You are on page 1of 83

MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 

Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 1 
   

 
 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 2 
   

 
 

2 Abstract

Fire alarm and detection as passive system is the most commonly


prescribed system for fire protection.
This paper summarises the prescription on design practice for fire
detection and alarm system contain in MS1745 Part 14
An introductory section pertaining to the liability / responsibility of
the professional engineer is included.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

This  presentation  summarises  the  prescription  on  design  practice  for  fire  detection  and  alarm 
system  contained  in  MS  1745  Part  14.  A  comparative  description  of  some  key  prescriptions  of  BS 
5839‐1  which  mirrors  those  in  MS  1745  –  14  are  also  included.  The  introductory  missive  on 
professional  liabilities  shows  that  proficiency  in  technical  standards  is  a  statutory  requirement  for 
engineers submitting plans under the ‘Street, Drainage and Building Act’. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 3 
   

 
 

3 CONTENTS
Introduction; Submitting Engineer’s Responsibilities
Overview & Structure of MS1745
Introduction, Scope, General; Design Flow
Assessing Needs, Planning Design
Circuit Survivability
Detection Zones
Initiating Devices; Siting & Spacing of Detectors, Manual
Break Glass, Alam
Detection Zones
Power Supplies; Cables & Interconnections, Fire Rated
Cables; EMC
Installation, Work Acceptance, Maintenance, Operation
Applications in Special Risk

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The content flow mirrors the content of MS1745 – 14. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 4 
   

 
 

4 INTRODUCTION – The Professional Engineer’s Responsibilities

The responsibilities of a Professional Engineer can be summarised:

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

From  the  above,  we  note  that  Civil  Law  is  the  most  important  legal  requirement  regulating  the 
conduct  and  practice  of  engineering.  The  Civil  Law  Act  is  applicable  in  all  countries  (including 
countries  with  Socialist  Justice  System  which  would  have  a  form  of  Civil  Law).  Thus  it  would  be 
pertinent  to  note  that  the  professional  engineer  will  be  regulated  by  Civil  Law  even  in  countries 
which do not have any form of registering professional engineers. 
.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 5 
   

 
 

5 INTRODUCTION – The Professional Engineer’s Responsibilities

Professional responsibility & Duty of Care

1 Professionalism requires the Engineer to place ‘public interest’


and his ‘client’s interest above his own.
2 Action may be taken by the public suffering damages against
any tortfeasor (‘wrong-doer’) causing such damage.
3 In negligence tort, the professional engineer owes a duty of
care to the public and his client.

Highland Tower Ruling, K.L. High Court, Aug 2000:


the learned judge ruled that “... the unqualified architect who undertook the
works would be judged on the standard of a reasonably qualified architect ..”

Thus even an unregistered engineer who practices engineering will be liable


under Civil Law!

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Under principles of Civil Law, even an unregistered engineer will be held liable for negligence once 
professional engineering services are offered. Fire fighting contractors who provide services (in the 
absence of any professional engineer) will therefore be held responsible in the event of negligence 
and damage caused to the public. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 6 
   

 
 

6 INTRODUCTION – The Professional Engineer’s Responsibilities

Where does it requires that a P.Eng MUST


be responsible ?

STREET, DRAINAGE AND BUILDING ACT 1974 ACT 133

Preamble
An Act to amend and consolidate the laws relating to street,
drainage and building in local authority areas in West
Malaysia, and for purposes connected therewith.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Under the ‘Street, Drainage and Building Act’ all buildings and structures are regulated by the local 
authorities. Thus permission must be sought before any building or structure can be erected. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 7 
   

 
 

7 INTRODUCTION – The Professional Engineer’s Responsibilities

Street, Drainage And Building ACT 1974 ACT 133


Part I, 3. Interpretation
"principal submitting person" means a qualified person who submits
building plans to the local authority for approval in accordance with
this Act or any by-laws made thereunder and includes any other
qualified person who takes over the duties and responsibilities of or
acts for the first mentioned qualified person;
"qualified person" means a Professional Architect, Professional
Engineer or building draughtsman registered under any written law
relating to the registration thereof;
"submitting person" means a qualified person who submits plans
other than building plans to the local authority or relevant statutory
authority in accordance with this Act or any by-laws made thereunder
and includes any other qualified person who takes over the duties and
responsibilities of or acts for the first mentioned qualified person;

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The  ‘Street,  Drainage  and  Building  Act’  very  clearly  requires  that  only  registered  Architect  and/or 
Engineers are allowed to submit plans to local authority. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 8 
   

 
 

8 INTRODUCTION – The Professional Engineer’s Responsibilities

How many who


claims to be
practitioner has a
copy of the UBBL?

MS 1745 : Part 14

MS 1745 : Part 5 & 6

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The above lists typical statutory declarations which the Engineer will have to make in the submission 
of plans. Two conclusions can be drawn from the above: 

(1) The submitting engineer must be proficient in the technical standards of which he signs off 
his  design.  This  includes  proficiency  in  the  Uniform  Building  By‐Law.  A  corollary  to  the 
aforesaid would be that engineers are also required (under principles of Civil Law or Tort 
Laws)  to  maintain  his  expertise;  meaning  that  he  must  keep  his  knowledge  abreast  of 
‘current’ practice (including updates to technical standards). 
(2) Listing  of  technical  standards  must  be  updated  to  take  into  account  latest  revision  and 
updates to standards applicable in statutory declarations. 

The ‘Standards of Malaysia Act 1996 (Act 549) prescribes that Malaysia Standard has primacy over 
other international recognised standards. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 9 
   

 
 

9 INTRODUCTION – The Professional Engineer’s Responsibilities

Certification of
Completion and
Compliance

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Certification of Completion and Compliance (C.C.C.) which came into force on April 2007, places the 
primary  responsibility  for  issuance  of  building  O.C.F.  (Occupation  Certificate  of  Fitness)  on  the 
submitting person (the registered architect and/or engineer). It should also be noted (form G8) that 
the accountability of the contractor responsible will be a growing topic of national discussions. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 10 
   

 
 

10 Overview of MS 1745

Part 1 – Introduction
Part 2 – Control and Indicating Equipment
Part 3 – Audible Fire Alarm Devices
Part 4 – Power Supply Equipment
Part 5 – Heat Detectors – Point detectors
Part 7 – Smoke detectors – point detectors using scattered light,
transmitted light or ionisation
Part 10 – Flame Detectors – Point detectors
Part 11 – Manual Call Points
Part 12 – Smoke Detectors – Line detectors using an optical light beam.
Part 13 – Compatibility Assessment of Systems Components,
Part 14 – Guidelines for Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use
and Maintenance
Part 15 – Multisensor Fire Detectors

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The complete series of MS1745 is listed above. It should be noted that this presentation will focus on 
Part  14  as  the  rest  of  the  standards  are  product  standards.  Understanding  technical  standards 
requires a basic idea on types of standards: 

(1) Basic Standards – are general standards dealing with topics used by other standards; e.g. 
terminology, testing techniques, definition of hazard class etc. 
(2) Product Standards – deals with specifying the product itself and can be sub‐divided into 3 
sub class: 
(a) Material Standards; quality of PVC, ferrous metal used in pipes etc. 
(b) Component Standards; valve, proximity switch, hydrants, detectors, meters etc. 
(c) Assembly  Standards;  built‐up  unit  from  components,  e.g.  alarm  panels  which  is  an 
assembly of components such as fuses, control modules etc. 
(3) Installation  Standards  –  are  general  standards  dealing  with  integration  of  various 
components, assemblies and equipment for a specific application. Part 14 of the MS 1745 
series would be an installation standard. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 11 
   

 
 

11 Overview of MS 1745

EN54 part 1 – Introduction


EN54 part 2 – Control and Indication Equipment
EN54 part 3 – Fire alarm devices, Sounders
EN54 part 4 – Power supply equipment
EN54 part 5 – Heat detectors, point detectors
EN54 part 6 – Heat detectors, rate of rise point detectors without static element
{WITHDRAWN}
EN54 part 7 - Smoke detectors, point detectors using scattered light, transmitted
light or ionisation
EN54 part 8 - Components of automatic fire detection systems. Spec. for high temp.
heat detectors {WITHDRAWN}
EN54 part 9 – Components of automatic detection systems. Method of test of
sensitivity to fire.
EN54 part 10 – Flame Detectors – Point detectors
EN54 part 11 – Manual Call Points
EN54 part 12 – Smoke Detectors – Line detectors using an optical light beam.
EN 54 part 13 – Compatibility Assessment of Systems Components,
EN 54 part 14 – Cabling and interconnection of a fire detection and alarm system

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

It  can  be  noted  that  part  6  and  8  have  been  withdrawn.  MS1745  do  not  include  part  6,  8  and  9. 
Beyond part 13 however, MS1745 diverge from EN 54.  

