wL}UG ?i Lh @?

)q
Bh@@4 hit|
@) Sc 2ff

 W?|hL_U|L?G wL}U@* L?t4 @?_ wL}U@* *

h@*t4
Wt |ihi L?i *L}U Lh @hi |ihi 4@?)q Ah@_|L?@**)c |ihi @t L?*) L?iQ|i *L}U
Lu ht|L|*i @?_ |i 5|LUtc @t 4i*_i_ |L}i|ih ? |i 4__*i @}itQ@?_ |i ^it
|L? ?iih @hLti At Ui?|h)c i @i tii? @ T*i|Lh@ Lu *L}UtG 6hi}i%+tti**
EU*@ttU@* *L}Uc ?||L?t4c T@h@UL?tt|i?| *L}Uc ^@?|4 *L}U Nt@**)c @_
LU@|it Lu |iti *L}Ut ihi t|** *L}U@* 4L?t|tc ? |i ti?ti |@| |i) |LL! |
|@| L|ih *L}Ut ihi hL?} | |i i}| Lu |i T*i|Lh@ @t Mii? |LL 4U
uLh tL4i TiLT*ic L @i _iU_i_ |@| |ihi t ?L L?i |hi *L}UG |ihi @hi *L|t
Lu |?}t U 4@)c | i^@* t|€U@|L?c Mi U@**i_ *L}U W? *L}Uc @t ? @
4*|U*|h@* tLUi|)c T*h@*t4 4t| Mi i?_Lhti_ Wt |t h}|qQ
Ai @?tihc @t L?i 4}| i TiU|c t |@| | _iTi?_t L? @| L?i 4i@?t
Aihi @hi Uih|@? ti?tit ? U |i @?tih t U*i@h*) )it< | ? |i U@ti Lu
Ui?|h@* 4TLh|@?UiQW ** i T*@? @| W |@!i |@| |L Mi ? _i ULhtiQW |?!
|@| |i @?tih t ?L<( @?_ W ** _iui?_ @ 4L?t| TLt|L?
W |?! |@| 4U Lu |i ?|@* T*@tM*|) Lu T*h@*t4 ? |t Ui?|h@* U@ti
@htit uhL4 @ UL?utL? Mi|ii? |i @hLt ti?tit Lu |i ^it|L? Ai €ht| |LTU
L? |i @}i?_@ tc |ihiuLhic @? @TThLTh@|i _t@4M}@|L? ?i Lu |i 4TLh|@?|
?L|L?t |@| hi^hit U*@h€U@|L? t |@| Lu h@*h) Mi|ii? *L}Ut 6Lh T*h@*t4
@htit ? @ tihLt uLh4 i? |ihi t tU @ h@*h)c @?_ i @hi U@**i_ TL? |L
@__U@|i @? ic ? tU UhU4t|@?Uitc _iU_i uLh 4Lhi |@? L?i U@?__@|iq
Ai ?L|L? Lu h@*h) ** |ihiuLhi Mi L?i Lu Lh UL?Uih?t
 _tUttL? Lu |iti tti ? |i €ht| 4@? T@h| Lu |i T@Tih ** U*i@h |i
}hL?_ uLh UL?t_ih?} tihLt LMiU|L?t |L 4L?t4c U i ** _L ? |i
Dq h{fhoohqw suholplqdu| glvfxvvlrq ri wkh lvvxh fdq eh irxqg lq Kddfn +4<:;,/ fk1451 Rqh
"
vkrxog qrwh/ dw wkh vwduw/ wkdw soxudolvp lv wr eh glvwlqjxlvhg iurp uhodwlylvp 1 Uhodwlylvp

htxdov soxudolvp soxv wkh fodlp wkdw hdfk ri wkh soxudolw| lv/ lq vrph uhohydqw vhqvh/ htxdoo|

jrrg1 Soxudolvwv vrphwlphv vdlo yhu| forvh wr wkh uhodwlylvw zlqg wkrxjk= cWkhuh duh glhuhqw/

htxdoo| jrrg zd|v ri 111^jlylqj dq dffrxqw ri ydolglw|`> wkh| duh glhuhqw/ htxdoo| jrrg orjlfv*1

+Ehdoo dqg Uhvwdoo +4<<;,/ s18> lwdolfv ruljlqdo1,


tiUL?_ At ** *i@i @ ui Lh_t |L Mi t@_ @ML| ?_U|i ?uihi?Ui ? |i
€?@* Mhiu tiU|L?

2 5L4i @tU #t|?U|L?t

2 hi @?_ TT*i_ wL}U
wi| 4ic uLh @ t|@h|c _t|?}t Mi|ii? Thi @?_ @TT*i_ *L}U W ** i T*@? @|
W 4i@? M) @? @?@*L}) | }iL4i|h)2 W| t ?L @? ?UL?|i?|Lt u@U| |@| |ihi
@hi 4@?) Thi }iL4i|hitG ,U*_i@?c +i4@??@?c tTihU@*c i|U ,@U t @ Tih
uiU|*) }LL_ 4@|i4@|U@* t|hU|hic @?_ U@? Mi uLh4*@|i_ @t @? @ L4 t)t|i4c
| t|@?_@h_ 4L_i*tc i|U Aihi t ?L ^it|L? Lu h@*h) Mi|ii? }iL4i|hit @|
|t *ii* Ai ^it|L? Lu h@*h) LUUht i? L?i @TT*it }iL4i|hit uLh tL4i
ThTLtic t@) |L ThL_i @? @UUL?| Lu |i T)tU@* }iL4i|h) Lu |i ULt4Lt Ai?
|i ^it|L? Lu U }iL4i|h) t h}| 4t| Mi u@Ui_
W? |i t@4i @)c |ihi @hi 4@?) Thi *L}Ut W i?4ih@|i_ tiih@* Lu |iti
@MLi ,@U t @ i**_i€?i_ 4@|i4@|U@* t|hU|hi | @ ThLLu|iLh)c 4L_i*
|iLh)c i|U Aihi t ?L ^it|L? Lu h@*h) Mi|ii? |i4 @| |t *ii* At
U@? LUUh L?*) i? L?i hi^hit @ *L}U uLh @TT*U@|L? |L tL4i i?_ Ai? |i
^it|L? Lu U *L}U t h}| @htit
Wu L?i t @t!?} @ML| Thi *L}Utc |i?c T*h@*t4 t ?UL?|i?|Lt*) ULhhiU|
*h@*|) t @? tti Lu tMt|@?Ui L?*) u L?i t @t!?} @ML| @TT*i_ *L}Ut W?
|t U@tic |ihi t |i TL|i?|@* uLh h@*h)c @?_ i|ih L?i tL*_ Mi @ 4L?t|
Lh @ T*h@*t| @ML| |t h@*h) t @ ^it|L? |@| 4t| Mi u@Ui_

22 AiLhi|U@* *h@*t4

wi| t |h?c |i?c |L @TT*i_ *L}Ut Ai €ht| |?} |L ?L|i ihi t |@| Thi
*L}Ut U@? Mi @TT*i_ uLh 4@?) ThTLtitc tU @t t4T*u)?} i*iU|hL?U UhU|tc
Lh @?@*)t?} Uih|@? }h@44@|U@* t|hU|hit ?_ @}@?c | t U*i@h @?_ ?UL?
|i?|Lt |@| _gihi?| Thi *L}Ut 4@) Mi @TThLTh@|i uLh i@U @TT*U@|L? W?
|i |L i @4T*it }i?c uLh i @4T*ic |i @TThLTh@|i *L}Ut @hi LL*i@? *L}U @?_
|i w@4Mi! U@*U*t `i ** @i uh|ih i @4T*itc U*Ltih |L L4ic *@|ih *
h@*|) tc |i?c @? ?|ihit|?} tti L?*) i? i @i L?i T@h|U*@h @TT*U@|L?
? 4?_
6 c |i?c L? tL4i L?i @TT*U@|L?  Thi *L}U t @TT*i_ M) ?|ihThi|?} |
? tL4i @) Lh L|ih W| |i? MiUL4it @ |iLh) Lu L |i _L4@? ? U |
t ?|ihThi|i_ Mi@it( t| @t @ Thi }iL4i|h)c i? ?|ihThi|i_ @t @ T)tU@*
Zklfk lv dsshdohg wr e| pdq| sduwlhv lq wkh ghedwh1 Vhh/ h1j1/ gd Frvwd +4<<:,/ Ehdoo dqg
#
Uhvwdoo +4<<;,1 Wkh dqdorj| lv glvfxvvhg lq ghwdlo lq Sulhvw +4<<d,1
Wkh Odpehn fdofxoxv lv d vxe0vwuxfwxudo orjlf zlwk d fohdu dssolfdwlrq wr judppdwlfdo
$
fdwhjrulhv1
2
}iL4i|h)c t @ |iLh) @ML| tT@Ui W? tU @ t|@|L? |ihi 4@) i** Mi _tT|it
@ML| U |iLh) t ULhhiU| At @t Uih|@?*) @TTi?i_ ? }iL4i|h) W| @*tL
@TTi?t ? *L}Uc @t i t@** @i tiih@* LUU@tL?t |L LMtihi Mi*L
5U _tT|it @hi |L Mi hitL*i_ ? *L}Uc @t ? }iL4i|h) @?_ i*tiihic M)
|i t@* Uh|ih@ Lu |iLhi|U@* i@*@|L?c tU @t @_i^@U) |L |i _@|@c @?_
|iLhi|U@* h|itc tU @t t4T*U|)c ?|)c ?L @_ LU?ittc i|U `i _L ?L| ?ii_
|L }L ?|L |i _i|@*t ihi Ai Thiti?| hi*i@?Ui Lu @** |t t |@| i @i |i
tLhUi Lu @?L|ih !?_ Lu T*h@*t4 Bi? @ € i_ @TT*U@|L? |L tL4i _L4@?c
|ihi 4@) Mi 4@?) _gihi?| @TT*i_ *L}Ut U UL?t|||i |iLhit @ML| |i
Mi@Lh Lu |@| _L4@?Q@?_ ULhhitTL?_?}*)c _tT|it @ML| U |iLh) t
h}| W ** U@** |tc uLh @?| Lu @ Mi||ih |ih4c |iLhi|U@* T*h@*t4

