Document1 PDF

s
A7 udha iyer :
[M
:2
]1
Medicines.overcome natural diseases by virtue of being capable of producing similar artificial state to the natural disease
state and by creating a stronger impact. No dissimilar diseases whether produced by nature or by medication can ever
cure natural.diseases afflicting the vital firce.
DELETED joined group via invite link
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:6
]4
sudha iyer
>
Medicines.overcome natural diseases by virtue of being capable o

>
:+1::+1:
S
- unday, February 25, 2018 -
DELETED joined group via invite link

Rohan Pran joined group via invite link
D6 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
P0
:4
2
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 34 Sixth Edition The greater strength of the artificial disea

>
The master discovered many things like in field of physics,medicine ,chemistry e.g. potentisation,miasms,similia etc here
he guide us about which should be given more imp then other.indeed potentisation was a breakthrough discovery (still we
are not at that much advancement) but its not the only one to achieve cure.we see some people practicing like thuja 30
will give result if not go for 200 and if not go for 1m etc.and also repeatation.
Here he clearly states the power
Power of medicine is useless untill its { HYPERLINK "http://simillimum.so/" \t "_blank" } please dont run behind
speculations by tom dick and harry just try to understand organon.master has given almost everything:smile:have a happy
sunday.
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:2
]9
Dipen Vaishnav
>
The master discovered many things like in field of physics,medic

>
:+1::+1:
- onday, February 26, 2018 -
M
K2 ailas Salunkhe :
[M
A3
4
:1
]7
:+1:
T
- uesday, February 27, 2018 -
edited
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 34 Sixth Edition The greater strength of the artificial disea

>
SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE
COMMENTS on Aphorism 34
Two important qualities of medicine required in the process of cure are its strength and symptom similarity as not only
greater strength but similarity of symptoms corrects the derangement of vital force as vital force itself could not react to
natural morbid force so it can be corrected by applying similar artificial morbid force in more strength in form of indicated
medicine of case which can remove the natural disease caused by derangement of vital force.
Even in natural process when one disease disappear under the influence of other then later should be intense as well as
similar to former one.
e.g.
Eczema on leg disappeared after appearance of suppurating ulcers at same site , here similarity is both diseases have a
action on skin.
Remedy employed in high potency with least similarity mostly results into worsening of disease while remedy with
maximum similarity but with insufficient dose of potency usually produce unsatisfactory result.
Sulphur 30 , 200 as a constitutional remedy failed to relieve blackish spots of fungal origin but Sulph10M cured it
completely.
Ars.alb relieved itching of eczema on face in some extent but Sepia as a holistic remedy of case cured the eczema.
( From clinical desk of Dr.Samadhan Ghule )
s
P:2 udha iyer :
[M0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE COMMENTS on Aphorism

>
:ok_hand::ok_hand::clap::clap:
R
P2 upali:
[M
:4
0
]1
Nice example of aphorisms

W
- ednesday, February 28, 2018-
D
A6 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:pray::pray::pray:
D
A2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]8
35
In order to illustrate this, we shall consider in three different cases, as well what happens in nature when two dissimilar
natural diseases meet to in one person, as also the result of the ordinary medical treatment of diseases with unsuitable
allopathic drugs, which are incapable of producing an artificial morbid condition similar to the disease to be cured, whereby
it will appear that even Nature herself is unable to remove a dissimilar disease already present by one that is
unhomoeopathic, even though it be stronger, and just as little is the unhomoeopathic employment of even the strongest
medicines ever capable of curing any disease whatsoever.
D7 r.Shradha:
[M
A0
8
:5
]9
Can any one give ,

some examples of half Acute disease.
D
A5 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:2
0
]1
D
P0 r.Shradha:
[M
3
:4
]2
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Photo
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand:
s
P4 andhya sahu:
[M
:1
]3
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
nice
D
P5 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
8
:2
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
Nice explanation:+1::ok_hand:
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:5
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
35 In order to illustrate this, we shall consider in three dif

>
Here Master Hahnemann discussed different possibilities when two forces meet together.
First condition is when two dissimilar natural diseases meet together , in second condition when one treat natural diseases
with unsuitable allopathic drugs, which are incapable of producing an artificial morbid condition similar to the disease to be
cured.
Even nature could not remove first disease condition by other strong disease which is not Homeopathic to first one so only
similar disease condition with some more strength can remove the existing natural disease.
In further two aphorisms Master would discuss what will happen under above mentioned conditions.
D0 r.Nasir kureshi :
[M
P5
9
:3
]8
:+1::+1:
D0 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P2
1
:5
]8
:pray::pray::pray:
DrSamadhan Ghule invited Dr.Megha Suneja
T
- hursday, March 1, 2018 -
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A3
5
:2
]8
§ 36
I. If the two dissimilar diseases meeting together in the human being be of equal strength, or still more if the older one be
the stronger, the new disease will be repelled by the old one from the body and not allowed to affect it. A patient suffering
from a severe chronic disease will not be infected by a moderate autumnal dysentery or other epidemic disease. The
plague of the Levant, according to Larry,1 does not break out where scurvy is prevalent, and persons suffering from
eczema are not infected by it. Rachitis, Jenner alleges, prevents vaccination from taking effect. Those suffering from
pulmonary consumption are not liable to be attacked by epidemic fevers of a not very violent character, according to Von
Hildenbrand.
1 Mémoires et Observations, in the Description de l' Egpte, tom. i.
D
A4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 36 I. If the two dissimilar diseases meeting together in the

>
All is the matter of energy ! Weaker or stronger determines the existence and survival of anything. Stronger always
replaces the weaker one it is simple and factual law of nature.
What happen when two dissimilar diseases meeting together ? Obviously stronger one replaces other !
Master explained this fact with different examples in reference with old records of literature. Person suffering from severe
chronic disease will not be infected by autumnal dysentery or any other epidemic disease. According to Larry persons
already suffering from survey or eczema are not susceptible to take infection of plaque. Rachitis prevents vaccination from
taking effects. According to Von Hildenbrand patient of pulmonary tuberculosis are not liable to take infection of moderate
epidemic fevers.
D4 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
A2
8
:0
]1
:+1::+1::+1:
edited
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
8
:0
]1
CASE OF FISTULA
An old age man consulted me for his complaints of fistula ( though he said piles but actual case of fistula ) .
P/ H -- 2 - 3 years ago fistula operated two times.
H/ O : -- Asthma < winter since 5 years.

H/O : -- Burning micturition since 5- 6 months.
Thirst + frequent
Thermal not clear.
Desire meat.
Family history of asthma.
Dr - Say please !
Pt - have a piles. ( actual case of fistula )
Dr - What is happening ?
Pt - Operated twice. It is not going. In these 5 - 6 months it increased. Spotting on Dhotar ( male wearing ).
Dr - OK.
Pt - Stool--- , it is not inside but at corner aside.

( telling about location of fistula )
Spotting on dhotar so thought once have to try ( treatment )whatever be the result.
Dr - OK.
Pt - I was admitted in hospital. He ( indicating toward his villager friend ) came and asked me what happened ? I said this
and this pile complaints I have , twice operated . What to do now ? Then he said me , don't go for operation. Let come with
me. Yesterday only I had to come but he said me , today is Sunday so off day , we will go tomorrow(smiling )
( his friend was talking about my clinic )
His friend - Is there hole aside or not ?
Pt - yes , it is there. spotting on dhotar. Why to talk untrue ?
His friend - Yes , say only true.
Pt - Yes , Spotting is there so not possible without hole.
Dr - How like that spotting ?
Pt - White. ( pus or mucous discharge from fistula ) and urine is hot and burning. Weakness in extremities.
Dr - What is pile complaints now ( purposely I asked in his conceptual term )
Pt - Nothing but burning urine , and hot legs burning.
Dr - What is complaints of stool ?
Pt - Nothing but have a komb (growth )and nothing in stool.
( Actually peoples use to refer komb ( growth ) about external piles but this fellow have a fistula still mentioning as a
komb )
Dr - What do you feel about this ?
Pt - Feel angry about self. How did it got to me ? Why did it chasing me ?
Dr - Is there any tension taking this problem ?

Pt - Now I think whatever be would happen I would not care .
Dr - Means ?
Pt - live or die !
Dr - Why do you think so ?
Pt - Then what to do ? Already two times operated still it is following me. So I got admitted in hospital then this my friend
told me that nothing is there to get so much harassed and he brought me here.
Dr - Is there any other tension ?
Pt - Nothing but only this complaint. Had no use of operations.
Dr - How is nature ?
Wife of Pt - Strict !
Dr - Strict means ?
Wife of patient - Angry , ask me not to talk someone or not to go somewhere .

Meal should be ready at 7am otherwise he use to go without food.
Work out the case to select the remedy .
D
P3 r. Abhishek Deshpande:
[M
5
:4
]2
:tulip:NUX VOMICA
DD- LYCO, SULPHUR
N
P4 ilesh Thaker :
[M
:2
]3
LYCOPODIUM
Anger with himself:point_up_2:
edited
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:0
]3
Dr. Abhishek Deshpande

>
Photo
>
Please explain Gambling ?

Delusion enlarged ?
D
[M
:1
]3
Spotting on dhotar once try whatever b tbe result
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]3
OK. good :+1:

Also think of other aspect from his health point of view.
D
[M
5
:2
]3
Discouraged
D
P9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]3
Once try whatever be the result - Gambling -- :ok_hand:nice perception.

>
Discouraged
>
Good .
Through this thinking how he approached his disease ?
Think on this . You would get one more rubric.
D
[M
:5
]3
Right sir:+1::+1:
Discouraged alternating with hope

D:6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P ]3
Though he is in discouraged situation how is he dealing with his condition ?

>
Discouraged alternating with hope

>
No word he uttered of hope.

Do you think this much understanding is there in this fellow ?
D
[M
:8
]3
He is trying one more time with a hope of cure
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:8
]3
Think of patient at all levels - emotional , intellectual and physical .

>
He is trying one more time with a hope of cure

>
No , he said he don't care whatever would be happen.

Its not hope.
D
[M
:9
]3
Ya right sir my mistake

[M
P ]3
How is patient intellectually ?

Here is the remedy !
Do you think this fellow is intellectual like Lyco or Sulph

through his dialogues ?
D
[M
1
:4
]3
No
P
P0 ooja Kshirsagar :
[M
2
:4
]3
Anger on himself,anxiety dark,delusion persecuted.
Fastidious
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:4
]3
One more information I would like to share here that he was railway worker. He just used to do work and his wife manage
all family affairs including economy.
P
[M
0
:4
]3
Workoholic.... Anxiety business
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:4
]3
Totality of all rubrics never give us remedy but we should be trained when and how one should use specific rubrics.
D
[M
1
:4
]3
Right sir
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]3
How much role of particular physical rubrics , how much role of physical generals and how much role of mind disposition
in given case ? And according to that one has to proceed.
The first thing we should learn that is to sort out SSUPS from case and to confirm it with overall case. It is an art to enter
in remedy of case by SSUPS with further conformation as a holistic remedy of case.
If you just collect all the rubrics without getting its core with systematic understanding of whole case then you
may wander away from a remedy of case.
D0 r. Abhishek Deshpande:
[M
P1
9
:4
]3
Ok
Can we take morose here
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
9
:4
]3
Always my purpose is not just tell you remedy with some rubrics but the process how to deal with individual case.
Every individual case has its own way to deal with according to data available before us .
First try to understand disease in person and person in disease , how is original person and how does he react
in diseased condition , that is try to get all the characteristic of disease expressed in a particular individual.
P
[M
1
:5
]3
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Every individual case has its own way to deal with according to
>
:ok_hand:
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
]3

>
Can we take morose here

>
You can but it is a big general rubric including almost 347 medicines.
D
[M
6
:5
]3
Here the person is discouraged and he doesn't care he will live or dead
This is attitude of person now

D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:0
]4
See , if you have a physical or mental characteristics in your case then don't stuck into bunch of particular physical rubrics
or big general rubrics.
Basically try to individualise the then confirm is it going with generals ?
Here general symptom is different from general rubric.
General symptom means symptom concerned with whole person either physically or mentally while general rubric means
the main big rubric ( heading rubric ) which includes a big list of medicines.
Hot - Physical general

Angry - Mental general
Any main rubric of mind and body like

Head - pain
or
Mind - Anxiety
is a general rubric.
[M
P3
2
:0
]4
Yes
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:0
]4
Once we learned the art and science of case work out then one can easily proceed through any case.

>
Photo
>
In this totality physical particulars are overestimated.
D
[M
5
:0
]4
No clear modalities??
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:0
]4
We have to be trained with when to use particular modality and when to use general modality.
D
[M
6
:0
]4
Ok
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
7
:0
]4
If particular modality is going with overall case and generals then no need to go for general modality that is why we say it
is a skill or art for form a prescriptive totality in selection of remedy.
D
[M
8
:0
]4
Ok
So we have to understand the present mental state??
Understand the patient in disease..
We have to think about the miasm as well
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:2
]4
Yes.
First try to get characteristic totality of rubrics , try to understand individual remedy , particular state remedy , miasmatic
remedy all these are different conditions should be applied according to steps of treatment. Most of time cure of chronic
case is a multi-step task. Step by step one has to proceed from good to better and finally a complete well being in this
process of cure.
[M
P1
8
:2
]4
Ok sir
D
P4 r.Nasir kureshi :
[M
1
:3
]5
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Yes. First try to get characteristic totality of rubrics , try t

>
nice explanation sir
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
3
:5
]6
Attend me here today at 9pm in group discussion of case.
IP[M]7:045 mtiyaz Bagban:
Nux vomica
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
6
:2
]7
Since many days members was asking for case discussion, today only two members actively participated !
In this crowd I would happy to share pearls of knowledge and experience with who can sense it's value.
B
P1 alivada Madhuri :
[M
8
:3
]7
M
P5 anny K:
[M
2
:4
]7
Balivada Madhuri
>
Photo
>
Which repertory is this
B
[M
:4
]7
Synthesis android version

S
P1 ikandar Pathan :
[M
2
:0
]8
D
P4 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
:0
]8
Chest complain alternating with fistula

Abscess suppuration fistula in
Extreme weakness
Urine burning.
Silicea
Main ssups what i got is history of asthma and now fistula.
D
P3 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
7
:1
]8
Dipen Vaishnav
>
Chest complain alternating with fistula Abscess suppuration fist

>
:ok_hand:nice thinking
B6 alivada Madhuri :
[M
P1
5
:2
]8
Dipen Vaishnav
>
Chest complain alternating with fistula Abscess suppuration fist

>
:+1::+1:
D
P0 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:3
]8
D
[M
:4
]8
Hello dr samadhan sir posting my second analysis based on only mental symptoms...
:tulip::tulip:MERCURIUS
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:0
]9
Hello everyone
P
P5 R Patil:
[M
2
:0
]9
Hello
jP[M]9:031 ohn:
Sulphur
D4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
7
:0
]9
First determine the principal symptoms of case , the prominent symptoms around which most of case revolves.
Principal Symptoms ?
In this case fistula and asthma these are the principal symptoms ( chief complaints ) of case but again fistula is
current burning issue of patient for which actually he consulted while he get suffer from asthma also sometimes
so it was just mentioned as history of asthma in case history of patient.
jP[M]9:034 ohn:
Fistula
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:0
]9
Yes.
All the details we get mainly focusing on principal complaint that is cause , modalities , concomitants, mind
disposition during complaints etc.
Here we focus first on fistula and all the details of it got from patient.
As usual we should search the SSUPS of case which can lead us to the remedy of case.
The way of answering of patient ?
Just think of way how did he answered the questions and here is the remedy of the case.
Take an example from case :
e.g.
When I asked about his complaints of fistula ( his supposed piles) he answered ,
Pt - Nothing but burning urine , and hot legs burning.
What do you sense through this answering of patient ?
D0 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P2
4
:1
]9
Unrelated
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:1
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Unrelated
>
Say more exactly in reference with rubric .

S0 agar Patwa:
[M
P3
5
:1
]9
Naive
D4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
6
:1
]9
No , naive means innocent. Here is the matter of intellect.
P0 R Patil:
[M
P3
6
:1
]9
Civil cannot be
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:1
]9
No , civil is the matter of social concern.
D3 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P0
7
:1
]9
Foolish
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:1
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Foolish
>
:+1::+1:
Yes , it was not sensible way of answering.
Rubric ?
D6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P0
8
:1
]9
Mind-speech-foolish
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:1
]9
Say precisely.
Was it speech ?
P3 R Patil:
[M
P4
8
:1
]9
Mind ans foolish
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:1
]9
:+1:
Put whole proper rubric with medicines .
D
P4 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
:1
]9
Mind foolish behaviour

D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:2
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Mind foolish behaviour

>
No , here no matter of behaviour.
D
P5 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
0
:2
]9
P
P4 R Patil:
[M
0
:2
]9
Mind answering foolish -Ars,bell
D
P4 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
0
:2
]9
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:2
]9
P R Patil
>
Mind answering foolish -Ars,bell

>
:+1::+1:
Hence here we got first SSUPS of case.
Record it.
D7 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P4
1
:2
]9
:+1:
jP[M]9:2148 ohn:
Answer irrelevant
P
[M
3
:2
]9
P R Patil
>
Mind ans foolish

>
:ok_hand:
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:2
]9
john
>
Answer irrelevant
>
Answering foolish is more proper rubric keeping in mind his low intellect.
Pt - Now I think whatever be would happen I would not care .
Rubric ?
edited
D1 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P5
3
:2
]9
Indifference to recovery
D6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P5
3
:2
]9
Heedless
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
4
:2
]9
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Indifference to recovery
>
To what ?
D
P3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
4
:2
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
To what ?
>
To recovery
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:2
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Heedless
>
No , heedless means not paying attention but actually he was taking treatment.
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
To recovery
>
:+1::+1:
Complete rubric ?
D6 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P3
5
:2
]9
Mind indifference recovery about his
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
Post repertorisation of these two rubrics.
D0 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P5
6
:2
]9
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:2
]9
Remedy common in between these two rubrics ?
D
P0 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
7
:2
]9
Ars
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
7
:2
]9
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Ars
>
:+1::+1:In this way even two characteristic rubrics can give us the remedy of case.
D6 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P5
7
:2
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:+1::+1:In this way even two characteristic rubrics can give us the
>
:+1::+1:
[M
P5
7
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
8
:2
]9
Let us confirm same with rest of case.

D
P0 r Avinash Gupta :
[M
8
:2
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:+1::+1:In this way even two characteristic rubrics can give us the
>
:+1:
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]9
Pt - Feel angry about self. How did it got to me ? Why did it chasing me ?
Rubrics ?
D
[M
0
:2
]9
MIND - ANGER - HIMSELF, WITH
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it.
R
P0 upali:
[M
:3
]9
Mind delusion persecuted he is
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
0
:3
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it.
As he had feel of being harassed.
D
[M
1
:3
]9
Mind- Delusion, persecuted, he is
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:3
]9
He is angry and think of being chased with feeling of harassment.
One more rubric ?
[M
P5
2
:3
]9
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:3
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Pt - Feel angry about self. How did it got to me ? Why did it ch

>
One more rubric ?
D
[M
2
:3
]9
Mind- Delusion, pursued, he is
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:3
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it.
Pt - Nothing but only this complaint. Had no use of operations.
Rubric ?
D1 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P2
6
:3
]9
Gen injuries operation ailment from
D
[M
6
:3
]9
Not getting
D7 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P4
6
:3
]9
Talking business of
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:3
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Talking business of
>
:+1::+1:
Here patient was talking of his main purpose with thought of loss and benefit.
[M
P1
7
:3
]9
:+1::+1:
R
P1 upali:
[M
7
:3
]9
Ok
P6 R Patil:
[M
P2
7
:3
]9
Objective reasonable
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:3
]9
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Gen injuries operation ailment from

>
Fistula was there before operation also.
D
P5 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
7
:3
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Fistula was there before operation also.

>
Ok
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:3
]9
P R Patil
>
Objective reasonable
>
Yes , really he did not get benefit of operation.

Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Talking business of
>
Record it.
Pt - live or die !
Spotting on dhotar so thought once have to try ( treatment )whatever be the result.
Rubric ?
D:3 r Avinash Gupta :
[M
P ]9
Bold
D
P7 r Dhan@shri:
[M
4
:3
]9
Gambling passion for

D
[M
:3
]9
Mind- gambling, passion for
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:4
]9
Dr Dhan@shri
>
Gambling passion for

>
:+1::+1:
D7 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P1
0
:4
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:+1::+1:
>
Please explain
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
0
:4
]9
Yes, gambling is try without knowing exact result.
D
[M
0
:4
]9
:+1:
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
Wife of patient - Angry , ask me not to talk someone or not to go somewhere .

Meal should be ready at 7am otherwise he use to go without food.
Rubrics ?
D5 r Avinash Gupta :
[M
P2
1
:4
]9
Fastidious
edited
D
P2 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
1
:4
]9
Censorious
D0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
1
:4
]9
:+1::+1:
R7 upali:
[M
P3
1
:4
]9
Mind fastidious
D0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
1
:4
]9
Dr Avinash Gupta
>
Fastidious
>
Record it.
P
P5 R Patil:
[M
1
:4
]9
Fastadious
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
1
:4
]9
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Censorious
>
:+1::+1:
[M
P0
2
:4
]9
Mind- dictatorial
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:4
]9

>
Mind- dictatorial
>
:+1::+1:
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Censorious
>
Record it.
>
Mind- dictatorial
>
Record it.
R
P5 upali:
[M
2
:4
]9
Plz explain censorious
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:4
]9
Mind - dictatorial
Mind - fastidious
( dictatorial - person in authority use to give order.

fastidious - want certain thing in certain way, hard to please.)
Rupali
>

>
Dr.Azam , please explain it.
P
[M
3
:4
]9
:ok_hand:
D
[M
3
:4
]9
Here patient is giving order how to behave
What to do
Dinner should be at on time
D
P2 r Dhan@shri:
[M
:4
]9
Rupali
>

>
Critical of others
R
P3 upali:
[M
2
:4
]9
What is difference between dictatorial & censorious
D
P0 r Dhan@shri:
[M
5
:4
]9
Dictatorial is dominating
D
P1 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
5
:4
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Dr.Azam , please explain it.

>
Inclination to criticize
D
[M
5
:4
]9
Dictator dictates and censorious censors
D7 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P1
5
:4
]9
Discover other faults
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
5
:4
]9
:+1::+1:
D6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P2
5
:4
]9
Dictatorial is ordering wht to do, censorious is criticising for what they hav done
[M
P2
5
:4
]9
:ok_hand:
R7 upali:
[M
P3
5
:4
]9
:+1::ok_hand:
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
Known case of fistula .
Rubric ?
D
P8 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
5
:4
]9
Rectum fistula
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:4
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it.
H/ O : -- Asthma < winter since 5 years
Rubric ?
edited
Note down there is no alteration of complaints.
[M
P1
7
:4
]9
Generals-history, personal, of asthma
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
7
:4
]9
Both are separate complaints.
P
P8 R Patil:
[M
:4
]9
Resp asthmatic winter agg
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
Take winter in more broad sense from our weather point of view.
D
[M
:4
]9
Respiration - asthmatic, cold air agg
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9

>
Respiration - asthmatic, cold air agg

>
:+1::+1:
Record it.
Now post full Repertorisation .
D
[M
:5
]9
D
P2 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
1
:5
]9
R
P4 upali:
[M
1
:5
]9
:ok_hand::ok_hand::+1::pray:
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:5
]9
Remedy of the case ?
D
P4 r Dhan@shri:
[M
2
:5
]9
Arsenic
R8 upali:
[M
P4
2
:5
]9
Ars alb
Dose:question:
P6 R Patil:
[M
P2
3
:5
]9
:+1::+1:
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
]9
Rx
Ars.alb30 stat.
Within a month all his complaints reduced significantly. After two month a dose of Ars.alb200 given with complete cure of
case.
(From clinical desk of Dr.Samadhan Ghule )
D
P4 r Dhan@shri:
[M
3
:5
]9
:ok_hand::clap::clap:
Nice learning sir:pray:
D
[M
3
:5
]9
:+1::+1::+1:
R
P1 upali:
[M
3
:5
]9
Nice teaching sir

D
[M
4
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Rx Ars.alb30 stat. Within a month all his complaints reduced

>
:ok_hand:
D
P2 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
4
:5
]9
Super explanation sir:ok_hand::ok_hand:
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:5
]9
Any query ?
D
P3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
0
:5
]9
:pray::pray::pray:
D
[M
2
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
I just missed the remedy by one rubric Indifference recovery..

Thanks for sharing and learning sir
D
P7 r Dhan@shri:
[M
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Any query ?
>
In acute exacerbation of asthma

What will be line of TT,in same case?
Same with taking totality?
edited
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
6
:5
]9
What you missed is SSUPS of case what chiefly determine the choice of remedy:blush: but very nice efforts.
Dr Dhan@shri
>
In acute exacerbation of asthma What will be line of TT,in same

>
That situation would decide it.
D
[M
7
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
What you missed is SSUPS of case what chiefly determine the choi
>
Right sir
B
[M
7
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1::+1:
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:5
]9
Any queries ?
B
[M
8
:5
]9
Nothing.. Thank you
D
P1 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Any queries ?
>
Fistula is cured completely ?
D
P2 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
:5
]9
I can not understand talking buiseness about
D
P:4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M0
]1
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Fistula is cured completely ?

>
Yes , afterward he never complained of that.
D
P:6 r.azam. Adabju:
[M0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Yes , afterward he never complained of that.

