You are on page 1of 6

317-321 Akbay 12038.qxp 20.5.

2008 8:48 Uhr Seite 317

Original article S W i S S M e d W k ly 2 0 0 8 ; 1 3 8 ( 2 1 2 2 ) : 3 1 7 3 2 1 w w w . s m w . c h 


Peer reviewed article

Interferential current versus biofeedback


results in urinary stress incontinence
Funda Demirtrk a, Trkan Akbayrak b, Ilkim itak Karakayac, Inci Yksel b, Nuray Kirdi b, Fazl Demirtrk d,
Serap Kaya a, Ali Ergena, Sinan Beksac f
a
Gaziosmanpasa University, School of Physical Education and Sports
b
Hacettepe University, Faculty of Health Science , Department of Physical Therapy
and Rehabilitation, Womens Health Unit, Samanpazar, Ankara, Turkey
c
Mugla University, Mugla School of Health Sciences, Department of Physiotherapy
and Rehabilitation, Mugla, Turkey
d
Gaziosmanpasa University, Obstetrics and Gynaecology
e
Hacettepe University, Department of Urology
f
Hacettepe University, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology

Abstract
Background: Urinary stress incontinence is a applied in the remaining cases. The treatments
common, disruptive and potentially disabling lasted 5 minutes per session, three times a week
condition in which the subject complains of invol- for a total of 5 sessions.
untary leakage on effort or exertion or on sneez- Results: All of the parameters improved after
ing or coughing. the treatments in each group (p <0.05) and both
Aim: This study was performed in order to treatment modalities seemed to have similar ef-
compare the effects of interferential current and fects on pad test (95% CI: .48 4.59), pelvic
biofeedback applications on incontinence severity muscle strength (95% CI: 9.29 .8) and qual-
in patients with urinary stress incontinence. ity of life (95% CI: .9 5.) outcomes.
In addition, pelvic muscle strength and qual- Conclusions: Physical therapy modalities used
ity of life as important parameters in these sub- in this trial are applied easily and non invasive.
jects were investigated. Also, when the nding that no adverse effects
Methods: In this prospective, randomised, were observed during the study period is taken
controlled study, forty women with moderate in- into consideration, it can be concluded that both
tensity of urinary stress incontinence as deter- methods can be used effectively in patients with
mined by one-hour pad test were included. Pelvic urinary stress incontinence.
muscle strength was evaluated by a biofeedback
device and quality of life was assessed by a 28- Key words: urinary stress incontinence; interferen-
itemed questionnaire. All of the parameters were tial current; biofeedback; pelvic oor exercises; quality
evaluated before and after the treatments. Twenty of life
cases underwent interferential current therapy,
while pelvic oor exercises via biofeedback were

Introduction
Urinary stress incontinence (USI) is dened changes is to open the bladder neck rather than to
as the complaint of involuntary leakage on effort close it thus causing urinary incontinence when
or exertion, or on sneezing or coughing []. intra-abdominal pressure is increased [25].
Pelvic oor muscle weakness plays an impor- USI may affect the quality of life adversely
tant role in USI aetiology [2, ]. Pelvic oor mus- and may lead to psycho-social problems such as
cles work to support the bladder neck in the intra- depression, social isolation, reduced self-con-
abdominal cavity and maintain urinary conti- dence and other related health problems [6, ].
nence. Weakness of these muscles leads the blad- In addition to medical and surgical ap-
der to shift to the extra-abdominal cavity and thus proaches, physical therapy and rehabilitation
No financial a change in the urethra-vesicle angle occurs. As a procedures play important role in the treatment
support declared.
result, the result of intra-abdominal pressure of USI. The aim of treatment focuses on
317-321 Akbay 12038.qxp 20.5.2008 8:48 Uhr Seite 318

