Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COOP-CT-2004-508723
ADOPBIO
Advanced Oxidation Processes and Biotreatments for Water Recycling in the Textile Industry
Table of Contents
Project objectives
Today more than 4.000 compounds are used in the textile finishing process, which
complicates design and setting up of a single cleaning up and recycling technology. The
equipment used in decolouring and cleaning up processes is very hard to set and tune with the
continuous variation in load and composition. Moreover, the pollutant charge can overload
the capability of the cleaning plant, therefore failures are common and operational costs are
prohibitive for SME companies.
One of the purposes of the project will be to investigate different dyeing and finishing
processes, drawing guidelines for the convenience of recycling water by this system.
ADOPBIO will focus on a decolouring and cleaning up treatment for textile finishing
wastewaters based on an UV-activated photolysis of the hydrogen peroxide (an targetted
Advanced Oxidation Process, AOP) combined with a bioflotation treatment.
The combination of these treatments can achieve a complete decolourization and recycling of
the process waters for every type of wet process (finishing, bleaching, dyeing, etc.).
ADOPBIO will also focus on the development and implementation of process control
software, based on artificial neural network and systems dynamics.
The textile finishing wastewater treatment is expected to achieve the following characteristics:
Quality of the treated process water :
• full decolorization (> 99% for interfering dyes; > 90% for other colour substances)
• reduction of surfactants (≥ 99%) and toxic compounds (COD reduction ≥ 95%) if not
recyclable
• recycling of at least 75% of the wastewaters
WP1 – Objectives
The objectives of the WP1 were the followings:
• description of the textile wet processes used by each end-user partner
• definition of a strategy for reducing use and preventing accumulation of chemicals
• economic impact analysis of wastewater recycling strategies and technologies
• technical specifications for a resource-saving wastewater treatment
WP1 – Results
1 WET PROCESS ANALYSIS
A deep review of the end-users wet processes was achieved through visiting the factories,
collecting samples of products and process waters, and analysing them with a particular
attention to the parameters that will be important for AOP and bioflotation treatments.
Within wet-processes, dyeing was the subject of main investigations.
In the following paragraphs results are reported for the two factories.
1.1 Wet process at Blondel SA.
Robert Blondel SA is a group including 3 mills for textile finishing. The main plant is placed
in St. Léger du Bourg Denis, near Rouen (Normandy), the second mill, Teinturie Centre
Alsace, is situated near Strasbourg, the third plant, Teinture et Apprête de Normandie, is in
Malaunay, close to Rouen. Robert Blondel SA works in partnership with important fashion
houses (Lacoste, Kindy, Olimpia, Kookai, Eminence, etc.), offering a full service with a
performant laboratory and a range of different capacity of baths on cones, hank and fabrics.
Plant in St. Léger du Bourg Denis.
Blondel’s factory in St. Léger du Bourg Denis is mainly dedicated to processing of yarns of
different materials as cotton, viscose, wool and silk. The lay-out of the plant is divided in
these parts: store room for raw materials; dyeing rooms; rewinding, inspection and packaging
departments; general services as energy, water softening, steam and neutralization via CO2 of
WP2 – Objectives
The objectives of the WP2 were the followings:
WP2 – Results
Different reactors have been used at laboratory level, both as concern AOPs and Bioflotation.
Here following are the pictures of the AOPs reactors ranging from 3 to 12 liters at SSeta lab
and that at UniMaribor of 6 liters and continuous control of main parameters:
The lamps tested were of an electric power of 500 and 1000 W also of different bulb length
that is W/cm.
The lamp of this reactor is of a tunable electric power from 400 to 1600W.
Through these reactors we investigated the behavior of many of the substances in use at the
end-users factories with particular attention to the dyestuffs of the largest consume.
Beginning with degradation of the selected dyestuff, the tests were run adding all the chemical
auxiliaries and salts necessary for a correct dyeing process with the purpose to investigate the
quenching effect of the chemicals and the intermediates produced during the AOP treatments.
