Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The fit for a particular location is particularly the production of road bitumen, and have
dependant on finding a use for the SDA pitch and included both two-product (deasphalted oil
various options are discussed. (DAO) and pitch) and three-product
(deasphalted oil, resin and pitch) process
configurations.
Background
While solvent deasphalting (SDA) has been used
for more than fifty years to upgrade non-volatile This merging of FW and UOP solvent
residues, the technology continues to evolve over deasphalting technologies provides our clients
time. It is a robust economical process that uses with the widest range of experiences, process
an aliphatic solvent to separate the typically more features, engineering know-how, technical
valuable oils and resins from the more aromatic support, and most importantly, a more efficient
and asphaltenic components of its vacuum residue and lower cost design.
feedstock. The earliest commercial applications of
solvent deasphalting used propane as the solvent Technology Overview
to extract high-quality lubricating oil bright stock
from vacuum residue. These applications were Solvent deasphalting, whether for the production
called propane deasphalting (or propane of lubricating oil or cracking stocks, uses a light
deresining when used to separate high molecular hydrocarbon solvent specifically tailored to ensure
weight resins from Pennsylvania-grade vacuum the most economical deasphalting design. For
residue). Solvent deasphalting process have example, propane solvent may be specified for a
gradually extended to include the preparation of low deasphalted oil yield operation such as lub
feedstocks for catalytic cracking, hydrocracking, production, while a solvent containing
and hydrodesulfurization units, as well as the hydrocarbons as heavy as hexane may be used to
production of specialty asphalts. obtain a high deasphalted oil yield for the
production of additional conversion unit feedstock.
In 1996, UOP and Foster Wheeler USA Plant designs have been developed using heavy
Corporation (FW) entered into a collaboration solvents at elevated temperatures in order to
agreement to merge their solvent deasphalting maximize the yield of usable deasphalted oil and
technologies. Both companies had extensive minimize the yield of pitch having a softening point
backgrounds in solvent deasphalting, and both of 350F or higher.
companies had recently entered into collaboration
covering other residue upgrading technologies UOP/FW SDA technology is unique by different
such as visbreaking and delayed coking. A from other solvent deasphalting technologies in
collaboration covering solvent deasphalting was that it is not just one technology, but rather a
considered a logical fit that would benefit the combination of technology features and options
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 1 of 11
February 2006
WHEN SOLVENT DEASPHALTING IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY FOR UPGRADING RESIDUE
Edward J. Houde - UOP LLC
Michael J. McGrath - Foster Wheeler USA Corporation
which have been developed by both companies. by incorporating both stripping and
These features and options allow UOP/FW to rectification of the oil feed. Superior
offer the optimum process design for any solvent quality DAO is obtained from the RDC
deasphalting application. even at DAO recovery rates exceeding 85
percent, with an even greater difference in
For example, UOP has predominately focused its quality being seen at lower DAO yields.
technology on downstream conversion unit
applications. As a result, UOPs solvent Supercritical solvent recovery. Supercritical
deasphalting experience has principally focused recovery of the solvent allows more efficient
on the use of butane and heavier type solvents utilization of the systems thermodynamic
that can obtain higher DAO recoveries. There is a characteristics while also reducing the units
distinct advantage to the use of supercritical operating costs.
separation for the recovery of the solvent and
DAO when using these types of solvents. ** Multiple product recovery designs that take
Consequently, UOP developed supercritical advantage of the changes in liquid-liquid
solvent-DAO separation technology. The other equilibrium that result from changes in
area that UOP focused its development efforts operating conditions between those utilized
involved minimizing the solvent to oil ratio while during extraction and those used for solvent
still producing a reasonably high quality DAO. recovery.