>
D
P:5 r.Kiranmayi:
[M0
]1
:+1::+1::ok_hand::ok_hand:
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1
Dipen Vaishnav
>
I can not understand talking buiseness about

>
Business is one's main purpose to do something. We generally say mind your business.
Patient talked of his main purpose ( fistula ) to consult avoiding other matter in terms of loss and benefit that is talking of
business.
D
P4 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
:3
0
]1
Got it.thnx sir:pray:
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
0
]1
Any more queries ?
D
P:4 r.azam. Adabju:
[M0
]1
Thank you sir
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
:4
0
]1
Now answer my queries :blush:

edited
Someone told as irrelevant answer, how does one differ it from foolish answer ?
Here he was talking related to his sickness ( so not irrelevant ) but what I felt is he was not getting my questions
properly so answering without sense of it that is non sense or foolish answering.
P
[M
:9
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Here he was talking related to his sickness ( so not irrelevant

>
:ok_hand:mast sir,,,, nice expln
D
[M0
]1
Why did we did not considered family history of asthma ?
D
P:5 r.azam. Adabju:
[M0
]1
Irrelevant means not related to the subject but foolish is without good judgement
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
0
]1
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Irrelevant means not related to the subject but foolish is witho

>
:+1: correct.
D
P:8 r.azam. Adabju:
[M0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Why did we did not considered family history of asthma ?

>
I think it maybe in next step of treatment
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
I think it maybe in next step of treatment

>
:+1: good.
Fistula is predominantly syphilitic while asthma is sycotic malady.

Further if needed we should consider family history of asthma to select sycotic remedy like Nat.sulph or Thuja
as a complementary of Ars in cure of asthma.
Why did not we considered desire meat ?

D8 r Avinash Gupta :
[M
P5
:6
0
]1
Ars doesn't have it
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:8
0
]1
If we have striking mental and pathological rubrics don't consider generals like food desires and aversions as eliminating
symptoms of case as those are not full proven with all our routine food items , day by day number of medicines getting
added in these rubrics so consider those rubrics just as differentiating or guiding rubrics if very marked in case.
D
[M
:2
0
]1
:+1:
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
:2
0
]1
Yes , any more queries ?
D
[M
:2
0
]1
Potency 30
Chronic case plus pathology
D
P9 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
If we have striking mental and pathological rubrics don't consid

>
:+1::+1::+1:
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1

>
Potency 30 Chronic case plus pathology

>
Yes , plus low intellect and sensitivity.
[M
P3
:2
0
]1
:+1:
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1
As we feel vitality is increased with reduction of pathology then we can go to higher potency to accomplish the cure.
D5 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P4
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
As we feel vitality is increased with reduction of pathology the

>
:ok_hand::ok_hand:
D
[M
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
As we feel vitality is increased with reduction of pathology the

>
Yes right
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P6
:2
0
]1
Later I gave Ars.alb 200 after that patient never came for same complaints.
Thanks all :pray:
D
P7 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:2
0
]1
:pray::pray::pray:
[M
P7
:2
0
]1
Thanks sir and all members :pray:
edited
D4 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P7
:2
0
]1
Thankyou:pray::blush:
[M
P8
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Later I gave Ars.alb 200 after that patient never came for same
>
:ok_hand::clap:
D
P:5 r. Akshita Gupta:
[M0
]1
Very nice case with elaborate explanation of arsenic alb:+1::+1::+1:

F
- riday, March 2, 2018 -
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A9
:5
0
]1
§ 37 Sixth Edition
So, also under ordinary medical treatment, an old chronic disease remains uncured and unaltered if it is treated according
to the common allopathic method, that is to say, with medicines that are incapable of producing in healthy individuals a
state of health similar to the disease, even though the treatment should last for years and is not of too violent
character.1 This is daily witnessed in practice, it is therefore unnecessary to give any illustrative examples.
1 But if treated with violent allopathic remedies, other diseases will be formed in its place which are more difficult and
dangerous to life.
D9 r SONAM RAISONI :
[M
P3
:4
2
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1::ok_hand:
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Photo
>
:ok_hand:
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1::ok_hand:
[M
P0
5
:3
2
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
Great :+1:
D
P0 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
:1
]2
What other think about me ? Which rubric should be taken for this feeling?
D9 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P0
4
:3
]2
Mind SENSITIVE opinion of others to the

D8 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
P4
7
:3
]2
Ok thanx.
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]3
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Mind SENSITIVE opinion of others to the

>
:+1:
edited
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:2
]4
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 37 Sixth Edition So, also under ordinary medical treatment, a

>
COMMENTS on Aphorisms 37
It is a fact that patient would never cure with allopathic medicines even though it received for long duration of time as
basically allopathy is not system of cure but of only palliation or suppression of disease so we never hope cure of any
disease from allopathic system of medicine.
Until and unless the medicine has not ability to produce similar disease condition it could not cure any disease so allopathy
fails to cure almost all diseases as it does not follow the law of natural cure by similar symptoms.
If used allopathic medicines have limited unwanted effects then it can proceed to palliate or suppress some diseases
without cure.
e.g.
I have had seen many cases of hypertension under allopathic treatment without absolute normal reading of blood
pressure even in some cases there is uncontrolled increased blood pressure in spite of taking full dose of allopathic
medicines. Some cases are there where patient suffered from complications of hypertension even though he had received
allopathic antihypertensive medicines, same about diabetes mellitus. With allopathic treatment readings of blood pressure
and blood sugar always remain fluctuating without any good end results. Maximum patients of diabetes died of
complications of diabetes only even they had received allopathic medicines so it is a fact that allopathic medicines neither
stop progress of disease nor prevent the complications.
If allopathic medicines are of more violent type like steroids which suppresses immunity and results into formation of
complicated diseases which are more difficult to treat and so dangerous to life.
R
P7 upali:
[M
2
:4
]5
:+1::+1:
D
[M
:4
]5
:+1:
D
P3 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
9
:0
]6
:+1::ok_hand:
P
[M
8
:3
]6
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE COMMENTS on Aphorisms

>
:ok_hand:
D6 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P5
2
:0
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1::+1::+1:
.P[M]7:3620 .....Haphizul Mondal.....:
s
P7 udha iyer :
[M
:6
0
]1
Nice case of arsalb:ok_hand::clap:

- aturday, March 3, 2018-
S
[M
A5
4
:0
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
Very true:+1::ok_hand:
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A4
9
:0
]1
§ 38
II. Or the new dissimilar disease is the stronger. In this case the disease under which the patient originally labored, being
the weaker, will be kept back and suspended by the accession of the stronger one, until the latter shall have run its course
or been cured, and then the old one reappears uncured. Two children affected with a kind of epilepsy remained free from
epileptic attacks after infection with ringworm (tinea) but as soon as the eruption on the head was gone the epilepsy
returned just as before, as Tulpius1 observed. The itch, as Schopf2 saw, disappeared on the occurrence of the scurvy, but
after the cure of the latter it again broke out. So, also the pulmonary phthisis remained stationary when the patient was
attacked by a violent typhus, but went on again after the latter had run its course.3 If mania occur in a consumptive
patient, the phthisis with all its symptoms is removed by the former; but if that go off, the phthisis returns immediately and
proves fatal.4 When measles and smallpox are prevalent at the same time, and both attack the same child, the measles
that had already broken out is generally checked by the smallpox that came somewhat later; nor does the measles resume
its course until after the cure of the smallpox; but it not infrequently happens that the inoculated smallpox is suspended for
four days by the supervention of the measles, as observed by Manget,5 after the desquamation of which the smallpox
completes its course. Even when the inoculation of the smallpox had taken effect for six days, and the measles then broke
out, the inflammation of the inoculation remained stationary and the smallpox did not ensue until the measles had
completed its regular course of seven days.6 In an epidemic of measles, that disease attacked many individuals on the
fourth or fifth day after the inoculation of smallpox and prevented the development of the smallpox until it had completed
its own course, whereupon the smallpox appeared and proceeded regularly to its termination.7 The true, smooth,
erysipelatous-looking scarlatina of Sydenham, with sore throat, was checked on the fourth day by the eruption of cow-pox,
which ran its regular course, and not till it was ended did the scarlatina again establish itself; but on another occasion, as
both diseases seem to be of equal strength, the cow-pox was suspended on the eighth day by the supervention of the true,
smooth scarlatina of Sydenham,8 and the red areola of the former disappeared until the scarlatina was gone, wherein the
cow-pox immediately resumed its course, and went on its regular termination.9 The measles suspended the cow-pox; on
the eighth day, when the cow-pox had nearly attained its climax, the measles broke out; the cow-pox now remained
stationary, and did not resume and complete its course until the desquamation of the measles, had taken place, so that on
the sixteenth day it presented the appearance it otherwise would have shown on the tenth day, as Kortum10 observed.
Even after the measles had broken out the cow-pox inoculation took effect, but did not run its course until these measles
had disappeared, as Kortum likewise witnessed.11
I myself saw the mumps (angina parotidea) immediately disappear when the cow-pox inoculation had taken effect and
had nearly attained its height; it was not until the complete termination of the cow-pox and the disappearance of its red
areola that this febrile tumefaction of the parotid and submaxillary glands, that is caused by a peculiar miasm, reappeared
and ran its regular course of seven days.
And thus it is with all dissimilar disease; the stronger suspends the weaker (when they do not complicate one another,
which is seldom the case with acute disease), but they never cure one another.
1 Obs., lib. I, obs. 8.
2 In Hufeland's Journal, xv, 2.
3 Chevalier, in Hufeland's Neuesten Annalen der franzosichen Heikunde, ii, p.192.
4 Mania phthisi superveniens eam cum omnibus suis phaenomenis auffert, verum mox redit phthisis et occidit, abeunte
mania. Reil Memorab., fasc. iii, v, p.171.
5 In the Edin
b. Med. Comment., pt. i, 1.
6 John Hunter, On the veneral Disease, p.5.
7 Rainey, in the Edinb. Med. Comment., iii, p.480.
8 Very accurately described by Withering and Plenciz, but differing greatly from the purpura (or Roodvonk),
which is often erroneously denominated scarlet fever. It is only of late year that the two, which were originally
very different diseases, have come to resemble each other in their symptoms.
9 Jenner, in Medicinische Annalen, August, 1800, p.747.
10 In Hufeland's Journal der praktischen Arzneikunde, xx, 3, p.50.
11 Loc. cit.
edited
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:6
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 38 II. Or the new dissimilar disease is the stronger. In this

>
In this aphorism Master Hahnemann discussed about what would happen when two dissimilar diseases come together
either of same strength or of different strength.
Stronger one dissimilar disease become active while during that period weaker one remain dormant but it become again
active as soon as stronger one finish its course of action. When two dissimilar diseases of same strength come together
one remain suspended still other is running its course of action.
Master gave examples of different diseases (e.g. measles, smallpox, itch , scurvy ,tuberculosis , typhus )
with reference of literature by different authorities where he explained how does one dissimilar disease suspends others
while running its course and how does suspended disease reappear again to run its course.
In our clinical practice we see that as we relieve present disease condition the older suspended one disease reappear again
to run its course. This logic would help us to cure the diseases radically by giving sequential treatment in multiple steps as
per appearance of totality of symptoms to achieve the complete cure.
[M
P4
1
:0
]2
:+1::+1:
P
[M
:0
]2
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:ok_hand::+1::clap::clap::clap:
D
P1 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
9
:5
]3
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1::+1::+1:
D
P8 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
1
:0
]4
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1::+1:
s
P3 udha iyer :
[M
8
:0
]4
Two dissimilar dses when they meet in human body can gv three types of reacns.
If the first ds already in body is stronger it will repel the newer less stronger one and will not allow entry into body.
If earlier one is weaker compared to newer one which is trying to invade; then the newer stronger ds will suspend the
older weaker one until it runs its course. Aft that the suspended weaker olderone will raise its head and run its course also.
If two dissimilar diseases r of equal strength; each will occupy its favourite organ or locality and thus body will.suffer the
effects of a double complex disease.
D
P3 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
9
:0
]4
sudha iyer
>
Two dissimilar dses when they meet in human body can gv three ty
>
:+1::+1:
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:1
]5
:+1::+1:
Must read following article by Dr.J.T.Kent to understand the process of case work out :
USE OF THE REPERTORY

By J. T. Kent, A. M., M. D.
As homœpathy includes both science and art, Repertory study must consist of science and art.
The scientific method is the mechanical method ; taking all the symptoms and writing out all the associated
remedies with gradings, making a summary with grades marked, at the end.
There is an artistic method that omits the mechanical, and is better, but all are not prepared to use it. The
artistic method demands that judgment be passed on all the symptoms, after the case is most carefully taken.
The symptoms must be judged as to their value as characteristics, in relation to the patient ; they must be
passed in review by the rational mind to determine those which are strange, rare, and peculiar.
Symptoms most peculiar to the patient must be taken first, then those less and less peculiar until the
symptoms that are common and not peculiar are reached, in order, from first to last.
These must be valued in proportion as they relate to the patient rather than to his parts, and used instead of
ultimates and symptoms pathognomonic.
Symptoms to be taken :
First - are those relating to the loves and hates, or desires and aversions.
Next - are those belonging to the rational mind, so-called intellectual mind.
Thirdly - those belonging to the memory.
These, the mental symptoms, must first be worked out by the usual form until the remedies best suited to
his mental condition are determined, omitting all symptoms that relate to a pathological cause and all that are
common to disease and to people. When the sum of these has been settled, a group of five or ten remedies, or
as many as appear, we we are then prepared to compare them and the remedies found related to the remaining
symptoms of the case.
The symptoms that are next most important are those related to the entire man and his entire body, or his
blood and fluids : as sensitiveness to heat, to cold, to storm, to rest, to night, to day, to time. They include both
symptoms and modalities.
As many as these as are found, also, in the first group, the mental summary, are to be retained.
There is no need of writing out the remedies not in the mental group ou summary ; these symptoms,
relating to the whole patient, cannot be omitted with any hope of success.
We must next look over all the record to ascertain which of that group are most similar to the particulars of
the regions of the body ; of the organs of the body ; of the parts ; and of the extremities.
Preference must be accorded to discharges from ulcers, from uterus during menstruation, from ears, and
from other parts, as those are very closely related to the vital operation of the economy.
Next must be used the modalities of the parts affected, and frequently these will be found to be the very
opposite of the modalities of the patient himself. A patient who craves heat for himself, generally, and for his
body, may require cold to his head, to his stomach, or to the inflamed parts, hence the same rubric will not fit
him and his parts. Hence to generalize by modalities of isolated particulars leads to the incorrect remedy or
confounds values placed upon certain remedies.
There are strange and rare symptoms, even in parts of the body, which the experienced physician learns are
so guiding that they must be ranked in the higher and first classes.
These include some keynotes which may guide safely to a remedy or to the shaping of results, provided that
the mental and the physical generals do not stand contrary, as to their modalities, and therefore oppose the
keynote-symptoms.
Any remedy correctly worked out, when looked up in the Materia Medica, should be perceived to agree with,
and to fit, the patient ; his symptoms ; his parts ; and his modalities. It is quite possible for a remedy not having
the highest marking in the anemnesis to be the most similar in image, as seen in the Materia
Medica.
The artistic prescriber sees much in the proving that cannot be retained in the Repertory, where everything
must be sacrificed for the alphabetical system. The artistic prescriber must study Materia Medica long and
earnestly to enable him to fix in his mind sick images, which, when needed, will infill the sick personalities of
human beings. These are too numerous and too various to be named or classified. I have often known the
intuitive prescriber to attempt to explain a so-called marvellous cure by saying : "I cannot quite say how I came
to give that remedy but it resembled him."
We have heard this, and felt it, and seen it, but who can attempt to explain it ? It is something that belongs
not to the neophyte, but comes gradually to the experienced artistic prescriber. It is only the growth of art in the
artistic mind : what is noticed in all artists. It belongs to all healing artists, but if carried too far it becomes a fatal
mistake, and must therefore be corrected by Repertory work done in even the most mechanical manner.
The more each one restrains the tendency to carelessness in prescribing and in method, the wiser he
becomes in artistic effects and Materia Medica work. The two features of prescribing must go hand in hand, and
must be kept in a high degree of balance, or loose methods and habits will come upon any good worker.
HOW TO STUDY THE REPERTORY
After all the symptoms of a patient have been written out the Repertory should be taken up. The beginner
should not attempt to abbreviate the anemnesis, but should write out the full general rubric for exercise, if
nothing more. If melancholy be the word, the remedies set to the word should be written down with all the
graduations. If the melancholy appear only before the menses let a sub-rubric be placed in manner to show at
a glance the number of remedies of the general class having the special period of aggravation. Many of the
most brilliant cures are made from the general rubric when the special does not help, and, in careful notes of
ten years, would bring down many of the general rubric symptoms, and furnish the best of clinical verifications.
The longer this is done the more can the busy doctor abbreviate his case-notes.
The special aggravation is a great help, but such observations are often wanting, and the general rubric
must be pressed into service.
Again, we have to work by analogy. In this method Bœnninghausen's Pocket Repertory is of the greatest
service.
Take Minton's most excellent work, and we find menstrual agonies are ameliorated by heat, peculiar to Ars.
and Nux., and by moist heat, to Nux-m. But the symptoms of one case are not like either of these remedies, and
we must go farther into the Materia Medica. We can there form the anemnesis by analogy and make use of
the general rubric, taking all the remedies known to be generally ameliorated by heat and warmth applied.
To be methodical, the general rubric should appear in the notes of the prescriber and the special below it. If
this plan be carefully carried out, a comparison of ten years'work be a most instructive perusal. What is true of
a remedy generally may often be true in particular, especially so in the absence of a contra-indicating
exception, well established.
If this plan be followed by beginners, always reading up the Materia Medica with the anamnesis by the time
business becomes plenty the work becomes easy and rapid. A young man can prescribe for a few patients a day
and make careful homœopathic cures, and he can gain speed enough to prescribe for twenty or thirty a day
after a few years. Any man who desires to avoid this careful method, should not pretend to be ahomœopathic
physician, as the right way is not in him, as the desire must precede the act.
The patient does not always express the symptom in the language that would best indicate the real
nature of the symptom. Then it is that judgment is required, that the physician may gain a correct
appreciation of the symptoms. So often is this true that the young
man and often the old are led from the true expressions of nature, and he will make an inappropriate
prescription. The task of taking symptoms is often a most difficult one. It is sometimes possible to abbreviate
the anemnesis by selecting one symptom that is very peculiar containing the key to the case. A young man
cannot often detect this peculiarity, and he should seldom attempt it. It is often convenient to abbreviate by
taking a group of three or four essentials in a given case, making a summary of these, and eliminating all
remedies not found in all the essential symptoms. A man with considerable experience may cut short the work
in this way. I have frequently known young men to mistake a modality for a symptom. This is fatal to a correct
result. The symptom is the sensation or condition, and the modality is only a modification. The symptom often
becomes peculiar or characteristic through its modality.
When a sensation is looking up in theRepertory, all the remedies belonging to it should be written out, and
individualization began by modalities.
I am frequently asked what is understood by peculiar as applied to a case. A little thought should lead each
man to the solution.
A high temperature, a fever without thirst, is in a measure peculiar. A hard chill with thirst for cold water is
peculiar. Thirst with a fever, with the heat, is not peculiar, because you can safely say it is common to find heat
with thirst, and uncommon to find heat without thirst. That which is common to any given disease is
never peculiar. This may seem too simple to demand an explanation, but let him who knows it go to the next
page. Pathognomonic symptoms are not used to individualize by, and are never peculiar in the sense asked for.
I am asked what I mean when I say to beginners, treat the patient and not the disease. My answer always
is about as follows : the symptom that is seldom found in a given disease is one not peculiar to the disease, but
peculiar to the patient, therefore the peculiarities of the patient have made the disease differ from all the
members of its class and from all others in the class, and make this disease, as affecting this patient, an
individuality by itself, and can only be treated as an individual. This individuality in the patient manifests itself
by peculiar symptoms nearly always prominent, and always looked for by the true healer. The man who gives
Acon. for fever knows nothing of the spirit of the law or the duties of the physician. The same is true
of Colocynthfor colic, Arsenicum for chill, etc.
"What shall we do when we find several peculiarities in the same patient and one remedy does not cover
them all ?" Here is where the astute physician will pick up his Repertory and commence the search for a remedy
most similar to all, and if he has been a student for a few years he need not go about asking foolish questions.
The lazy man has spent his days in the folly of pleasures, and the man of limited belief has shot out so many
valuable things that he is constantly up in public asking foolish questions and reporting cases with symptoms so
badly taken that he reveals the whereabouts of his past life. He has not made use of the Repertory, and shows
a complete ignorance of the rubrics and the usual formality of taking symptoms as taught by Hahnemann. It is
a blessed thing that they are not responsible for all their ignorance. Where shall the responsibility rest, and who
shall "throw the first stone ?"
It is so easy to wink at the sins that we ourselves are guilty of that is seems impossible to find judge or jury
before whom to arraign the first law-breaker.
The cry for liberty has been a grievous error, as liberty is and has been most shamefully abused. It means
a licence to violate law, and only a modest elasticity is necessary and full eclecticism is the product. It is
liberty that has driven out of use, or limited the use, of the Repertory that all the old healers so much
consulted. If Bœnninghausen used a Repertory with the limited remedies there proved, how much m
ore do we need to consult it.
HOW TO USE THE REPERTORY
Ever since the appearance of my Repertory in print many of my friends who use it have urged me to write
out my own method of using a Repertory. I realize that it is a most difficult undertaking, but shall attempt to
explain my method. I doubt not but most careful prescribers will find that they are working in a similar manner.
The use of the Repertory in homœopathic practice is a necessity if one is to do careful work. Our Materia
Medica is so cumbersome without a Repertory that the best prescriber must meet with only indifferent results.
After the case has been properly taken according to Hahnemann's rules it is ready for study. I do not intend
to offer in this manner the ordinary rubrics, because all know them so well. A case that is well taken and
ordinarily full will show morbid manifestations in sensitiveness to many surroundings, such as weather, heat and
cold, also in the desires and aversions, mental symptoms and the various regions of the body.
When I take up a full case for study, I single out all the expressions that describe the general state, such as
the aggravations and ameliorations of the general state of the patient or of many of his symptoms. I next
consider carefully all his longings, mental and physical, all the desires and aversions, antipathies, fears, dreads,
etc. Next I look for all the intellectual perversions, methods of reasoning, memory, causes of mental
disturbances, etc. All these I arrange in form together, in order to set opposite each one all remedies in
corresponding rubrics as found in the Repertory. By the cancellation process it will soon be seen that only a few
remedies run through all these symptoms, and therefore only a few are to be carefully compared in order to
ascertain which one of all these is most like the particular symptoms not yet lined up to be considered as the
first ones have been considered. Hahnemann teaches in the 153rd paragraph that we are to give particular
attention to such symptoms as are peculiar and characteristic. He teaches also that the physician must pay his
earnest attention to the patient. Now if these two things are duly considered, it will be seen that Hahnemann's
idea was that a characteristic symptom is one that is not common to disease but one that characterizes the
patient. All the first lot of symptoms singled out for a more comprehensive view are such, as characterize the
patient, and are predicated of the patient himself. By treating a portion of the symptoms in this way we have
reduced the list of possible remedies to a few or perhaps only one. As it is necessary to consider the totality of
the symptoms for a basis of the homœopathic prescription, it is now necessary to examine all the rest of the
symptoms in order to ascertain how these few remedies correspond with all the particulars.
It may be said that the above is only routine work and everybody does it just that way. True, but after so
much has been accepted the more intricate problems come up. To work out a well-rounded case is the simplest
part of Repertory work, but when one-sided cases appear and when the patient states his symptoms in
language that cannot be found in provings the case is far different. The record of the patient should stand as
nearly as possible in his own language. From an extensive correspondence and many years of teaching
graduates, I have come to the conclusion that it is a difficult matter for many to know when the record of
symptoms contains the possibilities of a curative prescription. Many cases are presented with no generals and
no mental symptoms - absolutely no characterizing symptoms - only the symptoms common to sickness. When
a successful prescription is made on such symptoms it is scarcely more than a "lucky hit". It cannot be classed
as scientific prescribing. Many records are presented with pages of vague description and one keynote that has
served as a disgraceful "stool pigeon" to call forth a failure from many doctors.
Unless the symptoms that character
ize the patient are brought out in the record the physician should not be surprised at a failure. The remedy must
be similar to the symptoms of the patient as well as the pathognomonic symptoms of his disease in order to cure.
To show something about the requirements of Repertory work, I will try to bring out hypothetical groups of
symptoms such as come to every man. In a well-rounded case, or as an isolated group, we frequently meet with
what is called "writer's cramp". This must be divided into many elements before it can be properly put on paper
as a work-out case or fragment of a case. If we should take "writer's cramp" and say no more about it, we would
have only a limited number of remedies to look to for cure. But our resources are unlimited, as well be seen.
"Writer's cramp", when examined into, will be found to mean cramp in fingers, hand or arms, or all three.
Sometimes numbness and tingling of one or all three ; sometimes sensation of paralysis in one or all three ;
sometimes tingling of fingers and hand, and all of these conditions from writing or worse while writing.
Cramp in fingers while writing : Brach., Cocc., Cycl., Trill., Mag-ph., Stann.
Cramp in hand while writing : Anac.,Euph., Mag-p., Nat-p., Sil.
Numbness in fingers while writing : Carl.
Numbness in hand while writing : Agar., Zinc.
Paralytic feeling in hand while writing : Acon., Agar., Chel., Cocc.
Cramp in wrist while writing : Amyl-n., Brach.
The above brings out all that can be found in the Materia Medica on this subject, and failure often follows
owing to the scanty clinical and pathogenetic records to which we have access ; but we have just begun to
consider that vexatious group of symptoms. It is true that sometimes the above scanty showing presents just
the remedy required. But oftener it does not, and then we may proceed as follows :
Cramp in the fingers, hand and wrist or such parts as are affected : use the general groups on pages 971,
972 & 973 of my Repertory.
Numbness of fingers and hand : pages 1038 and 1039, using also the general group.
Sensation of paralysis of hands and fingers : use the general groups, pages 1176 and 1179.
After these have been carefully written out, turn to the general rubric in Generalities, on page 1358,
"Exertion", and write out such of these remedies as are found in the complex symptoms from exertion. Writing
is nothing else but prolonged exertion. When this simple lesson is learned the physician will see at once that the
same process will show the remedy in those who have lost the power of the hand and fingers, or have cramps,
etc., from playing stringed instruments or playing the piano or the prolonged use of any tool or instrument. It is
using in proper manner a general rubric.
Furthermore, after cures have been made with remedies selected in this way, such remedies may be added
to the scanty list of particulars first referred to, and in this manner will our Repertory grow into usefulness. This
is the legitimate use of clinical symptoms. It is the proper application of the general rubric to the end that our
scanty particulars may be built up. The new Repertory is the only one ever found that provides a vacant space
for annotating just such information. If the large number of correct prescribers in the world would join in this
extension, we could soon have a Repertory of comparatively extensive particulars. Our generals were well
worked out by Bœnninghausen and much overdone, as he generalized many rubrics that were purely particulars,
the use of which as generals is misleading and ends in failure. The success coming from Bœnninghausen's
Pocket-book is due to the arrangement where by generals can be quickly made use of to furnish modalities for
individual symptoms, whether general or particular. This feature is preserved in my Repertory, as all know who
use it. But it is the generals that can be used this way. A large rubric made up of promiscuous particulars, none
of which are predicated of the patient is a "hit or miss" when appli
ed in general and usually a miss. For example, "aggravation from writing" is a rubric of particulars. In no
instance is there one wherein the patient himself is worse from writing, but the eyes, the head, the hands, the
back (from stooping), etc., make up this rubric. It is useless to resort to aggravation from writing when a
headache is the symptom and find the remedy refers to a complaint in some other part wholly unlike headache.
To make use of this modality for mental symptoms when it is applied to complaints of the hand is perverting the
uses of circumstances. Aggravation from writing should be limited to the symptoms that are worse from writing
and kept with them, as it is not a general. It is so done in my Repertory. This is wholly different in the great
rubric "motion". If we study Bryonia from that rubric, and from the Materia Medica, we will see that such a large
number of particular symptoms is aggravated by that remedy that it appears that the very patient himself is
worse from motion.
Hence, it will be seen that motion is a rubric that must show the extent of aggravation in relation to the
general bodily state by general and particular, and it must be retained in the generals. Any rubric that modifies
so many particulars that the very patient himself seems to be so modified must be classed as general. Many
wonderful cures have been made from the use of Bœnninghausen and many wonderful failures have followed,
and it is from the above cause. The new Repertory is produced to show forth all the particulars, each symptom
with the circumstance connected with it. It is in infancy and may remain so very long, unless all who use it unite
to preserve their experience in well-kept records and furnish the author with such. The author is devoting his life
to the growth and infilling and perfecting of this work, and begs all true workers will co-operate by noting errors
and omissions, and, above all, noting such modalities of particulars as have come from generals and been
observed in cures.
Copyright :copyright: Sylvain Cazalet 2004.