As concern thermal enhanced oxidation, we did not need any specific reactor but only
conventional lab tools. The course of the degradations has been followed measuring the
absorbance, TOC, pH, conductivity, residual H2O2 etc. and the values at different times have
been reported in diagrams and faced through a kinetic approach. Also the combination of
AOP and Bioflotation has been tested.
Here following are some cases of the results obtained.
Degradation of Irgalan Gelb 3RL KWL and other dyes in thermal enhanced
decolouration.
In the following graph is reported the degradation of a metal complex dyestuff.
In this experiment was investigated the effect of the concentration of H2O2 but in the same
way also the influence of the temperature, the amount of catalyst and the concentration of
different dyestuffs have been considered.
Results from kinetic studies of the UV/H2O2/catalyst decolouration show that all studied
reactions are of pseudo first order. For metal complex dyes the best conditions among tested
were: pH 7, dye concentration 30 mg/l, H2O2 5 ml. For reactive dyes the best conditions
were: pH 3, dye concentration 30 mg/l, H2O2 3 ml.
Some HPLC analysis allowed to understand part of the chemical mechanism of degradation
of dyes in the solution treated by AOP. Maleic acid was identified as an intermediate before
complete mineralization and this is due to opening the aromatic rings of the structure.
Bioflotation system
WP4 – Objectives
The objectives of the WP4 were the followings:
• definition of functionalities of the software controlling the treatment and feed-back
actions on the finishing process upstream
• implementation of the software and ß-tests by means of process simulation
• simulating how the AOP cells dynamically interact and work together for the benefit
of the whole - input for learning and neural network organisational control
WP4 – Results
The ANN-based models were built for model dye solutions to help in the process control. For
on – line prediction ANN models were performed using different number of neurons. 4
dimensional neurons were arranged in a rectangular grid. Each component of the neuron
corresponds to one variable determining the concentration of dye, volume H2O2 added,
intensity of the lamp and decoloration time. Different Kohonen-ANN architectures (5x5x4,
6x6x4, 8x8x4, 10x10x4, 20x20x4 …) were constructed. All were checked for conflicts, which
mean that two samples of different type fall into the same neuron.
Validation of the model was performed using cross validation. During the learning phase the
number of epochs and subsequently the number of iterations were optimized.
Cross validation means taking as model all experiments but one and trying to predict the
results of the experiment that was left out. The leave one out procedure was made for all
experiments. The predicted results were calculated and correlation between Yexp and Ymodel
was calculated. This process helps to calculate the results for the experiment that has never
been used in learning phase.
Comment: Erionyl Schwarz M BN and Dorospers Rot KRR gave bad r-cross validation
because the decolouration using H2O2 /UV procedure was not successful for these kind of
dyes.
The best solution for the controlled output is final absorbance Af:
A f = (1 − D) Ai = (1 − f (C p , PUV , T )) Ai (1)
Optimal control is proposed to solve the control problem. The most important thing when
applying optimal control is to define a cost function. If the latter is not chosen wisely, the
results of the control will be unsatisfactory. The cost has to include all important aspects of
the control problem. In our case, we decided to choose the following cost function:
Cp PUV T
J = kd g ( Af ) + k p + ke (3)
C max Pmax T max
where g(Af) is the function that defines the cost due to unsatisfactory final absorbance:
⎧0 Af < Asatis
g ( Af ) = ⎨ (4)
⎩( Af − Asatis ) Af ≥ Asatis
2
If the final absorbance is greater than a certain threshold Asatis (the acceptable level of the final
absorbance), the first term of the cost function will be 0. If, however, the final absorbance is
greater, the first term will be positive. Constants Cmax, Pmax and Tmax are maximal values of Cp,
PUV and T used in the modelling process, respectively. Thus, the second and the third term in
Eq. (3) represent the cost due to H2O2 consumption and the cost due to energy consumption,
respectively. The first term in Eq. (3) represents the punishment of the unsatisfactory
decolourisation. Defining the structure of the cost function (3) is not enough for solving the
problem. One of the most subtle tasks is choosing the values of the constants kd, kp and ke that
represent the weights of the decolourisation cost, the peroxide cost, and the energy cost,
respectively.
