Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Geology
Vol 91, 1996,pp. 1209-1224
U-PbGeochronology
andNd andPb IsotopeCharacteristics
of theAu-Ag-Rich
EskayCreekVolcanogenic
Massive
SulfideDeposit,BritishColumbia
FIONA CHILDE
MineralDeposit
Research
Unit,Department
of Eclrth(l•l(tOceanSciences,
University
of BritishColumbia,
6339Stores
Road,
Vancouver,British Columbia, Canada V6T 1Z4
Abstract
The EskavCreekdeposit
is anAu-Ag-rich
volcanogenic
massive
sulfidedeposit
located
withinthe Iskut
River
area
oFnorthwestern
British
Columbia.
AtEskay
Creek
beds
ofAu-Ag-rich
clastic
sulfides
andsulfosalts
hostedwithinthecontact argillite
areunderlainbythevariably alteredEskayrhyolite, whichhosts stockwork
mineralization,
andoverlainby the barrenhanging-wall basalt.The Eskayrhyolitehasyieldeda Middle
Jurassic
U-Pbzirconageof 175_+2 Ma.Interaction textures between theEskay rhyoliteandcontact argillite,
whichimplyeraplacement of the rhyolitepriorto lithification
of the argillite,alongwithprobable local
derivation
ofbedded sulfideclastsindicate
a MiddleJurassic ageformineralization, some7 to 16m.y.younger
thanintrusion-related
LowerJurassic mineralization withinthe region.The datapresented in thisstudy
demonstratethat thereis a second andsignificantperiodof Jurassic mineralization withinthe IskutRiver
area.
0361-0128/96/1866/1209-1655.00 1209
1210 CHILDE
SULPHURETS
CAMP
LEGEND
•F• Tertiary
COAST PLUTONIC COMPLEX
-• Middle
BOWSER Jurassic
LAKE GROUP
\ r-• EarlyJurassic
iNTRUSIVEROCKS +
+
__
[] EarlytoMiddle
HAZELTON Jurassic
GROUP
[] INTRUSIVE
Upper Tria,•lc
ROCKS
•[] STUHINI
Upper Triassic
GROUP
+
+
+
I Paleozoic•
STIKINEASSEMBLAGE km
I
+
+
+
+
+ +
FIG.1. LocationmapoftheEskay
Creekdeposit,
IskutRiverarea,northwestern
British
Columbia,
showing
themajor
stratigraphic
units,miningcamps,
deposits,
andoccurrences
(afterMacdonald
et al.,1996).
•IAsbmonFormotion
InlTu•ive,o•
I felsito '-;
-.'i:.'-.'
(10wet
..'?.'-;:
.:.'-:
Bajodon
-.'....-
toLower
Collovian)
E•:,v
•'o•
..::'.•....'.'....'... '.'.--
;.::i;i;
:!:i;
(Aalenien
to
Lower
Bejocion)•akuto•
from :'":':'12'A
R or•llite
&turbOtic Mocdonoldetd.,
1992)
::.':-'::...•:.•. //
• baf•Dgwallbasalt
o minerolized
- •'•"
z• :::';'.!,•';
:.;'-i
'.::
:'./!i:';!:
con•
_,• creek/a'er ".•_2•_
•. : ::
• foof•tlvolc•cunit
• Creek
Fom•r•.:'::.'.::'::.'.:..'::.'.::'::.'.'
.• ::'i:•.•
• o•lesite
•.•:om,,,•
ß•i•,•.•
brecoo
ovettoin
by
::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
, ?.
;i.'::...-i:.'::..:;;"-..m•.'.
'...:.".
'.-•..'i:.': ,,.•'.
!•;:;.'.!:.;:;.'.!:.:;;'.!'.•.:.:.::i/•
%•,,v'-
(inpart
Hettongian
I:-]a•!l•eou•to•lo•era•
:'.'.'.':'..'.'A
.'.'.'.'.'.''v- • 17•+/2A4o
. . •-,,,_• ,-.._,
/,,, ,,3,
i!i!;:i
{i!;:i
!i{;:i
;.i!;:i{i!;:i
!i!::i
{i!;:i
{:!;:i
;" ,, --/
============================ ::•::.::..:-:.-" v
:..• :'.:.{ •'.:.-.'.ß'.:...'
ß
..'.:..: ..'.:..• .ß'.: ':'.: . V.VVV
::Z-Z:.'::.•:.'::-::.' :Z-::.'::-:::::-::.: ß
: ...' : .-,' : .-.' : .-.- : .-.- : .-.- ; vvvvv
::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.
'-'.: "-'-: "-'- '-"-'- 'ß"-'-: "-'- '. •':vv vv v
ßß::-:::
'
:z-z:.'::-::.'::.:'
.... ' ......
'" :::" VVVVVV
".': ".':ß".':-".':-"-': :v
.-..... .•t'v
ß.::.-:-.::.-:-.::.-:-.::.-:-.::.-: vv
: .-.-..
::Z.:::::.::.'::-':'
.........
.':':Z•
. - - . ß
....
vvvvvvvvvvv
'' '
ß"
' '''"' '""' '""-'"""' vv•vvvvv'v
':-' ".':-'/.':-' ".':' ' ".'l•,d' .'