FWs SDA technology development emphasis was Lower solvent requirements used to achieve
initially more focused on lower lift, very high quality processing objectives. Although increasing
applications, such as the production of lube oil the amount of solvent used in the extraction
feedstocks for hydrocracking and further solvent improves the extraction efficiency, it also has
refining. Consequently its technology originally a major impact on the units operating costs.
focused around propane/butane deasphalting Consequently, the lowest solvent-to-oil ratio
using optimized extraction techniques for those necessary to achieve the desired product
specific applications. Additionally FW has made separation is typically specified.
available its detailed design and construction
experiences from a multitude of SDA projects. Optimal design of heat exchange systems.
UOP and FWs combined design experience
Technology Advantages in optimizing SDA heat exchange systems
allows the SDA user to select a multitude of
The UOP/FW SDA technology has several distinct heat exchange options, depending on the
advantages that ensure the refiner obtains the project specific objectives and opportunities.
most efficient, economical, and flexible SDA
process. These include: Extraction Devices
Novel extraction devices tailored to the The efficiency of the extraction process is the key
specific application: equipment design variable impacting both the
capital and operating costs of SDA. The
- UOP/FW/Sulzers Structured Packing and extractors role in SDA is to separate the
proprietary internals in both the multi- precipitate (pitch phase) from the continuous fluid
stage counter current extractor as well as stream (DAO/solvent).
the DAO and resin separators. This
technology provides state-of-the-art Both single-stage co-current extraction, where the
contacting and separation devices to bulk of the solvent is mixed with the feed prior to
maximize extraction efficiency as well as the extractor, as well as multi-stage counter-
optimal recovery of clean products. current extraction, where the bulk of the solvent
enters the bottom of the extractor separate from
- FWs multi-stage rotating disk contactor the feed, have been used commercially.
(RDC). The RDC is specifically designed
to achieve high product yields and quality Structured packing or RDCs used in multi-stage
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 2 of 11
February 2006
WHEN SOLVENT DEASPHALTING IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY FOR UPGRADING RESIDUE
Edward J. Houde - UOP LLC
Michael J. McGrath - Foster Wheeler USA Corporation
counter-current extraction provide both the The impact of solvent-to-oil ratio on both capital
contacting area and time required for extraction as and operating costs is conservatively reflected in
well as segregation of the stages to reduce back Tables 2 and 3. These tables summarize an
mixing below the feed stage. Above the feed internal study undertaken by UOP and FW to
stage, structured packing or coils provide for the assess the relative costs of different solvent-to-oil
coalescing of entrained droplets of feed or pitch. ratios. The cost of fuel has significantly increased
since this study was performed and the savings at
Supercritical Solvent Recovery lower solvent ratios would be even more
pronounced. While the cost benefits at a lower
Although, often referred to as supercritical solvent ratio can be substantial, the solvent-to-oil
extraction, it is the solvent separation, not the ratio also has an impact on DAO quality (see
extraction that is carried out in the supercritical Figure 1). Consequently, the optimal solvent ratio
region of the solvent. The use of supercritical is determined based on the DAOs downstream
solvent recovery results in a simpler process flow. processing requirements.