2 Ai @?L?U@* TT*U@|L? Lu wL}U

wi| t ?L |h? |L |i 4Lt| 4TLh|@?| @?_ |h@_|L?@* @TT*U@|L? Lu @ Thi *L}Uc
@| 4}| Mi U@**i_ |t U@?L?U@* @TT*U@|L?G |i @TT*U@|L? Lu @ *L}U ? |i
@?@*)tt Lu hi@tL??}c U @t @*tL |h@_|L?@**) U@**i_ *L}U<c Lu ULhti Et|
@t }iL4i|h)< @t ti_ @4M}Lt*) MiuLhi ,U*_i@? }iL4i|h) @?_ |t U@?L?U@*
@TT*U@|L? ihi _t|?}ti_c |L _itUhMi ML| Ai Ui?|h@* ThTLti Lu @?
@?@*)tt Lu hi@tL??} t |L _i|ih4?i @| uL**Lt uhL4 @|Q@| Thi4tit
tTTLh| @| UL?U*tL?tQ@?_ ) ? @h}4i?| ihi |t tc ? u@U|c |i
U@ti 4@) Mi U@**i_ @*_ W| t |h@_|L?@* |L _t|?}t Mi|ii? |L ?L|L?t Lu
@*_|)c _i_U|i @?_ ?_U|i 5L 44i_@|i*) | L*_ @TTi@h |@| i @i
@ T*h@*t4 ihi t |L i|ih |t t ?_ii_ |i U@tic W ** hi|h? @| |i i?_
Lu |t itt@) 6Lh 4Lt| Lu |t itt@) W ** uLUt t| L? _i_U|i @*_|)
iuLhi i U@? _tUtt |i tti Lu T*h@*|) uLh |t @TT*U@|L?c i ?ii_ |L
*LL! 4Lhi U*Lti*) @| L Thi *L}Ut @hi @TT*i_ ? @? @?@*)tt Lu hi@tL??}A
W? |i €ht| T*@Uic i hi@tL? ? |i ih?@U*@h `i it|@M*t M) LMtih@|L?
|@| @ T*@?i| 4Lit ? @ Uih|@? @)c @?_ t |L !?L u |i _itUhT|L? Lu
|t |h@iU|Lh) uL**Lt uhL4 Lh |iLh) Lu 4L|L?( Lh i ?uih @| L*_ Mi |i
U@ti u |i |*ih __ |c |L tii i|ih |iti UL?ti^i?Uit _Lc ? u@U|c LM|@?
hi4tit @?_ UL?U*tL?t @hi uLh4*@|i_ ? @ ?@|h@* *@?}@}i ) @** 4i@?tc
|t 4@) Mi @ ?@|h@* *@?}@}i @}4i?|i_ | |iU?U@* LU@M*@h)c tU @t
|@| Lu 4@|i4@|Ut Ai *@?}@}i i4T*L)i_c |L}c t t|** |i *@?}@}i Lu ti
@?_ UL44?U@|L?
hi *L}Utc @| *i@t| @t t|@?_@h_*) UL?Uii_c _L ?L| UL?Uih? |i ih?@U*@h
@| @**c M| @hi ULUi_ ? |ih4t Lu uLh4@* *@?}@}it  _i€?|L? Lu @*_|) t
ThL_i_ uLh ?uihi?Uit i Thitti_ ? L?i Lu |iti TT*)?} |t |L ThL_i @? @U
UL?| Lu @*_|) uLh |i ih?@U*@hc @t ? |i @TT*U@|L? Lu @?) Thi 4@|i4@|U@*
t|hU|hic hi^hit @? ?|ihThi|@|L? ?_ ? |i U@ti Lu *L}Uc |i ?|ihThi|@|L?
%Wkh wrslf lv glvfxvvhg dw juhdwhu ohqjwk lq Sulhvw +4<<d,/ vhfwlrq 43/ dqg frqfhuqlqj qhjd0
wlrq/ lq sduwlfxodu/ lq Sulhvw +4<<<,/ vhfwlrqv 5/ 61

t ^|i *|ih@**) tLG @ |h@?t*@|L? ThLUi_hi Mi|ii? |i uLh4@* *@?}@}i ? ^it
|L? @?_ |i ih?@U*@h 5U @ ThLUi_hi t h@hi*) @h|U*@|i_ @| }hi@| *i?}| ?
*L}U |i |t +@|ihc t|_i?|t @hi }i? ?|t @ML| |hi@|?} Lh< @t b E4Lt| Lu |i
|4ic i|Uc @?_ |i? ti| *LLti L? @ M?U Lu i ihUtitc |hL} U |i) _i
i*LT ThLUi_h@* !?L*i_}i | }i? tU @ |h@?t*@|L? ThLUi_hic @ Thi *L}U
ThL_it @? @UUL?| Lu @*_|) uLh ih?@U*@h ?uihi?Uit  ih?@U*@h ?uihi?Ui
t @*_ g |t |h@?t*@|L? ?|L |i uLh4@* *@?}@}i t @*_ ? |i Thi *L}U
Ai hit*|c 4LhiLihc Lu|i? ThL_Uit _t@}hii4i?| UULh_?} |L tL4i *L}Utc
|ihi t @? ?€?|_i Lu Th4it< uL**Lt uhL4 | t ?L| |i U@ti |@| |ihi t ?L|
@? ?€?|_i Lu Th4it<( @UULh_?} |L L|ihtc | _Lit ?L| UULh_?} |L tL4i
*L}Utc |i t!) t }hii?< uL**Lt uhL4 |i *@h ti?|i?Ui t ML| |hi @?_ u@*ti<(
@UULh_?} |L L|ihtc | _Lit ?L| 5U _t@}hii4i?|t 4i@? |@| i U*i@h*) @i
@ U@ti Lu |iLhi|U@* T*h@*t4 Wt |ihi @ 4Lhi tihLt !?_ Lu T*h@*t4 ihiq
AL @__hitt |t ^it|L?c *i| t |h? |L @UUL?|t Lu @*_|) uLh uLh4@* *@?}@}it

2e V@*_|)
Aihi t @ T*h@*|) Lu uLh4@* *@?}@}it i4T*L)i_ ? *L}U W @4 ?L| |@*!?} ihi
Lu |i u@U| |@| _gihi?| t)4ML*t @hi ti_ ? _gihi?| *@?}@}it Ai u@U| |@|
=< t ti_ uLh ?i}@|L? ? L?i *@?}@}ic *t| < t ti_ ? @?L|ihc t ?i|ih
ihi ?Lh |ihiG @t *L?} @t i@U T*@)t |i hL*i Lu ih?@U*@h ?i}@|L? @UULh_?}
|L |i @TThLTh@|i |h@?t*@|L? 4@?@*c |i |L @hic ? igiU|c |i t@4i t)4ML*
+@|ihc @| t 4TLh|@?| t |@| L?i *@?}@}i 4@) *@U! @ t)4ML*c ? |t ti?tic
|@| @?L|ih @t Atc @ 4L_@* *@?}@}i UL?|@?t 4L_@* LTih@|Lhtc U @?
i |i?tL?@* *@?}@}i *@U!t 5|hU|*) tTi@!?}c |i?c |i @UUL?|t Lu @*_|) uLh
|L tU *@?}@}it 4t| Mi _gihi?|c @?_ i @i @ T*h@*t4 | |tc @}@?c
t ?L| @ ih) ?|ihit|?} T*h@*t4 6Lh @t u@h @t |i UL44L? ti| Lu t)4ML*t }Litc
|i |L @UUL?|t 4@) Mi ? TihuiU| @}hii4i?|( | t t4T*) |@| L?i ELh i@U
i |i?_t |i L|ih ? tL4i _hiU|L?
Bi?c |i?c @ uLh4@* *@?}@}ic @?_ @ |h@?t*@|L? ThLUi_hi Mi|ii? | @?_
|i ih?@U*@hc @| tL*_ @ uLh4@* |iLh) Lu @*_|) Mi *!iq W |@!i |i @?tih
|L Mi itti?|@**) @t uL**Lt, `i? i hi@tL?c i hi@tL? @ML| @hLt t|@|L?t
Lh t|@|i Lu @g@ht Aiti 4@) Mi @U|@* Lh )TL|i|U@* `i hi@tL? |L it|@M*t
@| L*_t ? |iti t|@|L?t }i? @| i !?Lc Lh @tt4ic @ML| |i4 W
** U@** |t |h|Thitih@|L? EuLh@h_c5 |L} | t ?L| @U|@**) |h| |@|
t ? ^it|L? ?*itt |i t|@|L? i @hi hi@tL??} @ML| t |ti*u @U|@* Ai
TL?| Lu _i_U|L?c |i?c t |L }i t @ ti| Lu U@?L?t |@| @hi }@h@?|ii_ |L
Thitihi |h| ? |t ti?ti  @*_ ?uihi?Ui t |ihiuLhi L?i tU |@| ? @** |i
t|@|L?t ihi |i Thi4tit L*_c |i UL?U*tL? L*_t
&Wkh dqvzhu lv glvfxvvhg dqg ghihqghg lq Sulhvw +4<<e,1
'Frqyhuvho|/ zh pd| uhdvrq wr hvwdeolvk zkdw idlov wr krog lq d vlwxdwlrq/ jlyhq zkdw zh
nqrz/ ru dvvxph/ derxw zkdw idlov wr krog lq lw1 Wklv lv xqwuxwk0suhvhuydwlrq edfnzdugv1

e
 At @?tih tc Lu ULhtic ?L|?} 4Lhi |@? @ }it|hi ? |i _hiU|L? Lu
@? @UUL?| Lu @*_|) U hi4@?t |L Mi _L?i M) @) Lu tTi**?} L| @|
t|@|L?t |ihi @hic @?_ @| | t |L L*_ ? |i4 ?_ |ihi @hi Uih|@?*) _gih
i?| TLttM*|it ihiG @UULh_?} |L T@h@UL?tt|i?| ti4@?|Utc M| ?L| U*@ttU@* Lh
?||L?t| ti4@?|Utc |ihi @hi ?UL?tt|i?| t|@|L?t UULh_?} |L ?||L?
t| ti4@?|Ut E@?_ tL4i T@h@UL?tt|i?| ti4@?|Utc M| ?L| U*@ttU@* ti4@?|Ut
E@?_ tL4i L|ih T@h@UL?tt|i?| ti4@?|Utc |i _i€?|L? Lu |h| ? @ t|@|L?
hi^hit |i |h| UL?_|L?t Lu ?i}@|L? |L 4@!i hiuihi?Ui |L 4Lhi |@? L?i TLt
tM*i Lh*_ Aihi 4@) |ihiuLhi Mi _gihi?| it L? L |L €** ? |i _i|@*t
hi^hi_ | |i u@4*@h _tT|it @ML| |tc tU @t |i ?||L?t| Uh|^i
Lu U*@ttU@* *L}Uc Lh |i _@*i|it| Uh|^i Lu i T*Lti *L}Utc L*_ tii4 |L Mi
U@tit Lu |iLhi|U@* T*h@*t4 Wt |ihi @ 4Lhi tihLt !?_ Lu T*h@*t4 ihiq 5L
u@hc i @i ?L hi@tL? |L Mi*ii tL