.:. ::.-:-.::..:-.::.-:..::...•:•:.-
vvv
,.,. :.:.'.::.:.'.'.:.:.'.:.'.:• .'.:
.:.:...;.:...:.:-..:.:-.,•-_. ,,,,•¾.,,,,.•.•
,,•,:. ß
Fzc. 2. Geology
of the Proutplateau,showing
locationsof selected
mineralized
zonesprojected
to surface
(after
Edmunds andKuran,1991;Bartsch,
1993;andP. Lewis,pers.commun., 1996)ß
West
Limb East
Limb
0 I 2 3 4 5 6 7
a
b CENTIMETRES
FIC.4. Photographs
of (a)blackmatrixbreccia,
showing
flow-bandedrhyolitefragment
in a blacksilicified
matrix;(b)
flow-bandedeastlimbrhyolitewithaphaniticmatrixandquartzandfeldspar
phenocrysts;(c) 2lB zoneargillite-hosted
elastic sulfide and sulfosalt mineralization.
mineralization,
whichmayin partrepresent
feederzonesto langerite,
andothersulfosalts
(Roth,1995).Well-preserved
clasticmineralization,occursbelowthe stratiformmineraliza- featuressuchas gradedsulfidebedswith sharplydefined
tionin the 109,Pumphouse andPathfinder zones,andalong bases, soft-sediment deformation of the sulfide beds and
strikeat the EmmaandMackayadits(Fig.2). channel structures attest to the clastic nature of the ore
At present,the 21Bzoneis the focusof miningat Eskay within a high-energy,channel-likeenvironment(Roth,
Creek.It is anelongatezone,approximately 900m long,60 1995).Theproximity of stockwork zonesto clasticmineral-
to 200mwideandI to 15m thick,composed ofwell-bedded izationandthe presence of alteredrhyolitefragments in-
fragmental sulfides, argillite,alteredrhyoliteand terbedded
sulfosalts, withsulfidefragments suggest localderivation of
baritehosted withinthecontactargillite(Brittonet al.,1989; clasticsulfidesand sulfosalts(Macdonald et al., 1996). The
Roth,1995;Fig. 4c). The mainore mineralsare sphalerite distribution and mineralogy of the mineralized zonesare
andtetrahedrite,withlesserfriebergite,galena,pyrite,bou- outlinedin Figure5; detaileddescriptions areprovided by
1214 CHILDE
LEGEND
Stratiform mineralization
hosted
incontact
argillite.
[] 21A
Zone:
stibaite.
re•ar<innebar
lens
21B& Northeast
Extension
Zones:
21C
Zone
•
,,• 21C
Zone:
Hang•
woll
(HW)
.Z.o•e:.
chalco•rite
Discordant mineralization
hosted
•;:.
in footwall
ß.:,'.
rhyolite.
21AZone:
•sseminetedstitmite-rea•gar.
21B
Zone
•--••
'•••-z• /
21AZone
• .. .... . _,•
[] Pumpbouse-Pa#•der
Zones:
:...:...:..:..:.:'::-.-:.
..., /
I 109Zone:
pydte-c•kopyrite•arbon
veins
,,._..
...... ß
,.
/
200 100 0 1oo 200
FIC.5. Projection
to surface
of mineralized
zonesat the EskayCreekdeposit
(courtesy
of Homestake
CanadaInc.).
TABLE 1. U-PbZirconAnalytical
Datafor the EskayandEastLimbRhyolites
Isotopic
ratios
(_+10.,
%)6 Isotopic
dates
(Ma,-----20')
6
Wt U Pb'2 '2ø•Pb/ pb4 20spb5
Fraction
1 (pg) (%)
(mg) (ppm) (ppm) '2ø4pb3 2ø•pb/23SU 207pb/s3s
U 238U/20spb
'207pb/SOspb 207pb/23s
U '207pb/'206pb
Eskayrhyolite(EC-GC-11)
A, f, M5, eq 0.045 2,858 71 975 216 8.5 0.02525 + 0.13 0.1726 + 0.32 0.04957 +_ 0.22 160.8 _+ 0.4 161.7 + 0.9 174.8 _+ 10.3
D, f, M5, eq 0.034 3,071 77 4,388 39 7.9 0.02573 _+ 0.11 0.1757 _+ 0.22 0.04954 q- 0.13 163.8 q- 0.3 164.4 _+ 0.7 173.5 +_ 6.1
E, f, M5, eq 0.052 2,198 84 2,317 118 8.2 0.02663 _+ 0.11 0.1821 + 0.14 0.04959 +_ 0.07 169.4 _+ 0.4 169.8 +__0.4 175.8 +_ 3.1
F, f, M5, eq 0.034 3,608 77 4,388 39 7.9 0.02554 ñ 0.10 0.1745 ñ 0.27 0.04955 _+ 0.18 163.8 _+ 0.3 163.3 +_ 0.8 173.5 +_ 6.1
G, m, M5, eq 0.010 6,790 173 2,450 45 8.1 0.02589 +_ 0.14 0.1770 _+ 0.27 0.04959 +_ 0.18 164.8 +_ 0.4 165.5 ñ 0.8 176.0 +_ 8.5
Eastlimbrhyolite
(EC-GC-03)
Morphology
1:subhedral,
equantto prismatic
A, m, N1, eq 0.062 444 112 1,446 33 11.5 0.02743 _+ 0.10 0.1885 q- 0.25 0.04984 q- 0.17 174.5 +_ 0.3 175.4 +_ 0.8 187.8 ñ 8.0
B, f, N1, eq 0.115 426 12 3,390 25 11.0 0.02729 + 0.10 0.1869 + 0.22 0.04968 _+ 0.15 173.6 _+ 0.3 174.0 ñ 0.7 180.2 +_ 6.8
