Welcome, guest NEW SEARCH: Find articles, photos, video AZ City or ZIP

register | log in News Sports Money Things To Do Style Travel Moms Weather Health Food Home Today's Deal

Jobs Cars Real Estate Rentals Classified • Movies

Local: Ahwatukee Chandler Gilbert Glendale Mesa
• Dining
Peoria Phoenix Pinal Scottsdale SW Valley Surprise Tempe Traffic Archives: Search Prints
• Free Coupons
• Archives
LAURIE ROBERTS' COLUMNS & BLOG
Laurie Roberts is a columnist for The Arizona Republic.

Drive drunk and lose your license. But drive drunk

and kill somebody?
(Column published Sept. 29, 2007.)

This being the second weekend of a new DUI crackdown, it seems a good time to check in on a suspected drunk
driver accused of killing someone in the days before we decided to get tough on drunks.

Turns out the state of Arizona has finally figured out that Lori Ann Gilbert should not be driving.

This, just seven months after police say she swerved into oncoming traffic and killed a Phoenix grandmother.
This, just three months after she was caught driving and driving a second time, in remarkably similar
circumstances.

It's said that our new DUI laws are among the toughest in the nation. After following Gilbert's case, I'd say
there's still room for improvement.

It was just before noon on Feb. 16 and Phyllis Martin had just picked up her four-year-old grandson from
preschool. She was headed north on 43rd Avenue toward Thunderbird when a southbound pickup crossed into
incoming traffic, hitting her head on.

Martin, 55, was dead at the scene and her grandson, injured. Gilbert, 36, told police she'd had two beers. Two
giant beers, evidently. Blood tests put her alcohol level at 0.328 percent, more than four times the legal limit.

Yet police didn't take her license that day, despite a state law that allows them to temporarily suspend the driving
privileges of suspected drunk drivers.

Four months later, Gilbert was still legally licensed to careen down the streets. Marana police spotted her just
before midnight on June 27, driving up onto a sidewalk then drifting across several lanes and up onto the center
median. A preliminary breath test put her at 0.243 percent.

Marana police didn't take her license either, deciding to wait on results of a blood test. By August, they were
still waiting.

Now, however, a judge has finally found a way to mix common law and common sense. Earlier this month, after
a story about Gilbert's continued driving hit public view, Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Michael Gordon
demanded her license then destroyed it.

“He was very good,” said attorney Nick Hentoff, who is representing the victim's family. “He made her turn
over her license right there.”

Gordon also ordered Gilbert not to drink – something you'd think would be standard in such cases -- and he
scheduled a hearing for next week to determine whether she should even be out of jail, given evidence that she
continued to drink and drive after Martin's death.

Martin's family wants her off the streets, saying she's proved that she's a danger. It'll be interesting to see if
prosecutors join the family during Friday's hearing. Earlier this month, they were content to leave Gilbert free on
a $25,000 bond.

Meanwhile, a pair of legislators are astonished that Gilbert was still licensed to drive, seven months after the
fatal crash.

“I think I can pretty much guarantee we'll be taking a look at that next year,” said Sen. Jim Waring, the Phoenix
Republican who sponsored the new DUI laws that took effect last week.

“That definitely is a flaw in the law and should be changed,” echoed GOP Sen. Linda Gray of Phoenix. “It
doesn't make sense at all.”

According to Arizona law, police can seize a suspected drunk driver's license and notify the state Motor Vehicle
Division, so that it can administratively suspend it. But the law applies only when a person is arrested for DUI.
Police don't pursue DUI charges in manslaughter cases, for fear of jeopardizing the more serious charges.

Thus, you can drive drunk in Arizona and lose your license. But you can drive drunk and kill someone, and keep
on driving.

Makes perfect sense. Doesn't it?

Friday, September 28, 2007 at 02:02 PM

Report a Violation
Topics: AZTALK, PLUGGED IN - PHOENIX, REPUBLIC COLUMNISTS
7 COMMENTS FROM 6 USERS
<Reverse Sort Order>

posted by Skyelark on Oct 3, 2007 at 04:35 AM Report Violation

Drunk drivers don't care about anyone but themselves. After all, they have rights!

This woman should be sent to prison for at least five years. There is absolutely no excuse for what she did. And
please don't tell me alcoholism is a disease. I'm fully aware of the problems associated with alcoholism. I also
know that drinking, despite the protests of alcoholics, is a choice! Lori Ann Gilbert made a choice to keep
drinking, despite knowing she had a problem. She might have denied it because of her stupid arrogance,but she
was fully aware that she had a problem. And because of it, an innocent person died.

posted by nocgirl on Oct 1, 2007 at 11:59 AM Report Violation

This is why anyone who has a suspended license, should have their vehicle seized. I know several people who still
drive on suspended licenses from DWI's. Many do not care.

