Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 1
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 2
2 Abstract
This presentation summarises the prescription on design practice for fire detection and alarm
system contained in MS 1745 Part 14. A comparative description of some key prescriptions of BS
5839‐1 which mirrors those in MS 1745 – 14 are also included. The introductory missive on
professional liabilities shows that proficiency in technical standards is a statutory requirement for
engineers submitting plans under the ‘Street, Drainage and Building Act’.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 3
3 CONTENTS
Introduction; Submitting Engineer’s Responsibilities
Overview & Structure of MS1745
Introduction, Scope, General; Design Flow
Assessing Needs, Planning Design
Circuit Survivability
Detection Zones
Initiating Devices; Siting & Spacing of Detectors, Manual
Break Glass, Alam
Detection Zones
Power Supplies; Cables & Interconnections, Fire Rated
Cables; EMC
Installation, Work Acceptance, Maintenance, Operation
Applications in Special Risk
The content flow mirrors the content of MS1745 – 14.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 4
From the above, we note that Civil Law is the most important legal requirement regulating the
conduct and practice of engineering. The Civil Law Act is applicable in all countries (including
countries with Socialist Justice System which would have a form of Civil Law). Thus it would be
pertinent to note that the professional engineer will be regulated by Civil Law even in countries
which do not have any form of registering professional engineers.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 5
Under principles of Civil Law, even an unregistered engineer will be held liable for negligence once
professional engineering services are offered. Fire fighting contractors who provide services (in the
absence of any professional engineer) will therefore be held responsible in the event of negligence
and damage caused to the public.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 6
Preamble
An Act to amend and consolidate the laws relating to street,
drainage and building in local authority areas in West
Malaysia, and for purposes connected therewith.
Under the ‘Street, Drainage and Building Act’ all buildings and structures are regulated by the local
authorities. Thus permission must be sought before any building or structure can be erected.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 7
The ‘Street, Drainage and Building Act’ very clearly requires that only registered Architect and/or
Engineers are allowed to submit plans to local authority.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 8
MS 1745 : Part 14
The above lists typical statutory declarations which the Engineer will have to make in the submission
of plans. Two conclusions can be drawn from the above:
(1) The submitting engineer must be proficient in the technical standards of which he signs off
his design. This includes proficiency in the Uniform Building By‐Law. A corollary to the
aforesaid would be that engineers are also required (under principles of Civil Law or Tort
Laws) to maintain his expertise; meaning that he must keep his knowledge abreast of
‘current’ practice (including updates to technical standards).
(2) Listing of technical standards must be updated to take into account latest revision and
updates to standards applicable in statutory declarations.
The ‘Standards of Malaysia Act 1996 (Act 549) prescribes that Malaysia Standard has primacy over
other international recognised standards.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 9
Certification of
Completion and
Compliance
Certification of Completion and Compliance (C.C.C.) which came into force on April 2007, places the
primary responsibility for issuance of building O.C.F. (Occupation Certificate of Fitness) on the
submitting person (the registered architect and/or engineer). It should also be noted (form G8) that
the accountability of the contractor responsible will be a growing topic of national discussions.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 10
10 Overview of MS 1745
Part 1 – Introduction
Part 2 – Control and Indicating Equipment
Part 3 – Audible Fire Alarm Devices
Part 4 – Power Supply Equipment
Part 5 – Heat Detectors – Point detectors
Part 7 – Smoke detectors – point detectors using scattered light,
transmitted light or ionisation
Part 10 – Flame Detectors – Point detectors
Part 11 – Manual Call Points
Part 12 – Smoke Detectors – Line detectors using an optical light beam.
Part 13 – Compatibility Assessment of Systems Components,
Part 14 – Guidelines for Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use
and Maintenance
Part 15 – Multisensor Fire Detectors
The complete series of MS1745 is listed above. It should be noted that this presentation will focus on
Part 14 as the rest of the standards are product standards. Understanding technical standards
requires a basic idea on types of standards:
(1) Basic Standards – are general standards dealing with topics used by other standards; e.g.
terminology, testing techniques, definition of hazard class etc.
(2) Product Standards – deals with specifying the product itself and can be sub‐divided into 3
sub class:
(a) Material Standards; quality of PVC, ferrous metal used in pipes etc.