Interferential current versus biofeedback results in urinary stress incontinence 8

strengthening weak pelvic oor muscles in order Interferential current (IC) as one of the
to increase the low urethral closure pressure, thus medium frequency currents, is commonly used in
eliminating incontinence and improving quality the treatment of USI. IC can be applied with two
of life. Therefore, pelvic oor re-education meth- or four electrodes and effective low frequency oc-
ods including Kegel exercises, biofeedback (BF), curs in that area where the medium frequencies
electrical stimulation, vaginal cones and bladder intersect within the pelvis to stimulate the pelvic
training can be used in the treatment of this prob- oor. Ease of usage and external application with-
lem [5, 8]. out giving harm to the supercial tissues are the
BF offers the patient the chance to manipu- main advantages of this method. The current
late electro-physical responses of his/her pelvic produces positive responses in the body and the
oor muscles according to visual and auditory sig- intensity is well tolerated by the patients [, 4, ,
nals. Most women are not aware of how their 4].
pelvic oor muscles work. BF is used especially to In the literature, although a great deal of
teach muscle functions and to check if the exer- knowledge exists about the use and effectiveness
cises are performed correctly [, 9]. of physical therapy, there are only a limited num-
Reports of incontinence therapy by electrical ber of studies about the comparison of different
stimulation are to be found in the literature since physical therapy methods in USI. The aim of this
96 [4, 02]. Electrical stimulation aims to im- study is to compare the results of IC and BF and
prove the urethral closure pressure by restoration to investigate if these two modalities have similar
of reex activation of the pelvic oor muscles, effects on incontinence severity, pelvic muscle
maintaining synchronised contraction of these strength and quality of life in patients with USI.
muscles in addition to the strengthening effect [4].

Materials and methods


This prospective randomised and controlled study, 6 cases referred as having USI, those with urinary tract
which aimed to compare the results of different physio- infections, detrusor over activity, cognitive problems and
therapy techniques in patients with USI, was approved neoplasm were excluded, and those with moderate inten-
by the Hacettepe University, Ethics Committee of the sity of incontinence as determined by a one-hour pad test
Faculty of Medicine, and supported by the Scientic were randomly assigned into IC and BF groups, accord-
Research Centre of the same university (project number: ing to the application order. The patient ow diagram is
998 02 40 002). presented in gure .
The cases were diagnosed as urinary stress inconti- Age, height, weight and body mass index values were
nence by an urologist and a gynaecologist and referred to recorded as physical characteristics. Number of pregnan-
Hacettepe University, School of Physical Therapy and cies, parity, abortions, dilatation & curettage (D&C), type
Rehabilitation, Womens Health Unit, between the years of delivery and presence of episiotomy and/or perineal
9982005. Diagnosis was made according to the detailed tears were recorded as obstetrical history. Duration of
history, clinical and physical examinations and urody- the incontinence problem and menstrual status of the
namic tests (MMS UD 2000 B.V. Netherlands). Among subjects were determined. In addition, duration of

Figure 1
Assessed for eligibility (n = 67)
Patient flow diagram.

excluded (n = 26)
enrollment
Not meeting inclusion criteria (n = 26)
Urinary tract infections = 4
Cognitive problems = 3
Neoplasm = 1
Overactive bladder = 9
Randomized according to
Mild/severe incontinence intensity
application order (n = 41)
according to pad test = 9

Allocated to iC group (n = 20) Allocated to BF group (n = 21)


Received iC intervention (n = 20) Received BF intervention (n = 20)
did not receive iC intervention (n = 0) did not receive BF intervention (n = 0)

discontinued iC intervention (n = 0) discontinued BF intervention (n = 1)

Analyzed (n = 20) Analyzed (n = 20)


317-321 Akbay 12038.qxp 20.5.2008 8:48 Uhr Seite 319

S W i S S M e d W k ly 2 0 0 8 ; 1 3 8 ( 2 1 2 2 ) : 3 1 7 3 2 1 w w w . s m w . c h 9

