Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The work presented here describes the effect of wollastonite and talc on the micromechanisms of surface deformation and subsequent prop-
agation into the bulk of low and high crystallinity polypropylenes during tensile straining. The potential of high resolution electron microscopy
is utilized to examine deformation processes, and develop deformation mechanism maps. While mineral-reinforced polypropylenes exhibited
an increase in tensile modulus, yield strength remained unaffected. Crystallization behavior indicated that the reinforcement minerals increase
the rate of nucleation with consequent increase in percentage of bulk crystallinity. The reinforcement of polypropylene with wollastonite or
talc alters the primary micromechanism of deformation from deformation bands/crazing in neat polypropylenes to wedge/ridge tearing in
mineral-reinforced low crystallinity polypropylene composites. However, wedges were absent in high crystallinity polypropylene composites.
The final fracture in reinforced polypropylene occurs by a mixed mode consisting of fibrillation and brittle mode, while crazing–tearing and
brittle deformation are fracture modes for neat polypropylenes.
© 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
0921-5093/$ – see front matter © 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.msea.2004.01.003
R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315 297
as compared to regions far away [13,14]. The close-packing an edge-shared octahedral sheet of magnesium hydroxide
of lamellae in the vicinity of particle–matrix was attributed (tetrahedron–octahedron–tetrahedron). van der Waals’ gaps
to polymer–mineral surface interaction and implied higher (interlayer or gallery) between the layers are formed due
local crystallinity. to stacking of layers [29], which may assist in the delami-
While a number of studies have dealt with crystallization nation behavior of talc mineral particles during mechanical
and mechanical properties of polymeric materials con- deformation (please see below), resulting in reduced yield
taining reinforcement fillers, there is currently a lack of strength in reinforced polymers.
understanding of the micromechanisms of plastic deforma-
tion in mineral-reinforced composites. This is particularly
important because polymeric materials under conditions of 2. Experimental materials and procedure
mechanical deformation such as tensile, fatigue or impact
loading have a tendency to exhibit a whiter appearance. Tensile bars (ASTM D638 geometry) of low and high
In other words, an initially transparent or translucent poly- crystallinity polypropylenes reinforced with wollastonite
meric material exhibits enhanced opacity and whiter color and talc were cast by the injection molding process with
leading to increased optical brightness, referred as stress the longitudinal axis of the specimen corresponding to the
whitening. direction of molding. Tensile bars were also cast without
In general, the origin of stress whitening in thermoplas- mineral particles to study the influence of reinforcement
tic materials has been attributed to the formation of voids (low crystallinity neat polypropylene: N1, and high crys-
and microcrazing. Studies on the mechanism of crazing have tallinity neat polypropylene: N2). Depending on the nature
suggested that the nucleation of craze initiates with the for- of the mineral particles, the samples are designated as W1
mation of deformation bands, and the growth occurs by a (wollastonite-reinforced low crystallinity polypropylene of
process that involves existing voids advance finger-like ex- median particle size ∼8 m), T1 (talc-reinforced low crys-
tensions into the bulk polymer, linking up the stretched fib- tallinity polypropylene of median particle size ∼7.5 m),
rils in their wake [20,21]. Furthermore, electron microscopy W2 (wollastonite-reinforced high crystallinity polypropy-
studies indicated that in the craze zone, in addition to the lene of median particle size ∼8 m), and T2 (talc-reinforced
main fibrils that are present normal to the orientation of high crystallinity polypropylene of median particle size
a craze and bridge the two surfaces, cross-tie fibrils are ∼7.5 m). The volume fraction of wollastonite and talc
also present, which link the main fibrils [22]. Other dom- was kept constant at ∼20%. The melt flow rates (at 230 ◦ C
inant micromechanisms proposed for stress whitening in- and 2.16 kg piston force) of the injected-molded neat and
clude shear deformation bands, kinking, microcracking, and reinforced low and high crystallinity polypropylenes were
ductile ploughing. Stress whitening is an important con- maintained at ∼6 and 5 g for 10 min, respectively.
stituent of any mechanical deformation process. The crystallization behavior of neat and reinforced low
To encourage the use of polyolefins for load-bearing ap- and high crystallinity polypropylenes was carried out using
plications, it is important that they exhibit reduced suscep- differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) (TA Instruments).
tibility to mechanically induced surface damage and do not The samples were heated from room temperature (∼20 ◦ C)
stress whiten. Misra and co-workers [23,24] believe that to 180 ◦ C at a rate of 10 ◦ C/min, held at 180 ◦ C for about
polymeric materials characterized by high modulus and yield a minute, cooled to −20 ◦ C at the rate of 10 ◦ C/min, and
strength, and a large elastic regime are preferred materials a second scan was carried out in a manner similar to the
in applications where mechanically induced surface dam- first. The heat of fusion and crystallization obtained by DSC
age is the primary concern. Mechanically induced surface for neat and reinforced polypropylenes are listed in Table 1
damage in the form of scratch or internal damage in the along with the melting and crystallization temperatures.