(b) Component Standards; valve, proximity switch, hydrants, detectors, meters etc.
(c) Assembly Standards; built‐up unit from components, e.g. alarm panels which is an
assembly of components such as fuses, control modules etc.
(3) Installation Standards – are general standards dealing with integration of various
components, assemblies and equipment for a specific application. Part 14 of the MS 1745
series would be an installation standard.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 11
11 Overview of MS 1745
It can be noted that part 6 and 8 have been withdrawn. MS1745 do not include part 6, 8 and 9.
Beyond part 13 however, MS1745 diverge from EN 54.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 12
12 Overview of MS 1745
The rest of EN 54 series is listed above. Thus practitioners requiring standards on components not
listed under MS may refer to the standards listed above.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 13
13 Overview of MS 1745
BS 5839 is the standard which most practitioners follow in this country. A listing of the BS 5839
series is shown above.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 14
14 Overview of MS 1745
Listing of BS 5839 series.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 15
MS 1745 Part 14 Fire Detection and Alarm Systems for Buildings, Guidelines
for planning, design, installation, commissioning, use and maintenance
0 – Introduction
1 – Scope Annex A – Maintenance Check List
2 – Normative References Annex B – Dealing with False Alarm
3 – Terms and Reference Annex C – Model Certificates
4 – General
5 – Assessment of Needs
6 – Planning and Design
7 – Installation
8 – Commissioning and Verification
9 – Third Party Approval
10 – Documentations
11 – Maintenance
12 – Modification or Extension of an Installed System
13 – Operation of Other Fire Protection System
14 – Application in Special Risk
15 – Integrated Systems
16 – Hierarchical Systems
A summary of the Section headings of MS 1745 part 14 shows the topics which are covered in the
standard. Section 5 and 6 constitute a substantive part of the standard.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 16
0 – Introduction
MS 1745 is meant to be a guide, i.e. it is not mandatory.
It will become mandatory if specified in another document or by an
authority having power.
2 – Scope
Covers planning, design, installation, commission, operation and
maintenance of system.
System covered at least one detector.
DO NOT :
Do not cover systems combining fire alarm with other non-fire related
functions e.g. fire alarm hard-wired as part of a BMS.
Do not recommend whether fire alarm (including the type and extent)
to be installed in any premises
MS 1745 – 14 is worded as a Guide, i.e. it do not carry mandatory requirement. However where it is
cited in specifications, it become (contractually) mandatory. Citation or claims that a system
complies to MS 1745 – 14 also confers mandatory status to the standard.
MS 1745 – 14 DO NOT recommend the type, extent and scope of fire detection and alarm system to
be installed in any building. For recommendation on system and extent of coverage, we will have to
refer to other legal prescription (notably the UBBL).
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 17
2 – Normative Reference.
Makes reference to ALL other parts of MS1745.
Parts 1 to 12 can be said to be product standards.
Therefore compliance to MS1745 requires that components must be
certified to conform to the relevant parts of MS 1745.
By normative reference, the components which will be specified and installed under this standard
will have to comply with the relevant product standard in the MS 1745 series. Where product
standards are not available in MS, then the EN 54 series will have precedence.
The standard also prescribed that competent person and organisation should be retained.
Competent person in the Malaysian context and especially under the context of the ‘Street, Drainage
and Building Act’ will be the registered engineer.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 18
Initial concept
1. Building risk group,
2. Space to be protected,
Assessment of needs
3. Type of system to be installed,
4. Interaction with other fire
Planning and design protection measures
Installation
Commissioning and
verification 1. Selecting and locating detectors,
2. Zoning of building/ alarm zones,
3. Provision for control, displays
Third party approval and indications,
(optional) 4. Provision of power supplies
Use / Operation
Figure 1 in MS 1745 illustrates the process flow for compliance with MS 1745. As a
substantive portion of the standard deals with “Assessment of Needs” and “Planning and
Design”, the sub‐topics relevant to these two topics are listed as decision clouds.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 19
4 – General
4.2 Each of the process listed in Fig. 1 are assumed to be carried out by
different organisation.
4.3 Electrical safety is NOT covered in MS1745 but relevant legislative
requirements should be referred (MS 1979 and MS 1936).