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 12 
   

 
 

12 Overview of MS 1745

EN54 part 15 – Point detectors using a combination of detected fire phenonmena


EN54 part 16 – Components of fire alarm system voice alarm system, voice alarm
control and indicating equipment.
EN54 part 17 Fire detection and fire alarm systems. Short circuit isolators
EN 54 part 18 Fire detection and fire alarm systems. Input/output devices
EN 54 part 19
EN 54 part 20 Fire detection and fire alarm systems. Aspirating smoke detector
EN 54 part 21 Fire detection and fire alarm systems. Alarm transmission and fault
warning routing equipment
EN 54 part 22 Fire detection and fire alarm systems. Line type heat detectors
EN 54 part 23 Fire detection and fire alarm systems. Fire alarm devices. Visual
alarms
EN 54 part 24 Fire detection and fire alarm systems . Voice alarms - Loudspeakers
EN 54 part 25 Fire detection and fire alarm systems. Components using radio links
and system requirements
EN 54 part 26 Fire detection and fire alarm systems. Point fire detectors using
Carbon Monoxide sensors
EN 54 part 27 Fire detection and fire alarm systems. Duct smoke detectors

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The rest of EN 54 series is listed above. Thus practitioners requiring standards on components not 
listed under MS may refer to the standards listed above. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 13 
   

 
 

13 Overview of MS 1745

BS 5839 – Fire Detection and Alarm Systems for Buildings

Part 1 : 2002 - Code of practice for system design, installation,


commissioning and maintenance

Part 2 : 1983 - Specification for manual call points (withdrawn


and since replaced with BS EN 54-11:2002)

Part 3 : 1988 - Specification for automatic release mechanisms


for certain fire protection equipment

Part 4 : 1988 - Specification for control and indicating equipment


(withdrawn and replaced by BS EN54-2 ‘Control and indicating
equipment’ and BS EN54-4 ‘Power supply equipment’)

continue next page

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

BS  5839  is  the  standard  which  most  practitioners  follow  in  this  country.  A  listing  of  the  BS  5839 
series is shown above.  

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 14 
   

 
 

14 Overview of MS 1745

BS 5839 – Fire Detection and Alarm Systems for Buildings

Part 5 : 1988 – Specification for optical beam smoke detectors

Part 6 : 1985 – Code of practice for the design and installation of


fire detection and alarm systems in dwellings

Part 8 : 1988 Code of practice for the design, installation and


servicing of voice alarm system

Part 9 : 2003 Code of practice for the design, installation,


commissioning and maintenance of emergency voice
communication systems

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Listing of BS 5839 series. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 15 
   

 
 

15 Structure of MS 1745 Part 14

MS 1745 Part 14 Fire Detection and Alarm Systems for Buildings, Guidelines
for planning, design, installation, commissioning, use and maintenance
0 – Introduction
1 – Scope Annex A – Maintenance Check List
2 – Normative References Annex B – Dealing with False Alarm
3 – Terms and Reference Annex C – Model Certificates
4 – General
5 – Assessment of Needs
6 – Planning and Design
7 – Installation
8 – Commissioning and Verification
9 – Third Party Approval
10 – Documentations
11 – Maintenance
12 – Modification or Extension of an Installed System
13 – Operation of Other Fire Protection System
14 – Application in Special Risk
15 – Integrated Systems
16 – Hierarchical Systems

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

A summary of the Section headings of MS 1745 part 14 shows the topics which are covered in the 
standard. Section 5 and 6 constitute a substantive part of the standard. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 16 
   

 
 

16 MS 1745 Part 14 – Introduction and Scope

0 – Introduction
MS 1745 is meant to be a guide, i.e. it is not mandatory.
It will become mandatory if specified in another document or by an
authority having power.

2 – Scope
Covers planning, design, installation, commission, operation and
maintenance of system.
System covered at least one detector.
DO NOT :
Do not cover systems combining fire alarm with other non-fire related
functions e.g. fire alarm hard-wired as part of a BMS.
Do not recommend whether fire alarm (including the type and extent)
to be installed in any premises

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

MS 1745 – 14 is worded as a Guide, i.e. it do not carry mandatory requirement. However where it is 
cited  in  specifications,  it  become  (contractually)  mandatory.  Citation  or  claims  that  a  system 
complies to MS 1745 – 14 also confers mandatory status to the standard. 

MS 1745 – 14 DO NOT recommend the type, extent and scope of fire detection and alarm system to 
be installed in any building. For recommendation on system and extent of coverage, we will have to 
refer to other legal prescription (notably the UBBL). 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 17 
   

 
 

17 MS 1745 Part 14 – Normative Reference, Terms & definitions

2 – Normative Reference.
Makes reference to ALL other parts of MS1745.
Parts 1 to 12 can be said to be product standards.
Therefore compliance to MS1745 requires that components must be
certified to conform to the relevant parts of MS 1745.

3 – Terms and Definitions – some important terms:


Competent person – Person … certified by an accredited body with
the necessary knowledge, skills and experience ...
Competent organisation – Organisation which… has under its
employment competent persons with the necessary knowledge,
skills, experience and tools to carry out the work satisfactorily.
Designer – person or organisation taking responsibility for work in
Claus 6 (Planning and Design).

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

By  normative  reference,  the  components  which  will  be  specified  and  installed  under  this  standard 
will  have  to  comply  with  the  relevant  product  standard  in  the  MS  1745  series.  Where  product 
standards are not available in MS, then the EN 54 series will have precedence. 

The  standard  also  prescribed  that  competent  person  and  organisation  should  be  retained. 
Competent person in the Malaysian context and especially under the context of the ‘Street, Drainage 
and Building Act’ will be the registered engineer. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 18 
   

 
 

18 MS 1745 Part 14 – General

Initial concept
1. Building risk group,
2. Space to be protected,
Assessment of needs
3. Type of system to be installed,
4. Interaction with other fire
Planning and design protection measures

Installation

Commissioning and
verification 1. Selecting and locating detectors,
2. Zoning of building/ alarm zones,
3. Provision for control, displays
Third party approval and indications,
(optional) 4. Provision of power supplies

Use / Operation

Maintenance 4 – General – provide general guidance on use of MS1745

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Figure  1  in  MS  1745  illustrates  the  process  flow  for  compliance  with  MS  1745.  As  a 
substantive  portion  of  the  standard  deals  with  “Assessment  of  Needs”  and  “Planning  and 
Design”, the sub‐topics relevant to these two topics are listed as decision clouds. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 19 
   

 
 

19 MS 1745 Part 14 – General

4 – General
4.2 Each of the process listed in Fig. 1 are assumed to be carried out by
different organisation.
4.3 Electrical safety is NOT covered in MS1745 but relevant legislative
requirements should be referred (MS 1979 and MS 1936).
4.4 Design to minimise false alarm (Annex B).
4.5 Warranties to be provided by suppliers and manufacturers.
4.6 Proper documentations at each stage (Annex C – format certificates).
4.7 Responsibility of person to be clearly defined.
4.8 Persons or qualifications to be appropriately competent (cross
reference to definitions).

