Professional Documents
Culture Documents
org
Original Research
Introduction: This study evaluated clinical outcomes following acupuncture treatment of postpartum sciatica.
Methods: One hundred eleven women with postpartum sciatica were enrolled in an acupuncture group (n = 86) or a control group (n = 25),
according to their preference. Participants in the acupuncture group attended acupuncture therapy sessions 3 times a week for 4 weeks, while
participants in the control group were assigned to bed rest. Outcome measures included the Roland Disability Questionnaire for sciatica, a visual
analog scale for leg pain, and patient-reported perceived recovery. In addition, participants were surveyed after treatment to assess the acceptability
of acupuncture therapy.
Results: The outcome scores for disability and leg pain were significantly lower in the acupuncture group compared with the control group
(P ⬍ .05). All 86 women in the treatment group stated that acupuncture improved their well-being after treatment. At one month after treatment,
98% of participants in the treatment group reported recovery compared with 24% of the control group participants (P ⬍ .001). After treatment,
95% of lactating women in the acupuncture group believed that acupuncture had no significant interference with breast milk production. No
adverse effects of acupuncture were reported. All participants in the acupuncture group stated they would choose acupuncture in case of relapse.
However, the recurrence rate of sciatica in the acupuncture group (32%) was comparable to that of the control group (35%) at the one-year
follow-up interview.
Discussion: Compared with bed rest, acupuncture might be an effective and acceptable strategy to relieve symptoms of postpartum sciatica.
J Midwifery Womens Health 2018;63:214–220 c 2018 by the American College of Nurse-Midwives.
of sciatica and showed short-term and long-term benefits for disorders such as spinal disc herniation, spinal stenosis, tu-
this common disorder. Importantly, acupuncture has been mors, pelvic injury, and lumbar muscle strain. All participants
demonstrated to be relatively safe and rarely associated with gave informed consent after explanation of the study.
serious adverse effects in patients with sciatica.16 Emerging
evidence has shown the beneficial effect of acupuncture in im- Intervention
proving pregnancy-related low back pain and/or pelvic girdle
pain.18,19 Acupuncture is considered relatively safe for preg- Participants who met the inclusion criteria were divided into 2
nant women,19,20 and some clinical trials21,22 have reported groups: an acupuncture group and a control group, as per their
that adverse effects of acupuncture on neonates after birth choice. Those in the acupuncture group attended acupunc-
were rare. In terms of postpartum conditions, recent stud- ture therapy sessions 3 times a week for 4 weeks. The first
ies have mainly focused on the efficacy of acupuncture in session was given one day after the initial clinic visit. Clas-
lactation support23 and other postpartum disorders, such as sical acupuncture treatment was provided by a physician with
bleeding,23 constipation,21 pyogenic sacroiliitis24 and postpar- postgraduate acupuncture training who had 15 years of ex-
tum depressive symptoms.22 Nevertheless, the effectiveness of perience. The acupuncture technique was applied based on
acupuncture intervention on postpartum sciatica is still un- manual stimulation of a certain group of loci (Figure 1) us-
clear. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effective- ing filiform silver acupuncture needles (Hwato, Suzhou Med-
ness of acupuncture based on TCM theory as an intervention ical Instrument Factory, China) of 30 mm or 60 mm in
for alleviating postpartum sciatica. length and 0.3 mm in diameter. Primary acupoints included
Jingmen (GB25), Huantiao (GB30), Fengshi (GB31), Shenyu
METHODS
(BL23), Chengfu (BL36), and Qihai (CV6). Supplementary
acupoints including Sanyinjiao (SP6) and Zusanli (ST36) were
Design and Setting selected based on individual participants’ TCM syndrome; the
This preliminary study was a prospective controlled clini- supplementary acupoints were added for all the sessions of
cal trial. The study took place in the Acupuncture Center, treatment.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Hubei Woman & Child Generally, the needles were inserted at the depth of 5
Hospital. to 30 mm (depending on acupuncture point locations) with
a Deqi sensation. Because Qi is weak in the postpartum pe-
riod from the perspective of TCM,24 the technique of tonicity,
Sample which could induce recovery from physiologic disorders, was
Women with postpartum sciatica were consecutively re- applied according to the method reported by Leung.25 Par-
cruited from an outpatient orthopedic clinic at Hubei Woman ticipants were stimulated for 30 to 45 minutes (depending on
& Child Hospital. The inclusion criteria included women tolerance and comfort) in each session.
1) within the first 3 months after giving birth, 2) having The 25 participants who did not want to receive acupunc-
symptoms of unilateral well-localized leg pain, which usually ture and other forms of treatment were assigned to the control
radiated from the back to the foot or ankle, 3) with physical ex- group. To make the control intervention somewhat compa-
amination showing tenderness points along the sciatic nerve rable to the acupuncture group, we asked them to undergo a
on the involved side, and 4) willing to receive either acupunc- minimum of 2 hours of bed rest 3 times a week for 4 weeks
ture or bed rest without other treatment interventions such at home. Bed rest was described to them as without bear-
as medications. Imaging techniques and laboratory tests, in- ing weight and in a comfortable position. A research assistant
cluding computed tomography, magnetic resonance imaging, conducted household visits to collect data from the partici-
ultrasound, and electromyogram, were used to exclude other pants in the control group.