S
P0 agar Patwa:
[M
4
:3
]6
:+1::+1::+1::+1:
D
P3 hanashree:
[M
0
:4
]6
Can anyone suggest easiest way to learn kent 12 observation...
D
P1 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
3
:5
]6
sudha iyer
>
>
Very good explanation :pray::pray::pray:
[M
P3
5
:4
]7
sudha iyer
>
>
:+1::+1::+1::+1::+1:
- unday, March 4, 2018 -
S
S
A3 hahidul Islam :
[M
9
:2
]8
:+1::+1::ok_hand:
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
6
:5
]8
§ 39
Now the adherents of the ordinary school of medicine saw all this for so many centuries; they saw that Nature herself
cannot cure any disease by the accession of another, be it ever so strong, if the new disease be dissimilar to that already
present in the body. What shall we think of them, that they nevertheless went on treating chronic disease with allopathic
remedies, namely, with medicines and prescriptions capable of producing God knows what morbid state - almost invariably,
however, one dissimilar to the disease to be cured? And even though physicians did not hitherto observe nature attentively,
the miserable results of their treatment should have taught them that they were pursuing an inappropriate, a false path.
Did they not perceive when they employed, as was their custom, and aggressive allopathic treatment in a chronic disease,
that thereby they only created an artificial disease dissimilar to the original one, which, as long as it was kept up, merely
held in abeyance, merely suppressed, merely suspended the original disease, which latter, however, always returned, and
must return, as soon as the diminished strength of the patient no longer admitted of a continuance of the allopathic
attacks on the life? Thus the itch exanthema certainly disappears very soon from the skin under the employment of violent
purgatives, frequently repeated; but when the patient can no longer stand the factitious (dissimilar) disease of the bowels,
and can take no more purgatives, then either the cutaneous eruption breaks out as before, or the internal psora displays
itself in some bad symptom, and the patient, in addition to his undiminished original disease, has to endure the misery of
a painful ruined digestion and impaired strength to boot. So, also, when the ordinary physicians keep up artificial
ulcerations of the skin and issues on the exterior of the body, with the view of thereby eradicating a chronic disease, they
can NEVER cure them by that means, as such artificial cutaneous ulcers are quite alien and allopathic to the internal
affection; but inasmuch as the irritation produced by several tissues is at least sometimes a stronger (dissimilar) disease
than the indwelling malady, the latter is thereby sometimes silenced and suspended for a week or two. But it is only
suspended, and that for a very short time, while the patient's powers are gradually worn out. Epilepsy, suppressed for
many years by means of issues, invariably recurred, and in an aggravated form, when they were allowed to heal up, as
Pechlin1 and others testify. But purgatives for itch, and issues for epilepsy, cannot be more heterogeneous, more
dissimilar deranging agents - cannot be more allopathic, more exhausting modes of treatment - than are the customary
prescriptions, composed of unknown ingredients, used in ordinary practice for the other nameless, innumerable forms of
disease. These likewise do nothing but debilitate, and only suppress or suspend the malady for a short time without being
able to cure it, and when used for a long time always add a new morbid state to the old disease.
1 Obs. phys. med., lib. ii, obs, 30.

M
- onday, March 5, 2018 -
D
A0 r.Galib Raziya Kureshi:
[M
6
:3
]9
Plz suggest rubric/remedy

for this song
Ae jindagi gale lagale...
Humne bhi tere Har Ek gum ko gale se lagaya he na....
:bouquet::pray:
D
A4 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:3
0
]1
Dr.Galib Raziya Kureshi

>
Plz suggest rubric/remedy for this song Ae jindagi gale lagale.

>
Please write in english
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:0
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 39 Now the adherents of the ordinary school of medicine saw a

>
Nature proves the truth that newly appeared dissimilar disease never cure the previous one disease though more in
strength but still allopathy - old school of medicine is not attentive of this fact and use to apply different drugs without
knowing its exact morbid action on human being.
Allopathic medicines just suspend or suppress natural state of disease under its violent action resulting into nothing but
more distress or discomfort of patient.
Master Hahnemann explained this truth with some examples of diseases under allopathic treatment. When one treat itch ,
epilepsy by allopathic mode of medicines then for sure after some period of time either present disease condition become
worse than before or invite for more complicated , more dangerous diseases.
Some months ago one patient consulted me for his complaints of ringworm. After detail enquiry he told that he had same
complaint one year back but at that time he received allopathic treatment for six months with significant reduction of
ringworm but soon after that allopathic treatment he suffered from angina and then undergone through angiography and
angioplasty also to remove blocks in coronary artery. Then he came to me complaining, '' now my heart is stable with
allopathic medicines but again ringworm is worse. ''
Up to this date allopathic science is going on as it is ruining the health of poor ignorant sufferers by neglecting the truth of
nature's law of cure. Here we can only pray as Lord may bless them with wisdom to understand the way of natural cure of
disease.
D
P9 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:2
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1::+1::+1:
T
P2 ikva Sasson:
[M
:0
]8
~~~~~ Over the centuries no one ever saw a cure from a dissimilar disease.
People continued, and still continue, to give dissimilar medicines which sometimes silenced the disease for some time but
never cured.
When strong allopathic methods are used they add a new morbid state to the old , original disease.
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
1
:3
]9
Tikva Sasson
>
~~~~~ Over the centuries no one ever saw a cure from a dissimila
>
:+1::+1:
D2 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P0
7
:5
]9
Tikva Sasson
>
~~~~~ Over the centuries no one ever saw a cure from a dissimila
>
:+1::+1:
- uesday, March 6, 2018-
T
D0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
9
:3
2
]1
§ 40
III. Or the new disease, after having long acted on the organism, at length joins the old one that is dissimilar to it, and
forms with it a complex disease, so that each of them occupies a particular locality in the organism, namely, the organs
peculiarly adapted for it, and, as it were, only the place specially belonging to it, while it leaves the rest to the other
disease that is dissimilar to it. Thus a syphilitic patient may become psoric, and vice versa. As two disease dissimilar to
each other, they cannot remove, cannot cure one another. At first the venereal symptoms are kept in abeyance and
suspended when the psoric eruption begins to appear; in course of time, however (as the syphilis is at least as strong as
the psora), the two join together,1 that is, each involves those parts of the organism only which are most adapted for it,
and the patient is thereby rendered more diseased and more difficult to cure.
When two dissimilar acute infectious diseases meet, as, for example, smallpox and measles, the one usually suspends the
other, as has been before observed; yet there have also been severe epidemics of this kind, where, in rare cases, two
dissimilar acute diseases occurred simultaneously in one and the same body, and for a short time combined, as it were,
with each other. During an epidemic, in which smallpox and measles were prevalent at the same time, among three
hundred cases (in which these diseases avoided or suspended one another, and measles attacked patients twenty days
after the smallpox broke out, the smallpox, however, from seventeen to eighteen days after the appearance of the
measles, so that the first disease had previously completed its regular course) there was yet one single case in which P.
Russell2 met with both these dissimilar diseases in one person at the same time. Rainey3 witnessed the simultaneous
occurrence of smallpox and measles in two girls. J. Maurice4, in his whole practice, only observed two such cases. Similar
cases are to be found in Ettmuller's5 works, and in the writings of a few others.
Zencker6 saw cow-pox run its regular course along with measles and along with purpura.
The cow-pox went on its course undisturbed during a mercurial treatment for syphilis, as Jenner saw.
1 From careful experiments and cures of complex diseases of this kind, I am now firmly convinced that no real
amalgamation of the two takes place, but that in such cases the one exists in the organism besides the other only, each in
pairs that are adapted for it, and their cure will be completely effected by a judicious alternation of the best mercurial
preparation, with the remedies specific for the psora, each given in the most suitable dose and form.
2 Vide Transactions of a Society for the Improvement of Med. and Chir. Knowledge, ii.
3 In Edinb. Med and Phys. Journ., 1805.
4 In Med. and Phys. Journ., 1805.
5 Opera, ii, p.i, cap. 10.
6 In hufeland's Journal, xvii.

W
- ednesday, March 7, 2018-
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:1
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 40 III. Or the new disease, after having long acted on the or

>
As we discussed before usually one dissimilar disease suspends the other until it complete its course of action but in some
cases two dissimilar disease forms complex disease where one disease occupies peculiar locality in the organism , that is
organ peculiarly adapted for its action, while it leave rest of body under the action of other dissimilar disease.
Master explained this fact with examples of miasmatic diseases as well as acute diseases.
Syphilis and Psora may join together to form complicated miasmatic disease which is difficult to cure, in acute infectious
diseases like smallpox and measles join together to form complex disease.
In treatment of complex miasmatic diseases formed by syphilis and Psora one should judiciously alter syphilitic remedy like
Mercury with remedies specific for Psora ( e.g.Sulphur ) in the most suitable dose and form to effect the complete cure of
case.
In my clinical experience of chronic cases I frequently found cure of chronic cases accomplished by psoric remedies like
Sulph , Lyco or Lach followed by syphilitic or sycotic remedies indicated in a case of disease. If two prominent miasms are
there one has to treat them with individual specific miasmatic remedies as per indications from case.

D8 r.neha rushik Parikh:
[M
P2
0
:4
]9
:+1::+1:
D3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P0
2
:4
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
D4 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P3
:2
0
]1
:+1::+1:
R
P5 upali:
[M
4
:8
]1
:pray::pray:
T
- hursday, March 8, 2018 -
H
A3 ari:
[M
6
:2
]1
({ HYPERLINK
"http://www.thehealthconsciousness.com/pharma-co-license-suspended-vaccine-blamed-sterilization-500000-women-chi
ldren/" \t "_blank" })
{ HYPERLINK
"http://www.thehealthconsciousness.com/pharma-co-license-suspended-vaccine-blamed-sterilization-5
00000-women-children/" \t "_blank" }
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]2
A school boy of 10 consulted me for acute gastritis. Already he had consulted to allopathic consultants who advised him
ultrasonography of abdomen but report came normal. He took allopathic medicines for some days with no relief of
complaints and that is why his parents brought him to me.
Dr - Hello , what is happening dear ?
Pt - Vomiting after eating.
Dr - OK. What else ?
Pt - nothing , pain in abdomen.
Dr - OK. What else ?
Pt - Nothing.
Dr - After how many time vomiting is there after eating ?
Pt - Immediately , after 5 -6minutes.
Dr - Where is the pain in abdomen ?
Pt - (Located epigastric region by fingers.)
Dr - When does pain is there in abdomen ?
Pt - When vomiting not occurs.
Dr - And what about pain in abdomen after vomiting ?
Pt - No pain is there.
Dr - What do you feel more heat or cold ?
Pt -Feel cold.
Dr - Thirst ?
Pt - It is there after eating.
Clinical examination -: Tongue - clean.
No any other significant findings. No any significant change in mind disposition.
Work out the case to select the remedy .
Phos DD- ars

R
P3 upali:
[M
1
:5
]2
Ars alb.
D1 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P0
6
:5
]2
B
[M
8
:5
]2
Hyoscomus
D
[M
0
:1
]3
Arsenic
s
P6 udha iyer :
[M
2
:1
]3
Ars hyos ipecac
D
[M
:2
]3
Ipecac come close after arsenic
D
[M
0
:4
]3
Stomach inflammation
Stomach pain Epigastric
Stomach vomiting accompany clean tongue
Stomach vomiting eating after
Abdomen pain vomiting amel
Generalities heat lack of
Digitalis coming first
P
P8 R Patil:
[M
0
:5
]3
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
A school boy of 10 consulted me for acute gastritis. Already he

>
Phos
A
P5 sma Hashmi:
[M
1
:2
]4
Arsenic
D
P6 rkapil Dev :
[M
2
:7
]4
Ipecauc.. D/d ars
D
[M
:1
]6
arsenic:point_up_2::point_up_2::point_up_2::point_up_2:
D4 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
P0
2
:3
]6
Arsenic
V2 idyasagar:
[M
P1
7
:3
]6
jP[M]6:50 ohn:
Ars
edited
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
]7
:ok_hand::ok_hand: nice work out by all .
You can attend me today at 9pm for case discussion.
Again my main purpose is to discuss the process of case work out by an art and science of individualisation through
application of repertory with skill of artistic repertorisation.
[M
P1
5
:3
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand: nice work out by all . You can attend me today at 9pm for
>
ok sir
D
[M
8
:3
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand: nice work out by all . You can attend me today at 9pm for
>
We are waiting for that..
D6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P4
2
:5
]7
Arsenic
G
P6 anesh Patil:
[M
2
:0
]9
Sep
D6 rkapil Dev :
[M
P1
7
:0
]9
Waiting for disclose and ur analysis sir .. :pray::pray:..
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:0
]9
Hello everyone
D
P1 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
:0
]9
Mag phos
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:1
]9
In acute cases exact clinical diagnosis with characteristic modalities plays a great role in selection of remedy of case.
Modalities in this case ?

D
P6 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
2
:1
]9
Eating after agg

Vomiting after amel
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
2
:1
]9
OK. Say precisely .

D6 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
P2
3
:1
]9
Vomiting eating after

Stomach pain vomiting after amel
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
4
:1
]9
Say particular one symptom with more accuracy.
Dr - After how many time vomiting is there after eating ?

Pt - Immediately , after 5 -6minutes.
Rubric ?
D
P2 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
5
:1
]9
Vomiting eating after immediately
D6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P2
5
:1
]9
Stomach-vomiting-eating-after-immediately after
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
5
:1
]9
See the particular words used by patient while describing his symptoms.
Dipen Vaishnav
>
Vomiting eating after immediately

>
:+1:
D
> r.Kiranmayi
Stomach-vomiting-eating-after-immediately after
>
:+1::+1: record it.
Second modality ?
D2 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
P0
7
:1
]9
Stomach pain amel after vomiting
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:1
]9
Dipen Vaishnav
>
Stomach pain amel after vomiting

>
:+1:
Dr - And what about pain in abdomen after vomiting ?

Pt - No pain is there.
Rubric ?
D3 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P4
1
:2
]9
Stomch pain vomiting amel
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Stomch pain vomiting amel

>
:+1::+1:
Record it.
edited
Post repertorisation of these two rubrics from Synthesis android.
D
P6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
3
:2
]9
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
3
:2
]9
Remedy ?
D
P7 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
4
:2
]9
Ars
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:2
]9
:+1:
This is an art and science of repertoridation ! :blush:

D
P1 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
5
:2
]9
Got it sir
B
[M
5
:2
]9
:+1::ok_hand:
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:2
]9
Clinical diagnosis of this case ?
Yes ?
D4 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
P1
7
:2
]9
Acute gastritis
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
Clinical diagnosis : Acute gastritis
Rubric ?
D5 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
P0
8
:2
]9
Stomach inflammation acute
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:2
]9
:+1:
Record it.
Dr - Thirst ?
Pt - It is there after eating.
Rubric ?
D
P3 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
:2
]9
Stomach-thirst-eating-after agg
D
P1 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
5
:2
]9
Stomach thirst eating after agg
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it.
Clinical examination -: Tongue - clean.
Rubric ?
D7 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
P0
1
:3
]9
Mouth clean t tongue
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
1
:3
]9
:+1:Mouth - clean - tongue
Record it.
Now post total Repertorisation.
D
P8 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
0
:3
]9
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
]9
So final remedy of case ?
D7 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
P1
5
:3
]9
Ars
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:3
]9
:+1::+1:
Rx
Ars.alb 30 stat.
( watery doses sos )
Follow up at next day : No vomiting , no pain in abdomen , generals good.
D
P2 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
6
:3
]9
:+1:
D
P6 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:3
]9
:+1::+1::+1:
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:3
]9
Any queries ?
B
[M
7
:3
]9
No
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
Thanks all :pray:

D
P5 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
3
:4
]9
Thank you sir
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:4
]9
Rupali
>
Photo
>
:ok_hand: Rupali madam nicely chosen two characteristic modalities with characteristic general of thirst so shortly reach
the remedy of the case.
:bouquet: congratulation for an artistic sense of rubric selection.
Please keep it on. :+1::blush:
B
[M
6
:4
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Photo
>
Kiranmayi also selected artistically... Congrats doll...
D6 rkapil Dev :
[M
P0
3
:5
]9
So nice sir :clap::clap::clap:
Congrts all
:+1::+1:
D
P5 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
:3
0
]1
Balivada Madhuri
>
Kiranmayi also selected artistically... Congrats doll...

>
:pray::blush:
R
P8 upali:
[M
:3
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:ok_hand: Rupali madam nicely chosen two characteristic modalities with

>
:pray::pray:
Learning from you only sir.
Before you nobody has given such knowledge and guidance.
D5 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P2
:4
0
]1
Rupali
>
:pray::pray: Learning from you only sir. Before you nobody has given suc
>
Very true mam:pray::pray::pray:

D
P4 r.neha rushik Parikh:
[M
:5
0
]1
Nice case and its analysis :ok_hand::ok_hand::+1:

F
- riday, March 9, 2018 -
D
A0 r. Mrunal:
[M
5
:1
]7
Nice case sir:+1:..
s7 udha iyer :
[M
P3
:4
2
]1
By long treatment with dissimilar allopathic drugs; drug diseases r created which only serves to.complicate the natural
disease by forming a double complex disease.much more difficult to cure. Medical journals and case recirds r evidence of
this truth.
Treatment of syphilis with mercury does not cure but only adds an artificial.mercurial dusease in the system.
D
[M
:0
]1
sudha iyer
>
By long treatment with dissimilar allopathic drugs; drug diseas

>
:+1::+1::+1:
double complex diseaee
D6 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
P2
7
:0
]4
s
> udha iyer

>
:ok_hand::ok_hand:
S
S
P7 hahidul Islam :
[M
1
:0
]4
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1::+1:
M
- onday, March 12, 2018-
DrSamadhan Ghule invited bhalchandra chopade
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:0
]8
sudha iyer
>

>
:+1::+1:
Natural disease get complicated by another dissimilar disease but even worst condition is when natural disease
get complicated by morbid conditions produced by long coninued use of unsuitable allopathic drugs where
Syphilis may get complicated with Psora or Sycosis.
Natural diseases complicated by allopathic drugs are more difficult to cure or sometimes incurable.
Use of mercury in large doses in unhomeopathic way in treatment of syphilis is nothing but worsening of original
condition with addition of newly produced symptoms like swelling and ulcerations of bone by drug.
Now a days there are many allopathic chemical drug preparations used to treat different disease conditions
resulting into complicated diseases which severely damage to body economy and difficult to cure by
Homeopathic medicines so artificially complicated diseases are always dangerous than naturally complicated
diseases by union of dissimilar diseases.
V4 INOD DHANAWAT:
[M
P3
7
:0
]8
D0 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P5
7
:1
]8
:+1::+1::+1::+1:
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
:4
0
]1
Video2:4] 2.4 MB
[
{ HYPERLINK "chrome-extension://clhhggbfdinjmjhajaheehoeibfljjno/index.html" }{ HYPERLINK

"chrome-extension://clhhggbfdinjmjhajaheehoeibfljjno/index.html" }
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
]1
Appreciation of Homeopathy by Indian celebrity on the occasion of release of film about Homeopathy.
- uesday, March 13, 2018 -
T
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A9
:2
0
]1
§ 42
Nature herself permits, as has been stated, in some cases, the simultaneous occurrence of two (indeed, of three) natural
disease in one and the same body. This complication, however, it must be remarked, happens only in the case of two
dissimilar disease, which according to the eternal laws of nature do not remove, do not annihilate and cannot cure one
another, but, as it seems, both (or all three) remain, as it were, separate in the organism, and each takes possession of the
parts and systems peculiarly appropriate to it, which, on account of the want of resemblance of these maladies to each
other, can very well happen without disparagement to the unity of life.
D
A5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 42 Nature herself permits, as has been stated, in some cases,

>
SENSE AND ESSENSE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE
COMMENTS On Aphorism 42
Two or three dissimilar diseases exist together in single entity of life as one could not remove other due to their dissimilar
natures. They occupy their peculiar part , organ or system as per their affection for certain part ,organ or system.
They can run their course of action separately irrespective of presence of other and it can only happen on account of the
want of resemblance of these maladies to each other.
In view of therapeutic it should be noted that two or three different sets of symptoms in a case of patient may need series
of different remedies to effect complete cure as per available totality of symptoms in subsequent follow ups of case.
[M
A2
6
:4
]1
:+1::+1:
edited
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
7
:1
]8
Unsolved Case is presented by Dr.Vijay Mali:
Mr x 23 years male weight of 40 kg.

Complain about about not increase weight.last 3_4 years.his weight is constant at 40 kg.his wish is at least increased 10
kg.which look nice personality.
He is foody wants to eat more nonveg(chicken).vadapav,biryani.if he not get food on time he become irritable.(chid chid
hote)
Aversion milk.smell of milk feel nausea.
Thirst normal...Not more not less
Perspiration no
Urine burning specially in summer.
Stool regular.once in morning
Thermally towards hot....
Past history left renal stone
Mentals....Anger from contradiction.expressive on face of anyone make him angry.
But repentance after 1 hr.later.feel sorry about it.
Talkative.frowning notice while taking.
Speedy complete his work.restlessness
Dreams of day today { HYPERLINK "http://activity.work/" \t "_blank" }.
Work out the case to select the remedy.

Be fast ! Try your analysis still 9pm.
D6 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P4
2
:5
]8
iod
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
7
:2
]9
:+1::+1: nice work out.
Hello everyone
D
P5 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
8
:2
]9
Hello sir
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:2
]9
Which type treatment require this case ?
D8 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P4
0
:3
]9
Antimiasmatic
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:3
]9
Particular state , miasmatic , constitutional ?

Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Antimiasmatic
>
:+1::+1: very nice Kiran.
Let us see first totality of case.
Mr x 23 years male weight of 40 kg.

Complain about about not increase weight.last 3_4 years.his weight is constant at 40 kg.his wish is at least
increased 10 kg.which look nice personality.
Rubric ?
edited
D1 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P4
2
:3
]9
Generals emaciation
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:3
]9
:+1:
Record it.
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Mr x 23 years male weight of 40 kg. Complain about about not inc

>
Generals - constitution - dyscratic
What is dyscratic ?
Dyscratic means related to dyscrasia .
What is dyscrasia ?
D
P4 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
5
:3
]9
Discrasia is disordered state
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:3
]9
:+1:
Definition of dyscrasia - an abnormal or disordered state of the body or of a bodily part .

DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Generals - constitution - dyscratic

>
Record it.
Aversion milk.smell of milk feel nausea.
Rubric ?
D7 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P1
8
:3
]9
Gen milk aversion
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:3
]9
:+1:
Record it.
Food and drinks - Milk aversion to

Food and drinks - Milk agg.
Record it.
Urine burning specially in summer.
Rubrics ?
D6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P5
0
:4
]9
Urine burning
Gen summer agg
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
:+1::+1:
Urine - burning
Generals - season - summer agg.
Record it.
Past history left renal stone
Rubric ?
D
P5 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
2
:4
]9
Kidney stones
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
3
:4
]9
Take rubric in general sense.
D
P7 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
3
:4
]9
Gen lithemic constitution
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
:+1::+1:
Generals - stones in organ formation

Generals - constitution - lithemic
Record it.
Mentals....Anger from contradiction.
Rubric ?
D
P2 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
7
:4
]9
Mind anger contradiction from
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:4
]9
:+1:
Record it.
frowning noticed while talking.
Rubric ?
Mind Frowning disposed to
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:4
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it.
Speedy complete his work
Rubric ?
Mind - hurry
Mind hurry
D8 rkapil Dev :
[M
P3
0
:5
]9
Hurry work in
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:5
]9
Imtiyaz Bagban
>
M
> ind hurry
:+1::+1:
Record it.
Dreams of day today { HYPERLINK "http://activity.work/" \t "_blank" }.
Rubric ?
D
P2 r.Sanjay Patel:
[M
3
:5
]9
Dreams daily business
D6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P4
3
:5
]9
Dreams business of the day
D
P0 rkapil Dev :
[M
3
:5
]9
Dreams business day of
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:5
]9
:+1::+1:
Dreams - business - day of the
Miasm of case ?
D3 rkapil Dev :
[M
P2
4
:5
]9
Sycotic
D
P3 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
4
:5
]9
Syphilis
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:5
]9
Drkapil Dev
>
Sycotic
>
No
Psora
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:5
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Syphilis
>
No
D
P2 rkapil Dev :
[M
0
:5
]9
Psora
D
P6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
1
:5
]9
Yes psora, defective functioning
Disordered Assimilation .. deficiency
D
P3 rkapil Dev :
[M
:5
]9
Stone formation...?? Sycotic nahi hota sir
D
P8 r Dhan@shri:
[M
3
:5
]9
Psora
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:5
]9
Go to original concept of miasms by Hahnemann.
Predominant is psora
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Yes psora, defective functioning
>
No
D
P4 r Dhan@shri:
[M
:5
]9
And SYCOTIC
D
P7 rkapil Dev :
[M
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Go to original concept of miasms by Hahnemann.

>
Ok boss
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
]9
Imtiyaz Bagban
>
Disordered Assimilation .. deficiency

>
No
Drkapil Dev
>
Stone formation...?? Sycotic nahi hota sir

>
No
Dr Dhan@shri
>
And SYCOTIC
>
No
D
P3 r Dhan@shri:
[M
6
:5
]9
It's accumulation,na stone formation
Tubercular
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
6
:5
]9
No
D1 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P0
7
:5
]9
Psudopsora
Pseudopsora*
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:5
]9
Refer list of symptoms of miasms in chronic diseases by Master Hahnemann.

Dr Dhan@shri
>
Pseudopsora*
>
No
Repugnance to milk and emaciation indicates Psora.
D3 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P4
8
:5
]9
Ok..
D
P4 rkapil Dev :
[M
8
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Repugnance to milk and emaciation indicates Psora.

>
:pray::pray:
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:5
]9
So required medicine should be Hahnemannian antipsoric.
Post Repertorisation.
of above listed rubrics.
D
P:6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M0
]1
D
P: rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
]1
Remedy ?
D
P:3 r.Kiranmayi:
[M0
]1
Lycopodiumm
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
0
]1
Lycopodium is a great antipsoric remedy by Master Hahnemann.

Potency ?
Dynamic affection ( deep seated ) in weak constitution.
D
P5 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
:2
0
]1
1M
d3 r deepali:
[M
P5
:2
0
]1
200
D
P6 rkapil Dev :
[M
:3
0
]1
Give lower potency
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
0
]1
Drkapil Dev
>
Give lower potency

>
But deep acting.
D
P4 r.Sanjay Patel:
[M
:3
0
]1
Lm
D5 rkapil Dev :
[M
P4
:3
0
]1
Yes.. Lyco is deep acting
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
:3
0
]1
Dr.Sanjay Patel
>
Lm
>
:+1::+1:
Start with Lyco 0/1
D
P2 rkapil Dev :
[M
:4
0
]1
:+1:
D
P3 r.Sanjay Patel:
[M
:4
0
]1
:+1:
D
[M0
]1
Rx
Lyco 0/1 OD for 2weeks.
Follow up after 2 weeks.

D7 r.Sanjay Patel:
[M
P2
:5
0
]1
Nice analysis :+1::ok_hand:
D
P4 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
:5
0
]1
:+1::+1:
D
P3 r Dhan@shri:
[M
:5
0
]1
Nice learning sir

As always:ok_hand::clap::clap::pray:
edited
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
:6
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Rx Lyco 0/1 OD for 2weeks.

>
1 grain in 30 ml water.
10 stroke before every dose.
1 dose - 10 drops in cup of water, from that take mouthful of water. Discard remaining water.
D3 rkapil Dev :
[M
P4
:6
0
]1
Sir. One query...

Jab apn harek case ko is types ke generals se lete hn.. To mostly.. Sulph, lyco, calc.. Sepia,, asi hi remedy ati hn to.. Ase
me kya kare
edited
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:9
0
]1
Drkapil Dev
>
Sir. One query... Jab apn harek case ko is types ke generals s

>
Its only real demand of chronic cases which require antipsoric medicines in most of cases.
Your most of chronic cases would be solved by Hahnemann's leading 50 antipsoric medicines.
D5 rkapil Dev :
[M
P3
:9
0
]1
Ok.. Thanks :pray::pray:
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1
Any more query ?
Thanks all :pray:
D
P2 r Dhan@shri:
[M
:4
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Its only real demand of chronic cases which require antipsoric m
>
Yes..true sir
[M
P5
:2
0
]1
Nice case and nice learning :+1::ok_hand:

V6 ijay Mali:
[M
P3
5
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
1 grain in 30 ml water. 10 stroke before every dose. 1 dose - 1

>
Thank u Sirji..and all drs
D5 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P6
:2
0
]1
Thankyou vijay sir, nice case:+1:

V5 ijay Mali:
[M
P3
7
:2
0
]1
:+1::+1:
D
P2 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
:5
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Unsolved Case is presented by Dr.Vijay Mali: Mr x 23 years mal

>
Gourmand
Stomach nausea milk agg
Why these rubrics were not taken?

W
D
A:4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M0
]1
General - food and drink - Milk agg. ( general rubric considered )

DR. RAHUL MISAL
>
Gourmand Stomach nausea milk agg Why these rubrics were not t
>
Wants to eat non veg ( chicken ) , vadapa , biryani - this symptom may have different interpretations like desire
spices , desire chicken ; or debauchery , gourmand etc. So such symptoms we does not considering as
eliminating if does not go with rest of totality of case.
[M
A7
:5
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Wants to eat non veg ( chicken ) , vadapa , biryani - this sympt

>
:+1:
D
A7 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
:5
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Wants to eat non veg ( chicken ) , vadapa , biryani - this sympt

>
K
R:9 upali:
[M
A ]1
Nice case sir. With new rubrics for me.

T
- hursday, March 15, 2018-
D
A:3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M0
]1
§ 43
Totally different, however, is the result when two similar disease meet together in the organism, that is to say, when to the
disease already present a stronger similar one is added. In such cases we see how a cure can be effected by the
operations of nature, and we get a lesson as to how man ought to cure.
T0 ikva Sasson:
[M
P3
8
:5
]2
~~~~ Totally different is when two SIMILAR diseases meet in the body.
When a weaker disease is in the body and a stronger one comes we see the cure of the weaker disease that was already
present.
By observation we see how people need to cure diseases.
(This is ONE problem with preventing normal childhood diseases.)
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:3
]4
:+1::+1:
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 43 Totally different, however, is the result when two similar