C, m, M1, eq 0.115 434 12 4,312 20 11.3 0.02728 q- 0.10 0.1864 q- 0.21 0.04954 + 0.12 173.5 ñ 0.4 173.5 _+ 0.6 173.6 _+ 5.6
D, f, M2, eq 0.104 405 11 4,143 18 11.0 0.02749 +_ 0.10 0.1881 q- 0.20 0.04963 q- 0.19 174.8 _+ 0.3 175.0 _+ 0.7 177.9 _+ 5.5
L, f, N1, eq 0.123 313 9 5,693 12 11.5 0.02736 q- 0.11 0.1881 q- 0.20 0.04987 + 0.12 174.0 +_ 0.4 175.0 q- 0.6 188.7 _+ 5.7
Morphology
2: euhedral,
needles
I, f, M5, e* 0.134 1,725 46 2,947 118 18.4 0.02384 ñ 0.11 0.1628 ñ 0.13 0.04952 q- 0.07 151.9 q- 0.3 153.2 _+ 0.4 172.7 ñ 3.0
J, f, M5, e* 0.080 5,710 155 2,520 281 18.2 0.02461 ñ 0.13 0.1683 ñ 0.16 0.04989 + 0.07 156.7 + 0.4 157.9 +_ 0.5 175.8 +_ 3.4
K, f, M5, e 0.025 2,448 67 1,172 82 18.4 0.02477 q- 0.08 0.1693 q- 0.17 0.04956 q- 0.13 157.8 +_ 0.2 158.8 q- 0.5 174.5 + 6.0
1Allfractions
airabraded unlessmarkedby*; grainsize,intermediate
dimension:m = <134/•mand>74/•m, f = <74/•m;magnetic codes: Franzmagnetic
separator
sideslopeat whichgrainsarenonmagnetic,e.g.,N1 = nonmagnetic
at 1ø;fieldstrength
forall fractions
= 1.SA;frontslopeforall fractions
= 20ø;grain
character
codes:e = elongate,eq = equantto prismatic
.2Radiogenic
Pb
3Measured ratiocorrectedforspikeandPbfraetionationof 0.0043/A.M.U.
ñ 20%(Dalycollector)
4Totalcommon Pbin analysisbasedonblankisotopiccomposition
• RadiogenicPb
6CorrectedforblankPb,U, andcommon Pb(Staeey-Kramers modelPbcomposition atthe2øTPb/2ø6pb dateoffraction,
or ageof sample)
0.O29
affinity(Fig.8b).Regionally, rhyolitefromtheSalmon River
Formation in theIskutRiverarearanges froma calc-alkaline
IEskoyrbyolite
•///*/ to tholeiiticaffinity(A. Kaip,pers.commun.,1995).The
Eskayporphyry, withZr/Yratiosof 6 to 13,hasa transitional
0.027
175
+/-2
Mo • 170 to calc-alkalineaffinity(Bartsch,
Rare earth elements
1993).
Rareearthelement(REE)concentrations arepresented in
0.025
Table2 andcompared withtherangeof REEconcentrations
determined fortheselithologies andtheEskayporphyry by
Bartsch (1993;Fig.9a,b, andc). TheEskayrhyoliteexhibits
a slightenrichment in thelightREE buta near-fiat pattern
o fortheheavyREE, anda negative curopium anomaly; rhyo-
litefromtheeastlimbsampled in thisstudyexhibits
a similar
207 235
REE pattern(Fig. 9a). Theserelativelyflat REE patterns
Pb/ U suggest thatbothrhyolites aretheproducts of primitive
tho-
leiiticmagmas, asa resultof eitherpartialmeltingof sialic
0.029
I East
limb
rbyolite
I 'so/// crustor fractional
itedcomponent
crystallization
of basaltic
magma. Aninher-
to the zirconin the eastlimbrhyoliteindi-
catesthatthisrhyolitecontains somecomponent of partial
• o.0:s . • eubedr•
•• ' shapedzircon
• subbedrolequont
toprismafir
zirron
o.o%.• , o.b ' 0.20
TABLE
2. Major,Trace,andBareEarthElement,
andNd Isotope
DataforSamples
fromtheEskay
Anticline
Neutron activation
Massspectrometry
Sm(ppm) 6.28 8.60 3.62
Nd 27.26 30.39 10.88
147Sm/144Nd 0.1394 0.1712 0.2011
14•Ndfi44Nd
(incas.) 0.512791+ 4 X 10 • 0.512888_+11 X 10 • 0.512997+ 7 x 10-•
ENd[174
Ma) +4.3 +5.5 +6.9
T•m (Ma) 542 634
lOOO lOOO
o EC-GC-03, east limb rhyollte
'1
o EC-GC-03, east limb rhyolite
[] U-5•, 15.2 m, Eskay rhyolite [] U-5•, 15.2 m, Eskay rhyolite
lO lO
norm:chon
I I i I I
La Ce Pr Nd Sm Eu(Gd)Tb Dy Ho Er Tm Yb Lu La Ce Pr Nd Sm Eu(Gd)Tb Dy Ho Er Tm Yb Lu
lOOO 1000
o EC-GC-03. east limb rhyolite o EC-GC-03, east limb rhyolite
[] U-5•, 15.2 m, Eskayrhyollte [] U-58,15.2m, Eskayrhyollte
shaded area represents field ß CA90-527, 54m,
for rhyolltesfrom the east limb hangingwall basalt
reported by Bartsch (1993) shaded area represents field
lOO 100
fo• hangingwall basalts
reported by Ek•tsch (1993)
lO 10
La Ce Pr Nd Sm Eu(Gd)Tb Dy Ho Er Tm Yb Lu La Ce Pr Nd Sm Eu(Gd)Tb Dy Ho Er Tm Yb Lu
FIc. 9. Chondorite-normalized
REEdiagrams showingEskay
andeastlimbrhyolites
andhanging-wall
basalt,
compared
withdatafieldsfor samples
reported
by Bartsch
(1993).