Data Collection symptoms (Likert scores 1-2) was defined as “satisfactory re-
covery,” whereas “minimally improved” to “very much worse”
Baseline demographic data were collected prior to any inter-
(Likert scores 3-7) were defined as “unsatisfactory recovery.”
vention. Information about risk factors for sciatica (eg, weight
During 4 weeks of acupuncture treatment, the measure-
gain, coccygeal injury, emotional condition) was recorded
ments of RDQ, VAS scores, and patient-reported recovery
for each participant. Overweight was defined as a body
were made in the clinic immediately after the last therapy
mass index (BMI) of 25 or more. Coccygeal injuries in-
session of each week. After treatment was completed, data
cluded a bruise, dislocation, or fracture of the coccyx in the
were collected during household visits. The RDQ, VAS scores,
past medical or pregnancy history. Women were screened
and patient-reported recovery in control group participants
at their enrollment visit for postpartum depression with the
were collected during household visits by a research assis-
Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale, a standardized self-
tant through in-person interviews. Adherence to the require-
reported questionnaire,26 with a cutoff score of 12. During
ments of bed rest (a minimum of 2 hours, 3 times a week
this study period, psychiatric consultations and appropriate
for 4 weeks) was also supervised and verified by this research
psychological interventions were provided for those who were
assistant.
diagnosed with postpartum depression.
At the one-year follow-up interview at home, participants
Outcomes were measured by the Roland Disability Ques-
in the acupuncture group were also asked whether acupunc-
tionnaire (RDQ) for sciatica, a visual analogue scale (VAS)
ture treatment interfered with the process of lactation (ie,
for leg pain and back pain, and a Likert self-rating scale for
maternal milk production), whether any adverse effects of
patient-reported recovery. The RDQ for sciatica, a disease-
acupuncture were noted, and whether they would choose
specific scale consisting of 23 items reflecting functional status
acupuncture treatment for any recurrence of sciatica.
in a variety of daily living activities, produces scores ranging
from 0 to 23, with higher scores indicating worse functional Statistical Analyses
disability. The VAS anchors were 0 indicating no pain and 100
indicating the worst pain ever experienced. Both of these in- For descriptive statistics, means and standard deviations
struments are considered to be reliable and valid in measuring (SDs) were compared for normally distributed data. Univari-
disability and intensity of pain, respectively.27,28 The RDQ and ate analysis was conducted using the Wilcoxon rank-sum test.
VAS scores in acupuncture and control groups were analyzed Chi-square testing was used to analyze differences in the gen-
as continuous outcome variables at baseline, one, 2, 3, 4, 6, and eral characteristics of participants and patient-reported recov-
8 weeks (once each week) after the enrollment visit. ery between the acupuncture and control groups. All analyses
Self-reported recovery was measured using a 7-point Lik- were conducted using IBM-SPSS version14.0 (IBM Corpora-
ert scale,27 ranging from 1 (complete disappearance of symp- tion, Armonk, NY).
toms) to 7 (very much worse). Recovery was measured after
Ethical Considerations
the first session, after the last session, at one and 12 months
after treatment for the acupuncture group, and at one day Approval to conduct the study was given by the ethics com-
and one, 2, and 13 months after the enrollment visit for the mittee of Hubei Woman & Child Hospital. The study followed
control group. Complete or nearly complete disappearance of the ethical guidelines of the Helsinki Declaration.29
RESULTS
During a period of 6 years (2010-2016), we recruited a to-
tal of 111 consecutive participants with postpartum sciatica;
all completed this study. Demographics and characteristics
of intervention and control groups are displayed in Table 1.
Mean age at diagnosis for the entire group was 31 years
3 months (range: 26 to 42 years). Participants visited the
clinic for sciatica between one day and 58 days after birth.
Most women (73.9%) were breastfeeding. Thirty-seven pa-
tients (33.3%) experienced only leg pain; 8 patients (7.2%)
had pelvic girdle pain; low back pain occurred concurrently
with leg pain in 48 patients (43.2%); and 18 (16.2%) women
had a chief concern of pain in a wide range of areas involving
the leg, low back, and pelvic girdle. In this study, 54 patients
(48.6%) were overweight; 16 (14.4%) had the history of coccyx
injuries; and 31 women (27.9%) were diagnosed with postpar-
tum depression.
Patient-Reported Recovery
As shown in Table 2, after 4 weeks of acupuncture treat-
ment, all 86 (100%) women in the acupuncture group re-
ported complete or nearly complete disappearance of symp- Figure 2. Repeated Measurement Analysis Curves of Mean Scores
for RDQ for Sciatica (top panel) and VAS for Leg Pain (lower panel)
toms. In addition, 39 women (45%) reported that they felt
The points are the mean values with SD shown as bars. n = 86 in
significant improvement of pain after the needles were re- acupuncture group; n = 25 in control group.
moved in the first session, but none in the control group
Abbreviations: RDQ, Roland Disability Questionnaire; VAS, visual analog scale.
stated self-reported recovery at the identical time point *P ⬍ .05; **P ⬍ .01 compared with the identical control group.