>
Before this we have discussed about what happens when two dissimilar diseases meet together but matter is
totally different when two similar diseases meet together.
In a case when later added disease in organism is stronger than former one then we can see how does the
nature cure the former weaker disease under the influence of later similar but stronger disease and its nature's
law of cure.
e.g.
Asthma cured after appearance of acute bronchitis.

D
[M
2
:1
]7
:+1:
D3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P2
0
:5
]7
:+1::+1::+1:
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:5
]8
Drkapil Dev
>
Sir. One query... Jab apn harek case ko is types ke generals s
>
Psora forms 7/8 of all chronic maladies while the remaining 1/8 springs from syphilis and sycosis or from a complication of
two of these three miasmatic chronic disease or from a complication of all three of them. Psora is among all the diseases
the one, which is most misapprehended, and therefore, has been medically treated in the worst and most injurious
manner.
( Chronic diseases their peculiar nature & homoeopathic cure)
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
6
:1
]9
Hahnemann says that, the whole sycosis dependant on the fig wart miasma, as well as the excrescence, can only be cured
most surely and thoroughly through the internal use of Thuja. When the action of Thuja exhausted it should be alternated
with a small doses of Nitric acid, which must be allowed to act as long a time in order to remove the whole sycosis There
is no need to use any external application except in the most inveterate and difficult cases. In that cases the fig warts are
moistened every day with the mild pure juice prepared from the green leaves of Thuja, mixed with an equal volume of
alcohol.
If the patient was at the same time affected with another chronic ailment, i.e. psora complicated with sycosis or both the
miasma (psora and sycosis) are conjoined in threefold complication with syphilis; then it is necessary to treat the psoric
component first, with specific antipsoric medicines. Then to make use of the remedy for sycosis and lastly proper dose of
the best preparation of Mercury is given against syphilis. The same alternating treatment may be continued until a
complete cure is affected.
( Chronic diseases their peculiar nature and Homeopathic cure )

F
- riday, March 16, 2018-
D
A1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]8
§ 44 Sixth Edition
Similar diseases can neither (as is asserted of dissimilar disease in I) repel one another, nor (as has been shown of
dissimilar disease in II) suspend on another, so that the old one shall return after the new one has run its course; and just
as little can two similar disease (as has been demonstrated in III respecting dissimilar affections) exist beside each other
in the same organism, or together form a double complex disease.
S
P9 omnath Jagtap:
[M
:3
]2
A female pt aged 65yrs having following complaints since 40 yrs showing in picture
Aggravated by working in water
It is not leprosy ,test negetive. Diagnose the case and give remedy
D2 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P3
9
:5
]8
Somnath Jagtap
>
It is not leprosy ,test negetive. Diagnose the case and give rem
>
Destructive miasme = syphilitic=merc
D9 r.Razavi:
[M
P4
5
:2
0
]1
Somnath Jagtap
>
Photo
>
Hello. Skin tubercolosis must be
Study
edited
D
[M
:2
0
]1
Somnath Jagtap
>
It is not leprosy ,test negetive. Diagnose the case and give rem
>
Collect some characteristic individual symptoms by taking history which can b helpful in selecting her individual remedy.
Bcs thats only wud helpful to her in this complain.
S
- aturday, March 17, 2018 -
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A2
:4
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 44 Sixth Edition Similar diseases can neither (as is asserted

>
Two dissimilar diseases either repel or suspends action of each other,one does not allowed other to act still it complete its
own course of action or forms complex disease but the matter of similar diseases is totally different as they neither repel or
suspend each other nor form complex disease while existing in the same organism.
[M
P3
:6
2
]1
:+1::+1:
[M
P3
:7
2
]1
:+1:
R
P5 upali:
[M
7
:1
]3
Sir plz give example of double complex disease.
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
Rupali
>
Sir plz give example of double complex disease.

>
e..g.
Diabetes mellitus with hyperthyroidism , Hypothyroidism with hypertension.

R5 upali:
[M
P7
:2
0
]1
thank you sir.

S
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:0
]7
CASE OF CORN
A young physiotherapist lady consulted me for her complaints of painful corn.
Dr - Say please !
Pt - Whenever I walk have a pain in left sole since 7 months. Actually I had consulted surgeon , he advised surgical
removal of corn but I said no as I scare of surgery , then I had consulted dermatologist he gave some medicines to apply
on it repeatedly and with that I was better significantly better but again it appeared and paining much now since 2-3
weeks.
O/E - Thick hard ( horny ) corn on left sole.
Dr - What did you felt about surgery ?
Pt - Someone told me that you have to rest for a week , you can't work , you can't put foot into water ; and in one case I
had seen an exposed operated part as a hole inside put so I scared very much so decided to avoid surgery.
Dr- Is there any emotional stress ?
Pt - Actually I was very much involved means I was in love with someone. We was about to marry and suddenly we had
breakup so I had mentally trauma and that is only thing.
Dr - For how many days you was going through that situation ?
Pt - About 4 months , then I thought what is there is there and why to think of what is not there but again since last two
weeks again I feeling like same and crying a lot remembering him, still I love him a lot.
Dr - How are you by nature ?
Pt - I am very strict , don't like to attach people easily , and I am very moody. Confused ,cant make decision.
Dr - What do you can't tolerate hot or cold in general ?
Pt - I can't tolerate both.
Dr - How is your thirst ?
Pt - Very thirsty.
Dr - What you feel right now about that disappointment ?
Pt - I would not accept him again.
Dr - At one side you said still you love him a lot and at other side you are not ready to accept him, what is this ? Is it love ?
Pt - Once he done something wrong with me ,bad with me so I never think I would accept him again.
Dr - What do you like or don't like more in food and drinks ?
Pt - Junk food , pizza , burger , cake, fish , chicken . I don't like drumstick , cucumber, mataki .
Dr - Is there any food which aggravate you or causes complaints ?
Pt - Meat and beef causes diarrhea.
Dr - How is your sleep position ?
Pt - I has to hold , hug pillow or my mother's hand ( showing by gestures of hug ) while sleeping.
Past history - Pelvic inflammatory disease.
Family history - Cancer.
No other significant findings in generals.

Attend me today at 8.30pm for case discussion.
D8 rkapil Dev :
[M
P5
4
:2
]7
Phos.. D/d silicea
Natrum mur DD- carcinocin
D
P9 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
5
:2
]7
What is O/E
On examination
D0 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P4
6
:2
]7
:+1:
a7 vinash harshe:
[M
P5
0
:3
]8
Ailments from dissappoint of love
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:3
]8
Hello everyone
D
P0 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
5
:3
]8
Hello sir
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:3
]8
You are getting wrong concept of individualisation as individualisation means not only to select the single remedy but the
selected remedy should have the essence of case.
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Photo
>
Its better :+1:
What we are going to cure in this case ?
First focus on problem then decide the strategy to solve it.
D
P6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
0
:4
]8
Painful corn
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
0
:4
]8
:+1::+1:
Where it is ?
D
P5 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
0
:4
]8
Left sole
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:4
]8
What is affected and how is affected is very important.

Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Left sole
>
Yes
jP[M]8:416 ohn:
Calc
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
2
:4
]8
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
What is affected and how is affected is very important.

>
That is a location and affection ( pathogenesis )

john
>
Calc
>
Don't hurry to jump on remedy.

Try to understand the process.
jP[M]8:425 ohn:
Ok sir
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
3
:4
]8
Rubric for corn ?
D
P3 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
:4
]8
Extremities-corns
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:4
]8
Try to specify it.

jP[M]8:437 ohn:
Extremities corn feet sole
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]8
:+1::+1:
Record it.
What you felt characteristic in this case ?

jP[M]8:4609 ohn:
Fear especially about operation...
D7 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P1
6
:4
]8
Wont easily get attached to things, if lost cant accept again
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
6
:4
]8
Yes
Think of more characteristic.

Pt - I has to hold , hug pillow or my mother's hand ( showing by gestures of hug ) while sleeping.
Is it something more characteristic ?
D
P0 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
:4
]8
Clingy
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:4
]8
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Clingy
>
Very nice.
Rubric ?
D6 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P5
9
:4
]8
Mind desire to be held
D
P9 rkapil Dev :
[M
0
:5
]8
Clinging grasps at others
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:5
]8
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Mind desire to be held

>
held is different from clinging.

Drkapil Dev
>
Clinging grasps at others

>
Say more precisely.
D7 rkapil Dev :
[M
P2
1
:5
]8
Clinging persons and furniture to
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:5
]8
Still say more precisely .

R
P1 upali:
[M
:5
]8
Mind clinging takes the hand of mother
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
]8
Rupali
>
Mind clinging takes the hand of mother

>
:+1: please write rubric in exact words.

D7 rkapil Dev :
[M
P0
3
:5
]8
R
P2 upali:
[M
3
:5
]8
Mind clinging children in , mother child clings to the
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
3
:5
]8
Drkapil Dev
>
Photo
>
:+1::+1:
edited
Mind - clinging, children , in - mother , child clings to the - hand of the mother , child will always take the
Record it.
Post Repertorisation of two rubrics.
a7 vinash harshe:
[M
P3
4
:5
]8
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:5
]8
Remedy ?
D
P1 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
:5
]8
Phos
a
P1 vinash harshe:
[M
2
:5
]8
Mat mur
D
P3 rkapil Dev :
[M
:5
]8
Phos
R2 upali:
[M
P0
6
:5
]8
Phos
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
7
:5
]8
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Phos
>
:+1::+1:
See the science and art of individualisation through the Repertorisation.
Now just see how would be the remedy is suitable to overall case.
Pt - Someone told me that you have to rest for a week , you can't work , you can't put foot into water ; and in
one case I had seen an exposed operated part as a hole inside put so I scared very much so decided to avoid
surgery.
Rubric ?
D:5 rkapil Dev :

[M
P ]8
Impressionable
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
9
:5
]8
Yes but what is her main feel behind avoiding surgery ?
D
P1 rkapil Dev :
[M
:0
]9
Perhaps she wants to be active
Not wants to stay at one place only

R
P3 upali:
[M
:0
]9
She will be unable to work
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:0
]9
Drkapil Dev
>
Perhaps she wants to be active

>
No assumption but what she told exactly ?

DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Yes but what is her main feel behind avoiding surgery ?

>
Is it fear ?
D
P7 rkapil Dev :
[M
1
:0
]9
Fear operation
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
1
:0
]9
Drkapil Dev
>
Fear operation
>
Is it of only operation ?
D
P4 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
1
:0
]9
Fear of disease impending
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:0
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Is it of only operation ?
>
Or its consequences also ?

D
> r.Kiranmayi
Fear of disease impending

>
Not exactly.
D6 rkapil Dev :
[M
P1
2
:0
]9
Fear apoplexy
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:0
]9
No
G7 anesh Ingle:
[M
P3
2
:0
]9
Fear of happening something
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
2
:0
]9
Give proper word for what she told ?

D
[M
3
:0
]9
Fear suffering
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:0
]9
Ganesh Ingle
>
Fear of happening something

>
Not something but she told exactly.

Dr Avinash Gupta
>
Fear suffering
>
:+1::+1::+1:
Rubric ?
D
P6 rkapil Dev :
[M
3
:0
]9
Mind fear suffering of
G
P4 anesh Ingle:
[M
3
:0
]9
Fear of infection
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
3
:0
]9
Drkapil Dev
>
Mind fear suffering of

>
:+1::+1: Record it.

Ganesh Ingle
>
Fear of infection
>
No
Pt - Actually I was very much involved means I was in love with someone. We was about to marry and suddenly
we had breakup so I had mentally trauma and that is only thing.
Rubric ?
G
P5 anesh Ingle:
[M
:0
]9
Ailments from mental shock
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
5
:0
]9
Ganesh Ingle
>
Ailments from mental shock

>
Not exactly as it is secondary.
What happened exactly ?
D8 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P3
5
:0
]9
Disappointed love
G1 anesh Ingle:
[M
P4
5
:0
]9
Ailments from disappointment love

R
P4 upali:
[M
5
:0
]9
Ailments from disappointed love
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:0
]9
:+1::+1::+1:
Record it.
I am very moody.
Rubric ?
R5 upali:
[M
P3
7
:0
]9
Mind mood changable
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
7
:0
]9
:+1:
Record it.
D3 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P5
7
:0
]9
Mind morose
D
[M
8
:0
]9
Changeble mood
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:0
]9
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Mind morose
>
No , morose is sad and irritable.
Confused ,cant make decision.
Rubric ?
D2 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P3
8
:0
]9
Ok
D3 rkapil Dev :
[M
P4
8
:0
]9
Irresolution
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
8
:0
]9
:+1:
Record it.
Dr - What do you like or don't like more in food and drinks ?
Pt - Junk food , pizza , burger , cake, fish , chicken .
Rubric ?
D
P2 rkapil Dev :
[M
4
:0
]9
Spices
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:0
]9
:+1:
D
P8 rkapil Dev :
[M
0
:1
]9
Gen food and drinks spices desire
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:1
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it.
R
P4 upali:
[M
0
:1
]9
General food and drink. Farnacious desire for
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:1
]9
Rupali
>
General food and drink. Farnacious desire for

>
Main point is spicy.
Pt - Meat and beef causes diarrhea.
Rubric ?
[M
P0
4
:1
]9
General food and drink, meat agg
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:1
]9
Take more general rubric .
Meat and beef is rich of ?

R
P6 upali:
[M
4
:1
]9
Ok
[M
P5
4
:1
]9
Fat
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:1
]9
:+1:
Rubric ?
D
[M
5
:1
]9
General food and drink, fat agg
D0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
5
:1
]9
:+1:
Record it.
Dr - At one side you said still you love him a lot and at other side you are not ready to accept him, what is this ?
Is it love ?
Pt - Once he done something wrong with me ,bad with me so I never think I would accept him again.
Pt - About 4 months , then I thought what is there is there and why to think of what is not there but again since
last two weeks again I feeling like same and crying a lot remembering him, still I love him a lot.
[M
P2
7
:1
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Dr - At one side you said still you love him a lot and at other
>
Mind Contradictory action to his intention
D0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
8
:1
]9

>
Mind Contradictory action to his intention

>
Close but not exactly , what she tell is not ready to do for her own purpose of thinking.
In love person don't think of loss or benefit.
In subtle way that girl mind her business in every situation.
D
[M
1
:2
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Pt - About 4 months , then I thought what is there is there and

>
Dwells on past disaggreable occurence
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:2
]9
What she tell not willing to behave according to that.

>
Dwells on past disaggreable occurence

>
First try to take her overall mind disposition.
In subtle way it is hypocrisy.
D
[M
3
:2
]9
Ok
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:2
]9
With talking of business.
So rubrics ?
D
P1 rkapil Dev :
[M
3
:2
]9
Mind hypocrisy
[M
P1
3
:2
]9
Mind talking business of

D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
3
:2
]9
:+1:
D
P1 rkapil Dev :
[M
3
:2
]9
Mind talking business of
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it.
john
>
Extremities corn feet sole

>
O/E - Thick hard ( horny ) corn on left sole.
Say more specific rubric ?
D
P5 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
4
:2
]9
Extrem corns foot sole horny
D6 rkapil Dev :
[M
P5
4
:2
]9
Ext corn feet horny
[M
P0
5
:2
]9
Extremities corn feet sole horny
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
Extremities - corns - feet - soles - horny
Record it.
D7 rkapil Dev :
[M
P1
6
:2
]9
Gen sides left
D4 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P5
6
:2
]9
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
8
:2
]9
Drkapil Dev
>
Gen sides left

>
Yes
Dr.Kiranmayi
>
Photo
>
:+1::+1: So final remedy ?
D
P4 rkapil Dev :
[M
0
:2
]9
Phos
D
P4 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
0
:2
]9
Phos

[M
P ]9
:+1::+1:
Rx
Phos 200 stat.
Follow up - Within 2 weeks all her pain stopped completely. Size , hardness and thickness of corn reduced
significantly.
Asked for further follow ups still complete cure.
D
P2 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
0
:3
]9
D
[M
0
:3
]9
Thanks sir for sharing :+1:
D
P4 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
0
:3
]9
:+1::+1:
D7 rkapil Dev :
[M
P4
0
:3
]9
Nice analysis...
Thanks for sharing sir.. :pray::pray::pray:
D
[M
1
:3
]9
Characteristics symptoms plus chief complaints can give us remedy very easily
edited
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:3
]9
All other things like tall , fair , beautiful lady ( not mentioned in case ) also matching with constitution of Phos.
D
[M
2
:3
]9
Not to depend on mental symptoms only what we learn here
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:3
]9
Yes
D
[M
:3
]9
Prescribing on mental symptoms can mislead us if u r not excellent in mind rubrics

K
P1 austubh:
[M
4
:3
]9
V
[ oice message ]
10 KB
D4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
5
:3
]9

>
Prescribing on mental symptoms can mislead us if u r not excelle

>
Though excellent in mind rubrics one has to take totality of case as per standards of Homeopathic prescription.
D
[M
:3
]9
Sir i ask u one one question
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:3
]9
Yes ?
D
[M
6
:3
]9
nice case sir
late ho gaya aaj
:+1::+1::+1:phos
D
[M
7
:3
]9
If we prescribe on mental symptoms and the remedy not cover the chief complaint then
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
7
:3
]9

>
If we prescribe on mental symptoms and the remedy not cover the

>
Doubtful of cure.
D
[M
8
:3
]9
May be palliation?
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
0
:4
]9
Homeopathy : Homeo (similar ) + pathy ( disease )
It is the base of Homeopathy.

So the medicine should must have ability to produce similar disease.
>
May be palliation?
>
If we are walking on highway then no need to think of diversions.
D
[M
:4
]9
Ok sir
D0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
5
:4
]9
See this is patient. Later I would delete photo.
D
[M
5
:4
]9
Ok
D0 rkapil Dev :
[M
P2
6
:4
]9
What is specific in this photo acc to u sir..??
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:4
]9
Tall , fair , sharp features with beautiful look.
D
P5 rkapil Dev :
[M
7
:4
]9
:pray::pray:
What about sharp features sir
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
Drkapil Dev
>
What about sharp features sir

>
Observe Eyes , nose , ears , lips - sharp that is so called tubercular.
D
[M
5
:4
]9
:+1::+1:
D1 rkapil Dev :
[M
P3
0
:5
]9
:pray::pray:thanks sir for clearing doubts and making us better observer..
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
0
:5
]9
Thanks all :pray:

R8 upali:
[M
P4
1
:5
]9
:ok_hand::ok_hand:
Nice case sir
D
[M
6
:5
]9
:+1::+1:
constitution:+1::+1:
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
8
:5
]9
Family history of cancer :

Phos is carcinogenic element.
[M
P4
:5
0
]1
Nice case n its analysis :ok_hand::ok_hand:
R
P8 upali Mendhe:
[M
0
:3
]1
Nice case , analysis

M
a
A1 vinash harshe:
[M
3
:5
]6
Nice analysis
D
A3 r Manoj Babu 9821409773 Gupta:
[M
0
:4
]8
Wonderful case
[M
A1
2
:4
]8
Nice case analysis
D
A0 eepika Londhe:
[M
3
:1
]9
Nice case sir:pray::pray:

T
D
A2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:3
]4
§ 45 Sixth Edition
No! Two diseases, differing, it is true, in kind1but very similar in their phenomena and effects and in the sufferings and
symptoms they severally produce, invariably annihilate one another whenever they meet together in the organism; the
stronger disease namely, annihilates the weaker, and that for this simple reason, because the stronger morbific power
when it invades the system, by reason of its similarity of action involves precisely the same part of the organism that were
previously affected by the weaker morbid irritation, which, consequently, can no longer act on these parts, but is
extinguished2, or (in other words), the new similar but stronger morbific potency controls the feelings of the patient and
hence the life principle on account of its peculiarity, can no longer feel the weaker similar which becomes extinguished -
exists no longer - for it was never anything material, but a dynamic - spirit-like - (conceptual) affection. The life principle
henceforth is affected only and this but temporarily by the new, similar but stronger morbific potency.
1 Vide, supra, § 26, note.
2 Just as the image of a lamp's flame is rapidly overpowered and effaced from our retina by the stronger sunbeam
impinging on the eye.
M
A4 itul Patra:
[M
3
:2
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Tall , fair , sharp features with beautiful look.