form of voids undermines the longevity of the polymeric The tensile bars were deformed in uniaxial tension at
components and limits their use [25,26]. The minimization 20 ◦ C using a computerized MTS 210 tensile testing ma-
of plastic deformation (or stress whitening) can be accom- chine at selected displacement rates in the range of 2.5–
plished by increasing crystallinity [27], use of short chain 500 mm/min. The MTS testing machine was a constant-
polymers [28], compounding with additives, and a signifi- rate-of-crosshead movement comprising essentially a fixed
cant influence can be realized by reinforcement of polymers member carrying one grip and a movable member car-
with micrometric size particles, such as wollastonite and talc rying a second grip. The standard ASTM test specimens
minerals. were held between the fixed and movable grips that were
It is interesting to examine the mechanical deformation self-aligning such that they move freely into alignment as
behavior of mineral-reinforced polypropylenes such as wol- soon as any load is applied, and the long axis of the test
lastonite and talc that have contrasting structures. Wollas- specimen coincides with the direction of the applied pull
tonite (calcium silicate) has acicular (needle-like) structure through the centerline of the grip assembly. It was ensured
and is characterized by repeating, twisted, three silica tetra- that the test specimens were perfectly aligned in the di-
hedron unit, while talc (magnesium silicate) has a platy or rection of pull and no slippage occurred at the grips. A
layered structure made up of two silica tetrahedra fused to 25 mm course extensometer was used for determining the
298 R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315
Table 1
Physical and mechanical properties of neat and reinforced low and high crystallinity polypropylenes
Property Low crystallinity polypropylenes High crystallinity polypropylenes
distance between the two designated points within the gage and T1) (Fig. 1a) exhibit enhanced crystallization in com-
length of the test specimen. The gage length used for the parison to reinforced high crystallinity polypropylenes (W2
purpose was 50.8 mm. The longitudinal strain or extension and T2) (Fig. 1b), with respect to their neat polypropylenes
was measured automatically by the extensometer. as implied by relatively high heat of fusion. The heat of
Two types of tests were performed to examine (a) the fusion increased from ∼63 J/g in N1 to ∼75 J/g in W1 and
modes of deformation, (b) the evolution of deformation pro- ∼70 J/g in T1, while it increased from ∼81 J/g in N2 to ∼85
cesses with increase in strain and strain rate, and (c) the se- and 83 J/g in W2 and T2, respectively. The behavior was
quence of events that led to different modes of fracture. In consistent in different DSC runs. The increase in heat of fu-
the first type of test, tensile loading at a constant strain rate
to predetermined strain on the stress–strain plots was carried
3
out, followed by unloading of the samples. In the second
type of tests, the samples were tested to failure. This was
2.5
followed by field emission scanning electron microscopy
(JEOL 6300) studies of tensile deformed polymeric ma- W1
Heat Flow, W/g
2
terials. To define the boundaries of different micromecha- N1 T1
nisms of deformation with reasonable accuracy, the first at- 1.5
tempt was to define on the stress–strain plots the strain and
strain rate condition that represented the transition between 1
the different micromechanisms. This was followed by SEM
characterization of tensile deformed surfaces by interrupting 0.5
tests at different stress–strain conditions, and the procedure
repeated for varying strain rates. 0
75 90 105 120 135 150
(a) Temperature, C
o
3.1. Crystallization
2.5
2
lenes was studied to determine the effect of wollastonite and N2
talc on the kinetics of crystallization that is expected to in-
1.5
fluence the percentage of bulk crystallinity and consequently W2
deformation mechanisms. The temperature dependence of
1 T2
crystallization for neat and reinforced low and high crys-
tallinity polypropylenes is presented in Fig. 1. Fig. 1 shows
that the crystallization in reinforced polypropylenes starts 0.5
45
40
35
30
Engineering Stress, MPa
T1
25
20
N1
W1 Failed at a strain ~ 5.2
15
10
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2
(a) Engineering Strain
50
45
40
35
Engineering Stress, MPa
30
25
W2
20
T2
15
N2
10
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
(b) Engineering Strain
Fig. 2. Engineering stress–strain plot of neat and mineral-reinforced polymeric materials at a selected displacement rate of ∼50 mm/min: (a) low
crystallinity polypropylenes and (b) high crystallinity polypropylenes.
sion is a direct indication of higher percentage of bulk crys- In Table 1, melting and crystallization temperatures for
tallinity in polypropylene composites. Using a value of heat neat and reinforced polypropylenes are also presented. It
of fusion for 100% crystalline polypropylene of 138 J/g, the may be noted from Table 1 that the shift in melting tem-
percentage of crystallinity of neat and mineral-reinforced perature on the addition of mineral to polypropylenes is
polypropylenes are estimated and presented in Table 1. insignificant.
