Professional Documents
Culture Documents
R02 Moore PDF
R02 Moore PDF
48:253–66
Copyright © 1996 by Annual Reviews Inc. All rights reserved
KEY WORDS: suprachiasmatic nucleus, retinohypothalamic tract, sleep disorders, affective dis-
orders, melatonin
ABSTRACT
Circadian rhythms are major features of adaptation to our environment. In
mammals, circadian rhythms are generated and regulated by a circadian timing
system. This system consists of entrainment pathways, pacemakers, and pace-
maker output to effector systems that are under circadian control. The primary
entrainment pathway is the retinohypothalamic tract, which terminates in the
circadian pacemakers, the suprachiasmatic nuclei of the hypothalamus. The
output of the suprachiasmatic nuclei is principally to the hypothalamus, the
midline thalamus, and the basal forebrain. This provides a temporal organization
to the sleep-wake cycle, to many physiological and endocrine functions, and to
psychomotor performance functions. Disorders of circadian timing primarily
affect entrainment and pacemaker functions. The pineal hormone, melatonin,
appears to be a promising agent for therapy of some circadian timing disorders.
INTRODUCTION
As the earth rotates around the sun, it turns on its axis so that half of its surface
is continuously in light and half is continuously in darkness. These inexorable
cycles of light and dark provide the most pervasive recurring stimulus in our
environment, one to which virtually all eukaryotic organisms have evolved
adaptations. In mammals, the most evident manifestation of this adaptation is
the temporal organization of behavior into periods of rest and activity, sleep
and waking. Two patterns of mammalian behavior have evolved. Mammals
that utilize olfaction and audition as major senses for perceiving the environ-
0066-4219/97/0401-0253$08.00 253
254 MOORE
ment typically sleep during the day and are active at night, a nocturnal pattern.
In contrast, mammals that utilize vision as their primary sense are awake
during the day and sleep at night, a diurnal pattern. The diurnal pattern is
typical of primates, including humans. The generation and regulation of circa-
dian rhythms is a function of a specific neural system, the circadian timing
system (CTS). The CTS is responsible for providing not only a temporal
organization for behavior, but also for a large series of physiological and
endocrine functions that form a critical substrate for behavior. The ultimate
function of the CTS is to enhance the adaptive value of both sleep and waking
behavior to promote survival and reproduction.
To understand the neurobiology of normal and disordered circadian func-
tion, consider the two fundamental properties of circadian rhythms, generation
by endogenous pacemakers and entrainment by environmental stimuli. The
obvious explanation of a daily rhythm in sleep-wake behavior is that it repre-
sents a simple, passive response to the environmental light-dark cycle, but this
is not the case. When humans, or animals, are placed in temporal isolation, an
environment without time cues, the cycles of sleep and waking behavior
persist in what is termed a free-running state. That is, the rhythm persists but
with a period that differs from 24 h (Figure 1). The maintenance of free-run-
ning rhythms is accountable only by the action of an intrinsic clock, or pace-
maker. For the circadian clock in the organism to function properly in a normal
light-dark cycle, it must be reset regularly. This process is called entrainment.
The endogenous clock is reset predominantly by the major environmental
Zeitgeber (time giver), light. If we examine these fundamental properties of
circadian rhythms, endogenous generation and entrainment, it is obvious that a
CTS must have three basic components—photoreceptors and entrainment
pathways that provide photic information to the pacemakers, circadian pace-
makers, and efferent pathways that couple the pacemakers to effector sys-
tems—that are under circadian control. The intent of this article is to review
current understanding of the functional organization of the CTS and to use this
information as a basis for exploring some common disorders of circadian
function. Some aspects of circadian biology, particularly genetic and molecu-
lar ones, were covered recently (1) and are not considered here. Similarly, the
application of chronobiology to the design of optimal regimens of therapy (see
References 2 and 3 for reviews) is of considerable interest but beyond the
scope of this review.
Figure 1 Free-running rhythm of waking (closed bars), sleep (open bars), and highest (up carats)
and lowest (down carats) body temperature in a young female subject maintained in temporal
isolation for one month. Although there is some day-to-day variation, the free-running period (t) of
her endogenous circadian pacemaker is 24.3 h. (From Reference 59, with permission.)
specific pathways and cellular mechanisms (see below). The effect of light is
dependent on time of day; that is, light alters pacemaker function in a time-de-
pendent manner. This process is described by the phase-response curve (PRC)
(Figure 2). If a nocturnal animal is placed in temporal isolation (constant
darkness or constant dim light), it exhibits a free-running rest-activity rhythm.