 _LU@|it Lu *h@*t4
 #L4@? V@h@|L?
5L *i| t |h? |L tL4i TLttM*i hi@tL?t Aiti @i Mii? @_LU@|i_ M) @ ?4Mih
Lu TiLT*ic @?_ i ** *LL! @| t  Ai €ht| t ThL_i_ M) _@ Lt|@ Ebb.. #@
Lt|@<t 4@Lh @h}4i?| uLh T*h@*t4 t |L |i igiU| |@| hi@tL??} @ML| _gih
i?| !?_t Lu |?}t 4@) hi^hi _gihi?| *L}Ut Ai !?_t ? ^it|L? @hi !?_t
*!i 4@UhLLMiU|tc ^@?|4 LMiU|tc T*@|L?U LMiU|tc 4i?|@* UL?t|hU|L?tc i|U
`@| |L t@) @ML| |t _iTi?_t L? Lc i @U|*)c | t i?t@}i_ |@| *L}U **
@h)
?i |?} |@| _@ Lt|@ i?t@}it t |@| _gihi?| !?_t Lu LMiU|t @i _u
uihi?| ThLTih|it Atc uLh i @4T*ic i 4LL|t |i TLttM*|) |@| ^@?|4 LM
iU|t _L ?L| @i |i ThLTih|) Lu ti*u_i?||)c U 4@UhLLMiU|t @i Oi?Uic
4UhLLMiU|t hi^hi @ ?L?U*@ttU@* *L}U Lu _i?||)c L?i ihi ;% % ' % t
@Mti?|
W? hitTL?ti |L |tc |i LMLt 4L?t| hiT*) t |@| t?Ui @*_|) t |h|
Thitih@|L? ? @** t|@|L?tc u |ihi @hi t|@|L?t ? U LMiU|t 4@) ?L| Mi
ti*u_i?|U@*c |i? ti*u_i?||) t ?L| @ *L}U@* *@ @| @** At _Lit ?L| 4i@?
|@| i? hi@tL??} @ML|c i}c 4@UhLLMiU|t L?i 4@) ?L| ti |i *@c |L}
W| t t| @ RUL?|?}i?| ThLTih|) Lu Uih|@? _L4@?tc @?_ 4@) |t Mi ?L!i_
i? hi@tL??} @ML| |i4 W? @ t4*@h @)c |i ?||L?t| 4@) ?L!i |i *@
Lu i U*_i_ 4__*i i? hi@tL??} @ML| €?|i ELh @| *i@t| _iU_@M*i _L4@?tG
|tc T*t ?||L?t| *L}Uc }it U*@ttU@* *L}U | |i ?||L?t| @t ?L|
U@?}i_ *L}U@* @**i}@?Uit W| t t4T*) |@| U*@ttU@* @*_|) U@? Mi hiULihi_
i?|)4i4@|U@**)c }i? |i i |h@ _L4@?tTiU€U Thi4tit
:D uhylhz ri wklv lq Hqjolvk/ zklfk grfxphqwv wkh fodlpv dwwulexwhg wr gd Frvwd lq zkdw
iroorzv/ fdq eh irxqg lq Sulhvw +4<<f,1

D
 #@ Lt|@<t T*h@*t4 t 4Lhi h@_U@* |@? W @i tL u@h ?_U@|i_c |L} Oi
i?t@}it ?L| L?*) |@| LMiU|t Lu _gihi?| !?_t 4@) @i _gihi?| *L}U@* ThLT
ih|itc M| |@| _gihi?| *L}U@* LTih@|Lht 4@) @*tL ?ii_ |L Mi ti_ ? hi@tL??}
@ML| _gihi?| !?_t Lu LMiU|t Atc uLh i @4T*ic U*@ttU@* ?i}@|L? t @TThL
Th@|i uLh _i@*?} | T*@|L?U LMiU|tc @?_ ?||L?t| ?i}@|L? t @TThLTh@|i
uLh _i@*?} | 4i?|@* UL?t|hU|L?t
|c |t U@??L| Mi h}| *@ttU@* @?_ ?||L?t| UL??iU|it @i _gihi?|
4i@??}t EW?_ii_c tL4i ?||L?t|tc tU @t #44i||c ii? U*@4 |@| U*@t
tU@* UL??iU|it @i ?L 4i@??} @| @** Atc |@!i ?i}@|L? @t @? i @4T*i
*@ttU@* @?_ ?||L?t| ?i}@|L?t @i _gihi?| |h| UL?_|L?tH | _gih
i?Ui ? |h| UL?_|L?t i?|@*t _gihi?Ui ? 4i@??} Oi?Uic |i |L UL??iU|it
@i _gihi?| 4i@??}tb Lc i|ih ih?@U*@h ?i}@|L? t @4M}Lt Lh | t
?L| Wu | t ?L|c |i?c t?Ui |i _gihi?| |iLhit @||hM|i | _gihi?| 4i@?
?}tc |i) U@??L| ML| Mi h}| `i @i @ t4T*i |iLhi|U@* T*h@*t4 Ai
L|ih TLttM*|) t |@| ih?@U*@h ?i}@|L? t @4M}Lt Atc | 4@) Mi @h
}i_ |@| ih?@U*@h ?i}@|L? tL4i|4it 4i@?t U*@ttU@* ?i}@|L? @?_ tL4i|4it
4i@?t ?||L?t| ?i}@|L? | u |t ihi h}|c i L*_ @i |L *i}|4@|i
4i@??}t Lu ?i}@|L?c @?_ |i ULhhiU| @) |L |hi@| |t uLh4@**) L*_ Mi |L @i
|L ULhhitTL?_?} ?i}@|L? t}?t ? |i uLh4@* *@?}@}ic |i |h@?t*@|L? 4@?@*
|i**?} t L |L _t@4M}@|i i? |h@?t*@|?} ?|L uLh4@*iti W? i @U|*) |t
@)c | t Lu|i? @h}i_ |@| |i ,?}*t UL?_|L?@* t @4M}Ltc Mi|ii? |i
tM?U|i @?_ ?_U@|i At _Lit ?L| U@ti t |L U@?}i *L}Utc i t4T*)
@i @ uLh4@* *@?}@}i | |L UL?_|L?@* t)4ML*tc t@)  @?_ :c @?_ ti ML|
At t T*h@*t4 ? @ ti?tic M| |i ti?ti t t| L?i Lu @4M}|)
W? u@U|c W tii ?L UL}i?| hi@tL? |L tTTLti |@| ?i}@|L? t @4M}Lt ? |t
ti?tif W?_ii_c ?i}@|L? U@??L| @i _gihi?| 4i@??}t i? hi@tL??} @ML|
_gihi?| !?_t Lu |?}t At t MiU@ti i U@? hi@tL? @ML| _gihi?| !?_t
t4*|@?iLt*) `i U@?c uLh i @4T*ic hi@tL? uhL4 |i U*@4 |@| | t ?L| |i
U@ti |@| @ @?_ K @i tL4i T@h|U*@h ThLTih|) ? UL44L?c ihi @ @?_ K @hi Lu
_gihi?| !?_t LhiLihc |ihi @hi L|ih hi@tL?t @t |L ) ih?@U*@h ?i}@|L?
U@??L| Mi @4M}Lt Mi|ii? ?||L?t| @?_ U*@ttU@* ?i}@|L? 6Lh u | ihic
@t W @i @h}i_c i UL*_ @i |L uLh4@* ?i}@|L?t | | t i** !?L? |@| ?
|i Thiti?Ui Lu U*@ttU@* ?i}@|L?c 4@?) L|ih 4TLh|@?| ?||L?t| _t|?U|L?t
UL**@Tti 6Lh i @4T*ic |i ?||L?t| UL?_|L?@* UL**@Ttit ?|L |i U*@ttU@*
UL?_|L?@*
u ULhtic @t W @i @*hi@_) ?L|i_c |i ?||L?t| *L}U@? U@?c ? igiU|c ti
|i u** uLhUi Lu U*@ttU@* @h}4i?| i? hi@tL??} @ML| €?|i _L4@?t | |t
t ?L| MiU@ti ?i}@|L? @t U@?}i_ |t 4i@??} W| t MiU@ti |i) @hi i?||*i_
; Lqwxlwlrqlvw frqqhfwlyhv duh riwhq jlyhq surydelolw| frqglwlrqv/ exw vlqfh dq lqwxlwlrqlvw/ lq
hhfw/ lghqwlhv wuxwk dqg surydelolw|/ wkhvh duh wuxwk frqglwlrqv1
< Rqh pljkw fkdoohqjh wklv iru uhdvrqv wkdw zh zloo frph wr lq 618/ dqg L zloo ghdo zlwk wkhuh1
43 Wkhuh duh vrph uhdvrqv dv wr zk| rqh pljkw vxssrvh wkdw lw lv1 L zloo ghdo zlwk wkhvh lq
wkh qh{w vhfwlrq1