4.4 Design to minimise false alarm (Annex B).
4.5 Warranties to be provided by suppliers and manufacturers.
4.6 Proper documentations at each stage (Annex C – format certificates).
4.7 Responsibility of person to be clearly defined.
4.8 Persons or qualifications to be appropriately competent (cross
reference to definitions).
In Clause 4.3, the following are relevant electrical standards and codes which are mandatory under
the ‘Electricity Supply Act’:
(1) MS 1979:2007 "Electrical Installation of Buildings – Code of Practice"
(2) MS 1936:2006 “Electrical Installation of Building – Guide to MS IEC 60364"
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 20
Assessment of needs is the first step in delving into detail design and specification. Assessing ‘Needs’
identify the over‐riding consideration, Protection of Life versus Protection of Property with over‐
riding consideration of cost‐operation, which will define a design concept and the extent of coverage
required within and without a premise.
Consultation with insurance company should (in the author’s opinion) be an important consideration
in assessing needs as insurance premiums are not necessarily confined only to basic standard
prescribed under the law (UBBL). System designed and installed are frequently required to be
modified or have components changed, or even sub‐system added after audit by an insurance
company.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 21
Every practitioner in the building industry should have a copy of the “UBBL”. The UBBL (not Bomba
Officer) will be the first step in assessing the needs, extent and coverage of system to be included.
The above listed by‐laws in the UBBL pertaining to fire alarm and detection system has relevance.
By‐Law 244 however seems to be outdated in its citation of standards:
(1) Since 1986 the role of the “Fire Officer’s Committee” (FOC), UK has been taken over by the
“Loss Prevention Council” (LPC, UK).
(2) BS CP 1019 is superseded by BS5839 – 1
(3) BS 3116 part 1 : 1970 has since been withdrawn and superseded by BS 5839 (relevant
part).
(4) BS 3116 part 4 was superseded by BS 5839‐4 which in turn was withdrawn and superseded
by EN 54‐4.
(5) The original BS5446‐1:1977 was superseded by BS5446‐1:2000 (Fire detection and fire
alarm devices for dwellings. Specification for smoke alarms) which was withdrawn and
replaced with BS EN 14604:2005 (smoke alarm devices)
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 22
The UBBL 10th Schedule is the most important document prescribing the extent and scope of
coverage required for the various building hazard class. Four types of fire alarm and detection
Participants are requested to consult 10th Schedule of the UBBL.
systems are listed. P
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 23
MS 1745 – 14 defines coverage in four general classes. An assessment on the coverage required will
have to be made by a competent person as previously stated and as covered in the previous slide
the UBBL (especially the 10th Schedule) will be the first step in assessing coverage.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 24
As a comparison, BS5839 (of which most Malaysian practitioners would claim to be proficient – at
least going by the mandatory statutory declaration commonly made), assessing needs is more
nuance and clear. This clarity is especially important where insurer’s needs have to be clearly
declared. Practitioners should therefore, also consult BS 5839‐1 in assessing the type of coverage
required. Appendix A appended with this presentation has some recommendations on coverage
based on BS5839 classification.
Participants (as an exercise) should compare the recommendations in Appendix A with UBBL, 10th
Schedule.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 25
Areas which do not required coverage are listed above.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 26
Design to
Minimise False
Alarm (Annex B)
Devices & Sub
Systems Zoning
Compatibility
Compliance
to MS 1745
Fault Detectors
Limitation Siting
(circuit survivability)
Detectors
Selection
After defining the concept and extent of coverage of the design, the practitioner is now ready to
develop a detail design. The chart above illustrates the sub topics which must be considered in
designing and specifying systems in compliance with MS 1745.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 27
A major topic, after having decided on a system concept and extent of coverage, would be designing
circuit for fault‐limitation. In NFPA 72 (the other major fire standard in the world), “fault‐limitation”
is caption as “circuit‐survivability” which (in my opinion) is a better concept to capture in designing a
‘fail‐safe’ system. MS 1745 – 14; prescribes circuit‐survivability in the terms listed above. Thus an
audit to check compliance with MS 1745 would require some test to prove circuit‐survivability as
listed above.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 28
A hard‐wired implementation of the performance‐prescription for circuit‐survivability is listed in this
slide. The recommendations are just some steps which can be implemented and do not preclude
other steps which are particular to addressable systems. In addressable systems, devices are
typically connected in a ‘daisy‐chain’ in a loop, star or radial configuration. Thus circuit survivability
(depending on the addressable hardware) will have to be taken into account in such ‘data‐loops’. It
would therefore be pertinent for practitioners to check with vendors of addressable system on
whether and how compliance to MS 1745 can be effected.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 29
MS 1745 (similar to BS 5839‐1) requires that circuit faults should be indicated on monitoring panels.