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

In Clause 4.3, the following are relevant electrical standards and codes which are mandatory under 
the ‘Electricity Supply Act’: 

(1) MS 1979:2007 "Electrical Installation of Buildings – Code of Practice" 

(2) MS 1936:2006 “Electrical Installation of Building – Guide to MS IEC 60364" 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 20 
   

 
 

20 MS 1745 Part 14 – Assessment of Needs

MS 1745 DO NOT specify when, where and how fire


detection and alarm systems are installed.

Consult Client / Architect.


Consult Life Safety Code
Understand space planning,
legally in force (UBBL).
usage & operation needs.

Consult authorities having System


Concept Consult Insurance company.
jurisdiction (Jab. Bomba).

Consider integration with


Consult installers.
existing / other systems

continue next page

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Assessment of needs is the first step in delving into detail design and specification. Assessing ‘Needs’ 
identify  the  over‐riding  consideration,  Protection  of  Life  versus  Protection  of  Property  with  over‐
riding consideration of cost‐operation, which will define a design concept and the extent of coverage 
required within and without a premise. 

Consultation with insurance company should (in the author’s opinion) be an important consideration 
in  assessing  needs  as  insurance  premiums  are  not  necessarily  confined  only  to  basic  standard 
prescribed  under  the  law  (UBBL).  System  designed  and  installed  are  frequently  required  to  be 
modified  or  have  components  changed,  or  even  sub‐system  added  after  audit  by  an  insurance 
company. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 21 
   

 
 

21 MS 1745 Part 14 – Assessment of Needs

Uniform Building By Law (revised up to 2006)


Part VII – FIRE REQUIREMENTS
153 – Smoke detectors for lift lobbies.
225 – Detecting and extinguishing fire
Systems to be provided in accordance with 10th Schedule.
237 – Fire alarms
Premises G.F.A. >9,290M² (exclude car park & storage area)
OR >30.5M in height
shall be provided with 2 stage alarm with evacuation (continuous
signal)
238 – Command and control centre; Large premises > 30.5M in height
241 – Special requirements for fire alarm systems.
Visible alarm indicator signal where there are deaf persons
244 – Standards for Fire alarm FOC rules, BS CP 1019, BS 3116 & 5446
continue next page
Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)
 

Every practitioner in the building industry should have a copy of the “UBBL”. The UBBL (not Bomba 
Officer) will be the first step in assessing the needs, extent and coverage of system to be included. 
The above listed by‐laws in the UBBL pertaining to fire alarm and detection system has relevance. 

By‐Law 244 however seems to be outdated in its citation of standards: 

(1) Since 1986 the role of the “Fire Officer’s Committee” (FOC), UK has been taken over by the 
“Loss Prevention Council” (LPC, UK). 
(2) BS CP 1019 is superseded by BS5839 – 1 
(3) BS  3116  part  1  :  1970  has  since  been  withdrawn  and  superseded  by  BS  5839  (relevant 
part). 
(4) BS 3116 part 4 was superseded by BS 5839‐4 which in turn was withdrawn and superseded 
by EN 54‐4. 
(5) The  original  BS5446‐1:1977  was  superseded  by  BS5446‐1:2000  (Fire  detection  and  fire 
alarm  devices  for  dwellings.  Specification  for  smoke  alarms)  which  was  withdrawn  and 
replaced with BS EN 14604:2005 (smoke alarm devices) 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 22 
   

 
 

22 MS 1745 Part 14 – Assessment of Needs

UBBL, 10th Schedule prescribes

Fire alarm system prescribed in conjunction with other active fire


systems for the various building occupational hazard class are:
4 types of systems are prescribed:
1. Automatic Electrical Fire Alarm System
2. Manual Electrical Fire Alarm System
3. Signal Indicator Alarm System
4. Manual Alarm System

continue next page

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The  UBBL  10th  Schedule  is  the  most  important  document  prescribing  the  extent  and  scope  of 
coverage  required  for  the  various  building  hazard  class.  Four  types  of  fire  alarm  and  detection 
Participants are requested to consult 10th Schedule of the UBBL. 
systems are listed. P

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 23 
   

 
 

23 MS 1745 Part 14 – Assessment of Needs

MS 1745 Part 14 Section 6 classifies fire alarm systems by extent


of coverage.

4 types of Automatic Fire Detection Systems coverage are defined:


1.Total cover – covering all spaces in building
2.Compartment cover – covering only parts (usually the most vulnerable
areas) of the building.
3.Escape route cover.
4.Local cover – covering particular functions, special equipment or
areas of particularly high risk.

continue next page

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

MS 1745 – 14 defines coverage in four general classes. An assessment on the coverage required will 
have to be made by a competent person as previously stated and as covered in the previous slide 
the UBBL (especially the 10th Schedule) will be the first step in assessing coverage. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 24 
   

 
 

24 MS 1745 Part 14 – Assessment of Needs

BS 5839 – 1; coverage is defined based on clear needs:


Type P – Protection of Properties
P1 – All areas covered with detectors except voids less than
800mm in height
P2 – Defined areas in a building having a high fire risk
Type L – Protection of Life
L1 – Same as P1 (all areas covered with detectors except voids)
L2 – Same as P2 but for areas of high fire risk to life
L3 – Protection of escape route
L4 – Protection of circulation area (2002 edition)
L5 – Fire engineered solution (2002 edition)
Type M – Manual type
continue next page

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

As a comparison, BS5839 (of which most Malaysian practitioners would claim to be proficient – at 
least  going  by  the  mandatory  statutory  declaration  commonly  made),  assessing  needs  is  more 
nuance  and  clear.  This  clarity  is  especially  important  where  insurer’s  needs  have  to  be  clearly 
declared.  Practitioners  should  therefore,  also  consult  BS  5839‐1  in  assessing  the  type  of  coverage 
required.  Appendix  A  appended  with  this  presentation  has  some  recommendations  on  coverage 
based on BS5839 classification.  

Participants  (as  an  exercise)  should  compare  the  recommendations  in  Appendix  A  with  UBBL,  10th 
Schedule. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 25 
   

 
 

25 MS 1745 Part 14 – Assessment of Needs


MS 1745 – Areas not needing cover:
1. Bathrooms, shower rooms, washrooms etc.
2. Vertical shafts/ cable ducts < 2M² (proper fire stopped provided)
3. Unroofed loading bays
4. Unventilated frozen food stores gross volume < 20M³.
MS 1745 – Voids (under floor and above ceiling) need
independent cover by detectors:
1. Likely to be extensive spread of fire or smoke outside room of origin through
void before fire is detected by detectors outside void.
2. Need to protect cables of emergency system
MS 1745 – Voids not requiring coverage:
1. Less than 1m in height.
2. Less than 10M in length
3. Less than 10M in width
4. Totally separated from other areas by incombustible material
5. Do not contain fire load densities in excess of 25MJ combustible material in 1M²
6. Do not contain cables of emergency systems (unless cable are fire resist for
30min.)
Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)
 

Areas which do not required coverage are listed above. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 26 
   

 
 

26 MS 1745 – 14; Planning and Design

Design to 
Minimise False 
Alarm (Annex B)
Devices & Sub 
Systems  Zoning
Compatibility
Compliance 
to MS 1745

Fault  Detectors 
Limitation  Siting
(circuit survivability)

Detectors 
Selection

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

After  defining  the  concept  and  extent  of  coverage  of  the  design,  the  practitioner  is  now  ready  to 
develop  a  detail  design.  The  chart  above  illustrates  the  sub  topics  which  must  be  considered  in 
designing and specifying systems in compliance with MS 1745. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 27 
   

 
 

27 MS1745 – Circuit Survivability


In event of single short or open circuit:
Where devices integrate 1. Not more than 32 devices inoperable.
more than 1 function use 2. All inoperative devices in same zone.
isolating devices within 3. All inoperative devices fulfill same function.
housing to limit single
cable fault. Single cable fault in any circuit cannot prevent
correct operation of:
1.Auto detection of fire
2.Operation of manual call points
3.Sounder
4.Tx/Rx of signals to i/o devices
5.Initiate operation of ancillary equip.
Single cable fault in any circuit cannot prevent
1.Initiation of a fire signal in an area greater
than allowed for a single detection zone;
2.Sounding of a fire signal in an area greater
than allowed for a single detection zone;
3.Operation of all alarm devices within a
building (i.e. at least 1 sounder must operate).