12 Metal source
.......... N.•OftB
I0 Presentlythere is no clear consensus
on the principal
source of metals within ancient and modern submarine volca-
8
nogeniemassive sulfidedeposits. The metalswithinthese
depositsmaybe leachedfromunderlying volcanicandsedi-
mentary strata,derivedfrommagmatic sources,orsomecom-
binationof thesetwoprocesses (forexample, Doe andZart-
man,1979;Lydon,1988;Stanton,1990;Large,1992;de
2 Ronde,1995;Hustonet al.,1995).A reviewbyLydon(1988)
I• =Eskay
Creek concludes thata leaching modelfor the derivationof metals
in volcanogenie massive sulfidedepositsis supportedby ex-
400 300 200 I00 0
perimentalandcomputer-based studies,
observationof sea-
Time floor basalts,and similaritiesof basemetal ratiosof mineral-
F•G. 10.
izationwith thoseof the dominanthostlithologies.
Initial e•a valuesand associatederrors for volcanicrocksfrom
Stable
theEskayanticline.ShownforreferencearefieldsforPaleozoic
to Mesozoic and radiogenicisotope studies
havebeen cited as evidence
arcassemblages of theStikine
terrane,
uncontaminated island-arcvolcanic forderivationofmetalsfromboththeleaching ofstratabelow
rocks(uIAV) ø'6'7,
andmidocean ridgebasalts(normalMORB) s, evolution the ore deposit(for example,Thorpeet al., 1981;Fehnet
curvesfor uIAV and normal MORB are shownin dashedand solid lines, al., 1983;Lydon,1988)and,to a lesserextent,magmatic
respectively.
HG = felsicvolcanic,
andmarieto felsicintrusive
rocksof the fluids (de Ronde, 1995 and references therein). Stanton
HazeltonGroup•'2'3,
SG= marie volcanic
andinOxtsiverocksoftheStuhini
GroupTM,SA= marie to felsicvolcanic
rocksof theStikine
assemblageTM (1990)arguedfor significantmagmatic inputfor metalsand
References:•Samson (1990),3M.L.BevierandR.G. fluidsto volcanogenie
et al. (1989),2jackson massivesulfidedeposits,
citingasevi-
Anderson.(pets.commun., (1994),
4Childe
(unpub. data),SNodahandWas- dence:(1) the concentration of mineralized
zonesat specific
setburg(1981),6DePaolo andWasserburg (1977),7Hawkesworth et al. horizons, asopposedto throughouta volcaniccycle;(2) the
(1993),SJahn
et al.(1980)).
apparent discrepancybetweenthe generally smallersizeof
basalt-hosted
volcanogenie massive sulfidedeposits relative
to largerandesitc-to rhyolite-hosted volcanogenie massive
platemargins (Smellie,1995).Withinthe immediate Eskay sulfidedeposits(giventhe abundance of sea-floor basalts);
Creekarea,the interpretation of rhyoliticmagmas erupting and (3) variationsin metalratiosin volcanogenie massive
alonglinearfissure ventzones,controlonthefaciesdistribu- sulfideorebodies relativeto potentialsourcerocks.Differ-
tionof volcanic andsedimentary rocksbyregional andlocal encesin the Se/Sratiosof pyritein Cu-richand Cu-poor
faultblocks, andthe transitionto deep-marine sedimentarymineralization areconsistent witha component of the sulfur
sequences followingthe cessation of volcanismhavebeen in volcanogenie massive sulfidedeposits beingderivedfrom
suggested to indicateformation in eithera back-arc
or intra- a magmatic hydrothermal sources(Hustonet al., 1995).
arc basinenvironment(Bartsch,1993). The trace and REE Leadisotope data,in combination withotherinformation,
chemistry, andNd signature of theEskayrhyolite andhang- maybe usedto constrain the source of lead,andby analogy
ing-wallbasaltareconsistent with formationin an island-arc othermetalsin volcanogenie massive sulfidedeposits (Gul-
environment. son,1986).In describing a modelfor the generation of ore
Thehanging-wall basaltischaracterizedbyatholeiiticmag- fluidsbyleachingof metals fromoceanic crust,Lydon(1988)
maticaffinity. BothREE andNd isotope dataindicateenrich- suggestedthatthe orecomponents to the fluidsarenotde-
ment of the basaltrelativeto normalMORB, consistent
with rived from the immediate footwall to mineralization, but
minorcontamination fromanenriched MORB-type source. ratherfromdepthsof 0.5 to 3 km belowthe palcosea floor,
REE patterns andZr/Yratiosindicate a tholeiitic magmaticwellbelowthe presentlevelof exposure in the Eskayanti-
affinityfor the Eskayrhyolite, whereas coevalrhyolites on cline.Basedon knownstratigraphy in the IskutRiverarea,
the east limb have transitional to calc-alkaline affinities. Re- the basement to the EskayCreekdepositat thesedepths
gionally otherrhyolites of the SalmonRiverFormation have maybe composed of volcanic
andsedimentary rocksof the
morecalc-alkaline affinities(A. Kaip,pers.commun., 1995). UpperTriassicStuhiniGroupandPaleozoic Stikineassem-
Rhyolites at EskayCreekmaybe theproducts of fractional blage,andtheirintrusive equivalents.