>
If the patient had no such look then will she be prescribed phos?
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
e..g. Diabetes mellitus with hyperthyroidism , Hypothyroidism

>
In old aged man we seldom find HTN and prostate enlargement. Can it be considered double complex disease?
D
A9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:0
]8
Mitul Patra
>
If the patient had no such look then will she be prescribed phos
>
Yes you can if symptom totality of patient agree with symptoms of Phos.
Mitul Patra
>
In old aged man we seldom find HTN and prostate enlargement. Can
>
Yes
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 45 Sixth Edition No! Two diseases, differing, it is true, in

>
Diseases of different kind that is either originated from nature or produced by medicine if similar in their action
in form of its effect as phenomenon of symptoms then always stronger one take control of vital principle where
weaker one no more exist and so get extinguished from organism.
This is not materialistic but purely conceptual spiritual affection where stronger morbific dynamic force
annihilate the weaker morbific irritation as former occupy precisely same part of the organism manifesting
similar action as like later one but more stronger in power so controls the feelings of the patients resulting into
no more life principle can feel the weaker similar affection.
Under the influence of stronger morbific potency vital principle get free from weaker similar one and get
affected temporary by new stronger morbific potency.
Usually we see that whenever our eyes get exposed to rays of bright sunlight then effect of lamp light vanishes
from our eyesight as weaker lamp light could not show effect on retina when more bright sunlight affects the
retina.
s
P0 udha iyer :
[M
7
:5
]2
Stronger similar affecn whether natural or artificial(medicinal) will always extinguish the weaker one from the bonding
with vital force.
The stronger spiritual dynamic force by virtue of being similar occupies the same space vacated by the weaker one.
Now the vital force is temporarily under the influence of the stronger affection.
Eg: the effect of brightness of a lamp vanishes from our eyes when our eyes gets exposed to sunlight.
D3 r santosh Londhe :
[M
P4
7
:0
]9
Stronger, constitutional,dynamic power of artificial or medicinal disease take charge over weak natural disease
W
Raksha Thakkar invited Paras Chhayani
T
D
A4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]1
Solved Case is presented by Dr.Sudha Madam:
A young dr came to me for treatment of depressiin

Eyes had sadness and he talked in a low subdued voice.
He said he had problem of negative thinking. Some fear that something bad will happen in future. He worked in a dialysis
centre from morning to evening and the centre was short staffed. So he was gven post of manager one fine day. Either he
had to accept this post and take more responsibilities of the sacked drs or he could leave if he was not ready to handle
extra wirk. All this happened suddenly. He had the responsibility of deciding whethrr to admit pt for dialysis or refer them
to another big hospital. He could not afford to relax or rest or take a wrong decisiin as he was under the scanner always by
management. One small mistake and they would send him off. He wanted to leave as he was always under tension but he
dfnt have confidence to depend completely on his own practice.
He said that his practice is moderate but he felt that he could not impress patients; he couldnt gv them a feel of a
confident dr.
This hospital job hv made me unhappy and unsure of myself. I want desperately to leave; at the same time i start thinking
i hv a wife and child to manage; i need that payment from dialysis centre; hiw can i leave that job?
I feel confused. I feel i cannot judge or manage properly.
I feel worthless as if i cannot handle anything. I feel low in my own eyes.
I feel my present and future r shrouded in darkness. I was ur student longback. I know homoeopathy has medicines for
this problem. Pl show some light maam.
IA[M]1:460 mtiyaz Bagban:
Calcarea carb dd - Anacardium
s
A0 udha iyer :
[M
7
:4
]1
Convert wordings of pt to rubric.
S
A3 hraddha:
[M
0
:5
]1
Thermal ?
Natmur ? If pt is hot
IA[M]1:5243 mtiyaz Bagban:
Want of self confidence ,self depreciation
Irresolution
Fear to lose his job lucrative
Anxiety future about
Light desire
S
A2 hraddha:
[M
6
:5
]1
Helpless feeling
Anticipatory anxiety
s
P9 udha iyer :
[M
:0
2
]1
Dr imtiaz nice feel. Little more and yu will reach remedy.
Dr shradda yes there is helplessness
D
[M
:7
2
]1
Ailments from responsibilities

Pessimistic
Confidence want of
Anxiety family
Aurum mur natronatum
DD CARCINOSIN
Is it aurum nat mur??

V
P9 idyasagar:
[M
:3
2
]1
s
P9 udha iyer :
[M
:3
2
]1
Nice thinking for aurum. But i hv not gven this remedy
D
P6 rkapil Dev :
[M
:4
2
]1
Lyco..
Irresolution
Will weakness
Will contradiction
Helpless
Responsibility
Self depreciation
D/d anac.. And baryta carb
Ailments from domination.. boss ke hisab se hi kam karna hota tha..
Mam.. Something right track or. -...??

s4 udha iyer :
[M
P0
7
:5
2
]1
Rubrics r right dr kapil. Lyc failed. Sil staphy failed. So i had to go by ppp. And got success
Ur rubrics r very near
D0 rkapil Dev :
[M
P4
7
:5
2
]1
sudha iyer
>
Rubrics r right dr kapil. Lyc failed. Sil staphy failed. So i ha

>
Yes feel like lyco staph.. Calc.. Baryta carb
Ok mam.. Try to be more near
s0 udha iyer :
[M
P8
:5
2
]1
Yes. U will def reach.
Convert pts words to rubrics
D4 rkapil Dev :
[M
P8
:5
2
]1
Ok mam
D
P7 r Dhan@shri:
[M
4
:0
]1
Business incapacity
Anxiety children about
Needs assurance positive light
Gelsemium
DD arg nit
Anxiety when things are expected to from him
Anticipatory Anxiety
D6 r santosh Londhe :
[M
P3
7
:0
]1
Kali Phos Dd Aacar , Arg nit
D5 rkapil Dev :
[M
P2
9
:0
]1
Yes..
Kali phos is good option..
N
P8 ilesh Thaker :
[M
:3
]1
Pulsatila/phosphorus
D
[M
4
:5
]1
Its falco pecans

DD ARSENIC, CALCAREA BARYTA
A
P8 sma Hashmi:
[M
1
:0
]2
Lac can dd phos dd gels
s
P6 udha iyer :
[M
4
:1
]2
Nice going
edited
D7 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P1
0
:5
]3
Mind sadness
s
P7 udha iyer :
[M
1
:5
]3
None of the above medicines dr azam. This case was solved by just converting words of pt into rubrics.
D8 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
P3
6
:0
]4
Argentum nit
B
[M
:0
]4
sudha iyer
>
None of the above medicines dr azam. This case was solved by jus
>
Hello mam.. Nice to see u in group..
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:0
]4
sudha iyer
>
None of the above medicines dr azam. This case was solved by jus
>
Case is presented in passive voice so it is difficult to get which dialogues are of patient and which are interpreted by
physicians from his situation.
e.g. All this happened suddenly.
Is it interpreted fact or direct dialogue by patient ?
Matter become different .
D
P3 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
0
:1
]4
Kali br
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:1
]4
Balivada Madhuri
>
Hello mam.. Nice to see u in group..

>
It is better to comment on case of discussion first rather than formal chatting.
D7 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
P3
0
:1
]4
B
[M
:1
]4
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
It is better to comment on case of discussion first rather than

>
Sorry.. Delete my msg:pray:
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:1
]4
sudha iyer
>
Convert pts words to rubrics

>
Whenever we ask to convert patient's words into rubrics then dialogues of patient should be written as it is in his words.
D
[M
9
:2
]4
Confidence lack of
Ailments responsibility
Pessimistic
Anxiety future about
Irresolution
Delusion worthless
Light desire
Depression
?Calcarea // baryta
[M
P3
8
:1
]5
MIND - CONFIDENCE - want of self-confidence

MIND - CONFUSION of mind
MIND - DELUSIONS - worthless; he is
MIND - LIGHT - desire for
lac can
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]5
Sometime we have to judge a case by taking different group of rubrics as it may happen all rubrics of case might not be
going with one remedy so we should study case analysing it in different sectors and according that we have to decide
strategy of prescriptions. e.g.
If we are going to treat chronic case and concluded constitutional medicine of case but still we could not sure same
medicine would help in acute episode of chronic.
e.g.
We are decided Sulphur as a constitutional remedy in case of migraine but in cute attack of migraine you have to go for
some acute remedy like Bryonia or Belladonna as per acute indications of case or we have to treat certain mental state
with particular state remedy
e.g. Panic state by Stram.
In this way cure of chronic cases is a multistep process most of time rather than one time event.
( From Clinical desk of Dr.Samadhan Ghule )
In above case I would give work out in different sectors of rubrics.
D
[M
:2
]5
:+1::+1::+1:
D
P0 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
4
:2
]5
:+1::+1:
B
[M
:2
]5
Dr.Nasir kureshi
>
MIND - CONFIDENCE - want of self-confidence MIND - CONFUSION of

>
Nasir.. Mine also same rubrics
D
[M
6
:2
]5
:+1::+1::+1:
edited
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:2
]5
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Solved Case is presented by Dr.Sudha Madam: A young dr came to

>
Some fear that something bad will happen in future.
Mind - Fear - happen - something will
He worked in a dialysis centre from morning to evening and the centre was short staffed. So he was gven post of manager
one fine day. Either he had to accept this post and take more responsibilities of the sacked drs or he could leave if he was
not ready to handle extra wirk.
He had the responsibility of deciding whethrr to admit pt for dialysis or refer them to another big hospital.
Mind - Responsibility - taking responsibly too seriously

-- children in ( Single remedy rubric )
Here he is dependent ( child ) on hospital job.
This hospital job hv made me unhappy and unsure of myself.
Delusion - wrong - sufferedwrong , he has - children in ( SSUPS as contain only 3 remedies )
He could not afford to relax or rest or take a wrong decisions as he was under the scanner always by management.
One small mistake and they would send him off.
This hospital job hv made me unhappy and unsure of myself. I want desperately to leave; at the same time i start thinking
i hv a wife and child to manage; i need that payment from dialysis centre; hiw can i leave that job?
Mind - Helplessness, feeling of

-- Emotional level , on ( Single remedy rubric )
-- mental level , on ( Single remedy rubric )
( If you see all his helpless feeling is due to his thinking or emotions as actually nothing in fact in his life situation which is
really problematic and he is not going to solve , he is doing job and practice ; and also getting paid for that so what is
problematic is only his way of thinking)
Mind - Anxiety - future about
Mind - Anxiety - children about his
He wanted to leave as he was always under tension but he dfnt have confidence to depend completely on his own practice.
confident dr.
Mind - confidence - want of self-confidence

1st choice -- Carcinosin.
B
[M
2
:4
]5
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Some fear that something bad will happen in future. Mind - Fe

>
:+1: :+1:
D
[M
3
:4
]5
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Case is presented in passive voice so it is difficult to get whi

>
Absolutely agree with u
Here the patient is given the post of manager suddenly which he feels incapable of
Ailments from responsibility unusual - single remedy aurmurnat
[M
P1
6
:4
]5
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Some fear that something bad will happen in future. Mind - Fe

>
Sir, patient has strong feeling of worthlessness.. At This point I m getting confusion in selecting carcinocin..
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
6
:4
]5
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Photo
>
Add one more rubric

: Delusion - wrong - suffered wrong , he has - children in ( Baryta , Carc , Naja )
Balivada Madhuri
>
Sir, patient has strong feeling of worthlessness.. At This point

>
Wait , explaining in further sector of rubrics.

>
Ailments from responsibility unusual - single remedy aurmurnat

>
Yes one of close similar.
D
[M
:0
]5
Here the patients experience of his situation is very important. How he experience his situation. He experience
Helplessness, self depriciation, confidence lack of, anxiety about family, Pessimistic.
edited
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:0
]5
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
All this happened suddenly.
Mind - Astonished
I was ur student longback. I know homoeopathy has medicines for this problem. Pl show some light maam.
Mind - light - desire for
A young dr came to me for treatment of depressiin

Eyes had sadness and he talked in a low subdued voice.
I feel my present and future r shrouded in darkness.
Mind - Sadness - darkness ,in
confident dr.
hiw can i leave that job?

He could not afford to relax or rest or take a wrong decisions as he was under the scanner always by management.
One small mistake and they would send him off.
Mind - Helplessness, feeling of
Particular mind state remedy : Stram.
D:0 r. Abhishek Deshpande:

[M
P ]5
Why you have not taken rubric related to responsibility. After all his complaints started after that
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:9
]5

>
Why you have not taken rubric related to responsibility. After

>
please see my first analysis ( Carcinosin )

7th rubric .
edited
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
>
I feel low in my own eyes.
Mind - delusions - wretched he looks
( eyes are mirror )
I was ur student longback. I know homoeopathy has medicines for this problem. Pl show some light maam.
Mind - light - desire for
hiw can i leave that job?
He wanted to leave as he was always under tension but he dfnt have confidence to depend completely on his
own practice.
He said that his practice is moderate but he felt that he could not impress patients; he couldnt gv them a feel of
a confident dr.
Next differential remedy : Nat.m
G
P7 anesh Ingle:
[M
2
:0
]6
After adding rubric Helplessness feeling of
Carc
Coming
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:0
]6
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
I feel confused. I feel i cannot judge or manage properly.I feel worthless as if i cannot handle anything.
Mind - censorious oneself ( SSUPS contain only 4 remedies )
Mind - delusion - worthless, he is
confident dr.
One more close similar remedy to personality of patient -- Aur.
As a synthetic prescription
Aur + Nat.M = Aur. mur.nat
So differential remedies of Case : Carc , Stram , Nat , Aur , Aur.nat.m .
[M
P2
0
:1
]6
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
As a synthetic prescription Aur + Nat.M = Aur. mur.nat

>
Ya right. I had one case of uterine fibroid in which calcarea and phosphorus coming closely so i have given calcphos to the
patient and patient get cured
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:1
]6

>
Ya right. I had one case of uterine fibroid in which calcarea a

>
It happens :+1::+1:
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
So differential remedies of Case : Carc , Stram , Nat , Aur , A

>
In such a situation holistic approach ( mind + body ) helps to point individual remedy.
s8 udha iyer :
[M
P5
9
:0
]7
I think i will post answer of case first.
Laccan was the remedy which gave result.
Dr almas and dr nasir gas reached
s
P4 udha iyer :
[M
2
:1
]7
Dilip Jani[3/21/18]
Dilip Jani:
Confidence want of self
Fear of failure
Fear of failure in business
Anxiety with fear
Irresolution
Del worthless
Fear of dark
Light desire for
Anxiety from doubt about success
Lac can
Fe
md
rw
:o
g
sa
Lovedeep Kumar[3/21/18]
Anxiety success from doubt about

Confidence want of self
Fear failure of
Antagonism with himself
D
[M
6
:1
]7
:+1::+1::+1::+1:
B
[M
6
:1
]7
sudha iyer
>
Dr almas and dr nasir gas reached

>
Mam.. Me too:blush::blush:
s9 udha iyer :
[M
P0
8
:1
]7
Nice madhu. I was inma hurry. So ddnt see ur workout.
Now i send pts whatsap msgs which i had asked my hubby to put in my { HYPERLINK "http://telegram.so/" \t
"_blank" } i could share with u.
[M
P0
9
:1
]7
sudha iyer
>
Nice madhu. I was inma hurry. So ddnt see ur workout.

>
Actually not posted chart.. My rubrics are same as Nasir..
s
P1 udha iyer :
[M
0
:2
]7
Srinivasan Iyer[3/21/18]
Sorry for disturbing you.

Yesterday I have taken medicine......
But today I eaten onion......
Is there any issue with this........
No
How r u? Told u to tell me after 10 days.

Mam,
The effects are too good...
Prior aggravation was observed....for 2-4 days but after result was good.......I can able to sleep {
HYPERLINK "http://well.able/" \t "_blank" } to plan-think for future planing....
Nice. Nw no repetitiin for long time. Dont worry
Why u ddnt come fir follow up? Hope u r much better

Hello mam.
Feeling well......
I am shifted to Satara....near Pune.......
[M
P1
0
:2
]7
Worthless feeling is strong characteristic feature of lac can
s5 udha iyer :
[M
P1
0
:2
]7
Srinivasan Iyer[3/21/18]
Good .
: With family??
Yes with wife n son
:+1::clap: :clap:
: Joined hospital in satara
: As a dmo
: :+1:
: Started all new things
: Good. I am too happy fir u
: Yes. My pleasure. Thanks god and thanks to.homoeopatgy.
: Thank you mam
: I think this was the right decision
: Definitely. God bless u
: Yes thanks
Homoeopathy.......
: Ok. Bye. Keep in touch
: Bye mam......
: Hello. This my depression pts whatsap msgs. Can u forward these to my telegram?
[21/03 4:14 PM] sudha Iyer iyer: Then i share with griup
s
P0 udha iyer :
[M
1
:2
]7
See anac aurmn aur all were near in chart. But i had taken only ppp.
Even argn and carc in 6th snd 7th posn. But in this case i just converted pts concern into rubrics.
Thanks all for active participation.
And see rubrics taken by dilip jani sir and lovedeep sir. In that group we only take ppp.
B
[M
1
:2
]7
sudha iyer
>
And see rubrics taken by dilip jani sir and lovedeep sir. In tha
>
As far my knowledge, if worthless feeling is strong +lack of confidence + fear ( think of this dog's milk) lac can
s
P4 udha iyer :
[M
8
:2
]7
I think u gave an audio msg on laccan madhu long back
[M
P3
9
:2
]7
sudha iyer
>
I think u gave an audio msg on laccan madhu long back

>
Yes mam
s
P2 udha iyer :
[M
1
:3
]7
Thanks madhu
[M
P1
2
:3
]7
sudha iyer
>
Thanks madhu
>
Thanks for what mam:smile::smile:?
s
P4 udha iyer :
[M
2
:3
]7
Learning of laccan
Laccan i learned from all my friends in various groups.
B
[M
5
:3
]7
sudha iyer
>
Learning of laccan
>
Thanks to you mam.. Not active in groups in these days, u posted this case, that way I am discussing..
D4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
8
:3
]7
sudha iyer
>
Dilip Jani: Confidence want of self Fear of failure Fear of fail

>
:+1::+1: Thanks for Sharing :pray:

[M
P4
8
:3
]7
sudha iyer
>
Good . : With family?? Yes with wife n son :+1::clap: :clap: : Joined ho
>
Nice case with follow up mam :ok_hand::ok_hand:
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
9
:0
]8
sudha iyer
>

>
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Photo
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand:SSUPS
Mind - Anxiety - success, anxiety from doubt about -- new rubric to learn. ( from standard reference - Hering's
Guiding Symptoms )
If you see carefully in above chart rubric no.1 ( Mind - Anxiety - success anxiety, from doubt about )
individualise the Lac.c from rest of all other leading differential remedies of case , such rubrics are called SSUPS
that is individualising rubrics of case otherwise rest of other rubrics shared by many of medicines.
:+1:
s
P4 udha iyer :
[M
:2
]8
Yes.:+1:
D
[M
5
:2
]8
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand:SSUPS Mind - Anxiety - success, anxiety from doubt about --

>
Yes :ok_hand::ok_hand::+1:
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:2
]8
Next important rubrics of Lac.c is : -
Again it can be used as SSUPS as contain only limited number of rubrics( 11 )
Now combine above two rubrics .

DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Photo
>
:blush: This is an art and science of Repertorisation.
B
[M
9
:2
]8
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand:SSUPS Mind - Anxiety - success, anxiety from doubt about --

>
Nice rubric
[M
P5
9
:2
]8
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:ok_hand::ok_hand:
D
P9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:3
]8
Mind - light - desire for : is one more clear rubric of this case.
Combine this with

Again Lac.c :blush:
Dr.Nasir thought of Lac.c as his totality of rubrics contain this characteristic rubric's combination of Lac.c.
D
P0 r.Kiranmayi:
[M
:4
]8
:+1::+1:
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
0
:4
]8
What is individualising in the case and medicines always determine the choice of remedy.
[M
P1
3
:4
]8
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Next important rubrics of Lac.c is : - Mind - delusion - worth

>
yes i thought this way only

only 11 remedies
D0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
3
:4
]8
For scientific learning always keep aware your critical mind which can criticise as well as appreciate the matter of fact to
judge the truth.
I always use to say my students, try to learn the process of case work out which would help you to get the
remedy of every case.
Once you learn fishing then no need to pay to buy every particular type of fish from market.
Along with knowledge of rubrics the materia medica knowledge of individual images of medicines is essential
then only one can use rubrics artistically to select the individual remedy of case.
D
P1 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
3
:0
]9
sudha iyer
>

>
:clap::clap:nice case mam. Thanks for sharing

Balivada Madhuri
>
As far my knowledge, if worthless feeling is strong +lack of con

>
:+1:nice combination
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
4
:0
]9
One more important message I want to convey you :

Whenever you work out your case sincerely as perfect as possible based on law of similarity from your available knowledge
of Repertory and Materia Medica then nothing is absolutely wrong in practice of Homeopathy as your selected remedy
always helps you to go some steps ahead in the process of cure.
Again thanks all for vigorous participation in case discussion :pray:
s
P2 udha iyer :
[M
1
:0
]9
Thanks dear admin fr tking up study of my case with so much enthusiasm. Admin leads the way always.
Thanks to all membrs agsin who participated. The way forward is only by sharing and learning by working out
cases. :bouquet::bouquet:
A
P4 sma Hashmi:
[M
:5
0
]1
Mam me too:blush::blush:
Nice case mam

Thanks for sharing:+1:
D4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P9
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
So differential remedies of Case : Carc , Stram , Nat , Aur , A

>
If you would not get surprise I would like to assure that any one remedy from such analysed closely similar remedies of
case can offer significant improvement in case as per their proportion of similarity to case as some of above grouped
remedies also have individualising indications from case ; it is like sometimes you have some ways to reach particular
destiny and you can travel as per your own judgement of journey.
F
B
A4 alivada Madhuri :
[M
7
:0
]1
Lac can.. I posted this couple of weeks back, but posting again, as sudha mam posted lac can case yesterday..
.- MADHU
Voice message
[ ]
1.7 MB
D
A4 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
0
:2
]1
attraction, affection,appreciation three main axis in lac.c:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::pray::pray:
K:2 eshav Nakate:

[M
A ]1
Balivada Madhuri
>
Audio
>
:+1::+1::+1:
D
A4 rkapil Dev :
[M
6
:3
]1
Balivada Madhuri
>
Audio
>
:clap::clap:
Delusions nose someone else's nose... Lac can single.. What this means??
[M
P4
7
:5
2
]1
Drkapil Dev
>
Delusions nose someone else's nose... Lac can single.. What this
>
She feels that, she is not herself and her properties not her own-- as wears somebody else's nose..
Ex: The feeling of black person in fair people dominating country, unlucky feeling for born with black skin, he tries to
perform best, compete with them, but knows that ultimately he will still be black..
:point_up_2: Lac can situation :pray:
s
P3 udha iyer :
[M
:0
]1
Nose implies dignity. So when u feel u r wearing others nose means u lack confidence in urself that is selfdepreciation; u
r not confident on urssrlf
G9 anesh Patil:
[M
P2
4
:0
]1
Rajan sankaran sir gave example of lac can as a girl with dark color whose elder sister is fair and much good looking than
her. There is always a comparison between them and she feels herself worthless. She puts on make up... tries many things.
But ultimately she knows that she can't be as beautiful as her sister. :new_moon_with_face::full_moon_with_face:
B
[M
4
:0
]1
Balivada Madhuri
>
She feels that, she is not herself and her properties not her ow
>
Words from M. L. TYLER, sole of remedies and phatak mm