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

A major topic, after having decided on a system concept and extent of coverage, would be designing 
circuit for fault‐limitation. In NFPA 72 (the other major fire standard in the world), “fault‐limitation” 
is caption as “circuit‐survivability” which (in my opinion) is a better concept to capture in designing a 
‘fail‐safe’  system.  MS  1745  –  14;  prescribes  circuit‐survivability  in  the  terms  listed  above.  Thus  an 
audit  to  check  compliance  with  MS  1745  would  require  some  test  to  prove  circuit‐survivability  as 
listed above. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 28 
   

 
 

28 MS1745 – Circuit Survivability


Two faults in any circuit do not prevent the operation of either detectors,
manual call points or alarm devices over floor area exceeding 10,000M² OR
from more than 5 fire compartment whichever is the smaller.
Use max. 2 physical circuit per 10,000M² .
Use max. of 2 physical circuit per 10,000m² “Circuit 
Survivability” 
Physically segregate zones by circuit.
for Dummies!
Physically segregate sounder circuits.

Use ring/loop circuit if circuited across zone


Short circuit isolator recommended for ring circuits
to isolate segment of the ring in case of fault
without affecting the whole ring.
Start and return leg of loop/ring circuit to be
physically laid via separate route.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

A hard‐wired implementation of the performance‐prescription for circuit‐survivability is listed in this 
slide.  The  recommendations  are  just  some  steps  which  can  be  implemented  and  do  not  preclude 
other  steps  which  are  particular  to  addressable  systems.  In  addressable  systems,  devices  are 
typically connected in a ‘daisy‐chain’ in a loop, star or radial configuration. Thus circuit survivability 
(depending on the addressable hardware) will have to be taken into account in such ‘data‐loops’. It 
would  therefore  be  pertinent  for  practitioners  to  check  with  vendors  of  addressable  system  on 
whether and how compliance to MS 1745 can be effected. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 29 
   

 
 

29 MS1745 – Circuit Survivability

Faults should be indicated in panels

Incorrect Wiring Method


X Tee tapping – any disconnection
beyond the tap will make inoperable
devices beyond tap. No trouble
signal will be indicated.

Correct Wiring Method


Supervisory monitoring of open
and short circuit possible.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

MS 1745 (similar to BS 5839‐1) requires that circuit faults should be indicated on monitoring panels. 
In  such  case,  the  designer  and  installer  will  have  to  pay  attention  to  the  type  of  looping  circuit  in 
connecting up devices as illustrated above and following slide. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 30 
   

 
 

30 MS1745 – Circuit Survivability

NFPA 72 : 2002

NFPA72 classifies circuits into ‘CLASS’ and ‘STYLE’

(1) Class A circuits are capable of transmitting an alarm signal


during a single open or a non-simultaneous single ground fault.
(2) Class B circuits are incapable of transmitting an alarm beyond
the location of the fault conditions specified for class A.

Types of circuits are further designated ‘Style’ depending on its


ability to meet alarm and trouble performance during single-open,
single-ground, wire-to-wire short, loss of carrier etc.
Initiating Device Circuit (IDC) – Styles A, B, C, D & E
Notification Appliances Circuit (NAC) – Styles W, A, Y & Z
Signalling Line Circuit (SLC) – Styles 0.5, 1, 2, 3, 3.5, 4, 4.5, 5, 6, 7

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Whilst  MS  1745  and  BS  5839  defined  “circuit‐survivability”  in  general  “performance‐based”  terms, 
NFPA  72  (North  American)  has  detailed  prescription  on  defining  the  class  and  ‘style’  of  circuit  in 
terms of meeting alarm and trouble performance based on single‐open, single‐ground and wire‐to‐
wire short.  

Initiating Devices refer to devices which initiate signals such as detectors, flow switch etc. 

Notification  Appliances  refer  devices  which  receives  signal  and  act  on  the  signal;  e.g.  alarm 
sounders, visual indicators etc. 

Signalling  Line  Circuit  refers  to  circuit  which  transmit  signal  received  from  some  IDC  to  another 
monitoring or supervisory panel, e.g. would be a circuit to a repeater panel. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 31 
   

 
 

31 MS1745 – Circuit Survivability

NFPA 72 : 2002

(1) Class A circuits are capable of Supervision


is accomplished by monitoring the level of
current passing through the circuit and end-
of-line resistor.
(2) The 4-wire loop nature of this circuitry
enables the control panel to ‘condition’ the
looped circuit to single open and single
ground fault. This conditioning ensures that
all devices are capable of responding and
reporting an alarm despite a single-open or
single ground fault.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The above explained the concept of a Class A circuit. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 32 
   

 
 

32 MS1745 – Circuit Survivability

NFPA 72 : 2002

(1) Class B circuits. A single open disables all


devices electrically beyond the ‘open.
(2) Increases or decreases in the low level
supervisory current through the circuit and
end-of-line, provide monitoring signal to the
control panel indicating alarm or fault
conditions.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The above explains the concept behind a Class B circuit. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 33 
   

 
 

33 MS1745 – Circuit Survivability

CORRECT METHOD Corrrect wiring method – 2 wire detectors

Incorrect Method Incorrrect wiring method – 2 wire detectors

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The above illustrates common mistakes in wiring up circuit for Class A need. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 34 
   

 
 

34 MS1745 – Circuit Survivability

4-wire smoke detector employing a 3-wire connecting arrangement.


One side of power supply is connected to one side of initiating device circuit.
Wire run broken at each connection to smoke detector to provide supervision

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

................................................................................................................................................................. 

................................................................................................................................................................. 

................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 35 
   

 
 

35 MS 1745 – 14; Fire Detection Zones

(1) A single zone cannot exceed 1,600m²


(2) If a zone extends beyond a single fire
compartment, the zone boundaries
should be boundaries of fire
compartments and the floor area of the
Fire
zone should not exceed 400m².
Compartment (3) Each zone should be restricted to a
single storey of the building unless
(a) The zone consists of a stairwell,
light well etc. extending beyond one
storey but within one compartment.
(b) the total floor area of building <
300m², the whole building can be
one zone.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Basic prescription on zoning. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 36 
   

 
 

36 MS 1745 – 14; Fire Detection Zone

(1) Fire compartments 1 & 2 can be


designed as 1 detection zone
provided total area of
compartments 1 & 2 < 400m²
(2) Total floor area of any one zone
cannot exceed 1,600m².

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 37 
   

 
 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

37 MS 1745 – 14; Fire Detection Zone

Zone with more than 5 rooms:


(1)Indication of rooms should be
included in control/indicating panel,
OR
(2)Remote indicator lamps installed
outside each door to indicate room
in which detector has operated.

H Heat Detector
Alarm indicator lamp

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 38 
   

 
 

38 MS 1745 – 14; Initiating Devices

Heat Detectors Flame Detectors Smoke Detectors

1 Fixed temp
Fusible element 1 UV 
Continuous
2 IR 
Bimetal
3 UV/IR
2 Rate‐of‐Rise
line 1 ionisation 
spot 2 Optical
3 Rate Compensation Manual Switch 3 Beam
line
spot
4 Combination
5 Electronic Spot‐
Thermal

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The types of detectors are classified into the types above. In terms of sensitivity smoke detectors are 
more sensitive than heat detectors. Spot type heat detectors are the most common, whilst line heat‐
detectors are used in special application. Smoke detectors comprise of 2 main types (ionisation and 
optical).  Optical  smoke  detectors  comprise  of  2  types:  the  photoelectric  detector  and  the  beam 
detectors.  The  following  slide  illustrates  the  applications  of  line  (or  linear  detectors  and  beam 
detectors). 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 39 
   

 
 

39 MS 1745 – 14; Initiating Devices

Cable racks in service tunnels

Conveyors carrying coal dust.

