Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Earthquake Performance of Suleymaniye Mosque: University Kandilli Observatory and Earlhquake
Earthquake Performance of Suleymaniye Mosque: University Kandilli Observatory and Earlhquake
ABSTRACT: In a previous research project on the identification ofthe structural configuration ofSuleymaniye
Mosque, earthquake performance, natural frequencies and mo de shapes were determined by both ambient vibra-
tion tests and finite element analysis. In the present study the three dimensional finite element model prepared
during this research was refined and improved as another step ofthe ongoing research activities for the edifice
by adding the small domes to the model and increasing the number of elements to achieve maximum precission
in the analysis. Non-destructive material tests were carried out in order to determine the material properties. The
etfects of different materiais and different boundary conditions were also combined . A satisfactory correlation
is observed between the previous and present analytical results.
477
3 CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS ANO ultrasonic testing method and Schmidt Hammer test-
THEIR MATERIAL PROP ERTIES ing method were used.
478
Table 3. Average modulus of elastieity.
Modulus of
elastieity
Time (see) Veloeity (m/ see) (N/m 2 ). 109
Test Length
loeation (em) Il II II
Table 4. Average modulus of elastieity. as possible which increase the run time of the com-
puter. However, run time was considerably reduced
Modulu s of by the aid of a computer which had a large memory
Material elastieity Poisso n capacity and fast processors.
properties (N/m2 ) . 109 ratio Mass Thiekness
479
Figure I. 3-Dimensional view of Suleymaniye Mosque.
x
J/
480
improved by utilising the following modifications: • Foundation leveI was lovered 2.5 m below the
ground leveI.
• A detailed study was carried out to determine an
• Four different boundary conditions were analysed
optimum number of structural elements. For this
for different combinations of material properties.
purpose the total number of elements were raised to
3989 and the corresponding total number of nodes The frequencies corresponding to the first five
to 6980. modes are given in table 5, (Fig. 2)
• Small domes were added to the model which were
previouslyexcluded. 4.2 Analysis
The results ofthe various dynamic runs under differ-
Table 5. Results of modal analysis. ent combinations ofmaterial properties and boundary
conditions are summarized in Table 6.
Modes Frequency (Hz) Four different boundary conditions were analysed
for four different combinations ofmaterial properties.
Mode I (Lateral mode in 3,244 Severa I dynamic runs were carried out and finally
the north-south direction) a model with nearest frequency values to those of
Mode 2 (Lateral mo de in 3,420 ambient vibration tests was selected as the improved
the east-west direction) model which was used for the spectral response anal-
Mode 3 (Torsional mode) 4,305 ysis under a scenario earthquake for istanbul. Table 7
Mode 4 (Diagonal Torsional mode) 4,734
gives the material properties used in the analysis.
Mode 5 (Lateral squeezing in 4,745
east-west and north-south direction) Table 8 below can be used to compare the results
obtained from ambient vibration tests, earthquake
Natural frequencies
Model lnpul
na me Descriplion FI F2 F3 F4 F5 no
481
Table 7. Material properties used in the analysis. were used in the model and the resu lting frequencies
were compared with those obtained by ambient vibra-
Modulus of e lasticity values (N /m 2 ) . 109 tion tests. By using this comparison, different material
properties were applied to the model in order to
Input no Piers (Stone) Dome (Brick) Arches (Brick) obtain model ofthe best conformity with the ambient
vibration test results.
I 10 5 8,5
2 10 3 3
Four different boundary conditions were ana lysed
3 3,5 3 3 for a number of different combinations of material
4 10 3,5 3,5 properties.
Several dynamic runs were carried out and finally
a model with the nearest frequency values to those of
ambient vibration tests was selected.
Table 8. Comparison of model frequencies.
The improved model showed an acceptable compat-
Earthquake ibility with the test results, the earthquake results of
Ambient results Previous Improved 28.05 .1994 and the results ofthe previous model (3).
test results 28/05/ 1994 model model Unfortunately , precise documents ofthe works are
Mode (cps) (cps) (cps) (cps) not found in the archives. The chronicle usually reports
the payment of the works, but not their location and
1 3,38 3,38 3,26 3,24 technical details which would be very useful for the
2 3,44 3,42 3,65 3,42 analysis. lt is essential to obtain as-built drawings and
3 4,26 4,3 4,58 4,3 full description of the works for the future studies on
4 4,71 5,21 4,73
the edifice.
5 5,85 5,35 4,74
records and the finite element models . lt is observed Arioglu , E. & Arioglu, N. 1999. Mimar Sinan'in Ta~iyici
that the frequencies of the improved model and fre- olarak Kullandigi Küfeki Ta~inin Mühendislik Gizemi ,
quencies observed during 1994 earthquake are very Mimar Sinan Danemi Yapi Etkinlikler Seminar, istanbul
close to each other. Durukal, E. & Yüzügüllü, O. 1998 . Non-destructive Test-
ing Techn iques of Structural Materiais in Historical
Structures, /NCOMARECH-RAPHAEL 97/E/412 Com-
patib/e Materiais for the Proteclion ofElIropean Cultural
5 CONCLUSrON Heritage Pact 55, 1998, Athens
Selahiye, A. Determination of Dynamic Properties of
The three-dimensional finite element model previ- Süleymaniye Mosque. M.Sc. Thesis, Bogazici Uni-
ously prepared was improved by adding the small versity, Kandilli Earthqllake Observatory and Earth-
domes, lowering the foundat ion levei 2.5 m below the quake Research Im'litute, Department of Earthqllake
previous levei and increasing the number of elements Engineering
to achieve maximum precision. These improvements Papayanni, I. 1997. Repair Mortars Suitable for lnterventions
were realised after the preliminary studies on the ofOttoman Monuments, Studies inAncient Strllcture, Pro-
structural system and the material properties. ceedings of the Interna/ional Conference of Ear/hqllake
July 14- 18, 1997, /stanbul
In order to determine the material parameters suit- Anadol , K. & Arioglu, E. 1973 . Earthquake Resistance of
able for the definition of the edifice, diagnostic inves- Suleymaniye Mosque, Fiflh World Conference on Earth-
tigations were conducted using non-destructive testing quake Engineering, 1973, Rome
techn iques (Schmidt Hammer tests and ultrasonic LUSAS Finite Element System Theory Manuels, FEA Ltd. ,
pulse velocity measurements). The results obtained United Kingdom
482