Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10.soilstabilization 2
10.soilstabilization 2
It is
required to bear the loads without failure.In some places, soil may be weak which
cannot resist the oncoming loads.In such cases,soil stabilization is
needeed.Numerous methods are available in the literature for soil stabilization.But
sometimes,some of the methods like chemical stabilization,lime stabilization etc.
adversly affects the chemical composition of the soil. In this study,fly ash and
lime were mixed with clay soil to investigate the relative strength gain in terms
of unconfined compression,bearing capacity and compaction.The effect of fly ash and
lime on the geotechnical characteristics of clay-fly ash and clay-lime mixtures was
investigated by conductiung standard Proctor compaction tests,unconfined
compression tests,CBR tests and permeability test.The tests were performed as per
Indian Standard specifications. The following materials were used for preparing the
samples: Clayey soil Fly ash Lime The soft clay used for these experiments
was brought from a site,near Kumarakom.The physical properties of the soil were
determined as per IS specifications. Fly ash for the study was brought from
Hindustan Newsprints,Piravam.it is finely divided residue resulting from the
combustion of ground or powdered coal from electric generating plants. It has high
water absorption capacity. Lime for the study is locally available.it imparts much
strength to the soil by pozzolanic reaction which is explained later in the report.
In this test programme,without additives clay was tested to find the optimum
moisture content ,CBR value ,plasticity index and unconfined compression
strength.Fly ash and lime were added in varying percentages and that fraction for
which maximum strength is obtained was found out.The mixture is cured for 3,7 and
14 days.
Quicklime, Portland cement, Fly Ash orComposites) increases subgrade stiffness and
reduces expansion tendencies, it performs as a foundation (able to support and
distribute loads under saturated conditions). This report contains a summary of the
performance of lime and fly ash used with clay.
Fly ashes are finely divided residue resulting from the combustion of ground or
powdered coal from electric generating plants. Lime is another additive used, which
is locally available, to improve subgrade characteristics. It is obtained by
heating limestone at elevated temperatures. SCOPE OF THE PROJECT The soil used in
the study is natural clay brought from Kumarakom.Pavement subgrade over there is
composed of clayey soil whose bearing capacity is extremely low.Due to this
reason ,the roads require periodic maintenance to take up repeated application of
wheel loads.This proves to be costly ,and at the same time, conditions of raods
during monsoon seasons is extremely poor.Therefore, a thought on how to enhance the
stability of roads by chaper means demands appraisal. Soil stabilization can be
done using different additives ,but use of fly ash which is a waste material from
thermal power plants,at the same time difficult-to-dispose material will be much
significant.
2. To study the effect of lime and flyash on proctor’s density and OMC of
3. To study the effect of lime and flyash on the consistency limits of clayey soil.
4.
To study the changes in CBR of soil by the addition of lime and fly ash
Soil structure The clay particles in the soil structure are arranged in sheet like
structures composed of silica tetrahedral and alumina octahedra. The sheets form
many different combinations, but there are three main types of formations .the
first is kaolinite,which consists of alternating silica and alumina sheets bonded
together. This form of clay structure is very stable and does not swell appreciably
when wetted .the next form is montmorillonite, which is composed of two layers of
silica and one alumina sheet creating aweak bond between the layers. This weak
bonding
between the layers allows water and other cations to enter between the
layers,resulting in swelling in the clay particle. The last type is illite, which
is very similar to montmorillonite ,but has potassium ions between each layer which
help bond the layers together. Inter layer bonding illite is therefore stronger
than for montmorillonite,but weaker than kaolinite. Clay particles are small in
size but have alarge to mass ratio,resulting in alarger surface area available for
interaction with water and cations.the clay particles have negatively charged
surfaces that attract cations and polar molecules,including water forming a
boundwater layer around the negatively charged clay particles. The amount of water
surrounding the clay particles is related to the amount of water that is available
for the clay particle to take in and release. This moisture change around the clay
particles causes expansion and swelling pressures within clays that are confined .
STABILIZATION WITH LIME Lime stabilization is done by adding lime to soil. This is
useful for the stabilization of clayey soil. When lime reacts with soil there is
exchange of cations in the adsorbed water layer and a decrease in the plasticity of
the soil occurs. The resultant material is more friable than the orginal clay, and
is more suitable as subgrade. Lime is produced by burning of limestone in kiln. The
quality of lime obtained depends on the parent material and the production process.
And there are basically 5 types of limes 1. High calcium, quick lime (CaO)
2.