menopause for those subjects in the postmenopausal formed Kegel exercises using a BF device during 5 min-
period was recorded. utes, three times a week, for a total of 5 sessions. The
Smoking habit and alcohol consumption, presence treatment protocol was individually designed and all of
of constipation, chronic coughing, allergy, heart disease, the patients were instructed in the use of a BF device to
blood pressure problems and diuretic drug usage were obtain isolated pelvic oor muscle contraction. Before
recorded because of their possible effects on urinary in- starting the treatment, duration of maintenance of maxi-
continence. mum contraction of the pelvic oor muscles was deter-
A one-hour pad test was performed to determine the mined for each patient. This duration was then taken as
incontinence intensity []. A sensitive balance (Sartorius, the working period in the initial treatment sessions, and
BP 0 S) was used to measure the weight of the pad increased as the capability to maintain the maximal con-
before and after the test and the difference was recorded traction improved. A ten second resting period was given
as the amount of urine leakage. between the working periods.
Pelvic oor muscle strength was measured with BF All of the cases were re-evaluated after the treatment
device (Myomed 92 Enraf Nonius) in lithotomy posi- program had been carried out on every other day for ve
tion, using a vaginal probe. For each case, measurements weeks. Patients were also observed for possible adverse
were performed three times and the mean value was effects of the methods such as allergic skin reactions, ery-
noted as the pelvic oor muscle strength. Before the test, thema, inammation and pain. At discharge, cases in both
subjects were asked not to hold their breath, or contract groups were advised to continue with a home program
their abdominal, gluteal or thigh muscles during the eval- including Kegel exercises in order to maintain the effects
uation, in order to obtain an accurate value of pelvic oor of the treatments.
muscle strength. The same physiotherapist performed
pre-treatment and post-treatment measurements, by Statistics
controlling the interference of the above mentioned Statistical analysis was accomplished on a personal
muscles. computer by using statistical package for social sciences
A 28 itemed questionnaire graded from 0 to  for version 2.0 (SPSS 2.0, demo, SPSS Inc. Chicago, Illi-
each item (0 = best score, 84 = worst score) was com- nois). Quantitative and qualitative data were presented as
pleted by the subjects in order to determine the effects of convention mean (standard deviation) and n (%), respec-
the incontinence problem on the quality of life [5]. tively. Intra-group differences of the pad test, pelvic oor
In 20 patients IC with a frequency of 000 Hz was muscle strength values and QoLQ scores were analysed
applied for a duration of 5 minutes, three times a week by t-test for paired samples. Pre and post treatment dif-
for a total of 5 sessions. Two vacuum electrodes were ferences of means in pad test, pelvic oor muscle strength
placed in the suprapubic region, whilst another two were and quality of life questionnaire values between groups
positioned near to the medial side of the ischial tuberos- were analysed by t-test for independent samples. 95%
ity, crosswise. condence intervals (95% CI) were used for statistical
The second group included 20 subjects, who per- signicance.

Results
The mean age of the cases was 50.4 (SD = 6.9) years in IC Group and 5.8 (SD = .) years in BF
years. Physical properties of the subjects in each Group.
group are presented in table . The mean duration Twelve cases (60%) in BF group and six cases
of incontinence complaint was 6.5 (SD = 6.2) (0%) in IC group were in the postmenopausal
period. The mean duration of menopause was 4.8
Table 1 IC BF (SD = 5) years in IC Group and .6 (SD = 5) years
Physical characteris- Physical characteristics Mean (SD) Mean (SD) in BF Group.
tics and possible risk
factors related to Age (years) 52 () 49 () There were no apparent differences between
urinary incontinence
Height (cm) 60 (5) 60 (5) the groups for pregnancies, parity, number of
of the subjects.
abortions and Dilatation and Curettages (table ).
Weight (kg) 2 () 6 ()
All but one patient in each group indicated
Body mass index (kg/m2) 28 (4) 26 (5)
that they had delivered vaginally. Mean number of
Obstetrical history Mean (SD) Mean (SD) vaginal labour was  (SD = 2) (minimum = 0, max-
Pregnancies 5(4) 5() imum = 9) in IC group and  (SD = 2) (minimum
Parity () (2) = 0, maximum = 8) in BF group. One case in IC
Abortions () () group and two in the other group had experience
Dilatation and curettage () ()
of caesarean section.
Eight (40%) cases in IC group and seven
Possible risk factors n (%) n (%)
(5%) in BF group indicated that they had experi-
Smoking 9 (5) 8 (4) enced a perineal tear during labour. Episiotomy
Chronic coughing  (50)  (50) was recorded in 2 (60%) cases in IC group and in
Allergic conditions 4 (40) 6 (60) 0 (50%) cases in the other group.
Heart disease 4 (5)  (4) Factors that may have a possible effect on uri-
Problems about blood pressure 5 () 2 (29)
nary incontinence such as smoking, chronic
coughing, allergic conditions, heart disease, prob-
Constipation  (4) 4 (5)
lems with blood pressure, constipation or diuretic
Diuretic drug use 4 (5)  (4) drug use are presented in table .
317-321 Akbay 12038.qxp 20.5.2008 8:48 Uhr Seite 320

Interferential current versus biofeedback results in urinary stress incontinence 20

Figure 2 Figure 3
Pre and post treatment mean (95% Ci) values of the groups. Change of the values over time in each group.