Linear Heat Detectors

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The  above  illustrates  deployment  of  linear  heat  detectors  in  special  risk  applications  (cable  rack, 
conveyors carrying hazardous material etc.). 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 40 
   

 
 

40 MS 1745 – 14; Initiating Devices

Beam Smoke Detectors

Pre-stratified (variable based on


outside temperature)

Variable stratification due to the fire

Beam smoke detector


BEAM should be at height of
plume’s max. diameter.

optical line of sight

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Beam detectors detect smoke by measuring the obscuring of a light beam due to smoke. The above 
illustrates application of beam smoke detectors in a high ceiling application. 

Other specialised detectors are flame detectors which has two primary technology of infra‐red (IR) 
or  UV  light  detection.  Flame  detectors  are  useful  in  specialised  application  and  the  nature  of  the 
flame will have to be confirmed depending on the type of flammable material. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 41 
   

 
 

41 MS 1745 – 14; Siting and Spacing of Detectors

Limit of ceiling
Limit of ceiling
height for heat
height for smoke
detectors
detectors

CEILING HEIGHT (M)


Detector Types < 4.5 > 4.5 < 6 >6<8 > 8 < 11 > 8 < 25 > 25
Heat, Part 5 Grade 1 5 5 5 NN NS NS
Smoke, point, Part 7 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 NN NS
Beam Part 12 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5(a) NN NS
NS = Not suitable for use in range of heights
NN = Not normally used in the range, but may be used in special applications.
(a) A second layer of detectors will usually be necessary at about ½ ceiling height.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Prescription  on  ceiling  height  and  radius  of  coverage  given  is  ONLY  a  guide.  In  actual  practice  the 
practitioner will have to consult manufacturer’s guide on radius of coverage (after confirming with 
suitable conformance certification on validity of manufacturer’s claims. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 42 
   

 
 

42 MS 1745 – 14; Siting and Spacing of Detectors

Pitch / Sloping Roof

(1) A/H < 5% ; Standard Spacing

(2) Pitch > 1° ; Detector spacing


H to be increased by 1% for
each 1° of pitch up to a max.
increase of 25%.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

In  case  of  pitch  roof,  any  pitch  roof  with  depth  to  room  height  ratio  of  less  than  5%  can  be 
considered  a  “smooth”  ceiling  in  which  case  the  standard  spacing  table  applies.  However  if  the 
aforesaid  A/H  ratio  exceeds  5%  then  the  recommended  detector  spacing  is  increased  by  1%  for 
every 1° increase in pitch up to a maximum of 25%. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 43 
   

 
 

43 MS 1745 – 14; Siting and Spacing of Detectors

Ceiling irregularities Ceiling beams in cell-like


arrangement, the internal volume
(1) h/H < 5% ; Standard Spacing
of the cells covered by a single
(2) D > 0.25 x (H-h) Æ detector in every cell detector should not exceed:
(3) D < 0.25 x (H-h) Æ detector in every second cell (1)Heat: V = 6m² x ( H – h )
(4) D < 0.13 x (H-h) Æ detector in every third cell (2)Smoke: V = 12m² x ( H – h )

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Where beam depth is an issue, guidelines for moderating detector spacing are listed above. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 44 
   

 
 

44 MS 1745 – 14; Siting and Spacing of Detectors

False Ceiling and Floors Detectors sited above ceiling if


risk of fire starting above
ceiling and all conditions :
1.Ceiling perforation > 40% of
any 1m x 1m section of ceiling;
2.Each individual perforation
>10mm x 10mm
3.Thickness of ceiling > 3 X
min. dimensions of
perforation.

Detectors NOT required:


1.False floor is perforated; OR
2.False floor is fire rated class A11, A21 or 81 AND no fire load beneath
(e.g. cables).

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

In case of false floors and ceiling recommendations on coverage are included. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 45 
   

 
 

45 MS 1745 – 14; Siting and Spacing of Detectors

Atria (high level Detectors installed in


without ceiling)
absence of ceiling:
Rising
Plume 1.Place detectors in path
of rising plume.

Floors Section
2.Use beam detectors.
3.Effective operating
Hf radius = 12.5% Hf

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

In case were detectors are installed where ceiling are not present, the effective operating radius of 
detectors are reduced. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 46 
   

 
 

46 MS 1745 – 14; Siting and Spacing of Detectors

Detectors installed more than 500mm from any walls or obstruction.


Top of partition less than 300mm is considered to be a full height wall.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Detectors  should  not  be  sited  500mm  from  walls  or  obstruction.  Obstruction  include  beams  and 
partitions which are not more than 300 from ceiling. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 47 
   

 
 

47 MS 1745 – 14; Siting and Spacing of Detectors

Supply Air Inlet > 1m/s


> 1M

Aspirated detectors where


air speed may be high or
varying widely.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Detectors  should  not  be  sited  in  front  of  fresh  air  inlet  or  exhaust  and  where  (air  conditioning) 
supply air inlet has air velocity more than 1 m/s, it should be at least 1m away. In cases where high 
air velocity is a concern, aspirated type smoke detection system may be proposed. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 48 
   

 
 

48 MS 1745 – 14; Manual Break Glass

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Manual break glass should generally be sited along escape route. The standard recommends that a 
person escaping from a fire should not travel more than 30m to access a manual pull switch. Manual 
pull  switch  should  be  located  as  far  as  possible  near  exit  stair  case.  Common  mistakes  are  siting 
manual pull switch at dead‐ends and away from escape route. In such a case, a person will have to 
deviate from the escape route to access the switch which presents a danger to the escapee. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 49 
   

 
 

49 MS 1745 – 14; Alarm

> 65dBA OR
5dBA above ambient
Fire Door Normal Door <120dBA
– 30dBA – 20dBA

> 75dBA; <120dBA

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Recommendations on sound level is listed as 65 dB(A) OR 5dB(A) above general ambient sound level 
(whichever is the higher). In case where occupant is asleep (hotel rooms), sound levels should be 75 
dB(A).  Generally  a  fire  door  will  contribute  to  about  30dB(A)  reduction  whilst  a  normal  door  will 
contribute to about 30dB(A) reduction in sound level. The maximum sound level must however NOT 
exceed 120dB(A). Thus the designer will have to place a number of lower dBA sounders rather than 
one high dBA sounder to comply with this requirement. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 50 
   

 
 

50 MS 1745 – 14; Alarm

65dBA OR
5dBA above ambient
Sounders
1.At least 2 sounders in a
building.
2.At least 1 sounder in each fire
compartment.
3.Max level < 120dBA
4.Freq. 500Hz – 2kHz
5.Sound should be distinct (not
to be confused with other alarm
e.g. lunch)
6.Sound to be continuous.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

A  guide  on  sound  attenuation  with  distance  is  shown  in  the  graph  above.  Other  prescription  on 
sounders are also listed above. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 51 
   

 
 

51 Power Supplies

Primary supply
Æ Isolator/ switch fuse to be dedicated
Æ RCD as far as possible not to be used.
Æ Switching of system due to maintenance, energy savings etc should not
affect supply.
Types Æ Normal supply & Standby Supply
Batteries capacity Æ 72 hours normal quiescent condition & 30min. alarm.
Battery capacity with guaranteed downtime less than 24 hours. If system is
locally or remotely supervised and/or a maintenance contract is in force
guaranteeing max. downtime of less than 24 hrs, then battery capacity can
be reduced to 30 hours operating and 30 min. alarm.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Prescription on the standby capacities of batteries are listed above. Note the reduction in capacity 
allowed where supervised maintenance contract or local maintenance (competent) is available, the 
key term is a guaranteed down time of less than 24 hours in case of supply failure. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 52 
   

 
 

52 MS 1745 – 14; System control

Fire extinguishing system


Smoke or fire doors
Smoke venting equipment
Smoke or fire dampers
Ventilation shut down
Lift control
Security doors

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

A  typical  alarm  system,  in  most  case  will  also  be  used  to  actuate  other  emergency  or  essential 
services (list above). 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 53 
   

 
 

53 MS 1745 – 14; Cables and interconnection

Cables run in
areas which are
NOT fire
protected
should be fire
resistant OR
protected
against fire.