300 R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315
Fig. 4. Low magnification (a) SEM micrograph of the fracture surface of neat low crystallinity polypropylene (N1) along with the high magnification
micrographs of the two modes of failure, crazing–tearing (b) and brittle (c) at a displacement rate of ∼50 mm/min.
R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315 301
Fig. 5. Sequence of events leading to the debonding/detachment of mineral particles from the surface of wollastonite-reinforced low crystallinity
polypropylene (W1) at a displacement rate of ∼50 mm/min subjected to different amounts of percentage of strain: (a) ∼10; (b) ∼20; (c, d) ∼25; (e)
∼30; (f, g) ∼35.
302 R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315
of yielding and thus did not contribute to improvement in wollastonite- and talc-reinforced polypropylenes (W1,
yield strength. In a recent study on Nylon 6 composites W2, T1, and T2) can be explained by considering that
reinforced with micron-size silica and glass particles indi- the matrix/particle interface provides potential sites for
cated an increase in yield stress for composites with silica crack nucleation. The onset of composite failure occurs
and decrease for glass-containing composites [30]. Also, when the particles debond from the matrix such that the
yield stress increased with decrease in filler size. Tensile strain-to-fracture of the composite has a value that is inter-
modulus, was however higher for filled composites than mediate between the mineral and the polymer matrix.
that of pure components. The differences in the behavior of
silica- and glass-filled Nylon 6 composites were attributed 3.3. Microstructural evolution during tensile straining
to different dispersibility of fillers in the polymer matrix.
Thus, micron-size fillers can increase the modulus, and can Neat low and high crystallinity polypropylenes (N1 and
also decrease the strength. In another study on micron-size N2) exhibit distinct regions such as yielding and plastic
TiO2 -filled epoxy composites, modulus was increased and deformation. After yielding, further tensile deformation re-
the strain-to-fracture decreased relative to unfilled epoxy sulted in specimen necking and cold drawing in neat low
[30]. crystallinity polypropylene (N1). The neck propagated along
In the present case, the observed increase in modulus the gage length exhibiting cold drawing until the speci-
of wollastonite- and talc-reinforced polypropylenes can men failed. However, stress–strain plots of wollastonite- and
be explained in terms of reinforcement effect. The de- talc-reinforced polypropylenes (Fig. 2) did not exhibit cold
crease in percentage of strain-to-fracture in the micron-size drawing.
Fig. 6. Low magnification SEM micrograph of the fracture surface of wollastonite-reinforced low crystallinity polypropylene (W1) tensile tested at a
displacement rate of ∼50 mm/min (a) along with the high magnification micrographs of the two modes of fracture, fibrillation (b, c) and brittle (d, e)
showing voiding and detached mineral particles.
R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315 303
To study the deformation processes during tensile strain- many orders of magnitude greater than in the less severely
ing of neat and reinforced polypropylenes, samples were deformed regions. With increase in strain (percentage of
unloaded to predetermined strains on the engineering strain ∼17, displacement rate ∼250 mm/min), the defor-
stress–strain plots (Fig. 2). These include (a) end of elastic mation bands developed into distinct array of crazes. An
limit (commencement of yielding), (b) progress in yielding example of crazing is illustrated in Fig. 3a. The closely
and cold drawing, and (c) fracture. The unloaded samples spaced crazes are formed normal to the tensile axis and are
were studied using high resolution field emission SEM to opaque planes in the stress-whitened material. With increase
identify the deformation processes in neat and reinforced in strain, a crack nucleates through an array of crazes. The
polypropylenes that lead to fracture. presence of crack within the crazed zone modifies the stress
fields such that subsequent crazing (secondary crazing) oc-
3.3.1. Neat low crystallinity polypropylene curred at an angle to the primary crazes (Fig. 3b, percent-
At the commencement of plastic deformation (onset of age of strain ∼40, displacement rate ∼250 mm/min). Also,
yielding), ‘deformation bands’ were observed in regions of crazes multiplied with increase in strain along with the in-
intense local deformation because of severe plastic flow. crease in the density of voids and subsequently increasing
The local strain in the deformation bands is expected to be the stress-whitened zone. The sequence of events was similar
Fig. 7. Sequence of events leading to the debonding/detachment of mineral particles from the surface of talc-reinforced low crystallinity polypropylene
(T1) at a displacement rate of ∼50 mm/min subjected to different amounts of percentage of strain: (a) ∼10; (b) ∼20; (c) ∼25; (d) ∼30; (e) ∼40.