Gone is the need for multiple flash towers and
condensers associated with conventional multiple Figure 1: Effect of Solvent to Oil Ratio
effect evaporative type solvent recovery systems. 70
3/1 5/1
8/1
PPM Metals in DAO
60
Supercritical solvent recovery allows for more 50
efficient utilization of the systems thermodynamic 40
characteristics. Presented below is a comparative 30
tabulation of the utility requirements of 20
conventional subcritical evaporative and 10
supercritical solvent recovery systems. Note that 0
the difference from subcritical to supercritical 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 3 of 11
February 2006
WHEN SOLVENT DEASPHALTING IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY FOR UPGRADING RESIDUE
Edward J. Houde - UOP LLC
Michael J. McGrath - Foster Wheeler USA Corporation
Table 2
UOP/FW SDA Advantage
Capital Costs
Option: 1 2 Delta
Case: High Solvent to Low Solvent to _
Oil Ratio Oil Ratio
Solvent-to-oil Ratio (S/O) 8 5 3
Solvent C4 Mix C4 Mix -
Size (BPD) 28,000 28,000 -
% Equip. Assoc. with S/O 60 60 -
Equip. Assoc. with S/O $ 20,520,000 $ 15,700,000 $ 4,820,000
Other Equipment Cost $ 15,680,000 $ 15,680,000 $ -
Installed Cost, $MM $ 36,200,000 $ 31,380,000 $ 4,820,000
Unit Cost, $/BBL 1,290 1,120 170
Table 3
UOP/FW SDA Advantage
Operating Costs
Option: 1 2 Delta
Case: High Solvent to Low Solvent to -
Oil Ratio Oil Ratio
Solvent-to-oil Ratio 8 5 3
Solvent C4 Mix C4 Mix -
Average Utility Consumptions
(per barrel of feed)
Fuel, MMBTU 0.075 0.056 0.019
Steam, lbs 12.0 10.5 1.5
Power, kW 2.67 1.77 0.90
Incremental Cost
($Bbl Feed)
Fuel 0.293 0.206 0.087
Steam 0.00006 0.00005 0.000
Power 0.179 0.119 0.060
Total 0.342 0.248 0.094
Yearly Cost (28,000 BPD) $3,600,000 $2,500,000 $1,100,000
Unit Cost Reference
Fuel, MMBTU $3.82
3
Steam, 10 lbs $4.83
Power, $/kW $0.067
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 4 of 11
February 2006
WHEN SOLVENT DEASPHALTING IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY FOR UPGRADING RESIDUE
Edward J. Houde - UOP LLC
Michael J. McGrath - Foster Wheeler USA Corporation
Process Description
The recovered solvent streams from the DAO and
In non-lube oil production applications, regardless pitch recovery sections are cooled/condensed and
of whether a two-product or three-product recycled back to the extraction section for reuse.
configuration is employed, the units design would
Figure 2: Supercritical SDA Process
employ structured packing, supercritical solvent
recovery and the flexibility to utilize a range of
solvent types to achieve the desired separation.
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 5 of 11
February 2006
WHEN SOLVENT DEASPHALTING IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY FOR UPGRADING RESIDUE
Edward J. Houde - UOP LLC
Michael J. McGrath - Foster Wheeler USA Corporation
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 6 of 11
February 2006
WHEN SOLVENT DEASPHALTING IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY FOR UPGRADING RESIDUE
Edward J. Houde - UOP LLC
Michael J. McGrath - Foster Wheeler USA Corporation
difficult to maintain a stable operation at these extracts the more paraffinic components from
conditions, the extractor temperature is typically vacuum residues while rejecting the condensed
maintained below the solvents critical ring aromatics. The deasphalted oil product
temperature. quality is characterized by:
The quantity of solvent contained in the Reduced metal content - DAO with as little
solvent/residue mixture that is charged to the as 1 wppm nickel plus vanadium content
extractor vessel has an impact on extraction has been produced even from Venezuelan
efficiency. As shown in Figure 1, increasing the residues containing 700 to 1,000 wppm of
amount of solvent in the extractor while these metals.
maintaining a constant DAO yield improves the
degree of separation of the individual components Reduced carbon residue - The carbon
and results in the recovery of a higher-quality residue in deasphalted oils is significantly
DAO. lower than for distilled oils of equivalent
viscosity or mid-boiling point.
However, since the quantity of solvent which is
recirculated within the unit is significantly greater The deasphalted oil product yield-quality relation-
than the amount of feedstock being processed, ships obtained when solvent deasphalting typical
any improvement in product quality which results vacuum residues are shown in Figure 3. This data
from an increased solvent recirculation rate must is based on UOP and Foster Wheelers extensive
be balanced against the additional operating costs library of pilot plant and commercial solvent
associated with the increased solvent recirculation deasphalting data.