Leadisotope analyses
crystallizationof mariemagma, partialmeltingof sialiccrust, ofpotassium feldspar fromDevono-MississippianandUpper
or some combination of these two sources. Barrett and Sher- Triassicintrusiverocksfrom the Iskut River area,when calcu-
lock(in press)havenotedthat Nb/Zr ratiosareinconsistentlatedforwardto the MiddleJurassic, showsystematically less
withderivation of theEskayrhyolite entirelyasa product of radiogenicleadisotopecompositions thando EskayCreek
fractional
crystallizationofthehanging-wall basalt,indicatingsulfides(M.L. Bevierand R.G. Anderson, pers.commun.,
that thisunit mayhavesomecomponent of partialmelt. 1994;Childe,unpub.data;Fig. 11).Thesedataindicatethat
Zirconinheritance in rhyolitefromtheeastlimbimpliessome leachingof leadfromsuchsources wouldnot resultin the
component of crustalcontamination withinthisunit.A more isotopicsignature documented for EskayCreek sulfides.
evolved magmatic affinityandNd isotope signature for the EskayCreeksulfides partiallyoverlapthe clusterfor Lower
eastlimbrhyolitewouldsuggest thatthisrhyoliteeitheras- Jurassicintrusions andmineralization in the IskutRiverarea
similateda greater component ofpartialmelt,or slightly
less andpartiallylie in a regionthatismoreprimitive, indicating
juvenilesialiccrust,thandidthe Eskayrhyolite. derivationfromeithera Loweror MiddleJurassic source.
ESKAY CREEK VMS DEPOSIT, B.C. 1221
Uppercase
letterandnumberrefers
tosample
number,
lower
caseletterrefers
tofraction
number
Mineral
abbreviations:
boul= boulangerite,
cp= chalcopyrite,
gl= galena, py= pyrite,
sph= sphalerite
Errorsarequoted
atthe23 (95%confidence)
level
Valuesarecorrected
forinstrument
fractionation
bynormalization
based
onreplicate
analyses
oftheNBS-981
standard
LeadleachedfromLowerJurassic intrusions
of the Texas bletodeterminewhichoftheselattertwopotential
reservoirs
Creekplutonicandpremierporphyrysuites,suchas the istheprincipal
source
of leadandothermetalsin the Eskay
Eskayporphyry,couldcontribute leadconsistentwith the Creekdeposit.
observed isotopic
signature of EskayCreeksulfides. How-
ever,for intrusions
of thisageto be a principal Modemanalogue8
source of
metalswithinthedeposit theywouldneedtohavebeensig- Studies
ofmodernsea-floor
hydrothermalventfieldsdocu-
nificantly
moreextensive at depththantheirexposurein the
mentthedevelopment
of sulfide
mounds andchimneys over-
Eskayanticlinemaysuggest. Alternatively,
leadderivedfrom
lyingstockwork
zoneshostedwithinalteredvolcanicrocks
a MiddleJurassic
magmaticsource
couldalsoproducethe (for example,Hanningtonet al., 1986;Herziget al., 1993;
leadisotope
signature
of EskayCreeksulfides.
A potential Gemmell,1995).Mineralizationat EskayCreekmayhave
source of MiddleJurassic
magmatic fluidsistheEskay rhyo- formedin a similarmanner, withdegradation of accumula-
lite.Withoutabetterknowledge
ofthebasement totheEskay tionsof sea-floor sulfides
producing the gradedsulfideand
Creekdeposit at thedepths
at whichleaching isbelievedto sulfosalt bedspreserved withinthedeposit.Recently discov-
takeplace,anda clearerunderstanding of the sourcesof eredexhalative, gold-rich
polymetallic
sulfidemineralization
metalstovolcanogeniemassive
sulfidedeposits,
it isnotpossi- within back-arebasinsof the western Pacific,such as the
1222 CHILDE
2.•2
2.•9
ß
ENFM 0Ma
•C•'
0•o• D
9B
9 H
•9 Jurassic
•
_Q 2,04 2.036
0,81•x'2J
e•or
0.8297
0.8287
Q- 2,03
c•,-
.• Eskay
Creek
2,02
• average error
direction
oferror
due to fracfionc•on
Cluster
2.01 • I
0,810 0.814 0.818 0,822 0.826 0.830 0,832
2ø7pb/2pb
Fro. 11. '2ø7pb/2ø6pb
vs.'2øspb/2ø•Pb
diagram
for sulfide
andsulfosalt
samples
fromthe Eskayanticline.
Shown
for
reference areLowerJurassic andTertiaryfieldsfor the IskutRiverandStewartareasof the Stikineterrane(Alldricket
al., 1987;Godwinet al., 1988;J.K.Mortensen, unpub.data),uppercrustalandorogene growthcurves(Zartmanand
Haines,1988),andfeldspar fromUpperTriassic (T) andDevonian (D) intrusive
rocksin the Stikineterrane,calculated
to 175Ma, assuming (=9.74)and(=3.78;M.L. BevierandR.G.Anderson, pers.commun., 1994;Childe,unpub.data).
B = 21 B zone,E = Emmaadit,F = footwall volcanic unit,H = hanging-wallzone,M - Mackayadit,N = northeast
extensionzone,P = pathfinder zone,9 = 109zone.Notethatmoreradiogenic samplesplotcloserto the originonthis
diagram.
lead,andpresumably
othermetals,fromeithera Loweror the easternManusBasin,PapuaNew Guinea:PACRIMCongress, 1995,
Proceedings,p. 49-54.