304 R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315
at higher strain rates. It has been recently shown by Dasari high magnification micrographs of craze-tearing and brit-
and Misra [31] using AFM that in the crazed region, the tle regions of the fracture surface are presented in Fig. 4.
fibrils align in the direction of the tensile strained direction At this low displacement rate, the extent of craze forma-
(i.e. perpendicular to the crazed region), and micro-voids are tion in N1 was ∼65% and the brittle region was ∼35% of
generated because of fragmentation and splitting of stretched the fracture, and with increase in displacement rate, the ex-
fibrils. tent of craze region decreased with consequent increase in
The final fracture in neat polypropylene (N1) occurred by the brittle area. Furthermore, the low magnification SEM
tearing along the individual bundle of crazes growing from fractograph of N1 suggests that the fracture starts near the
opposite faces resulting in crazing–tearing at the edges and core of the tensile bar, and propagates outwards breaking
brittle mode of fracture in the center. It was proposed by through the crazed surface on both sides (resulting in tear-
Steger and Nielsen [32] that when the strain hardening of ing of the crazed region) at approximately the same posi-
fibrils is inadequate to compensate for the voids, craze be- tion along the length of the bar. An interesting aspect of
comes mechanically unstable and accumulates strain until brittle fracture is that while the fracture surface appears
a macroscopic crack propagates leading to fracture. SEM smooth, there are a large number of unbroken ligaments
micrographs illustrating the mixed mode of fracture in N1 that continued to deform plastically as decohesion of fibrils
at a low displacement rate of ∼50 mm/min along with the occurred.
Fig. 8. Low magnification SEM micrograph of the fracture surface of talc-reinforced low crystallinity polypropylene (T1) tensile tested at a displacement
rate of ∼50 mm/min (a) along with the high magnification micrographs of the two modes of fracture, fibrillation (b, c) and brittle (d, e) showing voiding
and detached mineral particles.
R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315 305
0.1
Brittle
Crazing
0.01
Crazing-Tearing
Strain Rate, s-1
0.0001 Crazing
Fully Elastic
0.00001
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45
(a) Strain
0.1
Fibrillation
+
Distinct Brittle Fracture
Wedge Pulling Apart of Wedges Associated with Debonding
Formation
+
0.01
Tearing along the Ridges
Strain Rate, s-1
Wedge
Multiplication
0.001
Formation of Ridges
Wedge
Fully Nucleation
Elastic
0.0001
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45 0.5
(b) Strain
Fig. 9. Domains of deformation processes as a function of strain and strain rate in (a) neat low crystallinity polypropylene (N1), (b) wollastonite-reinforced
low crystallinity polypropylene (W1), and (c) talc-reinforced low crystallinity polypropylene (T1).
306 R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315
0.1
Increased Density
of Ridges
Fibrillation
+
Brittle Fracture
Associated with Debonding
Wedge
0.01 Multiplication
Pulling Apart
Strain Rate, s-1
+ of Wedges
Formation
of
Ridges
Wedge +
Formation
0.001
0.0001
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
(c) Strain
Fig. 9. (Continued ).
Based on the detailed observations made during the dif- wedge from the constrained matrix. With increase in strain,
ferent stages of plastic deformation, it is believed that crazes the wedges multiplied and increased in density, which led
are initially formed on the surface (and close to surface) to increase in void size (Fig. 5b, percentage of strain ∼20,
and grow inwards. On subsequent increase in strain, a stable displacement rate ∼50 mm/min). Wedges associated with
crack nucleates and propagates through an array of closely voids of different sizes can be seen in Fig. 5b and c. At this
spaced crazes resulting in tearing along the bundle of crazes. stage, there was, however, no clear indication of debonding
In general, the rate of nucleation and growth of craze and of the filler particles from the matrix during this stage. Un-
the mode of fracture depends on the strain rate of the ten- like N1 (Fig. 3), in W1, localized deformation bands and
sile test. Since crazes grow from opposite surfaces and take crazes were absent. The filler particles presumably altered
time to reach the mid-thickness region, crazing/tearing was the distribution of local stress field in the polymer matrix
reduced at high strain rates. The factors that control the per- and inhibited crazing.
cent of crazing–tearing and brittle mode of fracture include Additionally, in the tensile strained regions, deformation
the rate of craze nucleation and rate of growth, the density features, which we call here as ‘ridges’ were formed perpen-
of crazes, and the ease with which the crack nucleates and dicular to the tensile direction (Fig. 5b). These wrinkle-like
grows within the craze. These factors are most likely to de- ridges are raised surface features in Fig. 5b and were formed
pend on material parameters, molecular weight and molec- in the direction in which the mineral particles were oriented
ular weight distribution. It is now established that the final in the matrix (Fig. 5b-d). The size or width of the individ-
fracture reflects the progress of deformation from the sur- ual ridges varied from 1 to 10 m. The ridges were precur-
face into the bulk [28,32–34]. sor to the debonding process. The formation of ridges can
be envisaged as follows. The presence of mineral particles
3.3.2. Wollastonite-reinforced low crystallinity reduces the plasticity of the polymer matrix and increases
polypropylene composite the rigidity or stiffness of the matrix. Thus, when the fib-
During the early stages of tensile deformation (com- rils associated with the polymer matrix are pulled along the
mencement of yielding, percentage of strain ∼10 and dis- tensile axis, the restrained plasticity increases the localized
placement rate ∼50 mm/min), wedges were formed on the stresses associated with the mineral particle. The particles
deformed surface of the specimen, parallel to the direction act as stress concentrators, and restrict the enhanced stretch-
of stress axis (Fig. 5a). The wedges nucleated at localized ing of polymer resulting in the formation of ridges. In other
stress concentration sites involving the formation of tiny words, the ridges are formed because of stress relaxation (or
voids. This is due to the initial separation of the tip of the stress release) of highly stressed localized regions.