S
|L @hLt i |h@ Thi4titc tU @t |i *@ Lu i U*_i_ 4__*i

2 L?|i | #iTi?_i?Ui
Ai ?i | ?L|@M*i @_LU@|i Lu T*h@*t4 |@| i *LL! @| t @|i?t EbHDc Ebbf
UULh_?} |L 4c _gihi?| *L}Ut @hi hi^hi_c ?L| uLh _gihi?| _L4@?tc M| ?
_gihi?| UL?|i |tc ihi @ UL?|i | tc ? @ ?|ti**c @ ThLM*i4tL*?} t|@|L?
AL Lu @|i?t< @h}4i?|t uLh T*h@*t4 @hi T@h|U*@h*) ?L|@M*i
Ai €ht|c }i? 4@?*) ? Ebbfc |@!it | uLh }h@?|i_ |@| @ T@h@UL?tt|i?|
*L}U t ULhhiU| ? tL4i UL?|i |tc M| @h}it |@| | U@??L| Mi ULhhiU| ? L|iht
Ei}c @ 4i|@|iLhi|U L?ic uLh U U*@ttU@* *L}U t hi^hi_ Oi?Uic T*h@*t4
Lc t| @t @? ?||L?t| 4@) ti @| @4L?|t |L U*@ttU@* *L}U i? hi@tL?
?} @ML| €?|i t|@|L?tc tL @ T@h@UL?tt|i?| *L}U@? 4@) ti @| @4L?|t
|L U*@ttU@* *L}U }i? @TThLTh@|i ?uLh4@|L? @ML| |i _L4@? 6Lh i @4T*ic
tUi?| ?uLh4@|L? t |@| uLh @** kc Ek a =k $ Bc ihi $ t @? @TThLTh@|i
_i|@U@M*i UL?_|L?@*c @?_ B t @ *L}U@* UL?t|@?| |@| i?|@*t iih)|?} At
i |h@ ?uLh4@|L?c |L}i|ih | |i M@ti T@h@UL?tt|i?| *L}Uc }i?ih@|it U*@ttU@*
*L}UQQ
| |t hiT*) 4}| ?L| t@|tu) @|i?tc uLh |i uL**L?} hi@tL? t W @i
t|hitti_c |i 4i@??} Lu @ *L}U@* LTih@|Lhc tU @t ?i}@|L?c _Lit ?L| U@?}i
t4T*) ? h|i Lu |i i |h@ ?uLh4@|L? |c @|i?t @h}itc @ T@h@UL?tt|i?|
?i}@|L? t| U@??L| i Thitt Uih|@? |?}t |@| ?ii_ |L Mi i Thitti_ ? |@*!?}
@ML| tU t|@|L?t W? T@h|U*@hc =k U@??L| i Thitt |i u@U| |@| k t hiiU|i_
`@| |L t@) @ML| |t @h}4i?| _iTi?_t L? L L?i ?|ihThi|t hiiU|L?<c U
4@)c ? u@U|c 4i@? tiih@* _gihi?| |?}t W ** ?L| }L ?|L 4@?) _i|@*t ihic
M| |i 4@Lh ti?ti Lu hiiU|L? |@| @|i?t @t ? 4?_ t |@| |L hiiU| k t |L
UL44| L?iti*u |L tL4i|?}c Uc ? UL??U|L? | kc ThL_Uit |h@*|) ET
222 | @ T@h@UL?tt|i?| *L}U@? U@? _L t| |@|c M) i?_Lht?} Eka=k $ BQ2
Ai tiUL?_ Lu @|i?t< @h}4i?|t E}i? 4@?*) ? EbHD t |@|c ?L||
t|@?_?} |i @MLic _gihi?| UL?|i |t hit*| ? _gihi?| 4i@??}t uLh *L}U@* LT
ih@|Lhtc @?_ i?Ui _i*ih _gihi?| *L}Ut ET Hu Ai @h}4i?| uLh 4i@??}
@h@?Ui t @ u@4*@h L?ic Lu @ !?_ i4T*L)i_ M) k? @?_ 6i)ih@Mi?_ ? |i
T*LtLT) Lu tUi?Ui Ai €ht| Thi4ti t |@| @| t @UUiT|i_ 4@) @h) uhL4
UL?|i | |L UL?|i | Ai tiUL?_ t |@| @| t @UUiT|i_ ET@h|@**) _i|ih4?it
|i 4i@??}t Lu |i Lh_t ?L*i_ W| uL**Lt uhL4 |iti |@| 4i@??}t U@?}i
uhL4 UL?|i | |L UL?|i |
L L?i 4}| t@) @ }LL_ _i@* @ML| |t @h}4i?|c M| |t Ui?|h@* u@*?}
t |@| @ U@?}i Lu @| t @UUiT|i_ _Lit ?L| E?iUitt@h*) hit*| ? @ U@?}i Lu
4i@??} `i? @ ht|@? *Ltit |ih Uih||_ic @?_ UL4it |L Mi*ii |@| BL_
"" Vhh Sulhvw +4<;:,/ ;181 Wkhuh duh ohvv euxwh irufh zd|v ri uhfryhulqj fodvvlfdo orjlf lq
frqvlvwhqw vlwxdwlrqv1 Vhh Sulhvw +4<<4,1
"# D ixoohu glvfxvvlrq ri wklv/ dqg ri wkh rwkhu uhohydqw vhqvhv ri uhmhfwlrq/ fdq eh irxqg lq
Sulhvw +4<<<,1

.
_Lit ?L| i t|c |i Lh_ BL_< @t ?L| U@?}i_ |t 4i@??} `@| |i) UL4i |L
Mi*ii t |i ih) LTTLt|i Lu @| |i) Mi*ii_ MiuLhi 54*@h*)c |i U*@ttU@*
*L}U@? Mi*iit |@| | t ?L| |i U@ti |@| | t ?L| |i U@ti |@| k i?|@*t k(
|i ?||L?t| Mi*iit L|ihti W| _Lit ?L| uL**L |@| | t ?L| |i U@ti |@|<
4i@?t tL4i|?} _gihi?| uLh |i |L Lu |i4 Wu | __c |i) L*_ ?L| Mi ?
_t@}hii4i?|c U |i) 4Lt| Uih|@?*) @hi W?||L?t| @?_ U*@ttU@* ?i}@|L?
_L 4i@? _gihi?| |?}t( @t W @i @h}i_c |i TL?| Lu _t@}hii4i?| Mi|ii?
|i |L *L}U@?t t ThiUti*) U Lu |Lti |L ?i}@|L?t | t |@| ULhhiU|*)
U@h@U|ihtit ih?@U*@h ?i}@|L?

 wL}U@* L?t|@?|t @?_ V@h@M*it

Ai ?i | |hii @h}4i?|t i ** *LL! @| @hi @** |L Mi uL?_ ? i@** @?_ +it|@**
EbbHc L }i @| tc Tih@Ttc |i 4Lt| tt|@?i_ _iui?Ui Lu T*h@*t4 :+
i?_Lhti @? @UUL?| Lu @*_|) t4*@h |L |@| U W }@i ? 2e(e M| @h}i
uLh T*h@*t4c ?L?i |i *itt Ai |hii @h}4i?|t @hi @** |L |i igiU| |@| |i
_i|@*t Lu |i @UUL?| 4@) Mi €**i_ ? ? _gihi?|c i^@**) *i}|4@|ic @)t
:+<t €ht| @h}4i?| ThLUii_t @t uL**Lt Aihi t @ t|hL?} |h@_|L? ? *L}U
Lu |hi@|?} Uih|@? Lh_t ? Thi4tit @?_ UL?U*tL?t @t T@h@4i|iht At t
_L?i ? |i ti4@?|Ut Lu €ht| Lh_ih *L}Uc i}c ihi L?i |hi@|t Thi_U@|it @?_
UL?t|@?|t @t ti4@?|U@**) @h@M*i :+ LMtihi |@| |i @UUL?| Lu @*_|)
U@? Mi T@h@4i|ihti_ ? |t @) |L }i |i t@* 4L_i*|iLhi|U EA@ht!@?
@UUL?| Lu @*_|)D `@| @hi |i UL?ti^i?Uit Lu |tq  t4T*i i @4T*i
**t|h@|it L?t_ih |i ?uihi?UiG @ t hi_( i?Ui @ t UL*Lhi_ At t @*_
L? |i ?T@h@4i|ihti_ @UUL?| ?) t|@|L? ? U @ t hi_c | t UL*Lhi_
EU t ?L| |L t@) |@| |ihi 4}| ?L| Mi ?UL?tt|i?| t|@|L?tc ? U |
t ?L| UL*Lhi_ |LL | |i ?uihi?Ui t ?L| @*_ @UULh_?} |L @ T@h@4i|ihti_
_i€?|L? Lu @*_|)Q@| *i@t| u |i T@h@4i|iht ?U*_i Thi_U@|itQuLh | t Lu
|i uLh4G  @ c '@ `@| t @| tti ihi t |i ^it|L? Lu @| t|@|L?t @hi
|L Mi @_4||i_ ?|L Lh ti4@?|Ut hi i |L ?U*_ic ? Lh tiiTc t|@|L?t ?
U |?}t U@? Mi ? |i i |i?tL? Lu hi_< M| ?L| Lu UL*Lhi_<c i|Uc Lh @hi i
?L|q
Lc | t |hi |@| |i 4L_i*|iLhi|U UL?t|hU|L? U@? Mi _L?i ? i|ih
@)c T@h@4i|ihti_ Lh ?T@h@4i|ihti_c tL }?} _gihi?| ?L|L?t Lu @*_|)
| @t u@h @t W U@? tiic |t t t| @?L|ih U@ti Lu |iLhi|U@* T*h@*t4QLh @|
*i@t|c :+ ThL_i ?L hi@tL?t uLh |?!?} L|ihti Ai) t@) |@| |i) _L
?L| |?! | uh|u* |L _iM@|i U Lu d|i |L @UUL?|to t *L}U< ETb W
"$ Li wkh| phdq dq|wklqj dw doo/ zklfk/ dv L kdyh qrwhg/ pd| eh glvsxwhg1
"% Vlplodu/ exw qrw lghqwlfdo1 Wkh| wklqn ri vlwxdwlrqv dv wkrvh ri vlwxdwlrq
vhpdqwlfv1 Iru ph/
d vlwxdwlrq lv +uhsuhvhqwhg e|, d vwuxfwxuh ri wkh nlqg qrupdoo| wkrxjkw ri dv dq lqwhusuhwdwlrq
ri wkh odqjxdjh1
"& E)U dsshdu wr vxjjhvw wkdw lw lv rqo| wkh sdudpdwhulvhg dffrxqw wkdw fdq eh dssolhg wr
irupdo odqjxdjhv +s1:,> wklv lv fhuwdlqo| qrw wuxh1

H
@4 hi@**) ?L| thi @| |t 4i@?t W| Uih|@?*) U@??L| 4i@? |@| |ihi @hi
?L UL?t_ih@|L?t |@| 4}| Tiht@_i L?i |L @__U@|i uLh L?i |iLh) Lih |i
L|ihQS @?) Lu |i 4Lit ? |t |iLhi|U@* _tT|i @hic ? u@U|c i** !?L?
Ai ?uihi?Ui @ t hi_( i?Ui @ t UL*Lhi_< t Uih|@?*) Th4@ u@Ui @*_
Oi?Uic u |i T@h@4i|hU @UUL?| t |L thic |t @*_|) 4t| Mi i T*@?i_
@@) Ai t|@?_@h_ 4Li t |L U*@4 |@| |i ?uihi?Ui tc ? u@U|c ?@*_c M|
|@| | @TTi@ht |L Mi @*_ MiU@ti i UL?uti | | @ @*_ i?|)4i4ic |
tTThitti_ Thi4ti ** hi_ |?}t @hi UL*Lhi_<c |@!i? uLh }h@?|i_ | |t 4Li
t ?L| ih) T*@tM*i i? tUh|?ti_ 6Lh u tL4i|?} @ML| ** hi_ |?}t @hi
UL*Lhi_< }@i | |i TLih |L 4@!i @? i?|)4i4ic Lti tTThitti_ Thi4ti |
@tc @TTi@h @*_c |i? |i ?uihi?UiG 5?L t |i( i?Ui t?L t |i @?_
@** hi_ |?}t @hi UL*Lhi_< tL*_ i^@**) @TTi@h @*_QU | _Lit ?L|
Aihi @hi L|ih hi@tL?t uLh Mi?} _tt@|t€i_ | |i T@h@4i|hU @UUL?| 6Lh
i @4T*ic |i T@h@4i|ihti_ _i€?|L? Lu @*_|) ? igiU| @**Lt |i 4i@??}t
Lu tL4i Lh_tc M| ?L| L|ihtc |L @h) | i? i @t! @| uL**Lt uhL4
tL4i|?}<t Mi?} hi_c i @hi ?L| @t!?} @ML| @| 4}| Mi |i U@ti u hi_<
4i@?| tL4i|?} _gihi?| A@|<t t| U@?}?} |i tMiU| W| t itti?|@*c |i?c
|@| 4i@??} U@?}i t ?L| @**Li_Qii? Lu tL U@**i_ *L}U@* @h@M*it.
At t ?L T*@Ui |L Thti |i h@4€U@|L?t Lu |i _tT|i uh|ih Ai 4@?
TL?| uLh Thiti?| ThTLtit t t| |@| T@h@4i|ihti_ @*_|) t ?L| hi@* @*_|)
@| @**Qt| @ u@*ti |iLh) |ihiLuH At t ?L| |L t@) |@| |i T@h@4i|ihti_
?L|L? Lu @*_|) t @ ti*itt ?L|L? W| t t|** |hi |@| iih) T@h@4i|hU@**) @*_
?uihi?Ui t @*_ Oi?Uic @ UL?U*tL? |@| uL**Lt @UULh_?} |L tU @ ?L|L?c
t|** uL**Ltc @?_ |t 4@) i** @**L tc ? hi@tL??}c |L tL @| i ?ii_ |
|ihi t 4Lhi |L @*_|) |@? uLh4@* @*_|)