With the onset of the animal’s rest period designated circadian time (CT) 0 and
the onset of activity designated CT 12, light administered from CT 2 to CT 10
has no effect on the free-running rhythm. When light is administered from CT
10 to approximately CT 16, however, it delays the onset of activity. From
approximately CT 18 to CT 2, light advances the onset of activity. The phase
delays reflect the fact that the pacemaker views light in the CT 10 to CT 16
time period as a lengthening of day. Phase advances reflect the fact that the
pacemaker views light in the CT 18 to CT 2 period as advancing the onset of
day. The entire PRC describes the complex responses of the pacemaker to light
(Figure 2). Although there is less information about human than about animal
responses to light, available data show humans exhibiting a similar PRC (see
References 4–6 for reviews).
Figure 2 The phase-response curve. The activity (horizontal bars) of animals maintained in
constant dark is recorded, with light pulses given as indicated before, during or after the period of
activity. Once the effects of light are determined, the PRC is constructed as shown.
advances during subjective day, and phase delays during subjective night.
Similar phase changes are observed in response to locomotor activity (21, 22),
and the activity-induced phase changes are blocked by lesions of the IGL (23).
Thus, it appears that the IGL integrates photic and nonphotic information to
provide entraining information to the SCN pacemaker (17). There are a number
of other afferent inputs to the SCN that are likely to provide further modulation
of pacemaker function (24).
Since locomotor activity is under circadian control, its effects on entrain-
ment can be interpreted as feedback effects on the pacemaker. Another exam-
ple of a feedback effect is the action of the pineal hormone, melatonin. In both
diurnal and nocturnal animals, the pineal gland synthesizes and releases mela-
tonin at night, a rhythm that is under the direct control of the SCN (24) via
pathways described below. Large numbers of melatonin receptors in nearly all
mammals, including man (25), are contained in the SCN, to which melatonin
is the mediator of feedback effects from the pineal gland. Melatonin can
entrain the SCN pacemaker under some conditions (26), and a PRC for mela-
tonin has been described for animals (27) and humans (28).
Pacemaker
EVIDENCE FOR SCN PACEMAKER FUNCTION Four lines of evidence establish
the SCN as the dominant mammalian circadian pacemaker. First, the SCN is the
major site of termination of the photic entrainment pathway, the RHT, and it
receives other entraining input as described above. Second, ablation of the SCN
results in a loss of nearly all circadian rhythms (see References 24 and 29 for
reviews). In each instance, the only effect of the SCN lesions is to alter the
temporal organization of the function studied. For example, SCN ablation
abolishes the sleep-wake rhythm, but the total amount of time spent awake and
asleep and the proportion of REM and slow-wave sleep are unaffected. Third,
the SCN exhibits a circadian rhythm in neuronal activity even when isolated
from the remainder of the brain in vivo (30) or in vitro (31). Fourth, transplan-
tation of fetal SCN into the brain of animals rendered arrhythmic by SCN lesions
restores rhythmicity (32), and the restored rhythm reflects the intrinsic rhyth-
micity of the donor tissue (33).
There is evidence that the eye contains an independent circadian oscillator
(34) in mammals but no indication that this has any effect on function outside
of the eye. Similarly, there may be local circadian oscillators in other tissues,
but the SCN appears to be the only brain circadian pacemaker that provides a
temporal organization for neural mechanisms of adaptation.
input, and a shell that receives input from other areas (35; see also 24). These
subdivisions are distinguishable both by the segregation of afferents and by the
peptide content of neurons that comprise them (24). Nevertheless, it appears that
all SCN neurons are GABA-producing in animals (36) and humans (37) so that
output is inhibitory. There are two potential principles of organization of the
SCN pacemaker: Circadian function could arise as an emergent property from
the coupling of a series of ultradian oscillators; or individual SCN neurons could
be born as circadian oscillators coupled by neural connections to form a
pacemaker (38). Recent data indicate that the latter organization is the one
employed. When SCN neurons are dissociated and maintained in tissue culture,
they retain individual patterns of firing that exhibit circadian rhythmicity (39).
It is not clear whether all SCN neurons are circadian oscillators or whether this
property is expressed only by neurons of the SCN core, or by some other
subpopulation.