3 Class of Circuits.
ID = Initiating Devices
ND = Notification Devices
Signal Circuits

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

MS 1745 – 14 contains clear prescription on the use of fire rated cables for automated fire detection 
and  alarm  system.  The  next  few  slides  will  show  the  context  and  prescription  on  cables  and  inter 
connections. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 54 
   

 
 

54 MS 1745 – 14; Cables and interconnection

Fault in Zone 2 Fault in F.C 1 may


may affect alarm affect alarm signal
signal in Zone 3 in FC2 (cables fire
(cables fire rated rated or protected
or protected for at for at least 30 min.)
least 30 min.)

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

In the two cases presented above, “fault‐limitations’ require the use of fire‐resistant cables. In these 
case, fire resistant is only limited to 30 minutes. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 55 
   

 
 

55 MS 1745 – 14; Cables and interconnection

BS 60331 – Fire Tests

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Common  misconception  in  the  market  is  the  specification  of  fire  rated  cables.  Fire  rated  cables 
under IEC 60331 requires that the cable should be able to operate for a certain period (say about 30 
minutes)  after  exposure  to  fire.  Many  cables  marketed  as  “fire  rated”  are  merely  “fire‐retardant”, 
i.e. it will not contribute to the spread or addition to the fire (or it will significantly present itself as a 
low fire load). Such cables are cables under IEC 60332‐3. However fire rating under the context of 
MS 1745 requires that cables must be able to operate for at least 30 minutes on being exposed to 
“fire‐fighting”  conditions.  The  above  and  following  slides  explain  the  concept  and  specifications 
behind specifying fire rating of cables.  

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 56 
   

 
 

56 MS 1745 – 14; Fire Rated Cables

BS 60332-3

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

IEC  60331  test  a  cable  for  its  fire  resistant  properties  (i.e.  ability  to  continue  operation  during  fire 
condition) as oppose to IEC 60332‐3 which examines flame propagation property of cables. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 57 
   

 
 

57 MS 1745 – 14; Fire Rated Cables

BS5839-1

2002 edition major change to requirement for fire rated cables.

All cables to be fire


rated. The category of
fire rating depends on
the application.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

BS  5839  categorise  fire  rating  of  cables  in  terms  of  its  application.  The  left‐most  two  standards 
specify cables for fire detection and alarm applications. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 58 
   

 
 

58 MS 1745-14; Fire Rated Cables

BS5839-1

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The  minimum  standard  of  fire  rating  permitted  under  MS1745  would  be  Category  W  cables  (fire 
fighting condition). 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 59 
   

 
 

59 MS 1745 – 14; Fire Rated Cables

BS5839-1

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

A more correct specification of cables under BS 5839‐1 (and by extension the MS 1745‐14) would be 
cables rated as PH30 standard grade cables at 830°C instead of 650°C under BS6387 Cat W cables. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 60 
   

 
 

60 MS 1745 – 14; Cables Protection

Fire rated cables with Normal PVC cables (300V)


mica sheath as fire barrier.

Protection against mechanical damage

Conduit Wiring
Metal Trunking G.I. – Class B certified to IEC 60614-1 & 2
uPVC be high impact class B, certified to IEC60614
If uPVC embedded in concrete they should be class C
Fire rated cables should be laid on trays and in case
where they are exposed (at low level) shall be
mechanically protected (conduit or trunking).

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Cables  are  required  to  be  protected  against  mechanical  damage.  This  normally  means  the  use  of 
metal trunking or conduit. The use of conduit however is the most contentious as many installation 
consider the use of PVC conduit without a proper check on its specification and certification. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 61 
   

 
 

61 MS 1745 – 14; Cables Protection


Some Common Defects
1. PVC conduit system are
substandard and are NOT
certified to electrical grade.
2. PVC conduit and/or cables
laid in condition where
continuous sunlight occurs
(PVC will deteriorate in the
presence of UV light).

3. Conduit embedded in concrete are of the wrong grade (conduit not properly graded
will crack when laid in concrete).
4. No proper junction boxes and/or terminal boxes.
5. Trunking and/or conduit ‘overloaded’.
6. Splicing/jointing of cables without proper terminal box.

No proper evaluation on fire-


rating of cables in complying PVC products should NOT be
with circuit-survivability! installed exposed to sunlight.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Some  common  mistakes  in  cable  laying  are  listed  above.  The  most  serious  is  the  used  of  sub 
standard  conduit  (including  GI  conduit  which  are  not  properly  certified).  A  proper  check  of  SIRIM 
certification  reveals  that  many  G.I.  conduit  system  may  not  even  be  of  the  correct  gauge  (class  B, 
medium grade and in case of embedding in concrete should be at least class C, heavy grade). 

It  is  even  more  pertinent  to  note  that  many  fire  alarm  cabling  systems  may  NOT  be  properly 
specified for fire rating where the standards require such rating.  

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 62 
   

 
 

62 MS 1745 – 14; Protection against EM disturbance


Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC)

EMC – DEFINITION
THE ABILITY OF A DEVICE, EQUIPMENT OR SYSTEM TO
FUNCTION SATISFACTORILY IN ITS ELECTROMAGNETIC
ENVIRONMENT WITHOUT INTRODUCING INTOLERABLE
DISTURBANCES TO THAT ENVIRONMENT OR TO OTHER
EQUIPMENT

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

With  the  proliferation  of  addressable  type  fire  alarm,  the  impact  of  electromagnetic  (EM) 
disturbances on sensitive electronic equipment which comprise part of the (supposedly) “fail‐safe” 
nature  of  automatic  detection  and  alarm  system  pose  a  serious  threat  to  its  integrity.  Though  MS 
1745  is  sparse  on  prescriptive  measure  on  protection  against  EM  disturbances,  it  should  be 
emphasised  that  failure  due  to  EM  disturbances  is  a  major  consideration  which  installers  of 
addressable system CANNOT ignore. 

A  starting  point  for  planning  for  EM  protection  is  to  gauge  the  “immunity‐level”  or  “susceptibility‐
level” of sensitive equipment, and the source and level of EM emission at the vicinity or connectivity 
(in EMC terminology it would be termed “EM‐coupling”) to sensitive equipment. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 63 
   

 
 

63 MS 1745 – 14; Protection against EM disturbance


1 Other power cables too near
Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) (especially motor and
capacitor switching)
Protect sensitive equipment against 2 Other hi-freq, control cables
EM disturbances too near.
3 Signal cables laid near roof
eaves (or at high level in
building) susceptible to
atmospheric EM disturbance.
4 Cables laid externally
(overhead or u/ground)
susceptible to atmospheric
EM disturbances.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The above attempts to summarise briefly the steps which can be taken to protect equipment against 
EM  disturbances.  Common  remedy  is  the  installation  of  (power‐grade  and/or  data‐grade)  surge 
protection  devices  (SPD).  Depending  on  the  nature  of  the  ground,  underground  cables  (especially 
hilly rocky ground) is as susceptible to atmospheric EM disturbances as overhead cables. A common 
over‐looked source of EM disturbance would be sensing cables laid at high level along timber roof 
eaves or roof eaves which are not suitably shielded against atmospheric EM radiation. 

Other  EM  treatments  include  proper  shielding  and  ground  for  sensitive  equipment.  An  expert  on 
EMC should be consulted for proper recommendations on EMC. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 64 
   

 
 

64 MS 1745 – 14; Installation & Work Acceptance

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The above is a template for approval and work acceptance procedure. A most basic check will start 
with  material  and  components  acceptance.  This  entails  an  examination  of  SIRIM  certification  to 
check that the right grade and type of components, materials and product are used. In third party 
certification  (such  as  Factory  Mutual)  this  step  would  be  a  pre‐requisite,  as  a  compilation  of 
conformance certification for products, materials and components used in the installation will need 
to be filed as record.  

