dta" jg ol^;te >lr"io-uf! 6t4^iv i;L*x ct; &Jl + cr,,rr E.r+ ,1.
6l-r-l -L;Jt,.--; cJl.eJl si-l ,'l! f G ,o.r)\r ! ..:^-t (\ f VY Vh ,.r1" ,,ri-:rr .,1,
.fl")f , -.lr)lr.r"f
31.a,) 46^ ; Q-; o
t;.a : ly o.u r5! csl axie 6;t-i i.r,l3l J6 j I Jn rr. -r : tr ,a,l.
c
ol-r1l !-Jt-; cJle-l y-l ,5j fG ,o:1, 1 .i*l (l f VY ?+ r"r'1; c.ri-:.,r olc
.plo:5.:-ts'l' -Li
\ , . JJE
f? \ I ,se:f ilE. rQa -,, .s-! L:l:t , ,i*:
i.sJs (e-f )l .rf ,ll-rc/ >La:- g+. c5; -r+ o\i f ai, J-l )l
,-;*- J -L-ra Vh.rr,ilJr-l oi bU tl-t:-; gl;j> ,-,l.t' 'rt*
e ,r$ ;); p. cc-b1r* F* 6 r1.r* J-:"U ;L;
n, .:-;>
t, t
",1*
.:lr..r,
'-il*.j,3 o:L 6i a;\;:j- tSE 6u;r; \ 6-lh-3
eJJ ),.r-j-r.i l; &1 "r-l G.f ilSL' ceJtia-.t-6q ,-itK 9U Ot^,
4sL.; 6;ty r ,." J.e; r.i<G, .*i\ r-r r * $-! g)l..fr:f
tj, i.r-* .!:.i 1-: pakam) f tt3l .r-i! -rj, ;i5; rl ;6-)l..r:- .L-L
y+dV af 1, ;I o-1ly^-o *-L rc-r'3lj #, ir* J) 6L" ,*Kn nrtfit
3 osjl,*6U d!" ,:-G .i-9U;; ,e_rs t r-fr-, G_y )l .*-f1. c-l
.:;Q: &*: J:; fV b-,ls 6cail> .*Frf
pl3,c i;3t- dtij d-ta-j )l cosljTl- 6laJL; J) ();l"i*ttt'./)ldlj
:-ra; -r"ar i-uo:
4. ) L)f gl,r'"-a ,l
\
-fi-, i;-,1t * -St" j", dJf ./U; .l -K;;*
tL:; dl5i *. altie _ltga -,, h_.,! +))l fii J"ot ,1 ,:a G? ) 6le
);Vil 6 >J 4} oI,c-e!.. -r>rr r-! -;") J
-pV ^{ri<,s,.cil, "r5'ti
r-il *EliJl r[r, eL, 6 rK ,^ 6lr,-, ...rt-S gi ,.;* e -r,T ;* ;,Li
.