The two primary types of lime used in construction today are quick lime(calcium
oxide) and hydrated lime (calcium hydroxide).Heating limestone at elevated
temperatures produce quick lime and addition of water to quick lime produces
hydrated lime. Equation shows the reaction that occurs when limestone is heated to
produce quick lime with carbon dioxide produced as by-product. CaCO3+heat CaO+CO2
Addition of water to quick lime produces hydrated lime along with heat as
byproduct: CaO+H2O Ca (OH)2+Heat
1.
As the reaction in the case of lime is low,there is no maximum time limit between
the addition of lime to the soil and the completion of compaction. However ,care
should be taken to avoid carbonation of lime in the process.
Max.dry density Optimum moisture content Liquid limit Plastic limit Plasticity
index
2.Additives Theadditives used for stabilization and modification include lime and
flyash. The soils weremixed with each of these additives for which there were
reasonable expectations of improved engineering properties. The amount of additive
used was determined based on testing the strength for addition of varying
percentages and selecting the one with greatest strength. The lime percentage was
fixed at 10% and flyash 14%.
LAB TESTING
The various tests conducted on the sample are the following: 1.Atterberg limits 2.
Specific gravity 3. Direct shear test 4. Proctor compaction test 5. CBR test 6.
Unconfined compression test(UCS) Firstly the above tests were conducted on plane
clay sample to determine its properties.UCS test is conducted to evaluate it
strength. Thereafter, certain percentages of lime and flyash are added to the clay
sample to stabilize it. And the percentages of the above additives which produce
the optimum strength to the soil are chosen by conducting UCS test on them.
Soil preparation The soil was collected from site in large sacks. It is brought to
the lab and is dried in oven for 24 hours in large pans. This soil due to loss of
water formed big lumps which is broken to smaller pieces or even fine powder and is
sieved according to the needs of different experiments.
Standard loads for CBR tests Penetration depth (mm) 2.5 5.0 7.5 Standard load (kg)
1370 2055 2630 Unit load (kg/cm2) 70 105 134
10 12.5
162 183
Samples for conducting CBR tests were prepared using moulds of dimensions 15cm
diameter and 17.5cm height. The weight of soil used is 5kg passing through 20mm
sieve. The samples were prepared at OMC and varying lime and flyash.In this study,
lime is added at 10% and fly ash at 14%. Direct shear test The shear strength of a
soil is its maximum resistance to shear stresses just before the failure. Shear
failure of a soil mass occurs when the shear stresses induced due to the applied
compressive loads exceed the shear strength of the soil. Failure in soil occurs by
relative movements of the particles and not by breaking of particles. Shear
strength is the principal engineering property which controls the stability of the
soil mass under loads. Shear strength determines bearing capacity of soils,
stability of slopes of soils, earth pressure against retaining structure etc.
Direct shear test is conducted on a soil specimen in a shear box which can split
into two equal halves and is covered with porous grid plates on either sides.
Normal load is applied for a constant stress and shear load is applied at a
constant rate of 0.02 mm/minute. The test is repeated for different stress and
failure stress is noted. A failure envelope is obtained by plotting shear stress
with different normal stress and is joined to form a straight line from which angle
of shear resistance and cohesion is obtained.
Specific gravity The specific gravity of solid particles is defined as the ratio of
the mass of a given volume of solids to the mess of an equal volume of water at
40C. Specific gravity of normal soils is between 2.65 to 2.80. Specific gravity of
soil mass indicates the average value of all the solid particles present in the
soil mass. Also it is an important parameter used for the determination of void
ratio and particle size. Consistency limits The consistency of fine grained soil is
the physical state in which it exists. It is used to denote the degree of firmness
of soil. The water content at which soil changes from one state to another is known
as consistency limits. A soil containing high water is in the liquid state. It has
no shear resistance and can flow like liquid. Therefore the shear strength is equal
to zero. As the water content is reduced, the soil becomes stiffer and starts
developing resistance to shear deformation. The water content at which soil changes
from liquid state to plastic state is known as liquid limit. The liquid limit is
find out by Casagrande’s liquid limit device. The number of blows of this device is
find out at different water content. Flow curve is plot with number of blows on x
axis and water content on y axis. The water content corresponding to 25 blows is
the liquid limit. Plastic limit is the water content below which the soil stop
behaving as a plastic material. It begins to crumble when rolled into a thread of
soil of 3mm diameter. At this water content , the soil loses its plasticity and
passes to the semi-solid state. The shear strength at the plastic limit ,is about
100 times that at the liquid limit.