Figure 3 Projections of the SCN pacemaker and functional correlations. The SCN has limited
primary projections but widespread secondary projections to areas involved in control of the many
functions regulated by the circadian system.
of sleep and waking and by other behavioral symptoms that reflect both the
sleep disturbances and alterations of circadian regulation of waking adaptive
behavior. From the organization of the CTS, we would expect three types of
circadian disorder: abnormalities of entrainment, pacemaker function, and
pacemaker coupling to effector systems.
Disorders of Entrainment
RAPID TIME-ZONE CHANGE SYNDROME (JET LAG) The jet lag syndrome is a
disorder of modern life. Symptoms of rapid time-zone change occur in some
individuals with changes of as little as 3 h, but at least a 5-h change is required
for most. The typical symptoms of jet lag include sleep disruption, fatigue,
difficulty concentrating, gastrointestinal distress, impaired psychomotor coor-
dination, reduced cognitive skills, and alterations of mood. The symptoms remit
spontaneously over days with their duration determined by the direction of
travel, west to east producing more impairment than east to west, and by the
number of time zones crossed. Measures to ameliorate jet lag are discussed by
Graeber (43). Recent studies indicate that melatonin is an effective treatment
(see Reference 44 for a review), presumably by acting on the SCN pacemaker.
Figure 4 Phase-response curves in controls, in blind subjects, and in phase-delay and phase-ad-
vance sleep disorders.
with the advanced sleep phase syndrome have persistent early onset of sleep,
usually around 7–9 p.m., with a consequent awakening at 3–5 a.m. Such
individuals complain of an inability to stay awake for social events in the evening
and of being alone without companionship when they get up in the early
morning. Attempts to delay sleep onset result in severe evening fatigue and
usually fail. This syndrome is often found in the elderly, and it reflects a lack of
sensitivity in the delay portion of the PRC (Figure 4).
AFFECTIVE DISORDERS
The affective disorders are a complex of diseases in which disturbances of
mood are prominent manifestations. There are also disturbances of sleep,
appetite, libido, cognition, and memory frequently reported. Although it has
long been thought that a disruption of circadian function may be a prominent
part of major depression, the most common of the affective disorders, this has
not been established. Two recent reviews (57, 58) concluded that there is no
primary disturbance of the circadian system in depression, but that circadian
function may be disrupted as part of the multiple manifestations of the primary
pathophysiology of these diseases. This is an area where much work still needs
264 MOORE
to be done. In particular, this area, and many others, would be well served if it
were possible to measure function of the CTS directly. It is quite likely,
though, that understanding the nature of circadian abnormalities in depression
should provide insight into its fundamental pathophysiology.
Literature Cited
1. Menaker MM. 1993. Special topic: circa- 15. Rea MA, Buckley B, Lutton, LM. 1993.
dian rhythms. Annu. Rev. Physiol. 55: Local administration of EAA antagonists
657–59 blocks light-induced phase shifts and cfos
2. Lemmer B, ed. 1989. Chronopharmacol- expression in the hamster SCN. Am. J.
ogy: Cellular and Biochemical Interac- Physiol. 265:R1191–98
tions. New York: Dekker. 527 pp. 16. Myers MP, Wagner-Smith K, Rothenfluh-
3. Bjarnason CA. 1995. Chronobiology: im- Hilfiker A, Young, MW. 1996. Light-in-
plications for cancer therapy. Acta Oncol. duced degradation of TIMELESS and en-
34:615–24 trainment of the Drosophila circadian
4. Minors DS, Waterhouse JM, Wirz-Justice clock. Science 271:1736–40
A. 1992. A human phase-response curve to 17. Moore RY, Card JP. 1994. The intergenicu-
light. Neurosci. Lett. 13:36–40 late leaflet: an anatomically and function-
5. Van Cauter E, Sturis J, Byrne MM, et al. ally distinct subdivision of the lateral geni-
1993. Preliminary studies on the immediate culate complex. J. Comp. Neurol. 344:403–
phase-shifting effects of light and exercise 30
on the circadian clock. J. Biol. Rhythms 18. Albers HE, Ferris CF. 1984. Neuropeptide