No license-no car.

posted by aridlandman on Sep 29, 2007 at 10:21 AM Report Violation

About time. Hopefully, they'll start pulling the passports of foreign "Princesses" in the
future, as well.

posted by Angelface on Sep 28, 2007 at 03:26 PM Report Violation

I don't understand why it is so difficult for courts to decide how to punish these
people. Anyone who has that few brain cells should obviously not be driving at
all. Why is it so difficult to charge them with murder when that is obviously
what has happend? So in the end, who is the bigger idiot, the person who drives
drunk repeatedly and kills someone or the court that can't decide to keep them
in jail?

You must be logged in to post comments.

Log In | Register

COMMUNITY NEWS

Ahwatukee
COMMUNITY
North Valley BLOGS
Pinal County
Chandler
NW Valley LOG IN
Scottsdale
Gilbert
Peoria
SW Valley
Glendale
Phoenix - Cen.
Surprise
Mesa
Phoenix - NE
Tempe
Southeast News
Plugged In
Southeast
Phoenix News
Plugged In Phoenix
West News
 Plugged In West
Scottsdale News
Plugged In
Scottsdale
Plugged In Arizona
Username / E-mail:

Password:

Sign In
Forgot password?

LAURIE ROBERTS

View Full Profile

Send a Message

Sign Guestbook

Add as a friend

Report a Violation

RSS:

About Laurie Roberts

PREVIOUS POSTS
A tough week for First Amendment supporters
NAU is spending $100k for WHAT?
Saying goodbye to a soldier and a mother
Father of baby left in hot car to face charges
Here's what fiduciaries are saying about probate abuses
Prop 302: Putting first things first
Marie Long, one year later
Saving Arizona's budget -- one ousted kid at a time
Saying goodbye to a piece of old Scottsdale
DREAMING of the day when they won't be political
pawns

ARCHIVES
June 07
July 07
August 07
September 07
October 07
November 07
December 07
January 08
February 08
March 08
April 08
May 08
June 08
July 08
August 08
September 08
October 08
November 08
December 08
January 09
February 09
March 09
 April 09
May 09
June 09
July 09
August 09
September 09
October 09
November 09
December 09
January 10
February 10
March 10
April 10
May 10
June 10
July 10
August 10
September 10
October 10

Arizona Cardinals' defense finally delivers

maximum effortComment by: MOJOHS @
03:31AMI disagree with your analyzes of
Warner being a homer announcer. I remember
when Troy Aikman started doing Dallas
games. Now that was a homer announcer
when he first started. It was actually nice not
hearing a color analyst not bad mouthing and
downgradin(15) Comments / Read story / Post
Comment
Medical marijuana law will be costly if
approved, health officials sayComment by:
wendyteagarden1 @ 03:30AMhow much.(41)
Comments / Read story / Post Comment
Glendale saddled with sports district
debtComment by: G52PIMs228 @
03:30AMYou are so funking stupid. it really
is too funny..(349) Comments / Read story /
Post Comment
Glendale saddled with sports district
debtComment by: FreeGovtMoney @
03:29AM$13 million is about 1/3 of the debt
service costs!(349) Comments / Read story /
Post Comment

At the very least, Max Hall gives

Arizona Cardinals hope at
quarterbackComment by: Willbro2000 @
03:27AMThe winner fo this Division will
probably be 7-9 or 8-8. That's not saying
much.(46) Comments / Read story / Post
Comment

SITE MAP

azcentral.com main

arizona vacations

lavozarizona.com

phoenix news

food | home

phoenix weather

arizona sports

style

classified
 phoenix business

photos

phoenix jobs

things to do

video

phoenix cars

momslikeme.com

arizona cardinals

phoenix homes

phoenix calendar

rss feeds

newsletters

public notices

CUSTOMER SERVICE

terms of service

advertise with Republic Media

privacy policy

contact The Republic

about The Republic

subscribe to The Republic

jobs at The Republic

Republic subscriber services

Media in Education

jobs at KPNX-TV

about KPNX-TV

PARTNERS

USA Today

Gannett Co. Inc.

Apartments: apartments.com

Cars: cars.com

Dating: eHarmony.com

Homes: Homefinder.com

HomeGain

Jobs: CareerBuilder.com
 Local Businesses

Shopping: ShopLocal.com

Copyright © 2009, azcentral.com. All rights reserved. Users of this site agree to the
Terms of Service and Privacy Policy/Your California Privacy Rights