Inserting (1) into (3), the following form of the cost function is obtained:
C P T
J (C p , PUV , T , Ai ) = k d g ((1 − f (C p , PUV , T )) Ai ) + k p p + ke UV (5)
Cmax PmaxTmax
The cost function depends on four variables and two known functions: f is the mapping
realised by the ANN, and g is given by Eq. (4). The optimal control is given by minimising
the cost function (5) with respect to three control variables (Cp, PUV and T). Since the
minimisation is done in four dimensional space (Cp, PUV, T, and Ai) each optimal control
variable depends upon the fixed value of initial absorbance (that is of course known prior to
the decolourisation process). Minimisation can be done off-line to come up with the control
functions:
PUV = h1 ( Ai )
T = h2 ( Ai ) (6)
C p = h3 ( Ai )
The three control functions h1, h2, and h3 are obtained in tabular form minimising the cost
function for the set of equidistantly spaced values for Ai.
In the continuation of the project the program in the Matlab language was built that is capable
of automatically train the ANN model
D = f (C p , PUV , T ) (7)
of the process based on the measurements given in the form of ASCII files (the measurements
will be collected from the real plant). After building the model, the control functions PUV, T,
Cp are recalculated. They are given in the tabular form as a function of the initial absorbance.
The output is produced in the form of an ASCII file that is used by the industrial PC to tune
the control parameters on the PLC.
P = 1600 W
UV
0.8
decolourisation
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
60
40 10
20 5
time [min] 0 0
volume of H202 [mL/L]
WP5 – Objectives
The objectives of the WP5 were the followings:
• manufacture of reactors for UV- and thermal-activated AOPs
• manufacture of the bioflotation reactor
• manufacture of the dyeing machine interfaced with the AOP reactors
WP5 – Results
- the work performed,
Manufacture of reactors for UV and thermal activated AOPs:
The goals consist in:
• manufacturing of the reactor chambers and lamps supports;
• assembling of the reactors chambers on a proper frame;
• assembling of the reactors connection pipes, valves and pumps;
• manufacturing of the electrical and pneumatic system;
Manufacture of the bioflotation reactor:
The manufacturing of the bioflotation reactor has been carried out by ECOLOGIA
APPLICATA to his subcontractor.
The goals consist in:
• manufacturing of the bioflotation reactor;
• manufacturing of the connection pipe between the various reactor parts;
• assembling of the reactor electrical cabinet;
• manufacturing of the electrical system
Manufacture of the dyeing machine interfaced with the AOP reactor
The manufacturing of the dyeing machine has been carried out by OBEM according to the
previous design.
The goals consist in:
• manufacturing of the dyeing machine;
• assembling of the dyeing machine, aop reactor and bioflotation reactor;
• manufacturing of the connection pipe between the machine and the reactors;
• assembling of the electrical cabinet supplied by DAMA;
• manufacturing of the electrical and pneumatic system
The final project aim is the definition of a system extremely flexible to allow the exploring of
all possible configurations for the cleaning process, because its efficiency depends on the
characteristics of the wet process that is related to the type of textile material to be dyed.
The "connection flexibility" for the system allow to test several configurations and provide
flexible cleaning solutions, according to the composition of the bath waters. The two
treatments, AOP and Bioflotation, can be carried out separately and independently giving
more efficiency to the system.