8:S99–108 Y: role in light-dark cycle entrainment of
6. Boivin DB, Duffy JF, Kronauer RE, Czeis- hamster circadian rhythms. Neurosci. Lett.
ler, CA. 1994. Sensitivity of the human 50:163–68
circadian pacemaker to moderately bright 19. Shibata S, Moore RY. 1993. Neuropeptide
light. J. Biol. Rhythms 9:315–31 Y and optic chiasm stimulation affect su-
7. Moore RY. 1978. Neural control of pineal prachiasmatic nucleus circadian function in
function in mammals and birds. J. Neural. vitro. Brain Res. 615:95–100
Trans. 13(Suppl.):47–58 20. Johnson RF, Smale L, Moore RY, Morin,
8. Moore RY, Lenn NJ. 1972. A retinohy- LP. 1988. Lateral geniculate lesions block
pothalamic projection in the rat. J. Comp. circadian phase-shift responses to a ben-
Neurol . 146:1–14 zodiazepine. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
9. Moore RY. 1973. Retinohypothalamic pro- 85:5301–4
jection in mammals: a comparative study. 21. Reebs SG, Mrosovsky N. 1989. Large
Brain Res. 51:403–9 phase-shifts of circadian rhythms caused
10. Johnson RF, Moore RY, Morin LP. 1988. by induced running in a re-entrainment
Loss of entrainment and anatomical plas- paradigm: the role of pulse duration and
ticity after lesions of the hamster retino- light. J. Comp. Physiol. 165:819–25
hypothalamic tract. Brain Res. 460:297– 22. Turek FW. 1989. The effects of stimulated
13 physical activity on the circadian pace-
11. Moore RY, Speh JC, Card JP.1995. The maker of mammals. J. Biol. Rhythms 4:
retinohypothalamic tract originates from a 135–48
distinct subset of retinal ganglion cells. J. 23. Johnson RF, Moore RY, Morin LP. 1989.
Comp. Neurol. 352:351–66 Lateral geniculate lesions alter circadian
12. Speh JC, Card JP, Moore RY. 1995. Identi- activity rhythms in the hamster. Brain Res.
fication of elements of the “circadian” ret- Bull. 22:411–22
ina using the pseudorabies virus. Soc. 24. Moore RY. 1996. Neural control of the pin-
Neurosci. 21:179 (Abstr.) eal gland. Behav. Brain Res. 73:125–30
13. Shirakawa T, Moore RY. 1994. Glutamate 25. Morgan PJ, Barrett JP, Howell HE, Helli-
shifts the phase of the circadian neuronal well R. 1994. Melatonin receptors: local-
timing rhythm in the rat suprachiasmatic ization, molecular pharmacology and
nucleus in vitro. Neurosci. Lett. 178:47–50 physiology significance. Neurochem. Int.
14. Ding JM, Chen D, Weber, ET, et al. 1994. 24:101–46
Resetting the biological clock: mediation of 26. Cassone, VM. 1990. Effects of melatonin
nocturnal circadian shifts by glutamate and on vertebrate circadian systems. TINS 13:
NO. Science 266:1713–17 457–63
CIRCADIAN RHYTHMS 265
27. Gillette MU, McArthur AJ. 1996. Circa- and the functional organization of the cir-
dian actions of melatonin at the suprachias- cadian system. Prog. Brain Res. In press
matic nucleus. Behav. Brain Res. 73: 42. Czeisler CA, Shanahan TL, Klerman ER,
135–39 et al. 1995. Suppression of melatonin secre-
28. Lewy AJ, Ahmed S, Jackson JMC, Sack, tion in some blind patients by exposure to
RL. 1992. Melatonin shifts human circa- bright light. New Engl. J. Med. 332:6–11
dian rhythms according to a phase response 43. Graeber RC. 1994. Jet lag and sleep disrup-
curve. Chronobiol. Int. 9:380–92 tion. In Principles and Practice of Sleep
29. Meijer JH, Rietveld WJ. 1989. The neuro- Medicine, ed. MH Kryger, T Roth, WC
physiology of the suprachiasmatic circa- Dement, pp. 463–70. New York: Saunders
dian pacemaker in rodents. Physiol. Rev. 44. Arendt J. 1995. Melatonin and the Mam-
69:671–702 malian Pineal Gland. London: Chapman &
30. Inouye SIT, Kawamura H. 1979. Persist- Hall
ence of circadian rhythmicity in a mammal- 45. Monk TH. 1994. Shift work. In Principles
ian hypothalamic “island” containing the and Practice of Sleep Medicine, ed. MH
suprachiasmatic nucleus. Proc. Natl. Acad. Kryger, T Roth, WC Dement, pp. 471–76.
