Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Law is a set of rules imposed upon all members of a community, which are binding, enforceable and
officially recognized.
Customs are collective habits or behaviours which have developed in a society over time
Rules are regulations or principles for conduct in certain situations.
Laws differ from rules because: laws are binding on the whole community, they are enforceable (e.g. there
are penalties), they are officially recognised by the court and government, they are discoverable (e.g.
people can find out how it applies), they relate to the public interest, and they reflect rights and duties of
people.
Procedural fairness
The idea that there must be fairness in resolving disputes, aka natural justice.
Involves the right to be heard, right to an unbiased decision maker, informing people of
the case against them and for decisions to be made only on logical evidence.
Rule of law
All people are equal before the law and none are above the law.
In R v Einfeld [2009] NSWSC, Marcus Einfeld, a Federal Court judge, committed
perjury and lied in court and received 3 years imprisonment.
People obey the law because it creates order, because it fits with their values, and because
they dont want to be punished.
Common law
British Origins
Court hierarchy
There are both state and federal court systems. Summary offences are less serious heard
in lower courts and indictable are serious in higher usually with judge/jury.
State Court system:
Local Court/Magistrates Court: A Magistrate hears and decides punishment. Hears
minor criminal (stealing, driving, traffic, drug possession) and civil (up to $100,000)
cases. Can hear committal hearings (determining whether prosecution has a strong
enough case to try defendant in a higher court).
Coroners Court: Investigates unexplained or suspicious deaths, performs coronial
inquests.
Childrens Court: Cases relating to criminal cases for children under 18 or care.
Land and Environment Court: Interprets and enforces environmental law.
District Court: More serious criminal (manslaughter, assault, robbery, drugs, sexual
assault) and civil ($100,000 - $750,000) cases. Hears appeals, cannot hear murder,
treason or piracy. Judge and sometimes jury.
Supreme Court: Highest state court. Deals with the most serious criminal (murder,
manslaughter, kidnapping, corporate law) and civil cases (no monetary limit). Hears
appeals, all cases have a judge and jury, but only a few civil have a jury.
Statute law
All state and federal parliaments except QLD have a Lower and Upper House.
The Legislative Council is the upper and the Legislative Assembly the lower.
Parliaments with two chambers are bicameral.
Governor General must give royal assent to both referendums and bills.
Legislative Process
Any MP can introduce a bill from public demand; a backbenchers bill is a private
members bill.
A bill goes through: Draft bill (Cabinet), first reading (distribution), second reading
(detailed speech), committee stage (debate and amendments), third reading (vote), Upper
House (repeats process), Royal Assent (Governor General).
Delegated Legislation
Delegated legislation is less important laws made by non-parliamentary subordinate
bodies such as departments or councils which have been delegated responsibility. Laws
are be made by experts and frees up parliamentary time.
Four types: regulations (by executive council), ordinances (for Australian territories), rules
(inside departments), by-laws (local council laws).
The Constitution
A constitution is a set of rules which applies to a group. The Australian Constitution is the
Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act 1900.
Division of Powers
The Constitution divides the powers between the state and federal governments; this was
because during federation the states were nervous about losing their power.
Section 51 sets out the power of the federal government to make laws relating to the
matters in s51. These powers are also concurrent and are shared with states e.g.
education, health, transport. Powers not listed here are residual powers of the states e.g.
police, prisons, power, water.
Section 114/52 set out the exclusive powers of the Commonwealth parliament e.g.
immigration, defence, taxation.
Section 109 states that Commonwealth law always overrules state law.
- In Commonwealth v Tasmania [1983] HCA (Franklin Dam case), Tasmania wanted to
build a dam but the Federal Government passed the World Heritage Conservation Act
1983 (Cth). The High Court ruled using s109 that the Commonwealth law overruled the
state law.
Section 128 sets out the process for referendum; majority of people in majority of states
must vote yes, must have absolute majority and pass both houses. Only 8/44 referendums
have been successful.
Separation of Powers
The first three chapters of the constitution set out the three arms of government. It
ensures a check on each institution and ensures power is not abused.
Legislative is the parliament and Governor General and is responsible for making and
passing the law.