Pad test
Pre (mean) Mean

Pad test Pre


Post (mean) Post
Pad test
Muscle strength
95%Ci

Pre (mean)
Post
Muscle strength Pre
Post (mean) Muscle strength

QolQ
Pre (mean) Pre
Post
QolQ
QolQ
Post (mean)
iC Group BF Group iC Group BF Group

Figure 2 presents pre and post treatment The degree of improvement in the intensity
means (95% CI) of the IC and BF groups. Incon- of incontinence (95% CI: -.48 4.59), pelvic
tinence intensity (95% CI: .9 4.5 and .94 muscle strength (95% CI: -9.29 .8) and qual-
.65 for IC and BF groups, respectively) pelvic ity of life (95% CI: -.9 5.) was found to be
oor muscle strength (95% CI: -0.05 -4.4 and similar in both groups (table 2).
-5.96 -6.0 for IC and BF groups, respectively) No adverse effects were observed during
and quality of life questionnaire scores (95% CI: treatments.
6.5 6.46 and .44 22.6 for IC and BF
groups, respectively) signicantly improved at the
end of treatment programs (gure ).

Discussion
The ndings of this study reveal that both IC the improvement in voiding frequency was more
and BF procedures are of benet in patients with evident in cases that performed pelvic oor exer-
USI, in regard to improvement in intensity of in- cises whereas the increase in the pelvic oor mus-
continence, pelvic muscle strength and quality of cle strength and reduction of subjective com-
life. In addition, the degree of improvement expe- plaints were more evident in BF group [9].
rienced using these methods seems to be similar. Berghmans et al. investigated the effects of
In the literature, studies on the conservative pelvic oor exercises with and without BF appli-
treatment of USI include methods such as pelvic cation in 44 patients of USI. They have pointed
oor exercises, electrical stimulation, vaginal out that the combined approach was more effec-
cones, bladder training and biofeedback [2, 6 tive than performing pelvic oor exercise alone
20]. BF can be applied alone or can be combined [22].
with other procedures in USI treatment [9, 2 In this study, BF was found effective in im-
2]. proving the pelvic oor muscle strength, pad test
Pages et al, compared the effects of pelvic amount and quality of life questionnaire results.
oor exercises and BF in 40 women with USI and There are a limited number of studies on the
found that voiding frequency and the subjective use of IC in USI treatment. Dumoulin et al. inves-
complaints of the cases improved in both groups tigated the effects of combined IC and exercise on
after four weeks of treatment followed by two pelvic oor muscle strength and incontinence in-
weeks with a home program. They indicated that tensity in eight cases with a postpartum USI prob-

Table 2 IC BF 95% Condence interval of the difference of means


Comparison of pre Mean (SD) Mean (SD) Lower Upper
and post treatment
differences in pad Pad test (g) .2 (2.8) 4.8 (6.) .48 4.59
test, pelvic floor mus-
Muscle strength (hPa) .2 (6) (0.6) 9.29 .8
cle strength and qual-
ity of life question- QoLQ score .6 (0.4) 4.9 (5.9) .9 5.
naire values between
groups (t-test for in- QoLQ: Quality of Life Questionnaire
dependent samples).
317-321 Akbay 12038.qxp 20.5.2008 8:48 Uhr Seite 321

S W i S S M e d W k ly 2 0 0 8 ; 1 3 8 ( 2 1 2 2 ) : 3 1 7 3 2 1 w w w . s m w . c h 2