MiddleJurassic
source. Blackwell,J.D., 1989,EskayCreekproject:Exploration review,1932 to
1989:Blaekwell MineralExplorationConsultants Ltd.,Reportto Calpine
Acknowledgments Resources andConsolidated StikineSilverLtd., 5 p.
Thiscontributionrepresents doc- Britton,J.M.,Blackwell,
a portionof the author's J.D.,andSehroter, T.G., 1989,//21zonedeposits,
toralthesis, withthe MineralDepositResearch lumbia,1989:B.C.Ministryof Energy,MinesExploration
in association EskayCreek,northwestern BritishColumbia: in BritishCo-
andPetroleum Resources,
Unit (MDRU) Volcanogenic Massive SulfideDepositsof the p. 197-223.
Cordillera
Project, andEngi- Childe,
fundedbytheNaturalSciences F.,Barrett,
T.J.,an•MeGuigan,
P.J.,
1994,
TheGrandue
volca-
neeringResearch Councilof Canada(NSERC),the Science nogeniemassive sulfidedeposit,northwestern BritishColumbia:U-Pb
Councilof BritishColumbia, ages and Pb isotope
andelevenmemberminingand gramwithAbstracts, relations
labs.l:
Geological Societyof AmericaPro-
p. A-381.
mineralexplorationcompanies. Supportto the authorwas Davies,A.G.S.,Lewis,P.D., andMacdonald, A.J.,1994,Stratigraphic
and
partlythroughan NSERCdoctoralscholarship. structural
settingof mineraldepositsin the BracejackLakearea,north-
The author wishes to thank Ron Britten, David Kuran, westernBritishColumbia:
CanadaGeological
SurveyPaper94-A,p. 37-
Henry Marsden,and AndrewKaip of HomestakeCanada 43.
Ltd.forsharingtheirwealthofknowledge oftheEskayCreek DePaolo, D.J., 1988,Neodymium
Berlin,Springer-Verlag,187p.
isotopegeochemistry, an introduction:
deposit,andfor accessto maps,company reports,
anddrill DePaolo,D.J.,andWasserburg, G.J.,1977,The sources of islandarcsas
core.Thisstudybenefitedgreatlyfromthe workof Roland indicatedby Nd andSr studies:Geophysical Research Letters,v. 4, p.
Bartsch,PeterLewis,JamesMacdonald, andTina Rothas 465-468.
partof the MDRU Metallogenesis of the IskutRiverArea defloor
Ronde,C.E.J.,1995,Fluidchemistry
hydrothermal systems
andisotopic
and associated
characteristics
VMS deposits:
of sea-
Potentialfor
Project.The assistance
of RichardFriedmanin the analysis magmatiecontributions: Mineralogieal Association of CanadaShort
of U-Pbsamples andinterpretation
of U-Pbdataisgratefully CourseNotes,v. 23, p. 479-509.
acknowledged.RegTh•riaultisacknowledged forNdisotope Doe, B.R., and Zartman, R.E., 1979, Plumboteetonies:The Phanerozoie,in
analyses
of samplesfromEskayCreek.Geologicalsoftware Barnes,H.L., ed.,Geochemistryof hydrothermal
oredeposits,
2nd.:Wi-
ley,New York,p. 22-70.
developed
bythelateJ.C.Roddick
assisted
in theplotting
of Edmunds,F.C., andKuran,D.L., 1991,TOK-KAYandGNC 1991explora-
U-Pb data. M.L. Bevier and R.G. Anderson are thanked for
tionprogram,
geological
anddiamond
drillingprogram:
PrimeResources
access
to unpublished
isotope
datafromtheIskutRiverarea. Groupinternalreport.
JohnThompson, JimMortensen, andTim Barrett,andtwo Edmunds, F.C., Kuran,D.L., andRye,K.A.,1994,The geology
of the 21
Economic Geology
reviewers
arethankedfortheirthoughtful zonedeposits at EskayCreeknorthwestern
BlackHillsWesternRegional Conference
BritishColumbia,
on Precious
Canada:
Metals,Coaland
reviews,which have greatlyimprovedthis manuscript. the Environment, 5th,p. 154-175.
MDRU contribution number P-073. Fanre,G., 1986,Principles
of isotope
geology:
NewYork,JohnWileyand
Sons,Inc., 589 p.
April 17, September
24, 1996 Fern, U., Doe, B.R., and Delevaux,M.H., 1983, The distributionof lead
REFERENCES
isotopesandthe originof Kurokooredeposits in the Hokuroko District,
Japan:ECONOMIC GEOLOGY MONOGRAPH 5, p. 488--506.
Alldrick,D.J.,1991,Geology andoredeposits of theStewart miningcamp, Gemmell, J.B.,1995,Comparison ofvolcanic-hosted massive sulfidedeposits
BritishColumbia: Unpublished Ph.D.thesis, Vancouver, Canada, Univer- in modemandancientback-arc basins:Examples fromsouthwest Pacific
sityof BritishColumbia, 347p. andAustralia: PACRIMCongress, 1995,Proceedings, p. 227-232.