e *@ttit Lu 5|@|L?
:+<t ?i | @h}4i?| t |L |i igiU| |@| i U@? LM|@? i^@**) *i}|4@|i ?L|L?t
Lu *L}U@* UL?ti^i?Ui M) _i€??} @*_|) @t |h| Thitih@|L? Lih _gihi?|
"' E)U djuhh= cRqh pljkw qrz zrqghu= Lv wkhuh dq| edvlv xsrq zklfk wr fkrrvh ehwzhhq
wkhvh wzr dffrxqwvB Lv wkhuh dq| uhdvrq |rx pljkw suhihu rqh wr wkh rwkhuB Wkh dqvzhu lv d
uhvrxqglqj |hv1* +E)U/ s1;> lwdolfv ruljlqdo1,
": D wklug remhfwlrq wr wkh sdudphwulf dffrxqw lv wkdw li lw lv wr kdyh dq| fuhglelolw|/ wkh

glvwlqfwlrq ehwzhhq orjlfdo frqvwdqwv dqg orjlfdo yduldeohv kdv wr eh gudzdeoh lq vrph sulqflsohg

idvklrq/ dqg L grxew wkdw wkhuh lv dq| vxfk zd|1 Lw lv wuxh wkdw wkhuh lv/ lq sudfwlfh/ d glvwlqfwlrq

ri wklv nlqg kdqghg grzq wr xv e| wudglwlrq/ zklfk sxwv cru* dqg cqrw* rq rqh vlgh/ dqg cuhg*

dqg cfrorxuhg* rq wkh rwkhu1 Exw wklv/ lw vhhpv wr ph/ lv vlpso| dq klvwrulfdo frqwlqjhqf|1
4; Lw lv shukdsv zruwk qrwlqj wkdw lq wkh vwdqgdug vhpdqwlfv ri uvw rughu orjlf/ zh dvvljq

suhglfdwhv duelwudu| h{whqvlrqv1 Vrphwlphv wklv lv jorvvhg lqirupdoo| dv dvvljqlqj hdfk suhglfdwh

d phdqlqj1 Vrphwlphv/ rq wkh rwkhu kdqg/ dq lqwhusuhwdwlrq lv wkrxjkw ri dv uhsuhvhqwlqj d

_srvvleoh zruog%/ zkhuh wkh h{whqvlrq ri hdfk suhglfdwh/ zkrvh phdqlqj lv ghwhuplqhg lq rwkhu

zd|v/ lv dv dvvljqhg1 Wkhvh duh qrw wkh vdph/ dv vkrxog qrz eh fohdu1 Lw lv shukdsv wkh frqixvlrq

ri wkhvh wzr wklqjv wkdw ohqgv wkh sdudphwhulvhg dssurdfk vrph fuhglelolw|1

b
U*@ttit Lu t|@|L?t Atc u i hit|hU| Lhti*it |L UL?tt|i?| @?_ UL4T*i|i
_L4@?tc U*@ttU@* *L}U@* UL?ti^i?Ui ** hit*|( u i |@!i @ MhL@_ih U*@ttc |
** ?L| Wu i ?U*_i t|@|L?t | i4T|) _L4@?t i ** @i @ uhii *L}U(
L|ihti ?L| `i |ihiuLhi @i @ T*h@*|) Lu @*_|itG L?i uLh i@U @TThLTh@|i
U*@tt Lu t|@|L?tQ@?_ @** i^@**) *i}|4@|i ?L|L?t Lu @*_|)
Ai LMLt hiT*) |L |t @h}4i?| t |@| | t L?*) |h|Thitih@|L? Lih @**
t|@|L?t |@| tc t|hU|*) tTi@!?}c @*_|) ?i Lu |i TL?|t @ML| _i_U|i
*L}U t |@| | ** Lh! UL4i @| 4@)G i _L ?L| @i |L Lhh) @ML| @?)|?}
i UiT| |i Thi4tit t W @i @*hi@_) LMtihi_c |t t ?L| |L t@) |@| ? Th@U|Ui
L?i 4@) ?L| hi@tL? @t u L?i ihi t?} @ _gihi?|c t|hL?}ihc ?L|L? Lu @*_|)c
L?i @TThLTh@|i |L @ 4Lhi *4|i_ U*@tt Lu t|@|L?t | |t t ?L| MiU@ti L?i
@t U@?}i_ *L}U@* @**i}@?Uit( | t MiU@ti L?i t @**Li_ |L ?L!i UL?|?}i?|
ThLTih|it Lu |i _L4@? ? ^it|L?
 TLttM*i hiT*) ihiQ> t |@| |i U*@tt Lu t|@|L?t t tL *@h}i @?_ @hi}@|i_
|@| |ihi @hi ?L ?uihi?Uit |@| @hi |h| Thitih?} Lih @** Lu |i4c i UiT|c
TLttM*)c |i |h@* k c k Oi?Ui 4L?t4 t @ULt W @i ?iih tii? @?)
Tiht@ti @h}4i?| @t |L ) L?i tL*_ tTTLti |t |L Mi |i U@tic Liih
W| 4@) i** Mi |@| |i ?|ihtiU|L? Lu |i @*_ Th?UT*it ? @** Thi *L}Ut t
i4T|)c M| |t t Mit_i |i TL?| `i @hi ?L| |@*!?} @ML| Thi *L}Ut ihi(
i @hi |@*!?} @ML| @TT*i_ *L}Utc @?_ ?_ii_c *L}Ut @TT*i_ uLh L?i T@h|U*@h
ThTLti
LhiLihc W |?! | t| u@*ti |@| @** Th?UT*it Lu ?uihi?Ui u@* ? tL4i
t|@|L? 6Lh i @4T*ic @?) t|@|L? ? U @ UL??U|L? L*_tc |i UL??U|t
L*_c t4T*) ? h|i Lu |i 4i@??} Lu a @|h@**)c u L?i ihi @**Li_ |L @h)
|i 4i@??}t Lu Lh_t @t |i U*@tt Lu t|@|L?t t MhL@_i?i_c |i? |t L*_ ?L|
Mi |i U@ti | i? i @t! @ML| @| t |i U@ti ? t|@|L?t ihi |i t!)
t M*i @?_ |i t? t t??}c i @hi ?|ihit|i_ ? t| |@|G @**L?} @?_< |L
|@!i L? tL4i L|ih 4i@??} t Mit_i |i TL?| W| t Uih|@?*) LTi? |L tL4iL?i
|L U*@4 |@| @| W @i t| t@_ }i|t |i 4i@??} Lu @?_< hL?}c @?_ |@|
|i t|@?_@h_ |h| UL?_|L?t @hi ?L|c ? u@U|c _i*ihi_ M) |t 4i@??} A@| t
@ tMt|@?|@* ttic @?_ Uih|@?*) }it hti |L |iLhi|U@* T*h@*t4c M| | t ?L|
}ih4@?i ihi t *L?} @t 4i@??}t @hi € i_c L?i U@?<| @h) |i4 |L _tTLti Lu
@*_ ?uihi?Uit
Aihi t @?L|ih TLttM*i 4Li |@| 4}| Mi 4@_i @| |t TL?| `@|c
i @U|*)c t |i _t@}hii4i?| Mi|ii? |i 4L?t| @?_ |i T*h@*t| @ML| ihiq
Ai 4L?t| @UUiT|t |@| |ihi t @ ULhi Lu ?iht@**) ULhhiU| ?uihi?Uit( M| |t
4@) Mi @}4i?|i_ u i @hi hi@tL??} @ML| Uih|@? !?_t Lu t|@|L?t Ai
T*h@*t| L*_t |@| _gihi?| tLh|t Lu t|@|L?t hi^hi _gihi?| @*_|itc M|
4@) @UUiT|Q** @UUiT|c u |i @MLi @h}4i?| t ULhhiU|Q|@| |ihi t @ ULhi Lu
?uihi?Uit |@| @hi @UUiT|@M*i ? @** !?_t Lu t|@|L?t `@| t |i _gihi?Uiq
L?ic | 4}| Mi |L}| Ai u@U|t @hi @}hii_ TL? `@| t @| tti t L?*)
4< Rqh wkdw/ lq idfw/ E)U jlyh lq vhfwlrq 91

f
L |L _itUhMi |i4 B
| ii? |t _U!%h@MM| T*h@*t4 L*_ @TTi@h ?L| |L Mi ULhhiU| 5TTLti
|@| L?i t @ T*h@*t| Lu |i !?_ ? ^it|L? `i Lu|i? hi@tL? @ML| tL4i
t|@|L? Lu L|ih( U@** | r( tTTLti |@| r t ? _gihi?| U*@ttit Lu t|@|L?tc
t@)c gQ @?_ g  5L*_ L?i ti |i ?L|L? Lu @*_|) @TThLTh@|i uLh gQ Lh uLh
g q `i U@??L| }i |i @?tih ML|< ihi A@!i tL4i ?uihi?Ui |@| t @*_
? gQ M| ?L| g c k c qc @?_ tTTLti |@| i !?L ELh @tt4i k( @hi ic
Lh @hi i ?L| i?||*i_ |L @UUiT| qq ,|ih i @hi Lh i @hi ?L| Q  ?@|h@*
hiT*) t |@| i tL*_ ti |i ?L|L? Lu @*_|) @TThLTh@|i |L |i t4@**it| U*@tt
Lu t|@|L?t |@| r t ?( ? |t U@tic Thit4@M*)c gQ _ g  | u i tL*_c
?_ii_c @TT*) |i ?L|L? Lu @*_|) @TThLTh@|i |L |i t4@**it| U*@tt |@| r t ?c
|i? i tL*_ @TT*) |i ?L|L? @TThLTh@|i |L irj Atc |i @*_ ?uihi?Uit
@hi |Lti |@| @i @ Thi4ti u@*ti ? rc Lh Lti UL?U*tL? t |hi ? r W?
L|ih Lh_tc | t ?L T*h@*t4 |@| @t MiUL4i @ULt L|i L |t t ?L|
@ ThLM*i4 uLh |i 4L?t| 6Lh |i 4L?t|c i? hi@tL??} @ML| t|@|L? r i
@TT*) |i ?^i*) ULhhiU| *L}U `i @hic Lu ULhtic i?||*i_ |L ?L!i @?) L|ih
?uLh4@|L? i @i @ML| rc i?|)4i4@|U@**) | |@| t i?|hi*) @t | tL*_
Mi