R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315 307
With further increase in strain, the ridges developed over locally broken areas. Additionally, the microstructure of the
the entire surface of the polymer composite with consequent sample appeared porous and consisted of severely deformed
reduction in the wedge density. In some highly strained fibrils (Fig. 5f) with large and shallow voids (Fig. 5g).
local regions, tearing of the material involving ridges can At all the strain rates studied, W1 was characterized by
be seen (Fig. 5c, percentage of strain ∼25, displacement two fracture morphologies, fibrillation and brittle. The low
rate ∼50 mm/min). A close view of the tearing of the ma- magnification SEM micrograph of the fracture surface at a
terial involving ridges leading to debonding of the mineral displacement rate of 50 mm/min is presented in Fig. 6 along
particles can be seen in Fig. 5d (percentage of strain ∼25). with the corresponding high magnification micrographs of
Continued deformation resulted in excessive tearing of the the modes of fracture. Due to the high amount of hydrostatic
polymer matrix with consequent detachment of the mineral stress present in the center of the specimen, fibrillation,
particles and formation of large and shallow voids (Fig. 5e, which is drawing of a network of fibrils, is concentrated
percentage of strain ∼30, displacement rate ∼50 mm/min). in the center of the fracture surface. The large numbers
Visually, at the strain corresponding to the tearing process, of voids present on the fracture surface are a consequence
the sample gradually became translucent and then opaque of debonding and detachment of particles from the matrix
as the strain whitening set in. With further increase in surface, which resulted in enhanced stress whitening of the
strain, the strain whitened area began to spread over the en- polymer composite. Furthermore, the area fraction of fib-
tire surface of the sample. However, the intensity of strain rillation decreased with increase in strain rate of the tensile
whitening was far less than that observed for neat low crys- test with consequent increase in the area fraction of brittle
tallinity polypropylene. SEM micrographs of the severely region, in a manner similar to neat polypropylene, where
stress-whitened zones (at a percentage of strain ∼35, dis- percentage of area fraction of crazing–tearing decreased
placement rate ∼50 mm/min) in wollastonite-reinforced with consequent increase in area fraction of brittle region.
polymer are presented in Fig. 5f and g. At this strain, the The area fraction of fibrillated region decreased from 60%
tearing and debonding process was also associated with at a displacement rate of 50 mm/min to 30% at a displace-
Fig. 10. SEM micrographs of tensile deformed neat high crystallinity polypropylene (N2) showing the sequence of events leading to the disentanglement
of the fibrils at selected displacement rates and percentage of strains of (a) 50 mm/min and percentage of strain ∼30, formation of deformation bands, (b)
125 mm/min and percentage of strain ∼30, distinct array of crazes, (c) 125 mm/min and percentage of strain ∼30 (another location), and (d) 380 mm/min
and percentage of strain ∼40, showing the separation of deformation bands/crazes from the constrained matrix.
308 R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315
ment rate of 380 mm/min. The change in deformation mode 3.3.3. Talc-reinforced low crystallinity polypropylene
from a combination of crazing–tearing/brittle fracture to composite
fibrillation/brittle mode of fracture is believed to be due The tensile deformation processes observed in talc-rein-
to the change in state of stress in polymeric material in a forced low crystallinity polypropylene (T1) were similar
way such that fibrillation/yielding is promoted before craz- to wollastonite-reinforced low crystallinity polypropylene
ing. This change in stress state may be caused due to the (W1). The sequence of deformation events in T1 at a
addition of mineral particles to the polymer matrix. displacement rate of 50 mm/min and at different strains
Fig. 11. SEM micrographs of the fracture surface of neat high crystallinity polypropylene (N2) at a displacement rate of ∼50 mm/min identifying
the different fracture modes involved (brittle, craze-tearing, and brittle with ductile pulling of fibrils) (a) and their corresponding high magnification
micrographs ((b) crazing–tearing, (c) brittle fracture, (d) brittle fracture with ductile pulling of fibrils).