and solvent recovery requirements, and the
increased capital costs associated with the larger Figure 3: SDA Quality Selectivity
equipment sizes. Once the required solvent-to-oil
ratio is established, however, it is usually not
adjusted unless the feed rate is increased and the 100
solvent circulation becomes the limitation on unit
Appearing in Deasphalted Oil, %
90
Sulfur, Nitrogen and Metals
TABLE 6
ESTIMATED UTILITY REQUIREMENTS
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 8 of 11
February 2006
WHEN SOLVENT DEASPHALTING IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY FOR UPGRADING RESIDUE
Edward J. Houde - UOP LLC
Michael J. McGrath - Foster Wheeler USA Corporation
It is analogous to vacuum distillation in that it only A recent project that has started up in the Far East
provides separation of products not conversion of is a good example of the applicability of solvent
products. If you change to a lower quality feed it deasphalting in an existing refinery. In this case,
will result in a lower quality of DAO or a lower yield the refiner desired to recover additional cracking
or both. It is not analogous in that it separates by stock from a residual fuel stream. The solvent
molecular types rather than volatility. The result in deasphalting unit was designed to process 6,000
general is that higher boiling components are BPSD (approximately 40,000 kg/hr) of a Middle
recovered in the units pitch product and the lower Eastern crude blend to recover a 50% yield of
boiling components are recovered in the units DAO. UOP/FW/Sulzers latest state-of-the-art,
DAO product. Due to solvent selectivity, however, proprietary internals and structured packing were
the pitch will contain low-boiling, highly aromatic used in both the units extractor and DAO
components while the DAO will contain high- separator.
boiling, paraffinic components. For a fuels type
solvent deasphalter, the pitch production will be The addition of the solvent deasphalting unit
minimized for a specific cracking stock (DAO plus allowed the refiner to increase the amount of
VGO) quality by maximizing the lift in the vacuum transportation fuels produced from the refinery.
unit to the limit of VGO quality. This also The recovered pitch, along with some clarified
minimizes the size of the solvent deasphalter. slurry oil, ( 20 Liq Vol % of the blend) was used
as a high viscosity residual fuel by an existing
Solvent deasphalting is less expensive to build nearby IPP to produce power. In order to
and operate than other residue conversion compensate for the higher viscosity of the IPPs
processes, although as noted earlier, it does not fuel blend, for this application, the fuel system and
provide any actual conversion. Therefore, it is burner temperatures were higher than from a tyical
most applicable to recovering the large quantity of solvent deasphalting operation.
high quality oils in light residues while rejecting the
small quantity of asphaltenes and impurities such
UOP/FW Technical Service
as metals and those components that contribute to
carbon residue. In addition, unlike residue
conversion units which benefit from economy of In addition to the benefits provided by UOP and
scale, solvent deasphalting can be economically FWs broad commercial experience bases,
applied at very small feed rates. licensees have full access to the widest range of
Finally, solvent deasphalting has good applicability support resources available to the refining
where the demand for a low-value residual fuel is industry. This allows UOP/FW to offer licensees
significantly smaller than the production of residual high-quality support from initial conception,
fuel oil based on vacuum tower bottoms through unit design and construction, and
production. continuing on through unit start-up and monitoring
of the operating units performance. These
Utilization of Pitch services include:
Pilot plant testing to establish design basis
The utilization of SDA pitch is very much
Technical services during unit checkout and
dependant on the local market. The primary outlet
start-up
for the pitch is as fuel, mainly as a blend
component in the residual oil market. Another Ongoing operations monitoring
significant market is as a blend component in the Engineer and operator training programs
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 9 of 11
February 2006
WHEN SOLVENT DEASPHALTING IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY FOR UPGRADING RESIDUE
Edward J. Houde - UOP LLC
Michael J. McGrath - Foster Wheeler USA Corporation
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 10 of 11
February 2006
WHEN SOLVENT DEASPHALTING IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY FOR UPGRADING RESIDUE
Edward J. Houde - UOP LLC
Michael J. McGrath - Foster Wheeler USA Corporation
TABLE 7
SOLVENT DEASPHALTING
PILOT PLANT vs. COMMERCIAL RDC OPERATION
Commercial
Pilot Plant Operation
Feed Inspections
Pitch Inspections
Penetration @ 77F 8 10
IDTC Conference
London, England Page 11 of 11
February 2006