In such case, the designer and installer will have to pay attention to the type of looping circuit in
connecting up devices as illustrated above and following slide.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 30
NFPA 72 : 2002
Whilst MS 1745 and BS 5839 defined “circuit‐survivability” in general “performance‐based” terms,
NFPA 72 (North American) has detailed prescription on defining the class and ‘style’ of circuit in
terms of meeting alarm and trouble performance based on single‐open, single‐ground and wire‐to‐
wire short.
Initiating Devices refer to devices which initiate signals such as detectors, flow switch etc.
Notification Appliances refer devices which receives signal and act on the signal; e.g. alarm
sounders, visual indicators etc.
Signalling Line Circuit refers to circuit which transmit signal received from some IDC to another
monitoring or supervisory panel, e.g. would be a circuit to a repeater panel.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 31
NFPA 72 : 2002
The above explained the concept of a Class A circuit.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 32
NFPA 72 : 2002
The above explains the concept behind a Class B circuit.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 33
The above illustrates common mistakes in wiring up circuit for Class A need.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 34
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 35
Basic prescription on zoning.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 36
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 37
..................................................................................................................................................................
H Heat Detector
Alarm indicator lamp
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 38
1 Fixed temp
Fusible element 1 UV
Continuous
2 IR
Bimetal
3 UV/IR
2 Rate‐of‐Rise
line 1 ionisation
spot 2 Optical
3 Rate Compensation Manual Switch 3 Beam
line
spot
4 Combination
5 Electronic Spot‐
Thermal
The types of detectors are classified into the types above. In terms of sensitivity smoke detectors are
more sensitive than heat detectors. Spot type heat detectors are the most common, whilst line heat‐
detectors are used in special application. Smoke detectors comprise of 2 main types (ionisation and
optical). Optical smoke detectors comprise of 2 types: the photoelectric detector and the beam
detectors. The following slide illustrates the applications of line (or linear detectors and beam
detectors).
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 39
The above illustrates deployment of linear heat detectors in special risk applications (cable rack,
conveyors carrying hazardous material etc.).
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 40
Beam detectors detect smoke by measuring the obscuring of a light beam due to smoke. The above
illustrates application of beam smoke detectors in a high ceiling application.
Other specialised detectors are flame detectors which has two primary technology of infra‐red (IR)
or UV light detection. Flame detectors are useful in specialised application and the nature of the
flame will have to be confirmed depending on the type of flammable material.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 41
Limit of ceiling
Limit of ceiling
height for heat
height for smoke
detectors
detectors
Prescription on ceiling height and radius of coverage given is ONLY a guide. In actual practice the
practitioner will have to consult manufacturer’s guide on radius of coverage (after confirming with
suitable conformance certification on validity of manufacturer’s claims.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 42
In case of pitch roof, any pitch roof with depth to room height ratio of less than 5% can be
considered a “smooth” ceiling in which case the standard spacing table applies. However if the
aforesaid A/H ratio exceeds 5% then the recommended detector spacing is increased by 1% for
every 1° increase in pitch up to a maximum of 25%.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 43
Where beam depth is an issue, guidelines for moderating detector spacing are listed above.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 44
In case of false floors and ceiling recommendations on coverage are included.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 45
Floors Section
2.Use beam detectors.