Alldrick,D.J.,Mortensen, J.K.,andArmstrong, R.L., 1986,Uranium-lead Godwin,C.I., Gabites,J.E., andAndrews, A., 1988,Leadtable: A galena
agedeterminations in the Stewartarea(104B/1):BritishColumbiaMinis- leadisotopedatabasefor the CanadianCordillera,with a guideto its
try of Energy,MinesandPetroleum Resources Paper1986-1,p. 217- useby explorationists: BritishColumbiaMinistryof Energy,Minesand
218. Petroleum Resources Paper1988-4, 188p.
Alldrick,D.J.,Gabites,
J.E.,andGodwin, C.I., 1987,Leadisotope datafrom Grove,E.W.,1986,Geology andmineraldeposits of theUnukRiver-Salmon
theStewart miningcamp(104B/1): BritishColumbia Ministryof Energy, River-Anyox area:BritishColumbia Ministryof Energy,MinesandPetro-
MinesandPetroleum ResourcesPaper1987-1,p. 93-102. leumResources Bulletin63, 434 p.
Anderson, R.G.,1989,A stratigraphic,plutonic andtructuralframework for Gulson,B.L.,1986,Leadisotopes in mineralexploration: Amsterdam, Else-
the IskutRivermaparea(NTS 104B),northwestern BritishColumbia: vier, 244 p.
Canada GeologicalSurvey Paper89-1E,p. 145-154. Hannington,M.D., Peter,J.M., and Scott,S.D., 1986,Goldin sea-floor
Anderson, R.G.,andThorkelson, D.J.,1990,Mesozoic stratigraphy
andset- polymetallic sulfidedeposits:ECONOMIC GEOLOGY, v. 81,p. 1867-1883.
tingfor somemineraldeposits in IskutRivermaparea,northwesternHarland,W.B.,Armstrong, R.L.,Cox,A.V.,Craig,L.E., Smith,A.G.,1990,
BritishColumbia: Canada GeologicalSurvey Paper90-1F,p. 131-139. A geologic timescale,1989:GreatBritain,Cambridge UniversityPress,
Barrett,T.J.,andMacLean, W., 1994,Chemostratigraphy andhydrothermal 263 p.
alterationin exploration
forVHMSdeposits in greenstonesandyounger Hawkesworth, c.J., Gallagher,K., Hergi,J.M., andMcDermott,F., 1993,
volcanic
rocks:Geological
Association
of CanadaShortCourseNotes,v. Mantleandslabcontributions in arcmagmas: AnnualReviewof Earth
11, p. 433-467. andPlanetary ScienceLetters,v. 21, p. 115-120.
Barrett,T.J.,andSherlock,
R.L.,in review,Geology of Henderson,
andgeochemistry J.R., Kirkham,R.V., Henderson, M.N., Payne,J.G.,Wright,
the EskayCreekdeposit, northwestern BritishColumbia,(submitted
to T.O.,andWright,R.L.,1992,Stratigraphy andstructure
oftheSulphurets
Exploration andMiningGeology). area,BritishColumbia:CanadaGeological SurveyPaper92-1A,p. 323-
332.
Bartsch,
R.D., 1993,Volcanic
stratigraphy
andlithogeochemistry
of the
LowerJurassic HazeltonGroup,hostto the EskayCreekprecious and Herzig,P.M., Hannington, M.D., Fouquet,Y., yon Stackelberg, U., and
basemetalvolcanogenic deposit:Unpublished M.Sc.thesis,Vancouver, Petersen, S.,1993,Gold-rich polymetallic sulfidesfromtheLaubackarc
Canada,Universityof BritishColumbia, 178p. andimplications for thegeochemistry of goldin sea-floor hydrothermal
Binns,R.A.,andScott,S.D., 1993,Activelyformingpolymetallie sulfide systems of the southwest Pacific:ECONOMIC GEOLOGY, v. 88, p. 2182-
deposits
associatedwith felsievolcanic
rocksin the easternMariusback- 2209.
arebasin,
Papua NewGuinea: ECONOMIC GEOLOGY, v.88,p.2226-2236. Huston, D.L., Sic, S.H., Suter, G.F., Cooke, D.R., and Both, R.A., 1995,
Binns,R.A.,Parr,J.M.,Scott,S.D.,Gemmell,J.B.,andHerzig,P.M., 1995, Trace elements in sulfide minerals from eastern Australian volcanic-hosted
PACMANUS:An active,siliceous volcanic-hosted
hydrothermalfieldin massive sulfidedeposits: PartI. Protonmicroprobe analyses of pyrite,
1224 CHILDE
chalcopyrite, andsphalerite,andPartII. Selenium levelsin pyrite:Com- Nodah,S.,andWasserburg, G.J.,1981,Nd andSrisotopic studyof volcanic
parison with•534S values andimplications forthesource of sulfurin volca- rocksfromJapan:EarthandPlanetary Science Letters,v. 52,p. 264-276.
hOgchic hydrothermal systems: ECONOMIC GEOLOGY, v. 90, p. 1167-- Roth,T., 1993,Geology,alterationand mineralization in the 21A zone,
1196. EskayCreek,northwestern BritishColumbia: Unpublished M.Sc.thesis,
Hutchison, C.S., 1974,Laboratory handbook of petrographic techniques: Vancouver, Canada, Universityof BritishColumbia, 229p.
NewYork,JohnWileyandSons,Inc.,527p. --1995, Mineralization andfaciesvariation in the EskayCreek21 zone
Jackson, J.L., 1990,Tectonicanalysis of the Nisling,northernStikineand polymetallic sulfide-sulfosalt
deposit,northwestern BritishColumbia
northernCacheCreekterranes,Yukonand BritishColumbia:Unpub- [abs.]:Geological Association-Mineralogical Association of CanadaPro-
lishedPh.D.thesis,Phoenix, Arizona,University of Arizona,200p. gramwithAbstracts, p. A-91.