The request for Method Statements is also, currently, a common project management tool. However 
a proper understanding of the design‐intent, specification and installation procedure IS NECESSARY 
before  method  statement  should  be  requested.  Method  statement  should  be  specific  and  NOT 
general in nature, i.e. the project manager must state specifically the type and procedure requested 
for Method Statement. Current practice of requesting for Method Statement in very general terms 
usually  result  in  Contractors  generating  “Method  Statement”  which  are  just  copies  of  the 
specifications. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 65 
   

 
 

65 MS 1745 – 14; Installation & Work Acceptance

Check that ALL penetration through fire stop/walls are fire-sealed.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Finally the responsible engineer (whether consultant or contractor) must check that proper fire seals 
are installed in ALL penetration of cables, conduit and pipes through fire partitions and floor slabs. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 66 
   

 
 

66 MS 1745 – 14; Commissioning & Verification

Check Conformance Understanding specifications


Understanding certifications
Certification

Check List During Method Statement if


Construction required must be specific in
nature

Pre-Delivery
Can be 1st party, Inspection
2nd party or 3rd
party inspection.
Tests During
Installation

Tests for buried/ Acceptance Tests


covered works.
1. Performance
2. Functional

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

The above is a template for ensuring final work acceptance. It should be noted that work acceptance 
do  not  only  entails  accepting  final  commissioning  reports  on  completion.  It  should  include 
compilation of material acceptance, record of installation checks from project inception, through to 
QC/QA checks during installation and final commissioning on completion. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 67 
   

 
 

67 MS 1745 – 14; Installation & Work Acceptance

F ire S erv ice s A c t


T ec hn ica l UBBL
S P EC IF Y IN G
S ta nd a rd s E N G IN EE R S
F ire Se rvic es
R e gulat io n s

P RO DUCT IN S PE C T IO N &
C E R T IFIC A T IO N E NFO RCE ME NT

C E R T IF IED
SA F E IN S T A L L A T ION

Fig ur e 1 – A M ode l for S ys te m Ce r tifi ca tion

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

A  model  for  system  certification  originally  drafted  in  2001  (for  the  electrical  safety  industry)  and 
currently adopted in MS 1979 can be paraphrased for the fire fighting industry. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 68 
   

 
 

68 MS 1745 – 14; Installation & Work Acceptance

Verification by Independent Party

1st PARTY – Self Test (e.g. routine factory QC tests).


First-party testing is a large sector. It is for example used as an internal
quality control measure that the products, materials, items and services
are up the requirements expressed in legislation, standards, technical
specifications and contracts with the clients. The manufacturers
declaration of conformity expressed by different ways of marking the
product is often based also on the outcome of these tests.

2nd PARTY – Test by buyers or consumers (e.g. factory test or


witness test by buyers).
Second-party testing is performed by the receiver of the products,
materials, items and services mainly in order to ensure that agreed
requirements and specifications are fulfilled. For ordinary consumers,
testing can be performed by consumer interest organisations or buyer
organisations of products.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

An explanation on the type of inspection testing is described above (first party and 2nd party tests). 
Understanding  the  framework  on  which  acceptance‐tests  are  conducted  is  essential  for  the 
approving  engineer.  First  party  tests  (self‐test  by  vendor/manufacturer)  would  be  the  first  line  of 
defence  of  the  approving  engineer.  Demanding  1st  party  certificate  is  akin  to  requesting  for  a 
product  “birth‐certificate”.  This  ensures  that  a  product  is  from  where  it  claims  to  be  (i.e.  genuine 
product). 2nd party witness tests are usually only requested for large assembled equipment. In some 
case, where witness test is in a foreign country, the client can engage a third party inspector (who is 
expected to be “independent”) to witness test on his behalf. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 69 
   

 
 

69 MS 1745 – 14; Installation & Work Acceptance

Verification by Independent Party

3rd PARTY – Test by independent inspectors (e.g. certification by


SIRIM, Factory Mutual).
Third-party testing is especially required, preferred or used if the results
have a considerable influence or effect on public or societal issues, in
particular related to health, environment, safety and large economic
values. It is also applied when taking measures to eliminate the
possibility of cheating and misconduct or when crucial risks and
consequences of wrong or manipulated results exist. Third-party testing
is expected to provide a nonbiased view and thus a better confidence in
the test results.

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Third party certification (such as Factory Mutual) is an important certification body for multinational 
corporation. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 70 
   

 
 

70 MS 1745 – 14; Installation & Work Acceptance

Model Certificates – Annex C

Certificate of
Design

Certificate of
Installation

Certificate of
Commission
& Verification

Certificate of
Acceptance

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Annex C in the Standard includes model certificates which can be used by practitioners to design a 
documented procedure for works acceptance. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 71 
   

 
 

71 MS 1745 – 14; Maintenance / Operation.

Alarm /
Emergency
Response
Plan Persons /
Preventive Organisations
Maintenance Responsible
Check List
Fire Drill
Routine &
Semi-Routine
Check List
Annex A

Maintenance
Manual &
Record of
As-Built

Extension/
Modifications/
Repair
Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)
 

In  the  compilation  of  completion  documentations  for  handing  over  to  the  operator  or  client,  the 
above  template  lists  the  important  parts  of  the  documents  which  should  be  included.  Current 
handing over documentations merely compiles a catalogue of equipment and components without 
any  operating  procedure  or  maintenance  check  list  procedure  for  each  components  and  system. 
Annex A has an excellent model form for check‐list for maintenance use. 

Other work procedure by the operator would be the conduct of occupants’ training (usually fire drill) 
and a documented procedure to ensure that extension and modification works do not compromise 
the integrity of existing fire systems. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 72 
   

 
 

72 MS 1745 – 14; Applications in Special Risk

Effects of high ventilation rate and air speed


Fire detection in concealed space, u/floor etc.
Local cover of cabinets required.
Closing of fire dampers in response to alarm signals
Consider aspirating systems
Electronic data processing
areas / electrical risks

Confirm content of storage


Consult with insurers

Detection linked wit auto extinguishing


systems.
Detection layer at rack to prevent spread of fire.

High Rack warehouse

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

A final section of MS 1745‐14 include a discussions on special risk which is listed above. Insurers are 
especially concerned with warehouses and data‐processing centres. Thus consultation with insurers 
are essential for ascertaining the acceptability of systems and grade of components used. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 73 
   

 
 

73 MS 1745 – 14; Applications in Special Risk

Smoke Control
Fire detection at atrium
Fire compartmentation
Smoke Control with detection
and auto fire suppression
High Atrium Building

Confirm nature and type of storage


Consult Hazmat legislation
ER Plan for hazmat

Detection and fire suppression systems


Linked to ER plan for hazmat.

High Hazard Area

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

In  ascertaining  the  fire  protection  needs  of  high  hazard  areas,  other  legislation  may  be  consulted 
such as the “Petroleum Safety Measures Act (for oil depots)”, “The Gas Supply Act” (Gas storage at 
retail‐end). “Environmental Quality Act” (schedule waste, hazmat handling). 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 74 
   

 
 

74 MS 1745 – 14; Applications in Special Risk

Confirm nature of fire hazard,


Check environmental conditions
Choice and siting of detectors

Detection and fire suppression systems suited


for environment and hazard class (e.g. mist
suppression system, foam system etc.) linked
to detection system.
Outdoor Areas
E.g. tank farm, conveyors

hplooi@streamyx.com
http://hplooi.blogspot.com

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)


 

Oil  tank,  coal  conveyors,  recycled  tyre  depot/storage  yard  are  just  some  of  the  outdoor  risk  areas 
which  demands  special  consideration  for  automatic  fire  detection  and  alarm.  In  most  case,  an 
understanding  of  the  risk,  type  of  fire  which  will  be  generated  and  the  fire  hazard  involve  will  be 
necessary before any solution can be proposed. For example: 