lem. They found that all of the parameters im- greater number of subjects are needed to ascer-
proved after three weeks of treatment [2]. tain any clinically useful differences between the
Another example of the literature on IC in two methods.
patients with USI is the study of Turkan et al. As the follow-up period of all cases is not
They presented the results of a physical therapy completed, it is planned to present the long term
program consisting of the use of IC and Kegel results of these treatments in a further study. Sub-
exercises in patients with different intensities of jects who successfully perform a home program
urodynamic incontinence, but not in comparison will be compared with those who fail to sustain
with other treatment modalities. They indicated the exercise program.
that the program was more effective in cases with The points that can be investigated in further
mild and moderate incontinence intensity rather studies include the results of IC and BF in differ-
than in those with severe incontinence [4]. ent intensities of USI, comparison with the results
Parallel to the results of the related literature, with other physiotherapeutic approaches and the
BF and IC have been found effective in improving effects of different frequencies of IC in USI pa-
pelvic oor muscle strength, incontinence inten- tients.
sity and QOL of cases in this study. These meth-
ods can be used in clinical practice as they are non
invasive, easily applied and well tolerated. Inter-
ferential current may be preferred when biofeed- Correspondence:
back application is not appropriate, as in some Trkan Akbayrak, PT, PhD
geriatric patients (in whom cooperation is re- Assoc Prof, Hacettepe University
duced due to visual or auditory incapacity), in Faculty of Health Science
children or in patients who are not willing to use Department of Physical Therapy
intravaginal/rectal applications. Although statisti- and Rehabilitation
cal analyses revealed that IC and BF seemed to Womens Health Unit, 06100
cause similar amount of improvement in the Samanpazar, Ankara, Turkey
measured variables, results of studies including a E-Mail: takbayrak@yahoo.com

References
 Abrams P, Cardozo L, Fall M, Grifths D, Rosier P, Ulmsten U,  Laycock J, Green RJ. Interferential therapy in the treatment of
Kerrebroeck P, Victor A, Wein A. The standardisation of termi- incontinence. Physiotherapy. 988;4:68.
nology of lower urinary tract function:report from the stan- 4 Low J, Reed A, Dyson M (eds). Interferential Currents. Elec-
dardisation sub-committee of the international continence so- trotherapy Explained (Principles and Practice), Butterworth-
ciety. Neurology and Urodynamics. 2002;2:68. Heinemann, Oxford, 990; pp: 6.
2 Herman H. Urogenital Dysfunction. In: Wilder E (ed). Obstet- 5 Karan A, Aksa B, Ayyldz H, Iskoglu M, Yaln , Eskiyurt N.
ric and Gynecologic Physical Therapy, Churchill Livingstone, Quality of life and its relation with objective assessment param-
New York, 988, pp: 8. eters in urinary incontinent patients. Turk J Geriatrics. 2000;
 Polden M, Mantle J. Continence and incontinence. In: Polden :026.
M, Mantle J (eds). Physiotherapy in Obstetrics and Gynaecol- 6 Mantle J, Vesi E. Physiotherapy for stress urinary incontinence:
ogy, Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 994, pp: 58. a national survey. BMJ. 99;0:55.
4 Turkan A, Inci Y, Fazli D. The short-term effects of physical  Moore KH. Conservative management for urinary inconti-
therapy in different intensities of urodynamic stress inconti- nence. Baillieres Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol. 2000;
nence. Gynecol Obstet Invest. 2005;59:48. 4:2589.
5 Ostergard DR, Bent AE (eds). Urogynecology and Urodynam- 8 Olah KS, Bridges N, Denning J, Farrar DJ. The conservative
ics: Theory and Practice, Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, management of patients with symptoms of stress incontinence:
99, pp: 228. a randomized, prospective study comparing weighted vaginal
6 Malone-Lee J. Recent developments in urinary incontinence in cones and interferential therapy. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 990;
late life. Physiotherapy. 994;80:4. 62:892.
 McGuire EJ. Identifying and managing stress incontinence in 9 Pages IH, Jahr S, Schaufele MK, Conradi E. Comparative
the elderly. Geriatrics. 990;5:4452. analysis of biofeedback and physical therapy for treatment of
8 Aksac B, Aki S, Karan A, Yalcin O, Isikoglu M, Eskiyurt N. urinary stress incontinence in women. Am J Phys Med Rehabil.
Biofeedback and pelvic oor exercises for the rehabilitation of 200;80:494502.
urinary stress incontinence. Gynecol Obstet Invest. 200;56: 20 Smith AL, Moy ML. Modern management of women with
2. stress urinary incontinence. Ostomy Wound Manage. 2004;50:
9 Knight S, Laycock J. The role of biofeedback in pelvic oor re- 29.
education. Physiotherapy. 994;86:458. 2 Aukee P, Immonen P, Laaksonen DE, Laippala P, Penttinen J,
0 Alexander S, Rowan D. Electrical control of urinary inconti- Airaksinen O. The effect of home biofeedback training on
nence: a clinical appraisal. Br J Surg. 90;5:668. stress incontinence. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2004;8:9
 Blowman C. Prospective double blind controlled trial of inten- .
sive physiotherapy with and without stimulation of the pelvic 22 Berghmans LC, Frederiks CM, de Bie RA, Weil EH, Smeets
oor in treatment of genuine stress incontinence. Physiother- LW, van Waalwijk van Doorn ES, Janknegt RA. Efcacy of
apy. 99;:664. biofeedback, when included with pelvic oor muscle exercise
2 Dumoulin C, Seaborne DE, Quirion-DeGirardi C, Sullivan SJ. treatment, for genuine stress incontinence. Neurourol Urodyn.
Pelvic-oor rehabilitation, part 2: pelvic-oor re-education 996;5:52.
with interferential currents and exercise in the treatment of 2 Seo JT, Yoon H, Kim YH. A randomized prospective study
genuine stress incontinence in postpartum women: a cohort comparing new vaginal cone and FES-Biofeedback. Yonsei
study. Physiotherapy. 995;5:058. Med J. 2004;45:8984.
Call for paper NEU.qxp:1. US SMW 38 28.2.2008 8:10 Uhr Seite 1