UPrJ-JJJ9--\>(J "l;
jlr *-l ,;., .>Ko,.(f t
1 .1t<" 1, :,tlr ,_y sls, fu
"r)u.u;lF
(f
' "r) -\':t? gr" r1o*l E:r* ,l!r -r> ,5-.f +tt-
? -p -p J6
L. :,Jl7- r.1..-r qr", .i ! 6,- I I
"bL c.*; I b j
6il3 ;
r >
c a-fc+. g* I d>L-
1
c-lFri dt de:e c*13; cjL s: -*-
)t er c-lfri a s *t etls ir
rr--*s--\, J c-_F Lo,
"-ll:;. ot-1rSr::* ) ,*l.!)\. -r,L,i J (rJ+ ;Lfrlrl ,<, 6-
)r-)t,Kt2r-, ..Ja-l t.L*e-t-Sr-p ri:T eV s 5"^; (6)r :31
'L*
u..r -rljT O.f s\F sl.t-rjl cslyl :t \f ',j\i* st
) -pg jt! irl.i,."-" 6?tP ttL agrlrrf F:;,-- 1l-
I a' l;
,btf o)g ,":f j7 -t* e(" ;.: j c+l o.:l-: ;lj C cfu c.(,- .1,
o
-,--l3-s .;-.?t )) LGJ+).:! Jrt ." itl- -rr iJ'>U ..-4 yU:,
c--lt,-" Jl ,.Jf-ir/ c*-fo,;l.ll rar i1.(-1 ,1b*l> c;l:oli
a^--a :l oj^i-l J );l (o$I: :f ,r:?rr o{ c;rn 1; Lila"U !'lJr
-,,1 c-.r"tL
i-.a,
J"_L* ;-_l
--l-l: .,.-!- g;Laa:_"j uaraGr*
6L- r,r*; il'; t J)I J-|4: s oL.: l;L;: ,r,l_tJ olp .pKu^;:
,-ual )) a: .{e.-L*i
"t _t.rbul q 1*.r_l _, ;*l ).a.L u-:t
o{l:f .3;t : )fl ... I J^* ,-*r;oy.a6J*J, :-'di rf . ,')
t GEs ptK-t, :6 s;L oFJ j=.|-J JLi":l;-r.1r5 ri : J*t
6t'-yg t' afv a---ai f cJl3; ,'.-a ,, .$ , u)n;l-r6:l
e sl : f ,:K1 ; 11 : ; ...;--ot>;t+ f D 6 .* 6"ole 6 _p5r
"*
Jsf 1: ! c-:,r; -r,_LJj! c--.:j cJ; t-, -,.(.; s sF ts 6-,t
G*
gb-l ,rl+ t; ,r7Kl,l: Gt-# : u1L;,; 6W C pb_r ! r ,S",.
_;Q
.-i* a"-= -u7 rl .-,l-rlc J-l .(f y t) urr. *UU+t J ,t'Vl l,
L*
+J j 6-fU' J 6t) c--elp )l G14J lr UI jli.," c,_y. )l.JUt
,-rly,,_r- ,;;" f--: a, .i-'l: o?):,s jU jl olx, fF o!_,
-l ;-L.;
o{*-Fejt lr Jlil JL+l r G-* e6rol;L-o 3l y *-K
-t
islLl -2;, 6,1r:-t-H1 :-r.J / \'Af
-*,t r*-fu".rjli
1.,1 ot-i,:U- c-+l-, )l *) s SV u2lL;6t^$i
J-sls:.,1: l; el f t : tS 4 t
ls slg-l'q 6i4'rE 4 -fl:t )l
jl J-: JJ,L c--t ,-f V ,S ,srl a, o[-:L- o37 6lr-; JSci tlGt -t
JJLi ,VI 1L-; t
.r,o) r,-uL" -r,-3$ -'l-rrt- :-r-;l fU J { tI
,Jkir5.!'ri ely-,J17-1i: >'t4 L.s. cJy;s jl .F- g;L(a,.(ff
.rf *_! Ur .f L-.tl) .;;t o,:$ t: ls- ,g-f oU t ;-, : g*b
ar:", jl s,tlr l,l .& eKi-S t ;"U
,S;-;ly o!r $.;s'^ln3a;:t.;
Ydd / s; tf oJtL_.,ka ,) dL- i.i-.r.il j :.r*;
!! c.: 6,t:.,lY A
Lacgiil.lll-r
t J
Hodgson, Marshall. The Venture o/ Islun. Chicago. Vol.ll. 1979.
r,ejl r'
,,1 ,a*JU r,r il - ,2, t. islt.$1.)rtoJ*l t
u:.-l)yt,r-1 a,
.r,c.H :lr-il .f
:5r "r5.r' >u-
,,tlraj) -)\i- 6*U-rcS* lJr .Il? J, f^ b ,-r!3: ;,-l gkiz: t J-2;" ;a.
isi ,lla d.lJlc,i 3r- ;l J, e J f f 1
'.Jl)+ t()).r.tr) ;fr-f -,1: oL>l (\
.'f lr- -t-U (Y A \" 1
.:S 2,ar"1 l-l t fi ..: .91; .A
Foucault, Michel. The Politic:s of Truth. ed. by Syluere Lotringer. N.Y.