3.Effective operating
Hf radius = 12.5% Hf
In case were detectors are installed where ceiling are not present, the effective operating radius of
detectors are reduced.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 46
Detectors should not be sited 500mm from walls or obstruction. Obstruction include beams and
partitions which are not more than 300 from ceiling.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 47
Detectors should not be sited in front of fresh air inlet or exhaust and where (air conditioning)
supply air inlet has air velocity more than 1 m/s, it should be at least 1m away. In cases where high
air velocity is a concern, aspirated type smoke detection system may be proposed.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 48
Manual break glass should generally be sited along escape route. The standard recommends that a
person escaping from a fire should not travel more than 30m to access a manual pull switch. Manual
pull switch should be located as far as possible near exit stair case. Common mistakes are siting
manual pull switch at dead‐ends and away from escape route. In such a case, a person will have to
deviate from the escape route to access the switch which presents a danger to the escapee.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 49
> 65dBA OR
5dBA above ambient
Fire Door Normal Door <120dBA
– 30dBA – 20dBA
Recommendations on sound level is listed as 65 dB(A) OR 5dB(A) above general ambient sound level
(whichever is the higher). In case where occupant is asleep (hotel rooms), sound levels should be 75
dB(A). Generally a fire door will contribute to about 30dB(A) reduction whilst a normal door will
contribute to about 30dB(A) reduction in sound level. The maximum sound level must however NOT
exceed 120dB(A). Thus the designer will have to place a number of lower dBA sounders rather than
one high dBA sounder to comply with this requirement.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 50
65dBA OR
5dBA above ambient
Sounders
1.At least 2 sounders in a
building.
2.At least 1 sounder in each fire
compartment.
3.Max level < 120dBA
4.Freq. 500Hz – 2kHz
5.Sound should be distinct (not
to be confused with other alarm
e.g. lunch)
6.Sound to be continuous.
A guide on sound attenuation with distance is shown in the graph above. Other prescription on
sounders are also listed above.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 51
51 Power Supplies
Primary supply
Æ Isolator/ switch fuse to be dedicated
Æ RCD as far as possible not to be used.
Æ Switching of system due to maintenance, energy savings etc should not
affect supply.
Types Æ Normal supply & Standby Supply
Batteries capacity Æ 72 hours normal quiescent condition & 30min. alarm.
Battery capacity with guaranteed downtime less than 24 hours. If system is
locally or remotely supervised and/or a maintenance contract is in force
guaranteeing max. downtime of less than 24 hrs, then battery capacity can
be reduced to 30 hours operating and 30 min. alarm.
Prescription on the standby capacities of batteries are listed above. Note the reduction in capacity
allowed where supervised maintenance contract or local maintenance (competent) is available, the
key term is a guaranteed down time of less than 24 hours in case of supply failure.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 52
A typical alarm system, in most case will also be used to actuate other emergency or essential
services (list above).
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 53
Cables run in
areas which are
NOT fire
protected
should be fire
resistant OR
protected
against fire.
3 Class of Circuits.
ID = Initiating Devices
ND = Notification Devices
Signal Circuits
MS 1745 – 14 contains clear prescription on the use of fire rated cables for automated fire detection
and alarm system. The next few slides will show the context and prescription on cables and inter
connections.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 54
In the two cases presented above, “fault‐limitations’ require the use of fire‐resistant cables. In these
case, fire resistant is only limited to 30 minutes.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 55
Common misconception in the market is the specification of fire rated cables. Fire rated cables
under IEC 60331 requires that the cable should be able to operate for a certain period (say about 30
minutes) after exposure to fire. Many cables marketed as “fire rated” are merely “fire‐retardant”,
i.e. it will not contribute to the spread or addition to the fire (or it will significantly present itself as a
low fire load). Such cables are cables under IEC 60332‐3. However fire rating under the context of
MS 1745 requires that cables must be able to operate for at least 30 minutes on being exposed to
“fire‐fighting” conditions. The above and following slides explain the concept and specifications
behind specifying fire rating of cables.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 56
BS 60332-3
IEC 60331 test a cable for its fire resistant properties (i.e. ability to continue operation during fire
condition) as oppose to IEC 60332‐3 which examines flame propagation property of cables.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 57
BS5839-1
BS 5839 categorise fire rating of cables in terms of its application. The left‐most two standards
specify cables for fire detection and alarm applications.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 58
BS5839-1
The minimum standard of fire rating permitted under MS1745 would be Category W cables (fire
fighting condition).