Ganesh Patil
>
Rajan sankaran sir gave example of lac can as a girl with dark c
>
Exactly... He gave this black man example too in his book... M. L. TYLER (drug pictures) narrated this some one
else nose in this way.
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:4
]2
Unsolved case is presented by Dr. Shrikant Manu:
This is my Patient Case Record. It's bit complicated but I took it as a challenge.
Pl help me to choose correct remedy with your own approaches.
Case Record
Age :36 Male
Profession : Teaching in Higher Classes
Weight : 74kg
Height : 5f 10inch
Looks : Handsome with light brown skin, Attractive Personality with fair body build
Place : Ranchi, Jharkhand [India]
Email : { HYPERLINK "mailto:shrikantmanu@yahoo.in" \t "_blank" }
Present Complain :
Shifting unbearable pain [sometime with inflammation] in waist extending towards lower and upper limbs, especially in
back and ribs from childhood.
Mood Swing with slight Depression.
Difficulties in standing and walking.
Weak memory.
Fatigue.
Weak digestion,
Clinical diagnosis :
Anklylosing Spondylitis
Low----HB, Vitamin-D,B12
High--ESR, CRP
HLA B-27 POSITIVE
Inflammation, small erosion and low signal intensity in both sacroiliac joints.
Bilateral sacroiliitis.
Medical History :
Ear Discharge, Intestinal worms , Rectal Prolapse . [age- 1 to 5]
Heavy Head, Gastritis, frequent urination with smell and unsatisfactory slight loose stool. [age- 6 to till now]
Long term use of antacids,antihistamines,nutrition supplements, antidepressants, NSAIDs, Skeletal and Muscle relaxants,
DMARDs. [age-25 to 35]
Vaccination : All the vaccination which facility provided by Government of India freely after birth of a child till 6 months.
Rabies vaccine in childhood.
Taken remedy : Rhus-t , Ruta, Ars, Nux-v, China, Colch, Antim-t, Antim-c, Thuj, Stram, Rhod, Lach, Carci , Aesc,- no Effect
Family history of suicidal death, hernia, sinus and rheumatism.
Modalities :
Worse - cold weather and winter, long time fixed pose, standing and sitting long time, flatulent food
Better- summer, after micro-exercises, pranayam, movement, warm applications, hot bath, acupressure, applying
pressure, Rubbing and massages
doing any work of great interest, Lying on hard plain surface, Applying oil on head, perspiration on middle back
Appetite & Sexuality - normal but when pain increases with slight fever and swelling of any body part then it decreases.
Aversion -:oily and stodger food, friends, noise, light, sun, odors, pickle, fats and rich food, being outdoor, show-off,
function-parties, celebration, festivals
Desire- -:water, potato, soup, family, music, warm food, sweet after taking meal, watching and reading serious/deep
fiction,
-:warm food/water, spicy food followed by sweat food
Thirst -:large quantities of water frequently, prefer extra hot in winter and extra cold in summer
No addiction, NO Repeating Dreams.
Perspiration-:a lot with slight offensive odor
Mind -:
Extreme logical in thought and debate,
Week memory alternating with dull memory,
Eloquent, Intelligent and Creative, Confident, Writer, Poet, Good orator, Obsessive, Compulsive, Strong Imagination,
Sometimes think much and conscientious about very trifle/insignificant things and topics,
Unknown fear about future works which is really very easy to do,
Fear of forgetting any important works to do,
Previously ambitious but now no ambition,
Acute senses, Impatient, Responsible, Sensitive, Emotional, Cautious, forgetful, indifference, Fastidious, irritability,
Does mistakes and calls wrong names by calling children and their students name,
Heart beat increases by sudden sound even it can be low,
Weakness After anger, Difficult to concentrate,
Vertigo and nausea in vehicle and swing,
Fear of happening something,
Sleep-:
If PT goes to bed after 9 PM, he can not sleep before midnight. Not feel fresh even after 8 hours sleep. When pain agg
sleep become superficial
All day sleepiness alternating with sleeplessness, Sleepiness with Nap after Lunch and it relaxes PT physically and
Mentally,
Sometimes sleepy but can not sleep,
Dream -: sometimes repeat the same things and thoughts in dream what happened in the day.
Hair -: Half White
Teeth
-: sensitive to extreme cold and bitter
Back
: Rheumatic pain in waist, spine , whole back , side ribs; stiffness in Lumbosacral region
: Heaviness in sacroilliac region , degeneration in spinal cord , Lumber pain extending to cervical
: inflammation in lumber, sacro-illiac region; sometimes it extended to lower and upper parts of body. If it
goes to chest breathing is difficult.
: weakness and stiffness in waist area,
Disposition -: Affectionate, Loquacious, Argumentative, Impatient, Love the indoors, Philosophical,

Ailment From -- Humiliation and dishonor/insult/abuse from Parents and Classmate in Childhood [probability
only]
The progression of disease is slow but comparably rapid in last 10 years. It was very slow in childhood.
B
[M
4
:1
]6
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Unsolved case is presented by Dr. Shrikant Manu: This is my Pat

>
Seems like silicea
I will give clear discription why I selected silecia, after my clinic hrs..
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:3
]6
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
> -: sensitive to extreme cold and bitter Back : Rheumatic
First of all one thing I want to clear in this case for case presenting doctor and all that is don't expect complete cure by one
prescription of remedy in such cases as per my experience from completely cured cases of ankylosing spondylitis such
cases require long term treatment about 1 - 2 years and during this period one has to use individual constitutional
remedy , specific antimiasmatic remedies as well as different acute state remedies whenever there is acute episodes of
pain attacks.
In group discussion one can expect only good initiation of cure by well selection of first prescription in such cases ,
attending physician should decide further management of case as per conditions of follow ups.
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
9
:5
]6
Keeping in view family history of suicidal death and personal history of autoimmune disease in this case one has to give
suitable antisyphilitic remedy at suitable time during course of treatment.
Taking in account history of taking almost all scheduled vaccines in this case one has to give at least one
suitable remedy from rubric of G - Vaccination - ailments after
Until and unless one does not remove all these blocks he could not expect complete cure of such cases.
B
[M
4
:1
]7
It is really deficult to analyse case by just reading patients symptoms on screen.. Most of the time it may lead to wrong
prescription. Every doctor has unique way of case taking, well I can pose my openion on this case, but can't prescribe any
remedy in this way.
Ankylosing spondylitis is autoimmune disease, so it is almost impossible to cure with single remedy.. It may take years to
treat.. Anti miasimatic(syphilitic) drugs and organ remedies
may require as intercurrent remedies.
Well, I want to talk on remedy on the basis of present predominant symptoms
Ankylosing spondylitis, shifting pains, summer AGG, intolerance of cold, frequent urination with worms, profuse offensive
perspiration, stiffness and weak spine, stools come out with difficulty, SILICEA is my choice for present situation.
(As I am not direct consultant of patient, I am not sure about prescription)
Thank you
Madhuri
V
P3 INOD DHANAWAT:
[M
0
:2
]7
General _ family history of susidal daeth

General _ sitting agg
Back _ pain
General _ autoimmune disease
General _ vaccination ailments after
Mind _affectionate
Mind _ loquacious
Mind _carefull of others
Mind _ philosophy ability for
Mind _ ailments from mortification
Stomach _ thirst large quantities for
Perspiration _ profuse
Mind _ conscious about trifles
Mind _anxity future about
Mind _ concentration difficult
Mind _ fear happen something will
Carcinocin / sulphur
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
4
:5
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Unsolved case is presented by Dr. Shrikant Manu: This is my Pat

>
Analysis of case :
Shifting unbearable pain
Generals - Pain - wandering

Generals - Pain - intolerable
Mood Swing with slight Depression.
Mind - mood - changeable
Clinical diagnosis :
Anklylosing Spondylitis
Back - Ankylosing spondylarthritis
Back - inflammation - joints - rheumatic
Long term use of antacids,antihistamines,nutrition supplements, antidepressants, NSAIDs, Skeletal and Muscle relaxants,
DMARDs. [age-25 to 35]
Generals - medicines - allopathic - abuse of
Vaccination : All the vaccination which facility provided by Government of India freely after birth of a child till 6 months.
Rabies vaccine in childhood.
Generals - Vaccinations - ailments after
Worse - cold weather and winter, long time fixed pose, standing and sitting long time, flatulent food
Generals - seasons - winter agg.
Better- summer, after micro-exercises, pranayam, movement, warm applications, hot bath, acupressure, applying
pressure, Rubbing and massages
doing any work of great interest, Lying on hard plain surface, Applying oil on head, perspiration on middle back
Generals - seasons - summer amel

Generals - warm application - amel
Generals - motion amel
Generals - rubbing amel
Generals - pressure amel
Mind - occupation amel
Previously ambitious but now no ambition
Mind - Ambition - loss of

Does mistakes and calls wrong names by calling children and their students name,
Mind - mistakes making - names in
Weakness After anger, Difficult to concentrate,
Mind - weakness - anger - after
Mind - Ailments - anger - from
Ailment From -- Humiliation and dishonor/insult/abuse from Parents and Classmate in Childhood [probability only]
Mind - Ailments from - mortification

Mind - Ailments from - humiliation
D4 r. Shrikant Manu :
[M
P3
6
:5
]7
I want to clear that all the mind symptoms what have been mentioned has strong proof.
But how can so much mind rubrics be taken altogether ?
If we don't allow such Patient NSAID with our classical remedy he can bear his pain , even for single day.
His brother,sister and father having same Gene -HLA b-27.

Same symptoms with less/ more Intensity.
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:0
]8
Thermal of case ?
D4 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P5
3
:0
]8
Chilly
[M
P3
4
:0
]8
Amel by warm application and hot bath
Agg -winter
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:0
]8
Dr. Shrikant Manu

>
I want to clear that all the mind symptoms what have been mentio
>
This is difficulty of this case as contain too much general mental rubrics.
Case taking more mechanical rather than fluent.
D
P1 r. Shrikant Manu :
[M
5
:0
]8
Ohh
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:0
]8
Dr. Shrikant Manu

>
Amel by warm application and hot bath

>
These are no criterias to define general thermal.

Dr. Shrikant Manu
>
Agg -winter
>
Modalities of disease are different from general thermal modality.

R1 upali:
[M
P4
6
:0
]8
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:0
]8
Hot - in general as a person could not tolerate hot weather

R
P2 upali:
[M
7
:0
]8
[M
P1
7
:0
]8
Need extra hot in cold and extra chilly in hot

R4 upali:
[M
P3
7
:0
]8
Sulph ,carc,
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
7
:0
]8
Chilly -
in general as a person could not tolerate cold
D
[M
:0
]8
Yes
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:0
]8
Dr. Shrikant Manu

>
Need extra hot in cold and extra chilly in hot

>
your patient is hot or chilly irrespective of modalities of diseases ?
D
[M
4
:0
]8
Chilly
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
9
:0
]8
OK
D
[M
3
:1
]8
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Hot - in general as a person could not tolerate hot weather

>
I think he is ambithermal because he need cooler in summer and heater/blower in winter
D
P9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:1
]8
Now think of one of differential remedied using artistic approach.
D
[M
5
:1
]8
Is miasmatic approach necessary ?
Difficult to specify PT miasm
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
0
:3
]8
Patient is full of mind symptoms and modalities so these factor are not individualising in this case as what is abundant it
become common.
So we have to search what is individualising in this case.
edited
Back - inflammation - joints - rheumatic
This rubric contain limited numbers (9)of medicines and well define location and pathology of case.
D
[M
5
:3
]8
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Patient is full of mind symptoms and modalities so these factor

>
Ok
edited
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:3
]8
Out of 9 - Flav , hyper ,nux , rawl , thal are not antimiasmatic remedies.
Case is full of symptoms of Psora ( read list of symptoms of Psora from chronic disease ) though there is syphilis
in family background so later we may have to give antisyphilitic as a intercurrent antimiasmatic remedy.
In this case it is wise to begin with antipsoric remedy .
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Photo
>
From this characteristic rubric Causticum is antipsoric medicine which ranks high in repertorisation so suitable to
overall case.
[M
P5
2
:4
]8
Ok
So ,Causticum is final.
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:4
]8
Materia Medica reference : CAUSTICUM

Hahnemann's Tinctura acris sine Kali
Manifests its action mainly in chronic rheumatic, arthritic and paralytic affections, indicated by the tearing, drawing pains
in the muscular and fibrous tissues
by William BOERICKE
Rx
Causticum 0/1 od for a week.
Follow up after week.
D
[M
9
:4
]8
Thanks a lot.
R2 upali:
[M
P5
:9
0
]1
:disappointed_relieved:too much tough case.

S
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A3
2
:0
]9
Case is presented by Dr.Keshav Nakate:
Short case of Pharyngitis -

A male patient,age -72 years came on 18/03/2018 complaining of pain in throat,difficulty in swallowing and hoarseness of
voice.I examined his throat and found that there is congestion of throat with redness.Complaints started suddenly and as
soon as he had cold-drinks.He was very anxious feeling that he will suffer for a week or more from this.He was relieved
immediately by a dose of remedy in 200 potency.During follow up on second day he told that usually when he takes cold
drinks he suffers from throat pain which would last for a week or two progressing into bronchitis.But this time his
complaints were relieved after first dose of remedy and further progress stopped.
[M
A3
5
:2
]9
feel of aconite
redness ...congestion..sudden onset...plus anxiuos
dd belladonna
edited
D8 arshan Parmar:
[M
A4
1
:3
]9
throat- inflammation -pharynx acute

throat - congestion
throat- discoluration - red -pharynx
throat- pain -cold drinks agg
throat- swallowing difficult
larynx- trachea - voice hoarsness
generals - pain appears suddenly
mind _ anxiety
Arg.N
[M
A2
8
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Case is presented by Dr.Keshav Nakate: Short case of Pharyngiti

>
Sudden onset as soon as after cold drink+ Anxiety = ACONITE
D
A2 arshan Parmar:
[M
:3
0
]1
Darshan Parmar
>
Photo
>
throat congestion....only 4 medicine
D
A:2 rkapil Dev :
[M0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Case is presented by Dr.Keshav Nakate: Short case of Pharyngiti

>
edited
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A3
8
:4
0
]1
Nice inputs :ok_hand::blush:

R
A9 upali:
[M
0
:5
]1
Acon DD Lach.
D
P4 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:0
2
]1
V0 idyasagar:
[M
P4
:6
2
]1
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
2
:0
]5
Darshan Parmar
>
throat- inflammation -pharynx acute throat - congestion throat-

>
First think of acute remedies in acute cases , in some exceptional cases you can give some chronic medicines in acute
cases also where you have not better option from acute remedies.
Vidyasagar
>
Photo
>
Need of individualisation.
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Photo
>
Need to use rubrics artistically.
Rupali
>
Photo
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand: nicely taken rubrics.
In management of acute cases exact characteristic symptoms of acute medicines should be known .
e.g.
3pm agg.of belladonna
M
P4 itul Patra:
[M
9
:1
]6
Hep. Sulph.
D
P0 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
5
:3
]6
K
P7 eshav Nakate:
[M
0
:1
]8
The remedy given was Aconite.
Onset and pace of complaint along with anxiety was overvalued.
Disease started instantaneously after an exposure to the cause.
R6 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P2
4
:1
]8
:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand:
:pray::+1:exposure after drinking cold drink. With suddeness of the complaints marked
Anxiety
Nice case sir thanks for sharing
K9 eshav Nakate:
[M
P2
5
:1
]8
Instant and instantaneous onset in apparently healthy person along with marked anxiety about ailment favours Aconite.
Patient visited me as soon as possible for him.
I will differentiate othrr remedies afterwards
R9 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P5
6
:1
]8
Thanks sir wonderful case wonderful discussion:pray:
Dr keshav:
Actually I had given him three doses of that remedy and asked him to take second dose after half an hour of
first dose if there was no progress.But by first dose only he was relieved.
dr ujwala:
Aconite
Dr keshav:
What did you learn from this ?
Raksha Thakkar:
Suddenness
Cold food drink aggravates
Anxiety marked herwith
dr ujwala:
Suddenly
Raksha Thakkar:
AnguishNess marked in aconite
Mental calmness contraindicates aconite
Dr Keshav:
Instant onset of disease with anxiety.
We will see what Boger says about Aconite in his Synoptic Key.
Sudden,violently acute,painful effects
tensions,congestion
Here the words violently acute" are very important.

Violently acute means starting instantly and intensely.
Raksha Thakkar:
Sir a querry u asked the pt to take dose after half hour no doubt it relieved in first dose itself
Dr Keshav:
Boger also has specific words for Aconite - " < after ices".
raksha:
Organon aphorism §246
Every perceptibly progressive and strikingly increasing amelioration during treatment is a condition which, as
long as it lasts, completely precludes every repetition of the administration of any medicine whatsoever,
because all the good the medicine taken continues to effect is now hastening towards its completion. This is not
infrequently the case in acute diseases, but in more chronic diseases, on the other hand, a single dose of an
appropriately selected homeopathic remedy will at times complete even with but slowly progressive
improvement and give the help which such a remedy in such a case can accomplish naturally within 40, 50, 60,
100 days. This is, however, but rarely the case; and besides, it must be a matter of great importance to the
physician as well as to the patient that were it possible, this period should be diminished to one-half,
one-quarter, and even still less, so that a much more rapid cure might be obtained. And this may be very happily
affected, as recent and oft-repeated observations have taught me under the following conditions: firstly, if the
medicine selected with the utmost care was perfectly homeopathic; secondly, if it is highly potentized, dissolved
in water and given in proper small dose that experience has taught as the most suitable in definite intervals for
the quickest accomplishment of the cure but with the precaution, THAT THE DEGREE OF EVERY DOSE DEVIATE
SOMEWHAT FROM THE PRECEDING AND FOLLOWING in order that the vital principle which is to be altered to
a similar medicinal disease be not aroused to untoward reactions and revolt as is always the case(132) with
unmodified and especially rapidly repeated doses.
This aphorism says all the good medicine taken continues to effect is now hastening towards cure
So giving a dose after half an hour
Dr Keshav:
There was condition to repeat.
If he did not feel well then only it was advised to take second dose.
As all of us know acute diseases may require repetition if potency exhausts .
Raksha Thakkar:
But the criteria of giving doses after every 15 mins interval is it justifiable
Dr Keshav:
Not justifiable.
Raksha Thakkar:
Degree of every dose deviate somewhat from preceeding dose
Dr Keshav:
Everytime you have to take follow-up .
Raksha Thakkar:
Yes or opt for water dose
Dr keshav:
Nowadays it is very easy to take followups because everyone has phones.
You can use them to take followups.

You can give medicines in stock and advise to repeat according to need.
Raksha Thakkar:
Water dose one can opt for instead of dry dose sir
M I rt
Dr keshav:
Yeah
Tomarrow we will discuss this remedy.
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:2
]8
Keshav Nakate
>
Instant and instantaneous onset in apparently healthy person alo

>
:+1::+1:Thanks for sharing :pray:
K
P7 eshav Nakate:
[M
3
:2
]8
Thank you.
Admin sir.
R
P4 aksha Thakkar:
[M
3
:2
]8
:pray:
K
P4 eshav Nakate:
[M
:2
]8
If Samadhan sir allows me I will differentiate among other indicated remedies tomarrow.
I request him also to comment on this case.
R1 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P4
5
:2
]8
Keshav Nakate
>
If Samadhan sir allows me I will differentiate among other indic

>
Would love to learn sir admin ji green signal pls :pray::blush:
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
7
:2
]8
Keshav Nakate
>
If Samadhan sir allows me I will differentiate among other indic

>
Yes but tomorrow is questionable as it may interrupt link of further discussions so better if you can do it today only.
Attend me about 9.30pm for scientific analysis of case in light of Repertory.
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:2
]9
Hello everyone
D
P8 r Dhan@shri:
[M
0
:3
]9
Hello sir
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
0
:3
]9
Parts affected ?
M
P5 itul Patra:
[M
1
:3
]9
Throat pharynx
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
1
:3
]9
:+1:
What else ?
M2 itul Patra:
[M
P4
1
:3
]9
Swallowing agg.
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
1
:3
]9
Part ?
M
P1 itul Patra:
[M
2
:3
]9
Pharynx
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:3
]9
Hoarseness of voice related to ?
D
P2 r Dhan@shri:
[M
:3
]9
Vocal cord
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:3
]9
Vocal cord is a part of ?
D
P0 arshan Parmar:
[M
:3
]9
larynx
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:3
]9
:+1:
D
P0 r Dhan@shri:
[M
2
:3
]9
Internal throat
Larynx
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
]9
So parts affected ?
D
P1 arshan Parmar:
[M
5
:3
]9
larynx
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:3
]9
And ?
D6 arshan Parmar:
[M
P0
4
:3
]9
pharynx
D0 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P1
4
:3
]9
Throat
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:3
]9
And ?
Look into whole case history you will get one more part affection ?
Try to sketch complete picture of disease then go to analysis.
D8 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P0
6
:3
]9
Oesophagus
Difficulties in swallowing
D0 arshan Parmar:
[M
P1
6
:3
]9
bronchioles.
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:3
]9
Darshan Parmar
>
bronchioles.
>
:+1:
D2 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P4
6
:3
]9
Ok
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
7
:3
]9
Go through following text of case where there is real beginning of :
usually when he takes cold drinks he suffers from throat pain which would last for a week or two progressing
into bronchitis.
Usually his throat pain get progress from larynx to bronchi.
OK ?
D6 arshan Parmar:
[M
P5
8
:3
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Usually his throat pain get progress from larynx to bronchi.

>
:+1::+1:
D
P1 r Dhan@shri:
[M
:3
]9
:+1:
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
]9
Here you can remind any clinical condition which is concerned with viral infection which affect the respiratory way from
larynx to bronchi ?
Viral pharyngitis
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
1
:4
]9
Imtiyaz Bagban
>
Viral pharyngitis
>
Doctor , pharyngitis is different from larynx and bronchi .
D
P8 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
1
:4
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Here you can remind any clinical condition which is concerned w

>
Laryngothracheobronchitis
I didn't get ur question sir

D2 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P5
1
:4
]9
Swine flu
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
2
:4
]9
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
>
:+1::+1: perfect
cheer for this answer :innocent:
D8 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P5
2
:4
]9
:pray::pray::pray:
D8 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P5
2
:4
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:+1::+1: perfect
>
:clap::clap::clap:
D2 arshan Parmar:
[M
P0
3
:4
]9
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand:
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
3
:4
]9
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
>
Clinical term for this in Repertory ?
Yes ?
D
P3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:4
]9
Croup
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
3
:4
]9
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Croup
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand:

Inflammation of bronchial tubes
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:4
]9
So this is a case of recurrent croup.
D
P6 r Dhan@shri:
[M
3
:4
]9
:+1:
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:4
]9
Imtiyaz Bagban
>
Inflammation of bronchial tubes

>
Involves both larynx and bronchi
As always I say first define the problem.
D
P0 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
6
:4
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
As always I say first define the problem.

>
:ok_hand::ok_hand:
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
6
:4
]9
Now try to get rubric combining hoarseness of voice and croup ?
edited
D8 arshan Parmar:
[M
P2
7
:4
]9
larynx and trachea voice hoarsness croup with
D
P0 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
7
:4
]9
edited
Trio of croup is acon,spong,hepar
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
]9
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Photo
>
:+1::+1: first SSUPS.

Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Trio of croup is acon,spong,hepar

>
:ok_hand: nice point.

edited
Again go through this text :
usually when he takes cold drinks he suffers from throat pain which would last for a week or two progressing
into bronchitis.
So principal complaint is ?
Yes ?
Its so simple
D
P3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
2
:5
]9
Cold agg
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:5
]9
No
Think simply
I asking principal complaint ?
D6 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P1
3
:5
]9
Throat pain
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:5
]9
:+1::+1:
Its starts after ?
D
P7 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
3
:5
]9
Cold drinks
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:5
]9
Now try to get a rubric contain both pain in throat and after taking cold drink ?
D
P2 arshan Parmar:
[M
1
:5
]9
throat pain cold drinks after agg
D
P2 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
4
:5
]9
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Now try to get a rubric contain both pain in throat and after ta
>
Then this rubric would contain both location and cause so again SSUPS !
Darshan Parmar
>
throat pain cold drinks after agg

>
Take rubric in broader sense
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Photo
>
Take rubric in broader sense
Yes ?
Throat - pain - cold - after taking a
D7 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P4
8
:5
]9
:+1:
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Throat - pain - cold - after taking a

>
OK ?
Now combine these two rubrics .
Post Repertorisation
D
P9 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:3
0
]1
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
0
]1
D
P6 arshan Parmar:
[M
:4
0
]1
:+1::+1::+1::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::+1::+1:
D
P9 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:4
0
]1
Yes:+1::+1::+1:
D
[M0
]1
So remedy ?
D
P:3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M0
]1
acon
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
0
]1
Now let us see how does Acon is suitable to overall case !
K6 eshav Nakate:
[M
P2
:3
0
]1
Amazing repertorisation.
D
[M0
]1
How does pain affected the patient ?
K
P2 eshav Nakate:
[M
:4
0
]1
He became anxious and quickly seeked medical help.
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
0
]1
:+1:
Patient become anxious from pain - Rubric ?
D8 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P3
:5
0
]1
D8 arshan Parmar:
[M
P3
:5
0
]1
anxiety pain from the
D
[M0
]1
:+1::+1:
Record it
Repertorisation of 3 rubrics ?
D
P5 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:7
0
]1
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:8
0
]1
Hence here we get Acon as a our final remedy with only 3 rubrics and that is what so called 3 legged tool of prescription.
K
P9 eshav Nakate:
[M
:8
0
]1
:+1:
D4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
:9
0
]1
Above 3 rubrics covers location , sensation , cause , and mind disposition as a concomitant.
quickly seek medical help - Rubric ?
D
P:3 arshan Parmar:
[M0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
quickly seek medical help - Rubric ?

>
carried desire to be carried fast.....
D
[M0
]1
Darshan Parmar
>
carried desire to be carried fast.....

>
:+1::+1: Record it.
How does more patient affected by pain ?
Go through following text :
He was very anxious feeling that he will suffer for a week or more from this.
D
P7 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:2
0
]1
Fear suffering
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
:2
0
]1
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Fear suffering
>
:+1::+1: very nice.
D
P5 r Dhan@shri:
[M
:2
0
]1
Fear of suffering
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
:3
0
]1
Patient developed fear of further suffering if disease would progress into bronchitis.
Dr Dhan@shri
>
Fear of suffering
>
Rubric ?
D2 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P5
:3
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Rubric ?
>
Itself
D7 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P5
:3
0
]1
Fear suffering of
D
P:4 r Dhan@shri:
[M0
]1
Mind fear of suffering
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
0
]1
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
Fear suffering of
>
:+1::+1:
Record it.
Dr Dhan@shri
>
Mind fear of suffering

>
Use proper wording while presenting rubrics.
Patient has both anxiety and fear -- rubric ?
D7 arshan Parmar:
[M
P4
:5
0
]1
anxiety fear with

D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
0
]1
:+1:
Record it.
Sudden onset of complaints -- rubric ?
D
P5 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:7
0
]1
General sudden manifestations
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
:7
0
]1
:+1::+1:
Record it.
Presently patient have inflammation of pharynx and larynx - Rubrics ?

Dr Dhan@shri
>
Itself
>
In rubric sequence of words is important.
D
P5 arshan Parmar:
[M
:9
0
]1
throat inflammation pharynx acute
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
:9
0
]1
:+1::+1:
Record it.
D
P3 arshan Parmar:
[M
:2
0
]1
larynx and trachea inflammation larynx acute
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1
:+1::+1:
Record it.
Difficult swallowing - Rubric ?
edited
D
P7 arshan Parmar:
[M
:2
0
]1
throat swallowing difficult
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1
Only Darshan active , all other slept ?