R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315 309
3.3.4. Neat high crystallinity polypropylene region. On continued deformation (e.g. 380 mm/min and
The tensile deformation behavior of neat high crys- percentage of strain ∼40), the deformation bands/crazes
tallinity polypropylene (N2) was similar to that of N1. At separated from the constrained matrix in the direction of
lower strains, N2 was characterized by deformation bands tensile axis (Fig. 10d).
(Fig. 10a, displacement rate of 50 mm/min and percentage In N2, three modes of fracture (brittle fracture, crazing–
of strain ∼30) that developed into distinct array of crazes tearing, and brittle fracture with ductile separation of fib-
with increase in strain (Fig. 10b, displacement rate of rils) were observed at lower displacement rates of less than
125 mm/min and percentage of strain ∼30). These closely ∼50 mm/min (Fig. 11a, displacement rate ∼50 mm/min).
spaced deformation bands/crazes are opaque planes and ap- However, at displacement rates greater than ∼50 mm/min,
pear as white streaks in stress-whitened material (Fig. 10c, only brittle mode of fracture was observed. Fig. 11b shows
percentage of strain ∼30, displacement rate ∼125 mm/min) the SEM micrograph of crazing/tearing region. Fine craz-
in a manner similar to N1. During the craze growth, a crack ing and tearing along the array of crazes can be seen. Craz-
can propagate through the array of crazes tearing them apart, ing/tearing mode of fracture occurred at some distance away
thereby increasing the opaqueness of the stress-whitened from the center of the fracture surface in comparison to
Fig. 13. Low magnification SEM micrograph of the fracture surface of wollastonite-reinforced high crystallinity polypropylene (W2) tensile tested at a
displacement rate of ∼50 mm/min (a) along with the high magnification micrographs of the two modes of fracture, fibrillation (b, c) and brittle (d, e)
showing voiding and detached mineral particles.
R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315 311
N1. Higher magnification SEM micrograph of brittle region 3.3.6. Talc-reinforced high crystallinity polypropylene
(Fig. 11c) indicates that even though the brittle fracture re- composite
gion is smooth, occasionally voids were observed. These Analogous to the behavior of wollastonite-reinforced high
voids are associated with an unidentified nucleating agent, crystallinity polypropylene (W2), wedge mode of deforma-
which are added to provide large number of nucleation sites. tion was absent in T2 and tensile straining initiated with
SEM micrograph of brittle region with ductile pulling of ridges. An illustration of this is presented in Fig. 14a, at a per-
fibrils at a displacement rate of 50 mm/min presented in centage of strain ∼10 and displacement rate of ∼50 mm/min.
Fig. 11d suggests that this region is similar to the brittle
region in N1 (Fig. 4c). Even though the region appears to
be brittle, there are a large number of unbroken fibrils that
continued to plastically deform as decohesion of fibrils pro-
gressed. It is also relevant to note here that atomic force
microscopy of the brittle region indicated that it involves re-
organization of microstructure signifying reduced stretching
of fibrils resulting in an irregular surface morphology at the
micrometric scale [26].
With increase in strain, ridge density increased (Fig. 14b, polypropylenes, similar to high crystallinity W2. The de-
percentage of strain ∼15) and on increased straining, tear- formation processes observed as a function of percentage
ing of ridges occurred with consequent debonding of the of strain and deformation rate for neat, wollastonite- and
talc particles, formation of shallow voids, and locally bro- talc-reinforced high crystallinity polypropylenes are sum-
ken polymer matrix (Fig. 14c, percentage of strain ∼20, dis- marized in Fig. 16.
placement rate ∼50 mm/min). The features of the fracture of Additionally, in a recent study on the effect of wollas-
T2 (Fig. 15) were essentially similar to that of T1 (Fig. 8). tonite and talc on the scratch behavior of polypropylenes,
However, the severity of voiding was significantly lower than talc-reinforced polypropylene exhibited significant inter-
T1 and the percentage of fibrillation was also less in rela- laminar delamination [35]. The high shear stress generated
tion to T1. The decrease in percentage of fibrillation in T2 is during the scratch was attributed to the delamination be-
again related to higher tensile modulus of high crystallinity havior of talc. Low Mohs hardness of talc reduced the
Fig. 15. Low magnification SEM micrograph of the fracture surface of talc-reinforced high crystallinity polypropylene (T2) tensile tested at a displacement
rate of ∼50 mm/min (a) along with the high magnification micrographs of the two modes of fracture, fibrillation (b, c) and brittle (d, e) showing voiding
and detached mineral particles.