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 59
BS5839-1
A more correct specification of cables under BS 5839‐1 (and by extension the MS 1745‐14) would be
cables rated as PH30 standard grade cables at 830°C instead of 650°C under BS6387 Cat W cables.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 60
Conduit Wiring
Metal Trunking G.I. – Class B certified to IEC 60614-1 & 2
uPVC be high impact class B, certified to IEC60614
If uPVC embedded in concrete they should be class C
Fire rated cables should be laid on trays and in case
where they are exposed (at low level) shall be
mechanically protected (conduit or trunking).
Cables are required to be protected against mechanical damage. This normally means the use of
metal trunking or conduit. The use of conduit however is the most contentious as many installation
consider the use of PVC conduit without a proper check on its specification and certification.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 61
3. Conduit embedded in concrete are of the wrong grade (conduit not properly graded
will crack when laid in concrete).
4. No proper junction boxes and/or terminal boxes.
5. Trunking and/or conduit ‘overloaded’.
6. Splicing/jointing of cables without proper terminal box.
Some common mistakes in cable laying are listed above. The most serious is the used of sub
standard conduit (including GI conduit which are not properly certified). A proper check of SIRIM
certification reveals that many G.I. conduit system may not even be of the correct gauge (class B,
medium grade and in case of embedding in concrete should be at least class C, heavy grade).
It is even more pertinent to note that many fire alarm cabling systems may NOT be properly
specified for fire rating where the standards require such rating.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 62
EMC – DEFINITION
THE ABILITY OF A DEVICE, EQUIPMENT OR SYSTEM TO
FUNCTION SATISFACTORILY IN ITS ELECTROMAGNETIC
ENVIRONMENT WITHOUT INTRODUCING INTOLERABLE
DISTURBANCES TO THAT ENVIRONMENT OR TO OTHER
EQUIPMENT
With the proliferation of addressable type fire alarm, the impact of electromagnetic (EM)
disturbances on sensitive electronic equipment which comprise part of the (supposedly) “fail‐safe”
nature of automatic detection and alarm system pose a serious threat to its integrity. Though MS
1745 is sparse on prescriptive measure on protection against EM disturbances, it should be
emphasised that failure due to EM disturbances is a major consideration which installers of
addressable system CANNOT ignore.
A starting point for planning for EM protection is to gauge the “immunity‐level” or “susceptibility‐
level” of sensitive equipment, and the source and level of EM emission at the vicinity or connectivity
(in EMC terminology it would be termed “EM‐coupling”) to sensitive equipment.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 63
The above attempts to summarise briefly the steps which can be taken to protect equipment against
EM disturbances. Common remedy is the installation of (power‐grade and/or data‐grade) surge
protection devices (SPD). Depending on the nature of the ground, underground cables (especially
hilly rocky ground) is as susceptible to atmospheric EM disturbances as overhead cables. A common
over‐looked source of EM disturbance would be sensing cables laid at high level along timber roof
eaves or roof eaves which are not suitably shielded against atmospheric EM radiation.
Other EM treatments include proper shielding and ground for sensitive equipment. An expert on
EMC should be consulted for proper recommendations on EMC.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 64
The above is a template for approval and work acceptance procedure. A most basic check will start
with material and components acceptance. This entails an examination of SIRIM certification to
check that the right grade and type of components, materials and product are used. In third party
certification (such as Factory Mutual) this step would be a pre‐requisite, as a compilation of
conformance certification for products, materials and components used in the installation will need
to be filed as record.
The request for Method Statements is also, currently, a common project management tool. However
a proper understanding of the design‐intent, specification and installation procedure IS NECESSARY
before method statement should be requested. Method statement should be specific and NOT
general in nature, i.e. the project manager must state specifically the type and procedure requested
for Method Statement. Current practice of requesting for Method Statement in very general terms
usually result in Contractors generating “Method Statement” which are just copies of the
specifications.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 65
Finally the responsible engineer (whether consultant or contractor) must check that proper fire seals
are installed in ALL penetration of cables, conduit and pipes through fire partitions and floor slabs.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 66
Pre-Delivery
Can be 1st party, Inspection
2nd party or 3rd
party inspection.