Executive is the Prime Minister and Ministers and departments, responsible for carrying
out and enforcing the law.
Judicial is the courts and applies and makes judgements about the law.
However, the Executive is part of the Legislative, and High Court judges are appointed by
Executive.
Responsible government is the idea that the Executive is responsible to and must maintain
the support of the majority of the Lower House which is directly elected.
Role of the High Court
ATSIC law is based on tradition, rituals and customs. It is known as customary law, meaning it
has developed over time as principles according to the customs of the people.
Australia is a large land mass, and there are many different Aboriginal groups which have
over 200 languages and customs.
However there are still common aspects, such as the involvement of community in
punishment and respect for elders.
The source of ATSIC law is the Dreaming, which is the history of the Indigenous peoples
and explains how the land, sky and animals were created.
Land and water belongs to a group and not an individual, thus each tribe has distinct
responsibilities to their land and water.
Loss of land means loss of culture and history.
All family relationships are important and dictate how everyone treats each other
Elders receive the most respect.
Customary law is passed down orally through the generations through songs, dance and
stories.
Some laws are only known to certain genders or certain age groups. There are
punishments for learning forbidden secrets.
- In R v Sydney Williams [1976] SASC, Sydney Williams killed his wife for speaking
forbidden secrets but the judge ruled that provocation was extreme and it was a tribal
matter. He was charged with manslaughter and a good behaviour bond.
In sentencing of Aboriginal offenders, customary law can be taken into account, e.g. circle
sentencing, where the magistrate and elders sit to discuss the offence and develop a
sentence, as well as in payback and mitigating factors (above).
Aspects seen in Australian law: Mediation used in in family, industrial relations and young
offenders cases, also environmental sustainability
There is much debate about the recognition of customary law. This includes the legality of
traditional (child bride) marriages, needing to accommodate other minoritys laws, and the
rejection of the rule of law. Legislators have been reluctant to formally incorporate ATSIC
law into Australian law.
International Law
State sovereignty is the authority which a state has to make and enforce rules for its
population.
It means international law cannot be enforced and does not need to be followed. States
may ignore international law if they feel it is in their best interests.
The United Nations is the chief organisation involved in international law. It has 193
members. Its main objective is to maintain global peace and security, develop
international relationships and achieve international cooperation in issues. It has six main
arms: the General Assembly (main forum for multilateral discussion), Security Council (has
final say over security and peacekeeping operations, has five permanent and ten non-
permanent members, needs unanimous permanent votes), ICJ (15 permanent members),
Secretariat (administrative staff), Economic and Social Council (economic, social, health
educational issues) and Trusteeship Council (supervises independence of nations,
disbanded in 1994).
Courts and tribunals include the ICJ, as well as the ICC which was set up by the Rome
Statute 2002. It deals with individuals charged with serious crimes against humanity e.g.
Darfur situation. Ad hoc/war crime tribunals are set up to try individuals convicted of war
crimes e.g. Nuremberg Trials, International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (1994).
Intergovernmental organisations are organised groups of nation states, pursuing mutual
interests in areas such as refugees, finance and environment. Examples include WHO, IMF,
EU and APEC.
Non-governmental organisations are groups based around common aims separate from
governments. They contribute to such areas as world peace, human rights, poverty and
the environment through lobbying and awareness. E.g. Greenpeace, Oxfam, the Red
Cross and Amnesty.
Australia is a party to many international treaties e.g. Convention on the Rights of a Child
incorporated into Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) and organisations such as WHO and
UNESCO. Treaties must be codified.
Australia has been part of UN peacekeeping activities in East Timor.
International law has been used in domestic cases, e.g. UNESCO World Heritage listing of
the Franklin River, Convention on the Rights of a Child in Minister for Immigration and
Ethnic Affairs v Teoh [1995] HCA.
3. Classification of law
Public law
Public law deals with the relationship between the government and the people.
Criminal law is the body of law under which acts are punishable by the state. It maintains
safety and social order. It is the responsibility of each state. Crimes Act 1900 (NSW).