D W?t|h4i?|@*t4
:+<t €?@* @h}4i?| t |@| i 4@) }i?ih@|i _gihi?| *L}Ut M) }?} |i |h|
UL?_|L?t Lu |i UL??iU|it ? _gihi?| @)t Atc uLh i @4T*ic i 4@) }i
i|ih ?||L?t| |h| UL?_|L?t Lh U*@ttU@* |h| UL?_|L?t Wu i _L |i
uLh4ihc |i hit*| t @ ?L|L? Lu @*_|) |@| t UL?t|hU|ic |@| tc |}|ih |@?
U*@ttU@* @*_|)c M| U | t TihuiU|*) *i}|4@|i |L ti uLh Uih|@? i?_t
Aihi @hi |L @tTiU|t Lu |t U*@4 |@| ?ii_ UL?Uih? t Ai €ht| @t ULihi_
itti?|@**) ?  Wu i }i _gihi?| |h| UL?_|L?t uLh |i UL??iU|itc i @hi
}?} |i uLh4@* UL??iU|it _gihi?| 4i@??}t `i? i @TT*) |i *L}Ut |L
ih?@U*@h hi@tL??} i @hic |ihiuLhic }?} _gihi?| |iLhit Lu |i 4i@??}t
Lu |i ih?@U*@h UL??iU|it `i @i @ U@ti Lu |iLhi|U@* T*h@*t4( @?_ |i
|iLhit U@??L| ML| Mi h}|QLh u |i) @hic i t4T*) @i @ U@ti Lu @4M}|)c
@t i @i @*hi@_) tii?
?i 4}| _tT|i |t @h}4i?| E@t +it|@** __ ? ULhhitTL?_i?Ui *@ttU@*
@?_ ?||L?t| UL??iU|it _L ?L| @i _gihi?| 4i@??}t Ah| UL?_|L?t
#! Wkh dujxphqw lv pdgh lq Sulhvw +4<<d,/ vhfw1 481
#" Uhvwdoo remhfwhg wr wklv lq fruuhvsrqghqfh/ dv iroorzv1 Hqwlwohphqw lv dpeljxrxv/ hdfk vhqvh
fruuhvsrqglqj wr rqh ri ydolglw|1 Vr rqh fdq eh hqwlwohg lq rqh vhqvh/ exw qrw dqrwkhu1 Qrz/
hqwlwohphqw fdq fhuwdlqo| eh dpeljxrxv1 Iru h{dpsoh/ rqh fdq eh hqwlwohg wr vrphwklqj xqghu
rqh ohjdo mxulvglfwlrq/ vd| d Ihghudo rqh/ exw qrw xqghu dqrwkhu/ vd| d Vwdwh rqh1 Exw wkh
fuxfldo txhvwlrq/ wkhq/ lv wkdw ri zklfk mxulvglfwlrq lv lq irufh lq wkh sduwlfxodu fdvh dw kdqg1
Zklfk rqh zloo suhydlo lq frxuwB Vlploduo| zlwk wkh fdvh ri orjlfdo hqwlwohphqw1 Zklfk orjlfdo
mxulvglfwlrq vkrxog lqirup p| hslvwhplf vwdwhB Dp L wr dgg  wr lw/ ru dp L qrwB Wkh pdwwhu
kdv wr eh vhwwohg rqh zd| ru wkh rwkhu1


@hi }i?ih@* @?_ ?uLh4 TT@hi?|*) _gihi?| |h| UL?_|L?t @hi t| tTiU@*
U@tit Atc uLh i @4T*ic |i |h| UL?_|L?t uLh |i UL??iU|it ? @ khT!i
?|ihThi|@|L? uLh ?||L?t| *L}U UL**@Tti ?|L U*@ttU@* UL?_|L?t @| RU*@ttU@*
Lh*_tc ?@4i*)c |Lti U @UUitt ?L Lh*_t L|ih |@? |i4ti*it `i _L ?L|c
|ihiuLhic @i UL??iU|it | _gihi?| 4i@??}t W| t t| |@| |i ?||L?t|
UL?|i?@?Uit 4Lhi t|@|L?t |@? |ih U*@ttU@* ULt?
Wu |t 4Li t h}|c |i? |t |h_ i @4T*i Lu T*h@*t4 hi_Uit |L |i Thi
Lt L?ic U W @i @*hi@_) _i@*| | | W _L ?L| |?! | t h}| 6Lh
@ _tT|i @ML| 4i@??}t U@? Mi U@ti_ L| t| @t 4U ? |ih4t Lu @| t|
@|L?t |ihi @hic @t ? |ih4t Lu |h| UL?_|L?t 6Lh i @4T*ic |L _i|ih4?i
i|ih | t T@h| Lu |i 4i@??} Lu |L tii< |@| |i i)it Mi i4T*L)i_c i 4}|
UL?t_ih i|ih |ihi @hi @?) E4@)Mi )TL|i|U@* t|@|L?t ihi tL4iL?i
UL*_ Mi _itUhMi_ @t tii?}c ii? |L} |i) @_ ?L Eu?U|L??} i)it ?i
L L*_t |@| tii?} ?L*it @?} i)it ** _i?) |i TLttM*|) Lu tU t|
@|L?t
, @U|*) |i t@4i t |hi Lu |i U@ti @| @?_ 6Lh tL4iL?i L |@!it U*@t
tU@* |h| UL?_|L?t |L }Lih? @? @UUL?| Lu |i UL??iU|itc t@) ?i}@|L?c uLh
i @4T*ic @| | 4i@?t |L t@) |@| =k L*_t ? @ t|@|L? t t| |@| k u@*t
|L L*_ |ihi W| uL**Lt |@| |ihi U@? Mi ?L t|@|L?t ihi ?i|ih k ?Lh
=k L*_t 5TTLtic uLh i @4T*ic |@| L?i |?!t Lu @ t|@|L? @t @ T@h| Lu @
TLttM*i Lh*_ LhiLihc tTTLti |@| i @i @ t|@|L? Lu U a t ?L|
@ T@h| W| uL**Lt |@| a t hi@_?}< t ?L| |hi Lu |@| t|@|L? 6Lh U*@ttU@*
?i}@|L?c | ** uL**L |@| a t ?L| hi@_?}< t |hi Lu |@| t|@|L? W| t ?L|
@? LT|L? |L t@) |@| ?i|ih Lu |iti |L t |hi Ai t|@|L? U@??L| Mi R?
UL4T*i|i t :+ |i4ti*it T| | ET2c |i U*@ttU@* @UUL?| Lu ?i}@|L?
u@*t uLh t|@|L?t< 
Ai tiUL?_ T@h| Lu :+<t U*@4 |@| i ?ii_ |L *LL! @| t |i U*@4 |@|c
ii? u L?i tc t@)c @ U*@ttU@* *L}U@?c L?i 4@) *i}|4@|i*) @UUiT| |i TL*U)
Lu hit|hU|?} L?i<t hi@tL??} |L |i ti Lu ?||L?t|U@**) @*_ ?uihi?Uitc @?_
tL hi@tL? UL?t|hU|i*)c uLh Uih|@? i?_t2e L |t TL*U) t Uih|@?*) ?L|
?||L?t4 6Lh ?||L?t4 t|€it 4@?) 4@|i4@|U@* Th?UT*it |@| @hi
U*@ttU@**) ?UL?tt|i?|c @?_ tL ?||L?t| 4@|i4@|Ut t ?L| @ ThLTih T@h| Lu
U*@ttU@* 4@|i4@|Ut i|ih t | @ TL*U) Lu hi@tL??} L?*) ? @UULh_@?Ui |
Th?UT*it |@| @hi UL?t|hU|i uhL4 @ U*@ttU@* TihtTiU|i 6Lh |t i |i?_t
?||L?t| *L}U 6Lh i @4T*ic | *i}|4@|it @h!L<t h?UT*i ? @h|4i|UG
E;%E b = a =;%= $ <% Eihi |i ^@?|€iht @hi UL?t|hU|i At t
##Rqh ri E)U*v/ s1451
#$Wkh fdvh lv hyhq fohduhu zlwk uhvshfw wr lqfrqvlvwhqw vlwxdwlrqv +ri d nlqg wkdw duh dovr
lqyrnhg lq vlwxdwlrq vhpdqwlfv,1 Li rqh vxevfulehv wr fodvvlfdo qhjdwlrq/ GH vlwxdwlrq fdq eh
vxfk wkdw  dqg = krog dw lw1 Wklv lv d yhu| sduw ri zkdw qhjdwlrq lv wdnhq wr phdq1
#% E)U/ s14:/ lwdolfv ruljlqdo= cWkh frqvwuxfwlylvp 111 ^ri fhuwdlq pdwkhpdwlfldqv` fdq ehvw eh
ghvfulehg dv pdwkhpdwlfv sxuvxhg lq wkh frqwh{w ri lqwxlwlrqlvw orjlf*1