R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315 313
scratch hardness of composite in relation to wollastonite- It is important to note that wedge mode of deforma-
reinforced polypropylenes and contributed to a deeper tion, which is generally characterized by extensive plastic
scratch and more scratch visibility (optical opacity or stress flow, was absent in both wollastonite- and talc-reinforced
whitening). Although, there was an increase in percentage high crystallinity polypropylenes (W2 and T2) consistent
of bulk crystallinity of reinforced polypropylenes over neat with partially brittle mode of fracture and lower percent-
polypropylenes, it causes embrittlement of the material and age of strain-to-fracture. However, irrespective of the nature
contributes to debonding and stress whitening. of reinforced-mineral (wollastonite or talc), the characteris-
Brittle Fracture
Brittle Fracture
0.1 Splitting of Fibrils/Microfibrils + +
Ductile Pulling
Multiplication of Crazes
Strain Rate, s-1
+
Pulling of Formation of
Fully Deformation Bands Secondary Crazes
Elastic +
Crazing
Brittle Fracture
0.01 +
Crazing/Tearing
+
Formation of Ductile Pulling
Deformation Bands
0.001
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
(a) Strain
0.1
Fibrillation
+
Brittle Fracture
Associated with
Debonding
0.01
Excessive Tearing
-1
Strain Rate, s
Formation of
of Ridge Ridges
Ridges Multiplication
+
Tearing
of
0.001 Fully Ridges
Elastic
0.0001
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25
(b) Strain
Fig. 16. Domains of deformation processes as a function of strain and strain rate in (a) neat high crystallinity polypropylene (N2), (b) wollastonite-reinforced
high crystallinity polypropylene (W2), and (c) talc-reinforced high crystallinity polypropylene (T2).
314 R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315
0.1
Ridge
Multiplication
Fibrillation
+
+
Tearing
Brittle Fracture
of
Associated with
Ridges
Debonding
0.01
Formation
Strain Rate, s-1
of
Ridges
Excessive Tearing
0.001 of
Ridges
Fully
Elastic
0.0001
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
(c) Strain
tics of the fracture of low and high crystallinity polypropy- bands, which developed into closely spaced crazes. Fi-
lenes were retained in micrometric-reinforced composites. nal separation occurred by tearing along individual bun-
Additionally, crazing, which contributes to stress whiten- dle of crazes growing from opposite faces resulting in
ing in neat polypropylenes was not observed in reinforced crazing–tearing at the edge and brittle mode of fracture
polypropylenes. Instead, excessive tearing and straighten- in the center. The percentage of craze-tearing decreased
ing of ridges produced fibrillated structure and detachment with increase in strain rate with consequent increase in
of minerals with consequent formation of voids contribut- brittle fracture.
ing to stress whitening in polymer micrometric composites. (d) In wollastonite- and talc-reinforced low crystallinity
The deformation maps presented in Figs. 9 and 16 provide polypropylenes, plastic deformation processes initiated
a broad perspective of the micromechanisms of deforma- with wedge-shaped microcracks, followed by ridges
tion that occur in different strain rate–strain regimes and that were formed due to stress relaxation. Further strain-
enable a relative comparison to be made between different ing led to the tearing of material along the ridges with
materials. consequent debonding/detachment of mineral particles.
At the debonding strain, the tearing and detachment
process was accompanied by localized breaking of
4. Conclusions polymer matrix. Additionally, the microstructure of the
sample appeared porous and consisted of severely de-
(a) In the presence of reinforcement, the crystallization formed fibrils with interdispersed voids. However, in
process is accelerated and there is an increase in per- comparison to wollastonite-reinforced low crystallinity
centage of crystallinity of polypropylenes, which can polypropylene, in talc-reinforced low crystallinity
be attributed to enhanced nucleation in the presence of polypropylene, the density, size, and stress relaxation
minerals. Also, talc-reinforcement has higher nucleat- associated with ridges was consistently greater.
ing capability than wollastonite-reinforcement. (e) The center of the fracture surface in wollastonite- and
(b) Reinforcement of polypropylenes with wollastonite talc-reinforced low crystallinity polypropylenes was
and talc increased the tensile modulus or stiffness of characterized by fibrillation, while the surrounding ar-
polypropylenes and reduced the percentage of strain- eas away from the center was characterized by brittle
to-fracture. fracture.
(c) Tensile deformation processes in neat polypropylene (f) Neat high crystallinity polypropylene exhibited a sim-
initiated with the formation of localized deformation ilar sequence of deformation events as neat low crys-
R.S. Hadal et al. / Materials Science and Engineering A 372 (2004) 296–315 315
tallinity polypropylene. However, the final fracture was [15] E. Ferrage, F. Martin, A. Boudet, S. Petit, G. Fourty, F. Jouffret,
predominantly brittle. P. Micoud, P. De Parseval, S. Salvi, C. Bourgerette, J. Ferret, Y.
Saint-Gerard, S. Buratto, J.P. Fortune, J. Mater. Sci. 37 (2003) 1561.