Darshan Parmar
>
throat swallowing difficult

>
:+1::+1:
Record it.
Post total Repertorisation .
D
P:2 r.azam. Adabju:
[M0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Record it.
>
:+1:
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
:2
0
]1
Repertorisation chart itself differentiate Aconite with all other leading differential remedies of case.
D6 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P4
3
:2
0
]1
Yes:+1::+1:
D
P4 arshan Parmar:
[M
:2
0
]1
:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand:
D9 r Dhan@shri:
[M
P4
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
In rubric sequence of words is important.

>
Yes I know sir
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
4
:2
0
]1
There is no fear of suffering in Bell as Bell is not serious ( frivolous ) about disease.
D7 arshan Parmar:
[M
P5
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
There is no fear of suffering in Bell as Bell is not serious ( f

>
:+1::+1::+1::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::+1:
D
P5 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
There is no fear of suffering in Bell as Bell is not serious ( f

>
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
7
:2
0
]1
As per my clinical experience Acon is mostly indicated medicine in acute viral respiratory infections after exposure to cold.
D
P8 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
As per my clinical experience Acon is mostly indicated medicine

>
K4 eshav Nakate:
[M
P3
8
:2
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
As per my clinical experience Acon is mostly indicated medicine

>
:+1:
edited
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
9
:2
0
]1
Especially croup after exposure to cold - clinical indication of Acon provided with selection by strict individualisation.
K6 eshav Nakate:
[M
P2
:3
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Especially croup after exposure to cold - clinical indication of

>
Nice explanation and full proof scientific analysis of the prescription through logical repertorisation.
D4 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P2
:3
0
]1
Keshav Nakate
>
Nice explanation and full proof scientific analysis of the presc

>
Yes:+1::+1::+1::+1:
D5 arshan Parmar:
[M
P2
:3
0
]1
redness is also there....
throat discolouration redness pharynx
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
0
]1
Anxiety from the pain, throat pain after taking cold , desire to be carried fast rule out Hep.
edited
D8 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P4
:3
0
]1
K7 eshav Nakate:
[M
P4
:3
0
]1
I also learned the other side of coin.As I am more at ease with materia medica than repertory.But I do not underestimate
use of repertory as an important tool.Thanks for paistaking explanation. Thanks admin for posting my case here and all
other participants taking enthusiastic part in discussion.
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
0
]1
Darshan Parmar
>
redness is also there.... throat discolouration redness pharynx

>
:+1::+1:
Any queries ?
D4 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P5
:3
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Any queries ?
>
Thanks a lot:pray::pray::pray:
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
0
]1
Keshav Nakate
>
I also learned the other side of coin.As I am more at ease with

>
:+1::+1:
edited
See how does above even small acute case analysis explains everything like role of clinical diagnosis ,
knowledge of disease , use of modalities and concomitant , importance of altered mind disposition during
disease , use of past history , nature of disease , pace of disease in selection of individual remedy of case.
K
P2 eshav Nakate:
[M
:4
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
See how does above even small acute case analysis explains every
>
:+1:
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
0
]1
This is what we say as

Holistic Homeopathy :blush::pray:
D3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P2
:4
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
See how does above even small acute case analysis explains every
>
:+1::+1:
edited
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
:4
0
]1
Exact sense of prescription develops through scientific analytic study of case with all subtle details of case.
R
P6 upali:
[M
:4
0
]1
Nice teaching sir.

Again new rubrics learnings:pray::pray::pray:
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P7
:4
0
]1
:+1::+1:
D
[M
0
:2
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Exact sense of prescription develops through scientific analytic

>
Very nicely explained :ok_hand::ok_hand::pray:

S
[M
A2
3
:0
]8
:clap::clap::clap::clap:very nice process of repertorisation
D7 rkapil Dev :
[M
A4
5
:2
]9
Very nice learning boss :pray::pray:

M
D
A9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:3
]7
§ 46
Many examples might be adduced of disease which, in the course of nature, have been homoeopathically cured by other
diseases presenting similar symptoms, were it not necessary, as our object is to speak about something determinate and
indubitable, to confine our attention solely to those (few) disease which are invariably the same, arise from a fixed miasm,
and hence merit a distinct name.
Among these the smallpox, so dreaded on account of the great number of its serious symptoms, occupies a prominent
position, and it has removed and cured a number of maladies with similar symptoms.
How frequently does smallpox produce violent ophthalmia, sometimes even causing blindness! And see! By its inoculation
Dezoteux1 cured a chronic ophthalmia permanently, and Leroy2 another.
An amaurosis of two years' duration, consequent on suppressed scald head, was perfectly cured by it, according to Klein.3
How often does smallpox cause deafness and dyspnoea! And both these chronic diseases it removed on reaching its acme,
as J. Fr. Closs4observed.
Swelling of the testicle, even of a very severe character, is a frequent symptom of small-pox, and on this account it was
enabled, as Klein5observed, to cure, by virtue of similarity, a large hard swelling of the left testicle, consequently on a
bruise. And another observer6 saw a similar swelling of the testicle cured by it.
Among the troublesome symptoms of small-pox is a dysenteric state of the bowels; and it subdued, as Fr.
Wendt7 observed, a case of dysentery, as a similar morbific agent.
Smallpox coming on after vaccination, as well on account of its greater strength as its great similarity, at once removes
entirely the cow-pox homoeopathically, and does not permit it to come to maturity; but, on the other hand, the cow-pox
when near maturity does, on account of its great similarity, homoeopathically diminish very much the supervening
smallpox and make it much milder8, as Muhry9 and many others testify.
The inoculated cow-pox, whose lymph, besides the protective matter, contains the contagion of a general cutaneous
eruption of another nature, consisting of usually small, dry (rarely large, pustular) pimples, resting on a small red areola,
frequently conjoined with round red cutaneous spots and often accompanied by the most violent itching, which rash
appears in not a few children several days before, more frequently, however, after the red areola of the cow-pock, and
goes off in a few days, leaving behind small, red, hard spots on the skin; - the inoculated cow-pox, I say, after it has taken,
cures perfectly and permanently, in a homoeopathic manner, by the similarity of this accessory miasm, analogous
cutaneous eruptions of children, often of very long standing and of a very troublesome character, as a number of
observers assert.10
The cow-pox, a peculiar symptom of which is to cause tumefaction of the arm11, cured, after it broke out, a swollen
half-paralyzed arm.12
The fever accompanying cow-pox, which occurs at the time of the production of the red areola, cured homoeopathically
intermittent fever in two individuals, as the younger Hardege13 reports, confirming what J. Hunter14 had already
observed, that two fevers (similar diseases) cannot co-exist in the same body.
The measles bear a strong resemblance in the character of its fever and cough to the whooping-cough, and hence it was
that Bosquillon15 noticed, in an epidemic where both these affections prevailed, that many children who then took
measles remained free from whooping-cough during that epidemic. They would all have been protected from, and
rendered incapable of being infected by, the whooping-cough in that and all subsequent epidemics, by the measles, if the
whooping-cough were not a disease that has only a partial similarity to the measles, that is to say, if it had also a
cutaneous eruption similar to what the latter possesses. As it is, however, the measles can but preserve a large number
from whooping-cough homoeopathically, and that only in the epidemic prevailing at the time.
If, however, the measles
come in contact with a disease resembling it in its chief symptom, the eruption, it can indisputably remove, and
effect a homoeopathic cure of the latter. Thus a chronic herpetic eruption was entirely and permanently
(homoeopathically) cured16 by the breaking out of the measles, as Kortum17observed. An excessively burning
miliary rash on the face, neck, and arms, that had lasted six years, and was aggravated by every change of
weather, on the invasion of measles assumed the form of a swelling of the surface of the skin; after the measles
had run its course the exanthema was cured, and returned no more.18
A new footnote is added here in the Sixth Edition, as follows:
This seems to be the reason for this beneficial remarkable fact namely that since the general distribution of
Janner's Cow-pox vaccination, human small-pox never again appeared as epidemically or virulently as 40-45
years before when one city visited lost at least one-half and often three-quarters of its children by death of this
miserable pestilence.
T
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:2
]4
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
come in contact with a disease resembling it in its chief sympto

>
COMMENTS ON Aphorism 46
In this Aphorism Master Hahnemann again emphasized the fact of cure by similar disease, with examples of different
diseases and their curative actions when those meet with similar diseases.
There are documentary proofs as infection of smallpox cured many disease conditions like opthalmia , amaurosis ,
deafness , dyspnea , swelling of testicles , dysenteric state homeopathically as smallpox possesses potential to produce
similar symptoms.
Small pox vaccinations removed cow pox due to its similarity.
Infection of cow-pox can cure peculiar eruptions ( small, dry , pustular pimples resting on small red areola ) , intermittent
fever and swelling of arms as cow-pox can produce similar symptoms.
Infection of measles can cure whooping cough , exanthema , chronic herpetic eruption as measles possesses a potential to
produce similar symptoms in more intensity.
D
P9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
]4
Unsolved Case is presented by Dr.Darshan Parmar:
boy age 24 years...
knee pain both sides

seating difficult
while try to seating pain in hip joint
mostly right side affected
sole pain while walking
pain while flexor movement of hand..(bending difficult )..difficulty in movement of hand
lower back pain....while stooping
since 10 11 years
all complaints summer aggravation

walking amelioration
while first motion agg...and continous motion relief
HOT patient
winter fan ...2
summer.....5
not cover even in winter
profuse sweat on soles

also while eating (in whole family profuse sweat and hot patient)
flatulance...sometimes
desire..potatoes..chillies.spices
sleep disturb due to pain3
Mind....
is taklif ke kaaran mujhe bethne me dikkat hoti he to khada rena padta he(due to this i can't sit )
achha nai lagta he..guilty feeling hoti he..(when someone called me their home i feel guilty how i seat when someone offer
me for meal)
kisi ke ghar jaye aur bethne ko bole aur me beth nai sakta..achha ni lagta..(i feel embarassed)
mujhe { HYPERLINK "http://m.com/" \t "_blank" } karna tha par papa ne kaha pgdca kar to mene wo kiya......is bimari
ki wajah se mera 2 saal bigda aur padh ni paya..(due to this i can't complete my degree also and waste 2 year)
dusre frnd ne degree le li aur jab hum milte he to always lagta he ye mere se aage nikla gye he....me pichhe reh gya
(my friend complete.their degre....nd i feel jealousy that my friends will get their job and i will not)
afsos hota he ki unko achhi nokari milegi me reh jaunga
sab ko bimariya hoti hogi par2 jaisa me seh raha hu koi nai seh sakta....(this is intolerable not anyone bear this like me)
meri family ne meri bahut seva ki he...aisi family har kisi ki nai hoti...(not every family is like mine..)
kisi ka dukh sunke mujhe b dukh hota he...(i am sad to hear someone's grief)
in sab se mar jaana achha....(it is good to die from all of these)

jab pain hota he to mind me wo hi sab pain pain chlta rehta he wo hi sochta rehta hu(i constant thinking about pain )
bahut bar mom dad ko bola mujhe mar do par wo hi he jinhone mujhe jinda rakha(often i said kill me but they kept me
alive)
past history....bachpan me chhota tha tab puri body pr plaster lagaya tha.....gir gya tha...(fracure and plaster at
whole.body in past)
family history....mother RA
observation waddeling gait.
D
P4 R. RAHUL MISAL:
[M
1
:3
]5
Staph
R5 upali:
[M
P1
2
:3
]6
Sulph
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:4
]8
Attend me at 9pm.
Hello everyone
What is striking in case ?
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]9
OK
Let us see first present complaints and how does it affected patient 3
It is pain in extremities.
How does it affected patient ?
D
[M
:2
]9
Not able to seat
Feel embarrassed
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
3
:2
]9
in sab se mar jaana achha....(it is good to die from all of these)
Rubric ?
D
[M
:2
]9
Suicidal disposition pain from
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it.
bahut bar mom dad ko bola mujhe mar do par wo hi he jinhone mujhe jinda rakha(often i said kill me but they
kept me alive)
Rubric ?
D
[M
4
:2
]9
Killed desire to be
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
4
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
Record it
D
[M
4
:2
]9
Two remedies
Bell carc
D0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
5
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
Post Repertorisation .
D
[M
5
:2
]9
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
6
:2
]9
Remedies common ?
[M
P3
6
:2
]9
Bell carc
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
See above two rubrics are representative of patient's typical reaction to his disease.
mujhe { HYPERLINK "http://m.com/" \t "_blank" } karna tha par papa ne kaha pgdca kar to mene wo
kiya......is bimari ki wajah se mera 2 saal bigda aur padh ni paya..(due to this i can't complete my degree also
and waste 2 year)
Rubrics ?
D
[M
:2
]9
Yielding disposition
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
]9
:+1::+1:
edited
More precise rubric ?
>
>
More precise rubric ?
D
[M
1
:3
]9
Servile
Delusion being injured?
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
2
:3
]9

>
>
Yielding disposition children in
D
[M
2
:3
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Yielding disposition children in

>
Right
P
P6 R Patil:
[M
2
:3
]9
Ail from abused
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
2
:3
]9

>
Right
>
(Children )As he is dependent on father
[M
P5
2
:3
]9
Ya
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
1
:3
]9
How father did treat him ?
R6 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P1
4
:3
]9
Dominated
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
4
:3
]9
Post Repertorisation of
3 rubrics post.
R5 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P2
4
:3
]9
Imposed his view on child
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:3
]9
Raksha Thakkar
>
Dominated
>
:ok_hand: exactly.
R
P0 aksha Thakkar:
[M
4
:3
]9
:pray::+1:
D
[M
5
:3
]9
R
P1 aksha Thakkar:
[M
5
:3
]9
Ailments from domination
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:3
]9
Remedy ?
R0 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P2
5
:3
]9
Carcinosin
D
[M
:3
]9
But in history domination is no where
P
P4 R Patil:
[M
5
:3
]9
:+1::+1:
R
P1 aksha Thakkar:
[M
6
:3
]9

>
But in history domination is no where

>
Kyu father impose kiye n Apne views bache pe
D
[M
6
:3
]9
Ya right... Study
:+1:
R
P6 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:3
]9
That's too a kind of domination n

>
:+1:
>
:+1::+1::blush:
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
7
:3
]9
See we considered his mental reaction to disease ( first 2 rubrics ) and his original nature ( yielding ) and we got the
remedy of patient.
Again this is an artistic repertorisation.
Raksha Thakkar
>

>
This is actual cause of disease.
Record it.
P8 R Patil:
[M
P5
7
:3
]9
Nice:+1::+1:
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
]9
All pain we generalise as pain in extremities.

DrSamadhan Ghule
>
All pain we generalise as pain in extremities.

>
Rubric ?
D
[M
:3
]9
Extremities pain lowerlimbs
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:3
]9
More general ?
Extremities - pain
Record it.
dusre frnd ne degree le li aur jab hum milte he to always lagta he ye mere se aage nikla gye he....me pichhe reh
gya
(my friend complete.their degre....nd i feel jealousy that my friends will get their job and i will not)
afsos hota he ki unko achhi nokari milegi me reh jaunga
Rubric ?
R
P2 aksha Thakkar:
[M
1
:4
]9
Envy
R
P2 upali:
[M
1
:4
]9
Mind envy
D
[M
:4
]9
Jealousy
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P1
2
:4
]9

>
Jealousy
>
More correct as he feel bad due to success of friends.
D
[M
2
:4
]9
Thats why
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:4
]9

>
Jealousy
>
Tell still more precise rubric ?

R
P5 upali:
[M
2
:4
]9
Ok
D
[M
2
:4
]9
In envy no such feeling
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
3
:4
]9
Yes
R
P1 aksha Thakkar:
[M
3
:4
]9
Ok noted
D
P1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:4
]9
Keep in mind child within him.
D
[M
1
:4
]9
Mind Jealousy children between
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
5
:4
]9
:+1::+1::+1:
Record it.
D
[M
5
:4
]9
Recorded
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
5
:4
]9
He is sympathetic by nature.
Rubric ?
D
P6 r. Abhishek Singla:
[M
5
:4
]9
Mind sympathetic
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:4
]9
:+1:
Record it.
R0 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P2
6
:4
]9
Sympathetic
D
P3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
6
:4
]9
Desire potatoes
Rubric ?
D8 r. Abhishek Singla:
[M
P5
6
:4
]9
Generals food and drink potatoes desire

D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:4
]9
:+1:
Record it.
Desire spices
Rubric ?
R
P0 aksha Thakkar:
[M
7
:4
]9
Craving spices
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
]9
Rubric ?
D
[M
7
:4
]9
Dr. Abhishek Singla:

Generals food and drink spicesdesire
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
8
:4
]9
:+1:
Record it.
In this case we go with some selected characteristic rubrics rather than taking all rubrics in account.
This is a skill.
[M
P2
0
:5
]9
:+1::+1::+1::+1:
[M
P0
1
:5
]9
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
3
:5
]9
Remedy ?
R
P1 aksha Thakkar:
[M
3
:5
]9
Jabardaaast
Carcinosin as rahi
D
P3 arshan Parmar:
[M
:5
]9
:pray::pray:nice analysis sir:ok_hand::ok_hand::+1::+1::+1::+1::pray::pray:
edited
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
4
:5
]9
Cause + altered mind disposition during disease + patient as a person ( mind and physical generals ) : based on these
points we prescribed the remedy Carcinosin.
R8 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P3
4
:5
]9
:+1::+1::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::point_up_2::pray:
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
]9
I put modalities secondary as altered mind disposition is more striking so used in individualisation.
R:5 aksha Thakkar:

[M
P ]9
:+1:
Sir potency 200

Single dose
Or v go for high potency as mentals prominent

D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
7
:5
]9
Rx Carcinosin 1M stat.
R
P1 aksha Thakkar:
[M
7
:5
]9
:+1::+1::+1:ok sir noted thank u so much
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
7
:5
]9
Follow up after one week.
R
P7 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:5
]9
I just love Ur way of dissecting the case and coming to rubric

Repertorial chart evidence based:+1::+1::+1:
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
8
:5
]9
Here I put past history of physical injury secondary as his mental suffering is more striking as a cause.
Cause - Ailments from domination
R
P6 aksha Thakkar:
[M
0
:5
]9
Ok noted
D
[M
:5
]9
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Rx Carcinosin 1M stat.
>
nice analysis :ok_hand::ok_hand: n easily understandable :ok_hand::ok_hand:
D
P:3 r. Abhishek Singla:
[M0
]1
Raksha Thakkar
>
I just love Ur way of dissecting the case and coming to rubric

>
Me too
D
P:4 arshan Parmar:
[M0
]1
here pt apni family ki taarif kr rha agar domination hota to...aisa.bolta ki meri family ne ye kiya wo kiya....sab ku6 meri
family....tarife wo sab...
[M
P3
:5
0
]1
Ok
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
:7
0
]1
Darshan Parmar
>
here pt apni family ki taarif kr rha agar domination hota to...a

>
Mind - Love - family , for

DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Mind - Love - family , for

>
Carcinosin is there.
Person love even who dominate him.
R
P:9 aksha Thakkar:
[M0
]1
:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::+1:
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:9
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
This is a Carcinosin.
D6 arshan Parmar:
[M
P2
:9
0
]1
:ok_hand::ok_hand:now clear
Carcinosin........:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::+1::+1::+1::pray::pray::pray::pray::pray:
R5 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P4
:9
0
]1
Yes that's the beauty of carcinosin superb
D
[M
:2
0
]1
One more prominent rubric

Mere jaisa dard se rha hu waise koi se nahi sakta h
MIND - HIGHSPIRITED
MIND - HIGHSPIRITED, IN CHILDREN, CARC SINGLE REMEDY
D
P4 arshan Parmar:
[M
:3
0
]1

>
One more prominent rubric Mere jaisa dard se rha hu waise koi s
>
:ok_hand:great....sir:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand:
D
[M
:5
0
]1
:+1::+1::+1:
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
0
]1

>
>
:+1::+1:
D
[M
:3
0
]1
Appologies sir... I thought it's over...:pray::pray::pray::pray:

Sorry for interrupting
D
[M0
]1
Dr. Abhishek Singla

>
Appologies sir... I thought it's over...:pray::pray::pray::pray: Sorry for inter

>
Please we discuss any case with preplan format of discussion.
D
[M
:5
0
]1

>
>
Here we cannot take Boasting bcoz he is actually tolerating severe pain and feeling severe pain
D
[M
:5
0
]1
I agreed sir... I just thought today's discussion is over.. so just posted..

I humbly appologies:pray::pray:
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
:5
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
There is a close rubric for this - I am not remembering exactly :disappointed:
Please if someone have Radar search option search from single remedy mind rubrics of Carcinosin.
D
[M
:8
0
]1
Not have
D6 r Manoj Babu 9821409773 Gupta:

[M
P5
:8
0
]1
SSUPS
[M
P2
:9
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Please if someone have Radar search option search from single re

>
Dnt hv radar
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1
That rubric of Carcinosin which mean person is good with who dominate him.
Mil gaya ( got it ) :blush::blush::blush:

D
P:2 r. Abhishek Deshpande:
[M0
]1
Pleasing desire to, father carc
Single remedy
D8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
:2
0
]1

>

>
:+1::+1: yes it is.:grinning:
[M
P5
:2
0
]1
:smile::smile::smile:
[M
P3
:2
0
]1

>

>
:+1::+1:
D9 arshan Parmar:
[M
P3
:2
0
]1
:ok_hand::ok_hand:woww:ok_hand:.....:+1::pray::+1::+1:
[M
P3
:2
0
]1
Dr.neha rushik Parikh

>
:+1::+1:
>
:+1:
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
:2
0
]1
Carcinosin clear ?
[M
P5
:2
0
]1

>

>
:+1::pensive:
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1
Darshan any more queries ?
D
P5 arshan Parmar:
[M
:2
0
]1
No sir....:+1:such a great analysis........:+1::pray::+1::ok_hand::+1::pray::pray:
R4 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P7
:2
0
]1
Mast case solving Maja aavi gayi :ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::+1:
edited
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P8
:2
0
]1
Pain in extremities aroused after domination by father, with altered mental disposition ( desire death from pain and desire
to be killed )in a person basically of yielding nature and sympathetic, using pleasing words for family(parents , father )as
a child with desire for potatoes and spices : This is a summarised Carcinosin from this case of discussion.
R
P9 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:2
0
]1
Later revolt stage MEI bhi jata n sir carcinosin
If yaha is bande Ko carcinosin n di jaye revolt MEI ja sakta n ye sir
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
0
]1
Yes
R
P7 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:3
0
]1
Ok sir noted
Really nice learning thanks a ton:pray:
D
P:3 arshan Parmar:
[M0
]1
Raksha Thakkar
>
If yaha is bande Ko carcinosin n di jaye revolt MEI ja sakta n y

>
Revolt...???
R
P9 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:3
0
]1
Violent action le Sakta ye banda fir

Papa k khilaf bhi ja sakta
Kis had tak domination kare usse computer application nahi karna tha papa ne kaha Kiya
Pleasing kar Raha papa Ko Kia hadd tak a day will come threshold cross hua atlakli ki Majhi aata Satakli
Ne dekhega ye banda AAR paar and will give it a tough fight
D2 arshan Parmar:
[M
P4
:3
0
]1
:+1::+1:ohh... i see:ok_hand::ok_hand:
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
:3
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Photo
>
This is the SSUPS of today's case.

What he said about parents is nothing but pleasing words !
R
P4 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:3
0
]1
:+1:
The soap opera Gopis husband ahem dominated by Kokila

Kokila got him married to illiterate Gopi
Ailments from domination for ahem by Kokila
Pleases mom's
Kokila imposes her view on ahem
Ahem abides
But a day comes when ahem revolts
Sath nibhana sajna the soap opera name
D
[M
:3
0
]1
Jab pain hota h to dimag me pain hi pain sochte rehta hu..

Anxiety pain from, carc is there
R
P8 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:3
0
]1

>
>
Samadhan sir as per this version high spirited apt sir?
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P8
:3
0
]1
Love through pleasing --
meri family ne meri bahut seva ki he...aisi family har kisi ki nai hoti...( my family served me a lot , not every family is like
mine..)
wo hi he jinhone mujhe jinda rakha ( they only kept me alive)
R4 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P8
:3
0
]1
Yes high spirited there in carcinosin

But ye version k liye apply nahi hoga I feel
High spirited is jinda dil
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Love through pleasing -- meri family ne meri bahut seva ki he.

>
:ok_hand:
D
[M0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Love through pleasing -- meri family ne meri bahut seva ki he.

>
Pleasing | desire to please others - parents --father
-- see how beautiful rubric from this case !
D
P:4 r. Abhishek Deshpande:
[M0
]1
Raksha Thakkar
>
Yes high spirited there in carcinosin But ye version k liye app

>
Meaning of high spirit is vivacious, cheerful, courageous, bold... Here he is showing courage... Towards tolerating pain
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Pleasing | desire to please others - parents --father -- see h

>
Single remedy ( Carcinosin ) rubric so SSUPS !
R2 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P3
:4
0
]1
Sir high spirited apt sir
For those version

[M
P3
:4
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Pain in extremities aroused after domination by father, with alt

>
CT analysis
Confirmatory Test
:+1::+1:
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
3
:4
0
]1
Raksha Thakkar
>
Yes high spirited there in carcinosin But ye version k liye app

>
You want know exact rubric for this ?

R
P2 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:4
0
]1
Yes
R
P3 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:4
0
]1
Fe
md
rw
:o
g
sa
Dr. Abhishek Deshpande[3/27/18]

R
P2 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:4
0
]1
This version
O sorry
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:4
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
You want know exact rubric for this ?