Tests During
Installation
The above is a template for ensuring final work acceptance. It should be noted that work acceptance
do not only entails accepting final commissioning reports on completion. It should include
compilation of material acceptance, record of installation checks from project inception, through to
QC/QA checks during installation and final commissioning on completion.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 67
P RO DUCT IN S PE C T IO N &
C E R T IFIC A T IO N E NFO RCE ME NT
C E R T IF IED
SA F E IN S T A L L A T ION
A model for system certification originally drafted in 2001 (for the electrical safety industry) and
currently adopted in MS 1979 can be paraphrased for the fire fighting industry.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 68
An explanation on the type of inspection testing is described above (first party and 2nd party tests).
Understanding the framework on which acceptance‐tests are conducted is essential for the
approving engineer. First party tests (self‐test by vendor/manufacturer) would be the first line of
defence of the approving engineer. Demanding 1st party certificate is akin to requesting for a
product “birth‐certificate”. This ensures that a product is from where it claims to be (i.e. genuine
product). 2nd party witness tests are usually only requested for large assembled equipment. In some
case, where witness test is in a foreign country, the client can engage a third party inspector (who is
expected to be “independent”) to witness test on his behalf.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 69
Third party certification (such as Factory Mutual) is an important certification body for multinational
corporation.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 70
Certificate of
Design
Certificate of
Installation
Certificate of
Commission
& Verification
Certificate of
Acceptance
Annex C in the Standard includes model certificates which can be used by practitioners to design a
documented procedure for works acceptance.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 71
Alarm /
Emergency
Response
Plan Persons /
Preventive Organisations
Maintenance Responsible
Check List
Fire Drill
Routine &
Semi-Routine
Check List
Annex A
Maintenance
Manual &
Record of
As-Built
Extension/
Modifications/
Repair
Ir. H.P. Looi, (6th October 2009)
In the compilation of completion documentations for handing over to the operator or client, the
above template lists the important parts of the documents which should be included. Current
handing over documentations merely compiles a catalogue of equipment and components without
any operating procedure or maintenance check list procedure for each components and system.
Annex A has an excellent model form for check‐list for maintenance use.
Other work procedure by the operator would be the conduct of occupants’ training (usually fire drill)
and a documented procedure to ensure that extension and modification works do not compromise
the integrity of existing fire systems.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 72
A final section of MS 1745‐14 include a discussions on special risk which is listed above. Insurers are
especially concerned with warehouses and data‐processing centres. Thus consultation with insurers
are essential for ascertaining the acceptability of systems and grade of components used.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 73
Smoke Control
Fire detection at atrium
Fire compartmentation
Smoke Control with detection
and auto fire suppression
High Atrium Building
In ascertaining the fire protection needs of high hazard areas, other legislation may be consulted
such as the “Petroleum Safety Measures Act (for oil depots)”, “The Gas Supply Act” (Gas storage at
retail‐end). “Environmental Quality Act” (schedule waste, hazmat handling).
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 74
hplooi@streamyx.com
http://hplooi.blogspot.com
Oil tank, coal conveyors, recycled tyre depot/storage yard are just some of the outdoor risk areas
which demands special consideration for automatic fire detection and alarm. In most case, an
understanding of the risk, type of fire which will be generated and the fire hazard involve will be
necessary before any solution can be proposed. For example:
(1) Tank farm fire is usually fought from a policy of containment, i.e. prevent the fire from
spreading. Once a fire starts it will be difficult to extinguish the fire. A response plan will
require sufficient amount of water just to contain the fire (containment dikes are usually
included in tank farm design) and prevent temperatures from reaching excessively high
levels.
(2) Waste tyre storage yard (typically outdoor) requires attention to fire containment. Once a
fire starts, it would be difficult to extinguish fires from mounds of tyre waste. A more
serious implication would be smouldering fire from tyre waste which would pose air quality
hazard to the surrounding area. Again containment is an essential first step in design Fire
suppression agent include special chemical agent for the suppression of fires from rubber
waste.
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 75
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
hplooi@streamyx.com 6th October 2009
MS 1745 Part 14; Fire Detection and Fire Alarm System, Guidelines for
Planning, Design, Installation, Commissioning, Use and Maintenance P a g e | 76
Lower Higher
Type of Premises Comments
Risk End Risk End
M normally meets legal requirements.
Most places of work, offices, shops,
M or P/2M P1/M Detection added to meet insurers and business
warehouse, factories, restaurants
interruption risk.