(P ⬍ .01).
The reported prevalence of perceived recovery at
2 months after the enrollment visit (ie, one month after
treatment in the acupuncture group) was 98% (84/86) among
those who received the acupuncture treatment but only 24% pain, the underlying imbalance of which is Qi and Blood Stasis
(6/25) for those in the control group (P ⬍ .01). in the postpartum Tixu (physically weak) state.30,31 This im-
At 13 months after the enrollment visit (ie, 12 months af- balance can lead to meridian deficiency and cause the mus-
ter acupuncture treatment for the intervention group), 9 par- cle spasm and tension that trigger the intense shooting pain
ticipants (4 in the acupuncture group, 5 in the control group) of sciatica.31 The acupoints used in this study, such as GB25,
were lost to follow-up. Of the responding 82 participants in GB30, GB31, BL23, and BL36, are commonly found along
the acupuncture group, 67% (55 participants) documented the bladder (BL) and gallbladder (GB) meridians and are
satisfactory recovery, compared with 50% (10/20) in control used empirically for treating pain in the waist and leg (in
group. At this time point, no significant difference in per- terms of TCM theory).32 These same 5 acupoints are com-
ceived recovery was found between the groups. monly utilized as classic acupuncture points for the treat-
We found that the recurrence rate of pain in the acupunc- ment of sciatica.33,34 Although the neuroanatomic basis of
ture group was 32% (26/82) at the one-year follow-up inter- these acupoints for sciatica treatment is unknown, it has been
view, which was comparable to the 35% recurrence in control suggested that acupuncture at certain points, including GB25
group (7/20). In 26 recurrent cases in the acupuncture group, and GB30, can increase the pain threshold in persons with
73% (19 cases) were accompanied by overweight (BMI of 25 sciatica.35 Acupoint BL23 is located at the erector spinae and
or more); 31% (8 cases) were with a history of coccygeal injury, quadratus lumborum muscle, where low back pain or sciat-
and 54% (14 cases) had postpartum depression, suggesting the ica is felt.14 Acupuncture at this point may exert its effect
recurrence might be associated with the unsolved clinical risk locally via intramuscular stimulation, which might stimulate
factors for sciatica. the nerve fibers in the muscle and trigger the release of va-
soactive substances, thereby improving local blood flow and
Acceptance of Acupuncture Therapy promote healing.14 Acupoint GB30 is located at the sciatic
nerve and acupuncture stimulation at GB30 may increase
At the one-year follow-up interview, 95% of 62 lactating
blood flow in the nerve.14 Using a rat model with acute sciatic
women in the acupuncture treatment group stated that
nerve injury, Dai et al36 found that electroacupuncture stimu-
acupuncture had no significant interference on breast milk
lation at GB30 could improve the function of the injured sci-
production, despite the fact that 3 women reported various
atic nerve. In addition, we added another primary acupoint
degrees of decrease in milk yield during therapy. None
(CV6), which is thought to tone the Qi, and is relevant to gy-
reported that adverse effects of acupuncture intervention
necology and maternity care,37 especially for the state of “post-
occurred during and after the treatment. Moreover, 100% of
partum Qi and Blood Stasis, or postpartum Tixu.”
participants indicated that they would choose acupuncture
The additional points including Sanyinjiao (SP6) and
treatment if they were to suffer relapses of sciatica pain in the
Zusanli (ST36) with TCM properties to “invigorate the
future.
Blood,” “dissolve the Stasis,” “dispel the Wind,” and “open
the meridian”38–42 were also selected in our study, when
DISCUSSION the patients were diagnosed with a TCM syndrome called
The results of this preliminary clinical study suggest that the Postpartum Qi Deficiency.43 In TCM, Sanyinjiao (SP6),
analgesic action of acupuncture could be effective for postpar- which can regulate the channel Qi of the liver, spleen, and
tum sciatica, as manifested by the lower RDQ and VAS scores, kidney,38 is commonly used for gynecologic, genitourinary,
and the higher patient-reported prevalence of perceived re- and emotional disorders. Experimental research has shown
covery in the acupuncture group. While existing research15–17 that acupuncture on SP6 could have an effect on the con-
has demonstrated that acupuncture is effective for sciatica in traction of the uterus and pain relief,39 and SP6 acupres-
general, to our knowledge, this is the first report on acupunc- sure has been reported effective in decreasing pain and du-
ture treatment for postpartum sciatica. ration of labor for primigravida women in labor.40 Similarly,
According to the principles of TCM, the condition that is the general function of Zusanli (ST36) is strengthening de-
congruent with postpartum sciatica is called postpartum body ficiency conditions by harmonizing the Qi and Blood, and