Administrative law regulates government decision making. It ensures the accountability of
government actions. It can be achieved through: internal review (by another in an agency),
external review (ombudsman, tribunals), and judicial review (federal and high courts).
Constitutional law relates to interpretation of the Constitution of Australia. Can deal with
separation and division of powers. Only in High Court, heard by one or more judges and
has binding decisions.
Private law
Private law deals with the relationships between individuals, companies and organisations.
Contract law deals with agreements and promises between parties. Damages are the
general remedy and compensate the plaintiff. Plaintiff can seek an injunction (order to do
or not do something) or specific performance (performing the contract out)
Tort law deals with civil wrongs. Torts are someone interfering with the rights of someone
else or their property. Unlike contract law, there does not need to be a legal relationship
between the parties. Torts include: negligence, nuisance, trespass, false imprisonment,
defamation. (Donoghue vs. Stephenson case)
Property law deals with things and interests that can be owned and have a commercial
value. Can include physical (real property) or intangible interests (shares, patents,
copyright, intellectual property). Can be dealt in either criminal or civil courts and usually
involves breach of contract law.
Civil law systems have a pre-set of rules (code of law) which are applied by judges in cases, comes
from the Roman system, with inquisitorial trials. However, in common law, the rules are derived
partly from precedent.
4. Law Reform
Law reform is the improvement and change of law to recognise changes within society.
Changing social values: Social values are the standards that guide people in their thinking.
The law must reflect the social values of the majority of the community to stay relevant.
Public morality continues to evolve; the law usually lags behind. E.g. rights for de facto and
same sex relationships which are now seen as normal in De Facto Relationships Act 1984
(NSW)
New concepts of justice: When the law is unable to deliver just outcomes to the
community, new concepts of justice need to be formulated. For example capital
punishment is no longer seen as effective or moral; the concept of justice shifts from
retribution to punishment. This is also seen in Youth Justice Conferences in Youth
Offenders Act 1977 (NSW), NSW Drug Court, Circle Sentencing.
New Technology: Advances in technology pressure the law to remain current.
Courts: Achieve law reform through precedent. They do not actively seek law reform and
it happens over time. The High Court has delivered reforming decisions e.g. Mabo case.
Parliaments: As parliament makes law, law reform is most released here, through the
passing of bills. The impetus comes from conditions and agencies of reform.
United Nations: For law reform between nation states. Can occur through courts or
through treaties and subsequent domestic legislation.
Intergovernmental Organisations: Decides upon issues and thus contribute to international
law reform through treaties and agreements.
Native Title
Native title is the name for general ownership rights and interests of Indigenous peoples to their
traditional lands. It differs from land rights, which is the specific legislative response regarding
leases for land.
Terra Nullius
Terra Nullius is a doctrine which states that a land has no civilised inhabitants and is thus
unoccupied. It was applied by the British to Australia in 1889 and thus extinguished any rights
Aboriginals had to the land.
Only the Federal and High Court can determine native title. The High Court is a court of last resort
and has thus handed down important decisions regarding native title. The Parliament enacts
legislation to recognise native title, usually in response to public pressure, debate and lobbying.
In Mabo v Queensland (No.2) [1992] HCA, the High Court ruled that Australia was not
terra nullius, native title may have been extinguished, and that the Merriam people had
rights to possess and use the Murray Islands.
Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) was passed in response. It provided recognition of native title,
and most importantly, provided procedures for determining native title claims and
subsequent dealings. The Act created the National Native Title Tribunal which mediates
native title issues, such as negotiating agreements between parties with interests.
In Wik Peoples v Queensland [1996] HCA, the Wik people of Cape York launched a native
title case to pastoral lease land. The High Court ruled that native title and pastoral rights
can co-exist, but that the farmers rights would prevail if there was conflict.
Native Title Amendment Act 1998 (Cth) ruled that the rights could co-exist, that tough
tests are required for native title, and that pastoralists do not need to consult those with
native title interests.
In Yorta Yorta People v Victoria [2002] HCA, the High Court upheld that the Yorta Yorta
people did not have native title, as they didnt have continuous, uninterrupted observance
of traditional customs on the land, which had a significant effect on the future of native
title law, showing the amount of evidence needed to prove native title.