In sleeping areas L3 is the base
Hotels and Hostels L2 L1 recommendation level. In practice this
becomes at least L2.
Pubs with no residential accommodation M.
Pubs M L2
Pubs with residential accommodation L3/L2.
Normally based on fire risk assessment
Schools M M/P2/L4 particularly arson risk. Detection also often
added if in partial use for community activities.
Hospitals L1 L1 Minor variations as per HTM1982
Accommodation under 300 normally M. Larger
Places of assembly, eg entertainment M L1 premises L4 to L1. Large premises are usually
L1.
Transportation terminals M/L5 M/L5 -
Covered shopping centres L3 L1 -
Residential care homes L3 L1 L1 for large premises
Prisons M L5 -
Phased evacuation buildings L3 L3 -
Extra risk to life posed by such things as inner
Buildings with means of escape
M/L5 M/L4 rooms, unoccupied spaces, cross building
difficulties
risks, use of automatic door holders etc.
Insurer requirements M/P2 M/P1 -
END OF APPENDIX A
B2-1/3
APPENDIX B – Circuit Class and Style, NFPA72 : 2002
Class B B B A A
Style A B C D Eα
Trouble
Trouble
Trouble
Trouble
Alarm
Alarm
Alarm
Alarm
Alarm
Abnormal condition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Single open – X – – X – – X – – X X – X X
Single ground – X – – X R – X R – X R – X R
Wire-to-wire short X – – X – – – X – X – – – X –
Loss of carrier (if used)/
– – – – – – – X – – – – – X –
Channel interface
R = Required capacity
X = Indication required at protected premises and as required in Chapter 5
α = Style exceeds minimum requirements of Class A
B2-1/3
Class B B B A
Style W X Y Z
abnormal conditions
abnormal conditions
abnormal conditions
premises
premises
premises
premises
Abnormal condition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Single open X – X X X – X X
Single ground X – X – X X X X
Wire-to-wire short X – X – X – X –
X = Indication required at protected premises and as required in Chapter 5
END OF APPENDIX B
Lower Higher
Type of Premises Comments
Risk End Risk End
M normally meets legal requirements.
Most places of work, offices, shops,
M or P/2M P1/M Detection added to meet insurers and business
warehouse, factories, restaurants
interruption risk.
In sleeping areas L3 is the base
Hotels and Hostels L2 L1 recommendation level. In practice this
becomes at least L2.
Pubs with no residential accommodation M.
Pubs M L2
Pubs with residential accommodation L3/L2.
Normally based on fire risk assessment
Schools M M/P2/L4 particularly arson risk. Detection also often
added if in partial use for community activities.
Hospitals L1 L1 Minor variations as per HTM1982
Accommodation under 300 normally M. Larger
Places of assembly, eg entertainment M L1 premises L4 to L1. Large premises are usually
L1.
Transportation terminals M/L5 M/L5 -
Covered shopping centres L3 L1 -
Residential care homes L3 L1 L1 for large premises
Prisons M L5 -
Phased evacuation buildings L3 L3 -
Extra risk to life posed by such things as inner
Buildings with means of escape
M/L5 M/L4 rooms, unoccupied spaces, cross building
difficulties
risks, use of automatic door holders etc.
Insurer requirements M/P2 M/P1 -
END OF APPENDIX A
B2-1/3
APPENDIX B – Circuit Class and Style, NFPA72 : 2002
Class B B B A A
Style A B C D Eα
Trouble
Trouble
Trouble
Trouble
Alarm
Alarm
Alarm
Alarm
Alarm
Abnormal condition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Single open – X – – X – – X – – X X – X X
Single ground – X – – X R – X R – X R – X R
Wire-to-wire short X – – X – – – X – X – – – X –
Loss of carrier (if used)/
– – – – – – – X – – – – – X –
Channel interface
R = Required capacity
X = Indication required at protected premises and as required in Chapter 5
α = Style exceeds minimum requirements of Class A
B2-1/3
Class B B B A
Style W X Y Z
abnormal conditions
abnormal conditions
abnormal conditions
premises
premises
premises
premises
Abnormal condition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Single open X – X X X – X X
Single ground X – X – X X X X
Wire-to-wire short X – X – X – X –
X = Indication required at protected premises and as required in Chapter 5
END OF APPENDIX B