Established in 1871

F o r m e r l y : S c h w e i ze r i s c h e M e d i z i n i s c h e W o c h e n s c h r i f t

Swiss Medical Weekly

The European Journal of Medical Sciences

The many reasons why you should choose SMW to publish your research
What Swiss Medical Weekly has to offer: International Advisory Committee
Prof. K. E. Juhani Airaksinen, Turku, Fin-
SMWs impact factor has been steadily land
rising. The 2006 impact factor is 1.346. Prof. Anthony Bayes de Luna, Barcelona,
Open access to the publication via Spain
the Internet, therefore wide audience Prof. Hubert E. Blum, Freiburg, Germany
and impact Prof. Walter E. Haefeli, Heidelberg, Ger-
Rapid listing in Medline many
LinkOut-button from PubMed Prof. Nino Kuenzli, Los Angeles, USA
with link to the full text website Prof. Ren Lutter, Amsterdam,
http://www.smw.ch (direct link from The Netherlands
each SMW record in PubMed) Prof. Claude Martin, Marseille, France
Prof. Josef Patsch, Innsbruck, Austria
No-nonsense submission you submit Prof. Luigi Tavazzi, Pavia, Italy
a single copy of your manuscript by
e-mail attachment We evaluate manuscripts of broad clinical
Peer review based on a broad spectrum interest from all specialities, including
of international academic referees experimental medicine and clinical in-
Assistance of professional statisticians vestigation.
for every article with statistical analyses
We look forward to receiving your paper!
Fast peer review, by e-mail exchange
with the referees Guidelines for authors:
Prompt decisions based on weekly con- http://www.smw.ch/set_authors.html
ferences of the Editorial Board
Prompt notification on the status of All manuscripts should be sent in electronic
form, to:
your manuscript by e-mail
Professional English copy editing
EMH Swiss Medical Publishers Ltd.
SMW Editorial Secretariat
Editorial Board Farnsburgerstrasse 8
Prof. Jean-Michel Dayer, Geneva CH-4132 Muttenz
Prof Paul Erne, Lucerne
Prof. Peter Gehr, Berne Manuscripts: submission@smw.ch
Prof. Andr P. Perruchoud, Basel Letters to the editor: letters@smw.ch
Prof. Andreas Schaffner, Zurich Editorial Board: red@smw.ch
(editor in chief) Internet: http://www.smw.ch
Prof. Werner Straub, Berne (senior editor)
Prof. Ludwig von Segesser, Lausanne

Official journal of the Swiss Society of Infectious Diseases,


the Swiss Society of Internal Medicine and the Swiss Respiratory Society
Supported by the FMH (Swiss Medical Association) and by Schwabe AG,
Editores Medicorum Helveticorum the long-established scientific publishing house founded in 1488

You might also like