Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chinatown
Other places, other times
by James Kavanagh
from Jump Cut, no. 3, 1974, pp. 1, 8
copyright Jump Cut: A Review of Contemporary Media, 1974, 2004
Later, when Noah Cross asks Gittes if Lou Escobar, the police lieutenant
in charge of the Mulwray murder, is honest, Gittes replies,
“You may think you know what you're dealing with, but
believe me, you don't.”
As Gittes says of Chinatown: “You can't always tell what’s going on.”
The movie brings us, with Gittes, to the unsettling realization that we
can't always tell what’s going on, even in our comfortable middle class
womb. The film indicates we must resign ourselves to our petty
insignificance and follow a strategy for survival which directs that we do
“as little as possible” . Finally, then, CHINATOWN overwhelms us with
a sense of hopelessness.
Arnold Kettle has some remarks about Blake’s poem that apply as well
to Polanski’s film:
CHINATOWN strikes in the pit of the stomach with the sickening truth
about personal and social relations’ utter depravity in a society where
money is king. That the film remains bourgeois, that it gives no very
clear sense of working class reality, that it cannot offer a more hopeful,
more revolutionary vision—these are all criticisms which are undeniably
accurate. But the same criticism also will remain undeniably hollow as
long as they come from a left movement in the United States which has
hardly begun to solve any of these problems for itself.