2
?L| ?||L?t|U@**) @*_ D
L?i |i *ittc | t Uih|@?*) |i U@ti |@| L?i UL*_ _iU_i |L LTih@|i | t|
?||L?t| *L}Uc Lhc 4Lhi }i?ih@**)c | @ UL?t|hU|i T@h| Lu L?i<t Thiuihhi_
*L}U E@tt4?} |@| |@| *L}U t ?L| |ti*u UL?t|hU|i ?i UL*_ _L |t t4T*)
@t @? i ihUti( M| 4Lhi 4TLh|@?|*)c |ihi 4}| Mi @ TihuiU|*) ti?tM*i TL?|
|L _L?} tL  TL?| 4}| Mi ThL_i_ M) |i u@U| |@| UL?U*tL?t LM|@?i_
UL?t|hU|i*) UL?|@? 4Lhi ?uLh4@|L?c Lh 4Lhi UL4T|@|L?@* UL?|i?|c |@?
UL?U*tL?t ThLi_ ?L?UL?t|hU|i*) +i@tL??} ? |t @) 4@) |ihiuLhi Mi @
tiu* ?t|h4i?|@* |iU?^i W ?L|i_ |@| @ Thi *L}U 4@) Mi @TT*i_ uLh 4@?)
ThTLtitc @?_ ?t|h4i?|@* ThTLtit @hi ThTLtit Oi?Ui |t t t4T*) @ U@ti
Lu @TT*)?} @ *L}U uLh @ _gihi?| i?_c @?_ i @i @*hi@_) tii? |@| _gihi?|
@TT*U@|L?t 4@) hi^hi _gihi?| *L}Ut L|ic |L}c |@| | _Lit ?L| uL**L
uhL4 |t |@| UL?U*tL?t LM|@?i_ t?} ?L?UL?t|hU|i Th?UT*it Lu ?uihi?Ui
@hi |i4ti*it _iuiU|i ? @?) @) Ai |?}t tL ThLi_ @hi }@h@?|ii_c ?
u@U|c |L L*_ ? |i t|@|L? @ML| U i @hi hi@tL??}c M) |i _i€?|L? Lu
@*_|)
`*t| i @hi L? |i ?t|h4i?|@* ti Lu *L}Utc *i| 4i }i L?i 4Lhi i @4T*i
Lu |t W?uihi?Ui ThLUi_hit @hi ti_ ? tUi?Ui ?_ tL4i|4it ? tUi?Uic i
@i @ |iLh) |@| i !?L |L Mi ?ULhhiU|c M| U i tic ?L?i|i*ittc uLh
?t|h4i?|@* ThTLtit Wu i @hi _L?} |tc |i? i @hi U*i@h*) @*tL @| *Mih|) |L
ti @|iih ?uihi?|@* ThLUittit i *!i u |i) t@|tu) |Lti ThTLtit
? i @4T*i Lu |t t @t uL**Lt Ai Lh |iLh) Lu |i @|L4 @t @ ih)
tiu* |iLh)c U 4@_i t|h!?}*) @UUh@|i i4ThU@* Thi_U|L?t W|t ?uihi?Ui
ThLUi_hit ihi }*) ?L?t|@?_@h_c |L}c ?L*?} |i U?!?} Lu Th?U
T*itc | *4|i_ L Lu ?uLh4@|L? Mi|ii? |i U?!t W| U@? Mi @h}i_ |@|
|t t Mit| ?_iht|LL_ ? |ih4t Lu @ ?L?@_?U|i T@h@UL?tt|i?| *L}U2S Lc
?L L?i iih |L}| |@| Lh<t |iLh) @t ULhhiU| W| t UL44L?*) t}}it|i_
|@| |t t MiU@ti | @t ?UL?tt|i?| W _L ?L| |?! |@| |t t @ }LL_ hi@tL?
`@| t @ }LL_ hi@tL? t |@| u @ |h|Thitih?} ?uihi?Ui 4iU@?t4 @_ Mii?
ti_c |i |iLh) L*_ @i @_ @** tLh|t Lu i4ThU@* UL?ti^i?Uit |@| @hi ?L|
LMtihi_2. Ai |iLh)c |i?c U@??L| Mi |hi #itT|i |tc | @t @? 4TLh|@?|
t|iTT?} t|L?i i? hL|i |L @ 4Lhi @_i^@|i |iLh) W| @t ?iUitt@h) |L LM|@?
?t}| ?|L @hLt Th?UT*it @?_ |ih ?|ih@U|L?c tL |@| 4Lhi @_i^@|i Th?
UT*it UL*_ Mi uLh4*@|i_ Ai ti Lu @ *L}U |@| t ?L| L?i Lu t4T*i |h|
Thitih@|L? @t TihuiU|*) *i}|4@|i ? |t UL?|i |
 ?4Mih Lu h|ihtc Lh!?} ? |i €i*_ Lu ?L?@_?U|i T@h@UL?tt|i?|
*L}U ? T@h|U*@hc @i @h}i_ |@| | 4@) Mi 4TLh|@?| |L @i @? ?uihi?Ui
i?}?i |@| Thitihit tL4i|?} L|ih |@? ELh @t i** @t |h|c uLh Uih|@?
58 Fodvvlfdoo|/ li dq dulwkphwlf suhglfdwh lv ghflgdeoh/ dqg zh duh dvvxuhg wkdw qrw hyhu|wklqj
idlov wr vdwlvi| lw/ wkhq zh fdq whvw lw iru hdfk qxpehu xqwlo zh qg rqh wkdw vdwlvhv lw1 Wklv lv
d shuihfwo| jrrg fodvvlfdo frqvwuxfwlrq/ exw qrw dq lqwxlwlrqlvw rqh1 Vhh Gxpphww +4<::,/ s155i1
59 Vhh Eurzq +4<<6,1
5: Vhh Sulhvw +4<<g,1


ThTLtit2H t W @i @*hi@_) t|hitti_c _gihi?| @TT*U@|L?t 4@) i** hi^hi
_gihi?| *L}Ut 5|@|i )Lh ThTLti @?_ L | t |L Mi @Uii_( |i? ti @ *L}U
|i @TT*U@|L? Lu U _Lit |t

S N?_ih_i|ih4?@|L? M) |i #@|@

wi| t €?t | L?i 4Lhi @h}4i?| uLh T*h@*t4 W? igiU|c @? @TT*i_ *L}U
tc @t W @i t@_c @ |iLh) @ML| L |t _L4@? Lu @TT*U@|L? Mi@it Oi?Uic
@ Thi *L}Uc i? }i? |i U@?L?U@* @TT*U@|L?c ThL_it @ |iLh) @ML| |i
?Lh4t Lu ULhhiU| E_i_U|i hi@tL??} W| 4@) Mi |L}| |@| |ihi t ?tu
€Ui?| ?uLh4@|L? |L _i|ih4?i U *L}U t |i ULhhiU| @TT*i_ *L}U ihi( ?
T@h|U*@hc |@| Lh ?||L?t @ML| |i }LL_?itt @?_ M@_?itt Lu T@h|U*@h ?uih
i?Uit QU ThL_i |i _@|@ ? |t U@tiQ@hi ?tUi?| |L _i|ih4?i U
|iLh) t ULhhiU| Oi?Uic |ihi 4@) Mi @ T*h@*|) Lu i^@**) ULhhiU| @?tiht
*h@*t4 Lu |t !?_ 4@) Mi @h}i_ L? ih) }i?ih@* }hL?_tc u@4*@h uhL4
|i T*LtLT) Lu tUi?Ui Ai ULhhiU| |iLh)c | 4@) Mi t@_c t @*@)t ?_ih
_i|ih4?i_ M) |i _@|@c U tc ? @?) U@tic tLu| W? h|i Lu |tc |i @h}4i?|
tL4i|4it UL?|?itc |i ULhhiU| |iLh) t @ Thi*) UL?i?|L?@* 4@||ih ?_ i
U@? 4@!i Uiih UL?i?|L?t @hi 4Lt| UL?i?i?|
`@| t |L Mi t@_ @ML| |tq Ai €ht| TL?| t |@| ?_i|ih4?t4 Lu |i
!?_ W @i t| _itUhMi_ tc ? }i?ih@*c ^|i Lihh@|i_ _i^@U) |L |i _@|@
t t| L?i Lu |i Uh|ih@ |L Mi i4T*L)i_ ? @ttitt?} |iLhit |ihtc tU @t
t4T*U|)c ?|)c @ *L _i}hii Lu @_ LU?ittc i|Uc @hi u@4*@h uhL4 |i *|ih@|hi
`*t| | t U*i@h*) @ TLttM*|) Lu tL4i tLh| |@| _gihi?| |iLhit 4@) )i| |iQ
@?_ ?L| t| ThL |i4c M| ? |i *L?} |ih4Q| t @h_ |L UL4i T | UL?Uhi|i
i @4T*it Lu |t ? |i t|Lh) Lu ?|i**iU|@* ?^h) | @?) h@|ic W !?L Lu ?L
@h}4i?| |L tTTLti |@| |t t @ hi@* TLttM*|) ? *L}U
?_ ii? u | ihic |t t ?L| @? i?_ Lu |i 4@||ih 6Lh |t T*h@*|) t
4ihi*) iTt|i4UG i t| U@??L| |i** U Lu |i |iLhit t |i ULhhiU| L?i
Bi? UL4Ti|?} |iLhitc @t *L?} @t L?i t @ hi@*t| @ML| |ih tMiU| 4@||ihc
@| 4Lt| L?i Lu |i4 U@? Mi ULhhiU|c ii? u i U@??L| |i** U Aihi t
|ihiuLhi ?L @*i|U T*h@*t4
| tL*_ i Mi @ hi@*t| @ML| *L}Uq Ai @?tihc W |?!c t )it V@*_
|) t _i|ih4?i_ M) |i U*@tt Lu t|@|L?t ?L*i_ ? |h|Thitih@|L?c ^|i
?_iTi?_i?|*) Lu Lh |iLh) Lu @*_|) At @?tih @t @ Uih|@? L?|L*L}U@*
t|?}c Liih 6Lhc @t W LMtihi_c |i t|@|L?t @ML| U i hi@tL? @hi ?L|
@** @U|@*G 4@?) @hi Thi*) )TL|i|U@* ?_ L?i 4t| Mi @ hi@*t| @ML| |iti
|LL Aihi @hi ?4ihLt _gihi?| tLh|t Lu hi@*t4 |@| L?i 4}| i?_Lhti ihic
4@?) Lu U @hi u@4*@h uhL4 _iM@|it @ML| |i ?@|hi Lu TLttM*i Lh*_t ?i
4@) |@!i )TL|i|U@* t|@|L?t |L Mi UL?Uhi|i ?L?@U|@* t|@|L?t( @Mt|h@U|
LMiU|tc *!i ti|t Lu ThLTLt|L?t Lh UL4M?@|L?t Lu @U|@* UL4TL?i?|t( hi@* M|
5; Vhh/ h1j1/ Eurzq +4<<d,1

e
?L?i t|i?| LMiU|t2b W ** ?L| @__hitt |i ^it|L? Lu U Lu |iti @UUL?|
t ULhhiU| ihif ?) Lu |i4 ** _Lc @t *L?} @t |i) ThL_i uLh @? ?_iTi?_i?|
hi@*4 Lu t|@|L?t( @?_ i?Ui @ _i|ih4?@|i @?tih |L |i ^it|L? Lu U
|iLh) t ULhhiU| Eii? u Lh |iLhit _L |ic iTt|i4U@**)