Jahn,B.-M.,Griffiths, B., Chariot,R., Cornichet,J.,andVidal,F., 1980,Nd Rye,K., 1992,Geological andgeochemical reportonthe 1991EskayCreek
andSrisotopic compositions andREE abundances of Cretaceous MORB diamond drillrelogprogram: International Corona Corporation, Internal
(holes417Dand418A,legs51,52 and53):EarthandPlanetary Science report.
Letters,v. 48, p. 171-184. Samson, S.D.,McClelland, W.C., Patchett, P.J.,Gehrels,G.E., andAnder-
son,R.G.,1989,Evidence fromneodymium isotopesformantlecontribu-
Kirkham,R.V.,and MargoBs, J., 1995,Overview of the Sulphurets area, tionsto Phanerozoic crustalgenesis in the Canadian Cordillera: Nature,
northwestern BritishColumbia: Canadian Instituteof MiningandMetal- v. 337, p. 705-709.
lurgySpecial Volume46, p. 473-498. Smellie, J.L.,ed., 1995,Volcanism associated withextension at consuming
Large,R.R.,1992,Australian volcanic-hosted massive sulfidedeposits:Fea- platemargins: London, The Geological Society,293p.
tures,styles, andgeneticmodels: ECONOMIC GEOLOGY, v. 87, p. 471-- Stanton, R.L., 1990,Magmatic evolution andtheoretype-lava typeaffilia-
510.
tionsofvolcanic exhalative
ores:Geology ofthemineraldeposits ofAustra-
Looke,G., McDonough, W.F., Goldstein, S.L.,andHoffman, A.W.,1990, lia andPapuaNew Guinea: Australasian Instituteof MiningandMetal-
Isotopiccompositions of volcanic glasses from the Lau basin:Marine lurgyMonograph 14,p. 101-107.
Mining,v.9,p.235-245. Steiger, R.H.,andJ•iger, E., 1977,Subcommission ongeochronology: Con-
Lydon,J.W.,1988,Volcanogenic massivesulfidedeposits Part2: Genetic vention ontheuseof decayconstants in geo-andcosmochronology: Earth
models:Geoscience CanadaReprintSeries3, p. 155-181. andPlanetary Science Letters,v. 14,p. 359-362.
Macdonald, A.J.,vander Heyden,P., Lefebure,D.V., andAlldrick,D.J., Sun,S.S.,andMcDonough, W.F., 1989,Chemical andisotopicsystematics
1992,Geochronometry of the IskutRiverarea-- an update:BritishCo- of oceanic basalts:
Implications
for mantlecomposition andprocess: Geo-
lumbiaMinistryof Energy,MinesandPetroleum Resources
Paper1992- logicalSocietySpecial Publication 42, p. 313-345.
1, p. 495-501. Sunkel,G., 1990,Originof petrological andgeochemical variationsof Lau
Macdonald, A.J.,Lewis,P.D., Thompson, J.F.H.,Nadaraju,G., Bartsch, basinlavas(SWPacific): MarineMining,v. 9, p. 205-234.
R.D., Bridge,D.J., Rhys,D.A., Roth,T., Kaip,A., Godwin,C.I., and Th•riault,R.J.,1990,Methods forRb-SrandSm-Ndisotopic analyses atthe
Sinclair,A.J.,1996,Metallogeny of anEarlyto MiddleJurassic
arc,Iskut geochronology laboratory:
Canada Geological Survey Paper89-2,p. 3-6.
River area, northwesternBritish Columbia:ECONOMICGEOLOGY,v. 91, Thorpe, R.I., Franklin,
J.M.,andSangster, D.F., 1981,Evolutionof leadin
massivesulfideoresof Bathurstdistrict,New Brunswick,Canada:Institute
p. 1098-1114.
MacLean, W.H., and Kranidiotis,P., 1987, Immobile element as monitors
of MiningandMetallurgy Transactions, sec.B, p. B55-B56.
Volpe,A.M.,Macdougall, J.D.,andHawkins, J.W.,1988,Laubasinbasalts
of masstransferin hydrothermalalteration: PhelpsDodgemassive sulfide (lbb):Traceelementand Sr-Ndisotopic evidence for heterogeneityin
deposits,Matagami, Quebec: ECONOMIC GEOLOGY, v. 82,p. 951--962. backarcbasinmantle:EarthandPlanetary ScienceLetters,v. 90,p. 174-
Mortensen,J.K.,Ghosh,D.,K., andFerri,F., 1995,U-Pb geochronology 186.
of intrusive
rocksassociated withcopper-gold porphyry depositsin the York,D., 1969,Least-squaresfit of a straightline withcorrelated errors:
Canadian Cordillera:CanadianInstituteof MiningandMetallurgy Special EarthandPlanetaryScience Letters,v. 5, p. 320-324.
Volume46, p. 142-158. Zartman,R.E.,andHaines,S.M., 1988,The plumbotectonic modelfor Pb
Nadaraju,G.T., 1993,Triassic-Jurassicbiochronologyof the easternIskut isotopicsystematics
amongmajorterrestrial reservoirs--acasefor bi-
Rivermaparea,northwestern BritishColumbia: Unpublished M.Sc.the- directional
transport:
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,v.52,p. 1327-
sis,Vancouver, Canada,University of BritishColumbia, 223p. 1339.