CHAPTER 4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS The following chapter covers the results of the
testing programmes. The results that are presented include soil properties
admixture percentages and the various testing results for the soil additive
combinations .
Native soil properties and admixture percentages Soil chacterstics were determined
using atterberg limits ,hydrometer analysis, specific gravity, standard proctor
compaction and unconfined compression tests. The test results is shown the table Sl
No: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Properties CBR value Max.dry density Optimum moisture content
Liquid limit Plastic limit Plasticity index 36% 26% 10 Values 4.3% 1517 kg/m3 20%
The grain size dirtribution curve for the soil used is shown in figure.
The percentage of lime and fly ash for stabilization is determined from the
unconfined compression test. The test results are shown.
The native soil has an unconfined compression of 400kpa. This increased by the
addition of lime and fly ash. The maximum strength is obtained by the addition of
10% lime and 14% fly ash.
Atterberg limits The atterberg limit test results with various soil additive
combination at different curing period are presented in the table and graphs
showing variation of atterberg limits with curing period is plotted for different
soil-additive combination.
Atterberg test results on clay-flyash-lime mixture Curing period Native soil Lime:3
days 7 days 14 days Flyash:3 days 7 days 14 days Liquid limit 36 25 23 22 35 35 35
Plastic limit 26 15 18 20 19 23 26 Plasticity index 10 10 10 5 16 12 9
The native liquid limit and plasticity index of the soil were 36 and 10. The PI
values were reduced when they are mixed with small amout of lime and became
nonplastic with the addition of more lime.For clay-lime mixture, the 3 day liquid
limit is 25, it reducese to 23 for 7days and it becomes 22 at 14days. The plastic
limit is increases from 15 at 3day to 20 at 14 days.As the liquid limit decreases
and plastic limit increases the plasticity index decreases from 10 to 5 with curing
period. For fly ash had more limited effect on the plasticity ofthese soils.The
liquid limit remains constant with curing period for the fly ash-clay mixture.The
plastic limit increases from 19 at 3day to 26 at 14days, as a liquid limit remains
constant and plastic limit increases, the plasticity index values decreases from 16
at 3days to 9 at 14 days.
MAXIMUM DENSITY AND OPTIMUM MOISTURE CONTENT Optimum moisture content and maximum
density for native soil and each of the soil additive combination at different
curing period is presented in the table and the variation of maximum density and
optimum moisture content is plotted Sl no: Water content Dry density
1 2 3 4
18 20 22 24
15.3 16 17.2 18
The maximum density and optimum moisture content for the native soil are 1517 kg/m3
and 20%. When mixed with fly ash the optimum moisture content
and the maximum density is decreased.The maximum density is 1490 kg/m3 at an
optimum moisture content of 18.9 % at 3 days.It is reduces to 1000kg/m3 at an
optimum content of 14.9% in 14 days. So both the maximum density and optimum
moisture content decreases for fly ash-clay mixture. When mixed with lime, the
optimim moisture content is increased and the maximum dry density is decreased.The
maximum density is 645 kg/m at an optimum moisture content of 24% in 3 days.In
7days the maximum density is 445 kg/m3 at an optimum moisture content of 26%.The
maximum density is decreased to 235 kg/m3 and optimum moisture content increased to
28%.
DIRECT SHEAR TEST-FLYASH 3 days curing Normal stress (kg/cm2) Native soil 0.5 1 1.5
Lime: 0.5 1 1.5 Fly ash: 0.569 .897 1.2 .72 1.074 1.33 0.99 1.24 1.45 0.497 0.789
0.99 Shear stress (kg/cm2) 7 days curing Shear stress (kg/cm2) 14 days curing Shear
stress (kg/cm2)
0.5 1 1.5
The direct shear stresses of native soil for normal stress 0.5 kg/cm2 is
0.497kg/cm2.When mixed with fly ash the direct shear stress increases to 0.569 for
3days curing, 0.581 for 7days curing and 0.695 kg/cm2 for 14days curing. When mixed
with lime, the direct shear stress increases to 0.569 for 3days curing, 0.72 for
7days curing and 0.99kg/cm2 for 14 days curing.
Load (kg)
38.16 59.36 69.536 82.256 86.496 CBR:Load –penetration graph for clay107.696
mixtures: flyash 117.872 Load(kg) 124.656 3 days curing 7 days curing 0 7.93 25.99
33.92 63.98 84.82 97.92 117.84 122.95
CONCLUSION