Sci. USA 76:5962–66 New York: Saunders
31. Shibata S, Moore RY. 1988. Electrical and 46. Eastman CI, Stewart KT, Mahoney MP, et
metabolic activity of suprachiasmatic nu- al. 1994. Dark goggles and bright light im-
cleus neurons in hamster hypothalamic prove circadian rhythm adaptation to night-
slices. Brain Res. 438:374–78 shift work. Sleep 17:535–43
32. Lehman MN, Silver R, Gladstone WR, et 47. Lewy AJ, Ahmed S, Sack RL. 1996. Phase
al. 1987. Circadian rhythmicity restored by shifting the human circadian clock using
neural transplant. Immunocytochemical melatonin. Behav. Brain Res. 73:131–34
characterization of the graft and its integra- 48. Wagner DR. 1990. Circadian rhythm sleep
tion with the host brain. J. Neurosci. 7: disorders. In Handbook of Sleep Disorders,
1626–38 ed. M Thorpy, pp. 493–52. New York: Dek-
33. Ralph MR, Foster RG, Davis FC, Menaker ker
M. 1990. Transplanted suprachiasmatic nu- 49. Roehrs T, Roth T. 1994. Chronic insomnias
cleus determines circadian rhythms. Sci- associated with circadian rhythm disorders.
ence 247:975–78 In Principles and Practice of Sleep Medi-
34. Tosini G, Menaker M. 1996. Circadian cine, ed. MH Kryger, T Roth, WC Dement,
rhythms in cultured mammalian retina. Sci- pp. 447–81. New York: Saunders
ence 272:419–22 50. Cohen RA, Albers HE. 1991. Disruption of
35. Cassone VM, Speh JC, Card JP, Moore human circadian and cognitive function
RY.1988. Comparative anatomy of mam- following a discrete hypothalamic lesion.
malian suprachiasmatic nucleus. J. Biol. Neurology 41:726–28
Rhythms 3:71–91 51. Prinz PN, Peskind ER, Vitaliano PP, et al.
36. Moore RY, Speh JC. 1993. GABA is the 1982. Changes in sleep and waking EEGs
principal neurotransmitter of the circadian of nondemented and demented elderly sub-
system. Neurosci. Lett. 150:112–16 jects. J. Am. Ger. Soc. 30:86–93
37. Gao B, Moore RY. 1996. Glutamic acid 52. Prinz PN, Christie C, Smallwood R, et al.
decarboxylase message isoforms in human 1984. Circadian temperature variation in
suprachiasmatic nucleus. J. Biol. Rhythms. healthy aged and Alzheimer’s disease. J.
In Press Gerontol. 39:30–35
38. Moore RY, Bernstein ME. 1989. Synapto- 53. Sharma M, Palacios-Bois J, Schwartz G, et
genesis in the rat suprachiasmatic nucleus al. 1989. Circadian rhythms of melatonin
demonstrated by electron microscopy and and cortisol in aging. Biol. Psychiatr. 25:
synapsin-I immunoreactivity. J. Neurosci. 305–19
9:2151–62 54. Swaab DF, Fliers FE, Partiman TS. 1985.
39. Welch DK, Logothetis DE, Meister M, The suprachiasmatic nucleus of the human
Reppert SM. 1995. Individual neurons dis- brain in relation to sex, age and senile de-
sociated from rat suprachiasmatic nucleus mentia. Brain Res. 342:37–44
express independently phased circadian fir- 55. Myers BL, Badia P. 1995. Changes in cir-
ing patterns. Neuron 14:697–706 cadian rhythms and sleep quality with ag-
40. Watts AG. 1991. The efferent projections of ing: mechanisms and interactions. Neuro-
the suprachiasmatic nucleus: anatomical sci. Biobehav. Rev. 19:553–71
insights into the control of circadian 56. Haimov I, Lavie P, Landon M, et al. 1995.
rhythms. In The Suprachiasmatic Nu- Melatonin replacement therapy of elderly
cleus—The Mind’s Clock, ed. DC Klein, RY insomniacs. Sleep 18:598–603
Moore, ST Reppert, pp. 77–106. New York: 57. Wirz-Justice A. 1995. Biological rhythms
Oxford in mood disorders. In Psychopharmacol-
41. Moore RY. 1996. Entrainment pathways ogy: The Fourth Generation of Progress,
266 MOORE