WP6 – Objectives
The objectives of the WP6 were the followings:
• integration of the wastewater treatment and recycling system (AOP reactors + dyeing
machine + bioflotation reactor + tertiary treatment equipments)
• wastewater and recycling system interfacing with the ANN-based software
• validation tests, analysis of technical results and operational costs
WP6 – Results
1 Integration of the wastewater treatment and recycling system (AOP reactors +
dyeing machine + bio flotation reactor BF + tertiary treatment equipments):
The final design consist in a platform were are installed all the parts of the system to allow the
transportation without any disassembling. In this way the system can be easy installed in the
involved partners facilities for the necessary tests. Each part (dyeing machine, reactors, tanks,
pumps,...) is fixed on the platform and connected with the others by an austenitic stainless
steel type 316 piping also fixed on the platform. In the piping system are installed all the
valves pumps, probes, gauges necessaries for the working in order to allow a great flexibility
and the possibility to test different configurations to check the different ADOPBIO recycling
technologies.(See fig 1) The valves involved in the process are automatically driven by the
PC control system, while the auxiliaries valves (e.g. tanks drain, washing, discharging, liquor
check) are manually driven. All the process data are controlled by the PC control system, so
can be easily memorized for reference. The system is completed by a recycled water storage
tank having a capacity of 1000 liters to recover the treated water. This tank is equipped with a
proper pump automatically driven which allow the reuse of this water directly in the dyeing
machine or for tanks and/or reactors filling or washing. As shown in the diagram of fig 1 and
in the scheme of fig 2 the working possibilities of the system are various due to its flexibility.
In fact the system can works as follows
o Dyeing + AOP
o Dyeing + Bio flotation
o Dyeing + AOP + Bio flotation
o Dyeing with reuse of recycled water + AOP
o Dyeing with reuse of recycled water + Bio flotation
o Dyeing with reuse of recycled water + AOP + Bio flotation
The industrial tests were carried out using, either the dyeing liquor from the dyeing
equipment, and the liquor from industrial dye-houses to check the validity of the prototype.
During these tests the necessity of minor modifications has been evidenced, and the following
improvements puts into service:
AOP reactor tank heating system; AOP reactor tank pH control and dosing system; AOP
reactor liquor sampling collection; AOP reactor flow rate modification; Lamps cooling.
As concern a tertiary treatment equipment, a filtration step has been considered but only at lab
scale and also the addition of a specific enzyme for residual H2O2 reduction was proved to be
needed to get the decolorized liquor be reusable in a dyeing process.
Storage tank
1000 liters recycled water storage tank
The objectives have been reached as concern decolourization and water reuse.
Operational costs of the plant appeared to be difficult to foreseen because they are widely
dependent on the dyeing process.
WP7 – Objectives
The objectives of the WP7 were the followings:
• monitoring of technical progress and financial control of the project
• assistance for consortium members to anticipate organizational problems
• setting up of corrective actions in order to respect the objectives of the project
WP7 – Results
The overall commitment of project partners is good and the work and resources between the
RTD performers and the SMEs is well balanced.
The work performed by the RTD performers has allowed a good progress towards the
objectives of the project, in particular in the validation of the pilot plant. Then, the pilot has
been well implemented in collaboration with the SMEs.
The SMEs have well participated to the activities led in particular in the building of the pilot
plant (OBEM, DAMA and HELIOS) and in the performance of the tests in the plant of TSP
and BLONDEL.
The situation of AOP is more complicated because, at laboratory level, a lot of different
systems are available for the treatment of wastes, but only ozone have been applied at full
scale level, as a polishing step after the application of a preliminary alternative treatment.
UV lamps are commercially applied for the bactericidal effect or for the remediation of waters
contaminated by low quantities of highly toxic substances. In ADOPBIO UV radiation has
been used as photo-activators of H2O2 to produce OH radicals that are able to oxidize most
organic substances in solution. This system has an efficient effect in the decoloration of
wastewaters containing dyestuffs and in general in the demolition of organic water-soluble
substances. The efficiency of the process is highly influenced by many factors but mainly by
the composition of the solutions. The state of the art of AOPs using H2O2 is, once more, a
combination of tools that look for the increasing of the production of OH radicals or the
exploitation of UV radiation. Ultrasounds and catalysts have been investigated by research
groups and in ADOPBIO we proved iron II salts for their catalytic action that substantially
improved the reaction rate in some of the tested solutions.
Artificial Intelligence Technology for plant operation have been studied for the control of
ADOPBIO system and applied at laboratory level, where some chemical parameters have
been measured in continuous. Artificial neural networks have been applied but other models,
like fuzzy models, spline models, etc. have been used for process control by research groups.