>
Yes ? Dr.Abhishek ?
R
P5 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:4
0
]1
Fe
md
rw
:o
g
sa
One more prominent rubric

MIND - HIGHSPIRITED
MIND - HIGHSPIRITED, IN CHILDREN, CARC SINGLE REMEDY
R
P5 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:4
0
]1
Ye wala
Ha yes
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
:4
0
]1
Raksha Thakkar
>
>
For this I would tell you wonderful rubric ! :blush:
R
P5 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:4
0
]1
Yes pls thanks

edited
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
6
:4
0
]1
What is his feel behind this ?
R5 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P7
:4
0
]1
I can tolerate the pain threshold level I can bear it
Any other person can't bear the same
I m strong enough
Raksha Thakkar:
high spirit one example i give of mentor humranwala mam ek baar ek pt ko ca breast carcinoma of breast hua
tha pt k reports mam k haath mei the mam was reluctant hesitant to declare ki bhai aapko cancer hai bolke ki
declare kaise kare yaar :cold_sweat:pt was like su thayu ben cancer aavu areee amara akha khandan ma cancer
che ben bahach ek breast wala have toh surname rakhvu che ek breast wala ben and mam pt die not of cancer
so no worry its of the fear of cancer that the pt dies dr no worries at all this is high spirited dr
R2 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P3
9
:4
0
]1
DELETED[6/26/17]
for those who couldnt comprehend gujarati pt says no worries dr its since generations after generations our
family us suffering from carcinoma of breast and each has got a mastectomy done v at times feel our surname
should b one breast wale saying it with a jovial and positive attitude dr dont worry people die of fear of cancer
and not of cancer
D
P:5 arshan Parmar:
[M0
]1
:+1::+1::pray::+1::ok_hand::ok_hand::+1:
R
P3 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:5
0
]1
:+1::+1::pray:
High spirited - jindadil
D
[M
:5
0
]1
Not to stick on one meaning of HIGHSPIRITED

D
[M
:5
0
]1
Raksha Thakkar
>
Raksha Thakkar: high spirit one example i give of mentor humranw

>
:ok_hand::ok_hand:
[M
P2
:5
0
]1
There are other meaning also

D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
:5
0
]1
Raksha Thakkar
>
Any other person can't bear the same

>
available or belonging only to particular people, and not shared by many - Exact word ?
R8 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P4
:5
0
]1
Samadhan sir pls guide

Dr Abhishek
Samadhan sir Bata payenge
Aap ka meaning bhi dekhenge hum sir may b aap bhi rt ho sir
[M
P2
:5
0
]1
No problem
R
P2 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:5
0
]1
Thanks
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
:5
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
available or belonging only to particular people, and not share

>
Answer this ?
Yes ?
R
P3 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:5
0
]1
Not clicking
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
:5
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Yes ?
>
What we say if something is limited to particular person ?
[M
P4
:5
0
]1
What i understand of that version is that the patient is showing boldness as well as courage towards tolerating pain which
anybody cannot...
R7 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P2
4
:5
0
]1
Audacity
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
0
]1

>
What i understand of that version is that the patient is showing

>
Don't think objectively in this version. What patient think ?
D
[M
:5
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
available or belonging only to particular people, and not share

>
Exclusive
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
0
]1
Dr. Abhishek Singla

>
Exclusive
>
Cheer for this answer !:innocent:
R
P4 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:5
0
]1
:+1::+1::+1::+1:
D
P:5 r.neha rushik Parikh:
[M0
]1
:+1::+1:
R3 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P6
:5
0
]1
Waaah Abhi mast
[M
P6
:5
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand: Cheer for this answer !:innocent:

>
Thanks sir:grin::grin:
D
P6 arshan Parmar:
[M
:5
0
]1
:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::clap::clap::clap::clap::clap:
[M
P2
6
:5
0
]1
Not studied case yet.. So... Reading comments
R3 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P6
:5
0
]1
Sir o version wala bhi guide pls

Balivada Madhuri
>
Not studied case yet.. So... Reading comments
>
Ok
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand: Cheer for this answer !:innocent:

>
He think what I am doing is particularly belongs to me and not a matter of all common persons.
Rubric ?
D3 arshan Parmar:
[M
P8
:5
0
]1
delusion distinguished..?
D4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P8
:5
0
]1
Darshan Parmar
>
>
No
B6 eena Shah :
[M
P4
8
:5
0
]1
Exclusive
D3 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P8
:5
0
]1
Think as it is simply
Beena Shah
>
Exclusive
>
Tell exact rubric
D
P9 arshan Parmar:
[M
:5
0
]1
delusion alone being world alone...???
D4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
9
:5
0
]1
Darshan Parmar
>
delusion alone being world alone...???

>
No , you are going away.
B
P3 eena Shah :
[M
:0
]1
Exclusive too
D
P6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
He think what I am doing is particularly belongs to me and not a

>
It is
Mind - exclusive , too
Beena Shah
>
Exclusive too
>
:+1::+1:
R
P6 aksha Thakkar:
[M
2
:0
]1
:+1:
D
P8 arshan Parmar:
[M
3
:0
]1
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:0
]1
Darshan Parmar
>
>
Distinguished means just different from other.
Now I would like to see Repertorisation including --
love family for
Pleasing desire to please others parents father
Exclusive too
Please anyone ?
D8 arshan Parmar:
[M
P3
2
:0
]1
R
P5 aksha Thakkar:
[M
2
:0
]1
:ok_hand:
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P5
2
:0
]1
Add this also --

Post total Repertorisation including all rubrics.
D
P8 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:0
]1
Fe
md
rw
:o
g
sa

D4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
5
:0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Post total Repertorisation including all rubrics.

>
Don't mind for repeated instructions but this is exercise to grow with knowledge.
D
[M
5
:0
]1
No no sir
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
6
:0
]1
High spirited means simply

with high levels of energy.
R
P4 aksha Thakkar:
[M
7
:0
]1
Pt k version kya honge sir high spirited mei
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P2
8
:0
]1
Raksha Thakkar
>
>
Through this version patient told about his too exclusive nature.
Raksha Thakkar
>
Pt k version kya honge sir high spirited mei

>
Rather than version this rubric is of interpretation when we judge patient as of high spirit , performing with high
energy in some critical condition.
R
P8 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:0
]1
Ok sir noted thank u so much

Wonderful learning sir and nice inputs by everyone god bless u all:pray::pray::pray::+1:
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:3
]1
Still something to explain there , wait :blush:

Raksha Thakkar
>

>
Tell more exact rubric ?
D
[M
2
:5
]1
Ailments from domination children in
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:5
]1
Say more exactly.
D
[M
:6
]1
Long history of parentral control
D
P9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:6
]1
:+1:
R
P3 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:6
]1
D
P9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:6
]1

>
Long history of parentral control

>
Say full rubric .
Mind - ailments from - domination , children in - parental control - from long history of excessive
D
[M
:6
]1
Mind Ailments from domination children in, long history of parentral control
R
P8 aksha Thakkar:
[M
4
:6
]1
Waaah waah mast
Superb learning
D
[M
2
:7
]1
:+1::+1:
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:8
]1
R
P4 aksha Thakkar:
[M
:8
]1
:+1:
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:8
]1

>
:+1::+1:
>
Now are you clear of meaning of high spirited ?
D
[M
:9
]1
Ok
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:2
]1
edited
Once more time go through all rubrics of above chart .
Its Carcinosin typical :blush:
:pray: Thanks all
[M
P5
3
:2
]1
Thanks sir and all members
R
P0 aksha Thakkar:
[M
5
:2
]1
:+1::+1::+1::+1::pray:
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
7
:2
]1
Still one more mind rubric you want to learn from case in concern with past history of injury ?
Main matter of this case is mental symptoms , OK ?
Can you tell rubric combining mental symptoms with history of injury ?
D
[M
8
:2
]1
Mind- Ailments from injuries accidents mental symptoms from..
D7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P0
9
:2
]1

>
Mind- Ailments from injuries accidents mental symptoms from..

>
:+1::+1::blush:
R
P8 aksha Thakkar:
[M
0
:3
]1
:+1::+1::+1:
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:3
]1
That injury may made him susceptible to get suffer from mental symptoms like desire death from pain , desire to be killed
etc. which is actually main individualising matter of this case.
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
That injury may made him susceptible to get suffer from mental s
>
This is logic :innocent:
D
[M
:3
]1
Right :+1:
D9 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
2
:3
]1
Logic is a main apparatus of art and science of Homeopathy !
R4 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P5
2
:3
]1
:+1::+1::+1:
:ok_hand::ok_hand::pray::blush:
edited
D
P7 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:3
]1
Be scientific , reasonable , objective, artistic and logical in the practice of Homeopathy.
God bless you all in service of sick by Homeopathy ! :pray::bouquet::innocent:
D
[M
6
:3
]1
Thanks sir and gn
R
P8 aksha Thakkar:
[M
6
:3
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Be scientific , reasonable , objective, artistic and logical in

>
:+1::+1::pray::pray::pray::ok_hand:
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
God bless you all in service of sick by Homeopathy ! :pray::bouquet::innocent:

>
God bless u too sir :pray:thanks

D
[M
9
:4
]1
Too gud to learn new today :+1::+1: thanks a ton sir :+1:
D
P2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
0
:5
]1
:+1::+1::blush:
W
D
A3 r Manoj Babu 9821409773 Gupta:
[M
0
:6
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
Be scientific , reasonable , objective, artistic and logical in

>
:pray::pray::pray::+1:
R
A3 upali:
[M
0
:2
]1
Nice teaching sir

DrSamadhan Ghule invited Nedhe Chakk
.P[M]4:018 .....Haphizul Mondal.....:
Nice learning sir.
D
[M
1
:3
]5
:+1::pray::pray::pray:
very nice analysis sir
D
P1 r Deepak Isapure:
[M
:4
]5
Nice analysis Dr Samadhan:+1::+1::ok_hand::ok_hand:

T
DrSamadhan Ghule invited DELETED
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A4
5
:2
]7
§ 47
Nothing could teach the physician in a plainer and more convincing manner than the above what kind of artificial morbific
agent (medicine) he ought to choose in order to cure in a sure, rapid and permanent manner, conformably with the
process that takes place in nature.
F
Veeresh Udamagal joined group via invite link
Unread messages

S
D
P7 r Dhan@shri:
[M
:0
2
]1
A:0 run Deo :
[M
P ]3
Dear Doc.kindly tell me if Syzigium { HYPERLINK "http://jumbo.is/" \t "_blank" } available in 30 or 200 potency or only
in mother tin.form
A
P9 nant Das:
[M
8
:2
]4
Arun Deo
>
Dear Doc.kindly tell me if Syzigium Jumbo.is available in 30 or

>
Available in potency form also but the genuineness of the manufacturing company.
Should be kept in mind.
M5 anny K:
[M
P2
6
:3
]4
Arun Deo
>
Dear Doc.kindly tell me if Syzigium Jumbo.is available in 30 or

>
Not good to use this
D1 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P3
5
:0
]7
Dr Dhan@shri
>
Photo
>
:+1::pray:
edited
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 47 Nothing could teach the physician in a plainer and more co

>
Its great lesson from nature that similar strong affection can cure previously existing weaker one disease in
organism and we have discussed this natural phenomena through examples of many diseases like measles ,
smallpox etc. in some previous aphorisms.
In this way one can understand the process of cure in plainer and convincing manner by selecting proper
remedy as a artificial morbific agent which can produce the morbid condition very similar to the natural disease
in organism resulting into sure, rapid and permanent cure.
e.g Patient suffered from tonsillitis after coryza.
Now this is the peculiar way of nature which produced tonsillitis after coryza.
When we go in search of medicine which can produce similar symptoms ( coryza and tonsillitis ) in a peculiar
way ( tonsillitis after coryza ) we get Sabadila as a remedy of the case.( original source - Herings guiding
symptoms ).
Throat - inflammation - tonsils - coryza , after : Sabad

[SSUPS as a single remedy rubric(Synthesis ) ]
Not only the symptoms but the manner how they get express is important matter in selection of similar medicine
required to cure the disease.
V2 INOD DHANAWAT:
[M
P4
0
:1
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
D
P9 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
4
:1
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1::+1:
D
[M
:7
0
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:ok_hand::ok_hand::+1:
- unday, April 1, 2018 -
S
D
P8 r santosh Londhe :
[M
6
:5
]1
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:ok_hand:
T
- hursday, April 5, 2018-
D5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A4
:3
0
]1
§ 48
Neither in the course of nature, as we see from all the above examples, nor by the physician's art, can an existing affection
or malady in any one instance be removed by a dissimilar morbific agent, be it ever so strong, but solely by one that is
similar in symptoms and is somewhat stronger, according to eternal, irrevocable laws of nature, which have not hitherto
been recognized.
D
P0 r Manoj Babu 9821409773 Gupta:
[M
:1
]6
Class Hiten Safi

+919820723617
F
- riday, April 6, 2018 -
D6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
A8
:2
0
]1
{ HYPERLINK "tg://join?invite=EAHwE0BYJg1LLU28aeru6g" \t "_blank" }
Please share only with reliable members
R6 aksha Thakkar:
[M
P3
9
:2
]1
Else ek kam karo give me number I add manually

Dr. Liji joined group via invite link
A2 slam Javed:
[M
P4
3
:5
]1
My no.is8275557026
Bidhan Chandra Das joined group via invite link
Rajarshi Fulia joined group via invite link
Dr. Lata joined group via invite link
D
[M
:4
]8
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 48 Neither in the course of nature, as we see from all the ab

>
Cure can only take place when similar medicine has been applied but yes in somewhat Strong in manifestation ,
Non homeopathic i.e dissimilar in nature would nt b able to cure disease rather they add in existing one.
D
P5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
:2
0
]1
Dr.neha rushik Parikh

>
Cure can only take place when similar medicine has been applied
>
:+1:
S
- unday, April 8, 2018 -
Sujata Chaudhari joined group via invite link
D2 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
P4
6
:5
]8
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
§ 48 Neither in the course of nature, as we see from all the ab

>
Cure of disease is only possible either by nature itself or medicine but applied term is existing disease can only be removed
by similar and somewhat stronger disease produced by nature or medicine.
Neither the course of nature nor the art of physician capable to cure the existing disease if newly added disease is not
similar to existing one even though so strong in its manifestation of symptoms.
This fact remained unrecognized for many centuries in the history of medicine until the talent of Master Hahnemann
discovered it through his scientific experimentation and clinical proving of this nature's law of cure by employing well
proved similar medicines for cure of natural diseases.
The employed remedy in form of medicine should be similar to existing disease in respect to number of symptoms as well
as their nature of manifestation.
e.g .
When we say just of fever there are N numbers of medicines capable to produce it but when we say it is typhoid fever with
involuntary urination then it specify the individual remedy, Gelsemium.
Fever - typhoid fever - accompanied by - urination involuntary : Gels

( Synthesis Repertory )
[M
P5
8
:1
]9
:+1::+1:
D
P8 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
:2
0
]1
:+1::+1::+1:
R
P6 upali:
[M
4
:3
]1
:+1:
s
P5 andhya sahu:
[M
2
:4
]1
:+1:
M
- onday, April 9, 2018 -
jA[M]7:059 ohn:
:ok_hand::ok_hand::pray:
D
A5 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
2
:3
]8
§ 49
We should have been able to meet with many more real, natural homoeopathic cures of this kind if, on the one hand, the
attention of observers had been more directed to them, and, on the other hand, if nature had not been so deficient in
helpful homoeopathic diseases.
pramod patil joined group via invite link

s
P6 onali:
[M
4
:1
]2
Respected doctors
Male age 31,weight 70 k.g,har tym tension m rehta h,kabi dusro ko lekr kabhi financial tension,nature m shy ,reserve
h,stranger ke bich mein apne apko mix ni kar pata ,gher m thk h sbke sath,kahi jana ho kuch krna ho,usse pehle usko bare
mein m sochna suru kr deta h,anticipetry anxiety,every tym he is in confusion,kabhi dil se khush ni rehta,nature wise he is
good,nind bhi achi aati h,bed mein jatein hi so jata h,drive krne se pehle sochne lag jata h kahi accident na kr de so avoid
krta h koi na koi bhana bnakar,sexually he is very well,but interest bhut kam h,koi bhi kam krne se pehle ye sochne lg jata
h koi use dekh to ni raha,faint ho jata h ak dum ,diet thk h,very responsible,dusro ki fikr rehti h,publicly bolte hue hesitae
krta h ,educated h har bat ki knowledge rakhta h,
[M
P0
4
:5
]2
sonali
>
Respected doctors Male age 31,weight 70 k.g,har tym tension m re

>
ARGENTUM NITRICUM
s
P0 onali:
[M
6
:1
]4
Balivada Madhuri
>
ARGENTUM NITRICUM
>
Potency and repetition plz?
D
P3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
6
:5
]4
sonali
>

>
B
[M
4
:0
]5
Dr.azam. Adabju
>

>
200C Monthly once for 3 months
D
P3 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
2
:1
]5
Balivada Madhuri
>
200C Monthly once for 3 months

>
B
[M
4
:1
]5
Dr.azam. Adabju
>
>
Sorry.. This is not for u..

sonali
>
Potency and repetition plz?

>
200c monthly once for 3months
D
P0 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
4
:1
]5
sonali
>

>
Please first post your case to admin( Dr.Samadhan ) with English translation of Hindi dialogues then only it would be
considered for discussion.
[M
P0
8
:1
]5
Sorry group.. I forgot rules and regulations of this group.. Dear Dr. Sonali plz post this to admin in English and he will post
in the group according to priority, will discuss in group... :pray: :pray: :pray:
s5 onali:
[M
P4
7
:3
]8
Balivada Madhuri
>
Sorry group.. I forgot rules and regulations of this group.. Dea

>
Ok thanks a lot
- uesday, April 10, 2018-
T
D
A6 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
5
:4
]7
A TRIBUTE TO MASTER HAHNEMANN

:pray::bouquet::tulip::rose:
10 th April Birthday of our great Master founder of Homeopathy.
The last words of Master :
'Non inutilis vixi' - I have not lived in vain.
D
A0 r Mahesh Chandra:
[M
1
:3
]8
D
A4 rNujhat M. A. Khan :
[M
1
:3
]8
Aameen
D3 r umama :
[M
A0
4
:5
]8
Happy world Homeopathy day :bouquet::bouquet::bouquet:
P6 riti Yadav:
[M
A4
1
:2
]9
D
A8 r Alien Hussain :
[M
5
:2
]9
Dr Alien Hussain[4/10/18]
D
A5 r. Ramesh somsolay Andhra P Homeo:
[M
1
:4
]9
Happy homeopathy day all you:bouquet::bouquet::bouquet::bouquet::bouquet::bouquet:

R9 upali:
[M
A4
5
:2
0
]1
:pray::pray:
D
P4 r.Galib Raziya Kureshi:
[M
:2
]1
Happy world homoeopathic day to my all lovable guru:rose::bouquet::kissing_heart:
D
P4 rSamadhan Ghule:
[M
8
:3
]1
A CASE OF DUB ( dysfunctional uterine bleeding )
10th.April18 at early morning I was in fresh mood thinking of birthday of our Master Hahnemann. I received a phone call ,
Good morning Sir ! My bleeding stopped completely.
Actually at last evening that young lady doctor consulted me for her complaints of DUB.
Dr - What is problem ?
Pt - Sir , I have prolonged and excessive menstrual bleeding and it goes on continue less or more until next menstrual
period.
All investigation reports including USG abdomen, BTCT and Hormonal essay came normal except low HB and that is
obviously caused by continuous loss of blood.
Dr - How is your mind disposition during this complaint ?
Pt - Use to be quiet.
Dr - What else ?
Pt - Have a more sleep.
ANALYSIS OF CASE
Pt - Sir , I have prolonged and excessive menstrual bleeding and it goes on continue less or more until next menstrual
period.
Female genitalia/sex - menses - protracted - until next period - almost until next period
(characteristic rubric includes only 4 medicines )
Pt - Use to be quiet.
Mind - quiet disposition
Pt - Have a more sleep.
Sleep - Need of sleep - great
Rx Nux.v 0/1 two doses 1hourly.
(Go through Aphorism164 to understand this prescription.)
Follow up at next morning - No uterine bleeding.
Asked to take same dose sos and give follow up after a week.

T2 ikva Sasson:
[M
P3
8
:4
]1
The Chronic Diseases
"The dose of antipsoric medicine must not be taken by females shortly before their menses are expected, nor during their
flow; but the dose can be given, if necessary, four days, i.e., about ninety-six hours after the menses have set in.
But in case the menses previously have been premature or too profuse, or two long-lasting, it is often necessary to give on
this fourth day a small dose of nux vomica (one very small pellet, moistened with a high dynamization) to be smelled, and
then, on the fourth or sixth day following, the antipsoric.
But if the female is very sensitive and nervous, she ought, until she comes near her full restoration, to smell such a pellet
once about every time seventy-two hours after the beginning of her menses, notwithstanding her continued antipsoric
treatment. "
D
P3 r.Shradha:
[M
0
:5
]1
- April 10 -
*World Homeopathy Day*
World Homeopathy Day
In Honor Of The Father Of Homeopathy System Of Medicine Dr. Samuel Hahnemann.
Few of the majorly celebrated days all around the world also comprise of the World Homeopathy Day. Homeopathy is one
of the major forms of treatment, adapted by most of the doctors of the world. This is a system of medicine that was
developed by Dr. Samuel Hahnemann in Germany at the advent of the 18th century. This system is an alternative to the
standard medicine system. The entire concept, revolving around this system of treatment, is drastically different to the
other conventional forms of medicines.
This second most widely used system of treatment had the first centre of its teaching in the year 1832 after which there
was a wide spread of homeopathic medical schools all over Europe. World Homeopathy Day is observed as one of the most
important days to be celebrated in the history of medical science. The doctors on this day come together and discuss
about the various facts and measures by this system of Homeopathy. The day is celebrated on the 10th of April every year
in memory of Dr. Samuel Hahnemann.
Now-a-days homeopathy is one of the major practices that are used to cure the diseases worldwide. Through the
celebration of the day, more knowledge about this form of medicine is made to spread at the different corners of the world
through the different mediums. This system of medicine uses a unique way of treatment by stimulating body’s own healing
power and has hence received wide popularity since its inception. A day, dedicated to it, is a proof of its popularity.
D8 r.azam. Adabju:
[M
P4
7
:5
]2
:clap::clap::clap::+1::+1::+1:
S
P9 hahidul Islam :
[M
:0
]3
:+1::+1:
D
[M
9
:0
]3
DrSamadhan Ghule
>
A CASE OF DUB ( dysfunctional uterine bleeding ) 10th.April18

>
:+1:
D
[M
:5
]3
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:+1:
R
P4 upali:
[M
:6
]3
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
Nice case sir

D1 ipen Vaishnav:
[M
P5
2
:0
]4
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
Nice analysed sir.:+1:happy world homeopathy day to all group members.
V
P9 eeresh Udamagal:
[M
:3
]4
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:ok_hand::ok_hand::+1: nice analysis sir
V
P7 INOD DHANAWAT:
[M
:5
]4
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
:ok_hand::ok_hand::ok_hand::bouquet::bouquet::bouquet:
P5 rasad Sinalkar:
[M
P2
6
:0
]7
DrSamadhan Ghule
>

>
Nice case sir:ok_hand::ok_hand:
D
P2 r Mahesh Jagtap:
[M
:4
0
]1
/:ok_hand::ok_hand:
W
- ednesday, April 11, 2018-
DrSamadhan Ghule invited Pratima Dixit

Document1 PDF

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Document1 PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

s

Medicines.overcome natural diseases by virtue of being capable o

DELETED joined group via invite link

§ 34 Sixth Edition The greater strength of the artificial disea

The master discovered many things like in field of physics,medic

§ 34 Sixth Edition The greater strength of the artificial disea

SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE

( From clinical desk of Dr.Samadhan Ghule )

SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE COMMENTS on Aphorism

Nice example of aphorisms

SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE COMMENTS on Aphorism

Can any one give ,

SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE COMMENTS on Aphorism

SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE COMMENTS on Aphorism

35 In order to illustrate this, we shall consider in three dif

SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE

( From clinical desk of Dr.Samadhan Ghule )

1 Mémoires et Observations, in the Description de l' Egpte, tom. i.

§ 36 I. If the two dissimilar diseases meeting together in the

SENSE AND ESSENCE OF ORGANON OF MEDICINE

( From clinical desk of Dr.Samadhan Ghule )

P/ H -- 2 - 3 years ago fistula operated two times.

H/ O : -- Asthma < winter since 5 years.

Family history of asthma.

Pt - have a piles. ( actual case of fistula )

Pt - Stool--- , it is not inside but at corner aside.

His friend - Is there hole aside or not ?

Pt - yes , it is there. spotting on dhotar. Why to talk untrue ?

His friend - Yes , say only true.

Pt - Yes , Spotting is there so not possible without hole.

Dr - How like that spotting ?

Dr - What is pile complaints now ( purposely I asked in his conceptual term )

Pt - Nothing but burning urine , and hot legs burning.

Dr - What is complaints of stool ?

Pt - Nothing but have a komb (growth )and nothing in stool.

Dr - What do you feel about this ?

Dr - Is there any tension taking this problem ?

Dr - Why do you think so ?

Dr - Is there any other tension ?

Pt - Nothing but only this complaint. Had no use of operations.

Wife of patient - Angry , ask me not to talk someone or not to go somewhere .

Work out the case to select the remedy .

( From clinical desk of Dr.Samadhan Ghule )

Anger with himself:point_up_2:

Dr. Abhishek Deshpande

Please explain Gambling ?

Spotting on dhotar once try whatever b tbe result

OK. good :+1:

Once try whatever be the result - Gambling -- :ok_hand:nice perception.

Discouraged alternating with hope

Though he is in discouraged situation how is he dealing with his condition ?

Discouraged alternating with hope

No word he uttered of hope.

He is trying one more time with a hope of cure

Think of patient at all levels - emotional , intellectual and physical .

He is trying one more time with a hope of cure

No , he said he don't care whatever would be happen.

Ya right sir my mistake

D:9 rSamadhan Ghule:

How is patient intellectually ?

Do you think this fellow is intellectual like Lyco or Sulph

Anger on himself,anxiety dark,delusion persecuted.

Can we take morose here