(1) Tank  farm  fire  is  usually  fought  from  a  policy  of  containment,  i.e.  prevent  the  fire  from 
spreading. Once a fire starts it will be difficult to extinguish the fire. A response plan will 
require sufficient amount of water just to contain the fire (containment dikes are usually 
included  in  tank  farm  design)  and  prevent  temperatures  from  reaching  excessively  high 
levels. 
(2) Waste tyre storage yard (typically outdoor) requires attention to fire containment. Once a 
fire  starts,  it  would  be  difficult  to  extinguish  fires  from  mounds  of  tyre  waste.  A  more 
serious implication would be smouldering fire from tyre waste which would pose air quality 
hazard to the surrounding area. Again containment is an essential first step in design Fire 
suppression agent include special chemical agent for the suppression of fires from rubber 
waste. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for 
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance  P a g e  | 75 
   

 
 

6th October 2009


Eastin Hotel. Petaling Jaya

MS 1745 – FIRE DETECTION AND ALARM SYSTEM


hplooi@streamyx.com
http://hplooi.blogspot.com

Ir. H.P. Looi, (6TH October 2009)


 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

.................................................................................................................................................................. 

  hplooi@streamyx.com  6th October 2009 
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 76

APPENDIX A –Types of Fire Alarm System, BS5839-1:2002


(Typical Application based on fire needs of premises)

Assessment of Needs Based on BS 5839 – 1 : 2002

Lower Higher
Type of Premises Comments
Risk End Risk End
M normally meets legal requirements.
Most places of work, offices, shops,
M or P/2M P1/M Detection added to meet insurers and business
warehouse, factories, restaurants
interruption risk.
In sleeping areas L3 is the base
Hotels and Hostels L2 L1 recommendation level. In practice this
becomes at least L2.
Pubs with no residential accommodation M.
Pubs M L2
Pubs with residential accommodation L3/L2.
Normally based on fire risk assessment
Schools M M/P2/L4 particularly arson risk. Detection also often
added if in partial use for community activities.
Hospitals L1 L1 Minor variations as per HTM1982
Accommodation under 300 normally M. Larger
Places of assembly, eg entertainment M L1 premises L4 to L1. Large premises are usually
L1.
Transportation terminals M/L5 M/L5 -
Covered shopping centres L3 L1 -
Residential care homes L3 L1 L1 for large premises
Prisons M L5 -
Phased evacuation buildings L3 L3 -
Extra risk to life posed by such things as inner
Buildings with means of escape
M/L5 M/L4 rooms, unoccupied spaces, cross building
difficulties
risks, use of automatic door holders etc.
Insurer requirements M/P2 M/P1 -

END OF APPENDIX A

© Copyright; All rights reserved


Ir. H.P. Looi (hplooi@mektricon.com)
(October 2009)
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 77

B2-1/3
APPENDIX B – Circuit Class and Style, NFPA72 : 2002

Table B1 – Performance of Initiating Devices Circuits (IDC)

Class B B B A A
Style A B C D Eα

Alarm receipt capability

Alarm receipt capability

Alarm receipt capability

Alarm receipt capability

Alarm receipt capability


during abnormal conditions

during abnormal conditions

during abnormal conditions

during abnormal conditions

during abnormal conditions


Trouble

Trouble

Trouble

Trouble

Trouble
Alarm

Alarm

Alarm

Alarm

Alarm
Abnormal condition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15

Single open – X – – X – – X – – X X – X X
Single ground – X – – X R – X R – X R – X R
Wire-to-wire short X – – X – – – X – X – – – X –
Loss of carrier (if used)/
– – – – – – – X – – – – – X –
Channel interface
R = Required capacity
X = Indication required at protected premises and as required in Chapter 5
α = Style exceeds minimum requirements of Class A

© Copyright; All rights reserved


Ir. H.P. Looi (hplooi@mektricon.com)
(October 2009)
B2-2/3
Table B2 – Performance of Signaling Line Circuits (SLC)

© Copyright; All rights reserved


Ir. H.P. Looi (hplooi@mektricon.com)
(October 2009)
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 79

B2-1/3

Table B3 – Notification Appliance Circuits (NAC)

Class B B B A
Style W X Y Z

Trouble indication at protected

Trouble indication at protected

Trouble indication at protected

Trouble indication at protected


Alarm capability during

Alarm capability during

Alarm capability during

Alarm capability during


abnormal conditions

abnormal conditions

abnormal conditions

abnormal conditions
premises

premises

premises

premises
Abnormal condition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Single open X – X X X – X X
Single ground X – X – X X X X
Wire-to-wire short X – X – X – X –
X = Indication required at protected premises and as required in Chapter 5

END OF APPENDIX B

© Copyright; All rights reserved


Ir. H.P. Looi (hplooi@mektricon.com)
(October 2009)
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 76

APPENDIX A –Types of Fire Alarm System, BS5839-1:2002


(Typical Application based on fire needs of premises)

Assessment of Needs Based on BS 5839 – 1 : 2002

Lower Higher
Type of Premises Comments
Risk End Risk End
M normally meets legal requirements.
Most places of work, offices, shops,
M or P/2M P1/M Detection added to meet insurers and business
warehouse, factories, restaurants
interruption risk.
In sleeping areas L3 is the base
Hotels and Hostels L2 L1 recommendation level. In practice this
becomes at least L2.
Pubs with no residential accommodation M.
Pubs M L2
Pubs with residential accommodation L3/L2.
Normally based on fire risk assessment
Schools M M/P2/L4 particularly arson risk. Detection also often
added if in partial use for community activities.
Hospitals L1 L1 Minor variations as per HTM1982
Accommodation under 300 normally M. Larger
Places of assembly, eg entertainment M L1 premises L4 to L1. Large premises are usually
L1.
Transportation terminals M/L5 M/L5 -
Covered shopping centres L3 L1 -
Residential care homes L3 L1 L1 for large premises
Prisons M L5 -
Phased evacuation buildings L3 L3 -
Extra risk to life posed by such things as inner
Buildings with means of escape
M/L5 M/L4 rooms, unoccupied spaces, cross building
difficulties
risks, use of automatic door holders etc.
Insurer requirements M/P2 M/P1 -

END OF APPENDIX A

© Copyright; All rights reserved


Ir. H.P. Looi (hplooi@mektricon.com)
(October 2009)
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 77

B2-1/3
APPENDIX B – Circuit Class and Style, NFPA72 : 2002

Table B1 – Performance of Initiating Devices Circuits (IDC)

Class B B B A A
Style A B C D Eα

Alarm receipt capability

Alarm receipt capability

Alarm receipt capability

Alarm receipt capability

Alarm receipt capability


during abnormal conditions

during abnormal conditions

during abnormal conditions

during abnormal conditions

during abnormal conditions


Trouble

Trouble

Trouble

Trouble

Trouble
Alarm

Alarm

Alarm

Alarm

Alarm
Abnormal condition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15

Single open – X – – X – – X – – X X – X X
Single ground – X – – X R – X R – X R – X R
Wire-to-wire short X – – X – – – X – X – – – X –
Loss of carrier (if used)/
– – – – – – – X – – – – – X –
Channel interface
R = Required capacity
X = Indication required at protected premises and as required in Chapter 5
α = Style exceeds minimum requirements of Class A

© Copyright; All rights reserved


Ir. H.P. Looi (hplooi@mektricon.com)
(October 2009)
B2-2/3
Table B2 – Performance of Signaling Line Circuits (SLC)

© Copyright; All rights reserved


Ir. H.P. Looi (hplooi@mektricon.com)
(October 2009)
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 79

B2-1/3

Table B3 – Notification Appliance Circuits (NAC)

Class B B B A
Style W X Y Z

Trouble indication at protected

Trouble indication at protected

Trouble indication at protected

Trouble indication at protected


Alarm capability during

Alarm capability during

Alarm capability during

Alarm capability during


abnormal conditions

abnormal conditions

abnormal conditions

abnormal conditions
premises

premises

premises

premises
Abnormal condition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Single open X – X X X – X X
Single ground X – X – X X X X
Wire-to-wire short X – X – X – X –
X = Indication required at protected premises and as required in Chapter 5

END OF APPENDIX B

© Copyright; All rights reserved


Ir. H.P. Looi (hplooi@mektricon.com)
(October 2009)

You might also like