1997. pp 180-
6. Kliun, Thomas. The Structure ol'Sc:ientiJic Revolutions. Cliicago. 1962.
:.6; tuoL;-t Ailfr -.^a cr!, .V
Greenblatt, Stephen, Shukespeurean Negotiutions. Berekely. 1988. pp. i-21
YdY t u^a jy.Jt "rka -,, .r!- i;_-r-;l 3 :-r*;
.r;
Gtr{_,t{ erk-t:;_-a ,.Ll
:.61 ,-L ;-l -2:,rJF Jlr e* .rt .l A
Koselleck, Rein Han. Critique Cr.xrs. Cambridge. 19gg., pp. l_15,62-76.
:..5) LGsy a\*; )1.J1* r!* ia 6Ll .t 1
Auerbach, Elich, Mirnesis. Tr. By Willard Task. New york. 1953. pp.
2ts-273.
,il)4, .&-jl;ti-J,'t J JrJt .;y." ,rV:.eS ._t ,6--j| i..i,-.ul ia .917
.l raA
:.ef-2 r:-r*; J AW 1\ ;a 6lJ
Lukacs, George. Soul and .Forn. Cambridge. 197 I .
.J"!-T Gb- j^+jl iltu \A1 1 /iJ\l e--j j o2l"-1;: cerLj gka ;:
(Journul o/ Royal Asiatic Sociery*)
Nizami Aruzi. Les quatres Discours. Tr. par lsabelle de Gastines. Paris.
1 968.
'..JSs
Greeftz, Clifford. Interpretations of Cultures. N.y. 1984.
:..f-,1 c.;L:l 1: nu) *_t(-, )lLl.3 ea.6la
Fineman, Joel. "The History of the Anecdote: Fiction and Ffiction." in
The New Historicism. Ed. by H. A. Ram Veeser, N.y. 1989. pp. 44-76.
1Y A-\ \ f g r;":1- r4ri_* .Y f
.\ Y . -14 ( jr:*- (fl .y d
.;-:::, r[a.a .y 1
Vt:f;-l Ls-)lei*; Sn C* )F st&.7 ).: ! .J.,-L* .r-l o:t>{ct .V v
.(*lJi ,s-r-:,JT a, cULL .;*l )f ,a
:C-l $i rrt-:lrbilt.f-l V! JJ dK r[n it* 1: .glalLi, 1: gr olji .y A
c\ A ,r calLi- _,21a-7;t q) .Y A {*L., cl i;L; ,1.r:,,:_ ! 6:
'llj
.\I oJLs o---yL)
e-i_$l .g[+l :,s>;t ,L. ('\ y 1 dp) ci.i.,,r, -r15 jk-o ;: ce(r;r,t
f u" .y 1
u.)y rrF
.I Y c-.xl::L cG:s:1 .61 i.2ls:',1f g-l c,t); J+
c,-r!j
"517.r.
:.d-f1 r,.;U ;_l -2:;K- ol+; :a.gl7.y \
Whitney, Charles. Francis Bat:on Antl Motlernitv. N.y. l9tt6
l,^ltl- e<- ,_1;t;
-2: -r.ii 6rUT Alp J -1,_J- .r,c; .gtaa,_t, uU .2: .\" y
"r-
"--r, ,)+ J ilJlt
:.e-f; ,Jl:" ,gl1 .oJ)
Eco, Umderlo. Interprctation and Over Interpretation. N.y. 1997.
:.e51 rc-L jLj Jh-U J,-$..jI .51 jl e{ ;:. s: Jyt- c,.2\y. 61,
Leys, Simon. "The Imitation of Our Lord Don euiote,,' in New york
Review of Books. June 1i, 1998. p.33.