e W?_U|i W?uihi?Ui
`i @i ?L _i@*| | @ ?4Mih Lu 4TLh|@?| @h}4i?|t uLh T*h@*t4 @ML|
_i_U|i @*_|) wi| 4i UL?U*_i |i itt@) M) hi|h??} |L |i tti Lu ?_U
|i @*_|)c |L tii @| | @__t |L |i TU|hi Ai t|@|L? ihi t UL4T*U@|i_
M) |i u@U| |@| |ihi t ?L |iLhi|U@* @}hii4i?| @ML| |i ?@|hi Lu ?_U|i
?uihi?Uic ii? Lu |i *4|i_ !?_ |@| i t|t uLh _i_U|i ?uihi?Ui `@| W
t@** _Lc |i?c t t@) @| W |?! t |i ULhhiU| @UUL?| Lu ?_U|i ?uihi?Uic
@?_ |@!i | uhL4 |ihi
Ai @UUL?| t 4Lt| t4T*) i T*@?i_ | @? i @4T*i L?t_ih |i ?uih
i?UiG L?3L t @ _L}( i?Uic L?3L @t uLh *i}t Ai ?uihi?Ui t ?L| _i_U|i*)
@*_G |ihi @hic @u|ih @**c _L}t L @i *Lt| *i}t ? @UU_i?|t | | t ?_U
|i*) }LL_( @?_ |t t tL MiU@ti ?Lh4@**) _L}t @i uLh *i}t W? L|ih Lh_tc
? @** ?Lh4@* t|@|L?t ihi |i Thi4ti t |hic tL t |i UL?U*tL? Lh4@*
|) UL4it M) _i}hiitc |L}c tL | t 4Lhi @UUh@|i |L t@) |@| ? @** |i 4Lt|
?Lh4@* t|@|L?t ? U |i Thi4tit @hi |hic tL t |i UL?U*tL?
Ai _i@ t @?_*i_ uLh4@**) M) t|hU|h?} t|@|L?t | @? Lh_ih?}c |@!i?
|L hiThiti?| ?Lh4@*|)  4Lt| ?Lh4@* t|@|L? ihi |i Thi4tit @hi |hi t
|i? @ t|@|L? ihi |i Thi4tit @hi |hic tU |@| |ihi t ?L t|@|L? }ih
? |i Lh_ih?} ihi |t t tL( M| i ?ii_ ?L| }L ?|L _i|@*t Lu |t uLh |i
uL**L?} _tUttL? Ai 4TLh|@?| TL?| |L ?L|i @| Thiti?| t |@| i? i
hi@tL? ?_U|i*)c @| UL?|t @t ?Lh4@* t UL?|i |_iTi?_i?| Wu i @hi hi@
tL??} @ML| ML*L}U@* @TTi?_@}itc @ _L} | uLh *i}t t ?L| ?Lh4@*( u i @hi
hi@tL??} @ML| Uhi@|hit< }i?L|)Titc |i _L} 4@) Mi TihuiU|*) ?Lh4@*c ThL_i_
|@| |t *Lt| *i} t U@ti_ M) @ hL@_ @UU_i?|c @?_ ?L| @ }i?i|U @M?Lh4@*|)
Lc L _Lit |t @giU| |i tti Lu T*h@*t4q 6ht|c |i u@U| |@| i @i
|L U@?L?t Lu ?uihi?Uic ?_U|i @?_ _i_U|ic t ?L| @ U@ti Lu T*h@*t4 At
t MiU@tic @UULh_?} |L |i @MLi _i€?|L?c @** _i_U|i*) @*_ ?uihi?Uit @hi
?_U|i*) @*_ EWu |h| t Thitihi_ ? @** ?|ihThi|@|L?tc | t Thitihi_ ?
@** 4Lt| ?Lh4@* L?it Oi?Uic i _L ?L| @i |L U@?L?t Lu ?uihi?UiG i @i
L?i ti| Lu @*_ ?uihi?Uitc ?t_i U |ihi t @ _t|?}ti_ tMti|
| |i u@U| |@| ?Lh4@*|) t UL?|i |hi*@|i _Lit }i hti |L @ T*h@*t4
`@| t ?_U|i*) @*_ ** _iTi?_ L? |i ?Lh4@*|) Lh_ih?}c U 4@) @h)
5<Ylhzv ri wkhvh nlqgv duh khog/ frqfhuqlqj srvvleoh zruogv/ e| Ohzlv/ Vwdoqdnhu/ Fuhvvzhoo
dqg Urxwoh|/ uhvshfwlyho|1
6! P| v|psdwklhv/ lq idfw/ olh zlwk d Phlqrqjldq dffrxqw1
$" Wklv lv ghihqghg lq Sulhvw +4<<e,1
D
uhL4 UL?|i | |L UL?|i | ?i 4}| Mi |i4T|i_ |L hiT*) ihi @t W hiT*i_ |L |i
T*h@*t| ? e W| t t|** |i U@ti |@| |ihi t @ ULhi Lu ?_U|i ?uihi?Uit |@|
@hi @*_ ? @** UL?|i |tc ?@4i*) |Lti |@| L*_ @|iih |i ?Lh4@*|) Lh_ih?}
`) ?L| U@** |Lti |i @*_ ?_U|i ?uihi?Uitc |i L|iht Mi?} hi_UM*i |L
|Lti i?|)4i4@|U@**)q  4@? @?tih |L |t t |@| u L?i UL?UiT|@*tit
|i @*_ ?_U|i ?uihi?Uit ? |t @)c |i? |ihi t ?L _gihi?Ui Mi|ii?
?_U|i @?_ _i_U|i @*_|) Ai @*_ ?_U|i ?uihi?Uit |h? L| |L Mi
?_t|?}t@M*i uhL4 |i @*_ _i_U|i L?it2 ?i U@? 4@?|@? @ 4L?t4
@ML| ?_U|i ?uihi?Uic M| u L?i _Litc | t @? i?|hi*) @ULt L?i

D L?U*tL?
`i @i ?L hiii_ tiih@* hi@tL?t uLh *L}U@* T*h@*t4c @?_ tiih@* |?}t
|@| T*h@*t4 4}| 4i@? Ai tti Lu 4L?t4 t T*h@*t4 @t |h?i_ L| |L
Mi @ _i*U@|i L?i t i @i tii?c |ihi @hi 4@?) ti?tit ? U T*h@*t4 t
?UL?|i?|Lt*) ULhhiU| L L?ic uLh i @4T*ic t }L?} |L @h}i @ML| T*h@*t4
? Thi *L}Uc Lh |iLhi|U@* T*h@*t4 ? @TT*i_ *L}U Ai 4TLh|@?|c @?_ @h_c
^it|L? t i|ih L?i tL*_ Mi @ 4L?t| Lh @ T*h@*t| @ML| |i ULhhiU| *L}U
uLh |i U@?L?U@* @TT*U@|L? t W @i @h}i_c 4L?t4 t |i ULhhiU| @?tih

+iuihi?Uit
do #@|i?t EbHDc i@??}c UUiT|@?Ui @?_ #@*iU|Ut<c ? a|| Ei_c
@?}i @?_ hL}hitt ? L_ih? 5Ui?Uic +i_i* M*t?} L

d2o #@|i?t Ebbfc }@?t| B*LM@* @h@UL?tt|i?U)<c 5|_it ? 5Li|

AL}| bc 2fb2b

do ai@** @?_ B+it|@** EbbHc wL}U@* *h@*t4<c |)TitUhT|

deo hL? Ebbc *_ "@?|4 AiLh)G @ @h@UL?tt|i?| TThL@U<c hL

Uii_?}t Lu |i *LtLT) Lu 5Ui?Ui ttLU@|L?c VL* 2c b.ee

dDo hL? Ebb@c 54T*i @|h@* #i_U|L? uLh `i@!*) }}hi}@|i @h@
UL?tt|i?| wL}Ut<c |L @TTi@h
$# Mxvw frqvlghu wkh ghjhqhudwh rughulqj/ zkhuh qr vlwxdwlrq frpsduhv zlwk dq| rwkhu1 Wkh
pd{lpdoo| qrupdo prghov ri d vhw ri suhplvhv duh wkhq mxvw lwv prghov1
$$ D yhuvlrq ri wklv sdshu zdv jlyhq dw wkh Xqlyhuvlw| ri Wdvpdqld1 L zrxog olnh wr wkdqn wkrvh
suhvhqw iru d qxpehu ri khosixo srlqwv/ exw sduwlfxodu|/ M1F1Ehdoo/ Md| Jduhog dqg Zlqvwrq
Qhvelww1 L*p dovr judwhixo wr Juhj Uhvwdoo iru klv frpphqwv rq hduolhu gudiwv ri wkh sdshu1 D
yhuvlrq ri wkh sdshu zdv dovr uhdg dw d phhwlqj ri wkh Vrflhw| iru H{dfw Sklorvrsk| khog dw
wkh Xqlyhuvlw| ri Ohwkeulgjh/ Pd|/ 4<<<1 L zrxog olnh wr wkdqn wkrvh suhvhqw iru wkhlu khosixo
frpphqwv1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ wkh dujxphqw iru soxudolvp ri 619 zdv suhvvhg rq ph e| d qxpehu ri
shrsoh wkhuh/ dqg hvshfldoo| Shwhu Zrrgux1

S
 dSo _@ Lt|@ Ebb.c wL}^i *@tt^i i| L? *@tt^iG ,tt@ th *it
6L?_i4i?|t _i *@ wL}^ic @ttL?

d.o #44i|| Eb..c ,*i4i?|t Lu W?||L?t4c  uLh_ N?iht|) hitt

dHo 5O@@U! Eb.Hc *LtLT) Lu wL}Utc @4Mh_}i N?iht|) hitt

dbo Bhit| EbH.c W? L?|h@_U|L?c @h|?t Lg

dfo Bhit| Ebbc ?4@**) W?UL?tt|i?| u <c 5|_@ wL}U@ Dfc 2

do Bhit| Ebbbc `@| L|q  #iui?Ui Lu @ #@*i|iU AiLh) Lu i}@|L?<c

TT f2f Lu O`@?t?} @?_ #B@MM@) Ei_tc `@| t i}@|L?qc k*ih
U@_i4U M*tih

d2o Bhit| Ebb@c ? *|ih?@|i BiL4i|hitc h|4i|Ut @?_ wL}Ut( @ AhM
|i |L w
p !@tiU3<c ? @}h@4@? Ei_c hLUii_?}t Lu |i L?uihi?Ui
w
p !@tiU3 ? #M*?c |L @TTi@h

do Bhit| EbbMc V@*_|)<c ? V@h3 Ei_c `@| t wL}Uqc 5wW M*U@

|L?tc |L @TTi@h

deo Bhit| EbbUc +ii Lu _@ Lt|@ Ebb.c 5|_@ wL}U@c |L @TTi@h

dDo Bhit| Ebb_c W?UL?tt|i?U) ? |i ,4ThU@* 5Ui?Uit<c ? aiit Ei_c

W?UL?tt|i?U) @?_ |i Ot|Lh) Lu 5Ui?Uic |L @TTi@h

.