(g) In wollastonite- and talc-reinforced high crystallinity [16] J. Gonzalez, C. Albano, M. Ichazo, B. Diaz, Eur. Polym. J. 38 (2002)
polypropylenes, wedge mode of deformation was ab- 2465.
sent and tensile straining initiated with ridges because [17] S. Hambir, N. Bulakh, J.P. Jog, Polym. Eng. Sci. 42 (2002) 1800.
of high rigidity of the polymer matrix. Subsequent [18] B. Fillon, A. Thierry, B. Lotz, J.C. Wittman, J. Therm. Anal. 42
deformation resulted in tearing of the ridges and for- (1994) 721.
[19] A.M. Chatterjee, F.P. Price, J. Polym. Sci.: Polym. Phys. Ed. 13
mation of shallow voids and locally broken polymer (1975) 2385.
matrix. The features of the fracture were essentially [20] R.J. Young, P.A. Lowell, Introduction to Polymers, 2nd ed., Stanley
similar to reinforced low crystallinity polypropylenes. Thornes Ltd., Cheltenham, 1997, p. 177.
(h) Reinforcement of polypropylenes with wollastonite al- [21] P.Z. Wang, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge, 2002.
tered the primary mechanism of stress whitening from [22] M.G.A. Tijssens, E. van der Giessen, L.J. Sluys, Int. J. Solids Struct.
37 (2000) 7307.
crazing–tearing to ridge-tearing mode of deformation. [23] A. Dasari, J. Rohrmann, R.D.K. Misra, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 358
(2003) 372.
[24] A. Dasari, J. Rohrmann, R.D.K. Misra, Macromol. Mater. Eng. 287
(2002) 889.
References [25] A. Dasari, S.J. Duncan, R.D.K. Misra, Mater. Sci. Technol. 18 (2002)
685.
[1] E.P. Giannelis, R. Krishnamoorti, E. Manias, Adv. Polym. Sci. 138 [26] A. Dasari, S.J. Duncan, R.D.K. Misra, Mater. Sci. Technol. 18 (2002)
(1999) 107. 1227.
[2] C.B. Ng, B.J. Ash, L.S. Schadler, R.W. Seigel, Adv. Comp. Lett. 10 [27] A. Dasari, J. Rohrmann, R.D.K. Misra, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 360
(2001) 101. (2003) 237.
[3] C.B. Ng, L.S. Schadler, R.W. Seigel, Nan. Mater. 12 (1999) 507. [28] A. Dasari, J. Rohrmann, R.D.K. Misra, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 351
[4] R.W. Seigel, S.K. Chang, B.J. Ash, J. Stone, P.M. Ajayan, R.W. (2003) 200.
Doremus, L.S. Schadler, Scripta Mater. 44 (2001) 2061. [29] E.P. Giannelis, Adv. Mater. 8 (1998) 29.
[5] O. Okada, A. Usuki, Mater. Sci. Eng. C3 (1995) 109. [30] M. Sumita, T. Shizuma, K. Miyasaka, K. Ishikawa, J. Macromol.
[6] Z. Wang, T.J. Pinnavaria, Chem. Mater. 19 (1998) 1820. Sci. Phys. Ed. B 22 (1983) 601.
[7] C.M. Chan, J. Wu, J.X. Li, Y.K. Cheng, Polymer 43 (2002) 2981. [31] A. Dasari, R.D.K. Misra, Microscopic aspects of surface deformation
[8] X. Kornmann, H. Lindberg, L.A. Berglund, Polymer 42 (2001) 1303. and fracture of high density polyethylene, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, in
[9] X. Kornmann, H. Lindberg, L.A. Berglund, Polymer 42 (2001) 4493. press.
[10] H. Wang, C. Zeng, M. Elkovitch, J. Lee, K.W. Koelling, Polym. [32] T.R. Steger, L.E. Nielsen, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. Phys. Ed. 16 (1978)
Eng. Sci. 41 (2001) 2036. 613.
[11] J.W. Gilman, T. Kashiwaga, J.E.T. Brown, S. Lomankin, E.P. Gian- [33] A. Dasari, R.D.K. Misra, The role of micrometric wollastonite parti-
nelis, E. Manias, in: Proceedings of the 43rd International SAMPE cles on stress whitening behavior of polypropylene composites, Acta
Symposium, Part I, vol. 43, 1998, p. 1053. Mater., in press.
[12] J. Sveda, R. Evanzin, Int. Polym. Sci. Technol. 11 (1984) 4. [34] A. Dasari, S. Kolluru, J. Rohrmann, R.D.K. Misra, Mater. Sci. Tech-
[13] A. Dasari, J. Rohrmann, R.D.K. Misra, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 367 nol. 19 (2003) 1289.
(2004) 248. [35] A. Dasari, J. Rohrmann, R.D.K. Misra, Susceptibility to scratch
[14] A. Dasari, J. Rohrmann, R.D.K. Misra, Scratch deformation charac- surface damage of wollastonite- and talc-containing polypropy-
teristics of micrometric wollastonite-reinforced ethylene–propylene lene micrometric composites, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, submitted for
copolymer composites, Polym. Eng. Sci., in press. publication.