In Yarmirr v Northern Territory [2001] HCA , the Yarmirr people sought to have native title
over an area of sea around Croker Island. They were granted native title, but this was not
exclusive as it would contravene common law fishing rights and international maritime
rights.
Agencies of reform
Law Reform commissions: e.g. Legal Affairs committee Law Reform Issues Regarding
Synthetic Drugs pushed for drug law reform
The Media: publishes sympathetic articles e.g. Changing drug laws is a political problem
SMH
Parliamentary committees: e.g. NSW Legislative Council Drug Treatment Inquiry 2012
NGOs: The Buttery and Lyndon Community provide drug treatment in a residential
environment.
Mechanisms of Reform
Courts: Drug Court of NSW deals with criminal offences involving a drug addiction and
prescribes treatment.
MERIT system (Magistrates Early Referral into Treatment) provides Local Court defendants
with rehab as a condition of bail.
Parliaments: Drugs Misuse Trafficking Act 1985 (NSW) prohibits certain drugs, with
different severities for possession and commercial supplying, aimed at deterring drug
dealing.
Customs Act 1901 (Cth) controls exports of drugs, reducing the amount of drugs traded
overall.
Summary Offences Act 1988 aims to reduce syringes and drug dealing in prisons and
detention.
United Nations: UN Drug Convention 1988 ( war on drugs); United Nations Office on
Drugs; Convention on Narcotic Drugs 1961 (prohibits specific drugs)
Intergovernmental Organisations: Kings Cross Injection Room supervises drug injections
under registered nurses, reduces discarded syringes and emergency scenarios.
Methadone Maintenance Treatment involves the long term prescribing of methadone as
an alternative to opioid (e.g. heroin) addiction.
Rights are entitlements by moral or legal authority which cannot be taken from a person.
Responsibilities are legal or moral obligations which a person has to others or to the state.
Types of rights include: legal rights (e.g. right to religion, right to silence), civil/political rights (right
to expression), economic/social/cultural rights (right to fair work, right to education),
environmental rights (clean water), and consumer rights.
All rights have corresponding responsibilities. Where someone has a responsibility to another
person, that person has a right to be treated that way. Where citizens have particular rights, the
state has a responsibility to ensure they arent violated.
2. Resolving Disputes
Each state and territory has its own police force. Federal police enforce federal law and crimes
across states. It can sometimes prevent and detect Commonwealth crimes by Australians
overseas.
Also note: Australian Customs and Border Service; Australian Crime Commission (cross jurisdiction
organised crime); Australian High Tech Crime Centre; ASIO
Media: Citizens inform the media of unjust/unfair decision which can influence
government actions.
MPs: Citizens speak to local MPs who may take the issue back to Parliament for debate.
Trade Unions: Unions can help negotiate workplace disputes with employers and discuss
agreements, wages and changes. E.g. Teachers Federation in 2008/2009
Interest groups: Can appeal to these groups in order to affect government and public.
Legal methods
Internal review
- Government reviews can be undertaken internally and although it is cheaper, it may
have a biased result
External review
- The Administrative Appeals Tribunal hears appeals against federal decisions, also note
the NSW Administrative Decisions Tribunal.
- The Ombudsman acts as a formal external control, with legal power to investigate
citizens complaints.
- The NSW Anti-Discrimination Board ensures people are protected from discrimination
and can issue fines.
- Royal Commissions are set up to investigate serious state/federal matter, and produce
a report containing recommendations.
- ICAC investigates alleged government corruption. It cannot prosecute but reports on
the issue.
- Australian Human Rights Commission advocates for a more tolerant and equitable
community and conducts research and investigates complaints.
Privacy: Now more advanced CCTV technologies (e.g. facial recognition) which can help
prevent crime but may infringe on liberties. E.g. Opal card information can be given to police
Opal card privacy is no protection for users SMH 2014
Gene technology and DNA: Genome mapping could be used in insurance; has ethical issues
as patient may wish to not know that they are at risk of contracting an illness; could be used
by employers discriminatorily.
- Consumer
- Discrimination
- Family
- Employment
Legislation